Single-molecule studies of the effect of template tension on T7 DNA polymerase activity

Unifying themes in DNA replication: reconciling single molecule kinetic studies with structural data on DNA polymerases

Structural data suggest that DNA polymerases, from at least three different families, employ common strategies for carrying out DNA replication. Universal features include a large conformational change in the enzyme-template complex and a conserved active-site geometry that imposes a sharp kink at the 5 end of the template strand. Recent single molecule experiments have shown that stretching the DNA template markedly alters the rate of DNA synthesis catalyzed by these motor enzymes. From these data, it was previously inferred that T7 DNA polymerase and two related enzymes convert two or four (depending on the enzyme) single-stranded (ss) template bases to double helix geometry in the polymerase active site during each catalytic cycle. We discuss structural data on related DNA polymerases, which suggest that only one (ss) template base is contracted to dsDNA geometry during the rate-limiting step of each replication cycle. Previous interpretations relied upon the global stretching curves for DNA polymers alone (with no reference to the enzyme or the structure of the transition state). In contrast, we present a structurally guided model that presumes the force dependence of the replication rate is governed chiefly by local interactions in the immediate vicinity of the enzyme s active site. Our analysis reconciles single molecule kinetic studies with structural data on DNA polymerases.

Dynamical scaling of the DNA unzipping transition

We report studies of the dynamics of a set of exactly solvable lattice models for the force-induced DNA unzipping transition. Besides yielding the whole equilibrium phase diagram, which reveals a reentrance, these models enable us to characterize the dynamics of the process starting from a nonequilibrium initial condition. The thermal melting of DNA displays a model dependent time evolution. On the contrary, the dynamical mechanism for the unzipping by force is very robust and the scaling behavior is independent of the details of the description and, hence, superuniversal.

Labeling phosphorylated LHCII with microspheres for tracking studies and force measurements

We report a method to selectively label phosphorylated, membrane proteins with microscopic particles. This technology is particularly useful in single particle studies. In such studies, the particles may serve to visualize protein diffusion and/or as 'handles' to study the force of interaction between the labeled protein and the membrane matrix. In the latter kind of experiments, forces can be applied and measured by calibrated optical tweezers. Optical tweezers were used in this work to test the strength of the particle labeling. Labeling a single protein with a particle produces a long-lived, distinct tag and is particularly useful for proteins in photosynthetic membranes, which contain endogenous fluorophores that would render single fluorescent proteins difficult to detect.

Fluorescence microscopy of single viral capsids

To build a foundation for the single-molecule fluorescence microscopy of protein complexes, the present study achieved fluorescence microscopy of single, nucleic acid-free protein capsids of bacteriophage T7. The capsids were stained with Alexa 488 (green emission). Manipulation of the capsids' thermal motion was achieved in three dimensions. The procedure for manipulation included embedding the capsids in an agarose gel. The data indicate that the thermal motion of capsids is reduced by the sieving of the gel. The thermal motion can be reduced to any desired level. A semilogarithmic plot of an effective diffusion constant as a function of gel concentration is linear. Single, diffusing T7 capsids were also visualized in the presence of single DNA molecules that had been both stretched and immobilized by gel-embedding. The DNA molecules were stained with ethidium (orange emission). This study shows that single-molecule (protein and DNA) analysis is possible for both packaging of DNA in a bacteriophage capsid and other events of DNA metabolism. The major problem is the maintenance of biochemical activity.

