Laparoscopic fundoplication failures: patterns of failure and response to fundoplication revision

Comparison of patient satisfaction after redo and primary fundoplications

BACKGROUND

Although much has been written about the results and patient satisfaction with fundoplication for the treatment of gastroesophageal reflux disease, the reports have focused primarily on surgical successes. With the growing number of fundoplications being performed, more patients are requiring reoperation because of recurrent symptoms or side effects. Reports of success rates for reoperation are available, but information regarding patient satisfaction is limited.

METHODS

All the patients undergoing fundoplication at our institution were sent short-form health surveys (SF-12), Gastroesophageal reflux disease-specific quality-of-life questionnaires (QOLRAD), and queries regarding long-term satisfaction.

RESULTS

Between November 1992 and July 2000, 221 patients (198 primary and 23 redo) underwent fundoplication. There were 19 open cases (3 primary and 16 redo). In the primary group, 173 patients underwent Nissen, 23 underwent Toupet, and 2 underwent Collis fundoplications. In the redo group, 12 patients underwent Nissen, 9 underwent Toupet, 1 underwent Collis, and l underwent Belsey fundoplications. Follow-up surveys were completed for 130 patients (112 primary and 18 redo) at a mean of 32.6 months (range, 0.8-98 months). In the primary group, 87% of the patients were satisfied with their operation, as compared with 75% in the redo group. There was a trend toward higher SF-12 mental scores (46 +/- 12 vs 40 +/- 14; p = 0.07) and QOLRAD scores (6.2 +/- 1.3 vs 5.2 +/- 2.0; p = 0.07) in the primary fundoplication group. There was a significant difference in the SF-12 physical scores between the groups (32 +/- 13 for the primary group vs 18.5 +/- 11 for the redo group; p = 0.0002). Additionally, 61% of the patients in the redo group were again using antireflux medications, whereas only 24% of the patients in the primary group were using medications again.

CONCLUSION

Gastroesophageal reflux disease symptom scores and quality-of-life scores for patients undergoing redo fundoplication are lower than the scores of patients having primary fundoplication. Quality of life is similar between primary and redo fundoplication patients in the mental component. However, redo patients do not do as well physically more than 2 years after surgery.

Paradigm shift in the management of gastroesophageal reflux disease

OBJECTIVE

To compare the short-term results of the radiofrequency treatment of the gastroesophageal junction known as the Stretta procedure versus laparoscopic fundoplication (LF) in patients with gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD).

SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA

The Stretta procedure has been shown to be safe, well tolerated, and highly effective in the treatment of GERD.

METHODS

All patients presenting to Vanderbilt University Medical Center for surgical evaluation of GERD between August 2000 and March 2002 were prospectively evaluated under an IRB-approved protocol. All patients underwent esophageal motility testing and endoscopy that documented GERD preoperatively, either by a positive 24-hour pH study or biopsy-proven esophagitis. Patients were offered the Stretta procedure if they had documented GERD and did not have a hiatal hernia larger than 2 cm, LES pressure less than 8 mmHg, or Barrett's esophagus. Patients with larger hiatal hernias, LES pressure less than 8 mmHg, or Barrett's were offered LF. All patients were studied pre- and postoperatively with validated GERD-specific quality-of-life questionnaires (QOLRAD) and short-form health surveys (SF-12). Current medication use and satisfaction with the procedure was also obtained.

RESULTS

Results are reported as mean +/- SEM. Seventy-five patients (age 49 +/- 14 years, 44% male, 56% female) underwent LF and 65 patients (age 46 +/- 12 years, 42%, 58% female) underwent the Stretta procedure. Preoperative esophageal acid exposure time was higher in the LF group. Preoperative LES pressure was higher in the Stretta group. In the LF group, 41% had large hiatal hernias (>2 cm), 8 patients required Collis gastroplasty, 6 had Barrett's esophagus, and 10 had undergone previous fundoplication. At 6 months, the QOLRAD and SF-12 scores were significantly improved within both groups. There was an equal magnitude of improvement between pre- and postoperative QOLRAD and SF-12 scores between Stretta and LF patients. Fifty-eight percent of Stretta patients were off proton pump inhibitors, and an additional 31% had reduced their dose significantly; 97% of LF patients were off PPIs. Twenty-two Stretta patients returned for 24-hour pH testing at a mean of 7.2 +/- 0.5 months, and there was a significant reduction in esophageal acid exposure time. Both groups were highly satisfied with their procedure.

CONCLUSIONS

The addition of a less invasive, endoscopic treatment for GERD to the surgical algorithm has allowed the authors to stratify the management of GERD patients to treatment with either Stretta or LF according to size of hiatal hernia, LES pressure, Barrett's esophagus, and significant pulmonary symptoms. Patients undergoing Stretta are highly satisfied and have improved GERD symptoms and quality of life comparable to LF. The Stretta procedure is an effective alternative to LF in well-selected patients.

