Treatment of Duchenne's muscular dystrophy with penicillamine. Results of a double-blind trial

Antioxidants for Treatment of Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

INTRODUCTION

Increasing evidence has shown that oxidative stress is involved in the pathogenesis of Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD). Oxidative stress impairs muscle function, reduces regenerative capacity, and leads to atrophy and muscle weakness. The present study aimed to evaluate the effectiveness and safety of antioxidants in treatment of DMD patients.

METHODS

Medline, Embase, EBSCOhost, and Cochrane Library databases were searched using relevant keywords regarding DMD and antioxidants. The risk of bias for all included studies was assessed using the Cochrane risk of bias tool. The effectiveness of antioxidants in improving pulmonary function and muscle strength in DMD patients and their rate of adverse events was evaluated by meta-analysis.

RESULTS

A total of nine eligible studies were identified. Among these, two studies involving 85 patients compared idebenone with placebo. Pooled data showed a significant improvement in pulmonary function after idebenone treatment. Flavonoids- and omega 3-based compounds (FLAVOMEGA) significantly improved muscle strength. Two studies evaluated coenzyme Q10 (CoQ10) and reported clinical improvement in physical activity. The remaining four studies evaluated pentoxifylline, superoxide dismutase, vitamin E combination with penicillamine and penicillamine alone, respectively, and found no significant differences between the intervention and placebo groups, measured by pulmonary function, muscle strength, movement function, or quality of life. Most adverse events were mild, while the rates of dropout and serious adverse events were low with respect to antioxidants.

CONCLUSIONS

Idebenone appeared to be safe and effective in improving pulmonary function in DMD patients, while pentoxifylline, superoxide dismutase, penicillamine, or a combination of vitamin E with penicillamine did not show a significant therapeutic effect. CoQ10 and FLAVOMEGA might be beneficial in improving muscle strength or physical activity in DMD patients. However, additional trials with more participants are warranted in the future.

Amplification of proinflammatory phenotype, damage, and weakness by oxidative stress in the diaphragm muscle of mdx mice

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is a common and devastating type of childhood-onset muscular dystrophy, attributed to an X-linked defect in the gene that encodes dystrophin. Myopathy with DMD is most pronounced in the diaphragm muscle and fast-twitch limb muscles and is dependent upon susceptibility to damage, inflammatory cell infiltration, and proinflammatory signaling (nuclear factor-κB; NF-κB). Although recent papers have reawakened the notion that oxidative stress links inflammatory signaling with pathology in DMD in limb muscle, the importance of redox mechanisms had been clouded by inconsistent results from indirect scavenger approaches, including in the diaphragm muscle. Therefore, we used a novel catalytic mimetic of superoxide dismutase and catalase (EUK-134) as a direct scavenger of oxidative stress in myopathy in the diaphragm of the mdx mouse model. EUK-134 reduced 4-hydroxynonenal and total hydroperoxides, markers of oxidative stress in the mdx diaphragm. EUK-134 also attenuated positive staining of macrophages and T-cells as well as activation of NF-κB and p65 protein abundance. Moreover, EUK-134 ameliorated markers of muscle damage including internalized nuclei, variability of cross-sectional area, and type IIc fibers. Finally, impairment of contractile force was partially rescued by EUK-134 in the diaphragm of mdx mice. We conclude that oxidative stress amplifies DMD pathology in the diaphragm muscle.

Exacerbation of pathology by oxidative stress in respiratory and locomotor muscles with Duchenne muscular dystrophy

Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) is the most devastating type of muscular dystrophy, leading to progressive weakness of respiratory (e.g. diaphragm) and locomotor muscles (e.g. gastrocnemius). DMD is caused by X-linked defects in the gene that encodes for dystrophin, a key scaffolding protein of the dystroglycan complex (DCG) within the sarcolemmal cytoskeleton. As a result of a compromised dystroglycan complex, mechanical integrity is impaired and important signalling proteins (e.g. nNOS, caveolin-3) and pathways are disrupted. Disruption of the dystroglycan complex leads to high susceptibility to injury with repeated, eccentric contractions as well as inflammation, resulting in significant damage and necrosis. Chronic damage and repair cycling leads to fibrosis and weakness. While the link between inflammation with damage and weakness in the DMD diaphragm is unresolved, elevated oxidative stress may contribute to damage, weakness and possibly fibrosis. While utilization of non-specific antioxidant interventions has yielded inconsistent results, recent data suggest that NAD(P)H oxidase could play a pivotal role in elevating oxidative stress via integrated changes in caveolin-3 and stretch-activated channels (SACs). Oxidative stress may act as an amplifier, exacerbating disruption of the dystroglycan complex, upregulation of the inflammatory transcription factor NF-B, and thus functional impairment of force-generating capacity.