Signaling in channel/enzyme multimers: ATPase transitions in SUR module gate ATP-sensitive K+ conductance

ATP-sensitive potassium (K(ATP)) channels are bifunctional multimers assembled by an ion conductor and a sulfonylurea receptor (SUR) ATPase. Sensitive to ATP/ADP, K(ATP) channels are vital metabolic sensors. However, channel regulation by competitive ATP/ADP binding would require oscillations in intracellular nucleotides incompatible with cell survival. We found that channel behavior is determined by the ATPase-driven engagement of SUR into discrete conformations. Capture of the SUR catalytic cycle in prehydrolytic states facilitated pore closure, while recruitment of posthydrolytic intermediates translated in pore opening. In the cell, channel openers stabilized posthydrolytic states promoting K(ATP) channel activation. Nucleotide exchange between intrinsic ATPase and ATP/ADP-scavenging systems defined the lifetimes of specific SUR conformations gating K(ATP) channels. Signal transduction through the catalytic module provides a paradigm for channel/enzyme operation and integrates membrane excitability with metabolic cascades.

Stretching single-stranded DNA: interplay of electrostatic, base-pairing, and base-pair stacking interactions

Recent single-macromolecule observations revealed that the force/extension characteristics of single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) are closely related to solution ionic concentration and DNA sequence composition. To understand this, we studied the elastic property of ssDNA through the Monte Carlo implementation of a modified freely jointed chain (FJC), with electrostatic, base-pairing, and base-pair stacking interactions all incorporated. The simulated force-extension profiles for both random and designed sequences have attained quantitative agreements with the experimental data. In low-salt solution, electrostatic interaction dominates, and at low forces, the molecule can be more easily aligned than an unmodified FJC. In high-salt solution, secondary hairpin structure appears in ssDNA by the formation of base pairs between complementary bases, and external stretching causes a hairpin-coil structural transition, which is continuous for ssDNA made of random sequences. In designed sequences such as poly(dA-dT) and poly(dG-dC), the stacking potential between base pairs encourages the aggregation of base pairs into bulk hairpins and makes the hairpin-coil transition a discontinuous (first-order) process. The sensitivity of elongation to the base-pairing rule is also investigated. The comparison of modeling calculations and the experimental data suggests that the base pairing of single-stranded polynucleotide molecules tends to form a nested and independent planar hairpin structure rather than a random intersecting pattern.

Tuning DNA "strings": modulating the rate of DNA replication with mechanical tension

Recent experiments have measured the rate of replication of DNA catalyzed by a single enzyme moving along a stretched template strand. The dependence on tension was interpreted as evidence that T7 and related DNA polymerases convert two (n = 2) or more single-stranded template bases to double helix geometry in the polymerization site during each catalytic cycle. However, we find structural data on the T7 enzyme--template complex indicate n = 1. We also present a model for the "tuning" of replication rate by mechanical tension. This model considers only local interactions in the neighborhood of the enzyme, unlike previous models that use stretching curves for the entire polymer chain. Our results, with n = 1, reconcile force-dependent replication rate studies with structural data on DNA polymerase complexes.

Ratiometric single-molecule studies of freely diffusing biomolecules

We outline recent developments in biological single-molecule fluorescence detection with particular emphasis on observations by ratiometric fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) of biomolecules freely diffusing in solution. Single-molecule-diffusion methodologies were developed to minimize perturbations introduced by interactions between molecules and surfaces. Confocal microscopy is used in combination with sensitive detectors to observe bursts of photons from fluorescently labeled biomolecules as they diffuse through the focal volume. These bursts are analyzed to extract ratiometric observables such as FRET efficiency and polarization anisotropy. We describe the development of single-molecule FRET methodology and its application to the observation of the Förster distance dependence and the study of protein folding and polymer physics problems. Finally, we discuss future advances in data acquisition and analysis techniques that can provide a more complete picture of the accessible molecular information.

Myosin learns to walk

Recent experiments, drawing upon single-molecule, solution kinetic and structural techniques, have clarified our mechanistic understanding of class V myosins. The findings of the past two years can be summarized as follows: (1) Myosin V is a highly efficient processive motor, surpassing even conventional kinesin in the distance that individual molecules can traverse. (2) The kinetic scheme underlying ATP turnover resembles those of myosins I and II but with rate constants tuned to favor strong binding to actin. ADP release precedes dissociation from actin and is rate-limiting in the cycle. (3) Myosin V walks in strides averaging ∼36 nm, the long pitch pseudo-repeat of the actin helix, each step coupled to a single ATP hydrolysis. Such a unitary displacement, the largest molecular step size measured to date, is required for a processive myosin motor to follow a linear trajectory along a helical actin track.

