Programmed death of autoreactive thymocytes

Rat "first-wave" mature thymocytes: cycling lymphoblasts that are sensitive to activation-induced cell death but rescued by interleukin 2

The sequential appearance of thymocyte subsets in rat ontogeny was studied using the surface markers CD4, CD8, and the alpha/beta T cell receptor (here referred to as TcR). It was noted that the first TcRhigh thymocytes, appearing around birth, are not resting lymphocytes but cycling blast cells. These "first wave" TcRhigh cells are medullary in location and predominantly of the CD4/CD8 "single-positive" phenotype. Only about 5% express the light chain of the interleukin (IL)2 receptor, indicating that binding of IL 2 to high-affinity receptors is not driving proliferation of these blasts. Newborn TcR high blast cells were purified and analyzed in vitro. When cultured without further additions, they rapidly stopped cycling. Stimulation with cross-linked anti-TcR monoclonal antibody plus IL 2 resulted in vigorous and rapid proliferation that exhibited accelerated kinetics as compared to peripheral resting T cells. In contrast, TcR cross-linking without exogenous IL 2 induced cell death. This TcR-induced cell death involved fragmentation of DNA characteristic of apoptosis that was readily detectable within 18 h of culture. Addition of IL 2 to these short-term cultures prevented TcR-induced DNA fragmentation. Together, these results suggest that in newly formed TcRhigh thymocytes, TcR engagement results in clonal deletion if the IL 2 receptor remains unoccupied but allows clonal expansion if IL 2 is provided. This mechanism may be operative in the establishment of self-tolerance during T cell development.

Neonatal tolerance induction in the thymus to MHC-class II-associated antigens. IV. Significance of intrathymic chimerism of blood-born Ia+ cells in Mls tolerance

The significance of thymus cell chimerism in the induction and maintenance of tolerance was investigated. Mls-1b BALB/c mice were neonatally tolerized by the intravenous administration of either bone marrow (BM) cells or peritoneal cavity (PerC) cells from Mls-1b/a (BALB/c x AKR) F1 mice. Tolerance was long-lasting in the BM cell group, but transient in the PerC cell group, probably because PerC cells lack hemopoietic stem cells required for a continuous supply of tolerance-inducing cells. The degree of anti-Mls-1a responsiveness of these BALB/c thymus cells was correlated with the degree of intrathymic distribution of the inoculated F1 cells. The effect of BM cell inoculation, resulting in a year-long deletion of Mls-1a-reactive V beta 6-bearing T cells is in marked contrast to that of PerC cell inoculation which causes only a transient loss of V beta 6+ mature thymocytes (for about 1 week after birth). This functional profile of the tolerant state correlates well with the degree and persistence of the intrathymic presence of F1 type Ia+ cells. The long-lasting presence of donor-derived cells throughout the thymus tissue in the BM cell group is also in marked contrast to the early disappearance of Ia+ cells (within 2-3 weeks) from the cortex and then from the medulla in the PerC cell group, although these Ia+ cells were once spread throughout the thymus tissue 4 days after the tolerance-inducing cell inoculation. Taken together with a failure to induce consistent unresponsiveness to Mls-1a determinants in Mls-1b thymocytes regenerating in Mls-1a-thymic epithelial environments, all the above data indicate that intrathymic chimerism caused by hemopoietic stem cell-derived MHC-class II-bearing cells is a requisite for the induction and maintenance of unresponsiveness by means of clonal deletion in experimentally as well as naturally induced tolerance to Mls determinants.

BCL2 protein is topographically restricted in tissues characterized by apoptotic cell death

