Mitochondrial free radical production and aging in mammals and birds

Hydrogen peroxide overproduction in megamitochondria of troglitazone-treated human hepatocytes

Troglitazone has been withdrawn from therapeutic options for diabetes mellitus because of its severe hepatocyte toxicity of unknown pathogenesis. The aim of the present study was to assess both morphologic and functional alterations in the mitochondria of troglitazone-treated hepatocytes. A polarized human hepatocyte cell line, OUMS-29, was used in this study. The mitochondrial volume and the mitochondrial transmembrane potential (DeltaPsi(m)) were examined using flow cytometry with nonylacridine orange (NAO) and rhodamine-123, respectively. An ultrastructural examination of the troglitazone-treated OUMS-29 cells was performed using transmission electron microscopy (TEM). Reactive oxygen species (ROS) production was assessed using flow cytometry with dihydroethidium and 2',7'-dichlorodihydrofluorescein diacetate. A significant increase in the mitochondrial volume of the troglitazone-treated cells was found by the NAO analysis, in comparison with pioglitazone-treated and ciglitazone-treated cells. The increase in volume was due to a marked enlargement in the mitochondria. The markedly enlarged mitochondria with intramitochondrial electron-dense deposits were confirmed on TEM, which showed myelin-like structures, indicating degraded membrane constituents. The troglitazone-treated cells showed a significant decline in the DeltaPsi(m) per unit mitochondrial volume but resulted in no clear cell death. ROS analysis revealed a significant production of hydrogen peroxide in the troglitazone-treated hepatocytes. This production was attenuated using an antioxidant, N-acetyl-L-cysteine. In conclusion, troglitazone caused overproduction of hydrogen peroxide, which deteriorated both mitochondrial membrane structures and mitochondrial function, leading to a possible priming for the severe hepatocyte toxicity.

Lipid peroxidation and the aging process

Consistent evidence supports the hypothesis that a progressive accumulation of oxidative damage to important cellular molecules is a fundamental mechanism involved in most senescence-associated alterations. Oxidative damage occurs when free radicals produced within an organism are not completely destroyed by the appropriate endogenous defense systems. Because lipids are a major component of living organisms and probably the first easy target of free radicals once they are produced, lipid peroxidation might play an important role in initiating and/or mediating some aspects of the aging process. It has been widely demonstrated that there is an age-associated increase in the steady-state concentrations of lipid peroxidation products. However, establishing the involvement of this phenomenon in the pathogenesis of the aging process has not been an easy task. The recent development of more reliable techniques to measure lipid peroxidation, together with more well-defined animal models of aging, should be of great help in future studies in this field. The current evidence for the presence and importance of lipid peroxidation in the aging process is discussed in this review.

Age-specific metabolic rates and mortality rates in the genus Drosophila

Early theories of aging suggested that organisms with relatively high metabolic rates would live shorter lives. Despite widespread tests of this 'rate of living' theory of aging, there is little empirical evidence to support the idea. A more fine-grained approach that examined age-related changes in metabolic rate over the life span could provide valuable insight into the relationship between metabolic rate and aging. Here we compare age-related metabolic rate (measured as CO2 production per hour) and age-related mortality rate among five species in the genus Drosophila. We find no evidence that longer-lived species have lower metabolic rates. In all five species, there is no clear evidence of an age-related metabolic decline. Metabolic rates are strikingly constant throughout the life course, with the exception of females of D. hydei, in which metabolic rates show an increase over the first third of the life span and then decline. We argue that some physiological traits may have been shaped by such strong selection over evolutionary time that they are relatively resistant to the decline in the force of selection that occurs within the life time of a single individual. We suggest that comparisons of specific traits that do not show signs of aging with those traits that do decline with age could provide insight into the aging process.

