The possible carcinogenic effect of cholecystectomy. No postoperative increase in the proportion of secondary bile acids

Future incidence and mortality of colorectal carcinoma in the United States: an updated overview of risk factors and preventative measures

According to the Global Cancer Observatory (GLOBOCAN) 2020, colorectal carcinoma (CRC) was the second leading cause of cancer death globally. Current literature utilizes reported databases such as Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results (SEER) to better understand the epidemiology of CRC. The global cancer observatory’s “Cancer Tomorrow” data visualization tools was used to predict the future incidence and mortality of colorectal cancers until 2030 as a guided tool to look over ways to reduce incidence by controlling risk factors of CRC. The total number of CRC is expected to rise by 2030, with a percent change of 17.3%. The expected percent change in colon cancer is more than rectal cancer (19.8% vs. 11.6%). The estimated number of deaths secondary to CRC is expected to increase in 2030, an estimated percent change of 22.2%. The incidence and mortality rate was higher in men vs. women; however, the gap seems to be closing on trend analysis. Major risk factors for CRC include familial syndromes, family history, race, gender, obesity, diet, alcohol, and smoking. Risk can be reduced by exercise and dietary changes, fiber intake, vitamin D, calcium, and minerals. Individualized screening based on age, gender, and additional risk factors could be an option that needs further comparative data to propose a definitive benefit over established screening guidelines.

Gall bladder: The metabolic orchestrator

It is commonly held that the gall bladder (GB) is not indispensable for life. However, recent studies strongly suggest that GB removal can lead to the development of metabolic syndrome (MetS). With the recent recognition of the role of bile acids (BAs) in systemic metabolic regulation, it is worthwhile to re-examine the function of the GB, which can be regarded as the physiological "pacemaker" of BA flow. Thus, in the present study, we review the role of the GB in BA flow regulation, describe the epidemiologic evidence that associates cholecystectomy with various components of MetS, and discuss the possible mechanism behind these connections in order to demonstrate the pivotal role that GB plays in metabolic regulation.

Systematic review and meta-analysis: cholecystectomy and the risk of cholangiocarcinoma

Studies have reported that cholecystectomy may increase the risk of cholangiocarcinoma. However, this association is controversial. Thus, we conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis to explore the relationship between cholecystectomy and the risk of cholangiocarcinoma. Relevant studies were identified by searching PubMed, EMBASE, ISI Web of Science published before February 2017. We used the random effects model proposed by DerSimonian and Laird to quantify the relationship between cholecystectomy and risk of cholangiocarcinoma. Publication bias was evaluated using funnel plots, Begg's and Egger's tests. Subgroup and sensitivity analyses were performed to validate the stability of the results. 16 articles, comprising 220,376 patients with cholecystectomy and 562,392 healthy controls, were included in our research. Our meta-analysis suggested that the risk of cholangiocarcinoma was significantly higher in the cholecystectomized patients in comparison with healthy controls, with heterogeneity among studies (summary odds ratio [OR] = 0.72; confidence interval [CI] = 0.55-0.90; I² = 69.5%). Additionally, this association was also observed in cohort studies (OR = 0.83; 95% CI = 0.73-0.94) and case-control studies (OR = 0.60; 95% CI = 0.40-0.80). However, When the intrahepatic cholangiocarcinoma and extrahepatic cholangiocarcinoma were analyzed separately, the present study only indicated cholecystectomy was associated with increased the risk of extrahepatic cholangiocarcinoma (OR = 1.19; 95% CI = 0.32-2.05), rather than intrahepatic cholangiocarcinoma (OR = 1.19; 95% CI = 0.32-2.05). In conclusion, cholecystectomy was associated with a significant 54% increase in the risk of cholangiocarcinoma, especially in the extrahepatic cholangiocarcinoma.

Gallstone disease is associated with rectal cancer: a meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Increased levels of secondary bile acids after cholecystectomy and cholelithiasis are believed to increase the risk of colorectal cancer, and several studies have suggested that the risk of colorectal cancer may be the greatest proximally. Numerous conflicting studies have been published and it remains unclear whether the risk is apparent in the rectum. This meta-analysis aims to determine the risk of developing rectal cancer following gallstone disease or cholecystectomy.

METHODS

The prospective protocol included a literature search of PubMed, MEDLINE, EMBASE, and Current Contents (1950-2011). Selection criteria were developed to sort for studies exploring the relationship between cholelithiasis, cholecystectomy, and rectal cancer in an adult population. A random-effects model was used to generate pooled odds ratios (OR) and 95% confidence intervals (CI). Publication bias and heterogeneity were assessed.