Twisting and stretching single DNA molecules

The elastic properties of DNA are essential for its biological function. They control its bending and twisting as well as the induction of structural modifications in the molecule. These can affect its interaction with the cell machinery. The response of a single DNA molecule to a mechanical stress can be precisely determined in single-molecule experiments which give access to an accurate measurement of the elastic parameters of DNA.

Force-induced melting of the DNA double helix. 2. Effect of solution conditions

In this paper, we consider the implications of the general theory developed in the accompanying paper, to interpret experiments on DNA overstretching that involve variables such as solution temperature, pH, and ionic strength. We find the DNA helix-coil phase boundary in the force-temperature space. At temperatures significantly below the regular (zero force) DNA melting temperature, the overstretching force, f(ov)(T), is predicted to decrease nearly linearly with temperature. We calculate the slope of this dependence as a function of entropy and heat-capacity changes upon DNA melting. Fitting of the experimental f(ov)(T) dependence allows determination of both of these quantities in very good agreement with their calorimetric values. At temperatures slightly above the regular DNA melting temperature, we predict stabilization of dsDNA by moderate forces, and destabilization by higher forces. Thus the DNA stretching curves, f(b), should exhibit two rather than one overstretching transitions: from single stranded (ss) to double stranded (ds) and then back at the higher force. We also predict that any change in DNA solution conditions that affects its melting temperature should have a similar effect on DNA overstretching force. This result is used to calculate the dependence of DNA overstretching force on solution pH, f(ov)(pH), from the known dependence of DNA melting temperature on pH. The calculated f(ov)(pH) is in excellent agreement with its experimental determination (M. C. Williams, J. R. Wenner, I. Rouzina, and V. A. Bloomfield, Biophys. J., accepted for publication). Finally, we quantitatively explain the measured dependence of DNA overstretching force on solution ionic strength for crosslinked and noncrosslinked DNA. The much stronger salt dependence of f(ov) in noncrosslinked DNA results from its lower linear charge density in the melted state, compared to crosslinked or double-stranded overstretched S-DNA.

Force-induced melting of the DNA double helix 1. Thermodynamic analysis

The highly cooperative elongation of a single B-DNA molecule to almost twice its contour length upon application of a stretching force is interpreted as force-induced DNA melting. This interpretation is based on the similarity between experimental and calculated stretching profiles, when the force-dependent free energy of melting is obtained directly from the experimental force versus extension curves of double- and single-stranded DNA. The high cooperativity of the overstretching transition is consistent with a melting interpretation. The ability of nicked DNA to withstand forces greater than that at the transition midpoint is explained as a result of the one-dimensional nature of the melting transition, which leads to alternating zones of melted and unmelted DNA even substantially above the melting midpoint. We discuss the relationship between force-induced melting and the B-to-S transition suggested by other authors. The recently measured effect on T7 DNA polymerase activity of the force applied to a ssDNA template is interpreted in terms of preferential stabilization of dsDNA by weak forces approximately equal to 7 pN.

Processive translocation and DNA unwinding by individual RecBCD enzyme molecules

RecBCD enzyme is a processive DNA helicase and nuclease that participates in the repair of chromosomal DNA through homologous recombination. We have visualized directly the movement of individual RecBCD enzymes on single molecules of double-stranded DNA (dsDNA). Detection involves the optical trapping of solitary, fluorescently tagged dsDNA molecules that are attached to polystyrene beads, and their visualization by fluorescence microscopy. Both helicase translocation and DNA unwinding are monitored by the displacement of fluorescent dye from the DNA by the enzyme. Here we show that unwinding is both continuous and processive, occurring at a maximum rate of 972 +/- 172 base pairs per second (0.30 microm s(-1)), with as many as 42,300 base pairs of dsDNA unwound by a single RecBCD enzyme molecule. The mean behaviour of the individual RecBCD enzyme molecules corresponds to that observed in bulk solution.

