Ocular counterrolling abnormalities in spasmodic torticollis

The effect of cognitive task on postural stability in cervical dystonia

BACKGROUND

Cervical dystonia (CD) is the most common form of focal dystonia. It is not known exactly whether abnormal head postures in cervical dystonia cause balance problems. Dual-tasking is a common every-day life situation.

OBJECTIVE

We aimed to evaluate postural stability (PS) in patients with CD and the effect of cognitive task on PS. As a secondary aim, we evaluated the effect of onabotulinum toxin A (BoNT) injection on PS.

METHODS

A total of 24 patients with CD who were on BoNT treatment for at least one year and 23 healthy controls were included. Posturographic analyses were carried out in all the subjects on static posturography platform under four different conditions: eyes open, eyes closed, tandem stance and cognitive task. In patients, posturographic analysis was carried out just before the BoNT injections and was repeated four weeks later.

RESULTS

Before treatment, the anterior-posterior sway was significantly higher in CD patients with the eyes open condition compared to the controls (p=0.03). Cognitive task significantly affected several sway velocities. Tandem stance significantly affected many sway parameters, whereas the eyes closed condition did not. After treatment, only two parameters in tandem stance and one in cognitive task improved within the patient group, in a pairwise comparison.

CONCLUSIONS

Postural control is impaired in CD patients probably due to the impaired proprioceptive and sensorimotor integration. In reference to dual task theories possibly due to divided attention and task prioritization, cognitive dual-task and harder postural task disturbes the PS in these patients.

Oculomotor functions in focal dystonias: A systematic review

Focal Dystonia (FD) is a chronic neurological disorder, which causes twisting and repetitive movements and abnormal postures induced by involuntary sustained contractions of agonist and antagonist muscles. Based on the hypothesis that several dystonia-related brain regions, including cerebellum, are implicated in oculomotor disturbances (OCD), a number of studies investigated oculomotor function in patients with dystonia. However, conceptual clarity with respect to the used assessment tools and interpretation of the findings is lacking in the literature. This is the first article to systematically review studies that assessed oculomotor function in patients with FD. In total, 329 publications, published until September 1, 2019, were identified through MEDLINE search. Twenty out of 329 studies, involving 232 subjects in total, met the inclusion criteria. Most of the studies reported oculomotor disturbances in patients with FD. Abnormalities included asymmetry in vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR), disturbances in saccadic functions, and prolonged latencies of eye motion. Discrepancies in the results could be explained, at least partially, by the long period of time over which the reviewed studies were published, the different methods used for testing the eye movements, and the limited number of patients assessed since the majority of data derived from case reports or small-scale studies. Further prospective studies with larger subject numbers are needed, using advanced tools for the assessment of oculomotor function in focal dystonia.

Physiology of midbrain head movement neurons in cervical dystonia

BACKGROUND

Early theories for cervical dystonia, as promoted by Hassler, emphasized the role of the midbrain interstitial nucleus of Cajal. Focus then shifted to the basal ganglia, and it was further supported with the success of deep brain stimulation. Contemporary theories suggested the role of the cerebellum, but even more recent hypotheses renewed interest in the midbrain. Although the pretectum was visited on several occasions, we still do not know about the physiology of midbrain neurons in cervical dystonia.

METHODS

We analyzed the unique database of pretectal neurons collected in the 1970s and 1980s during historic stereotactic surgeries aimed to treat cervical dystonia. This database is valuable because such recordings could otherwise never be obtained from humans.

RESULTS

We found the following 3 types of eye or neck movement sensitivity: eye-only neurons responded to pure vertical eye movements, neck-only neurons were sensitive to pure neck movements, and the combined eye-neck neurons responded to eye and neck movements. There were the 2 neuronal subtypes: burst-tonic and tonic. The eye-neck or eye-only neurons sustained their activity during eccentric gaze holding. In contrast, the response of neck-only and eye-neck neurons exponentially decayed during neck movements.

CONCLUSIONS

Modern quantitative analysis of a historic database of midbrain single units from patients with cervical dystonia might support novel hypotheses for normal and abnormal head movements. This data, collected almost 4 decades ago, must be carefully viewed, especially because it was acquired using a less sophisticated technology available at that time and the aim was not to address specific hypothesis, but to make an accurate lesion providing optimal relief from dystonia. © 2017 International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society.