Recurrence after laparoscopic and open Nissen fundoplication: a comparison of the mechanisms of failure

BACKGROUND

Laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication as treatment for gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) in adults has a reported recurrence rate of 2-17%. We investigated the rates and mechanisms of failure after laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication in children.

METHODS

All patients who underwent a laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication for GERD and who subsequently required a redo Nissen were reviewed (n = 15). The control group consisted of the most recent 15 patients who developed recurrent GER after an open Nissen, fundoplication.

RESULTS

Between 1994 and 2000, laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication was performed in 179 patients. Fifteen patients (8.7%) underwent revision. The mechanisms of failure were herniation in four patients, wrap dehiscence in four, a too-short wrap in three, a loosened wrap in two, and other reasons in two. The reoperation was performed laparoscopically in five patients (33%). The failure mechanisms were different in the open patients: eight were due to slipped wraps; three to dehiscences; and two to herniations.

CONCLUSION

The failure rate after laparoscopic Nissen is acceptably low. A redo laparoscopic Nissen can be performed safely after an initial laparoscopic approach.

The failed fundoplication

Fundoplication is the standard surgical approach to gastroesophageal reflux (GER) in a child. Although successful in many patients, there is a significant risk of complications and failure, especially in high-risk patients such as those with certain types of associated anomalies, diffuse motility disorders, chronic pulmonary disease, neurologic impairment, and young infants. Fundoplication failure can take the form of persistent reflux-related symptoms, symptoms that are caused by complications of the surgery, or anatomic problems such a para-esophageal hernia or migration of the wrap into the mediastinum. The most effective strategy for treatment of the child undergoing fundoplication is to prevent failure by careful patient selection, individualization of the operation based on the patient's anatomy and physiology, and meticulous attention to the technical details of the operation. Options for the child with a failed fundoplication include medical management, jejunal feeding using a percutaneous tube or a Roux-en-Y jejunostomy, revision of the fundoplication, or esophagogastric dissociation. If the fundoplication is to be revised, the same principles of patient selection, individualization of the operation, and attention to technique must be used to optimize the chance of success. The primary goal in the treatment of GER is to improve quality of life for the patient and the family.

Complications of laparoscopic fundoplication in the elderly

Our objective was to assess the complications of laparoscopic fundoplication in 77 patients older than 70 years of age. The indications for surgery were (1) complications of reflux esophagitis (n = 17), (2) large hiatal hernia (n = 10), (3) asthma and bronchitis (n = 7), (4) the need for other surgery (n = 13), and (5) a patient's desire to discontinue medical treatment that was controlling reflux esophagitis (n = 30). Operative time varied from 34 to 250 minutes (mean [standard deviation], 116 +/- 20). Hospital stay varied from 12 hours to 19 days (mean, 1.2). No patient needed conversion to open operation. Intraoperative complications were observed in 4 patients (5.2%): left pneumothorax in 2, major operative bleeding in 1, and minor spleen lesion in 1. The most common postoperative complications were gas-bloating syndrome and dysphagia. Gastric ulcer was diagnosed in two. Other postoperative complications included acute delirium, acute urinary retention, and acute ischemia of the lower extremity. One patient died of congestive heart failure. It is concluded that laparoscopic fundoplication is an effective procedure for treating geriatric patients with reflux esophagitis and may be performed with low morbidity and mortality rates.

Short esophagus: literature incidence

There are controversies regarding existence and incidence of short esophagus. The authors reviewed the literature incidence of short esophagus among operated patients due to gastroesophageal reflux disease in the last 3 years. The overall incidence of short esophagus was 1.53%. The proposed risk factors (paraesophageal hernia, Barrett's esophagus, reoperation, esophageal strictures and access route) do have a higher incidence of short esophagus, with the exception of the Barrett's esophagus. Although several biases can be associated with the review, the authors identified the short esophagus incidence in the literature.

Determining an appropriate threshold for referral to surgery for gastroesophageal reflux disease

BACKGROUND

Persistent symptomatic gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) can be treated with medication or surgery. The purposes of this study were (1) to determine how poor the quality of life on medication would need to be to justify assuming the risks of surgery, and (2) to estimate the proportion of patients currently on medication whose quality of life is below this value.

METHODS

We developed a Markov decision analysis model to simulate health outcomes (measured in quality adjusted life years [QALY]) over 10 years for medication and surgery in patients with typical GERD symptoms. We included probabilities of events obtained from a systematic literature review. Quality of life adjustments, expressed as utilities, were drawn from a survey of 131 patients 1 to 5 years after antireflux surgery. By using this model, we calculated what quality of life on medications would change the optimal strategy from medication to surgery (threshold). To determine the proportion of patients below this value, we prospectively surveyed 40 medically treated GERD patients at our hospital.

