Prone positioning attenuates and redistributes ventilator-induced lung injury in dogs

Low tidal volume ventilation induces proinflammatory and profibrogenic response in lungs of rats

OBJECTIVE

We examined whether mechanical ventilation with low tidal volume induces polymorphonuclear infiltration and proinflammatory and profibrogenic responses in rat lungs compared dependent and nondependent lung region to expression of interleukin-1beta (IL-1beta) and alpha-1 procollagen III (PC III) mRNA.

DESIGN

An experimental, randomized and controlled protocol with previously normal rats.

INTERVENTIONS

Three groups of ten animals were studied. Two groups were ventilated (FIO2=0.3) in supine position for 1 h without positive end expiratory pressure, one group with a low tidal volume (6 ml/kg), and the other with a high tidal volume (24 ml/kg). In the third group animals were kept in spontaneous ventilation for 1 h.

MEASUREMENTS AND RESULTS

After ventilation the right lung was used to quantify polymorphonuclear infiltration. The left lung was divided into dependent and nondependent regions, and expression of IL-1beta and PC III mRNA was quantified by northern blot analysis. The group ventilated with low tidal volume had greater polymorphonuclear infiltration IL-1beta and PC III mRNA expression than the nonventilated group. Similar results were observed with high tidal volumes. There was no difference between low and high tidal volume ventilation. Expression levels of IL-1beta and PC III mRNA were higher in the nondependent region of ventilated groups and equal in the nonventilated group.

CONCLUSIONS

Even a low tidal volume mode of mechanical ventilation induces proinflammatory and profibrogenic response, with a nondependent predominance for IL-1beta and PC III mRNA expression in supine, ventilated, previously normal rats.

Clinical review: the implications of experimental and clinical studies of recruitment maneuvers in acute lung injury

Mechanical ventilation can cause and perpetuate lung injury if alveolar overdistension, cyclic collapse, and reopening of alveolar units occur. The use of low tidal volume and limited airway pressure has improved survival in patients with acute lung injury or acute respiratory distress syndrome. The use of recruitment maneuvers has been proposed as an adjunct to mechanical ventilation to re-expand collapsed lung tissue. Many investigators have studied the benefits of recruitment maneuvers in healthy anesthetized patients and in patients ventilated with low positive end-expiratory pressure. However, it is unclear whether recruitment maneuvers are useful when patients with acute lung injury or acute respiratory distress syndrome are ventilated with high positive end-expiratory pressure, and in the presence of lung fibrosis or a stiff chest wall. Moreover, it is unclear whether the use of high airway pressures during recruitment maneuvers can cause bacterial translocation. This article reviews the intrinsic mechanisms of mechanical stress, the controversy regarding clinical use of recruitment maneuvers, and the interactions between lung infection and application of high intrathoracic pressures.

Combined effects of prone positioning and airway pressure release ventilation on gas exchange in patients with acute lung injury

BACKGROUND

Prone positioning has been shown to improve oxygenation in 60-70% of patients with acute lung injury (ALI) or acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS). Another way to improve matching of ventilation to perfusion is the use of partial ventilatory support. Preserving spontaneous breathing during mechanical ventilation has been shown to improve oxygenation in comparison with controlled mechanical ventilation. However, no randomized studies are available exploring the effects of preserved spontaneous breathing on gas exchange in combination with prone positioning. Our aim was to determine whether the response of oxygenation to the prone position differs between pressure-controlled synchronized intermittent mandatory ventilation with pressure support (SIMV-PC/PS) and airway pressure release ventilation with unsupported spontaneous breathing (APRV).

METHODS

We undertook a prospective randomized intervention study in a medical-surgical adult intensive care unit of a university hospital. Of 45, 33 ALI patients (acute lung injury) within 72 h after initiation of mechanical ventilation, and in whom the prone position was applied according to a predefined strategy, were included in the study. After initial stabilization the patients were randomized to receive either SIMV-PC/PS or APRV with predefined general ventilatory goals (PEEP, tidal volume, inspiratory pressure and PaCO2-level). The protocol for prone positioning was the same for both treatment arms. Prone positioning was triggered by finding a PaO2/FiO2-ratio below 200 mmHg evaluated twice per day. The duration of each prone episode was 6 h.