Spiral ligament pathology in quiet-aged gerbils

The ultrastructure of the spiral ligament was compared in aged and young gerbils to assess the involvement of connective tissues in the lateral wall and particularly the fibrocytes in development of presbyacusis. Pathologic features in fibrocytes of senescent gerbils spanned a wide range reflecting different stages of lateral wall involution. All of the type II, IV and V fibrocytes selectively developed cytosolic vacuoles in an early degenerative phase showing minimal strial involvement. Clear spaces indicative of interstitial edema separated the vacuolated cell bodies and their plasmalemmal processes. As a presumed intermediate phase, profiles of amorphous substance apparently derived from apoptosis/necrosis of type II fibrocytes infiltrated the type II fibrocyte area among nearly normal appearing cells. In cochlear turns with advanced strial degeneration, type II fibrocytes disappeared from the spiral prominence area leaving only type I-like fibrocytes occasionally accompanied by a collagen infiltrate. Type V fibrocytes disappeared similarly from the suprastrial area. The extent of atrophy in type II fibrocytes corresponded in general with that in the neighboring stria vascularis. Age-dependent atrophy in the lateral wall largely spared type I fibrocytes except that they often enclosed discrete amorphous foci lacking organelles. The involution thus affected principally the Na,K-ATPase-positive fibrocytes functioning in active uptake rather than passive conductance of K(+). The vacuolization and degeneration exclusive to ATPase-rich fibrocytes and the associated intercellular edema are interpreted as secondary responses, possibly as a result of impaired diffusion of K(+) through downstream marginal cells.

Mechanisms of aging: an appraisal of the oxidative stress hypothesis

The main purpose of this article is to provide a critical overview of the currently available evidence bearing on the validity of the oxidative stress hypothesis of aging, which postulates that senescence-associated attenuations in physiological functions are caused by molecular oxidative damage. Several lines of correlative evidence support the predictions of the hypothesis, e.g., macromolecular oxidative damage increases with age and tends to be associated with life expectancy of organisms. Nevertheless, a direct link between oxidative stress and aging has not as yet been established. Single gene mutations have been reported to extend the life spans of lower organisms, such as nematodes and insects; however, such prolongations of chronological clock time survival are usually associated with decreases in the rate of metabolism and reproductive output without affecting the metabolic potential, i.e., the total amount of energy consumed during life. Studies on genetic manipulations of the aging process have often been conducted on relatively short-lived strains that are physiologically weak, whereby life-span extensions can not be unambiguously assigned to a slowing effect on the rate of aging. It is concluded that although there is considerable evidence implicating oxidative stress in the aging process, additional evidence is needed to clearly define the nature of the involvement.

Enhancement of protein kinase C activity and chemiluminescence intensity in mitochondria isolated from the kidney cortex of rats treated with cephaloridine

The development of nephrotoxicity induced by cephaloridine (CER) has been reported to be due to reactive oxygen species (ROS). Protein kinase C (PKC) has been suggested to modulate the generation of ROS. We investigated the possible participation of ROS generation assessed by chemiluminescence (CL) and PKC activity in rat kidney cortical mitochondria in the development of CER-induced nephrotoxicity. We first evaluated the magnitude of the nephrotoxic damage caused by CER in rats. The plasma parameters and ultrastructural morphology changes were increased markedly 24hr after the treatment of rats with CER. We demonstrated that the treatment of rats with CER clearly evoked not only enhancement of Cypridina luciferin analog (CLA)-dependent CL intensity, but also the activation of PKC in mitochondria isolated from the kidney cortex of rats 1.5 and 3.5 hr after injection of the drug. These changes were detected in advance of those observed in plasma and by electron microscopy. The increase in CLA-dependent CL intensity detected in the kidney cortical mitochondria 1.5 and 3.5 hr after injection of CER was inhibited completely by the addition of superoxide dismutase, suggesting the generation of superoxide anion in these mitochondria during the early stages of CER-induced nephrotoxicity. These results suggest that the activation of PKC and the enhancement of superoxide anion generation in kidney cortical mitochondria precede the increases in plasma parameters and the electron micrographic changes indicative of renal dysfunction in rats treated with CER. Additionally, they suggest a possible relationship between PKC activation in mitochondria and free radical-induced CER nephrotoxicity in rats.

Role of oxidative stress and protein oxidation in the aging process

The hypothesis is that the rate of oxygen consumption and the ensuing accrual of molecular oxidative damage constitute a fundamental mechanism governing the rate of aging is supported by several lines of evidence: (i) life spans of cold blooded animals and mammals with unstable basal metabolic rate (BMR) are extended and oxidative damage (OxD) is attenuated by an experimental decrease in metabolic rate; (ii) single gene mutations in Drosophila and Caenorhabditis elegans that extend life span almost invariably result in a generalized slowing of physiological activities, albeit via different mechanisms, affecting a decrease in OxD; (iii) caloric restriction decreases body temperature and OxD; and, (iv) results of studies on the effects of transgenic overexpressions of antioxidant enzymes are generally supportive, but quite ambiguous. It is suggested that oxidative damage to proteins plays a crucial role in aging because oxidized proteins lose catalytic function and are preferentially hydrolyzed. It is hypothesized that oxidative damage to specific proteins constitutes one of the mechanisms linking oxidative stress/damage and age-associated losses in physiological functions.

