Pain processing during three levels of noxious stimulation produces differential patterns of central activity

An fMRI study of the anterior cingulate cortex and surrounding medial wall activations evoked by noxious cutaneous heat and cold stimuli

The anterior cingulate cortex (ACC) and adjacent regions in the medial wall have been implicated in sensory, motor and cognitive processes, including pain. Our previous functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) studies have demonstrated pain-related activation of the posterior portion of the ACC during transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) and variable patterns of cortical activation with innocuous and noxious thermal stimuli in individual subjects. The present study represents the companion paper to our recent study of pain- and thermal-related cortical activations with the aim to use fMRI to delineate the activations in the ACC and surrounding regions of the medial wall during application of innocuous and noxious thermal stimuli as well as during performance of a motor task in individual subjects. Ten normal subjects were imaged on a conventional 1.5 T GE 'echospeed' system. Functional images were obtained from sagittal sections through each hemisphere centered at approximately 3-5 and 7-9 mm from midline. Each subject was imaged during innocuous (cool, warm) and noxious thermal (cold, hot) stimulation of the thenar eminence, and execution of a motor (sequential finger-thumb opposition) task. Task-related activations were mostly confined to contralateral and medial ipsilateral images. Although the present results demonstrate intersubject variability in the task-related activations, some general modality-specific patterns were apparent: (i) innocuous thermal-related activations were located mainly in the anterior ACC; (ii) noxious thermal-related activations were primarily located in the anterior ACC, the ventral portion of the posterior ACC, and the supplementary motor area (SMA); (iii) motor-related activations were primarily located in the SMA and dorsal portion of the posterior ACC. These results indicate that specific spatial patterns of activation exist within the ACC and surrounding regions of the medial wall for innocuous and noxious thermal stimuli, and that noxious thermal- and motor-related activations appear to be segregated within the ACC. Therefore, we propose a segregation of the ACC into an anterior non-specific attention/arousal system and a posterior pain system.

Cerebral blood-flow changes evoked by two levels of painful heat stimulation: a positron emission tomography study in humans

Positron emission tomography (PET) and accumulation of H(2)(15)O as a marker of neuronal activity were used to create maps of cerebral blood-flow changes evoked by painful heat stimulation in 10 subjects. Two levels of painful tonic and phasic heat stimuli were applied with use of a newly developed contact heat thermode on the volar surface of the dominant (right) arm. The subjects participated in two separate PET sessions. Maps reflecting low and high levels of painful tonic heat were obtained in the first session, and low and high levels of painful phasic heat in the second session. The subjects scored their peak pain intensity and unpleasantness on 10-cm visual analogue scales. For each subject, PET images were aligned to nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) images and remapped into the standardized co-ordinate system of Talairach. After normalization of the PET volumes, subtraction images were formed voxel-by-voxel and converted to a t-statistic volume. The perceived pain intensity and unpleasantness were identical with painful tonic and phasic heat stimulation. Directed searches revealed significant blood-flow increases in the contralateral primary sensorimotor cortex (MI/SI), SII, insular cortex and cingulate cortex when the low tonic heat map was subtracted from the high. A similar, but not identical, pain-processing network was observed for the maps representing the subtraction of low and high phasic heat. In this subtraction, the blood-flow increases in MSI/SI did not reach statistical significance, and significant blood flow decreases were found in the contralateral middle temporal gyrus. Finally, the location of the activation site in the cingulate cortex was different from that observed during tonic heat pain. This study has provided more evidence for the existence of a common pain-processing network engaged during the perception of different levels of toxic and phasic heat pain. Copyright 1998 European Federation of Chapters of the International Association for the Study of Pain.

Pain-related cerebral activation is altered by a distracting cognitive task

It has previously been suggested that the activity in sensory regions of the brain can be modulated by attentional mechanisms during parallel cognitive processing. To investigate whether such attention-related modulations are present in the processing of pain, the regional cerebral blood flow was measured using [(15)O]butanol and positron emission tomography in conditions involving both pain and parallel cognitive demands. The painful stimulus consisted of the standard cold pressor test and the cognitive task was a computerised perceptual maze test. The activations during the maze test reproduced findings in previous studies of the same cognitive task. The cold pressor test evoked significant activity in the contralateral S1, and bilaterally in the somatosensory association areas (including S2), the ACC and the mid-insula. The activity in the somatosensory association areas and periaqueductal gray/midbrain were significantly modified, i.e. relatively decreased, when the subjects also were performing the maze task. The altered activity was accompanied with significantly lower ratings of pain during the cognitive task. In contrast, lateral orbitofrontal regions showed a relative increase of activity during pain combined with the maze task as compared to only pain, which suggests the possibility of the involvement of frontal cortex in modulation of regions processing pain.

