Cell migration and chimerism after whole-organ transplantation: the basis of graft acceptance

Evaluation of seven PCR-based assays for the analysis of microchimerism

OBJECTIVE

The presence of small numbers of cells of donor origin in the circulation of recipients of organ transplants (microchimerism) may correlate with immunologic tolerance. As part of our ongoing studies on microchimerism, we evaluated the utility of seven PCR-based assays for the detection of the less abundant DNA in paired mixtures (100 ng total DNA).

DESIGN AND METHODS

DNA samples were screened to identify pairs informative for one or more PCR assays. DNA mixtures from the informative pairs were then analyzed using at least one assay. The assays were based on the X-Y homologous region; a Y chromosome microsatellite locus; three autosomal microsatellite loci; the D1S80 minisatellite locus; and sequence specific oligonucleotide probe (SSOP) analysis of the HLA DRB1 locus.

RESULTS

About 0.1% of male DNA against a background of female DNA was detectable using primers for the X-Y homologous region, but the sensitivity was increased to 0.0001% using nested primers for the Y chromosome microsatellite marker. Analysis of the minor DNA component was difficult with the three autosomal microsatellite assays because of the presence of shadow bands. Similar problems with the D1S80 assay were resolved using more stringent PCR conditions, and the sensitivity was 0.1%. Using the DRB1 locus, we were able to detect 1% DNA in the mixed samples.

CONCLUSIONS

These studies show that: (a) nested PCR for the Y chromosome is the most sensitive assay for the detection of microchimerism; (b) D1S80 is a useful marker for microchimerism; (c) additional optimization of analytical conditions is required if autosomal microsatellite markers and the SSOP assay are to be used for microchimerism analysis.

Analysis of the relationship between chimerism and the allgeneic humoral response

BACKGROUND

Persistence of antigens has been suggested to play a role in two opposing immunological phenomena: tolerance and memory. Therefore, we studied the impact of chimerism on alloreactive antibody (allo-Ab) production in kidney transplant patients.

METHODS

Thirty-five female renal transplant recipients of male donor organs were classified into the following groups: group 1, 13 sensitized uremic patients on dialysis; group 2, 5 nonsensitized uremic patients on dialysis; group 3, six sensitized patients experiencing graft rejection (3 acute vascular, 1 acute cellular, and 2 chronic); and group 4, 11 nonsensitized with functioning allografts (9 with good function, 1 with acute cellular rejection, and 1 with chronic rejection). Mean duration of dialysis after graft failure was similar in groups 1 (56+/-29.7 months) and 2 (41.8+/-42.4 months), as was dialysis efficiency. Chimerism was measured indirectly in the peripheral blood lymphocytes by polymerase chain reaction amplification of a specific Y chromosome DNA gene sequence with a detection sensitivity limit of 1 male cell per 1 million female cells. Allo-Ab production was measured by the PRA-STAT enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (Sangstat) method.

RESULTS

Chimerism was observed in 60% of groups 1 and 2, 83% of group 3, and 82% of group 4. Among all groups, graft existence, irrespective of its function, positively predicted chimerism in 92% with a sensitivity of 88% and a specificity of 78%. In group 3, all three patients with acute vascular rejection had chimerism and donor-specific allo-Abs. In group 4, eight of the nine patients with no rejection had chimerism.

CONCLUSION

Chimerism relates to persistence of allogeneic stimulus irrespective of its function. Chimerism did not confer protection against allo-Ab production or vascular rejection, and its existence was not crucial for sustenance of allo-Ab production.

Allogeneic hepatocyte transplantation: Contribution of Fas-Fas ligand interaction to allogeneic hepatocyte rejection

Hepatocyte transplantation is a potential therapeutic modality for overcoming the shortage of liver donors, and the clinical application of allogeneic hepatocyte transplantation has been considered. However, there are two major problems with allogeneic hepatocyte transplantation: protection of transplanted hepatocytes from rejection and stimulation of the rapid proliferation of surviving cells. Without immunosuppression, allogeneic hepatocytes are rapidly rejected within a few days after transplantation, even though it is relatively easy to induce immunotolerance after allogeneic whole liver transplantation. Accordingly, different rejection mechanisms seem to operate after allogeneic hepatocyte transplantation and whole liver transplantation. To overcome the rejection of transplanted hepatocytes, induction of donor-specific unresponsiveness to graft without compromising the host immune system would be ideal. We previously reported that the Fas-Fas ligand system plays a critical role in the CD28-independent pathway of hepatocyte rejection. Therefore, blockade of rejection using CTLA4 immunoglobulin (CTLA4Ig) or anti-CD80/86 monoclonal antibodies and anti-FasL monoclonal antibody may prolong the survival of transplanted allogeneic hepatocytes. Furthermore, administration of hepatocyte growth factor (HGF) can promote the proliferation of allogeneic hepatocytes and this may lead to the development of a functioning liver substitute.

Outcomes of recipients of both bone marrow and solid organ transplants. A review

In this review we examine the clinical outcomes of patients who have received both bone marrow transplantation (BMT) and solid organ transplantation (SOT) and discuss the possible immunologic consequences of the dual transplants. We collected cases through a comprehensive literature search (MEDLINE database, English literature only) covering the years 1990 through 1997 and correspondence with the International Bone Marrow Transplant Registry. Our study selected case reports of patients who have undergone both bone marrow and solid organ transplants; cases in which bone marrow transplantation was undertaken as an adjunct ot induce or augment donor-specific tolerance in a recipient to the transplanted organ were excluded. Clinical characteristics included patient's demographic information, underlying disorders for each transplant, source of donor organ or tissue, time between transplants, and immunosuppressive regimens used to prevent graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) or graft rejection. Clinical outcomes included patient survival, complications of transplantation, and donor-specific tolerance that was experienced in many cases. Twenty-one cases of SOT after BMT and 7 cases of BMT after SOT were reviewed. Solid organ transplantations included lung, liver, cardiac, and kidney for a variety of BMT-related complications including GVHD, hepatic veno-occlusive disease, chronic renal failure, end-stage pulmonary disease, and severe cardiomyopathy. Bone marrow transplants were performed following SOT for aplastic anemia and hematologic malignancies. Clinical outcomes for patients who received both BMT and SOT were variable and depended on transplant indication and degree of histocompatibility. Prior bone marrow transplantation may tolerize for a subsequent organ transplant from the same donor. Conversely, severe GVHD may follow BMT from human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-matched donors following SOT. The favorable survival in this high-risk group of patients may represent a literature review bias (that is, an undetermined number of unsuccessful cases may not have been reported). Nonetheless, dual transplantation is clearly feasible in selected cases.