Heart and breast muscle mitochondrial dysfunction in pulmonary hypertension syndrome in broilers (Gallus domesticus)

This study was conducted to determine function and defects in electron transport in muscle mitochondria of meat chickens (broilers) with pulmonary hypertension syndrome (PHS). The respiratory control ratio (RCR, indicative of respiratory chain coupling) was higher in the control than in PHS breast and heart muscle mitochondria, but there were no differences in the ADP/O (an index of oxidative phosphorylation). Sequential additions of ADP improved the RCR in the control breast muscle mitochondria and the ADP/O in PHS breast and heart muscle mitochondria. Basal hydrogen peroxide production, (an indicator of electron leak), was higher in PHS breast and heart muscle mitochondria than in controls and differences in electron leak in PHS mitochondria were magnified by inhibiting electron transport at Complex I and III (cyt b(562)). Complex I activity was lower in PHS heart mitochondria but there was no difference in Complex II activity. Thus, compared to controls, PHS mitochondria exhibited site-specific defects in electron transport within Complex I and III that could contribute to lower respiratory chain coupling. Additionally, it appears that healthy broilers may exhibit higher basal levels of electron leak compared to other avian species. Together, these findings provide insight into inefficient cellular use of oxygen that may contribute to the development of PHS in broilers.

Influence of aging and long-term caloric restriction on oxygen radical generation and oxidative DNA damage in rat liver mitochondria

The effect of long-term caloric restriction and aging on the rates of mitochondrial H2O2 production and oxygen consumption as well as on oxidative damage to nuclear (nDNA) and mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) was studied in rat liver tissue. Long-term caloric restriction significantly decreased H2O2 production of rat liver mitochondria (47% reduction) and significantly reduced oxidative damage to mtDNA (46% reduction) with no changes in nDNA. The decrease in ROS production was located at complex I because it only took place with complex I-linked substrates (pyruvate/malate) but not with complex II-linked substrates (succinate). The mechanism responsible for that decrease in ROS production was not a decrease in mitochondrial oxygen consumption because it did not change after long-term restriction. Instead, the caloric restricted mitochondria released less ROS per unit electron flow, due to a decrease in the reduction degree of the complex I generator. On the other hand, increased ROS production with aging in state 3 was observed in succinate-supplemented mitochondria because old control animals were unable to suppress H2O2 production during the energy transition from state 4 to state 3. The levels of 8-oxodG in mtDNA increased with age in old animals and this increase was abolished by caloric restriction. These results support the idea that caloric restriction reduces the aging rate at least in part by decreasing the rate of mitochondrial ROS production and so, the rate of oxidative attack to biological macromolecules like mtDNA.

Membrane fatty acid unsaturation, protection against oxidative stress, and maximum life span: a homeoviscous-longevity adaptation?

Aging is a progressive and universal process originating endogenously that manifests during postmaturational life. Available comparative evidence supporting the mitochondrial free radical theory of aging consistently indicates that two basic molecular traits are associated with the rate of aging and thus with the maximum life span: the presence of low rates of mitochondrial oxygen radical production and low degrees of fatty acid unsaturation of cellular membranes in postmitotic tissues of long-lived homeothermic vertebrates in relation to those of short-lived ones. Recent research shows that steady-state levels of free radical-derived damage to mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) and, in some cases, to proteins are lower in long- than in short-lived animals. Thus, nonenzymatic oxidative modification of tissue macromolecules is related to the rate of aging. The low degree of fatty acid unsaturation in biomembranes of long-lived animals may confer advantage by decreasing their sensitivity to lipid peroxidation. Furthermore, this may prevent lipoxidation-derived damage to other macromolecules. Taking into account the fatty acid distribution pattern, the origin of the low degree of membrane unsaturation in long-lived species seems to be the presence of species-specific desaturation pathways that determine membrane composition while an appropriate environment for membrane function is maintained. Mechanisms that prevent or decrease the generation of endogenous damage during the evolution of long-lived animals seem to be more important than trying to intercept those damaging agents or repairing the damage already inflicted. Here, the physiological meaning of these findings and the effects of experimental manipulations such as dietary stress, caloric restriction, and endocrine control in relation to aging and longevity are discussed.