RESULTS

The first two episodes of prone positioning were analyzed. Gas exchange was measured before and at the end of prone positioning. Of the 45 patients enrolled, 33 were turned prone once and 28 twice. No significant differences were detected in baseline characteristics. Changes in oxygenation were analyzed in response to the first and second prone episodes 5 h and 24 h after randomization and initiation of SIMV-PC/PS or APRV respectively. Before the first prone episode the PaO2/FiO2-ratio was significantly better (P = 0.02) in the APRV-group (median; interquartile range) (162; 108-192 mmHg) than in the SIMV-PC/PS-group (123; 78-154 mmHg). The response in oxygenation to the first prone episode was similar in both groups: PaO2/FiO2-ratio increased 39.5; 17.75-77.5 mmHg in the SIMV-PC/PS-group and 75.0; 9.0-125.0 mmHg in the APRV-group (P = 0.49). Before the second prone episode, the PaO2/FiO2-ratio was comparable (SIMV-PC/PS 130.5; 61.0-161.0 mmHg vs. APRV 134; 98.3-175.0 mmHg). Improvement in oxygenation was significantly (P = 0.02) greater in the APRV group (82; 37.0-141.0 mmHg) than in the SIMV-PC/PS group (50; 24.0-68.8 mmHg) during the second prone episode. General ventilatory and hemodynamic variables and use of sedatives were similar in both groups during the study.

CONCLUSIONS

APRV during prone positioning is feasible in the treatment of ALI patients. APRV after 24 h appears to enhance improvement in oxygenation in response to prone positioning.

[Effects of prone position, inhaled nitric oxide and surfactant in children with hypoxemic pulmonary disease]

OBJECTIVE

To analyze the therapeutic response to prone position, inhaled nitric oxide (NO) and surfactant in children with hypoxemic pulmonary disease.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We studied the effect of prone position, NO, and surfactant in critically ill children with acute hypoxemic pulmonary disease unresponsive to conventional therapy. We analyzed PaO2, SatO2, the PaO2/FiO2 ratio, oxygenation index and PaCO2 before and after each treatment, as well as the subsequent clinical course. An increase of more than 20 % in the PaO2/FiO2 ratio was considered a positive response.

RESULTS

Ninety treatments were administered in 56 patients: 55 patients were treated with NO, 18 with prone position and 17 with surfactant. All three treatments substantially improved oxygenation. The mean increase in the PaO2/FiO2 ratio was 35 % with nitric oxide, 33 % with prone position and 50 % with surfactant. The mean decrease in oxygenation index was 22 % with nitric oxide, 24 % with prone position and 17 % with surfactant. Seventy-one percent of patients treated with NO, 61 % of patients treated with prone position, and 64 % of patients who received surfactant were responders. The three treatments produced a slight decrease in PaCO2 (2.5 mmHg with nitric oxide, 4.7 mmHg with prone position and 5.1 mmHg with surfactant).

CONCLUSIONS

Inhaled NO, prone position and surfactant improve oxygenation in some children with hypoxic pulmonary disease.

Effects of prone and supine posture on cardiopulmonary function after experimental chlorine gas lung injury

BACKGROUND

Chlorine gas may induce severe acute lung injury. Improvement of pulmonary gas exchange in patients and animals with acute lung injury nursed in the prone position was observed in recent years. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effects of prone and supine positions on pulmonary and cardiovascular functions following experimental chlorine gas lung injury.

METHODS

Twenty anesthetized and mechanically ventilated pigs were exposed to chlorine gas (400 p.p.m. in air) for 20 min in the supine position, then assigned randomly to ventilation in the supine or prone positions (n=10 in each group). Hemodynamics, gas exchange, lung mechanics and oxygen transport were evaluated for 5 h.