Lymphoid/nonlymphoid compartmentalization of donor leukocyte chimerism in rat recipients of heart allografts, with or without adjunct bone marrow

BACKGROUND

The role of leukocyte migration and chimerism in organ allograft acceptance has been obscured by the lack of information about the late localization of the donor cells.

METHODS

Male Lewis rat-->female Brown Norway abdominal heart transplantation was performed under tacrolimus immunosuppression (days 0-13, 20, and 27) with or without donor bone marrow and (in bone marrow subgroups) a 1-week postoperative course of a possibly chimerism-enhancing drug. Using rat sex-determining region-Y-specific oligonucleotide primers, we determined the donor DNA concentration by polymerase chain reaction in serial venous blood samples for 100 days and in tissue specimens when animals were killed.

RESULTS

Chimerism was detected out to 56 days in 89% of the blood samples but in none of the samples at 100 days. However, donor DNA was detected when animals were killed in 95% of the native hearts, 80% of the skin biopsy specimens, and 23% of the spleens. The presence and quantity of early and late chimerism were strongly correlated the administration of adjunct bone marrow and with a reduction in the vasculopathy and inflammation index in the cardiac allografts. Marginally significant further increases in chimerism and/or reductions in chronic heart rejection beyond those achieved with adjunct bone marrow alone were associated with additional treatment with the growth factors Flt-3 ligand, granulocyte colony-stimulating factor, and a recombinant molecular variant of interleukin-6 (interleukin-6 mutein) but not with hepatocyte growth factor or lisofylline.

CONCLUSIONS

The previously suspected shift of early chimerism in the blood and lymphoid organs to dominance in host nonlymphoid tissues is consistent with the dual mechanisms of clonal exhaustion and immune indifference, governed by antigen migration and localization, that have been postulated elsewhere to account for organ allograft acceptance.

Tolerance and latent cellular rejection in long-term liver transplant recipients

Tolerance develops in a proportion of long-term liver transplant recipients but currently cannot be identified before an attempt at withdrawal from immunosuppression therapy. In the present study, we have examined the immunophenotypic characteristics of the cellular infiltrate in portal tracts and lobules as observed in liver biopsy specimens in relation to the outcome of subsequent withdrawal from immunosuppression therapy. Cryostat biopsy specimens from 27 long-term recipients before drug withdrawal, and from 10 patients with recent transplants who were having acute rejection, were analyzed. Immunohistochemical staining was performed for CD3+ (pan T cell), CD8+ (cytotoxic), CD4+ (helper), CD45RO+ (memory), CD45RA+ (naive), CD56+ (natural killer), CD68+ (macrophage), and CD8+ perforin+ cells. Fewer CD8+ and CD3+ cells were present in the lobular areas of biopsy specimens from patients who were successfully withdrawn from immunosuppression therapy (n = 6) compared with biopsy specimens from patients with nontolerant grafts (n = 9; 15 vs. 23 cells/high-power field [hpf] [P < .01] and 16 vs. 26 cells/hpf [P < .03], respectively) or biopsy specimens obtained during acute rejection (15 vs. 31 cells/hpf [P < .01] and 16 vs. 32 cells/hpf [P < .01]). Cell frequencies in the biopsy specimens of nontolerant long-term patients were similar to those found with acute rejection. Immunophenotyping the lobular inflammation within long-term liver allografts assists in identifying those patients in whom drug withdrawal is likely to be unsuccessful and in whom it is postulated a form of inactive, latent cellular rejection exists.

Activated sub-populations of lymphocytes and natural killer cells in normal liver and liver grafts before transplantation

AIMS/BACKGROUND

The anatomic structure of the liver suggests that it is a place of intense trafficking between intra-hepatic and peripheral blood compartment leukocytes. Furthermore, the liver contains a large number of passenger leukocytes that may play a role in the appearance of donor-type microchimerism after transplantation. In this study, we aimed to define the principal lymphocyte sub-populations contained in donor peripheral blood and liver grafts and in normal liver removed during minimally invasive surgery.

METHODS

Liver biopsies were taken at the time of vascular clampage during liver extraction from donors in a brain dead state (GI: n=14). Normal liver biopsies were removed during minimaly invasive surgery (GII: n= 10).

RESULTS

We observed evidence of the presence of lymphocytic activation associated with the two major CD8+ lymphocyte and natural killer (NK) cell populations in the two groups, with a significant increase in TCRgammadelta-bearing lymphocyte receptors between normal liver and the liver graft.

CONCLUSIONS

The presence of activated leukocytes in the graft could have a fundamental role in induction of peripheral tolerance. This activation could be the result of a basic immunological response linked to the interaction of T cells and NK cells, and of secondary activation due to stress and the conditions necessary for organ removal from donors in a brain dead state.

Detection of Microchimerism After Allogeneic Blood Transfusion Using Nested Polymerase Chain Reaction Amplification With Sequence-Specific Primers (PCR-SSP): A Cautionary Tale

In bone marrow transplantation, the detection of chimerism is an important adjunct to the repertoire of tests available for determining acceptance of the graft. In solid organ transplantation, there is currently intense interest in the role that chimerism plays in both short- and long-term host reactivity to the graft. Allogeneic blood transfusion has been associated with a subtle immunosuppressive effect in renal transplantation and chimerism is implicated as a possible mechanism for this effect. To assess the survival of allogeneic cells after blood transfusion or transplantation, we have developed a technique based on molecular typing for HLA class II alleles, which enables the detection of donor-derived cells in patients receiving blood transfusions. While developing this technology, we investigated why we and others observe false amplification. Sequencing of false products has shown that they arise from amplification of both pseudogenes and non-pseudogenes present in the DNA under test. Elucidation of this phenomenon allows the amplification of these false products to be predicted in any given combination and hence avoided by the judicious selection of primers. Validation has been achieved by following donor alleles after transfusion of blood containing defined numbers of leukocytes expressing selected mismatched antigens.