Determination of mitochondrial reactive oxygen species: methodological aspects

The generation of Reactive Oxygen Species (ROS) as by-products in mitochondria Electron Transport Chain (ETC) has long been admitted as the cost of aerobic energy metabolism with oxidative damages as consequence. The purpose of this methodological review is to present some of the most widespread methods of ROS generation and to underline the limitations as well as some problems, identified with some experiments as examples, in the interpretation of such results. There is now no doubt that besides their pejorative role, ROS are involved in a variety of cellular processes for the continuous adaptation of the cell to its environment. Because ROS metabolism is a complex area (low production, instability of species, efficient antioxidant defense system, several places of production...) bias, variances and limitations in ROS measurements must be recognized in order to avoid artefactual conclusions, and especially to improve our understanding of physiological and pathophysiological mechanisms of such phenomenon.

Heme deficiency selectively interrupts assembly of mitochondrial complex IV in human fibroblasts: revelance to aging

Heme deficiency was studied in young and old normal human fibroblasts (IMR90). Regardless of age, heme deficiency increased the steady-state level of oxidants and lipid peroxidation and sensitized the cells to fluctuations in intracellular Ca(2+). Heme deficiency selectively decreased the activity and protein content of mitochondrial complex IV (cytochrome c oxidase) by 95%, indicating a decrease in successful assembly. Complexes I-III and catalase remained intact under conditions of heme deficiency, whereas ferrochelatase was up-regulated. Complex IV is the only hemeprotein in the cell that contains heme a, which may account for its susceptibility. The rate of removal and assembly of complex IV declines with age. These findings are relevant to worldwide iron deficiency in women and children and to an age-related decline in complex IV in Alzheimer's disease patients.

N-t-Butyl hydroxylamine is an antioxidant that reverses age-related changes in mitochondria in vivo and in vitro

N-t-butyl hydroxylamine (NtBHA) delays senescence-dependent changes in human lung fibroblasts (IMR90) (Atamna et al., J. Biol. Chem. 275, 6741-6748). The current study examines the effect of NtBHA on mitochondria in old and young rats and human primary fibroblasts (IMR90). In NtBHA-treated rats, the age-dependent decline in food consumption and ambulatory activity was reversed without affecting body weight. The respiratory control ratio of mitochondria from liver of old rats improved after feeding NtBHA. These findings suggest that NtBHA improved mitochondrial function in vivo. The age-dependent increase in proteins with thiol-mixed disulfides was significantly lower in old rats treated with NtBHA. NtBHA was effective only in old rats; no significant effect was observed in young rats. In IMR90 cells, NtBHA delayed senescence-associated changes in mitochondria and cellular senescence induced by maintaining the cells under suboptimal levels of growth factors. Proteasomal activity was also higher in cells treated with NtBHA than in untreated cells. NtBHA accumulates in cells 10- to 15-fold the extracellular concentration and is maintained by mitochondrial NADH. NtBHA is an antioxidant that is recycled by mitochondrial electron transport chain and prevents radical-induced toxicity to mitochondria.

Garbage catastrophe theory of aging: imperfect removal of oxidative damage?

Increasing evidence suggests an important role of oxidant-induced damage in the progress of senescent changes, providing support for the free radical theory of aging proposed by Harman in 1956. However, considering that biological organisms continuously renew their structures, it is not clear why oxidative damage should accumulate with age. No strong evidence has been provided in favor of the concept of aging as an accumulation of synthetic errors (e.g. Orgel's 'error-catastrophe' theory and the somatic mutation theory). Rather, we believe that the process of aging may derive from imperfect clearance of oxidatively damaged, relatively indigestible material, the accumulation of which further hinders cellular catabolic and anabolic functions. From this perspective, it might be predicted that: (i) suppression of oxidative damage would enhance longevity; (ii) accumulation of incompletely digested material (e.g. lipofuscin pigment) would interfere with cellular functions and increase probability of death; (iii) rejuvenation during reproduction is mainly provided by dilution of undigested material associated with intensive growth of the developing organism; and (iv) age-related damage starts to accumulate substantially when development is complete, and mainly affects postmitotic, cells and extracellular matrix, not proliferating cells. There is abundant support for all these predictions.

