HIV-1 can escape from RNA interference by evolving an alternative structure in its RNA genome

Novel Pol II fusion promoter directs human immunodeficiency virus type 1-inducible coexpression of a short hairpin RNA and protein

We demonstrate a novel approach for coexpression of a short hairpin RNA (shRNA) with an open reading frame which exploits transcriptional read-through of a minimal polyadenylation signal from a Pol II promoter. We first observed efficient inducible expression of enhanced green fluorescent protein along with an anti-rev shRNA. We took advantage of this observation to test coexpression of the transdominant negative mutant (humanized) of human immunodeficiency type 1 (HIV-1) Rev (huRevM10) along with an anti-rev shRNA via an HIV-1-inducible fusion promoter. The coexpression of the shRNA and transdominant protein resulted in potent, long-term inhibition of HIV-1 gene expression and suppression of shRNA-resistant mutants. This dual expression system has broad-based potential for other shRNA applications, such as cases where simultaneous knockdown of mutant and wild-type transcripts must be accompanied by replacement of the wild-type protein.

siRNA, miRNA and HIV: promises and challenges

Small interfering RNA (siRNA) and microRNA (miRNA) are small RNAs of 18-25 nucleotides (nt) in length that play important roles in regulating gene expression. They are incorporated into an RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC) and serve as guides for silencing their corresponding target mRNAs based on complementary base-pairing. The promise of gene silencing has led many researchers to consider siRNA as an anti-viral tool. However, in long-term settings, many viruses appear to escape from this therapeutical strategy. An example of this may be seen in the case of human immunodeficiency virus type-1 (HIV-1) which is able to evade RNA silencing by either mutating the siRNA-targeted sequence or by encoding for a partial suppressor of RNAi (RNA interference). On the other hand, because miRNA targeting does not require absolute complementarity of base-pairing, mutational escape by viruses from miRNA-specified silencing may be more difficult to achieve. In this review, we discuss stratagems used by various viruses to avoid the cells' antiviral si/mi-RNA defenses and notions of how viruses might control and regulate host cell genes by encoding viral miRNAs (vmiRNAs).

Strategies to identify potential therapeutic target sites in RNA

Antisense agents are powerful tools to inhibit gene expression in a sequence-specific manner. They are used for functional genomics, as diagnostic tools and for therapeutic purposes. Three classes of antisense agents can be distinguished by their mode of action: single-stranded antisense oligodeoxynucleotides; catalytic active RNA/DNA such as ribozymes, DNA- or locked nucleic acid (LNA)zymes; and small interfering RNA molecules known as siRNA. The selection of target sites in highly structured RNA molecules is crucial for their successful application. This is a difficult task, since RNA is assembled into nucleoprotein complexes and forms stable secondary structures in vivo, rendering most of the molecule inaccessible to intermolecular base pairing with complementary nucleic acids. In this review, we discuss several selection strategies to identify potential target sites in RNA molecules. In particular, we focus on combinatorial library approaches that allow high throughput screening of sequences for the design of antisense agents.

Sequence homology required by human immunodeficiency virus type 1 to escape from short interfering RNAs

Short interfering RNAs (siRNAs) targeting viral or cellular genes can efficiently inhibit human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) replication. Nevertheless, the emergence of mutations in the gene being targeted could lead to the rapid escape from the siRNA. Here, we simulate viral escape by systematically introducing single-nucleotide substitutions in all 19 HIV-1 residues targeted by an effective siRNA. We found that all mutant viruses that were tested replicated better in the presence of the siRNA than in the presence of the wild-type virus. The antiviral activity of the siRNA was completely abolished by single substitutions in 10 (positions 4 to 11, 14, and 15) out of 16 positions tested (substitution at 3 of the 19 positions explored rendered nonviable viruses). With the exception of the substitution observed at position 12, substitutions at either the 5' end or the 3' end (positions 1 to 3, 16, and 18) were better tolerated by the RNA interference machinery and only in part affected siRNA inhibition. Our results show that optimal HIV-1 gene silencing by siRNA requires a complete homology within most of the target sequence and that substitutions at only a few positions at the 5' and 3' ends are partially tolerated.

Anti-viral RNA silencing: do we look like plants?

The anti-viral function of RNA silencing was first discovered in plants as a natural manifestation of the artificial 'co-suppression', which refers to the extinction of endogenous gene induced by homologous transgene. Because silencing components are conserved among most, if not all, eukaryotes, the question rapidly arose as to determine whether this process fulfils anti-viral functions in animals, such as insects and mammals. It appears that, whereas the anti-viral process seems to be similarly conserved from plants to insects, even in worms, RNA silencing does influence the replication of mammalian viruses but in a particular mode: micro(mi)RNAs, endogenous small RNAs naturally implicated in translational control, rather than virus-derived small interfering (si)RNAs like in other organisms, are involved. In fact, these recent studies even suggest that RNA silencing may be beneficial for viral replication. Accordingly, several large DNA mammalian viruses have been shown to encode their own miRNAs. Here, we summarize the seminal studies that have implicated RNA silencing in viral infection and compare the different eukaryotic responses.