Microchimerism after liver transplantation: prevalence and methodological aspects of detection

BACKGROUND

Microchimerism after liver transplantation is a readily observed phenomenon. The immunological implications, however, remain unclear. Moreover, methodological approaches and their detection limits in the study of allogeneic microchimerism have not been studied in detail.

METHODS

Therefore, the aim of this study was to evaluate the single-step and nested formats of the polymerase chain reaction/sequence-specific priming (PCR-SSP) approach under standardized conditions. For that purpose, a panel of recombinant plasmid clones was generated by PCR cloning. The panel contained the allelic sequences of the second exon of DRB1 covering all DR specificities on a low-resolution level. Using this panel, limiting dilution assays for various DR sequences in the presence and absence of competitor DNA were carried out to determine the minimal number of copies required for detection by single-step and nested PCR-SSP. Subsequently, 22 liver transplant recipients were analyzed in a retrospective study for the presence of allogeneic microchimerism by nested PCR-SSP.

RESULTS

Although at least 10 copies of template DNA could be detected by nested PCR-SSP overall, single-step PCR-SSP was on average 10(2) to 10(3) times less sensitive. Upon the addition of human competitor DNA, the detection limits decreased on average by a factor of 10. In addition, sequence-specific differences in amplification efficiency could be appreciated. Using nested PCR-SSP, peripheral blood allogeneic microchimerism could be observed in 17 of 22 HLA-DR-mismatched liver recipients. Recombinants representing recipient DRB1 specificities were used to exclude false-positive results by lack of cross-reactivities of the donor-specific primers and to evaluate negative results due to sample-related reduced amplification efficiencies in microchimerism-negative recipients. In donor/recipient combinations that differed by at least one DR specificity, allogeneic microchimerism was seen in 87.5% of the cases. In five chimerism-negative cases, sample-related problems were detected in two cases.

CONCLUSION

The optimization and standardization of the detection of genomic HLA sequences at low copy number may be greatly facilitated using a clonal reference system. Furthermore, a clonal reference system may be used to conduct cross-priming experiments to exclude false-positive results and may allow the determination of sample-specific detection limits for donor-derived HLA-DR specificities in chimerism-negative patients. Our evaluation of the PCR-SSP approach for the study of allogeneic microchimerism indicated that nested PCR-SSP provides the most sensitive format when HLA sequences are targeted. Yet, the detection sensitivity may vary between individual alleles and specificities. Allogeneic microchimerism in liver recipients can be observed in the majority of patients. However, the detection may be subject to the degree of mismatching, the HLA-DR alleles involved, and sample-related impaired PCR amplification efficiency.

Detection of Microchimerism After Allogeneic Blood Transfusion Using Nested Polymerase Chain Reaction Amplification With Sequence-Specific Primers (PCR-SSP): A Cautionary Tale

In bone marrow transplantation, the detection of chimerism is an important adjunct to the repertoire of tests available for determining acceptance of the graft. In solid organ transplantation, there is currently intense interest in the role that chimerism plays in both short- and long-term host reactivity to the graft. Allogeneic blood transfusion has been associated with a subtle immunosuppressive effect in renal transplantation and chimerism is implicated as a possible mechanism for this effect. To assess the survival of allogeneic cells after blood transfusion or transplantation, we have developed a technique based on molecular typing for HLA class II alleles, which enables the detection of donor-derived cells in patients receiving blood transfusions. While developing this technology, we investigated why we and others observe false amplification. Sequencing of false products has shown that they arise from amplification of both pseudogenes and non-pseudogenes present in the DNA under test. Elucidation of this phenomenon allows the amplification of these false products to be predicted in any given combination and hence avoided by the judicious selection of primers. Validation has been achieved by following donor alleles after transfusion of blood containing defined numbers of leukocytes expressing selected mismatched antigens.

Immunologic suppression mediated by genetically modified hepatocytes expressing secreted allo-MHC class I molecules

Studies suggest that immunosuppression associated with liver transplantation may be related to the secretion of MHC class I antigen (Ag) by hepatocytes. To investigate this possibility, we developed a culture system whereby naive Lewis (RT1.A1) splenocytes were cocultured with autologous hepatocytes transfected with plasmids encoding either the membrane-bound or secreted allogeneic MHC class I Ag, RT1.Aa. Cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) and helper T lymphocyte (HTL) limiting dilution assays were subsequently performed on preconditioned lymphocytes. Lymphocytes preconditioned with hepatocytes secreting RT1.Aa showed an alloantigen specific inhibition of CTL precursors (CTLp). In contrast, exposure of splenocytes to hepatocyte-expressed membrane-bound RT1.Aa resulted in Ag-specific CTLp priming. This CTLp priming effect by hepatocyte-expressed membrane-bound Ag could be effectively blocked when splenocytes were first preincubated with hepatocytes secreting RT1.Aa, before being exposed to hepatocytes expressing membrane-bound RT1.Aa. In contrast to CTLp, HTLp frequency, as determined by IL-2 production, was unaffected by either hepatocyte-expressed membrane-bound or secreted RT1.Aa. Further studies on splenocytes conditioned with hepatocytes expressing secreted allo-MHC Ag suggest the possibility of suppressor cell development. This was demonstrated by prolongation of ACI (RT1a) heart allograft survival in Lewis recipients following adoptive transfer of splenocytes that were preconditioned in vitro with hepatocytes secreting alloantigen.