The BCL2 protooncogene encodes an inner mitochondrial membrane protein that blocks programmed cell death. BCL2 was isolated from the chromosomal breakpoint of follicular B-cell lymphoma. Transgenic mice that overexpress BCL2 display extended survival of resting B cells. In this study we use a monospecific anti-human BCL2 antibody to define the distribution of BCL2 protein within organized tissues. BCL2 is restricted within germinal centers to the follicular mantle and to portions of the light zone implicated in the selection and maintenance of plasma cells and memory B cells. BCL2 is present in the surviving T cells in the thymic medulla. All hematopoietic lineages that derive from a renewing stem cell also display BCL2. A limited number of nonlymphoid tissues demonstrate BCL2 and can be grouped as (i) glandular epithelium in which hormones or growth factors regulate hyperplasia and involution, (ii) complex differentiating epithelium such as skin and intestine characterized by long-lived stem cells, and (iii) long-lived postmitotic cells such as neurons. Within these tissues that demonstrate apoptotic cell turnover, BCL2 is often topographically restricted to long-lived or proliferating cell zones. BCL2's function as an antidote to apoptosis may confer longevity to progenitor and effector cells in these tissues.

Clonal deletion of autospecific B lymphocytes

Using mice transgenic for functional, rearranged immunoglobulin heavy and light chain genes, it can be demonstrated that B lymphocytes reactive with cell surface-bound class I MHC antigen can be controlled by clonal elimination. Even low-affinity cell-bound ligands can induce deletion. Deletion can occur in the pre-B to B cell transitional stage or after the B cells exist the bone marrow, depending on where the cells first encounter autoantigen. IgD appears to play no role in protecting cells from deletion. It is argued that defects in B-cell tolerance alone may be sufficient to lead to systemic autoimmunity.

Apoptosis is associated with the extensive B cell death in the sheep ileal Peyer's patch and the chicken bursa of Fabricius: a possible role in B cell selection

The ileal Peyer's patch (PP) and the bursa of Fabricius have major roles in populating the B cell system in sheep and chickens, respectively. These tissues contain greater than 90% B cells and possess a massive proliferation index with greater than 5% of B cells entering mitosis per hour. Paradoxically, almost all of the B cells produced in these sites rapidly die in situ. Here we show that the extensive B cell death occurring in the ileal PP and bursa is associated with apoptosis. Gel electrophoresis of ileal PP cell DNA from 7-14 week-old lambs and bursal cell DNA from 4-week-old chickens demonstrated a laddering of DNA in multiples of approximately 200 bp, a pattern indicative of apoptosis. In sheep, the intensity of the laddering pattern seen after agarose gel electrophoresis was always greater with ileal PP cell DNA compared with thymocyte DNA, and usually greater than jejunal PP cell DNA. Likewise, DNA isolated from chicken bursal cells and mouse PP cells always exhibited a more intense laddering pattern than chicken or mouse thymocytes, respectively. When placed in culture ileal PP cells died rapidly less than 40% viable cells were recovered after 24 h. Within 6 h of culture many ileal PP cells exhibited an apoptotic appearance in that they contained condensed chromatin and fragmented nuclei. Moreover, greater than 55% of total cellular DNA was fragmented. Compared with thymocytes, ileal PP cells underwent DNA fragmentation to a much greater extent and with a faster time course in short-term culture. We propose that cell death by apoptosis may make an important contribution to B cell development in the lamb ileal PP and the chicken bursa. Apoptosis may provide a mechanism for the diversification of the B cell immune repertoire and/or the selection of non-self reactive B cells.

Clonal expansion precedes anergy and death of V beta 8+ peripheral T cells responding to staphylococcal enterotoxin B in vivo

Staphylococcal enterotoxin B (SEB) selectively stimulates T cells bearing T cell receptor V beta 8 domains and hence provides a useful model to study immunity and tolerance in vivo. We show here that V beta 8+ T cells in both CD4+ and CD8+ subsets expand dramatically (fivefold) in lymphoid tissues of mice 2-4 days following injection with SEB. This initial clonal expansion, which is accompanied by a transient hyper-reactivity to SEB, is followed by a rapid decrease in V beta 8+ cells and a concomitant induction of specific non-responsiveness which persists for at least 30 days. Selective death of V beta 8+ cells occurs during this latter phase. Taken together, our data indicate that clonal expansion, anergy and death can occur as sequential stages of an immune response in vivo.

