The MHC class I ligand-generating system: roles of immunoproteasomes and the interferon-gamma-inducible proteasome activator PA28

The proteasome activator 11 S REG (PA28) and class I antigen presentation

There are two immune responses in vertebrates: humoral immunity is mediated by circulating antibodies, whereas cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) confer cellular immunity. CTL lyse infected cells upon recognition of cell-surface MHC Class I molecules complexed with foreign peptides. The displayed peptides are produced in the cytosol by degradation of host proteins or proteins from intracellular pathogens that might be present. Proteasomes are cylindrical multisubunit proteases that generate many of the peptides eventually transferred to the cell surface for immune surveillance. In mammalian proteasomes, six active sites face a central chamber. As this chamber is sealed off from the enzyme's surface, there must be mechanisms to promote entry of substrates. Two protein complexes have been found to bind the ends of the proteasome and activate it. One of the activators is the 19 S regulatory complex of the 26 S proteasome; the other activator is '11 S REG' [Dubiel, Pratt, Ferrell and Rechsteiner (1992) J. Biol. Chem. 267, 22369-22377] or 'PA28' [Ma, Slaughter and DeMartino (1992) J. Biol. Chem. 267, 10515-10523]. During the past 7 years, our understanding of the structure of REG molecules has increased significantly, but much less is known about their biological functions. There are three REG subunits, namely alpha, beta and gamma. Recombinant REGalpha forms a ring-shaped heptamer of known crystal structure. 11 S REG is a heteroheptamer of alpha and beta subunits. REGgamma is also presumably a heptameric ring, and it is found in the nuclei of the nematode work Caenorhabditis elegans and higher organisms, where it may couple proteasomes to other nuclear components. REGalpha and REGbeta, which are abundant in vertebrate immune tissues, are located mostly in the cytoplasm. Synthesis of REG alpha and beta subunits is induced by interferon-gamma, and this has led to the prevalent hypothesis that REG alpha/beta hetero-oligomers play an important role in Class I antigen presentation. In the present review we focus on the structural properties of REG molecules and on the evidence that REGalpha/beta functions in the Class I immune response.

Mapping subunit contacts in the regulatory complex of the 26 S proteasome. S2 and S5b form a tetramer with ATPase subunits S4 and S7

The 19 S regulatory complex (RC) of the 26 S proteasome is composed of at least 18 different subunits, including six ATPases that form specific pairs S4-S7, S6-S8, and S6'-S10b in vitro. One of the largest regulatory complex subunits, S2, was translated in reticulocyte lysate containing [(35)S]methionine and used to probe membranes containing SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis separated RC subunits. S2 bound to two ATPases, S4 and S7. Association of S2 with regulatory complex subunits was also assayed by co-translation and sedimentation. S2 formed an immunoprecipitable heterotrimer upon co-translation with S4 and S7. The non-ATPase S5b also formed a ternary complex with S4 and S7 and the three proteins assembled into a tetramer with S2. Neither S2 nor S5b formed complexes with S6'-S10b dimers or with S6-S8 oligomers. The use of chimeric ATPases demonstrated that S2 binds the NH(2)-terminal region of S4 and the COOH-terminal two-thirds of S7. Conversely, S5b binds the COOH-terminal two-thirds of S4 and to S7's NH(2)-terminal region. The demonstrated association of S2 with ATPases in the mammalian 19 S regulatory complex is consistent with and extends the recent finding that the yeast RC is composed of two subcomplexes, the lid and the base (Glickman, M. H., Rubin, D. M., Coux, O., Wefes, I., Pfeifer, G., Cejka, Z., Baumeister, W., Fried, V. A., and Finley, D. (1998) Cell 94, 615-623).