Effect of short-term caloric restriction on H2O2 production and oxidative DNA damage in rat liver mitochondria and location of the free radical source

Oxygen free radicals (ROS) of mitochondrial origin seem to be involved in aging. Whereas in other tissues complexes I or III of the respiratory chain contain the ROS generators, in this study we find that rat liver mitochondria generate oxygen radicals at complexes I, II, and III. Short-term (6 weeks) caloric restriction significantly decreased H2O2 production in rat liver mitochondria. This decrease in ROS production was located at complex I because it occurred with complex I-linked substrates (pyruvate/malate), but did not reach statistical significance with the complex II-linked substrate succinate. The mechanism responsible for the lowered ROS production was not a decrease in oxygen consumption. Instead, the mitochondria of caloric-restricted animals released less ROS per unit electron flow. This was due to a decrease in the degree of reduction of the complex I generator. Furthermore, oxidative damage to mitochondrial and nuclear DNA was also decreased in the liver by short-term caloric restriction. The results agree with the idea that caloric restriction delays aging, at least in part, by decreasing the rate of mitochondrial ROS generation and thus the rate of attack to molecules, like DNA, highly relevant for the accumulation of age-dependent changes.

Mitochondrial dysfunction in cardiac disease: ischemia--reperfusion, aging, and heart failure

Mitochondria contribute to cardiac dysfunction and myocyte injury via a loss of metabolic capacity and by the production and release of toxic products. This article discusses aspects of mitochondrial structure and metabolism that are pertinent to the role of mitochondria in cardiac disease. Generalized mechanisms of mitochondrial-derived myocyte injury are also discussed, as are the strengths and weaknesses of experimental models used to study the contribution of mitochondria to cardiac injury. Finally, the involvement of mitochondria in the pathogenesis of specific cardiac disease states (ischemia, reperfusion, aging, ischemic preconditioning, and cardiomyopathy) is addressed.

How long should telomeres be?

What began as a study of the "end-replication problem" took on a new dimension as it became clear that telomeres are a "molecular clock" of replication in human somatic cells. Here we review the biology of telomeres in vitro and in vivo, in mice and humans. We suggest that, in humans, telomeres are involved in the biology of aging and pathobiology of disorders of aging, including cancer and cardiovascular disease. We also propose that the underlying dynamics of telomere biology is in line with broad principles of evolutionary theories.

Nutraceutical interventions may delay aging and the age-related diseases

Largely due to better control of infectious diseases and to year-round access to a more nutritious diet, life expectancy in developed countries has increased dramatically in the twentieth century. However, as the average age of the population has risen, the incidence of chronic age-related diseases such as Alzheimer's, Parkinson's, cardiovascular disease, cancer, arthritis, osteoporosis, benign prostatic hyperplasia, late-onset diabetes, and macular degeneration have increased. To obtain further significant improvements in both lifespan and the quality of life in this century, treatments and nutritional changes that address the age-related diseases and the aging process itself need to be examined and validated. There are many reports suggesting that oxidative stress and certain nutritional deficiencies may contribute to the aging process and to many age-related diseases. In this article, we report on two human clinical trials using novel antioxidant supplements in which urinary oxidative stress is significantly reduced. We also discuss the conceptual basis and existing literature for several nutritional supplements that may have beneficial effects on aging and age-related diseases. Based on the available data, we suggest that human life expectancy can be significantly increased in the twenty-first century by optimizing diet and using nutritional supplements.