Donor pretreatment with Flt-3 ligand augments antidonor cytotoxic T lymphocyte, natural killer, and lymphokine-activated killer cell activities within liver allografts and alters the pattern of intragraft apoptotic activity

BACKGROUND

Liver allografts are accepted across major histocompatibility complex (MHC) barriers in mice and induce donor-specific tolerance without requirement for immunosuppressive therapy. There is evidence that passenger leukocytes may play a key role in tolerance induction. Flt-3 ligand (FL) is a recently cloned hematopoietic cytokine that strikingly augments functional dendritic cells (DCs) within lymphoid and nonlymphoid tissue.

METHODS

The expression of costimulatory molecules and MHC class II antigen on DCs isolated from livers of FL-treated B10 (H2b) mice (10 microg/day; 10 days) was examined by flow cytometric analysis, and their allostimulatory activity assessed in primary mixed leukocyte cultures. B10 livers from FL-treated donors were transplanted orthotopically into naive C3H (H2k) recipients. Donor cells (MHC class II+) in recipient spleens were identified by immunohistochemistry. Antidonor cytotoxic T lymphocyte activity, and both natural killer and lymphokine-activated killer cell activities of graft nonparenchymal cells and host splenocytes were determined using isotope release assays. Apoptotic activity within liver grafts was determined by terminal deoxynucleotidyltransferase-mediated dUTP-biotin nick end labeling.

RESULTS

DCs isolated from livers of FL-treated donor mice exhibited increased cell surface expression of CD40, CD80, CD86, and IAb, and augmented T cell allostimulatory activity compared with controls. Within 24 hr of organ transplantation, the numbers of donor IAb+ cells within recipient spleens was augmented substantially compared with normal liver recipients. Livers from FL-treated donors were rejected acutely (median survival time, 5 days), whereas control B10 liver allografts survived >100 days. Nonparenchymal cells from rejecting grafts 4 days after transplantation exhibited increased antidonor cytotoxic T lymphocyte, natural killer, and lymphokine-activated killer cell activities compared with cells from spontaneously accepted grafts. This augmented cytotoxic reactivity was associated with histologic evidence of injury to bile duct epithelium and vascular endothelium that was not readily evident in controls.

CONCLUSION

Thus, although normal livers provide allostimulatory signals sufficient to elicit an antidonor immune response, regulatory mechanisms that may include apoptosis of graft-infiltrating T cells, and that are overcome by augmenting the number of functional donor DCs, may account for inherent liver tolerogenicity.

Clinical intestinal transplantation: new perspectives and immunologic considerations

BACKGROUND

Although tacrolimus-based immunosuppression has made intestinal transplantation feasible, the risk of the requisite chronic high-dose treatment has inhibited the widespread use of these procedures. We have examined our 1990-1997 experience to determine whether immunomodulatory strategies to improve outlook could be added to drug treatment.

STUDY DESIGN

Ninety-eight consecutive patients (59 children, 39 adults) with a panoply of indications received 104 allografts under tacrolimus-based immunosuppression: intestine only (n = 37); liver and intestine (n = 50); or multivisceral (n = 17). Of the last 42 patients, 20 received unmodified adjunct donor bone marrow cells; the other 22 were contemporaneous control patients.

RESULTS

With a mean followup of 32 +/- 26 months (range, 1-86 months), 12 recipients (3 intestine only, 9 composite grafts) are alive with good nutrition beyond the 5-year milestone. Forty-seven (48%) of the total group survive bearing grafts that provide full (91%) or partial (9%) nutrition. Actuarial patient survival at 1 and 5 years (72% and 48%, respectively) was similar with isolated intestinal and composite graft recipients, but the loss rate of grafts from rejection was highest with intestine alone. The best results were in patients between 2 and 18 years of age (68% at 5 years). Adjunct bone marrow did not significantly affect the incidence of graft rejection, B-cell lymphoma, or the rate or severity of graft-versus-host disease.

CONCLUSIONS

These results demonstrate that longterm rehabilitation similar to that with the other kinds of organ allografts is achievable with all three kinds of intestinal transplant procedures, that the morbidity and mortality is still too high for their widespread application, and that the liver is significantly but marginally protective of concomitantly engrafted intestine. Although none of the endpoints were markedly altered by donor leukocyte augmentation (and chimerism) with bone marrow, establishment of the safety of this adjunct procedure opens the way to further immune modulation strategies that can be added to the augmentation protocol.

Incidence and severity of acute allograft rejection in liver transplant recipients treated with alfa interferon

Interferon alfa-2b (IFN-alpha) therapy has been shown to be effective in the treatment of viral hepatitis B (HBV) or viral hepatitis C (HCV) in patients who did not undergo transplantation. However, in allograft recipients, treatment with IFN-alpha often leads to allograft rejection. The aim of the present study was to determine if IFN-alpha therapy increases the incidence or severity of acute rejection in human liver allograft recipients. One hundred five orthotopic liver transplant (OLT) recipients with HBV (n = 32), HCV (n = 58), or Non A Non B Non C (n = 15) viral infections were treated with a 6-month course of IFN-alpha, 5 million U subcutaneously three times a week, which began 2 to 97 months after transplantation. The mean hepatitis activity index (HAI) at the beginning of the therapy was 10.1 +/- 3.0. The baseline immunosuppression was achieved by tacrolimus in 77 patients and by cyclosporine A (CyA) in 28 patients. Contemporaneous controls consisted of 132 OLT patients (100 who received tacrolimus and 32 who received CyA) who did not receive IFN-alpha. A retrospective analysis was performed on this group of patients. The incidence of rejection and the baseline immunosuppression were compared. All biopsies were reviewed without knowledge of clinical data and scored for HAI and for rejection activity index (RAI). The biochemical response to IFN-alpha was also examined. The mean baseline maintenance dose of prednisone was greater by 2 mg daily in patients who received IFN-alpha with tacrolimus compared with control patients who did not receive IFN-alpha with tacrolimus (IFN-alpha 5. 3 +/- 5.2 mg daily v controls 3.3 +/- 4.9 mg daily; P </= .05). Similarly, the mean maintenance dose of prednisone was greater by 2.5 mg daily in patients who received IFN-alpha compared with controls who received CyA-based immunosuppression (IFN-alpha 9.8 +/- 3.1 mg daily v controls 7.3 +/- 3.3 mg daily; P = .01). Acute rejection episodes were detected in 10.5% (n = 11) of IFN-alpha-treated patients compared with 8.8% of controls for the similar time period from OLT and period of exposure to risk of rejection. Mean RAI was 2.0 +/- 2.4 for the IFN-alpha-treated group and 2.1 +/- 1.7 for controls. Rejection episodes with IFN-alpha treatment were mild and responded to steroid therapy. In OLT recipients, the risk of acute rejection was not increased by the introduction of IFN-alpha. However, in this study, patients were exposed to greater levels of immunosuppression.