RESULTS

Of the 2358 studies identified, 42 were suitable for final analysis. There were 1,547,506 subjects in total, 14,226 diagnosed with rectal cancer, and 496,552 with gallstones or cholecystectomy. There was a statistically significant risk of rectal cancer following cholelithiasis (OR = 1.33; 95% CI = 1.02-1.73), though no risk was apparent following cholecystectomy (OR = 1.14; 95% CI = 0.92-1.41).

CONCLUSIONS

Cholelithiasis increases the risk of rectal cancer. No association exists between cholecystectomy and rectal cancer.

Cholecystectomy as a risk factor for colorectal cancer: a meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

It has been suggested that there is an increased risk of colorectal cancer after cholecystectomy due to increased levels of secondary bile acids. Some studies suggest the risk is higher for women and for the development of right-sided tumours.

METHODS

A review of the literature yielded 95 relevant studies, of which 35 were suitable for a meta-analysis involving age- and sex-matched controls.

RESULTS

The pooled odds ratio for a positive association between cholecystectomy and colorectal cancer was 1.11 (95% confidence interval (CI), 1.02 to 1.21). For women the odds ratio was 1.14 (95 % CI, 10.01 to 1.28) and for right-sided cancer 1.86 (95% CI, 1.31 to 2.65).

CONCLUSIONS

It is possible that this small observed association may be due to a publication bias for positive results or bias within the included studies. If it is indeed a real effect, the risk to an individual is very small.

Is there a causal connection between bile acids and colorectal cancer?

Bile acid composition was assessed in 50 patients with colorectal cancer as compared to that in a control group of 50 subjects. The two groups were age- and sex-matched. The overall bile acid values were similar in both groups, while the relative concentrations of primary and secondary bile acids were different, a significant increase in the patients with colorectal cancer being observed. This finding thus seems to confirm the existence of a link between colorectal cancer and cholelithiasis. Both conditions share common risk factors, such as alterations in cholesterol metabolism and bile acid composition.

Long-term effects of cholecystectomy on bile acid metabolism

Comparative studies between different patient groups have suggested that cholecystectomy enhances bacterial dehydroxylation of the primary bile acid cholic acid (CA) to the secondary bile acid deoxycholic acid (DCA). DCA may exert a cocarcinogenic effect on the colonic mucosa. In a short-term follow-up study on nine female patients we found no alterations of the CA or DCA pools after cholecystectomy. However, in the long term, cholecystectomy could promote changes of the intestinal bacterial flora and thereby lead to enhanced conversion of CA to DCA, causing an expansion of the DCA pool size and a reduction of the CA pool size. To test this hypothesis, pool sizes, fractional turnover rates (FTR), and synthesis or input rates of CA, chenodeoxycholic acid (CDCA) and DCA were determined in 12 female patients before and again 5 to 8 years after cholecystectomy. In the long term, pool size and synthesis rate of CA had not changed and DCA pool size had expanded by only 7.5% (not significant [NS]). DCA input increased by 32% (NS) but was balanced by an increase in FTR of 36%. Pool size (-17%) and synthesis rate (-5%) of CDCA were not significantly diminished. Overall, the sizes of the total bile acid pool (-6%, NS; 50 +/- 8 vs. 53 +/- 13 mumol/kg) and the pool fractions of CA (44.7 +/- 10.3% vs. 42.8 +/- 7.6%) and DCA (25.5 +/- 14.1% vs. 23.6 +/- 9.3%) remained similar. In conclusion, cholecystectomy causes no changes in bile acid pool composition and thus has no adverse effects on bile acid metabolism in the long term.

CCK-8 and gastrin plasma levels in cholecystectomized and colorectal cancer patients

The elevated incidence of large bowel carcinoma after cholecystectomy has long been controversial. The pathomechanism of this entity, however, is still unclear. Many authors have demonstrated a correlation between cholecystokinin (CCK) and gastrin levels and the occurrence of colorectal cancer. As yet, no clear data are available on the potential impact of cholecystectomy on CCK level alterations. Moreover, no reports have yet been published on CCK receptors. We have investigated the role of CCK-8 and gastrin plasma levels in patients with prior cholecystectomy and CCK receptor levels in patients with colorectal cancer. 125 patients entered a prospective study. Of these, 45 served as controls. 40 patients had prior cholecystectomy, 5 patients underwent cholecystectomy during the ongoing trial. 35 patients had a colorectal cancer, 5 of these had prior cholecystectomy. No patient had elevated CCK-8 plasma levels. Gastrin levels were slightly elevated in 2 patients. There was no correlation between large bowel carcinoma and CCK-8 and gastrin levels. Elevated CCK-8 levels following cholecystectomy occur neither immediately after surgery nor on a long-term basis. Immunohistochemical studies in patients with colorectal cancer showed no CCK receptors in the normal colonic or tumor tissue. These findings are contrary to gastrin receptor data.