Antiviral Applications of RNAi

RNA interference is a natural mechanism by which small interfering (si)RNA operates to specifically and potently down-regulate the expression of a target gene. This down-regulation has been thought to predominantly function at the level of the messenger (m)RNA, post-transcriptional gene silencing (PTGS). Recently, the discovery that siRNAs can function to suppress a gene's expression at the level of transcription, i.e., transcriptional gene silencing (TGS), has created a major paradigm shift in mammalian RNAi. These recent findings significantly broaden the role RNA, specifically siRNAs and potentially microRNAs, plays in the regulation of gene expression as well as the breadth of potential siRNA target sites. Indeed, the specificity and simplicity of design makes the use of siRNAs to target and suppress virtually any gene or gene promoter of interest a realized technology. Furthermore, since siRNAs are a small nucleic acid reagent, they are unlikely to elicit an immune response, making them a theoretically good future therapeutic. This review will focus on the development, delivery, and potential therapeutic use of antiviral siRNAs in treating viral infections as well as emerging viral threats.

Targeting the HIV-1 RNA leader sequence with synthetic oligonucleotides and siRNA: chemistry and cell delivery

New candidates for development as potential drugs or virucides against HIV-1 infection and AIDS continue to be needed. The HIV-1 RNA leader sequence has many essential functional sites for virus replication and regulation that includes several highly conserved sequences. The review describes the historical context of targeting the HIV-1 RNA leader sequence with antisense phosphorothioate oligonucleotides, such as GEM 91, and goes on to describe modern approaches to targeting this region with steric blocking oligonucleotide analogues having newer and more advantageous chemistries, as well as recent studies on siRNA, towards the attainment of antiviral activity. Recent attempts to obtain improved cell delivery are highlighted, including exciting new developments in the use of peptide conjugates of peptide nucleic acid (PNA) as potential virucides.

Inhibition of drug-resistant HIV-1 by RNA interference

RNA interference is a powerful tool used to inhibit human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) replication in vitro. Almost all HIV-1 genes have been targets for small interfering RNA (siRNA) molecules, and HIV-1 replication can be specifically and successfully inhibited by this technique. RNA interference has been proposed as an alternative strategy to inhibit replication of drug-resistant viruses that emerge during suboptimal antiretroviral therapy for HIV-1. To investigate specific inhibition of drug-resistant HIV-1 by RNA interference, we designed siRNA molecules that recognize codons 181-188 of the reverse transcriptase (RT) gene of wild-type HIV-1 and HIV-1 carrying the M184V mutation, which confers high-level resistance to the RT inhibitor lamivudine. Using viral variants with single point mutations at codon 184, we measured the impact of these mutations on virus replication. We have demonstrated that siRNA targeting either wild-type HIV-1 or M184V variants inhibits replication of the corresponding virus, but does not influence replication of virus with a mismatch in the targeted region. Combining two effective siRNAs did not show synergistic inhibitory effect on HIV-1 replication. However, a combination of lamivudine and siRNA-M184V was very effective in inhibiting replication of both wild-type and variant M184V viruses in mixed infection experiments. Taken together, these results demonstrate that RNA interference might be useful in the treatment of drug-resistant HIV-1 infection.

A novel approach for inhibition of HIV-1 by RNA interference: counteracting viral escape with a second generation of siRNAs

RNA interference (RNAi) is an evolutionary conserved gene silencing mechanism in which small interfering RNA (siRNA) mediates the sequence specific degradation of mRNA. The recent discovery that exogenously delivered siRNA can trigger RNAi in mammalian cells raises the possibility to use this technology as a therapeutic tool against pathogenic viruses. Indeed, it has been shown that siRNAs can be used effectively to inhibit virus replication. The focus of this review is on RNA interference strategies against HIV-1 and how this new technology may be developed into a new successful therapy. One of the hallmarks of RNAi, its sequence specificity, also presents a way out for the virus, as single nucleotide substitutions in the target region can abolish the suppression. Strategies to prevent the emergence of resistant viruses have been suggested and involve the targeting of conserved sequences and the simultaneous use of multiple siRNAs, similar to current highly active antiretroviral therapy. We present an additional strategy aimed at preventing viral escape by using a second generation of siRNAs that recognize the mutated target sites.

