Spontaneous autoimmunity prevented by thymic expression of a single self-antigen

Expression of autoimmune regulator gene (AIRE) and T regulatory cells in human thymomas

Expression of the autoimmune regulator gene (AIRE) and the presence of CD25(+)/forkhead box p3 (FoxP3)(+) T regulatory (T(reg)) cells were investigated in histologically normal adult thymi and in thymomas using immunohistochemistry and quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR). In the normal thymus staining for AIRE was detected in the nucleus of some epithelial-like cells located in the medulla; in thymomas AIRE-positive cells were extremely rare and could be detected only in the areas of medullary differentiation of two B1 type, organoid thymomas. RNA was extracted from 36 cases of thymoma and 21 non-neoplastic thymi obtained from 11 myasthenic (MG(+)) and 10 non-myasthenic (MG(-)) patients. It was found that AIRE is 8.5-fold more expressed in non-neoplastic thymi than in thymomas (P = 0.01), and that the amount of AIRE transcripts present in the thymoma tissue are not influenced by the association with MG, nor by the histological type. A possible involvement of AIRE in the development of MG was suggested by the observation that medullary thymic epithelial cells isolated from AIRE-deficient mice contain low levels of RNA transcripts for CHRNA 1, a gene coding for acetylcholine receptor. Expression of human CHRNA 1 RNA was investigated in 34 human thymomas obtained from 20 MG(-) patients and 14 MG(+) patients. No significant difference was found in the two groups (thymoma MG(+), CHRNA1 = 0.013 +/- 0.03; thymoma MG-, CHRNA1 = 0.01 +/- 0.03). In normal and hyperplastic thymi CD25(+)/Foxp3(+) cells were located mainly in the medulla, and their number was not influenced by the presence of MG. Foxp3(+) and CD25(+) cells were significantly less numerous in thymomas. A quantitative estimate of T(reg) cells revealed that the levels of Foxp3 RNA detected in non-neoplastic thymi were significantly higher (P = 0.02) than those observed in 31 cases of thymomas. Our findings indicate that the tissue microenvironment of thymomas is defective in the expression of relevant functions that exert a crucial role in the negative selection of autoreactive lymphocytes.

A decade of AIRE

In 1997, the autoimmune regulator (AIRE) gene was identified as the locus underlying susceptibility to the polyendocrine autoimmune disease known as autoimmune polyendocrinopathy-candidiasis-ectodermal dystrophy (APECED). In the intervening 10 years, it has become increasingly clear that this rare disorder has provided us with an illuminative window on one of the most fundamental processes of the immune system--the establishment and maintenance of self tolerance.

What's new in the Aire?

Unraveling the mechanisms underlying autoimmune disease remains a difficult challenge. Recent lessons learned from the study of AIRE (autoimmune regulator), the gene responsible for the rare monogenic human syndrome APS-1, highlight the power of genetics to reveal disease pathogenesis. With the discovery of AIRE, central tolerance has re-emerged as a crucial check against autoimmunity. Aire-mediated regulation of diverse self-antigens in the thymus serves as a paradigm for the importance of promiscuous gene expression in the prevention of autoimmune disease. Recent characterization of Aire-targeted antigens continues to bear this out. Here, we review the current progress surrounding the role of Aire in central tolerance from a molecular, genetic and developmental basis.

RANK signals from CD4(+)3(-) inducer cells regulate development of Aire-expressing epithelial cells in the thymic medulla

Aire-expressing medullary thymic epithelial cells (mTECs) play a key role in preventing autoimmunity by expressing tissue-restricted antigens to help purge the emerging T cell receptor repertoire of self-reactive specificities. Here we demonstrate a novel role for a CD4(+)3(-) inducer cell population, previously linked to development of organized secondary lymphoid structures and maintenance of T cell memory in the functional regulation of Aire-mediated promiscuous gene expression in the thymus. CD4(+)3(-) cells are closely associated with mTECs in adult thymus, and in fetal thymus their appearance is temporally linked with the appearance of Aire(+) mTECs. We show that RANKL signals from this cell promote the maturation of RANK-expressing CD80(-)Aire(-) mTEC progenitors into CD80(+)Aire(+) mTECs, and that transplantation of RANK-deficient thymic stroma into immunodeficient hosts induces autoimmunity. Collectively, our data reveal cellular and molecular mechanisms leading to the generation of Aire(+) mTECs and highlight a previously unrecognized role for CD4(+)3(-)RANKL(+) inducer cells in intrathymic self-tolerance.