Role of bile acids and metabolic activity of colonic bacteria in increased risk of colon cancer after cholecystectomy

Since the metabolic activity of the colonic flora plays a definite role in colon cancer and an increased incidence of this disease is reported after cholecystectomy, we studied the metabolic activity of the colonic flora in a group of postcholecystectomy patients and matched controls by measuring, as representative end products of the bacterial metabolism, their fecal bile acids (BA), fecal 3-methylindole (SK) and indole (IN), and respiratory methane and hydrogen. Patients had significantly higher SK and lower IN, and, among BA, higher lithocholic (LCA) and chenodeoxycholic acid concentrations and LCA/deoxycholic acid ratio in the stools than controls. Similar differences from controls were reported for colon cancer. Comparable bacterial metabolic activities are thus operative in the large bowel of postcholecystectomized and colon cancer patients. This supports the biological plausibility of the association of cholecystectomy and colon cancer.

Gallstones and colorectal cancer--there is a relationship, but it is hardly due to cholecystectomy

The prevalence of gallstone disease in 145 consecutive patients with colorectal cancer was compared with gallstone prevalence in 4,159 subjects randomly selected from a population. The group of patients had a significantly higher prevalence of gallstone disease than the population (odds ratio = 1.59; 95 percent confidence limits 1.04-2.45), whereas cholecystectomies occurred with equal frequency in the two groups. There was a nonsignificant trend toward more right-sided cancers in patients with gallstones than in patients without. These results, together with available literature, give substantial evidence for an association between gallstones and colorectal cancer, an association which is not due to cholecystectomy being a predisposing factor to colorectal cancer. Sporadic findings of an association between cholecystectomy and colorectal cancer can be explained by the above relationship.

Cholecystectomy as a risk factor for colorectal adenomatous polyps and carcinoma

Multiple studies have suggested a possible relationship between prior cholecystectomy and the occurrence of subsequent colorectal carcinoma. This relationship has been particularly noticed among female patients and for right-sided lesions of the colon. In the current study, the authors undertook a case-control study among patients who underwent colonoscopy in three private practices in New York City between April 1986 and March 1988. Over this period, 302 adenomatous polyp cases, 106 colon cancer cases, and 507 controls were interviewed regarding their prior history of cholecystectomy. Overall, no significant association was observed between cholecystectomy and either colorectal adenomatous polyps or cancer. Cholecystectomy does not appear to be a significant risk factor for colorectal neoplasia.

Duodenogastric reflux of bile acids, gastrin and parietal cells, and gastric acid secretion before and 6 months after cholecystectomy

In order to evaluate the effect of cholecystectomy on the gastric mucosa, the duodenogastric reflux of total and single bile acids, the number of parietal and gastrin cells, and the volume of gastric acid secretion were examined in 15 patients with gallstones and functioning gallbladders before and 6 months after cholecystectomy. The duodenogastric reflux of the total bile acids increased from a mean preoperative value of 1.9 mumol/hour to a mean postoperative value of 21 mumol/hour (p = 0.008). The duodenogastric reflux of all single bile acids increased after cholecystectomy, with a higher increase in glycoconjugated compared with tauroconjugated bile acids. The parietal cells decreased from a mean preoperative value of 82.8 to a mean postoperative value of 68.7 (p = 0.05), whereas there was only a mild increase in the number of gastrin cells; the output of gastric acid remained unchanged. The variation of the gastrin cells before and after cholecystectomy was negatively correlated only with the variation of taurocholic acid (r = -0.50, p = 0.05), while the variation of the parietal cells was mildly correlated with all single bile acids (r = 0.35-0.50, 0.05 less than p less than 0.02). These findings show an increased duodenogastric reflux of bile acids 6 months after cholecystectomy with a mild morphologic alteration of the gastric mucosa.