The conundrum of cervicogenic dizziness

Cervicogenic or cervical dizziness is debated as an entity. However, there exists both a physiologic basis and a multitude of clinical data to make such a disease concept at least possible and worth considering. In addition, the interaction of proprioceptive and vestibular mechanisms may amplify dizziness of other origin. Cervical pain and dizziness are both common symptoms and may coincide, and neck pain or obvious dysfunction does not necessarily cause dizziness or balance disturbances. So far, there is also the lack of a proper diagnostic test for cervicogenic dizziness. On the other hand, there is growing evidence that cervical proprioceptive input is important for balance and postural control not only in animals but also in humans, and that intervention in disorders affecting the human cervical segment may relieve dizziness in some patients. It is advocated that the diagnosis should be used with care and that there is a need for better diagnostic tests. In the absence of such a test, one has to rely on preliminary criteria and a diagnosis ex juvantibus. A possible approach would require patients to present with neck pain before or in close temporal relation with dizziness; that other causes should be made at least unlikely; and that treatment of a cervical dysfunction reduces also dizziness or balance disturbance.

The Dystonias

Dystonia is a difficult problem for both the clinician and the scientist. It is sufficiently common to be seen by almost all physicians, yet uncommon enough to prevent any physician from gaining broad experience in its diagnosis and treatment. Each case represents a difficult challenge even to the specialist. The basic scientist is faced with investigating a disorder that is without relevant animal models and which is so rare that obtaining suitable tissue for study is a major obstacle. Dystonia may be idiopathic, or associated with lesions from many sources, including a variety of rare diseases. If idiopathic, it may be genetically transmitted or sporadic. If genetically transmitted, it may be generalized or focal, with symptoms varying in different members of the same family. It may be refractory to treatment, or it may respond to any one of a number of individual drugs that have very different mechanisms of action. For idiopathic dystonias, no clear method of genetic transmission has been established and no consistent pathology identified.

Three-Dimensional Eye–Head Coordination After Injection of Muscimol Into the Interstitial Nucleus of Cajal (INC)

The interstitial nucleus of Cajal (INC) is thought to be the “neural integrator” for torsional/vertical eye position and head posture. Here, we investigated the coordination of eye and head movements after reversible INC inactivation. Three-dimensional (3-D) eye–head movements were recorded in three head-unrestrained monkeys using search coils. INC sites were identified by unit recording/electrical stimulation and then reversibly inactivated by 0.3 μl of 0.05% muscimol injection into 26 INC sites. After muscimol injection, the eye and head 1) began to drift (an inability to maintain stable fixation) torsionally: clockwise (CW)/counterclockwise (CCW) after left/right INC inactivation respectively. 2) The eye and head tilted torsionally CW/CCW after left/right INC inactivation, respectively. Horizontal gaze/head drifts were inconsistently present and did not result in considerable position offsets. Vertical eye drift was dependent on both vertical eye position and the magnitude of the previous vertical saccade, as in head-fixed condition. This correlation was smaller for gaze and head drift, suggesting that the gaze and head deficits could not be explained by a first-order integrator model. Ocular counterroll (OC) was completely disrupted. The gain of torsional vestibuloocular reflex (VOR) during spontaneous eye and head movements was reduced by 22% in both CW/CCW directions after either left or right INC inactivation. Our results suggest a complex interdependence of eye and head deficits after INC inactivation during fixation, gaze shifts, and VOR. Some of our results resemble the symptoms of spasmodic torticollis (ST).

Static and dynamic balance function in spasmodic torticollis

The consequences of abnormal head posture on static and dynamic balance skill were studied in a group of 10 patients with idiopathic spasmodic torticollis (ST). In static conditions, body sway was assessed using a conventional force platform with eyes open and with eyes closed. Standardized dynamic balance conditions were produced using a rocking platform; lateral and anteroposterior dynamic balance skills were assessed by measuring linear displacement both of the body base and of the head. Dynamic tests were repeated 6 weeks after botulinum toxin treatment in all patients. Patients' results were compared with those obtained from 10 control subjects. In static conditions, ST patients did not differ from control subjects, but in dynamic conditions, balance parameters were greater in the patient group than in the control group. This was true for the lateral direction and for dynamic balance parameters recorded both before and after botulinum toxin treatment. Eye closure significantly increased dynamic balance parameters in both groups. However, the effect of eye closure was greater in the patient group than the control group, especially for lateral sway, suggesting that patients used vision to compensate for the dynamic balance disturbance induced by the spasmodic torticollis. Despite a significant improvement of head posture in all patients after botulinum toxin treatment, no significant changes in dynamic balance parameters were observed between the first and second test. The possible origins of the dynamic balance disturbance observed in ST patients are discussed.