Limbically Augmented Pain Syndrome (LAPS): Kindling, Corticolimbic Sensitization, and the Convergence of Affective and Sensory Symptoms in Chronic Pain Disorders

There is abundant clinical evidence that depression occurs with high frequency among chronic pain patients. When compared with other serious medical disorders, the prevalence of depression in chronic pain appears high. The fundamental reason for this association is unknown. Theories have attempted to explain the link between pain and depression in terms of psychologic mechanisms. Other theories highlight shared neurobiologic substrates. However, a comprehensive theory integrating biologic and psychologic viewpoints remains elusive. In this article, we draw on research on neuroplastic processes in corticolimbic structures to model the linkage between the sensory and affective domains of pain. Our hypothesis is based on kindling experiments in animals that elucidate the complex neurobiologic mechanisms that transduce exteroceptive and interoceptive stimuli into "memory" at the cellular/synaptic level. This experimental model has found application in the affective disorders to explain how a person's history of exposure to psychologic trauma configures the neurobiologic substrate for later-amplified pathologic response. In applying kindling research to pain, we begin by reviewing the literature on nociception-induced neuroplasticity at the corticolimbic level. We suggest that kindling and related models of neuroplasticity can be used to describe ways in which exposure to a noxious stimulus may, under certain conditions, lead to a sensitized corticolimbic state. This sensitized state can be described in terms of the kindling properties of amplification, spontaneity, neuroanatomic spreading, and cross-sensitization. A case example illustrates how these properties offer a neurobiologic framework for understanding the sensory/affective/behavioral symptom complex seen in a subset of chronic pain patients. These patients are characterized by atypical and treatment-refractory pain complaints, in association with disturbances of mood, sleep, energy, libido, memory/concentration, behavior, and stress intolerance. We introduce the term "limbically augmented pain syndrome" to describe this symptom complex.

Effects of distraction on pain-related somatosensory evoked magnetic fields and potentials following painful electrical stimulation

We aimed to compare the effects of distraction on pain-related somatosensory evoked magnetic fields (pain SEF) following painful electrical stimulation with simultaneous recordings of evoked potentials (pain SEP). Painful electrical stimuli were applied to the right index finger of eleven healthy subjects. A table with 25 random two-digit numbers was shown to the subjects, who were asked to add 5 numbers of each line in their mind (calculation task) or to memorize the numbers (memorization task) during the recording. In the SEF recording, 3 short-latency components within 50 ms of the stimulation were generated in the primary sensory cortex (SI) of the hemisphere contralateral to the stimulated finger. Middle-latency components between 100 and 250 ms after the stimuli were recorded from the secondary somatosensory cortex (SII) in the bilateral hemispheres or the cingulate cortex. No SEF components were significantly affected by either task. In the SEP recording, the middle-latency components (N140 and P230) were identified as being maximal around the vertex. Amplitudes of the N140 and P230 were not affected by each task, but the peak-to-peak amplitude (N140-P230) was significantly decreased by both the calculation and memorization tasks, particularly by the former. Subjective pain rating was decreased in both the calculation and memorization tasks, particularly in the former. We concluded that distraction tasks reduced activities in the limbic system, in which the middle-latency EEG component probably generated, while neither the short-latency SEF components generated in SI nor the primary pain-related SEF components generated in SII-insula are affected.

Lateralized and widespread brain activation during transient blood pressure elevation revealed by magnetic resonance imaging

The location and possible lateralization of structures mediating autonomic processing are not well-described in the human. Functional magnetic resonance imaging procedures were used to demonstrate signal changes in multiple brain sites during blood pressure challenges. Magnetic resonance signals in brain tissue were visualized with a 1.5 Tesla scanner in 11 healthy volunteers (22-37 years), by using echo-planar procedures. Images were collected during baseline states and three pressor challenges: cold application to the hand or forehead, and a Valsalva maneuver. Image values from experimental conditions were compared with corresponding baseline values on a voxel-by-voxel basis to identify brain regions responsive to physiologic activation. Probability maps (P < 0.01) of voxel changes, with Bonferroni corrections for multiple comparisons, were determined, and amplitude of signal changes associated with significance maps were pseudocolored and overlaid on anatomic images. The time courses and extent of signal alterations in defined unilateral regions were followed and compared with changes in corresponding regions on the contralateral side. Pressor challenges elicited significant regional signal intensity changes within the orbitomedial prefrontal cortex, temporal cortex, amygdala, hippocampal formation, thalamus, and hypothalamus. Cerebellar, midbrain, and pontine areas were also recruited. Signal changes, especially at forebrain sites, were often highly lateralized. The findings indicate that (1) transient, behaviorally-coupled cardiovascular challenges elicit discrete activity changes over multiple brain sites, and (2) these activity changes, especially in specific prefrontal and temporal forebrain regions and cerebellum, are often expressed unilaterally, even to a bilateral challenge.

Activation of the anterior cingulate cortex by thalamic stimulation in patients with chronic pain: a positron emission tomography study

Object

Deep brain stimulation (DBS) of the sensory thalamus has been used to treat chronic, intractable pain. The goal of this study was to investigate the thalamocortical pathways activated during thalamic DBS.

Methods

The authors compared positron emission tomography (PET) images obtained before, during, and after DBS in five patients with chronic pain. Two of the five patients reported significant DBS-induced pain relief during PET scanning, and the remaining three patients did not report any analgesic effect of DBS during scanning. The most robust effect associated with DBS was activation of the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC). An anterior ACC activation was sustained throughout the 40 minutes of DBS, whereas a more posteriorly located ACC activation occurred at a delay after onset of DBS, although these activations were not dependent on the degree of pain relief reported during DBS. However, implications specific to the analgesic effect of DBS require further study of a larger, more homogeneous patient population. Additional effects of thalamic DBS were detected in motor-related regions (the globus pallidus, cortical area 4, and the cerebellum) and visual and association cortical areas.