Continuing observations on the regulatory effects of donor-specific bone marrow cell infusions and chimerism in kidney transplant recipients

BACKGROUND

Continued follow-up of a series of donor bone marrow cell (DBMC)-infused first cadaver renal transplant recipients is described (n=58), now at a 36-month actuarial time point postoperatively. Serial polymerase chain reaction-flow cytometry (PCR-Flow) and cellular immune assays of iliac crest bone marrow aspirates and peripheral blood have begun to be compared with concomitantly transplanted recipients of living-related donor (LRD) kidneys and donor marrow infusions given the same immunosuppressive regimen (n=16). There have also been comparisons (36 months) with 188 controls transplanted concomitantly, i.e., recipients of first cadaver kidney transplants, who did not receive bone marrow.

METHODS

Each group was given equivalent immunosuppressive regimens of OKT3 anti-T cell induction and maintenance tacrolimus, mycophenolate mofetil, and methylprednisolone. Actuarial patient and graft survival have been 96% and 93%, respectively, in the controls and 91% and 91%, respectively, in the DBMC-infused recipients. Trough levels of tacrolimus were significantly lower in the DBMC-infused group.

RESULTS

In PCR-Flow measurements, in peripheral blood up to 6 months postoperatively, there were higher levels of chimerism, i.e., in the total number of donor cells, as well as the donor CD3+ and CD34+ subsets in the LRD recipients administered DBMC infusions, compared with cadaver DBMC recipients, supporting the notion of a positive effect of histocompatibility on chimerism levels. In PCR-Flow measurements of recipient iliac crest bone marrow aspirates as in previous studies on peripheral blood, early acute rejection episodes (<1 month) were found to be associated with a later (6-14 months) decrease in donor cell lineage chimerism. However, a trend toward recovery of chimeric levels occurred by 21-28 months in a second iliac crest marrow aspirate 1 year after the first aspirate in the DBMC-infused recipients who experienced such early rejection episodes. This was in contrast to the controls in whom there were sustained low levels of iliac crest bone marrow chimerism at both the earlier and later intervals (i.e., no chimeric recovery), with 17/183 surviving controls progressing into chronic rejection. This has not yet been seen in the DBMC-infused group (0/54). In in vitro observations on cellular immune reactivity at 1 year postoperatively, decreased peripheral blood lymphocyte proliferative reactions were seen in response to phytohemagglutinin and Staph-A mitogens, as well as to cytomegalovirus and Epstein-Barr viral protein antigens in the DBMC-infused group versus the controls. Chronic immunosuppression did not seem to effect a vigorous in vitro inhibitory (regulatory) activity of bone marrow taken from these transplant recipients 2 years postoperatively in mixed lymphocyte culture and cell-mediated lympholysis reactions, using allogeneic responding cells from "normal" laboratory volunteers. Autologous peripheral blood lymphoproliferative responses to phytohemagglutinin and Staph-A mitogens, as well as to cytomegalovirus and Epstein-Barr virus protein antigens, were also regulated by either organ donor (non-immunosuppressed) bone marrow cells or by transplant recipient (immunosuppressed) bone marrow cells. What appeared to be disparate between the DBMC-infused and control groups (both immunosuppressed) was the trend for the (autologous) bone marrow suppressive effect on antiviral lymphoproliferative responses, to be stronger in the DBMC-infused group, who also had significantly (>one order of magnitude) higher levels of chimerism (P=0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

It is concluded that the establishment of a chimeric state in DBMC-infused recipients, albeit of relatively low magnitude (approximately 1% at 2 years in recipient iliac crest bone marrow), has had a definite regulatory effect on immune responses. These results, therefore, add weight to the "causal" horn of the dilemma as to whether donor cell chimerism is a cause or an effect of

Flt-3 Ligand Increases Microchimerism But Can Prevent the Therapeutic Effect of Donor Bone Marrow in Transiently Immunosuppressed Cardiac Allograft Recipients

C3H (H2k) mice received 50 × 106 B10 (H2b) bone marrow (BM) cells either alone or with flt-3 ligand (FL) (10 μg/day), tacrolimus (2 mg/kg/day), or both agents for 7 days. Donor MHC class II+ (IAb+) cells were quantitated in spleens by immunohistochemical analysis, and donor class II DNA detected in BM by PCR. Donor cells were rare in the BM alone and BM + FL groups, whereas there was a substantial increase in chimerism in the BM + tacrolimus group. Addition of FL to BM + tacrolimus led to a further eightfold increase in donor cells and enhanced donor DNA compared with the BM + tacrolimus group. This increase in donor cells was almost 500-fold compared with BM alone. C3H recipients of B10 heart allografts given perioperative B10 BM and tacrolimus (days 0–13) exhibited a markedly extended median graft survival time (MST, 42 days) compared with those given tacrolimus alone (MST, 22 days). Addition of FL (10 μg/day; 7 days) to BM + tacrolimus prevented the beneficial effect of donor BM (MST, 18 days). BM alone or BM + FL resulted in uniform early heart graft failure (MST &lt; 8 days). Functional studies revealed maximal antidonor MLR and CTL activities in the BM- and BM + FL-treated groups, with minimal activity in the tacrolimus-treated groups. Thus, dramatic growth factor-induced increases in chimerism achieved under cover of immunosuppression may result in augmented antidonor T cell reactivity and reduced graft survival after immunosuppressive drug withdrawal. With FL, this may reflect striking augmentation of immunostimulatory dendritic cells.