Perception of spatial orientation in spasmodic torticollis. Part 2: The visual vertical

Twenty-nine patients with idiopathic spasmodic torticollis (ST) and matched normal control subjects were asked to align a target line to perceived earth vertical [visual vertical (VV)]. Settings were made against a whole-field random-dot background that was either stationary or rotating around the line of sight, and subjects performed the task upright and lying horizontally on their sides. Normal subjects were tested both head upright and after assuming a voluntary head tilt. Patients with ST set the VV close to true upright with a minimal deviation toward tilt of the head in contrast to normal subjects assuming a head tilt who set the VV in the opposite direction to the head tilt (Müller "E" effect). Settings against the spinning disk were biased in the direction of rotation similarly for both subject groups. Settings made against static or spinning disk performed when subjects lay horizontally were tilted in the direction of recumbence (Aubert "A" effect) similarly for both subject groups. When attempting to set the target line parallel to the long axis of the face, patients with head tilt set the line to upright, whereas normal subjects correctly estimated their tilts. One hypothesis offered to explain these results is that the patients referenced only their upright trunk for vertical and did not make use of neck proprioceptive or vestibular signals of head tilt so that all settings were made as if the trunk and head were upright. Alternatively, patients may have used only otolith signals as the reference for upright, and these are recalibrated in ST patients with head tilt. The pathological deviation becomes accepted as upright posture, and VVs and facial orientation are estimated as if the head were upright. In either case the findings indicate abnormal processing of the perception of visual verticality in ST patients.

Perception of spatial orientation in spasmodic torticollis. Part I: The postural vertical

Estimates of points of entering and exiting from upright posture were obtained from 25 seated, restrained patients with idiopathic spasmodic torticollis (ST) and matched normal subjects exposed to cycles of 1.5 degrees/s tilts in a flight simulator. Estimates were obtained for displacements in roll and pitch about upright and for yaw tilts about a rostrocaudal, "barbecue," axis with the subjects supinated. For both pitch and roll, normal subjects estimated entering upright when they were still approximately 1 degree from machine upright and perceived themselves to be upright through a mean arc of 6 degrees. In barbecue tilt, entering upright was estimated at 0.2 degree for an arc of 6 degrees. Patients estimated entering upright at 2.8 degrees in roll and 3 degrees in pitch but estimated exiting upright at the same tilt as normal subjects; that is, they were less specific in detecting verticality. Patients were normal in barbecue tilt. No relationship between tilt estimates and head deviation was found. There were no differences between normal subjects when tested with their head in normal posture and with an assumed tilt of 20 degrees. Normal subjects probably based their estimates on combined vestibular-somatosensory signals, whereas torticollis patients appeared to derive more from a vestibular signal. However, patients referred the vestibular signals to the trunk long axis when asked to indicate the whole-body vertical. The findings suggest disruption of the normal combined vestibuloproprioceptive mechanism for detecting body uprightness in ST.

Click-evoked vestibulocollic reflexes in torticollis

A total of 26 patients with torticollis were studied using a recently developed technique for recording vestibulocollic reflexes from the sternocleidomastoid muscles in addition to conventional caloric tests of vestibular function. Previous reports of abnormalities of vestibulo-ocular reflexes in these patients were confirmed with just fewer than half having significant canal pareses or directional preponderances (nine of 20 tested). In addition, there was a high incidence of abnormal click-evoked vestibulocollic reflexes (17 of 26 tested), which were not simply the result of prior treatment with botulinum toxin, nor due to unequal levels of muscle activation. In patients never previously treated with botulinum toxin (14 patients), the effect almost always consisted of suppressed responses in the sternocleidomastoid muscle ipsilateral to the direction of head turning. Because responses were not abnormal in all patients tested, and more commonly so in those with a history of torticollis of > or = 5 years (eight of nine patients) than in de novo patients, we suggest that the changes are more likely to be compensatory than causal.