Processing of some antigens by the standard proteasome but not by the immunoproteasome results in poor presentation by dendritic cells

By stimulating human lymphocytes with an autologous renal carcinoma, we obtained CTL recognizing an antigen derived from a novel, ubiquitous protein. The CTL failed to lyse autologous EBV-transformed B cells, even though the latter express the protein. This is due to the presence in these cells of immunoproteasomes, which, unlike standard proteasomes, cannot produce the antigenic peptide. We show that dendritic cells also carry immunoproteasomes and fail to present this antigen. This may explain why the relevant CTL escape thymic deletion and are not regularly activated in the periphery. Lack of cleavage by the immunoproteasome was also observed for melanoma differentiation antigen Melan-A26-35/HLA-A2, currently used for antitumoral vaccination. For immunization with such antigens, proteins should be less suitable than peptides, which do not require proteasome digestion in dendritic cells.

Growth retardation in mice lacking the proteasome activator PA28gamma

The proteasome activator PA28 binds to both ends of the central catalytic machine, known as the 20 S proteasome, in opposite orientations to form the enzymatically active proteasome. The PA28 family is composed of three members designated alpha, beta, and gamma; PA28alpha and PA28beta form the heteropolymer mainly located in the cytoplasm, whereas PA28gamma forms a homopolymer that predominantly occurs in the nucleus. Available evidence indicates that the heteropolymer of PA28alpha and PA28beta is involved in the processing of intracellular antigens, but the function of PA28gamma remains elusive. To investigate the role of PA28gamma in vivo, we generated mice deficient in the PA28gamma gene. The PA28gamma-deficient mice were born without appreciable abnormalities in all tissues examined, but their growth after birth was retarded compared with that of PA28gamma(+/-) or PA28gamma(+/+) mice. We also investigated the effects of the PA28gamma deficiency using cultured embryonic fibroblasts; cells lacking PA28gamma were larger and displayed a lower saturation density than their wild-type counterparts. Neither the expression of PA28alpha/beta nor the subcellular localization of PA28alpha was affected in PA28gamma(-/-) cells. These results indicate that PA28gamma functions as a regulator of cell proliferation and body growth in mice and suggest that neither PA28alpha nor PA28beta compensates for the PA28gamma deficiency.

Interferon regulatory factor 1 mediates the interferon-gamma induction of the human immunoproteasome subunit multicatalytic endopeptidase complex-like 1

Proteasomes generate antigenic peptides from intracellular proteins for presentation to the immune system by the major histocompatibility complex class I molecules. The antiviral cytokine IFN-gamma alters the catalytic specificity of proteasomes by inducing the synthesis of an alternative set of three proteolytically active proteasome subunits. We have analyzed the mechanism of IFN-gamma induction for the IFN-gamma-induced subunit multicatalytic endopeptidase complex-like 1 (MECL1). The human MECL1 promoter contains two interferon-stimulated response elements (ISREs), generally known to bind members of the interferon regulatory factor (IRF) family. The importance of these elements for IFN-gamma induction of MECL1 was addressed by transfecting an endothelial cell line with MECL1 promoter constructs. By deletions and mutations of the ISRE sequences, we demonstrated that both ISREs were needed for full IFN-gamma induction of the reporter gene. The second (downstream) ISRE was essential for both IFN-gamma-induced and basal transcriptional activity of the promoter. In electrophoretic mobility shift assays, anti-IRF-1 antibodies supershifted an IFN-gamma-induced protein binding specifically to both ISRE sequences, whereas IRF-2 bound the second ISRE before induction. Co-transfection of IRF-1 resulted in induced MECL1 promoter activity in the absence of IFN-gamma. These data indicate that the IFN-gamma induction of human MECL1 is mediated by IFN-gamma-induced IRF-1.

The specificity of proteasomes: impact on MHC class I processing and presentation of antigens

We have studied polypeptide processing by purified proteasomes, with regard to proteolytic specificity and cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) epitope generation. Owing to defined preferences with respect to cleavage sites and fragment length, proteasomes degrade polypeptide substrates into cohorts of overlapping oligopeptides. Many of the proteolytic fragments exhibit structural features in common with major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I ligands including fragment size and frequencies of amino acids at fragment boundaries. Proteasomes frequently generate definitive MHC class I ligands and/or slightly longer peptides, while substantially larger peptides are rare. Individual CTL epitopes are produced in widely varying amounts, often consistent with immunohierarchies among CTL epitopes. We further found that polypeptide processing is remarkably conserved among proteasomes of eukaryotic origin and that invertebrate proteasomes can efficiently produce known high-copy MHC class I ligands, suggesting evolutionary adaptation of the transporter associated with antigen processing and MHC class I to ancient constraints imposed by proteasomal protein degradation.