Conclusions

The authors demonstrate that the ACC is activated during thalamic DBS in patients with chronic pain.

Pain perception and response: central nervous system mechanisms

Although several decades of studies have detailed peripheral and ascending nociceptive pathways to the thalamus and cerebral cortex, pain is a symptom that has remained difficult to characterize anatomically and physiologically. Positron emission tomography (PET) and functional magnetic imaging (fMRI) have recently demonstrated a number of cerebral and brain stem loci responding to cutaneous noxious stimuli. However, intersubject variability, both in the frequency and increased or decreased intensity of the responses, has caused uncertainty as to their significance. Nevertheless, the large number of available imaging studies have shown that many areas with recognized functions are frequently affected by painful stimuli. With this evidence and recent developments in tracing central nervous system connections between areas responding to noxious stimuli, it is possible to identify nociceptive pathways that are within, or contribute to, afferent spino-thalamo-cortical sensory and efferent skeletomotor and autonomic motor systems. In this study it is proposed that cortical and nuclear mechanisms for pain perception and response are hierarchically arranged with the prefrontal cortex at its highest level. Nevertheless, all components make particular contributions without which certain nociceptive failures can occur, as in pathological pain arising in some cases of nervous system injury.

Primary somatosensory cortex is actively involved in pain processing in human

We recorded somatosensory evoked magnetic fields (SEFs) by a whole head magnetometer to elucidate cortical receptive areas involved in pain processing, focusing on the primary somatosensory cortex (SI), following painful CO(2) laser stimulation of the dorsum of the left hand in 12 healthy human subjects. In seven subjects, three spatially segregated cortical areas (contralateral SI and bilateral second (SII) somatosensory cortices) were simultaneously activated at around 210 ms after the stimulus, suggesting parallel processing of pain information in SI and SII. Equivalent current dipole (ECD) in SI pointed anteriorly in three subjects whereas posteriorly in the remaining four. We also recorded SEFs following electric stimulation of the left median nerve at wrist in three subjects. ECD of CO(2) laser stimulation was located medial-superior to that of electric stimulation in all three subjects. In addition, by direct recording of somatosensory evoked potentials (SEPs) from peri-Rolandic cortex by subdural electrodes in an epilepsy patient, we identified a response to the laser stimulation over the contralateral SI with the peak latency of 220 ms. Its distribution was similar to, but slightly wider than, that of P25 of electric SEPs. Taken together, it is postulated that the pain impulse is received in the crown of the postcentral gyrus in human.

Parietal and cingulate processes in central pain. A combined positron emission tomography (PET) and functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) study of an unusual case

Parietal, insular and anterior cingulate cortices are involved in the processing of noxious inputs and genesis of pain sensation. Parietal lesions may generate central pain by mechanisms generally assumed to involve the 'medial' pain system (i.e. medial thalamic nuclei and anterior cingulate cortex (ACC)). We report here PET and fMRI data in a patient who developed central pain and allodynia in her left side after a bifocal infarct involving both the right parietal cortex (SI and SII) and the right ACC (Brodmann areas 24 and 32), thus questioning the schematic representation of cortical pain processing. No rCBF increase was found in any part of the residual cingulate cortices, neither in the basal state (which included spontaneous pain and extended hypoperfusion around the infarct), nor during left allodynic pain. Thus, as previously observed in patients with lateral medullary infarct, neither spontaneous pain nor allodynia reproduce the cingulate activation observed after noxious pain in normal subjects. Conversely, both PET and fMRI data argue in favour of plastic changes in the 'lateral discriminative' pain system. Particularly, allodynia was associated with increased activity anteriorly to the infarct in the right insula/SII cortex. This response is likely to be responsible for the strange and very unpleasant allodynic sensation elicited on the left side by a non-noxious stimulation.

Activation of the anterior cingulate cortex by thalamic stimulation in patients with chronic pain: a positron emission tomography study

OBJECT

Deep brain stimulation (DBS) of the sensory thalamus has been used to treat chronic, intractable pain. The goal of this study was to investigate the thalamocortical pathways activated during thalamic DBS.

METHODS

The authors compared positron emission tomography (PET) images obtained before, during, and after DBS in five patients with chronic pain. Two of the five patients reported significant DBS-induced pain relief during PET scanning, and the remaining three patients did not report any analgesic effect of DBS during scanning. The most robust effect associated with DBS was activation of the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC). An anterior ACC activation was sustained throughout the 40 minutes of DBS, whereas a more posteriorly located ACC activation occurred at a delay after onset of DBS, although these activations were not dependent on the degree of pain relief reported during DBS. However, implications specific to the analgesic effect of DBS require further study of a larger, more homogeneous patient population. Additional effects of thalamic DBS were detected in motor-related regions (the globus pallidus, cortical area 4, and the cerebellum) and visual and association cortical areas.

CONCLUSIONS

The authors demonstrate that the ACC is activated during thalamic DBS in patients with chronic pain.