Oxidative stress regulation of stem and progenitor cells

In recent years, it has become clear that balanced regulation of reactive oxygen species is of critical significance for cell-fate determination as well as for stem cell development, function, and survival. Although many questions regarding intracellular redox status regulation of stem cell fate remain, we review here what is known regarding the impact of cell-fate signaling as shown with a variety of human cancer cells and more recently on cancer-initiating cells and on the regenerative capacity of skeletal muscle and hematopoietic tissue and their stem cells. We also discuss the role of altered intracellular redox status as a potential primary pathogenic mechanism in muscular dystrophy and hematopoietic pathologies. Studies discussed here illustrate how understanding altered redox regulation of stem cell behavior may contribute to the development of novel stem cell therapies.

Oxidative stress and the pathogenesis of muscular dystrophies

The muscular dystrophies represent a diverse group of diseases differing in underlying genetic basis, age of onset, mode of inheritance, and severity of progression, but they share certain common pathologic features. Most prominent among these features is the necrotic degeneration of muscle fibers. Although the genetic basis of many of the dystrophies has been known for over a decade and new disease genes continue to be discovered, the pathogenetic mechanisms leading to muscle cell death in the dystrophies remain a mystery. This review focuses on the oxidative stress theory, which states that the final common pathway of muscle cell death in these diseases involves oxidative damage.

High performance liquid chromatography analysis of D-penicillamine by derivatization with N-(1-pyrenyl)maleimide (NPM)

D-Penicillamine (2-amino-3-mercapto-3-methylbutanoic acid), a well-known heavy metal chelator, is the drug of choice in the treatment of Wilson's disease and is also effective for the treatment of several disorders including rheumatoid arthritis, primary biliary cirrhosis, scleroderma, fibrotic lung diseases and progressive systemic sclerosis. The method proposed incorporates a technique, previously developed in our laboratory, that utilizes the derivatizing agent N-(1-pyrenyl)maleimide (NPM) and reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). The coefficients of variation for within-run precision and between-run precision for 500 nM standard D-penicillamine (D-pen) were 2.27% and 2.23%, respectively. Female Sprague-Dawley rats were given 1 g/kg D-pen i.p. and the amounts of D-pen in liver, kidney, brain and plasma were subsequently analyzed. This assay is rapid, sensitive and reproducible for determining D-pen in biological samples.

Evidence of oxidative stress in mdx mouse muscle: studies of the pre-necrotic state

Considerable evidence indicates that free radical injury may underlie the pathologic changes in muscular dystrophies from mammalian and avian species. We have investigated the role of oxidative injury in muscle necrosis in mice with a muscular dystrophy due to a defect in the dystrophin gene (the mdx strain). In order to avoid secondary consequences of muscle necrosis, all experiments were done on muscle prior to the onset of the degenerative process (i.e. during the 'pre-necrotic' phase) which lasted up to 20 days of age in the muscles examined. In pre-necrotic mdx muscle, there was an induction of expression of genes encoding antioxidant enzymes, indicative of a cellular response to oxidative stress. In addition, the levels of lipid peroxidation were greater in mdx muscle than in the control. Since the free radical nitric oxide (NO*) has been shown to mediate oxidative injury in various disease states, and because dystrophin has been shown to form a complex with the enzyme nitric oxide synthase, we examined pre-necrotic mdx muscle for evidence of NO*-mediated injury by measuring cellular nitrotyrosine formation. By both immunohistochemical and electrochemical analyses, no evidence of increased nitrotyrosine levels in mdx muscle was detected. Therefore, although no relationship with NO*-mediated toxicity was found, we found evidence of increased oxidative stress preceding the onset of muscle cell death in dystrophin-deficient mice. These results lend support to the hypothesis that free radical-mediated injury may contribute to the pathogenesis of muscular dystrophies.

Muscle cells from mdx mice have an increased susceptibility to oxidative stress

Several lines of evidence suggest that free radical mediated injury and oxidative stress may lead to muscle necrosis in the muscular dystrophies, including those related to defects in the dystrophin gene. We have examined muscle cell death using an in vitro assay in which the processes that lead to myofiber necrosis in vivo may be amenable to investigation in a simplified cell culture system. Using myotube cultures from normal and dystrophin-deficient (mdx) mice, we have examined the susceptibilities of the cells to different metabolic stresses. Dystrophin-deficient cells were more susceptible to free radical induced injury when compared to normal cells, but the two populations were equally susceptible to other forms of metabolic stress. The differential response appeared to be specifically related to dystrophin expression since undifferentiated myoblasts (which do not express dystrophin) from normal and mdx mice were equally sensitive to oxidative stress. Thus, the absence of dystrophin appears to render muscle specifically more susceptible to free radical induced injury. These results support the hypothesis that oxidative stress may lead to myofiber necrosis in these disorders. Elucidating the mechanisms leading to cell death may help to explain the variabilities in disease expression that are seen as a function of age, among different muscles, and across species in animals with muscular dystrophy due to dystrophin deficiency.