Cell death mechanisms and the immune system

The immune system provides good models for cell death, a phenomenon now recognized to be of fundamental importance in many fields of biology. Cell death is strikingly polymorphic: it can proceed via necrosis (as in complement-mediated cell death) or apoptosis, but the latter displays different patterns (in the receptor-mediated death of some thymocytes, in cell death mediated by TNF alpha or by cytotoxic T cells), perhaps reflecting different pathways of control of a common core mechanism. Even though there are differences in the morphological and metabolic changes associated with the different patterns of apoptosis, some recurrent sequences of events are observed in almost all dying cells. The metabolic state of a cell often seems to play a major role in determining if and how this cell will die in given external circumstances. The nature of molecules causally involved in the dying cell can now be approached in some systems.

Clonal deletion of immature CD4+8+ thymocytes in suspension culture by extrathymic antigen-presenting cells

One mechanism ensuring self tolerance of T cells is the clonal deletion of thymocytes bearing alpha beta T-cell receptors. The stage of thymocyte development at which the interaction with antigen-presenting cells (APCs) leads to deletion, however, has not been determined directly. Indirect evidence suggests that intrathymic APCs induce deletion of CD4+8+ thymocytes (which die by apoptosis) but deletion at less and more mature developmental stages has also been implied. It is also not clear if clonal elimination of thymocytes can be triggered by peripheral antigens carried on extrathymic APCs migrating through the thymus. Here we show antigen-specific induction of apoptosis in CD4+8+ thymocytes cultured in suspension, by thymic as well as splenic APCs. Thus the recognition of antigen by CD4+8+ thymocytes may lead to deletion, suggesting that this is the central mechanism of tolerance induction, which is not limited by the antigen-presenting ability of the thymic stroma.

CD77: an antigen of germinal center B cells entering apoptosis

We have previously reported that a neutral glycolipid (globotriosylceramide; Gb3) was specifically expressed on Burkitt's lymphoma cells and on a subset of germinal center tonsillar B lymphocytes. Recently the Gb3 molecule was recognized as a new B cell differentiation antigen and now defines the CD77 cluster. Here we report an extensive phenotypic and functional characterization of the tonsillar CD77+ B lymphocytes. These cells have a low buoyant density and are thus purified using a Percoll gradient. They express various B cell antigens such as CD19, CD20, CD21, CD22 and CD40, as well as the adhesion molecules LFA-1, LFA-3 and CD44. They are positive for surface IgM and negative for surface IgD. Although these results suggest a phenotype of activated B cells, the CD77+ cells are negative for the classical activation antigens: CD23 (the low-affinity Fc receptor for IgE), CD25 [the interleukin (IL) 2 receptor alpha chain] and CD71 (the transferrin receptor). Proliferation and protein synthesis of CD77+ cells was measured after stimulation with a range of mitogens and IL. None of the agents tested are able to induce proliferation and protein synthesis with the exception of a combination of recombinant IL 4 plus anti-CD40 antibody. When examined by electron microscopy, CD77+ B lymphocytes present a morphology similar to that of cells undergoing programmed cell death, also called apoptosis (i.e. chromatin condensation, nuclear fragmentation, membrane blebbing). As shown by direct examination of DNA, these CD77+ cells are indeed in the process of apoptosis. Treatment of the CD77+ cells by recombinant IL 4 and anti-CD40 antibody prevents apoptosis. All these results suggest that the CD77 molecule defines a B lymphocyte maturation pathway, specific for germinal center, where the cells undergo programmed cell death.