Complete cure of persistent virus infections by antiviral siRNAs

Small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) have been developed as antiviral agents for mammalian cells. The capacity of specific siRNAs to prevent virus infections has been demonstrated, and there is evidence that these new antiviral agents could have a partial therapeutic effect a few days after infection. We investigated the possibility of curing a persistent infection, several months after becoming established, using an in vitro model of persistent poliovirus (PV) infection in HEp-2 cells. Despite high virus titers and the presence of PV mutants, repeated treatment with a mixture of two siRNAs targeting both noncoding and coding regions, one of them in a highly conserved region, resulted in the complete cure of the majority of persistently infected cultures. No escape mutants emerged in treated cultures. The antiviral effect of specific siRNAs, consistent with a mechanism of RNA interference, correlated with a decrease in the amount of viral RNA, until its complete disappearance, resulting in cultures cured of virions and viral RNA.

Antiviral silencing in animals

RNA silencing or RNA interference (RNAi) refers to the small RNA-guided gene silencing mechanism conserved in a wide range of eukaryotic organisms from plants to mammals. As part of this special issue on the biology, mechanisms and applications of RNAi, here we review the recent advances on defining a role of RNAi in the responses of invertebrate and vertebrate animals to virus infection. Approximately 40 miRNAs and 10 RNAi suppressors encoded by diverse mammalian viruses have been identified. Assays used for the identification of viral suppressors and possible biological functions of both viral miRNAs and suppressors are discussed. We propose that herpes viral miRNAs may act as specificity factors to initiate heterochromatin assembly of the latent viral DNA genome in the nucleus.

Long-term inhibition of HIV-1 infection in primary hematopoietic cells by lentiviral vector delivery of a triple combination of anti-HIV shRNA, anti-CCR5 ribozyme, and a nucleolar-localizing TAR decoy

Combinatorial therapies for the treatment of HIV-1 infection have proven to be effective in reducing patient viral loads and slowing the progression to AIDS. We have developed a series of RNA-based inhibitors for use in a gene therapy-based treatment for HIV-1 infection. The transcriptional units have been inserted into the backbone of a replication-defective lentiviral vector capable of transducing a wide array of cell types, including CD34+ hematopoietic progenitor cells. The combinatorial therapeutic RNA vector harbors a U6 Pol III promoter-driven short hairpin RNA (shRNA) targeting the rev and tat mRNAs of HIV-1, a U6 transcribed nucleolar-localizing TAR RNA decoy, and a VA1-derived Pol III cassette that expresses an anti-CCR5 ribozyme. Each of these therapeutic RNAs targets a different gene product and blocks HIV infection by a distinct mechanism. Our results demonstrate that the combinatorial vector suppresses HIV replication long term in a more-than-additive fashion relative to the single shRNA or double shRNA/ribozyme or decoy combinations. Our data demonstrate the validity and efficacy of a combinatorial RNA-based gene therapy for the treatment of HIV-1 infection.

Inhibition, escape, and attenuated growth of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus treated with antisense morpholino oligomers

The recently emerged severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus (SARS-CoV) is a potent pathogen of humans and is capable of rapid global spread. Peptide-conjugated antisense morpholino oligomers (P-PMO) were designed to bind by base pairing to specific sequences in the SARS-CoV (Tor2 strain) genome. The P-PMO were tested for their capacity to inhibit production of infectious virus as well as to probe the function of conserved viral RNA motifs and secondary structures. Several virus-targeted P-PMO and a random-sequence control P-PMO showed low inhibitory activity against SARS coronavirus. Certain other virus-targeted P-PMO reduced virus-induced cytopathology and cell-to-cell spread as a consequence of decreasing viral amplification. Active P-PMO were effective when administered at any time prior to peak viral synthesis and exerted sustained antiviral effects while present in culture medium. P-PMO showed low nonspecific inhibitory activity against translation of nontargeted RNA or growth of the arenavirus lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus. Two P-PMO targeting the viral transcription-regulatory sequence (TRS) region in the 5' untranslated region were the most effective inhibitors tested. After several viral passages in the presence of a TRS-targeted P-PMO, partially drug-resistant SARS-CoV mutants arose which contained three contiguous base point mutations at the binding site of a TRS-targeted P-PMO. Those partially resistant viruses grew more slowly and formed smaller plaques than wild-type SARS-CoV. These results suggest PMO compounds have powerful therapeutic and investigative potential toward coronavirus infection.

