European experience of bone-marrow transplantation for severe combined immunodeficiency

Severe combined immunodeficiency: a retrospective single-center study of clinical presentation and outcome in 117 patients

We carried out a retrospective analysis of 117 patients with severe combined immunodeficiency who were examined in a single center between Jan. 1, 1970, and Jan. 1, 1992, for the purpose of evaluating disease onset, progression, and outcome. The frequency of case referral increased from 8 from 1970 to 1975 to 56 from 1986 to 1991. The most frequent phenotype was T-/B+ (absence of T lymphocytes and presence of B lymphocytes) (n = 51); there were 36 cases of alymphocytosis, 16 of adenosine deaminase deficiency, 13 of Omenn syndrome, and 1 of reticular dysgenesis. Protracted diarrhea and lung infections were the main infectious complications; infection with bacillus Calmette-Guérin occurred in 10 of 28 vaccinated patients, but none of the six recipients of oral polio vaccine subsequently had poliomyelitis. The presence of maternal T cells was suspected or proved in half the patients with alymphocytosis or T-B+ severe combined immunodeficiency but did not occur in the other forms of the disease. Of the 117 patients, 22 died before transplantation could be performed. Adenosine deaminase deficiency and Omenn syndrome were more frequently associated with death before hematopoietic stem cell transplantation was possible. Fetal liver transplantation was successful in 1 of 10 cases. The survival rate among the 30 recipients of bone marrow with identical human leukocyte antigens (HLA) was 80%, with a median follow-up of 129 months; 23 of 25 patients recovered full immune function. The survival rate among the 50 recipients of HLA-haploidentical T cell-depleted bone marrow was 56%, with a mean follow-up of 35 months. Of the latter patients, 10 (35%) still require immunoglobulin substitution. There has been a trend toward improvement in the survival rate of haploidentical bone marrow recipients, presumably because of more effective infection-control measures and better transplantation strategy.

Transfer of the ADA gene into bone marrow cells and peripheral blood lymphocytes for the treatment of patients affected by ADA-deficient SCID

Severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID) caused by deficiency of the enzyme adenosine deaminase (ADA) is the first genetic disorder considered for human somatic cell gene therapy. ADA-SCID patients can be cured by HLA-matched sibling donor bone marrow transplantation. Alternative transplantation strategies as well as enzyme replacement are being tested in those patients who do not have a suitable matched sibling donor. Some ADA-SCID patients may not be candidates for cytoablation due to infectious damage to the lung or liver, or may have a milder phenotype that does not justify the risks associated with haploidentical bone marrow transplantation. Replacement therapy with PEG-ADA has resulted in improvement in growth, a variable increase in the number of peripheral blood lymphocytes, and a decrease in the incidence of severe infections. Another approach to the treatment of severe genetic diseases is now represented by somatic cell gene therapy. We and others have conducted experiments in vitro and in vivo that have documented that T-lymphocytes are suitable vehicles for gene transfer. Although the pluripotent stem cell remains the ideal target cell for somatic cell gene therapy of disorders of the hematopoietic system, the use of T-lymphocytes as gene therapy vehicles is specifically indicated for ADA-deficient patients where they represent the affected cells. Furthermore, the selective engraftment of T-cells only, following bone marrow transplantation, has resulted in reconstitution of cellular and humoral immunity. A model for the functional analysis in vivo of the human immune system has been utilized for the preclinical evaluation of this approach.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

T lymphocyte ontogeny in adenosine deaminase-deficient severe combined immune deficiency after treatment with polyethylene glycol-modified adenosine deaminase

Adenosine deaminase (ADA) deficiency causes severe combined immune deficiency (SCID) by interfering with the metabolism of deoxyadenosine, which is toxic to T lymphocytes at all stages of differentiation. Enzyme replacement with polyethylene glycol-modified ADA (PEG-ADA) has been previously shown to correct deoxyadenosine metabolism and improve mitogen-induced T lymphocyte proliferation. We studied the biochemical and immunologic effects of PEG-ADA in two infants with ADA-deficient SCID. While in a catabolic state, higher doses of PEG-ADA than previously described were required to normalize deoxyadenosine metabolism. After biochemical improvement, the patients recovered immune function in a pattern similar to that observed in normal thymic ontogeny and in patients with immunological reconstitution after bone marrow transplantation. Immune reconstitution was marked by the sequential appearance in the peripheral blood of phenotypic T lymphocytes corresponding to successive stages of thymic differentiation. Functional reconstitution was marked by the successive appearance of mitogen responses dependent on exogenous in vitro IL-2, mitogen responses not requiring exogenous IL-2, antigen-specific responses dependent on exogenous IL-2, and finally, antigen-specific responses not requiring exogenous IL-2. Natural killer function was tested in one patient and normalized with PEG-ADA therapy. Optimal PEG-ADA therapy appears to normalize thymic differentiation in ADA-deficient SCID, resulting in normal antigen-specific immune function.