Short-latency neck muscle responses to vertical body tilt in normal subjects and in patients with spasmodic torticollis

EMG responses in the sternocleidomastoid (SCM) and dorsal neck muscles (DNM) to vertical head acceleration were studied in normal subjects and in patients with spasmodic torticollis, standing on a platform that could be tilted upwards. The vertical body displacement and the induced changes in the head-neck angle (a flexion-extension sequence) were recorded. Excitatory responses, symmetrical on the two sides, were elicited in normal subjects in both muscle groups, at a latency of about 60 msec (DNM) and 90 msec (SCM). With the head initially extended, the latency of DNM response increased, leaving that of SCM unchanged. During an isometric rotatory effort, an early inhibitory period was recorded in the active muscles at a latency of about 40 msec. Downward tilt did not evoke the responses. The DNM excitatory responses appeared to be related to muscle stretch, while those in SCM, as well as the inhibitory responses in both muscles, were thought to originate in the vestibular receptors. During active head rotation the response increased in amplitude in the active SCM and decreased in the lengthened antagonist; decreased responses in the lengthened muscle persisted during passive head rotation. This was attributed to an influence from the tonic neck receptors. In the patients, SCM responses had normal latency, but were reduced in amplitude or absent in the dystonic muscle, in spite of tilt-induced head movements comparable to those recorded in normals. The diminution was even bigger if compared to normal subjects with the head actively rotated to a similar extent. It persisted when the head was returned to normal position by the "geste antagoniste." The inhibitory responses were unaffected in the active normal and dystonic muscles. The possible role of a deficit of the central vestibular connections in the decreased excitatory SCM response in dystonic patients is considered.

Ocular torsion quantification with video images

The present paper describes a technique to quantify eye rotations about the visual axis (ocular torsion). Two digitized polar transformed images of the iris are displayed on a video monitor in order to facilitate a visual comparison and manual interaction. Emphasis is placed on error analysis and the method's simplicity when applied to static ocular torsion measurement. The implementation, applying averaging over ocular torsion determined in partitioned iris images, yields a theoretical resolution of 5' of arc. In a control experiment with an artificial eye, the accuracy showed to be better than 14' of arc. In practice, the measuring device was validated with the data from the literature by means of an experiment about ocular torsion in humans during tilt and hypergravity conditions (up to 3 g).

Swallowing, speech, and brainstem auditory-evoked potentials in spasmodic torticollis

To explore the controversial "brainstem theory" of spasmodic torticollis, eight consecutively referred patients were examined. Three independent examinations were conducted on the same day: a videofluoroscopic barium swallowing examination, an instrumental speech examination, and a brainstem auditory-evoked potential (BAEP) analysis. Swallowing was normal in two patients; speech physiology, in five; and BAEPs, in all. Normal BAEPs refute the brainstem theory, while abnormalities of speech and swallowing temper this conclusion. Several alternative explanations are proposed.

Abnormal motoric laterality in strabismus and a hypothesis concerning its neurological origins

A survey of the literature concerning motoric laterality in strabismus was undertaken. The assessment of manual and ocular dominance was based on a total of eleven studies conducted between 1934 and 1986. The average percentage of right-handedness in strabismics was 73.8%, whereas the average percentage of right-eyedness was 46.9%. Both figures are significantly lower than those obtained for the normal population. It is hypothesized that reduced right dominance in strabismics results from dysfunction of the otoliths and/or their higher brainstem pathways.

Ocular torsion as a test of the asymmetry hypothesis of space motion sickness

Disconjugate eye torsion induced by 0 G and 1.8 G during parabolic flight was studied in nine former astronauts in 1990 and eight in 1991, four of whom were included in the previous experiment. The astronauts could be divided into two statistically significant groups on the basis of low and high scores of disconjugacy. When their histories of space motion sickness (SMS) were later revealed, all of the low scorers had not been sick on previous space flights; all the high scorers had had SMS. These data give support to the hypothesis that SMS in one-half or two-thirds of astronauts is due to an otolith, probably utricular, asymmetry in those persons.

Otolith-ocular testing in human subjects

Assessment of the otolith-ocular reflex of human subjects involves linear acceleration and/or changes in the orientation of the head with respect to gravity. Several such stimuli are currently under investigation regarding their applicability to the evaluation of patients with dizziness and balance disorders. Discussed in this paper are off-vertical axis rotation, eccentric rotation, pitch and roll rotation, and linear acceleration. For each of these stimuli, basic principles, normative human data, and patient data are described. Although none of these methods are currently established for clinical use, each of them, especially off-vertical axis rotation and linear acceleration, have the potential for developing into a clinically useful method for assessing otolith function in man.