Direct imaging of single-molecules: from dynamics of a single DNA chain to the study of complex DNA-protein interactions

Recent years have seen significant advances in the characterization and manipulation of individual molecules. The combination of single-molecule fluorescence and micromanipulation enables one to study physical and biological systems at new length scales, to unravel qualitative mechanisms, and to measure kinetic parameters that cannot be addressed by traditional biochemistry. DNA is one of the most studied biomolecules. Imaging single DNA molecules eliminates important limitations of classical techniques and provides a new method for testing polymer dynamics and DNA-protein interactions. Here we review some applications of this new approach to physical and biological problems, focusing on videomicroscopy observations of individual DNA chains extended in a shear flow. We will first describe data obtained on the stretching, relaxation and dynamics of a single tethered polymer in a shear flow, to demonstrate that the deformation of sheared tethered chains is partially governed by the thermally driven fluctuations of the chain transverse to the flow direction. Next, we will show how single-molecule videomicroscopy can be used to study in real time DNA folding into chromatin, a complex association of DNA and proteins responsible for the packaging of DNA in the nucleus of an eukaryotic cell.

Fast kinetics of chromatin assembly revealed by single-molecule videomicroscopy and scanning force microscopy

Fluorescence videomicroscopy and scanning force microscopy were used to follow, in real time, chromatin assembly on individual DNA molecules immersed in cell-free systems competent for physiological chromatin assembly. Within a few seconds, molecules are already compacted into a form exhibiting strong similarities to native chromatin fibers. In these extracts, the compaction rate is more than 100 times faster than expected from standard biochemical assays. Our data provide definite information on the forces involved (a few piconewtons) and on the reaction path. DNA compaction as a function of time revealed unique features of the assembly reaction in these extracts. They imply a sequential process with at least three steps, involving DNA wrapping as the final event. An absolute and quantitative measure of the kinetic parameters of the early steps in chromatin assembly under physiological conditions could thus be obtained.

Preferential relaxation of positively supercoiled DNA by E. coli topoisomerase IV in single-molecule and ensemble measurements

We show that positively supercoiled [(+) SC] DNA is the preferred substrate for Escherichia coli topoisomerase IV (topo IV). We measured topo IV relaxation of (-) and (+) supercoils in real time on single, tethered DNA molecules to complement ensemble experiments. We find that the preference for (+) SC DNA is complete at low enzyme concentration. Otherwise, topo IV relaxed (+) supercoils at a 20-fold faster rate than (-) supercoils, due primarily to about a 10-fold increase in processivity with (+) SC DNA. The preferential cleavage of (+) SC DNA in a competition experiment showed that substrate discrimination can take place prior to strand passage in the presence or absence of ATP. We propose that topo IV discriminates between (-) and (+) supercoiled DNA by recognition of the geometry of (+) SC DNA. Our results explain how topo IV can rapidly remove (+) supercoils to support DNA replication without relaxing the essential (-) supercoils of the chromosome. They also show that the rate of supercoil relaxation by topo IV is several orders of magnitude faster than hitherto appreciated, so that a single enzyme may suffice at each replication fork.

Grabbing the cat by the tail: manipulating molecules one by one

Methods for manipulating single molecules are yielding new information about both the forces that hold biomolecules together and the mechanics of molecular motors. We describe here the physical principles behind these methods, and discuss their capabilities and current limitations.