Ascending projections from the area around the spinal cord central canal: A Phaseolus vulgaris leucoagglutinin study in rats

A single small iontophoretic injection of Phaseolus vulgaris leucoagglutinin labels projections from the area surrounding the spinal cord central canal at midthoracic (T6-T9) or lumbosacral (L6-S1) segments of the spinal cord. The projections from the midthoracic or lumbosacral level of the medial spinal cord are found: 1) ascending ipsilaterally in the dorsal column near the dorsal intermediate septum or the midline of the gracile fasciculus, respectively; 2) terminating primarily in the dorsal, lateral rim of the gracile nucleus and the medial rim of the cuneate nucleus or the dorsomedial rim of the gracile nucleus, respectively; and 3) ascending bilaterally with slight contralateral predominance in the ventrolateral quadrant of the spinal cord and terminating in the ventral and medial medullary reticular formation. Other less dense projections are to the pons, midbrain, thalamus, hypothalamus, and other forebrain structures. Projections arising from the lumbosacral level are also found in Barrington's nucleus. The results of the present study support previous retrograde tract tracing and physiological studies from our group demonstrating that the neurons in the area adjacent to the central canal of the midthoracic or lumbosacral level of the spinal cord send long ascending projections to the dorsal column nucleus that are important in the transmission of second-order afferent information for visceral nociception. Thus, the axonal projections through both the dorsal and the ventrolateral white matter from the CC region terminate in many regions of the brain providing spinal input for sensory integration, autonomic regulation, motor and emotional responses, and limbic activation.

A PET activation study of dynamic mechanical allodynia in patients with mononeuropathy

The objective of this study was to investigate the central processing of dynamic mechanical allodynia in patients with mononeuropathy. Regional cerebral blood flow, as an indicator of neuronal activity, was measured with positron emission tomography. Paired comparisons were made between three different states; rest, allodynia during brushing the painful skin area, and brushing of the homologous contralateral area. Bilateral activations were observed in the primary somatosensory cortex (S1) and the secondary somatosensory cortex (S2) during allodynia compared to rest. The S1 activation contralateral to the site of the stimulus was more expressed during allodynia than during innocuous touch. Significant activations of the contralateral posterior parietal cortex, the periaqueductal gray (PAG), the thalamus bilaterally and motor areas were also observed in the allodynic state compared to both non-allodynic states. In the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC) there was only a suggested activation when the allodynic state was compared with the non-allodynic states. In order to account for the individual variability in the intensity of allodynia and ongoing spontaneous pain, rCBF was regressed on the individually reported pain intensity, and significant covariations were observed in the ACC and the right anterior insula. Significantly decreased regional blood flow was observed bilaterally in the medial and lateral temporal lobe as well as in the occipital and posterior cingulate cortices when the allodynic state was compared to the non-painful conditions. This finding is consistent with previous studies suggesting attentional modulation and a central coping strategy for known and expected painful stimuli. Involvement of the medial pain system has previously been reported in patients with mononeuropathy during ongoing spontaneous pain. This study reveals a bilateral activation of the lateral pain system as well as involvement of the medial pain system during dynamic mechanical allodynia in patients with mononeuropathy.

Functional magnetic resonance imaging in spontaneous attacks of SUNCT: short-lasting neuralgiform headache with conjunctival injection and tearing

A 71-year-old woman presented with a short history of episodes of severe left-sided orbital and temporal pain in paroxysms lasting 60 to 90 seconds, and accompanied by ipsilateral lacrimation of the eye, rhinorrhea, and conjunctival injection. Results of clinical examination and structural imaging were normal and a clinical diagnosis of SUNCT (short-lasting unilateral neuralgiform pains with conjunctival injection and tearing) was made. The patient had a BOLD contrast-magnetic resonance imaging study in which significant activation was seen in the region of the ipsilateral hypothalamic gray, comparing the pain to pain-free state. The region of activation was the same in this patient as has been reported in acute attacks of cluster headache.

Ventromedial thalamic neurons convey nociceptive signals from the whole body surface to the dorsolateral neocortex

The somatosensory properties of ventromedial (VM) thalamic neurons were investigated in anesthetized rats by examining their responses to calibrated cutaneous stimuli. A population of neurons within the lateral part of the ventromedial thalamus (VMl) showed two peaks of activation after percutaneous electrical stimuli, regardless of which part of the body was stimulated. The early and late peaks were elicited by Adelta- and C-fiber activities with mean conduction velocities of 12.9 +/- 0.9 and 1 +/- 0.2 m/sec, respectively. These responses were strongly depressed or blocked after microinjections within the medullary subnucleus reticularis dorsalis of xylocaine or the NMDA antagonist MK-801. None of the VMl neurons responded to innocuous cutaneous or proprioceptive stimuli. In contrast, all these neurons responded to noxious mechanical and thermal stimulation of the limbs and showed monotonic increases in their discharges to increasingly strong noxious cutaneous stimuli. In addition, some VMl neurons were antidromically activated by stimulation in layer I of the dorsolateral frontal cortex. These findings suggest that the rat VMl conveys and encodes cutaneous nociceptive inputs from any part of the body surface to layer I of the dorsolateral neocortex. This reticulo-thalamo-cortical network may allow any signal of pain to gain access to widespread areas of the neocortex and thus help prime the cortex for attentional reactions and/or the coordination of motor responses.