Repertoire development and ligand specificity of murine TCR gamma delta cells

During the past several years, we have been studying the circulating TCR gamma delta cells expressed in peripheral lymphoid tissues. Biochemical and molecular characterization of the TCR gamma delta heterodimers present on these TCR gamma delta cells identified 3 TCR gamma proteins, V gamma 2-C gamma 1, V gamma 1.2-C gamma 2, and V gamma 1.1-C gamma 4. In addition, at least 6 different V delta gene products (V delta 2,4,5,6,V alpha 10, V alpha 11) are expressed in peripheral lymphoid tissue. Nucleotide sequence analysis has revealed a great deal of junctional diversity present among the different V gamma and V delta proteins. Thus, compared to other nonlymphoid tissues (e.g., skin), this population of TCR gamma delta cells appears quite extensive. The development and specificity of TCR gamma delta cells has been pursued by two approaches. First, different TCR gamma delta cells clones were generated which recognize MHC-encoded gene products. One clone recognizes an unconventional TL-encoded antigen, whereas others have been shown to recognize either classical MHC class I or class II antigens. The TCR gamma delta receptor genes have been cloned from the TL-specific TCR gamma delta cell and used to construct transgenic mice to examine the development of TCR gamma delta cells. Although the Tg+ TCR gamma delta cells are tolerized by thymic clonal tolerance similar to TCR alpha beta cells, the epithelial Tg+ TCR gamma delta cells are subjected to non-deletional tolerance (anergy). A second approach towards examining the development of TCR gamma delta cells has been to compare the repertoire of TCR gamma delta splenocytes in a variety of inbred and MHC-congenic strains of mice using subset-specific anti-murine TCR gamma delta mAb. The percentage of individual subsets of splenic TCR gamma delta cells differ widely between different inbred strains of mice due to both MHC- and TCR-encoded genetic differences. In summary, these studies provides a basis for understanding and determining the ligand(s) of the TCR gamma delta heterodimer and the factors which shape the peripheral TCR gamma delta repertoire.

In vivo accumulation of sulfated glycoprotein 2 mRNA in rat thymocytes upon dexamethasone-induced cell death

Two hours after a single intraperitoneal injection of dexamethasone (20 micrograms/Kg b.w.) into adult male rats, a typical ladder of DNA fragments was detectable upon separation on agarose gels of DNA from thymocytes. This became maximally evident at 4 hours. Accumulation of sulfated glycoprotein-2 (SGP-2) mRNA, whose rate of expression has been associated to the processes of programmed cell death, preceded the appearance of DNA degradation, starting to increase as early as 30 min after steroid injection, and maintained higher than controls until 8 hrs; a different time course was shown by changes in the levels of beta-actin mRNA. In the spleen, under the same conditions, the SGP-2 message also increased at 30 min, prior to DNA fragmentation, but decreased thereafter below the control value.

Dose-dependent induction of apoptosis in human tumour cell lines by widely diverging stimuli

Cell death may occur by either of two mechanisms: apoptosis or necrosis. Necrosis, the first type of cell death to be recognized, is an uncontrolled degenerative phenomenon invariably caused by noxious stimuli and is the result of irreversible failure of membrane function. Apoptosis, on the other hand, is a death process which involves a series of well-organized events which require active cell participation, and is primarily caused by physiological stimuli. In the present study we show that cell death induced by a range of varied agents may take the form of either apoptosis or necrosis. Apoptotic cell death was found to occur at low levels of these agents, while at higher levels necrosis occurred. Hence, cells which are not killed directly, but merely injured by these agents, have the capacity to activate an internally programmed suicide death mechanism, whereas cells receiving greater injuries apparently do not. In addition, the presence of extracellular calcium was found to be necessary for the induction of apoptosis with all agents tested.

Role of MHC and antigens in T-cell development

The role of self-peptides in influencing the development of the T-cell repertoire has been the focus of recent studies. The findings suggest that the recognition of self-peptides bound to MHC proteins in the thymus is part of the thymic self-recognition process that results in selective maturation, or positive selection of T cells.

Towards an integrated view of thymopoiesis

One prediction from the complex series of steps in intrathymic T-cell differentiation is that to regulate it the stroma controlling the process must be equally complex: the attraction of precursors, commitment to the T-cell lineage, induction of T-cell receptor (TCR) gene rearrangement, accessory molecule expression, repertoire expansion, major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecule-based selection (positive and negative), acquisition of functional maturity and migratory capacity must all be controlled. In this review, Richard Boyd and Patrice Hugo combine knowledge of T-cell differentiation with thymic stromal cell heterogeneity to offer an integrated view of thymopoiesis within the thymic microenvironment.