RESULTS

All animals showed severe pulmonary dysfunction immediately after chlorine gassing with a threefold increase in pulmonary vascular resistance index, a drop in arterial oxygenation (12.3+/-1.3 kPa to 5.4+/-0.7 kPa) and a fall in lung-thorax compliance (22+/-1 ml cmH2O-1 to 8+/-2 ml cmH2O-1). Venous admixture (Qs/Qt) improved in animals in the prone position while there was no change in the supine position (prone 32+/-11% vs. supine 42+/-9% at 5 h,P<0.05). Lung-thorax compliance improved significantly with time in the prone group only (P<0.01). Oxygen delivery increased significantly in prone animals compared with animals nursed in the supine posture (P<0.001).

CONCLUSION

Immediate prone positioning after chlorine gas injury not only inhibited deterioration of gas exchange but was also associated with improved pulmonary function and oxygen transport.

Impact of low pulmonary vascular pressure on ventilator-induced lung injury

OBJECTIVE

To study the impact of low pulmonary vascular pressure on ventilator-induced lung injury.

DESIGN

Randomized prospective animal study.

SUBJECTS

Isolated perfused rabbit heart-lung preparation.

SETTINGS

Animal research laboratory in a university hospital.

INTERVENTIONS

Twenty isolated sets of normal lungs were perfused (constant flow, 0.3 L/min; left atrial pressure, 6 mm Hg), ventilated for 20 min (pressure control ventilation, 15 cm H2O; baseline period), and then randomized into three groups. Group A (control, n = 7) was perfused and ventilated as previously described during three consecutive 20-min periods. In group B (high airway pressure/normal left atrial pressure, n = 7), pressure control ventilation was 20, 25, and 30 cm H2O during each period. Group C (high airway pressure/low left atrial pressure, n = 6) was ventilated as group B but, in contrast to groups A and B, left atrial pressure was reduced to 1 mm Hg.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

The rate of edema formation (WGR, weight gain per minute normalized for initial lung weight) and the ultrafiltration coefficient (Kf) were measured during and after each period and their changes from baseline [DeltaWGR (edema formation index) and DeltaKf (vascular permeability index)] calculated to compare groups. The incidence and timing of vascular failure were compared. Vascular failure was considered to be present if all the following conditions were met: pulmonary hypertension, accelerated weight gain, and occurrence of fluid leak from the lungs. At the end of the study, DeltaWGR (g.g.min(-1)) was higher in group C (0.54 +/- 0.17) than in groups B (0.08 +/- 0.04) and A (0.00 +/- 0.01; p<.05), as well as in group B compared with A (p <.05). Similar differences between groups (p <.05) were found for DeltaK (g x min(-1) x cm H2O(-1) x 100 g(-1)): C, 7.24 +/- 2.36; B, 1.40 +/- 0.49; A, 0.01 +/- 0.03. Vascular failure was not observed in groups A and B but occurred in all but one preparation in group C (p <.05; C vs. A and B).

CONCLUSION

Reducing left atrial pressure results in more severe ventilator-induced lung injury. These results suggest that lung blood volume modulates cyclic tidal lung stress.

Characterization of a murine model of endotoxin-induced acute lung injury

Endotoxin-induced microvascular lung injury in mice is a commonly used experimental model of the acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS). The present paper aimed to characterize this popular model in a comprehensive and systematic fashion. Male C57bl/6 mice (n = 5) were administered an LD55 dose of E. coli endotoxin (15 mg/kg, i.p.), and lungs were harvested at several time points and evaluated for injury as well as for expression of a variety of inflammatory mediators. Endotoxin induced many features characteristic of acute microvascular lung injury. These included early (1-2 h) expression of inflammatory mediators (IL-1alpha, IL-1beta, IL-4, IL-6, IL-10, TNF-alpha, interferon-alpha, interferon gamma, and MCP-1) and leukocyte accumulation in lung tissue (lung myeloperoxidase activity 18.5 +/- 7.8 U/g tissue, P < 0.05), followed by pulmonary edema (lung water content index 17.4% +/- 2.5%, P < 0.05) and mortality. Histopathological evaluation of lung tissue was compatible with these findings. The characterization of this murine model of endotoxin-induced microvascular injury will facilitate its utilization in ARDS research.

Reduced tidal volumes and lung protective ventilatory strategies: where do we go from here?