Structural basis for the recognition of DNA repair proteins UNG2, XPA, and RAD52 by replication factor RPA

Replication protein A (RPA), the nuclear ssDNA-binding protein in eukaryotes, is essential to DNA replication, recombination, and repair. We have shown that a globular domain at the C terminus of subunit RPA32 contains a specific surface that interacts in a similar manner with the DNA repair enzyme UNG2 and repair factors XPA and RAD52, each of which functions in a different repair pathway. NMR structures of the RPA32 domain, free and in complex with the minimal interaction domain of UNG2, were determined, defining a common structural basis for linking RPA to the nucleotide excision, base excision, and recombinational pathways of repairing damaged DNA. Our findings support a hand-off model for the assembly and coordination of different components of the DNA repair machinery.

Replication by a single DNA polymerase of a stretched single-stranded DNA

A new approach to the study of DNA/protein interactions has been opened through the recent advances in the manipulation of single DNA molecules. These allow the behavior of individual molecular motors to be studied under load and compared with bulk measurements. One example of such a motor is the DNA polymerase, which replicates DNA. We measured the replication rate by a single enzyme of a stretched single strand of DNA. The marked difference between the elasticity of single- and double-stranded DNA allows for the monitoring of replication in real time. We have found that the rate of replication depends strongly on the stretching force applied to the template. In particular, by varying the load we determined that the biochemical steps limiting replication are coupled to movement. The replication rate increases at low forces, decreases at forces greater than 4 pN, and ceases when the single-stranded DNA substrate is under a load greater than approximately 20 pN. The decay of the replication rate follows an Arrhenius law and indicates that multiple bases on the template strand are involved in the rate-limiting step of each cycle. This observation is consistent with the induced-fit mechanism for error detection during replication.

Force spectroscopy with single bio-molecules

For many biological molecules, force is an important functional and structural parameter. With the rapidly growing knowledge about the relation between structure, function, and force, single-molecule force spectroscopy has become a versatile analytical tool for the structural and functional investigation of single bio-molecules in their native environments. Within the past year, detailed insights into binding potentials of receptor ligand pairs, protein folding pathways, molecular motors, DNA mechanics and the functioning of DNA-binding agents (such as proteins and drugs), as well as the function of molecular motors, have been obtained.

An integrated laser trap/flow control video microscope for the study of single biomolecules

We have developed an integrated laser trap/flow control video microscope for mechanical manipulation of single biopolymers. The instrument is automated to maximize experimental throughput. A single-beam optical trap capable of trapping micron-scale polystyrene beads in the middle of a 200-microm-deep microchamber is used, making it possible to insert a micropipette inside this chamber to hold a second bead by suction. Together, these beads function as easily exchangeable surfaces between which macromolecules of interest can be attached. A computer-controlled flow system is used to exchange the liquid in the chamber and to establish a flow rate with high precision. The flow and the optical trap can be used to exert forces on the beads, the displacements of which can be measured either by video microscopy or by laser deflection. To test the performance of this instrument, individual biotinylated DNA molecules were assembled between two streptavidin beads, and the DNA elasticity was characterized using both laser trap and flow forces. DNA extension under varying forces was measured by video microscopy. The combination of the flow system and video microscopy is a versatile design that is particularly useful for the study of systems susceptible to laser-induced damage. This capability was demonstrated by following the translocation of transcribing RNA polymerase up to 650 s.

Single-molecule studies of DNA mechanics

During the past decade, physical techniques such as optical tweezers and atomic force microscopy were used to study the mechanical properties of DNA at the single-molecule level. Knowledge of DNA's stretching and twisting properties now permits these single-molecule techniques to be used in the study of biological processes such as DNA replication and transcription.

Single-molecule study of transcriptional pausing and arrest by E. coli RNA polymerase

Using an optical-trap/flow-control video microscopy technique, we followed transcription by single molecules of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase in real time over long template distances. These studies reveal that RNA polymerase molecules possess different intrinsic transcription rates and different propensities to pause and stop. The data also show that reversible pausing is a kinetic intermediate between normal elongation and the arrested state. The conformational metastability of RNA polymerase revealed by this single-molecule study of transcription has direct implications for the mechanisms of gene regulation in both bacteria and eukaryotes.