RESULTS

Surgery resulted in more QALYs than medical therapy when the utility with medication use was below 0.90. Sensitivity analysis showed this value to be relatively insensitive to reasonable variations in surgical risks (mortality, failures, reoperation) and quality of life after surgery. Among those surveyed on medications, 48% fell below this threshold and would be predicted to benefit from surgery.

CONCLUSION

Our model suggests that surgery would likely benefit a high proportion of medically treated GERD patients. Individual assessment of quality of life with GERD should be considered to aid clinical decision making.

Surgical and endoscopic treatment of gastroesophageal reflux disease

There is no evidence to advocate medical or surgical therapy as the best therapy for GERD. The decision to have antireflux surgery must be individualized. All patients taking long-term medications for GERD should receive advice on the safety and wisdom of staying on that therapy and information on antireflux surgery. Fundoplication should be considered in three circumstances [4]: 1. Patients who are intolerant of PPI therapy because of side effects should be considered for surgery. This situation will be less common now with five PPIs, however. 2. Patients who are poorly responsive to PPI therapy should be considered for surgery. This situation is probably not common, given the effectiveness of the currently available PPIs. It is more common in patients with atypical GERD. The gastroenterologist should be as certain as possible that the patient not only has GERD, but also that the patient's symptoms are reflux related. 3. Surgery should be considered when patients desire a permanent solution to free them of the need to take medications. These patients must be warned about the potential suboptimal results, including the frequent need for medication within a few years of having the procedure and the small but real possibility of becoming worse after the operation. Even in experienced hands, 1% to 2% of patients are worse after the procedure. A careful preoperative evaluation to ensure that the patient's symptoms are reflux related and that the right operative procedure is performed offers the patient the best opportunity for success. Widespread use of endoscopic therapy for GERD is probably still several years away. The best endoscopic therapy is yet to be determined, but it will need to be safe, effective, and easy to use.

Long-term follow-up after laparoscopic refundoplication for failed antireflux surgery: quality of life, symptomatic outcome, and patient satisfaction

Quality of life and patient satisfaction have been shown to be important factors in evaluating outcome of laparoscopic antireflux surgery (LARS). The aim of this study was to evaluate data pertaining to quality of life, patient satisfaction, and changes in symptoms in patients who underwent laparoscopic redo surgery after primary failed open or laparoscopic antireflux surgery 3 to 5 years postoperatively. Between March 1995 and June 1998, a total of 27 patients whose mean age was 57 years (range 35 to 78 years) underwent laparoscopic refundoplication for primary failed open or laparoscopic antireflux surgery. Quality of life was evaluated by means of the Gastrointestinal Quality of Life Index (GIQLI). Additionally, patient satisfaction and symptomatic outcome were evaluated using a standardized questionnaire. Three to 5 years after laparoscopic refundoplication, patients rated their quality of life (GIQLI) in an overall score of 113.4 points. Twenty-five patients (92.6%) rated their satisfaction with the redo procedure as very good and would undergo surgery again, if necessary. These patients were no longer taking any antireflux medication at follow-up. Two patients (7.4%) reported rare episodes of heartburn, which were managed successfully with proton pump inhibitors on demand, and four patients (14.8%) reported some episodes of regurgitation but with no decrease in quality of life. Seven patients (25.9%) suffer from mild-to-moderate dysphagia 5 years postoperatively, and 12 patients (44.4%) report having occasional chest pain but no other symptoms of gastroesophageal reflux disease. Nine of these patients suffer from concomitant cardiopulmonary disease. Laparoscopic refundoplication after primary failed antireflux surgery results in a high degree of patient satisfaction and significant improvement in quality of life with a good symptomatic outcome for a follow-up period of 3 to 5 years after surgery.

Surgical Experience in Fifty-Five Consecutive Reoperative Fundoplications

Laparoscopic antireflux surgery has dramatically changed the way heartburn and regurgitation have been managed over the last 10 years. The possibility of surgical correction with limited morbidity has resulted in a substantial increase in the number of fundoplications performed. Given that the rate of operative failure can be expected to be constant the need for surgical management of recurrent symptoms will become more prevalent. Between August 1996 and December 2001 55 patients presented with recurrent symptoms after a previous antireflux surgery. The presentation, management, and operative outcomes of patients undergoing reoperative fundoplication were studied. The 55 patients (25 male and 30 female) had a mean age of 47.1 years (range 22–69 years). Mean laparoscopic operative time was 234 minutes (range 180–330 minutes), and mean open time was 261 minutes (range 150–390 minutes). A laparoscopic repair was attempted in 45 patients and was completed without conversion in 37 (82.3%); seven of the eight patients requiring conversion had at least one prior open antireflux procedure. Average length of stay was 4.6 days (range one to 46 days); laparoscopic patients were in the hospital an average of 2 days (range one to 6 days). There were eight (12.7%) perioperative complications, no esophageal leaks, and no deaths. Average follow-up was 21.3 months (range 1–65 months). In patients who had a definitive antireflux procedure (53) 49 (92.5%) reported good to excellent outcomes; four had fair outcomes. All stated they were improved. Four patients reported occasional dysphagia, three reported intermittent nausea, five have infrequent to frequent chest pain, and four have diarrhea at least weekly. Despite being technically difficult reoperative fundoplication effectively alleviates dysphagia, regurgitation, and reflux symptoms in the majority of patients with low operative morbidity. The operation can be completed laparoscopically in most of those whose original operation was performed laparoscopically.