A comparative fMRI study of cortical representations for thermal painful, vibrotactile, and motor performance tasks

Cortical activity due to a thermal painful stimulus applied to the right hand was studied in the middle third of the contralateral brain and compared to activations for vibrotactile and motor tasks using the same body part, in nine normal subjects. Cortical activity was demonstrated utilizing multislice echo-planar functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) and a surface coil. The cortical activity was analyzed based upon individual subject activity maps and on group-averaged activity maps. The results show significant differences in activations across the three tasks and the cortical areas studied. The study indicates that fMRI enables examination of cortical networks subserving pain perception at an anatomical detail not available with other brain imaging techniques and shows that this cortical network underlying pain perception shares components with the networks underlying touch perception and motor execution. However, the thermal pain perception network also has components that are unique to this perception. The uniquely activated areas were in the secondary somatosensory region, insula, and posterior cingulate cortex. The posterior cingulate cortex activity was in a region that, in the monkey, receives nociceptive inputs from posterior thalamic medial and lateral nuclei that in turn are targets for spinothalamic terminations. Discrete subdivisions of the primary somatosensory and motor cortical areas were also activated in the thermal pain task, showing region-dependent differences in the extent of overlap with the other two tasks. Within the primary motor cortex, a hand region was preferentially active in the task in which the stimulus was painful heat. In the primary somatosensory cortex most activity in the painful heat task was localized to area 1, where the motor and vibratory task activities were also coincident. The study also indicates that the functional connectivity across multiple cortical regions reorganizes dynamically with each task.

Perfusion weighted imaging during migraine: spontaneous visual aura and headache

Using perfusion weighted imaging, we studied 28 spontaneous migraine episodes; 7 during visual aura (n = 6), 7 during the headache phase following visual aura (n = 3), and 14 cases of migraine without aura (n = 13). The data were analyzed using a region-of-interest-based approach. During aura, relative cerebral blood flow (rCBF) was significantly decreased (27% +/- 0.07) in occipital cortex contralateral to the affected hemifield. rCBV was decreased (15% +/- 0.12) and mean transit time increased (32% +/- 0.3), persisting up to 2.5 h into the headache phase. Other brain regions did not show significant perfusion changes. During migraine without aura, no significant hemodynamic changes were observed. In one patient who experienced both migraine with and without aura, perfusion deficits were observed only during migraine with aura. These findings suggest that decremental blood flow changes in occipital lobe are most characteristic of migraine with aura.

Pain intensity processing within the human brain: a bilateral, distributed mechanism

Functional imaging studies of human subjects have identified a diverse assortment of brain areas that are engaged in the processing of pain. Although many of these brain areas are highly interconnected and are engaged in multiple processing roles, each area has been typically considered in isolation. Accordingly, little attention has been given to the global functional organization of brain mechanisms mediating pain processing. In the present investigation, we have combined positron emission tomography with psychophysical assessment of graded painful stimuli to better characterize the multiregional organization of supraspinal pain processing mechanisms and to identify a brain mechanism subserving the processing of pain intensity. Multiple regression analysis revealed statistically reliable relationships between perceived pain intensity and activation of a functionally diverse group of brain regions, including those important in sensation, motor control, affect, and attention. Pain intensity-related activation occurred bilaterally in the cerebellum, putamen, thalamus, insula, anterior cingulate cortex, and secondary somatosensory cortex, contralaterally in the primary somatosensory cortex and supplementary motor area, and ipsilaterally in the ventral premotor area. These results confirm the existence of a highly distributed, bilateral supraspinal mechanism engaged in the processing of pain intensity. The conservation of pain intensity information across multiple, functionally distinct brain areas contrasts sharply with traditional views that sensory-discriminative processing of pain is confined within the somatosensory cortex and can account for the preservation of conscious awareness of pain intensity after extensive cerebral cortical lesions.

Cerebral topography of rectal stimulation using single photon emission computed tomography

Central processing of visceral information in humans is incompletely understood. We aimed to demonstrate the feasibility of single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) and to quantitate the changes in regional cerebral blood flow during rectal distension. Ten healthy volunteers underwent randomized sham and active rectal distensions on separate days, during which cerebral blood flow was assessed by intravenous technetium-99m ethyl cysteinate dimer ((99m)Tc-ECD) SPECT. Three-dimensional coregistration of brain images was used to quantitate activation in four preselected cerebral foci and two control regions. Paired analysis compared blood flow during sham and active distensions. There was increased right anterior cingulate gyrus activity (6.5 +/- 2.9%, P = 0.03) with active rectal distension. A 5.4 +/- 2.4% reduction in blood flow in the superior parieto-occipital control region (P = 0.04) suggested blood "redistribution" during stimulation. Marked variability in activation of the frontal cortex, thalamus/basal ganglia complex, and mesiotemporal lobe was noted. Thus rectal distension increases activity in the right anterior cingulate gyrus on average; other foci of cerebral activation are quite variable, suggesting a lack of specific cerebral projections during rectal stimulation.