An improved method for the detection of DNA fragmentation

An application of the Southern blot technique is described which permits the detection of DNA fragmentation due to cell death by apoptosis. DNA fragments were isolated from cell suspensions and tissues, separated on agarose gel, transferred by Southern blot and hybridized with a radiolabeled total cellular DNA probe. The application of this procedure to thymus cell samples, revealed the distinct ladder pattern of DNA fragments in multiples of about 180-200 base pairs, a characteristic feature of DNA fragmentation. In comparison to conventional DNA visualization with ethidium bromide staining, the radiolabeled probe improved the detection of DNA fragments at least eight-fold. This method detects low levels of DNA fragments, as well as physiological tissue DNA fragmentation, while avoiding cell damage due to DNA radiolabeling.

Programmed cell death and extrathymic reduction of Vbeta8+ CD4+ T cells in mice tolerant to Staphylococcus aureus enterotoxin B

Clonal deletion and functional inactivation of self-reactive cells have been invoked as mechanisms underlying intrathymic development of T-cell tolerance. The relative importance of these mechanisms in the development of tolerance of more mature, peripheral T cells either to self or to exogenous antigens is unclear, although recent data relate the development of T-cell tolerance in the periphery to clonal anergy. We have now investigated the induction of extrathymic tolerance using BALB/c mice that were made tolerant to Staphylococcus aureus enterotoxin B, a superantigen which specifically interacts in such mice with T cells bearing V beta 8 antigen receptors. Both euthymic and athymic mice made tolerant to S. aureus enterotoxin B had a markedly reduced number of V beta 8.1,2+ CD4+ peripheral T cells. This reduction was accompanied by genomic DNA fragmentation that is associated with cell death. These results indicate that a deletional mechanism can contribute to the induction of T-cell tolerance in peripheral lymphoid cells.

IL3-dependent cells die by apoptosis on removal of their growth factor

The IL3-dependent cell line FDCP-2 dies within 32 h of removal of IL3. Electron microscope studies indicate that 22 h after IL3 removal the nuclei are condensed, but the morphology of mitochondria and ribosomes is preserved. This pattern is characteristic of apoptosis. IL3 removal also results in the fragmentation of DNA into nucleosome-sized pieces, suggesting that an endonuclease is activated. The protein synthesis inhibitor, cycloheximide, enhances survival on IL3 removal, suggesting that death is an active process. The nuclease inhibitor, aurintricarboxylic acid, also enhances survival, suggesting a causal role for DNA fragmentation in apoptosis.

Induction by antigen of intrathymic apoptosis of CD4+CD8+TCRlo thymocytes in vivo

In order to examine the mechanisms by which clonal deletion of autoreactive T cells occurs, a peptide antigen was used to induce deletion of antigen-reactive thymocytes in vivo. Mice transgenic for a T cell receptor (TCR) that reacts to this peptide contain thymocytes that progress from the immature to the mature phenotype. Intraperitoneal administration of the peptide antigen to transgenic mice results in a rapid deletion of the immature CD4+ CD8+ TCRlo thymocytes. Apoptosis of cortical thymocytes can be seen within 20 hours of treatment. These results provide direct evidence for the in vivo role of apoptosis in the development of antigen-induced tolerance.