Regulation of membrane-mediated chronic muscle degeneration in dystrophic hamsters by calcium-channel blockers: diltiazem, nifedipine and verapamil

Membrane-mediated excessive intracellular calcium accumulation (EICA) is a fundamental pathogenetic event associated with chronic muscle degeneration in patients with Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD), and in animals with hereditary muscular dystrophy (HMD). Because of potential Ca(2+)-channel blocking properties, we investigated the relative efficacies of chronic diltiazem (DTZM) (50 mg/kg/d), nifedipine (NFDN) (6 mg/kg/d), and verapamil (VPML) (25 mg/kg/d) therapies in reducing EICA and improving dystrophic pathobiology beginning in 30-day-old male BIO-14.6 strain dystrophic hamsters (DH). Each agent, and sterile distilled water as vehicle control, was given in a single daily oral dose for 180 days to four groups each of DH and BIO-F1B strain normal hamsters (NH). Plasma [Ca] and [Mg]; plasma aldolase (ALD), creatine kinase (CK), and lactate dehydrogenase (LDH) activities; relative cardiac hypertrophy and relative soleus hypertrophy; tissue [Ca] and [Mg] of the heart and rectus femoris muscle, histology of rectus femoris, and overall mortality rate were quantitated. Muscle Mg was not modified in DH, or by any of these agents. NFDN produced significant edema in the soleus and myocardium. During the 6-month therapeutic trial, 45% DH and 18% NH died on VPML, 27% DH and 9% NH on NFDN, and 20% DH controls on distilled water, but none on DTZM; suggesting that DTZM treated DH lived longer than DH controls. Relative efficacy in regulating EICA in both the cardiac and skeletal muscles; plasma ALD, CK, and LDH; and improving associated dystrophic pathobiology was found to be DTZM >>> NFDN > VPML. DTZM appears to be the most effective and safest agent in mitigating EICA in cardiac and skeletal muscles, efflux of intracellular enzymes, histopathology of dystrophic muscle with sporadic necrosis, and chronic muscle degeneration in DH with HMD. DTZM therapy also halted the high morbidity and mortality associated with the dystrophic pathobiology inherent in DH.

Myoblast transfer therapy for Duchenne muscular dystrophy

A randomly selected extensor digitorum brevis (EDB) muscle in each of three Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) boys aged 9 to 10 was injected with approximately 8 x 10(6) myoblasts. The contralateral EDBs were sham-injected with carrier solution. Donor myoblasts were derived from cell culture of muscle biopsies from the normal ward or normal brothers of the recipients. Cyclosporine (CsA) treatment began two days before myoblast injection and continued for three months. Three days prior to myoblast injection and three months after, the isometric twitch and maximum voluntary contraction of the left and the right EDBs were measured. Myoblast-injected EDBs showed increases in tensions whereas sham-injected EDBs showed reductions. Both immunocytochemical staining and immunoblot revealed dystrophin in the myoblast-injected EDBs. Dystrophic characteristics such as fiber splitting, central nucleation, phagocytic necrosis, variation in fiber shape and size, and infiltration of fat and connective tissues were less frequently observed in these muscles. Sham-injected EDBs exhibited significant structural and functional degeneration and no dystrophin. Throughout the study, there was no sign of erythema, swelling or tenderness at the injection sites. Serial laboratory evaluation including electrolytes, creatinine, and urea did not reveal any significant changes before or after myoblast transfer. We conclude that myoblast transfer therapy is a safe and efficacious procedure to improve the biochemistry, structure, and function of degenerative EDB muscles in DMD.

Clinical investigation in Duchenne muscular dystrophy: penicillamine and vitamin E

A double-blind controlled trial of penicillamine and vitamin E against placebo was conducted in 106 boys with Duchenne muscular dystrophy. Nine dropped out of the study after being randomized. Patients were evaluated using an established protocol that measures muscle strength, joint contractures, functional grade, and pulmonary function. The trial lasted for 18 months. The power of the study to detect a 75% slowing of the disease was 0.95 at a P less than 0.05. No therapeutic effect was observed in the patients taking penicillamine and vitamin E as compared with those taking placebo.