Haemodynamic brain responses to acute pain in humans: sensory and attentional networks

Turning attention towards or away from a painful heat stimulus is known to modify both the subjective intensity of pain and the cortical evoked potentials to noxious stimuli. Using PET, we investigated in 12 volunteers whether pain-related regional cerebral blood flow (rCBF) changes were also modulated by attention. High (mean 46.6 degrees C) or low (mean 39 degrees C) intensity thermal stimuli were applied to the hand under three attentional conditions: (i) attention directed towards the stimuli, (ii) attention diverted from the stimuli, and (iii) no task. Only the insular/second somatosensory cortices were found to respond whatever the attentional context and might, therefore, subserve the sensory-discriminative dimension of pain (intensity coding). In parallel, other rCBF changes previously described as 'pain-related' appeared to depend essentially on the attentional context. Attention to the thermal stimulus involved a large network which was primarily right-sided, including prefrontal, posterior parietal, anterior cingulate cortices and thalamus. Anterior cingulate activity was not found to pertain to the intensity coding network but rather to the attentional neural activity triggered by pain. The attentional network disclosed in this study could be further subdivided into a non-specific arousal component, involving thalamic and upper brainstem regions, and a selective attention and orientating component including prefrontal, posterior parietal and cingulate cortices. A further effect observed in response to high intensity stimuli was a rCBF decrease within the somatosensory cortex ipsilateral to stimulation, which was considered to reflect contrast enhancing and/or anticipation processes. Attentional processes could possibly explain part of the variability observed in previous PET reports and should therefore be considered in further studies on pain in both normal subjects and patients with chronic pain.

Magnetoencephalographic responses to painful impact stimulation

Magnetoencephalographic (MEG) field recordings are unique to detect current dipoles in SI and SII. Few devices are available for painful mechanical stimulation in magnetically shielded MEG rooms. The aim of the present MEG (dual 37-channel biomagnetometer) study was to investigate the location of the cortical generators evoked by painful impact stimuli of different intensities. An airgun was placed outside the shielded MEG room, and small plastic bullets were fired at the arm and trunk of the subjects in the room. The velocity of the bullet was measured and related to the evoked pain intensity. Stimuli were delivered for each of the following three conditions: strong pain intensity elicited from the upper arm and upper trunk; weak pain intensity elicited from the upper trunk. The evoked MEG responses had a major component with the characteristically polarity-reversal deflections indicating a dipole located beneath the coils. The response could be estimated by a single current dipole. When the estimated locations of the dipoles were superimposed on the individual magnetic resonance images (MRIs), consistent bilateral activation of areas corresponding to the secondary sensory cortices (SII) was found.

Forebrain mechanisms of nociception and pain: analysis through imaging

Pain is a unified experience composed of interacting discriminative, affective-motivational, and cognitive components, each of which is mediated and modulated through forebrain mechanisms acting at spinal, brainstem, and cerebral levels. The size of the human forebrain in relation to the spinal cord gives anatomical emphasis to forebrain control over nociceptive processing. Human forebrain pathology can cause pain without the activation of nociceptors. Functional imaging of the normal human brain with positron emission tomography (PET) shows synaptically induced increases in regional cerebral blood flow (rCBF) in several regions specifically during pain. We have examined the variables of gender, type of noxious stimulus, and the origin of nociceptive input as potential determinants of the pattern and intensity of rCBF responses. The structures most consistently activated across genders and during contact heat pain, cold pain, cutaneous laser pain or intramuscular pain were the contralateral insula and anterior cingulate cortex, the bilateral thalamus and premotor cortex, and the cerebellar vermis. These regions are commonly activated in PET studies of pain conducted by other investigators, and the intensity of the brain rCBF response correlates parametrically with perceived pain intensity. To complement the human studies, we developed an animal model for investigating stimulus-induced rCBF responses in the rat. In accord with behavioral measures and the results of human PET, there is a progressive and selective activation of somatosensory and limbic system structures in the brain and brainstem following the subcutaneous injection of formalin. The animal model and human PET studies should be mutually reinforcing and thus facilitate progress in understanding forebrain mechanisms of normal and pathological pain.

Central nervous pathway for acupuncture stimulation: localization of processing with functional MR imaging of the brain--preliminary experience

PURPOSE

To characterize the central nervous system (CNS) pathway for acupuncture stimulation in the human brain by using functional magnetic resonance (MR) imaging.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Functional MR imaging of the whole brain was performed in two groups of nine healthy subjects during four stimulation paradigms: real acupuncture at acupoints ST.36 (on the leg) and LI.4 (on the hand) and control stimulations (minimal acupuncture and superficial pricking on the leg). Stimulations were performed in semirandomized, balanced order nested within two experiments. Psychophysical responses (pain, De-Qi effect [characteristic acupuncture effect of needle-manipulation sensation], anxiety, and unpleasantness) and autonomic responses were assessed. Talairach coordinates-transformed imaging data were averaged for a group analysis.

RESULTS

Acupuncture at LI.4 and ST.36 resulted in significantly higher scores for De-Qi and in substantial bradycardia. Acupuncture at both acupoints resulted in activation of the hypothalamus and nucleus accumbens and deactivation of the rostral part of the anterior cingulate cortex, amygdala formation, and hippocampal complex; control stimulations did not result in such activations and deactivations.