Analysis of a 26-kb Region Linked to the Mhc in Zebrafish: Genomic Organization of the Proteasome Component β/Transporter Associated with Antigen Processing-2 Gene Cluster and Identification of Five New Proteasome β Subunit Genes

Sequencing of zebrafish (Danio rerio) bacterial artificial chromosome and P1 artificial chromosome genomic clone fragments and of cDNA clones has led to the identification of five new loci coding for β subunits of proteasomes (PSMB). Together with the four genes identified previously, nine PSMB genes have now been defined in the zebrafish. Six of the nine genes reside in the zebrafish MHC (Mhc) class I region, four of them reside in a single cluster closely associated with TAP2 on a 26-kb long genomic fragment, and two reside at some distance from the fragment. In addition to homologues of the human genes PSMB5 through PSMB9, two new genes, PSMB11 and PSMB12, have been found for which there are no known corresponding genes in humans. The new genes reside in the PSMB cluster in the Mhc. Homology and promoter region analysis suggest that the Mhc-associated genes might be inducible by IFN-γ. The zebrafish class I region contains representatives of three phylogenetically distinguishable groups of PSMB genes, X, Y, and Z. It is proposed that these genes were present in the ancestral PSMB region before Mhc class I genes became associated with it.

Halophilic 20S proteasomes of the archaeon Haloferax volcanii: purification, characterization, and gene sequence analysis

A 20S proteasome, composed of alpha(1) and beta subunits arranged in a barrel-shaped structure of four stacked rings, was purified from a halophilic archaeon Haloferax volcanii. The predominant peptide-hydrolyzing activity of the 600-kDa alpha(1)beta-proteasome on synthetic substrates was cleavage carboxyl to hydrophobic residues (chymotrypsin-like [CL] activity) and was optimal at 2 M NaCl, pH 7.7 to 9.5, and 75 degrees C. The alpha(1)beta-proteasome also hydrolyzed insulin B-chain protein. Removal of NaCl inactivated the CL activity of the alpha(1)beta-proteasome and dissociated the complex into monomers. Rapid equilibration of the monomers into buffer containing 2 M NaCl facilitated their reassociation into fully active alpha(1)beta-proteasomes of 600 kDa. However, long-term incubation of the halophilic proteasome in the absence of salt resulted in hydrolysis and irreversible inactivation of the enzyme. Thus, the isolated proteasome has unusual salt requirements which distinguish it from any proteasome which has been described. Comparison of the beta-subunit protein sequence with the sequence deduced from the gene revealed that a 49-residue propeptide is removed to expose a highly conserved N-terminal threonine which is proposed to serve as the catalytic nucleophile and primary proton acceptor during peptide bond hydrolysis. Consistent with this mechanism, the known proteasome inhibitors carbobenzoxyl-leucinyl-leucinyl-leucinal-H (MG132) and N-acetyl-leucinyl-leucinyl-norleucinal (calpain inhibitor I) were found to inhibit the CL activity of the H. volcanii proteasome (K(i) = 0.2 and 8 microM, respectively). In addition to the genes encoding the alpha(1) and beta subunits, a gene encoding a second alpha-type proteasome protein (alpha(2)) was identified. All three genes coding for the proteasome subunits were mapped in the chromosome and found to be unlinked. Modification of the methods used to purify the alpha(1)beta-proteasome resulted in the copurification of the alpha(2) protein with the alpha(1) and beta subunits in nonstoichometric ratios as cylindrical particles of four stacked rings of 600 kDa with CL activity rates similar to the alpha(1)beta-proteasome, suggesting that at least two separate 20S proteasomes are synthesized. This study is the first description of a prokaryote which produces two separate 20S proteasomes and suggests that there may be distinct physiological roles for the two different alpha subunits in this halophilic archaeon.