Free radicals: a potential pathogenic mechanism in inherited muscular dystrophy

Despite years of intensive work, the biochemical defect responsible for the pathogenesis of inherited muscular dystrophy has not been identified either in humans or animal models. This review examines evidence in support of the hypothesis that free radicals may be responsible for muscle degeneration in this disorder. A variety of cellular abnormalities noted in dystrophic muscles can be accounted for by free radical mediated damage. In addition, chemical by-products associated with free radical damage are found in dystrophic muscle tissue from humans and animals with this disease. Various enzymatic antioxidant systems can be enhanced as a normal cellular response to oxidative stress, and such changes are seen both in dystrophic muscle cells and certain other tissues of dystrophic animals. An increased level of free radical damage would follow from either: enhanced production of free radical species, or a deficient component of the cellular antioxidant system, such as vitamin E. The free radical hypothesis of muscular dystrophy can account for data supporting several alternative theories of the pathogenesis of this disease, as well as other observations which have not previously been explained.

Treatment of Duchenne muscular dystrophy with growth hormone inhibitors

A controlled, double-blind therapeutic trial with the drug mazindol, a growth hormone inhibitor, was performed in a pair of 7 1/2 year-old monozygotic twins, with Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD). The rationale for this trial was based on a patient (reported previously) affected simultaneously with DMD and growth hormone (GH) deficiency, who is showing a benign course of the dystrophic process and is still walking at 18 years. One of the twins received 2 mg of mazindol daily, while the other received a placebo. The assessment, repeated every 2 months, included weight and height measurements, functional and motor ability tests, ergometry and determinations of serum enzymes and GH levels. After one year of trial the code was broken and it was seen that the twin under placebo treatment was strikingly worse than his brother, the progression of whose condition was practically arrested. These results strongly suggest that treatment with a GH inhibitor is beneficial for DMD patients.

Clinical trials of allopurinol in Duchenne muscular dystrophy

A wide range of different disturbances characteristic of Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) can be attributed to a fundamental chronic shortage of intracellular adenosine 5'-triphosphate (ATP), in turn arising from a basic lack of total adenylate. Purine conservation by the hypoxanthine isomer allopurinol, which promotes salvage and inhibits catabolism, greatly increases muscle ATP and total adenylate, with corresponding clinical benefit. Among subsequent confirmatory clinical trials some gave positive results, while others provided no information. Reasons given why these latter proved uninformative include asking questions either irrelevant and/or incapable of being answered, not least in older boys with too much shrinking fibrous tissue infiltrating too little remaining muscle. Informative results from any metabolic intervention can be expected only where sufficient muscle is left to respond, and this age-linked effect is everywhere evident in the positive trials. Thus, if an effect of allopurinol now seems apparent, and since it is extremely safe and does not enter the genetic material, it is suggested that it be administered shortly after birth before irreversible pathological changes occur. This implies neo-natal male mass screening, easily accomplished by a simple dried-blood spot test, and already carried out successfully elsewhere.

Drugs in muscular dystrophy of the chicken: corticosterone-21-acetate

In a previous series of 22-day evaluations of 31 compounds, only corticosterone-21-acetate (C-21-A) increased righting ability of genetically dystrophic chickens to a greater extent than the standard of comparison, methysergide maleate. In the present study, C-21-A was subjected to longer-term trials of up to 48 days, and additional signs of the myopathy were examined. The highest doses of C-21-A increased righting ability for the duration of the trials, decreased the typically elevated plasma levels of creatine kinase (CK) activity by more than 80%, and improved morphology of the dystrophic pectoralis major muscle at the light microscopic level. The major adverse effect of C-21-A, reduction of body weight, was consistently observed at the relatively high doses needed to increase righting ability. That alone, however, could not account for increased righting ability, and plasma CK activity was decreased even at doses that did not reduce body weight. The results show that C-21-A is the most effective compound yet tested in this system and, perhaps more significantly, provides the first evidence that it is possible to identify compounds that improve muscle morphology in a hereditary myopathy using a short-term, step-wise system.

Functional evaluation of Duchenne muscular dystrophy: proposal for a protocol

A protocol for the evaluation of functional activities in subjects with Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) was designed. The aim of our study was to define objective clinical criteria for the evaluation both of the clinical status of the patient and of the natural history of the illness itself. A protocol with such criteria is particularly necessary when testing the efficacy of treatment. 43 still-ambulant children with DMD between the ages of 3.10 yr and 10.4 yr were examined. Of this number 19 children were evaluated every 4 months over a period of 12 months; of these 14 formed part of a randomized double blind trial with L-carnitine (1.2-1.8 g/day) versus placebo.