Cellular immune responses of human cadaver donor bone marrow cells and their susceptibility to commonly used immunosuppressive drugs in transplantation

BACKGROUND

The cascade of immunological effects brought about by donor bone marrow cell (DBMC) infusions in human organ transplantation, especially in the context of continuous pharmacologic immunosuppression, is not fully understood. Yet, in inbred rodents and even primates, administration of specific bone marrow cells has caused a state of acquired immunologic tolerance.

METHODS

In vitro mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC) and cell-mediated lympholysis (CML) culture systems were used to compare the responding and regulatory properties of DBMC and individual bone marrow cell subsets versus spleen cells in the presence or absence of pharmacologic immunosuppression.

RESULTS

In the absence of immunosuppressive drugs, the DBMC proliferated in MLC and in response to phytohemagglutinin, but to a lower magnitude than donor spleen cells. In CML assays, DBMC failed to function as cytotoxic cells. Removal of both CD3+ and CD34+ cells together (not just singly) had to occur for complete abrogation of the proliferative response of DBMC evoked in the presence of allogeneic stimulating cells. Testing several experimental variables using flow cytometric analysis led to the conclusion that when purified DBMC CD34+ cells were placed in coculture with irradiated allogeneic peripheral blood mononuclear cells, such CD34+ cells give rise both to CD3- TCRalphabeta+ as well as to dimly staining CD3+ TCRalphabeta+ cells. Low pharmacologic concentrations of tacrolimus/cyclosporine (CsA) and mycophenolic acid (MPA) singly or in combination had no effect on the spontaneous proliferation of DBMC and had significantly less inhibitory activity on MLC responses of DBMC and its purified CD3+ or CD34+ subpopulations, compared with the responses of spleen cells. Moreover, the previously described regulatory effects of DBMC on the MLC responses of peripheral blood or splenic responding cells were not inhibited by these immunosuppressive drugs.

CONCLUSIONS

Taken together, these results support the notion that in vitro DBMC subpopulations, which proliferate as responding cells in co-culture with x-irradiated allogeneic cells and which cause regulatory effects when added as a third component to MLC reactions, seem to be culture-generated lymphoid cell lineage(s) progeny of CD34+ cells. This possibly includes unique CD3+ "primitive" (dimly staining) T cells, which are not as inhibited in their function by tacrolimus/CsA and MPA, as are postthymic (splenic) T cells.

Immune cholangitis: liver allograft rejection and graft-versus-host disease

A pronounced similarity exists between liver allograft rejection and graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) in the damage and eventual destruction of small intrahepatic bile ducts. Although an immunologic reaction has an important role, precisely identifying the target antigens or reason for persistence of the immune response has been difficult. An important difference between GVHD and liver rejection is the development of obliterative arteriopathy only in rejection. The three main histopathologic features of acute rejection are a predominantly mononuclear but mixed portal inflammation, subendothelial inflammation of portal or terminal hepatic veins (or both), and bile duct inflammation and damage. In acute rejection, a controversial issue is determining when therapeutic intervention is needed. The recommended approach is to base treatment on a combination of histopathologic changes and liver injury or dysfunction. Chronic rejection, which usually does not occur before 2 months after transplantation, is characterized by two main histopathologic features: (1) damage and loss of small bile ducts and (2) obliterative arteriopathy. Acute GVHD begins within the first month after transplantation and most commonly involves the skin, gastrointestinal tract, and liver, whereas chronic GVHD usually develops more than 80 to 100 days after liver transplantation and affects 30 to 50% of long-term survivors. Recognition of the early, cellular stages of chronic GVHD is important in preventing irreversible damage.

Myoblast transplantation in non-dystrophic dog

Dog myoblasts obtained from muscle biopsies were infected in vitro with a defective retroviral vector containing a cytoplasmic beta-galactosidase (beta-Gal) gene. These myoblasts were initially transplanted in the irradiated muscles of SCID mice and beta-Gal positive muscle fibers were observed. beta-Gal myoblasts were also transplanted back either in the donor dogs (autotransplantation model) or in unrelated recipient dogs (allotransplantation model). Following these myoblast injections, a rapid inflammatory reaction developed within the muscle as indicated by an expression of P-selectin and of pro-inflammatory cytokine mRNAs (interleukin 6 (IL-6) and transforming growth factor beta (TGF-beta), and by a neutrophil infiltration. Following either auto- or allotransplantation in inadequately or non-immunosuppressed dogs, a specific immune reaction also developed within 2 weeks as indicated by the infiltration of CD4+ and of CD8+ lymphocytes, the increased expression of IL-10 and granzyme B mRNAs and the presence of antibodies reacting with the injected cells. Some dogs were immunosuppressed with several combinations of FK506, cyclosporine (CsA) and RS-61443. In dogs immunosuppressed with CsA combined with RS-61443, only a few myoblasts and myotubes expressing beta-Gal were observed 1-2 weeks after the transplantation, but no muscle fibers expressing beta-Gal were observed after 4 weeks, and antibodies against the injected cells were formed. In dogs immunosuppressed with FK506 alone, although no antibodies against the injected cells were produced, there were no small cells and no muscle fibers expressing beta-Gal 1 month after the transplantation. However, FK506 triggered diarrhea and vomiting in dogs. When the dogs were immunosuppressed with FK506 combined with CsA and RS-61443, muscle fibers expressing beta-Gal were present 4 weeks after the transplantation and no antibodies reacting with donor myoblasts were detected. These results indicate that the combination of three immunosuppressive agents (i.e., FK506, CsA and RS-61443) is effective in controlling the specific immune reactions following myoblast transplantation in dogs and they underline that the outcome of myoblast transplantation is dependent in part on an adequate immunosuppression. These results obtained here in normal dogs may justify myoblast transplantation in dystrophic dogs despite the side effects of FK506.