Minimally Invasive Surgical Techniques in Reoperative Surgery for Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease in Infants and Children

Fundoplication is commonly performed in children suffering from complications of gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD). Recently laparoscopic fundoplication has become a standard of care for GERD in children. Published reports show that 2.3 to 14 per cent of children require reoperation after failed fundoplication. The purpose of this study is to show the feasibility of minimally invasive surgical (MIS) techniques to treat children after failed fundoplication. A retrospective chart review was performed for all patients who underwent laparoscopic redo fundoplication at Children's Healthcare of Atlanta at Egleston from July 1998 to July 2000. The patients' records were reviewed for age, diagnosis, type and time of initial operation, type and time of redo operation, operative time for redo operation, and complications. Seventeen children (age 3 months to 18 years) had operations for failed fundoplication attempted using MIS techniques. Six of these children were referred after their initial operation performed elsewhere. Nine (53%) were neurologically impaired. Ten (59%) have respiratory complications of GERD. The initial procedures were as follows: One open Nissen fundoplication, two open Thal fundoplications, 13 laparoscopic Nissen fundoplications, and one laparoscopic Toupet fundoplication. The reoperative procedures performed were revision of fundoplication and hiatal hernia repair (13) or hiatal hernia repair only (four). Two patients had concurrent gastric emptying procedures. One procedure was converted to open for technical reasons. One patient developed a pelvic abscess secondary to leakage around the gastrostomy tube. One child had erosion into the esophagus of a Dacron® patch that was used to close a large hiatal defect. Thirteen patients began feeding by the first postoperative day. We conclude that MIS techniques can be applied to reoperative surgery for the treatment of GERD with an acceptable complication rate in this difficult group of patients. Reoperative patients appear to have the same benefits from MIS as patients undergoing their initial procedure.

Outcomes after minimally invasive reoperation for gastroesophageal reflux disease

BACKGROUND

Reoperative antireflux surgery is complex and traditionally performed by open methods. Increasingly, surgeons are performing minimally invasive reoperations. This report summarizes our experience with laparoscopic reoperative antireflux surgery (LRAS).

METHODS

A retrospective review (1996 to 2001) identified 80 LRAS cases. Median age was 49 (22 to 80) years with 52 females and 28 males. Primary symptoms included heartburn (53%), regurgitation (22%), and dysphagia (25%). Detailed outcomes recorded at follow-up included heartburn severity using the Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease-Health Related Quality of Life scale (HRQOL) and SF36 physical (PCS) and mental (MCS) component summary scores.

RESULTS

LRAS was completed in 97.5% of cases (two conversions). The most common problems identified were mediastinal migration of the wrap in 48 (60%) and misplaced wrap in 11 (13.8%). LRAS operations included Collis-Nissen (42), Nissen (26), Toupet (six), and six others. Pyloroplasty was required in nine (11%). Complications occurred in 16 patients. These included nine minor gastric perforations (all repaired intraoperatively) and two reoperations for complications (1 patient with a bile leak and the second with a pyloroplasty site leak). Median length of stay was 2.5 days. Median follow-up was 18 (1 to 52) months; 18 (23%) required proton-pump inhibitors. Detailed outcomes were available in 50 patients. Mean PCS and MCS scores were 42 and 47, respectively (normals = 50). HRQOL scores were excellent in 35 (65%), satisfactory in 9 (17%), and poor in 10 (18%). Ten patients (18%) reported that they were dissatisfied.

CONCLUSIONS

LRAS can be performed safely with complication and success rates similar to open operations in a center with extensive laparoscopic experience.

Clinical and histologic follow-up after antireflux surgery for Barrett's esophagus