CONCLUSION

Functional MR imaging can demonstrate the CNS pathway for acupuncture stimulation. Acupuncture at ST.36 and LI.4 activates structures of descending antinociceptive pathway and deactivates multiple limbic areas subserving pain association. These findings may shed light on the CNS mechanism of acupuncture analgesia and form a basis for future investigations of endogenous pain modulation circuits in the human brain.

Pain

Advances in our understanding of the activation of peripheral damage-sensing neurons (nociceptors) over the past year have been complemented by electrophysiological and imaging studies of central nervous system pain-related centres. The manipulation of gene expression in a reversible and cell type specific way combined with imaging and electrophysiological studies holds promise for helping us to identify the spatial and molecular substrates of pain perception with increasing precision and gives hope for improved analgesic therapies.

Cerebral responses to pain in patients suffering acute post-dental extraction pain measured by positron emission tomography (PET)

Previous studies with normal volunteers have demonstrated distributed cortical responses to experimental heat pain within a network of structures. The network includes the insula, anterior cingulate, prefrontal, inferior parietal and somatosensory cortices. Patients suffering from chronic nociceptive pain following rheumatoid arthritis (RA) have shown damped central responses to experimental heat pain applied to the back of the right hand. In this study of patients with acute, left-sided, post-molar-extraction (surgical) pain, we assessed the cortical responses to experimental heat pain, applied to the back of the right hand, using positron emission tomography (PET), and compared the responses with a previously reported control group and the RA group. In response to the experimental heat pain, the surgical group indicated significantly increased regional cerebral blood flow in the prefrontal cortex [Brodman's area (BA) 44] ipsilateral to the heat stimulus. Contralateral increases were detected in the putamen and transverse temporal gyrus (BA 40/41/42) with bilateral increases in the insular cortex. Compared to the control and RA group, there were significantly reduced responses in the anterior cingulate (BA 24), pre-frontal medial, and orbito-frontal (BA 9/10/32/47) cortices. These results suggest that relatively discrete regions of the cerebral cortex are responsible for acute nociceptive processing during an acute inflammatory episode. The reduced frontal and anterior cingulate responses to the experimental heat pain (applied to the right hand) during acute inflammatory pain (left jaw) illustrates cortical modulation of nociceptive processing that may be related to non-somatotopic, bilateral, nociceptive inputs to these areas. Copyright 1999 European Federation of Chapters of the International Association for the Study of Pain.

The neurobiology of pain

Understanding the plasticity of pain and analgesia exhibited in different pain states may improve therapies for the two major types of pain, neuropathic and inflammatory pain, in which nerve and tissue damage leads to alterations at both peripheral and central levels. At the level of the peripheral nerve, drugs that act on particular sodium channels may target only pain-related activity. Agents that act on some of the peripheral mediators of pain may control peripheral nerve activity. A new generation of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, cyclo-oxygenase 2 inhibitors, that lack gastric actions are becoming available. In the spinal cord, the release of peptides and glutamate causes activation of multiple receptors, particularly, the N-methyl-D-aspartate receptor for glutamate, which, in concert with other spinal systems, generates spinal hypersensitivity. Blocking the generation of excitability is one approach, but increasing inhibitions may also provide analgesia. Opioid actions are via presynaptic and post-synaptic inhibitory effects on central and peripheral C fibre terminals, spinal neurones, and supraspinal mechanisms. Our knowledge of brain mechanisms of pain is still, however, limited. Other new targets have been revealed by molecular biology and animal models of clinical pain, but the possibility of a "magic bullet" is doubtful. Thus, another approach could be single molecules with dual drug actions, that encompass targets where additive or synergistic effects of different mechanisms may enable pain relief without major adverse effects.

Mechanisms of cardiac pain

Angina pectoris often results from ischemic episodes that excite chemosensitive and mechanoreceptive receptors in the heart. Ischemic episodes release a collage of chemicals, including adenosine and bradykinin, that excites the receptors of the sympathetic and vagal afferent pathways. Sympathetic afferent fibers from the heart enter the upper thoracic spinal cord and synapse on cells of origin of ascending pathways. This review focuses on the spinothalamic tract, but other pathways are excited as well. Excitation of spinothalamic tract cells in the upper thoracic and lower cervical segments, except C7 and C8 segments, contributes to the anginal pain experienced in the chest and arm. Cardiac vagal afferent fibers synapse in the nucleus tractus solitarius of the medulla and then descend to excite upper cervical spinothalamic tract cells. This innervation contributes to the anginal pain experienced in the neck and jaw. The spinothalamic tract projects to the medial and lateral thalamus and, based on positron emission tomography studies, activates several cortical areas, including the anterior cingulate gyrus (BA 24 and 25), the lateral basal frontal cortex, and the mesiofrontal cortex.

Resolution of central pain after embolization of an arteriovenous malformation. Case report

The authors describe a patient with right-sided central pain resulting from a left parietal arteriovenous malformation (AVM). The AVM was treated with staged embolization and stereotactic radiosurgery, and its obliteration was documented on follow-up angiographic studies. Surprisingly, the patient noted complete resolution of her pain syndrome after embolization, which is an extremely rare result. Central pain and its proposed mechanisms are discussed.