Low fatty acid unsaturation: a mechanism for lowered lipoperoxidative modification of tissue proteins in mammalian species with long life spans

Carbonyl compounds generated by the nonenzymatic oxidation of polyunsaturated fatty acids react with nucleophilic groups in proteins, leading to their modification. It has not been tested whether fatty acid unsaturation is related to steady-state levels of lipoxidation-derived protein modification in vivo. A low fatty acid unsaturation, hence a low protein lipoxidation, in tissues of longevous animals would be consistent with the free radical theory of aging, because membrane lipids increase their sensitivity to oxidative damage as a function of their degree of unsaturation. To evaluate the relationship between fatty acid composition, protein lipoxidation, and maximum life span (MLSP), we analyzed liver fatty acids and proteins from seven mammalian species, ranging in MLSP from 3.5 to 46 years. The results show that the peroxidizability index of fatty acids and the sensitivity to in vitro lipid peroxidation are negatively correlated with the MLSP. Based on gas chromatography and mass spectroscopy analyses, liver proteins of all these species contain malondialdehyde-lysine and Nepsilon-carboxymethyllysine adducts, two biomarkers of protein lipoxidation. The steady-state levels of malondialdehyde-lysine and Nepsilon-carboxymethyl lysine are directly related to the peroxidizability index and inversely related to the MLSP. We propose that a low degree of fatty acid unsaturation may have been selected in longevous mammals to protect their tissue lipids and proteins against oxidative damage while maintaining an appropriate environment for membrane function.

Oxidative damage to mitochondrial DNA is inversely related to maximum life span in the heart and brain of mammals

DNA damage is considered of paramount importance in aging. Among causes of this damage, free radical attack, particularly from mitochondrial origin, is receiving special attention. If oxidative damage to DNA is involved in aging, long-lived animals (which age slowly) should show lower levels of markers of this kind of damage than short-lived ones. However, this possibility has not heretofore been investigated. In this study, steady-state levels of 8-oxo-7, 8-dihydro-2'-deoxyguanosine (8-oxodG) referred to deoxyguanosine (dG) were measured by high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) in the mitochondrial (mtDNA) and nuclear (nDNA) DNA from the heart of eight and the brain of six mammalian species ranging in maximum life span (MLSP) from 3.5 to 46 years. Exactly the same digestion of DNA to deoxynucleosides and HPLC protocols was used for mtDNA and nDNA. Significantly higher (three- to ninefold) 8-oxodG/dG values were found in mtDNA than in nDNA in all the species studied in both tissues. 8-oxodG/dG in nDNA did not correlate with MLSP across species either in the heart (r=-0.68; P<0.06) or brain (r = 0.53; P<0.27). However, 8-oxodG/dG in mtDNA was inversely correlated with MLSP both in heart (r=-0.92; P<0.001) and brain (r=-0.88; P<0.016) tissues following the power function y = a(.)x(b), where y is 8-oxodG/dG and x is the MLSP. This agrees with the consistent observation that mitochondrial free radical generation is also lower in long-lived than in short-lived species. The results obtained agree with the notion that oxygen radicals of mitochondrial origin oxidatively damage mtDNA in a way related to the aging rate of each species.-Barja, G., Herrero, A. Oxidative damage to mitochondrial DNA is inversely related to maximum life span in the heart and brain of mammals.

8-oxo-deoxyguanosine levels in heart and brain mitochondrial and nuclear DNA of two mammals and three birds in relation to their different rates of aging

Previous studies found that the rate of mitochondrial oxygen radical generation is lower in long-lived birds than in short-lived mammals. In the present study, the oxidative DNA damage marker 8-oxo-7,8-dihydro-2'-deoxyguanosine (8-oxodG) in heart and brain mitochondrial (mtDNA) and nuclear DNA (nDNA) was compared between mammals and birds of approximately similar body size and metabolic rates; rats (maximum life span, MLSP = 4 years) vs pigeons (MLSP = 35 years), and mice (MLSP = 3.5 years) vs parakeets (MLSP = 21 years) or canaries (MLSP = 24 years). Lower steady-state 8-oxodG values were observed in all cases in the heart mtDNA in birds than in mammals. 8-oxodG levels were also lower in brain mtDNA in pigeons than in rats, in brain nDNA in canaries than in mice, and in heart nDNA in parakeets compared with mice. The rest of the comparisons did not show significant differences between species. These results taken together indicate that oxidative damage to DNA tends to be lower in birds (highly long-lived species) than in short-lived mammals, specially in the case of mtDNA. This is consistent with the low rate of mitochondrial oxygen radical generation observed in all long-lived species investigated up to date, birds or mammals, including the bird species studied here. The results also show that 8-oxodG steady-state levels are much higher in mtDNA than in nDNA in all the tissues (heart and brain) and species (birds and mammals) studied.