Suppression of RNA interference by adenovirus virus-associated RNA

We show that human adenovirus inhibits RNA interference (RNAi) at late times of infection by suppressing the activity of two key enzyme systems involved, Dicer and RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC). To define the mechanisms by which adenovirus blocks RNAi, we used a panel of mutant adenoviruses defective in virus-associated (VA) RNA expression. The results show that the virus-associated RNAs, VA RNAI and VA RNAII, function as suppressors of RNAi by interfering with the activity of Dicer. The VA RNAs bind Dicer and function as competitive substrates squelching Dicer. Further, we show that VA RNAI and VA RNAII are processed by Dicer, both in vitro and during a lytic infection, and that the resulting short interfering RNAs (siRNAs) are incorporated into active RISC. Dicer cleaves the terminal stem of both VA RNAI and VA RNAII. However, whereas both strands of the VA RNAI-specific siRNA are incorporated into RISC, the 3' strand of the VA RNAII-specific siRNA is selectively incorporated during a lytic infection. In summary, our work shows that adenovirus suppresses RNAi during a lytic infection and gives insight into the mechanisms of RNAi suppression by VA RNA.

Small non-coding RNAs as magic bullets

RNA interference (RNAi) - inhibition of gene expression by small, non-coding RNAs [small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) or microRNAs (miRNAs)] - has changed our view of regulation of expression dramatically. The application of siRNAs for both functional analysis of genes and medication raises several questions. These include the design of the double-stranded oligonucleotides, their preparation and introduction into cells or animals either as chemically synthesized entities or as transcripts from a suitable vector. Delivery of the oligonucleotides, choice of vector, chemical modification to stabilize against nucleases and avoidance of side effects (e.g. stimulation of interferons) are major challenges. Work to identify the multiple targets of miRNAs is still in its infancy, and a clear distinction between siRNAs and miRNAs is difficult in some instances. Moreover, transcriptional silencing by RNAi is poorly understood; it is evident that the siRNA machinery is involved but the details await clarification. Given the multitude of interactions of the small non-coding RNAs revealed so far, we should be prepared to encounter, as yet, undiscovered interactions and mechanisms.

Specific inhibition of HIV-1 replication by short hairpin RNAs targeting human cyclin T1 without inducing apoptosis

RNA interference (RNAi), a sequence-specific RNA degradation mechanism mediated by small interfering RNA (siRNA), can be used not only as a research tool but also as a therapeutic strategy for viral infection. We demonstrated that intracellular expression of short hairpin RNA (shRNA) targeting human cyclin T1 (hCycT1), a cellular factor essential for transcription of messenger and genomic RNAs from the long terminal repeat promoter of provirus of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1), could effectively suppress the replication of HIV-1. We also showed that downregulation of hCycT1 did not cause apoptotic cell death, therefore, targeting cellular factor hCycT1 by shRNAs may provide an attractive approach for genetic therapy of HIV-1 infection in the future.

Short hairpin RNA targeted to the highly conserved 2B nonstructural protein coding region inhibits replication of multiple serotypes of foot-and-mouth disease virus

Foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) is one of the most contagious agents of animals. Recent disease outbreaks in FMD-free countries have prompted the development of new control strategies that could improve the levels of protection against this virus. We have delivered a plasmid expressing a short hairpin RNA (shRNA) directed against a highly conserved sequence in the 2B nonstructural protein coding region of FMDV RNA to porcine cells. After virus infection, these cells showed a significant reduction in the synthesis of viral RNA and proteins, as well as a decrease in virus yield when compared to control cells. The antiviral effect was sequence specific and not attributable to induction of the interferon pathway. Since FMDV is an antigenically variable virus, we examined the effectiveness of this strategy against multiple serotypes and found that expressed 2B shRNA resulted in efficient silencing of at least 4 FMDV serotypes. Thus, RNA interference may be a potential alternative control strategy to limit the spread of this highly contagious virus in livestock.

Local RNA target structure influences siRNA efficacy: a systematic global analysis

The efficiency with which small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) down-regulate specific gene expression in living cells is variable and a number of sequence-governed, biochemical parameters of the siRNA duplex have been proposed for the design of an efficient siRNA. Some of these parameters have been clearly identified to influence the assembly of the RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC), or to favour the sequence preferences of the RISC endonuclease. For other parameters, it is difficult to ascertain whether the influence is a determinant of the siRNA per se, or a determinant of the target RNA, especially its local structural characteristics. In order to gain an insight into the effects of local target structure on the biological activity of siRNA, we have used large sets of siRNAs directed against local targets of the mRNAs of ICAM-1 and survivin. Target structures were classified as accessible or inaccessible using an original, iterative computational approach and by experimental RNase H mapping. The effectiveness of siRNA was characterized by measuring the IC50 values in cell culture and the maximal extent of target suppression. Mean IC50 values were tenfold lower for accessible local target sites, with respect to inaccessible ones. Mean maximal target suppression was improved. These data illustrate that local target structure does, indeed, influence the activity of siRNA. We suggest that local target screening can significantly improve the hit rate in the design of biologically active siRNAs.