Bone marrow transplantation in Europe: major geographical differences. The European Group for Bone Marrow Transplantation [EBMT]

In 1991 171 teams in 21 European countries performed 4976 bone marrow transplants. There were 1829 transplants from an HLA-identical sibling donor, 101 from a nonidentical family member, 30 from a twin, 217 from an unrelated volunteer donor and 2799 autologous transplants. Indications for transplants were leukaemias in 2569 (52%), lymphoproliferative disorders in 1472 (30%), solid tumours in 549 (11%), aplastic anaemia and thalassaemia in 261 (5%), inborn errors in 97 and miscellaneous disorders in 28 patients. There are marked differences between the participating European countries. They relate to absolute numbers, indications and techniques. Less than 10 transplants per 10-million inhabitants are performed in Eastern European countries. Ten to fifty transplants per 10-million inhabitants are done in two, 50-100 transplants per 10-million inhabitants in five, 100-200 transplants per 10-million inhabitants in eight countries and more than 200 per 10-million inhabitants in one country (P < 0.01). The number of transplant teams ranges from less than one to twelve per 10-million inhabitants (P < 0.01). For the continent it becomes 3.3 per 10-million inhabitants. The reasons for these differences are not explained by this survey. The most likely explanation for the differences in transplant activity is availability of transplant beds, trained staff and resources. Bone marrow transplants are expensive. However, the demand is increasing and will increase further with the routine availability of unrelated volunteer donors. Clearly, criteria are required in Europe to define the indications and solutions to meet the legitimate requirements for transplantation in the various regions of Europe.

Chimerism and tolerance to host and donor in severe combined immunodeficiencies transplanted with fetal liver stem cells

We have studied the peripheral T cell repertoire of two patients with severe combined immunodeficiency who were successfully treated with human histocompatibility leukocyte antigen (HLA)-mismatched fetal liver stem cell transplantation. The patients presented a split chimerism. T cells were of donor origin, whereas the B cells/monocytes were of the host phenotype. Interestingly, the natural killer (NK) cells in one patient were donor derived and in the other patient of host origin. The NK cells were functional but did not have antihost or donor reactivity. Despite the HLA mismatch between donor and host cells, complete tolerance was achieved in vivo, and a specific unresponsiveness of peripheral blood mononuclear cells from both patients toward the host cells was demonstrated in vitro. Nevertheless, we could isolate T cell receptor (TCR)alpha beta, CD4+ or CD8+, T cell clones specifically reacting with HLA class I and II molecules of the host. The CD4+ host-reactive T cell clones from both patients produced interleukins 2 and 5, interferon-gamma, granulocyte/macrophage colony-stimulating factor but are specifically defective in interleukin 4 production. The frequencies of CD8+ host-reactive T cells were high, and were in the same range as those observed for CD8+ alloreactive T cells. In contrast, no donor-reactive CD8+ T cells or host or donor-reactive TCR gamma delta + T cells were detected. These data indicate that, after fetal stem cell transplantation, donor-reactive, but not host-reactive cells, are deleted from the T cell repertoire. Therefore, a peripheral mechanism of suppression or clonal anergy, rather than clonal deletion, is involved in maintaining in vivo tolerance toward the host.

T-cell-depleted maternal bone marrow transplantation for siblings with X-linked severe combined immunodeficiency

Prenatal diagnosis of X-linked severe combined immunodeficiency in a male fetus made possible elective neonatal bone marrow transplantation before onset of symptoms. Bone marrow transplantation was performed by using T-cell-depleted maternal marrow that had been cryopreserved 2 years earlier, at the time that his older affected brother underwent transplantation. The second patient had less morbidity and more rapid reconstitution of his immune function.

Insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus and severe atopic dermatitis in a child with adenosine deaminase deficiency

We report a 2.3-year-old girl with complete lack of adenosine deaminase (ADA) activity who presented with severe atopic dermatitis and insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus but only mild recurrent infections. Abnormalities of immune function included profound depletion of CD8+ lymphocytes, hyperimmunoglobulinaemia E, and very low in vitro proliferative response to mitogens. Treatment with polyethylene glycol-conjugated ADA was followed by rapid amelioration of clinical and immunological conditions. The immunological and clinical features of this child suggest that the clinical spectrum of ADA deficiency may be broader than originally supposed.

Gene transfer of adenosine deaminase into primitive human hematopoietic progenitor cells

The inherited deficiency in adenosine deaminase (ADA), which results in severe combined immunodeficiency, is generally regarded as an optimal model for the development of human somatic gene therapy. The ideal target for the correction of ADA deficiency and other lympho-hematopoietic disorders would be the hematopoietic stem cell. We have used a combination of recombinant human interleukins-3 and -6 to stimulate the proliferation of primitive human hematopoietic progenitor cells during a period of co-cultivation with irradiated cells producing high titers of an ADA-transducing retroviral vector packaged in amphotropic particles. In a series of nine experiments, an average of 83% of the clonogenic progenitors (CFU-E and CFU-GM) were found to have acquired the transferred sequence as determined by polymerase chain reaction analysis. In addition, in two experiments, 24-44% of the clonogenic progenitors derived from long-term myeloid cultures 9 weeks post-transduction were found to contain vector sequence. The latter cells are derived from so-called "long-term culture-initiating cells" (LTC-IC), which are primitive cells probably related to hematopoietic stem cells. Moreover, the transduced ADA enzyme was found to be expressed in both normal and ADA-deficient erythroid colonies, and in the nonadherent cells of long-term bone marrow culture for at least 2 weeks at levels that approximate the endogenous ADA levels of normal erythroid cells. These results indicate that the ADA coding sequence can efficiently be introduced by retroviral gene transfer into both committed and primitive human hematopoietic progenitor cells, and that this will result in adequate expression of the transduced enzyme in the progeny of committed hematopoietic progenitors.

Severe combined immunodeficiency disease, adenosine deaminase deficiency and gene therapy

Patients with severe combined immunodeficiency disease represent a model for the first clinical applications of gene therapy. Present attempts use insertion of the human adenosine deaminase gene into the peripheral blood T lymphocytes of patients who lack this gene. The ultimate treatment, however, will require insertion of the normal human adenosine deaminase gene into pluripotent stem cells and expression of the gene in their progeny.