Lessons on immune tolerance from the monogenic disease APS1

Autoimmunity is a complex disease process that results from a breakdown in the ability of the immune system to discriminate self from non-self. One approach to unraveling how autoimmunity occurs is to study monogenic diseases, for which a single gene defect is responsible. Recent work on the monogenic autoimmune disease 'autoimmune polyglandular syndrome type 1' (APS1) and on the causal gene of this disorder--autoimmune regulator (AIRE)--is providing new lessons on how immune tolerance is maintained.

Limited peripheral T cell anergy predisposes to retinal autoimmunity

Autoimmune uveoretinitis accounts for at least 10% of worldwide blindness, yet it is unclear why tolerance to retinal Ags is so fragile and, particularly, to what extent this might be due to defects in peripheral tolerance. To address this issue, we generated double-transgenic mice expressing hen egg lysozyme, under the retinal interphotoreceptor retinoid-binding promoter, and a hen egg lysozyme-specific CD4(+) TCR transgene. In this manner, we have tracked autoreactive CD4(+) T cells from their development in the thymus to their involvement in uveoretinitis and compared tolerogenic mechanisms induced in a variety of organs to the same self-Ag. Our findings show that central tolerance to retinal and pancreatic Ags is qualitatively similar and equally dependent on the transcriptional regulator protein AIRE. However, the lack of Ag presentation in the eye-draining lymph nodes results in a failure to induce high levels of T cell anergy. Under these circumstances, despite considerable central deletion, low levels of retinal-specific autoreactive CD4(+) T cells can induce severe autoimmune disease. The relative lack of anergy induction by retinal Ags, in contrast to the same Ag in other organs, helps to explain the unique susceptibility of the eye to spontaneous and experimentally induced autoimmune disease.

Loss of Aire-dependent thymic expression of a peripheral tissue antigen renders it a target of autoimmunity

Both humans and mice with a mutation in the autoimmune regulator (aire) gene develop multiorgan autoimmune disease. Aire was shown to exert its critical function in medullary epithelial cells of the thymus by promoting ectopic expression of peripheral tissue antigens. It was hypothesized that the widespread autoimmunity of Aire-deficient individuals reflects a lack of tolerance induction to the repertoire of peripheral tissue antigens expressed in the thymus of normal individuals. Here, we substantiate this hypothesis by identifying Mucin 6 as a stomach-specific antigen targeted by autoantibodies in gastritis-prone mice lacking thymic expression of aire and demonstrate that transcription of the Mucin 6 gene in thymic medullary epithelial cells is indeed Aire-dependent.

Highly variable expression of tissue-restricted self-antigens in human thymus: Implications for self-tolerance and autoimmunity

Induction of T cell tolerance in the thymus (central tolerance) is essential for preventing organ-specific autoimmunity. This apparent paradox is in part explained by promiscuous expression of numerous tissue-restricted self-antigens (TRA) in medullary thymic epithelial cells (mTEC), which is highly conserved between mice and man. In animal models, the threshold of central tolerance towards such TRA is surprisingly sensitive towards minor shifts in antigen expression levels and this might also be the case in humans. To precisely assess the inter-individual variability of TRA expression in man, we determined the level of transcription of several auto-antigens in purified human mTEC and subsets thereof by quantitative RT-PCR. We detected two expression patterns: first, high variability (>20-fold) correlated with autoimmune regulator (Aire) expression and mTEC differentiation, and secondly, non-correlated low variability. Importantly, our approach revealed a significantly higher Aire-correlated insulin transcription in mTEC of carriers of the protective insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus locus 2 haplotype compared to the non-protective haplotype. The considerable, yet selective variability in thymic expression levels of target auto-antigen expression might constitute a hitherto underestimated risk factor for the susceptibility of autoimmune diseases in man.

Aire-ing self antigen variability and tolerance

Positional cloning of the underlying genes for the rare syndrome autoimmune polyendocrinopathy candidadiasis extrodermal dystrophy (APECED) opened a new venue of research on the role of central tolerance in autoimmunity. The associated autoimmune regulator gene (AIRE), was found to be expressed in medullary thymus epithelial cells (mTEC) in both man and mice, and to control promiscuous expression of sets of self antigens. The lack of AIRE in both mice and man led to the development of a quite specific, but also an inter-individual variable, set of autoimmune and infectious diseases. An article in this issue of the European Journal of Immunology demonstrates that several autoantigens controlled by AIRE are variably expressed in different human individuals. Most importantly it is shown that carriers of the type 1 diabetes (T1D) associated locus IDDM2 show lower expression of insulin in mTEC, as controlled by AIRE. The genetic variability of autoantigen expression in the thymus thus seems to determine the variable predisposition to autoimmunity.