There are few prospective studies that document the histologic follow-up after antireflux surgery in patients with Barrett's esophagus, as defined by the recently standardized criteria. We report the clinical, endoscopic, and histologic results of patients with Barrett's esophagus followed postoperatively for at least 2 years. Diagnosis of Barrett's esophagus required preoperative endoscopic evidence of columnar-lined epithelium in the esophagus and a biopsy demonstrating specialized intestinal metaplasia, which stains positively with Alcian blue stain. Between April 1993 and November 1998, a total of 104 patients meeting these criteria underwent fundoplication (laparoscopic [n = 84] or open [n = 6] nissen, laparoscopic Toupet [n = 11], laparoscopic Collis-Nissen [n = 1], Collins-Toupet [n = 1] or open Dor [n = 1]). Short-segment Barrett's esophagus (length of intestinal metaplasia <3 cm) was found preoperatively in 34% and low-grade dysplasia in 4% of patients. All patients were contacted yearly by mail, phone, or clinic visit. At a mean follow-up of 4.6 years (range 2 to 7.5 years), 81% of patients had stopped taking antisecretory medications and 97% were satisfied with the results of their operations. Eight patients have undergone reoperation for recurrence of symptoms. Two patients have died and two were excluded from endoscopic biopsy because of portal hypertension. Sixty-six patients complied with the surveillance protocol, and their histologic results were returned to our center. Symptomatic follow-up of the 34 patients who refused surveillance esophagogastro and duodenoscopy revealed two patients who were taking medication for reflux symptoms. None of the patients have developed high-grade dysplasia or esophageal carcinoma during surveillance endoscopy (337 total patient-years of follow-up). The incidence of regression of intestinal metaplasia to cardiac-fundic-type metaplasia after successful antireflux surgery is greater than previously reported. We suspect that this is a result of longer follow-up and the inclusion of patients with short-segment Barrett's esophagus. A substantial number of patients with Barrett's esophagus who are asymptomatic after antireflux surgery refuse surveillance endoscopy.

Laparoscopic Paraesophageal Hernia Repair Has an Acceptable Recurrence Rate

Recent literature has reported as high as a 42 per cent recurrence rate after laparoscopic paraesophageal hernia repair (LPEHR). We report long-term follow-up in a cohort of patients undergoing LPEHR at Vanderbilt University. Thirty-one patients underwent attempted LPEHR between September 1993 and May 2000. Six of 31 patients (19%) were converted to an open procedure and were excluded from the study. All patients had complete excision of the sac, primary closure of the crura, and an antireflux procedure. An Institutional Review Board-approved follow-up barium esophagram was performed at a mean of 25 months postoperatively. Three experienced laparoscopic surgeons (K.S., M.H., and W.R.) collectively reviewed the esophagrams for evidence of recurrence. The mean age of patients was 61 years (range 41–92). There were six males and 19 females. Fifteen of 25 patients (60%) returned for an esophagram. Only one of 15 patients (7%) had a recurrent paraesophageal hernia. However, five of 15 patients (33%) had herniated an intact wrap 2 to 4 cm above the diaphragm. The patient with a true paraesophageal hernia recurrence returned with symptoms of dysphagia. Two of the five patients (40%) with a herniated wrap complained of heartburn, which was controlled with a proton pump inhibitor. All other patients were asymptomatic. Our recurrence rate of true paraesophageal hernias after LPEHR is low (7%) and compares with that reported in the literature for open repairs. However, 33 per cent of the patients in this study were found to have a herniated wrap. Because there is no risk of strangulation we have not operated on any of these patients. LPEHR is our procedure of choice for Type II and III hiatal hernias with good symptom relief and a low true recurrence rate.

Development of achalasia secondary to laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication

Dysphagia after laparoscopic Nissen fundoplication (LNF) is commonly attributed to edema and/or improperly constructed wraps, and in some instances the cause can be difficult to identify. We report, for the first time, the development of secondary achalasia after LNF as a cause of late-onset postoperative dysphagia. A total of 250 consecutive patients undergoing LNF were analyzed for the development of postoperative dysphagia at a university hospital. Patients were considered to have secondary achalasia if they met the following four criteria: (1) preoperative manometry demonstrating normal peristalsis and normal lower esophageal sphincter (LES) relaxation; (2) lack of esophageal peristalsis on postoperative manometry or fluoroscopy with or without incomplete LES relaxation; (3) no mucosal lesions seen on endoscopy; and (4) dysphagia refractory to dilatation. The following three groups of patients were identified: patients who developed secondary achalasia (group A, n = 7); patients with persistent dysphagia requiring and responding to postoperative dilatation (group B, n = 12 patients); and patients whose postoperative recovery was not complicated by dysphagia (group C, n = 231). The groups were comparable in terms of all preoperative variables except for age. Patients in group A were older than those in group B (57 years [range 27 to 66 years] vs. 36.5 years [range 27 to 63 years], P = 0.028) but were not significantly older than patients in group C (45 years [range 20 to 84 years], P = 0.42). The onset of severe dysphagia was later in group A than in group B (135 days [range 15 to 300 days] vs. 20 days [range 9 to 70 days], P = 0.002). The median weight loss in group A was also significantly greater than in Group B (15 pounds [range 11 to 44 pounds] vs. 4 pounds [range 0 to 15 pounds], P = 0.0007). Two patients in group A who underwent reoperation failed to improve. Botulinum toxin injections were tried in two patients and Heller myotomy in one with good results. Nine patients in group B improved promptly after one dilatation, and three improved after two dilatations. Secondary achalasia should be considered as one of the causes of persistent dysphagia after an apparently successful antireflux operation. Secondary achalasia tends to occur in older patients and is characterized by a delayed onset of symptoms. Imaging studies are a reliable means of excluding mechanical obstruction as a cause of secondary achalasia, and a negative result should raise the suspicion of secondary achalasia. Esophageal motility studies are necessary to confirm the diagnosis. Failure to consider the diagnosis of secondary achalasia can lead to multiple fruitless attempts at dilatation or even inappropriate reoperations.