Defining the outcome of immunosuppression withdrawal after liver transplantation

Successful immunosuppression withdrawal should benefit the natural history of organ transplantation patients. To identify the clinical hazards of removing drug treatment and possible characteristics that predict a favorable outcome in long-term liver recipients, immunosuppression was withdrawn completely and the clinicopathological outcome documented in 18 liver recipients. Indication for transplantation, HLA matching, early rejection history, and presence of microchimerism were examined as predictors of outcome. Chimerism was determined by polymerase chain reaction-based examination for donor-specific HLA-DRB1 alleles and Y-gene-specific nucleotide sequences. At 3 years, 5 patients (28%) remained completely off immunosuppression; 12 patients (67%) experienced histological graft changes: acute rejection in 4, portal tract inflammation/hepatitis in 7, and necrosis in 1. Hepatitis B or C viral infections did not account for the nonrejection patterns. Unmasking of systemic disorders occurred. Chimerism, demonstrated in 7 patients (39%), with skin the optimal tissue, was not associated with tolerance. Parameters associated with successful drug withdrawal were transplantation for non-immune-mediated liver disorders, fewer donor-recipient HLA A, B, and DR mismatches, and a low incidence of early rejection. Immunosuppression withdrawal is a feasible option in a proportion of selected liver recipients, but identification of tolerant patients remains imprecise.

Mutual tolerance after liver and not after heart transplantation? Evaluation of patient-anti-donor and donor-anti-patient responses by mixed lymphocyte culture

The ultimate goal in organ transplantation is the induction of donor-specific transplantation tolerance. The fact that in some patients it is possible to withdraw immunosuppressive therapy completely, suggests that immunological adaptation or donor-specific nonresponsiveness can occur following transplantation. In earlier studies we have shown that after blood transfusion, the mixed lymphocyte reactivity of the donor against patient peripheral blood mononuclear lymphocytes taken after blood transfusion gradually decreased with time. This may reflect the induction of an immunoregulatory mechanism, which protects the recipient against an immune reaction of the donor, enhancing a state of mixed chimerism. A similar phenomenon might also play a role in the immunological mechanism leading to transplantation tolerance. Therefore, we studied responses in patients with a well-functioning liver and heart transplant using a primed lymphocyte test (PLT) and a mixed lymphocyte culture (MLC). Two years after liver transplantation the PLT and MLC responses of patient against donor were decreased significantly compared to the situation before transplantation. The response of donor against patient was also lower two years after transplantation. The decreased responses were donor-specific since responses to third-party cells generally remained unchanged. In heart transplant recipients we could not detect a donor-specific downregulation. The reversed response, of donor against patient, was not different from responses of third-party against patient cells. Therefore, we conclude that donor-specific nonresponsiveness is not induced in patients with well-functioning heart transplants. In contrast, after a successful liver transplantation the response of patient against donor is decreased, as is the reversed response. It may be valuable to test whether in liver transplant patients withdrawing or reducing of maintenance immunosuppression is permitted for patients who appear to have developed two-way donor-specific hyporeactivity.

Bronchiolitis obliterans: pathogenesis, prevention, and management

Increasing early success-post lung transplant has been tempered by the long-term development of histologic bronchiolitis obliterans (OB) or of the progressive airway obstruction which is called bronchiolitis obliterans syndrome (BOS). Multiple lines of evidence suggest that OB/BOS is due to an injury directed against the epithelial cells in the airways of the donor lung by the immune system of the recipient. Acute rejection is the strongest risk factor for the subsequent development of this process. Efforts to prevent or minimize acute rejection may reduce the prevalence of OB/BOS. Results of treatment with augmented immunosuppression have been disappointing but the treatment of complicating infections in the allograft can be beneficial. Multicenter studies are needed to assess the efficacy of new immunosuppressive agents in preventing or treating OB/BOS.

Donor bone marrow potentiates the effect of tacrolimus on nonvascularized heart allograft survival: association with microchimerism and growth of donor dendritic cell progenitors from recipient bone marrow

BACKGROUND

The influence of donor hematopoietic cell microchimerism on organ allograft survival has been studied largely in vascularized transplant models. Here, we examine the impact of donor bone marrow (BM) cells administered intravenously together with transient systemic tacrolimus therapy on microchimerism, the survival of nonvascularized cardiac allografts, and growth of donor antigen-presenting cells [dendritic cells (DCs)] from recipient BM.

METHODS

Adult male C3H (H2k) mice received heterotopic heart transplants from B10 (H2b) donors in the dorsal ear pinna. They were given no further treatment, or either a short course of tacrolimus (FK506; 2 mg/kg i.p. from day 0 to day 13), unmodified donor BM cells (50x10(6) i.v. on day 0) or both treatments. Grafts were examined daily for contractile activity. Anti-donor cytotoxic T lymphocyte responses were determined in recipients' spleens. Microchimerism (IAb+ cells) was demonstrated by immunocytochemical staining of spleens, and of cells expanded from recipient BM using cytokines and culture conditions that promote the growth of DCs.

RESULTS

Tacrolimus alone significantly prolonged median heart graft survival time from 10 to 22 days (P<0.001). BM alone failed to prolong graft survival. By contrast, tacrolimus + donor BM resulted in a mean survival time of 42 days (P<0.01 compared with tacrolimus treatment alone). This marked increase in heart allograft survival was associated with reduced anti-donor cytotoxic T lymphocyte responses attributable to a nonspecific effect of tacrolimus. In addition, however, a link was observed between the beneficial effect of donor BM and comparatively large numbers of donor major histocompatibility complex class II (IAb+)-positive cells in recipients' spleens, and in cultures of granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor + interleukin-4-stimulated DCs from recipients' BM. No donor-derived cells were propagated from heart graft recipients given either tacrolimus or donor BM alone.

CONCLUSIONS

This nonvascularized organ transplant model demonstrates the positive effect on allograft survival of donor BM given at the time of transplant to transiently immunosuppressed recipients. The findings also reveal links between hematopoietic cell chimerism, the presence of donor DC progenitors in recipient BM, and organ allograft survival.