Testing otolith function

Otolithic signals contribute to; (1) perception of orientation and linear motion, (2) generate compensatory eye movements in response to linear acceleration of the head and (3) participate in the co-ordination of movement and balance. Tests of these functions shown to be useful in identifying clinical disorders have been reviewed: (1) Evaluation of orientation to gravity, as estimated by adjustment of the visual vertical, indicates deranged otolith function at a peripheral or central level and the sensitivity of this test can be enhanced by performing estimates during centrifugation on a motorised turntable. Estimation of thresholds of self motion on a parallel swing identifies global reduction or unilateral loss of peripheral function, with central disorders awaiting study. (2) Otolith ocular reflexes to linear head translation can be used to demonstrate overall integrity of peripheral function and reveal central abnormalities. Counter-rolling responses to head roll-tilt and measurements of cyclodeviation of the eyes demonstrate functional asymmetries, with some lateralising value, particularly in central lesions. Global function and asymmetries may also be evaluated by 'head eccentric' rotational testing, which adds a tangential linear acceleration to the angular stimulus. The linear acceleration enhances the canal response by adding an otolith component. (3) Latency and amplitude of surface electro-myography (EMG) responses in the limbs to sudden falls, which can be recorded with the subject suspended on a hinged bed, indicate gross peripheral abnormality of function and can lateralize disorders of CNS motor pathways. It is concluded that some tests of otolith function can be of use in indicating global loss of peripheral otolith function, others are capable of lateralizing a marked loss of function and all have the potential to give information about central disorders. They all have to be interpreted within the clinical context and, unfortunately, none have yet been shown to be sensitive to partial, particularly unilateral, dysfunction.

Cervico-ocular function in patients with spasmodic torticollis

The cervico-ocular (COR) and active and passive vestibulo-ocular reflexes (VOR) were measured in seven patients with spasmodic torticollis (ST) and six normal controls. The COR was found to be weak or absent in both groups. The VOR gain was similar in the two groups but five patients had a significant asymmetry of the response. There was no evidence of abnormal cervico-vestibular interaction during active head rotation. The study suggests that the VOR asymmetry frequently found in ST cannot be explained on the basis of an abnormal cervical input.

Saccadic function in spasmodic torticollis

Twelve patients with idiopathic spasmodic torticollis were compared with 19 normal controls on tests of saccadic eye movements thought to depend upon normal basal ganglia function. The patients were able to make random, predictive, remembered, and self-paced saccades equally as well as control subjects. This suggests that those parts of the basal ganglia which may be damaged in spasmodic torticollis, are separate from pathways responsible for the normal initiation and execution of saccades.

Responsiveness of idiopathic spasmodic torticollis to botulinum A toxin injection. A critical evaluation of five cases

Five patients with Idiopathic Spasmodic Torticollis (IST), one associated with Meige's disease, have been cured by local injection of purified botulinum "A" toxin (BT). The therapeutic effect on the different subjects treated proved to be variable, and often the effect varied as well on the same subject from session to session. The response was only partly related to the dose of BT injected, and appeared inversely proportional to the number of hyperactive muscles. Transient dysphagia was the major untoward effect of the treatment. The inconstant response to BT makes us consider BT worth to be used selectively in the so-called "agonistic" cases of IST.

Vestibular hyperreactivity in patients with idiopathic spasmodic torticollis

Ocular motor tests performed on 14 patients with idiopathic spasmodic torticollis were normal. The vestibulo-ocular reflex tested in eight patients showed a significant high level in seven. It is suggested that this phenomenon is secondary rather than the cause of spasmodic torticollis.

Vestibulo-ocular abnormalities in spasmodic torticollis before and after botulinum toxin injections

In order to establish whether vestibular abnormalities often found in spasmodic torticollis are secondary to the abnormal head posture, the vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR) was studied in eight patients before and after correction of head posture with botulinum toxin. Eye movements were recorded in the dark during sinusoidal and velocity step rotation. Four patients showed a significantly asymmetric response, with the slow phase of the VOR more active ipsilateral to the torticollis (chin). Despite significant improvement of the head posture in all patients for up to 10 weeks following treatment, no correction of the vestibular asymmetry occurred. This suggests that the VOR abnormalities are not caused by the head posture itself. We interpret the findings as evidence of primary involvement of the vestibular system in torticollis and we postulate a widespread derangement of the sensory-motor mechanisms controlling head posture in this disease.