Laparoscopic antireflux surgery with routine mesh-hiatoplasty in the treatment of gastroesophageal reflux disease

One of the most frequent complications after laparoscopic antireflux surgery is intrathoracic migration of the wrap ("slipped" Nissen fundoplication). The most common reasons for this are inadequate closure of the crura or disruption of the crural closure. The aim of this prospective study was to evaluate surgical outcomes in patients who underwent laparoscopic antireflux surgery with simple nonabsorbable polypropylene sutures for hiatal closure in comparison to patients who underwent routine mesh-hiatoplasty. Between 1993 and 1998, a group of 361 patients underwent primary laparoscopic Nissen or Toupet fundoplication with the use of simple nonabsorbable polypropylene sutures for hiatal closure. Since December 1998, in all patients (n = 170) who underwent laparoscopic antireflux surgery, a 1 x 3 cm polypropylene mesh was placed on the crura behind the esophagus to reinforce them. Functional outcome, symptoms of gastroesophageal reflux disease, and postoperative complications such as recurrent hiatal hernia with or without intrathoracic migration of the wrap have been used for assessment of outcomes. In the initial series of 361 patients, postoperative herniation of the wrap occurred in 22 patients (6.1%). Of these 22 patients, 17 of them (4.7%) had to undergo laparoscopic redo surgery. The remaining five patients were free of symptoms. In comparison to these results, in a second group of 170 patients there was only one (0.6%) who had postoperative herniation of the wrap into the chest. There have been no significant differences in objective data such as DeMeester scores or lower esophageal sphincter pressure between the two groups. Postoperative dysphagia was increased during the early period after surgery in patients undergoing mesh-hiatoplasty but resolved without any further treatment within the first year after laparoscopic antireflux surgery. We concluded that routine hiatoplasty with the use of a polypropylene mesh is effective in preventing postoperative herniation of the wrap and leads to a significantly better surgical outcome than closure of the hiatal crura with simple sutures, without any additional long-term side effects.

Surgical clips to help identify anatomy after a Nissen fundoplication

Laparoscopic fundoplication has had a remarkable growth in the treatment of gastroesophageal reflux disease. But a failure rate of more than 5% has led to increasing numbers of patients with recurrent symptoms presenting for corrective surgery. A simple technique of placing surgical clips on the sutures used to place the wrap helps identify the anatomy during contrast studies and helps plan for corrective surgery.

Mesh Crural Repair of Large Paraesophageal Hiatal Hernias

Surgical repair is indicated in patients with paraesophageal hernias but is associated with a high recurrence rate. Our objective was to assess the safety and efficacy of mesh reinforcement of the crural closure in laparoscopic paraesophageal hernia repair. We conducted a 7-year retrospective review of all patients undergoing laparoscopic paraesophageal hernia repair with or without use of mesh. The main outcome measures were use of mesh, reason for use, age, sex, preoperative symptoms, length of operation, length of hospital stay, postoperative complications, and long-term follow-up conducted by physician interview. Twelve patients were repaired with mesh (Group A) and 12 without (Group B). Age, sex, operating time, length of hospital stay, and postoperative complications were similar in both groups. In Group A two patients required an interposition graft and ten required mesh reinforcement of the crural closure. One Group A patient developed an early recurrence requiring a reoperation, and one Group B patient developed a gastric leak where the fundus was sutured to the crura. The remainder of the patients experienced resolution of their symptoms at 2 weeks follow-up. Long-term follow-up (average 37 months) showed one Group B patient with a recurrence of reflux symptoms, but an upper gastrointestinal study showed no recurrence of hernia. All others remained asymptomatic. We conclude that the use of mesh in laparoscopic repair of large paraesophageal hernias appears safe and may reduce recurrence.

Preoperative evaluation of patients with gastroesophageal reflux disease

All patients who are candidates for laparoscopic fundoplication for the treatment of gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) should have a symptom review, barium swallow imaging, endoscopy, esophageal manometry, and ambulatory pH monitoring. The presence of a typical primary symptom, an abnormal 24-hour pH score, and a good response to acid-suppression therapy are predictive of a successful surgical outcome. The surgeon should be particularly wary of the following types of patients who may be referred for fundoplication but not have GERD: those who do not respond to proton pump inhibitors, those without esophagitis, those with only atypical symptoms, those in whom pH monitoring was done without previous manometry, and those with a borderline reflux score, severe vomiting, severe dysphagia and heartburn, unusual symptoms, severe depression, or morbid obesity.