Current status of intestinal transplantation in children

PURPOSE

A clinical trial of intestinal transplantation (Itx) under tacrolimus and prednisone immunosuppression was initiated in June 1990 in children with irreversible intestinal failure and who were dependent on total parenteral nutrition (TPN).

METHODS

Fifty-five patients (28 girls, 27 boys) with a median age of 3.2 years (range, 0.5 to 18 years) received 58 intestinal transplants that included isolated small bowel (SB) (n = 17), liver SB (LSB) (n=33), and multivisceral (MV) (n=8) allografts. Nine patients also received bone marrow infusion, and there were 20 colonic allografts. Azathioprine, cyclophosphamide, or mycophenolate mofetil were used in different phases of the series. Indications for Itx included: gastroschisis (n=14), volvulus (n=13), necrotizing enterocolitis (n=6), intestinal atresia (n=8), chronic intestinal pseudoobstruction (n=5), Hirschsprung's disease (n=4), microvillus inclusion disease (n=3), multiple polyposis (n=1), and trauma [n=1).

RESULTS

Currently, 30 patients are alive (patient survival, 55%; graft survival, 52%). Twenty-nine children with functioning grafts are living at home and off TPN, with a mean follow-up of 962 (range, 75 to 2,424) days. Immunologic complications have included liver allograft rejection (n=18), intestinal allograft rejection (n=52), posttransplant lymphoproliferative disease (n=16), cytomegalovirus (n=16) and graft-versus-host disease (n=4). A combination of associated complications included intestinal perforation (n=4), biliary leak (n=3), bile duct stenosis (n=1), intestinal leak (n=6), dehiscence with evisceration (n=4), hepatic artery thrombosis (n=3), bleeding (n=9), portal vein stenosis (n=1), intraabdominal abscess (n=11), and chylous ascites (n=4). Graft loss occurred as a result of rejection (n=8), infection (n=12), technical complications (n=8), and complications of TPN after graft removal (n=3). There were four retransplants (SB, n=1; LSB n=3).

CONCLUSIONS

Intestinal transplantation is a valid therapeutic option for patients with intestinal failure suffering complications of TPN. The complex clinical and immunologic course of these patients is reflected in a higher complication rate as well as patient and graft loss than seen after heart, liver, and kidney transplantation, although better than after lung transplantation.

Blockade of the CD40-CD40 ligand pathway potentiates the capacity of donor-derived dendritic cell progenitors to induce long-term cardiac allograft survival

BACKGROUND

Failure of costimulatory molecule-deficient donor dendritic cells (DCs) to induce indefinite allograft acceptance may be a result of the 'late" up-regulation of these molecules on the DCs after interaction with host T cells. Ligation of CD40 on antigen-presenting cells by its cognate ligand CD40L is thought to induce expression of CD80 (B7-1) and CD86 (B7-2). We examined the influence of anti-CD40L monoclonal antibody (mAb) on the capacity of donor-derived DC progenitors to induce long-term allograft survival.

METHODS

High purity DC progenitors were grown from B10 (H2b) mouse bone marrow in granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor and transforming growth factor beta1 (TGFbeta1). Mature DC were propagated in granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor and interleukin-4. Their phenotype was characterized by flow cytometric analysis and their function by mixed leukocyte reactivity. Anti-donor cytotoxic T lymphocyte activity in grafts and spleens of vascularized heart allograft recipients was also assessed.

RESULTS

The TGFbeta3-cultured cells were (1) DEC 205-positive, MHC class II-positive, CD80dim, CD86dim, and CD40dim, (2) poor stimulators of naive allogeneic T-cell proliferation, and (3) able to prolong significantly B10 cardiac allograft survival in C3H (H2k) recipients when given (2 x 10[6] i.v.) 7 days before organ transplantation (median survival time [MST] 26 days vs. 12 days in controls, and 5 days in interleukin-4 DC-treated animals). Their allostimulatory activity was further diminished by addition of anti-CD40L mAb at the start of the mixed leukocyte cultures. Anti-CD40L mAb alone (250 microg/mouse, i.p.; day -7) did not prolong cardiac graft survival (MST 12 days). In contrast, TGFbeta-cultured DCs + anti-CD40L mAb extended graft survival to a MST of 77 days, and inhibited substantially the anti-donor cytotoxic T lymphocyte activity of graft-infiltrating cells and host spleen cells assessed 8 days after transplant.

CONCLUSIONS

The CD40-CD40L pathway appears important in regulation of allogeneic DC-T-cell functional interaction in vivo; its blockade increases markedly the potential of costimulatory molecule-deficient DCs of donor origin to induce long-lasting allograft survival.

Evidence for engraftment of human bone marrow cells in non-lethally irradiated baboons

BACKGROUND

Prior to organ harvesting, an attempt was made to modulate the donor's immune responses against prospective xenogeneic recipients by infusion of "recipient-type" bone marrow.

METHODS

For this purpose, baboons conditioned with total lymphoid irradiation were given 6 x 10(8) unmodified human bone marrow cells/kg body weight with no subsequent treatment.

RESULTS

Animals survived until they were euthanized at 18 months. Using primers specific for human chorionic gonadotrophin gene, the presence of human DNA was confirmed by polymerase chain reaction in the blood of one animal for up to 18 months after cell transplantation; in the other animal, xenogeneic chimerism became undetectable in the blood at 6 months after bone marrow infusion. However, tissue samples obtained from both animals at the time they were euthanized had evidence of donor (human) DNA. Additionally, the presence of donor DNA in individually harvested colonies of erythroid and myeloid lineages suggested that infused human bone marrow cells had engrafted across the xenogeneic barrier in both baboons.

CONCLUSIONS

Bone marrow transplantation from human to baboon leads to establishment of chimerism and modulation of donor-specific immune reactivity, which suggests that this strategy could be reproducibly employed to create "surrogate" tolerogenesis in prospective donors for subsequent organ transplantation across xenogeneic barriers.