Follicle cell proteasome activity and acid extract from the egg vitelline coat prompt the onset of self-sterility in Ciona intestinalis oocytes

In the hermaphrodite ascidian Ciona intestinalis, the egg vitelline coat (VC) controls gamete self-nonself discrimination. Oocytes, after germinal vesicle breakdown, can be fertilized by both self and nonself sperm. However, a barrier to fertilization by self sperm progressively develops in the VC in the 3 hours after germinal vesicle breakdown. During this period, follicle cells attached to the outer surface of the VC release self-sterility factors that bind to the VC. Within the follicle cells, these factors (possibly peptides) are thought to be shuttled to the cell membrane by an hsp70 homolog (Cihsp70). In fact, antibodies to hsp70 block the development of self-sterility. Proteasomes are central to the production of antigen peptides. Specific inhibition of proteasome activity with clasto-lactacystin beta-lactone (CLbetaL) prevented the onset of self-sterility, but had no effect once this process had started. CLbetaL did not block fertilization by nonself sperm. The self-sterility factors were removed from mature oocytes by exposure to acidified media, and their biological activity was transferred to immature oocytes treated with CLbetaL. The obvious high multiplicity of self-nonself recognition alleles involved in fertilization, and the involvement of an hsp70 and a proteasome in processing self-sterility factors, suggests that this system may be evolutionarily related to the vertebrate immune system.

26 S proteasome-mediated production of an authentic major histocompatibility class I-restricted epitope from an intact protein substrate

Peptides displayed on the cell surface by major histocompatibility class I molecules (MHC class I) are generated by proteolytic processing of protein-antigens in the cytoplasm. Initially, antigens are degraded by the 26 S proteasome, most probably following ubiquitination. However, it is unclear whether this proteolysis results in the generation of MHC class I ligands or if further processing is required. To investigate the role of the 26 S proteasome in antigen presentation, we analyzed the processing of an intact antigen by purified 26 S proteasome. A recombinant ornithine decarboxylase was produced harboring the H-2K(b)-restricted peptide epitope, derived from ovalbumin SIINFEKL (termed ODC-ova). Utilizing recombinant antizyme to target the antigen to the 26 S proteasome, we found that proteolysis of ODC-ova by the 26 S proteasome resulted in the generation of the K(b)-ligand. Mass spectrometry analysis indicated that in addition to SIINFEKL, the N-terminally extended ligand, HSIINFEKL, was also generated. Production of SIINFEKL was linear with time and directly proportional to the rate of ODC-ova degradation. The overall yield of SIINFEKL was approximately 5% of the amount of ODC-ova degraded. The addition of PA28, the 20 S, or the 20 S-PA28 complex to the 26 S proteasome did not significantly affect the yield of the antigenic peptide. These findings demonstrate that the 26 S proteasome can efficiently digest an intact physiological substrate and generate an authentic MHC class I-restricted epitope.

Specificity of the proteasome and the TAP transporter

The generation of antigenic peptides and their transport across the membrane of the endoplasmic reticulum for assembly with MHC class I molecules are essential steps in antigen presentation to cytotoxic T lymphocytes. Recent studies have characterized the substrate specificities of the proteasome and the transporter associated with antigen processing. It is interesting to compare the specificity of this transporter to the wide spectrum of peptides generated by the proteasome, to the binding motifs of MHC class I molecules and in particular to the principles of T cell recognition.

Splice acceptor site mutation of the transporter associated with antigen processing-1 gene in human bare lymphocyte syndrome

Expression of histocompatibility leukocyte antigen (HLA) class I molecules on the cell surface depends on the heterodimer of the transporter associated with antigen processing 1 and 2 (TAP1 and TAP2), which transport peptides cleaved by proteasome to the class I molecules. Defects in the TAP2 protein have been reported in two families with HLA class I deficiency, the so-called bare lymphocyte syndrome (BLS) type I. We have, to our knowledge, identified for the first time a splice site mutation in the TAP1 gene of another BLS patient. In addition, class I heavy chains (HCs) did not form the normal complex with tapasin in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) of the cells of our patient.