Initial experience with the stretta procedure for the treatment of gastroesophageal reflux disease

BACKGROUND

The Stretta device (Curon Medical, Sunnyvale, CA) is a balloon-tipped four-needle catheter that delivers radiofrequency (RF) energy to the smooth muscle of the gastroesophageal junction. It can be used for the endoscopic treatment of gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD).

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Data prospectively collected on the first 25 consecutive patients undergoing the Stretta procedure at Vanderbilt University Medical Center between August 2000 and March 2001 are reported. Patient evaluation included esophageal manometry, ambulatory 24-hour pH testing, a standard GERD-specific quality-of-life survey (QOLRAD), a general quality-of-life survey (SF12), and endoscopy. Stretta surgery was performed following a standardized protocol. Thermocouple-controlled RF energy was delivered to the lower esophageal sphincter (LES) after endoscopic location of the z-line. Patients were followed up 3 months after endoscopic treatment. Results are presented as mean +/- SEM.

RESULTS

Prior to treatment, patients had a mean DeMeester score of 31.0+/-11.4, an LES pressure of 24+/-2 mm Hg, and normal esophageal peristalsis. Of the 25 outpatient procedures, 19 were done under conscious sedation and 6 under general anesthesia. There was a small learning curve (76+/-8 min for the first three procedures; 50+/-2 min for the subsequent 22). The mild to moderate pain during the first 24 postoperative hours was controlled with over-the-counter medication. Two complications were noted: one patient presented with ulcerative esophagitis and gastroparesis 10 days after the Stretta treatment, and one patient developed pancreatitis on postoperative day 27, which was probably unrelated to the Stretta procedure. Eight of the thirteen patients (62%) available for 3-month follow-up were off all antisecretory medication. The other five patients were still taking medications but had been able to reduce the amount considerably. The average daily dose of proton pump inhibitors was 43.0+/-5.0 mg/preoperatively and 6.4+/-2.2 mg/3 months postoperatively (P < 0.001). Other classes of GERD treatment such as metoclopramide had been completely abandoned. In all patients, QOLRAD scores improved (3.5+/-0.4 to 5.5+/-0.5; P < 0.001) as did SF12 physical (23.7+/-3.0 to 31.0+/-3.4; P < 0.008) and mental (40.5+/-2.9 to 47.7+/-3.2, P < 0.017) scores. All patients would undergo a Stretta procedure again except one 78-year-old man with progressive Alzheimer's disease.

CONCLUSION

The Stretta procedure is a promising new modality in the management of GERD. It can be safely performed in one short session with gastroesophageal endoscopy under conscious sedation in an outpatient setting. It improves GERD symptoms and quality-of-life scores in patients at 3 months and eliminates or significantly reduces the need for antisecretory drugs.

Laparoscopic repair of large paraesophageal hiatal hernia

BACKGROUND

The objective of this study was to analyze our initial results after laparoscopic repair of large paraesophageal hiatal hernias.

METHODS

Between October 1997 and May 2000, 37 patients (23 women, 14 men) underwent laparoscopic repair of a large type II (pure paraesophageal) or type III (combined sliding and paraesophageal) hiatal hernia with more than 50% of the stomach herniated into the chest. Median age was 72 years (range 52 to 92 years). Data related to patient demographics, esophageal function, operative techniques, postoperative symptomatology, and complications were analyzed.

RESULTS

Laparoscopic hernia repair and Nissen fundoplication was possible in 35 of 37 patients (95.0%). Median hospitalization was 4 days (range 2 to 20 days). Intraoperative complications occurred in 6 patients (16.2%) and included pneumothorax in 3 patients, splenic injury in 2, and crural tear in 1. Early postoperative complications occurred in 5 patients (13.5%) and included esophageal leak in 2, severe bloating in 2, and a small bowel obstruction in 1. Two patients died within 30 days (5.4%), 1 from delayed splenic bleeding and 1 from adult respiratory distress syndrome secondary to a recurrent strangulated hiatal hernia. Follow-up was complete in 31 patients (94.0%) and ranged from 3 to 34 months (median 15 months). Twenty-seven patients (87.1%) were improved. Four patients (12.9%) required early postoperative dilatation. Recurrent paraesophageal hiatal hernia occurred in 4 patients (12.9%). Functional results were classified as excellent in 17 patients (54.9%), good in 9 (29.0%), fair in 1 (3.2%), and poor in 4 (12.9%).

CONCLUSIONS

Laparoscopic repair of large paraesophageal hiatal hernias is a challenging operation associated with significant morbidity and mortality. More experience, longer follow-up, and further refinement of the operative technique is indicated before it can be recommended as the standard approach.