Three major determinants of lung injury associated with mechanical ventilation have been clearly identified: high pressure/high volume, the shear forces caused by intratidal collapse and decollapse leading to barotrauma/volotrauma/biotrauma. The lung protective strategy aims to reduce the impact of all three determinants. A groundbreaking study showed that reduced tidal volume is less dangerous than high tidal volume, but the researchers did not apply "full" lung protective strategy and did not take into account the shear forces. "Full" protective lung strategy was tested in only one study and in a limited number of patients. Several physiologic studies strongly suggest the advantages of the lung protective strategy.

Pro/con clinical debate: the use of prone positioning in the management of patients with acute respiratory distress syndrome

Critical care medicine is a relatively new specialty and as such there is not a great deal of accumulated data to allow clinicians to practice 'evidence-based medicine' in all situations they encounter. When evidence does exist, intensivists may choose not to follow it based on 'gut feelings' or their own interpretation of how the data apply to their patient. It is perhaps not surprising that these latter events occur given that intensivists are often literally fighting for their patient's lives. Prone positioning evokes a large emotional response from many intensivists. Despite accumulating data there appears to be two camps of clinicians: those who strongly believe in the therapy, and those who want more data. The emotion and rationale for the mindset of the two camps is evident in this issue of Critical Care Forum. With compelling arguments on both sides of the fence, it is apparent that this debate is far from over. The authors of this pro/con debate, which is based on a clinical scenario, first describe their position and then respond to their opponent's position.

Effect of prone positioning on the survival of patients with acute respiratory failure

BACKGROUND

Although placing patients with acute respiratory failure in a prone (face down) position improves their oxygenation 60 to 70 percent of the time, the effect on survival is not known.

METHODS

In a multicenter, randomized trial, we compared conventional treatment (in the supine position) of patients with acute lung injury or the acute respiratory distress syndrome with a predefined strategy of placing patients in a prone position for six or more hours daily for 10 days. We enrolled 304 patients, 152 in each group.

RESULTS

The mortality rate was 23.0 percent during the 10-day study period, 49.3 percent at the time of discharge from the intensive care unit, and 60.5 percent at 6 months. The relative risk of death in the prone group as compared with the supine group was 0.84 at the end of the study period (95 percent confidence interval, 0.56 to 1.27), 1.05 at the time of discharge from the intensive care unit (95 percent confidence interval, 0.84 to 1.32), and 1.06 at six months (95 percent confidence interval, 0.88 to 1.28). During the study period the mean (+/-SD) increase in the ratio of the partial pressure of arterial oxygen to the fraction of inspired oxygen, measured each morning while patients were supine, was greater in the prone than the supine group (63.0+/-66.8 vs. 44.6+/-68.2, P=0.02). The incidence of complications related to positioning (such as pressure sores and accidental extubation) was similar in the two groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Although placing patients with acute respiratory failure in a prone position improves their oxygenation, it does not improve survival.

Perfusion characteristics of oleic acid--injured canine lung on Gd-DTPA--enhanced dynamic magnetic resonance imaging

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES

We conducted an animal study to describe and interpret the perfusion characteristics of oleic acid (OA)-injured lungs on gadopentetate dimeglumine (Gd-DTPA)-enhanced dynamic perfusion magnetic resonance (MR) imaging.

METHODS

Fourteen dogs received an intravenous OA infusion in the supine (n = 4), prone (n = 4), and right lateral decubitus (n = 6) positions, and 10 minutes later these animals in the same postures underwent the dynamic MR study. Regional Gd-DTPA kinetics was analyzed by the time-signal intensity (SI) curves and by qualitative functional map images of the mean transit time that was representative of the mean circulation time in the vascular bed and the average cumulative sum of the relative increases in SI representative of Gd-DTPA distribution volume during Gd-DTPA first pass. The results were compared with those in six control animals and in another six animals that underwent the MR study 3 minutes (n = 3) and 60 minutes (n = 3) after OA infusion. The MR findings were correlated with the distribution of lung damage and the infused OA particles as assessed by histology.