Pain pathways involved in fear conditioning measured with fear-potentiated startle: lesion studies

It is well established that the basolateral amygdala is critically involved in the association between an unconditioned stimulus (US), such as a foot shock, and a conditioned stimulus (CS), such as a light, during classic fear conditioning. However, little is known about how the US (pain) inputs are relayed to the basolateral amygdala. The present studies were designed to define potential US pathways to the amygdala using lesion methods. Electrolytic lesions before or after training were placed in caudal granular/dysgranular insular cortex (IC) alone or in conjunction with the posterior intralaminar nuclei of the thalamus (PoT/PIL), and the effects on fear conditioning were examined. Pretraining lesions of both IC and PoT/PIL, but not lesions of IC alone, blocked the acquisition of fear-potentiated startle. However, post-training combined lesions of IC and PoT/PIL did not prevent expression of conditioned fear. Given that previous studies have shown that lesions of PoT/PIL alone had no effect on acquisition of conditioned fear, these results suggest that two parallel cortical (insula-amygdala) and subcortical (PoT/PIL-amygdala) pathways are involved in relaying shock information to the basolateral amygdala during fear conditioning.

The contribution of functional imaging techniques to our understanding of rheumatic pain

The main cerebral components of the human pain matrix have been defined using functional imaging techniques. The experience of pain is likely to be elaborated as a result of parallel processing within this matrix. There is not, therefore, a single pain center. The determinants of pain are as likely to be determined by top-down as by bottom-up processes. The precise function of the different components of the matrix are just beginning to be defined. There appear to be important adaptive responses in the forebrain components of the matrix during arthritic pain. Endogenous opioid peptides are strong candidates for the modulation of some of these responses. More extensive and sequential behavioral and functional imaging studies are required to establish the contribution these adaptive responses make to the perception of pain.

The induction of pain: an integrative review

The highly disagreeable sensation of pain results from an extraordinarily complex and interactive series of mechanisms integrated at all levels of the neuroaxis, from the periphery, via the dorsal horn to higher cerebral structures. Pain is usually elicited by the activation of specific nociceptors ('nociceptive pain'). However, it may also result from injury to sensory fibres, or from damage to the CNS itself ('neuropathic pain'). Although acute and subchronic, nociceptive pain fulfils a warning role, chronic and/or severe nociceptive and neuropathic pain is maladaptive. Recent years have seen a progressive unravelling of the neuroanatomical circuits and cellular mechanisms underlying the induction of pain. In addition to familiar inflammatory mediators, such as prostaglandins and bradykinin, potentially-important, pronociceptive roles have been proposed for a variety of 'exotic' species, including protons, ATP, cytokines, neurotrophins (growth factors) and nitric oxide. Further, both in the periphery and in the CNS, non-neuronal glial and immunecompetent cells have been shown to play a modulatory role in the response to inflammation and injury, and in processes modifying nociception. In the dorsal horn of the spinal cord, wherein the primary processing of nociceptive information occurs, N-methyl-D-aspartate receptors are activated by glutamate released from nocisponsive afferent fibres. Their activation plays a key role in the induction of neuronal sensitization, a process underlying prolonged painful states. In addition, upon peripheral nerve injury, a reduction of inhibitory interneurone tone in the dorsal horn exacerbates sensitized states and further enhance nociception. As concerns the transfer of nociceptive information to the brain, several pathways other than the classical spinothalamic tract are of importance: for example, the postsynaptic dorsal column pathway. In discussing the roles of supraspinal structures in pain sensation, differences between its 'discriminative-sensory' and 'affective-cognitive' dimensions should be emphasized. The purpose of the present article is to provide a global account of mechanisms involved in the induction of pain. Particular attention is focused on cellular aspects and on the consequences of peripheral nerve injury. In the first part of the review, neuronal pathways for the transmission of nociceptive information from peripheral nerve terminals to the dorsal horn, and therefrom to higher centres, are outlined. This neuronal framework is then exploited for a consideration of peripheral, spinal and supraspinal mechanisms involved in the induction of pain by stimulation of peripheral nociceptors, by peripheral nerve injury and by damage to the CNS itself. Finally, a hypothesis is forwarded that neurotrophins may play an important role in central, adaptive mechanisms modulating nociception. An improved understanding of the origins of pain should facilitate the development of novel strategies for its more effective treatment.

Cerebral responses to a continual tonic pain stimulus measured using positron emission tomography

We have previously demonstrated the localised positron emission tomographic cerebral correlates of the experience of painful phasic heat in the normal human brain. In this study we examine whether these responses are different using a continuous, tonic heat stimulus. The regional cerebral responses to non-painful and painful thermal stimuli in 12 male subjects were studied by monitoring serial measurements of regional cerebral blood flow (rCBF) with positron emission tomography (PET) using H2(15)O. Significantly increased rCBF responses to tonic noxious stimulation compared with non-noxious stimulation were observed bilaterally in the anterior cingulate (Brodmann's area (BA) 24) cortex. Contralateral responses were observed in the lentiform nucleus and posterior insula cortex and ipsilateral responses were observed in the thalamus, cerebellum, prefrontal (BA 10) cortex and anterior insula cortex. These findings demonstrate general agreement between the main areas of cerebral activation during both phasic and tonic pain.