Neurohormonal immunoregulation

The immune system may be divided into primary lymphoid organs (bone marrow, bursa of Fabricius, and thymus), which produce mature leukocytes and secondary organs (spleen, lymph nodes, tonsils, Peyer's patches, etc.), which are concerned with specific immune responses. In the primary organs, stem cells proliferate and differentiate into various subsets of polymorphonuclear and mononuclear cells. Evidence is increasing that cell proliferation in the primary lymphoid organs is dependent on pituitary growth hormone (GH) and prolactin (PRL), which control the expression of growth regulatory genes (protooncogenes) such as c-myc and also induce essential growth factors (insulinlike growth factor, thymic and bursal hormones, etc.) and, possibly, their receptors. The adrenocorticotropic hormone-adrenal axis serves as an inhibitory pathway, antagonizing the action of PRL and GH on primary lymphoid tissue. The effect of glucocorticoids is especially forceful on thymocytes through the activation of the genetically programmed suicide pathway. Sex hormones also regulate the primary lymphoid organs, but their mechanism of action remains to be clarified. Thymus-derived feedback signals toward the pituitary gland have already been described. The pituitary gland exerts a similar regulatory influence on mature lymphocytes during their antigen-driven differentiation. PRL or GH is required for primary immune reactions; however, the secondary immune response may be less dependent on these hormones. Once the immune system is primed, antigen itself becomes a primary regulator. Exposure of memory cells to antigen leads to the production of growth factors (interleukins) and to the expression of their receptors. Therefore, antigen appears to fulfill, at this stage, a role that is originally played by GH or PRL in the primary lymphoid organs and, to some extent, also during antigen-driven differentiation. During immune reactions, interleukin-1 and tumor necrosis factor activate the adrenocorticotropic hormoneadrenal axis, which plays an important role in setting upper limits to and terminating responses. Lymphocytes have receptors for and react to numerous hormones, neurotransmitters, and mediators derived from a number of organs and tissues. Therefore, ultimately the reaction of a lymphocyte will be the vector of all positive and negative signals received. A hierarchy and sequential system of signals exists. Primary regulatory signals (competence signals) represent the most powerful regulators (e.g., PRL, GH or antigen) of lymphoid cells. The delivery of a competence signal is the prerequisite for subsequent lymphoproliferation, which is regulated by growth factors that are specific for a certain developmental stage of the lymphoid cell and act sequentially. Hormonal factors that promote growth and differentiation deliver the second regulatory signals. Competence factors and growth and differentiation hormones regulate gene expression in lymphocytes. The third class of signals modulate the function of mature effector cells (e.g., locomotion, secretion, phagocytosis, cytotoxicity). Neuro-transmitters appear to function as secondary signal modulators and tertiary functional regulators.

How many signals are enough?

The many signals that control the progress of various immune responses to both foreign and self antigens can be divided into no less than three major groups. The first group is the initial positive stimulus, associated with activation events through antigen receptors and their associated proteins. These signals launch lymphocytes in their response to antigen, either foreign or self. The second group of signals is negative and involves various end products and interactions between cells, all recognizing antigen. These signals are endogenous to the reacting cell, or nearly so (two interacting cells from the same clone, daughter cells, which are in the same locale and bind to the same ligand). The third group (the prevention of end product feedback, involving various forms of antigen presentation, T cell contributions, rheumatoid factor activity, and other mechanisms) is more likely to occur with nonself antigens, which are temporally and spatially more restricted than self antigens. Experimental evidence for this immunological schema is summarized and clarified in its relationship to the Bretscher-Cohn theory of self-nonself recognition and to suppressor cell and idiotype-antiidiotypic theories.

Thymic dendritic cells and B cells: isolation and function

The thymus is the primary organ in which T cells undergo rearrangement of T cell receptor alpha and beta genes, positive selection for affinity to self MHC products, and elimination (negative selection) of reactivity to self antigens. These events require an interaction of the developing T cell with other cell types in the thymus. The latter include epithelial cells, macrophages, dendritic cells, and the recently described thymic B cells the majority of which are CD5+. Here we review the identification and isolation of thymic dendritic cells and CD5+ B cells. We consider phenotype, ontogeny, and function, including possible contributions to the induction of self tolerance. Thymic dendritic cells are similar to spleen dendritic cells, but are larger and exhibit a few differences in phenotype. Dendritic cells from both organs are equally potent accessory cells for the MLR and lectin-induced, T cell proliferation. Thymic dendritic cells have higher levels of Fc receptors and support anti-CD3 dependent mitogenesis. Thymic CD5+ B cells share phenotypic features with peritoneal CD5+ B cells. However thymic B cells neither proliferate nor form antibody producing cells in response to the stimulation with LPS or anti-IgM plus IL-4, but do respond to stimulation with MHC class II-restricted helper T cells. Thymic dendritic cells and CD5+ B cells both appear at a similar time in ontogeny, about 14 d of gestation, which is the time T cell differentiation begins to take place. Dendritic cells from spleen, which are potent activators for peripheral T cells, are also potent inactivators for thymic-derived cytotoxic T cells. A correlation between reactivity to MIs products and the expression of TCR-V beta genes is well documented, and B cells are the primary APC for this antigen. Therefore, thymic CD5+ B cells may be a good tool for the investigation of tolerance to M1s products.