RESULTS

The dynamic MR study showed postural shifts on the gravity-dependent perfusion map of normal lungs. Contrast enhancement during Gd-DTPA first pass in the lung was lower and more heterogeneous in the OA-injured lung models than in controls but was followed by conversely greater and persistent enhancement during the Gd-DTPA redistribution phase. Regardless of the postures for OA infusion, these abnormalities were predominant in the dependent lungs and became more pronounced with time after OA infusion, where more prominent capillary obstruction with OA droplets and alveolar/interstitial edema were histologically observed. On the functional map images, greater mean transit time and the average cumulative sum of the relative increases in SI values were also predominantly distributed in the dependent lungs.

CONCLUSIONS

Low and heterogeneous enhancement was observed during Gd-DTPA first pass but was followed by persistent enhancement during the Gd-DTPA redistribution phase, and predominant abnormalities in the dependent lungs may be characteristic features of the perfusion of OA-injured lungs. The histological correlations indicate that these abnormalities may reflect OA-induced pathophysiologies associated with capillary OA obstruction, increased vascular resistance, and capillary permeability/extravascular spaces and that lung damage may be gravity dependent.

Potential of Gd-DTPA-mannan liposome particles as a pulmonary perfusion MRI contrast agent: an initial animal study

Suga K, Mikawa M, Ogasawara N, et al. Potential of Gd-DTPA-mannan liposome particles as a pulmonary perfusion MRI contrast agent: An initial animal study. Invest Radiol 2001;36:136-145.

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES

A paramagnetic, particle-type MR contrast agent, (Gd-diethylenetriamine pentaacetic acid [DTPA]-mannan-cholesterol)-coated liposomes, was designed to localize in the lung by the mechanism of capillary blockade, and the potential of this agent for pulmonary perfusion MRI was experimentally investigated.

METHODS

Before and up to 60 minutes after slow injection of this contrast agent, MR images were sequentially acquired at 10-second intervals along the same transaxial plane of the lung by using a gradient-echo pulse sequence with a short echo time of 1.2 ms on a 1.5-T MR scanner. After the minimal dose for obtaining a sufficient lung enhancement effect was determined in five rabbits, the time course of the enhancement effect was evaluated in six dogs by arterial blood gas analysis. The efficacy of MRI for detecting perfusion defects was evaluated in seven other dogs with pulmonary embolism.

RESULTS

Normal lungs were dose-dependently enhanced by this agent, and with a 2.0 mL/kg dose, dependent lungs were enhanced by more than 201%, with an average half-life of the enhancement effect of 35.7 +/- 5.3 minutes. With less than this dose (1.0-1.5 mL/kg), all of the embolized lung portions were clearly identified as perfusion defects. The prolonged enhancement effect allowed the acquisition of subsequent multisectional lung images, thus facilitating the assessment of anatomic location and extent of the perfusion defects. The reduction of PaO2 in room air after injection was within 5 mm Hg in both normal and embolized animals.

CONCLUSIONS

These initial, experimental results show that paramagnetically labeled liposome particles may be a successful MR contrast agent for pulmonary perfusion imaging.

Acute lung injury: outcomes and new therapies

Mortality rates in ARDS are improving, with several recent studies reporting mortality in the order of 20-40% rather than the early descriptions of this disease in which a mortality of 40-60% or higher was frequently cited. The ability to accurately predict outcomes plays an important role in the assessment of the impact of new therapies. Traditionally clinicians have relied on simple respiratory indices to assess mortality risk; however, the predictive ability of such indices, particularly early in the course of the disease, is somewhat limited. Adult data suggest that improved prediction not only of the outcome of established ARDS but also of the development of ARDS in at-risk patients may be obtained by measuring the concentrations of inflammatory mediators and/or surfactant-associated proteins in plasma or bronchoalveolar lavage samples. A bewildering array of therapies for ARDS is available; in many cases the benefits are uncertain. Treatments of proven value in adults include using PEEP beyond the lower inflection point of the pressure-volume curve and limiting tidal volumes to 6 ml/kg. Nitric oxide appears to offer no benefit to outcomes, although it does improve oxygenation in some patients. Surfactant is still undergoing assessment in randomised controlled trials; however, the use of aerosolised surfactant has been recently shown to be ineffective in adult patients with ARDS. Perfluorocarbon-assisted gas exchange (PAGE) or partial liquid ventilation is similarly still being assessed in randomised controlled trials in adults.