[Surgical treatment of gastroesophageal reflux disease in adults]

Pathological gastroesophageal reflux is common. The aim of this review was to compare the results of different surgical techniques. Papers were selected on Medline from 1990 to April 2001. A critical analysis was performed, concerning definitions of included patients, surgical techniques, and criteria of evaluation. For comparison, the results of 23 randomized studies were mainly selected. Their heterogeneity has not allowed a meta-analysis. A few techniques had poorer results than others: simple closure of His angle, Hill operation, Belsey Mark IV technique, and Angelchik prosthesis. In most studies, results of partial fundoplication on reflux were as good as those of total Nissen fundoplication and fewer patients had postoperative dysphagia. In a double blind trial, immediate advantages of laparoscopic approach were less important than those observed in non comparative studies. Another trial was interrupted after inclusion of 103 patients because of the higher rate of side-effects in the laparoscopic group. These results may help the surgeon in the choice of a technique. Patients have to be informed of potential adverse effects of the different techniques chosen by their surgeon.

Gastropericardial fistula after failure of laparoscopic hiatal repair

We describe a 77-year-old patient with gastropericardial fistula occurring 5 years after laparoscopic surgery for hiatal hernia and gastroesophageal reflux. The patient presented with isolated intermittent substernal pain without fever. Chest radiographs disclosed extensive pneumopericardium and thoracic computed tomography suggested gastropericardial fistula between the pericardium and the surgical wrap, slipped into the thorax. Emergency surgery allowed successful repair through laparotomy via the trans-hiatal approach.

Complications of laparoscopic antireflux surgery

Over the last decade, the laparoscopic approach to antireflux surgery has been widely applied, resulting in improved early outcomes and greater patient acceptance of surgery for gastroesophageal reflux disease. However, although short-term outcomes are probably better overall than those following open surgery, it has become apparent that the laparoscopic approach is associated with an increased risk of some complications, and as well as the occurrence of new complications specific to the laparoscopic approach. Significant complications include acute paraesophageal hiatus herniation, severe dysphagia, pneumothorax, vascular injury, and perforation of the gastrointestinal tract. The incidence of some of these complications decreases as surgeons gain experience; others can be minimized by using an appropriate operative technique. In addition, laparoscopic reintervention is usually straightforward in the 1st postoperative week. For this reason, the surgeon should have a low threshold for early laparoscopic reexploration, facilitated by early radiological contrast studies, in order to reduce the likelihood that problems will arise later.

Dysphagia after antireflux surgery

BACKGROUND

Dysphagia is experienced by many patients after antireflux surgery. This literature review examines factors associated with the development, prediction and management of postoperative dysphagia.

METHODS

Published studies examining issues related to dysphagia, gastro-oesophageal reflux and fundoplication were reviewed.

RESULTS

Postoperative dysphagia is usually temporary but proves troublesome for 5--10 per cent of patients. Technical modifications, such as a partial wrap, division of short gastric vessels and method of hiatal closure, have not conclusively reduced its incidence. There is no reliable preoperative test to predict dysphagia.

CONCLUSION

It is uncertain whether postoperative dysphagia arises from patient predilection or is largely a consequence of mechanical changes created by fundoplication. Anatomical errors account for a significant proportion of patients referred for correction of dysphagia but these are uncommon in large single-institution studies. Abnormal manometry cannot predict dysphagia and, on current evidence, 'tailoring' the operation does not prevent its occurrence.

Laparoscopic revision of failed antireflux operations

BACKGROUND

A small number of patients fail fundoplication and require reoperation. Laparoscopic techniques have been applied to reoperative fundoplications. We reviewed our experience with reoperative laparoscopic fundoplication.

METHODS

Reoperative laparoscopic fundoplication was undertaken in 28 patients, 19 F and 9 M, of mean age 56 years +/- 12. Previous antireflux procedures included 19 open and 12 laparoscopic antireflux operations.

RESULTS

Symptoms were heartburn (90%), dysphagia (35%), and atypical symptoms (30%%). The mean interval from antireflux procedure to revision was 13 months +/- 4.2. The mean DeMeester score was 78+/-32 (normal 14.7). Eighteen patients (64%) had hiatal breakdown, 17 (60%) had wrap failure, 2 (7%) had slipped Nissen, 3 (11%) had paraesophageal hernias, and 1 (3%) had an excessively tight wrap. Twenty-five revisions were completed laparoscopically, while 3 patients required conversion to the open technique. Complications occurred in 9 of 17 (53%) patients failing previous open fundoplications and in 4 of 12 patients (33%) failing previous laparoscopic fundoplications and included 15 gastrotomies and 1 esophagotomy, all repaired laparoscopically, 3 postoperative gastric leaks, and 4 pneumothoraces requiring tube thoracostomy. No deaths occurred. Median length of stay was 5 days (range 2-90 days). At a mean follow-up of 20 months +/- 17, 2 patients (7%) have failed revision of their fundoplications, with the rest of the patients being essentially asymptomatic (93%).

CONCLUSIONS

The results achieved with reoperative laparoscopic fundoplication are similar to those of primary laparoscopic fundoplications. Laparoscopic reoperations, particularly of primary open fundoplication, can be technically challenging and fraught with complications.