The chromosomal duplication model of the major histocompatibility complex

The major histocompatibility complex (MHC) is a genetic region that has been extensively studied by immunologists, molecular biologists, and evolutionary biologists. Nevertheless, our knowledge of how the MHC acquired its present-day organization is quite limited. The recent discovery that the mammalian genome contains regions paralogous to the MHC has led us to the proposal that the MHC region of jawed vertebrates arose as a result of ancient chromosomal duplications. Here, I review the current status of this proposal.

Insight into the primordial MHC from studies in ectothermic vertebrates

MHC classical class I and class II genes have been identified in representative species from all major jawed vertebrate taxa, the oldest group being the cartilaginous fish, whereas no class I/II genes of any type have been detected in animals from older taxa. Among ectothermic vertebrate classes, studies of MHC architecture have been done in cartilaginous fish (sharks), bony fish (several teleost species), and amphibians (the frog Xenopus). The Xenopus MHC contains class I, class II, and class III genes, demonstrating that all of these genes were linked in the ancestor of the tetrapods, but the gene order is not the same as that in mouse/man. Studies of polyploid Xenopus suggest that MHC genes can be differentially silenced when multiple copies are present; i.e. MHC 'subregions' can be silenced. Surprisingly, in all teleosts examined to date class I and class II genes are not linked. Likewise, class III genes like the complement genes factor B (Bf) and C4 are scattered throughout the genome of teleosts. However, the presumed classical class I genes are closely linked to the 'immune' proteasome genes, LMP2 and LMP7, and to the peptide-transporter genes (TAP), implying that a true 'class I region' exists in this group. A similar type of linkage group is found in chickens and perhaps Xenopus, and thus it may reveal the ancestral organization of class I-associated genes. In cartilaginous fish, classical and non-classical class I genes have been isolated from three shark species, and class II A and B chain genes from nurse sharks. Studies of MHC linkage in sharks are being carried out to provide further understanding of the putative primordial organization of MHC Segregation studies in one shark family point to linkage of classical class I and class II genes, suggesting that the non-linkage of these genes in teleosts is a derived characteristic.

What do the paralogous regions in the genome tell us about the origin of the adaptive immune system?

During the last decade, our understanding of the immune system of ectothermic vertebrates has advanced significantly. It is now clear that all jawed vertebrates are equipped with the adaptive immune system characterized by the MHC molecules and the rearranging receptors. In contrast, there is no molecular evidence that suggests the existence of adaptive immunity in jawless vertebrates. How did the adaptive immune system emerge? Our recent work suggests that one of the driving forces that enabled the emergence of the adaptive immune system was one or more genome-wide or large-scale chromosomal duplications presumed to have taken place in a common ancestor of jawed vertebrates.

The proteasome: a protein-destroying machine

Most cellular proteins are targeted for degradation by the proteasome, a eukaryotic ATP-dependent protease, after they have been covalently attached to ubiquitin (Ub) in the form of a poly Ub chain functioning as a degradation signal. The proteasome is an unusually large multisubunit proteolytic complex, consisting of a central catalytic machine (called the 20S proteasome) and two terminal regulatory subcomplexes, termed PA700 or PA28, that are attached to both ends of the central portion in opposite orientations, to form enzymatically active proteasomes. The large assembled proteasome acts as a protein-destroying machine responsible for the selective breakdown of numerous ubiquitinylated cellular proteins and certain nonubiquitinylated proteins. To date, proteolysis mediated by the Ub-proteasome pathway has been shown to be involved in a wide variety of biologically important processes, such as the cell cycle, apoptosis, metabolism, signal transduction, immune response and protein quality control, implying that it functions as a previously unrecognized regulatory system for determining the final fate of protein factors involved in these biological reactions.