A national survey of physician-assisted suicide and euthanasia in the United States

Attitudes toward euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide among Italian primary care physicians

The public debate about euthanasia and assisted suicide is less pronounced in Italy than in other countries, and data about this topic are lacking. The aim of this study was to investigate primary care physicians' experience in requests for and opinions about euthanasia and/or assisted suicide for terminally ill patients and the relationship between attitudes and professional variables. Three-hundred thirty-six general practitioners completed the Euthanasia Questionnaire to assess attitudes toward euthanasia and/or assisted suicide and the Maslach Burnout Inventory to examine burnout symptoms. The rate of requests for euthanasia or assisted suicide was low (11% and 4.5%, respectively). Only a minority of the physicians endorsed euthanasia and/or assisted suicide. Agreement with the practice of euthanasia/assisted suicide was correlated with non-Catholic religious affiliation, inexperience in treating terminally ill patients, and the burnout dimension of depersonalization. The fact that professional as well as individual factors (e.g., inexperience, non-Catholic affiliation, burnout) were associated with favorable attitudes toward euthanasia and/or assisted suicide underscores the need to examine the problem as a complex phenomenon involving the dyadic patient-doctor relationship.

Legalized physician-assisted suicide in Oregon--the first year's experience

BACKGROUND AND METHODS

On October 27, 1997, Oregon legalized physician-assisted suicide. We collected data on all terminally ill Oregon residents who received prescriptions for lethal medications under the Oregon Death with Dignity Act and who died in 1998. The data were obtained from physicians' reports, death certificates, and interviews with physicians. We compared persons who took lethal medications prescribed under the act with those who died from similar illnesses but did not receive prescriptions for lethal medications.

RESULTS

Information on 23 persons who received prescriptions for lethal medications was reported to the Oregon Health Division; 15 died after taking the lethal medications, 6 died from underlying illnesses, and 2 were alive as of January 1, 1999. The median age of the 15 patients who died after taking lethal medications was 69 years; 8 were male, and all 15 were white. Thirteen of the 15 patients had cancer. The case patients and controls were similar with regard to sex, race, urban or rural residence, level of education, health insurance coverage, and hospice enrollment. No case patients or controls expressed concern about the financial impact of their illness. One case patient and 15 controls expressed concern about inadequate control of pain (P=0.10). The case patients were more likely than the controls to have never married (P=0.04) and were more likely to be concerned about loss of autonomy due to illness (P=0.01) and loss of control of bodily functions (P=0.02). At death, 21 percent of the case patients and 84 percent of the controls were completely disabled (P<0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

During the first year of legalized physician-assisted suicide in Oregon, the decision to request and use a prescription for lethal medication was associated with concern about loss of autonomy or control of bodily functions, not with fear of intractable pain or concern about financial loss. In addition, we found that the choice of physician-assisted suicide was not associated with level of education or health insurance coverage.

Nontreatment and aggressive narcotic therapy among hospitalized pancreatic cancer patients

OBJECTIVES

Strong feelings about patient autonomy as expressed in living wills, polls, and legislative referenda have been challenging the medical establishment to increase nontreatment, defined as foregoing a life-prolonging treatment, and even to provide treatments having life-shortening potential to selected patients. Because there are little data about the actual practice of these procedures, including aggressive narcotic therapy as defined herein, we studied the terminal management of 417 pancreatic cancer patients.

DESIGN AND PARTICIPANTS

The medical records of 417 residents of King County, Washington, who died of pancreatic cancer in the time periods 1959-1962, 1969-1972, and 1985-1990, were reviewed to study the frequency of, and risk factors for, end-of-life nontreatment decisions and aggressive narcotic therapy decisions, defined here as the decision to administer treatment doses of narcotics or major sedatives to already comatose patients within 4 hours of death.

RESULTS

Antibiotics were not provided to 71% of the 70 febrile patients (two readings >38.33-38.83 degrees C or one reading of 38.88 degrees C), intravenous fluid was not provided to 43% of 294 dehydrated patients (oral intake <500 mL/24 hours), transfusions were not provided to 39% of 57 severely anemic patients (hematocrit <20%), and laparotomy was not performed for 86% of 36 patients with abdominal emergencies (obstruction, bleeding, dehiscence). Also, 46% of the 118 patients who were comatose for at least 24 hours before death received aggressive narcotic therapy, as defined above. A total of 335 of the 417 patients had documentation of at least one of the above life-threatening conditions or were comatose for at least 24 hours before death, and 289 (86%) of these patients experienced nontreatment of one or more of these conditions or received aggressive narcotic therapy. Nontreatment decisions for febrile, dehydrated, or anemic patients tended to be more frequent if the patient was comatose (P=.004, .010, and .065, respectively), if there was a nontreatment statement in the medical record (P=.009, .035, and .001, respectively), or if the patient was described as terminal (P=.262, .029, and .002, respectively). Aggressive narcotic therapy in comatose patients was more common among patients who had regular visitors (P=.002), who had pre-coma pain (P=.006), who had nontreatment statements in their charts (P=.031), whose in-charge physician was an oncologist (P < .001), who were treated in a community nonprofit hospital compared with a Catholic hospital (P=.007), or who were treated in recent years (P=.011).

CONCLUSION

Both nontreatment and aggressive narcotic therapy forms of medical management have been occurring commonly in terminal pancreatic cancer patients in King County, Washington, during the past 3 decades, the latter with greater frequency in recent years.

Criminal act or palliative care? Prosecutions involving the care of the dying

Author examines criminal investigations and prosecutions of physicians and nurses in connection with their care of dying patients and concludes that the criminal law has failed to protect patients and families and has significant power to deter appropriate pain management for dying patients.