Bile acid composition in brown pigment stones

The bile acids in brown pigment stones and gallbladder bile were fractionated into free acids, glycine and taurine conjugates, and sulfates using diethylaminohydroxypropyl Sephadex LH-20 (DEAP-LH-20) column chromatography and were quantitated by gas chromatography. Twenty-eight cases of brown pigment stones were studied and divided into two groups: those with and those without bacteria possessing bile acid-deconjugating activity. In the former, free bile acid amounted to 62 +/- 34% of the total bile acid, while in the latter, only 0.1% of total bile acid was free bile acid. The fraction of total bile acid made up of free bile acids was found to be consistently higher in brown pigment stones than in the corresponding bile, irrespective of the presence or absence of biliary infection. Free bile acid is present in negligible amounts in normal bile. Total bile acid concentration in the bile of patients with brown pigment stones was significantly less than that of controls (13 vs 50 mg/ml). Biliary infection is almost always present in cases with brown pigment stones. These findings suggest that bacterial infection is present at the initiation of brown pigment stone formation as well as during the period of ensuing stone growth.

Increased oxidoreduction of deoxycholic acid in cholecystectomised patients

The extent of oxidoreduction of deoxycholic acid in the enterohepatic circulation was studied in seven healthy subjects and seven patients after cholecystectomy. (12 beta-3H) Deoxycholic acid was given orally together with (24-14C) labelled bile acid. The rate of oxidoreduction of the 12 alpha-hydroxyl group of deoxycholic acid was calculated from the decay in ratio between 3H and 14C. In spite of a normal proportion of deoxycholic acid and other secondary bile acids in bile, patients after cholecystectomy had more than two-fold higher degree of oxidoreduction of the 12 alpha-hydroxyl group than healthy controls. The high extent of oxidoreduction is probably because of an increased exposure of the bile acid pool to intestinal bacteria and may have physiological implications.

Biliary bile acids in cholelithiasis and colon cancer

The role of biliary deoxycholate as an endogenous colon carcinogen and the possible association between cholelithiasis and/or cholecystectomy and the subsequent development of large bowel cancer is unclear. This paper describes biliary bile acids analysis performed on 13 patients undergoing cholecystectomy for gall stones, 10 patients undergoing colonic resection for colon cancer, and eight control patients. For all 31 patients the total bile acids concentration was highly variable (8.3 mg/ml-106.5 mg/ml). The median ratio of primary to secondary bile acids was 2.7:1. The biliary bile acid ratios were similar in both control patients (3.7:1) and those with colon cancer (3.1:1), whereas patients with gall stones had significantly higher secondary bile acid levels in their biliary bile (ratio 1.9:1, p = less than 0.05). This result indicates that raised biliary deoxycholate concentrations are not present in patients with colon cancer and are therefore unlikely to be a major predisposing factor in the aetiology of this disease. It is unlikely that cholelithiasis and/or cholecystectomy predispose to the subsequent development of colon tumours.

Effects of cholecystectomy on the kinetics of primary and secondary bile acids

Removal of the gallbladder is thought to increase formation and pool size of secondary bile acids, mainly deoxycholic acid (DCA), by increased exposure of primary bile acids (cholic acid [CA], chenodeoxycholic acid [CDCA]) to bacterial dehydroxylation in the intestine. We have tested this hypothesis by simultaneous determination of pool size and turnover of DCA, CA, and CDCA in nine women before and at various intervals after removal of a functioning gallbladder. An isotope dilution technique using marker bile acids labeled with stable isotopes (2H4-DCA, 13C-CA, 13C-CDCA) was used. After cholecystectomy, concentration and output of bile acids relative to bilirubin increased (P less than 0.02) in fasting duodenal bile and cholesterol saturation decreased by 27% (P less than 0.05) consistent with enhanced enterohepatic cycling of bile acids. Three months after removal of the gallbladder bile acid kinetics were in a new steady state: pool size and turnover of CDCA were unchanged. Synthesis of CA, the precursor of DCA, was diminished by 37% (P = 0.05), probably resulting from feedback inhibition by continuous transhepatic flux of bile acids. The fraction of CA transferred after 7 alpha-dehydroxylation to the DCA pool increased from 46 +/- 16 to 66 +/- 32% (P less than 0.05). However, this enhanced transfer did not lead to increased input or size of the DCA pool, because synthesis of the precursor CA had decreased.

Cholecystectomy and colorectal cancer

This review examines the evidence for and against an association between cholecystectomy and colorectal cancer.

Relative risk of colorectal cancer after cholecystectomy. A multicentre case-control study

The relative risk of developing colorectal cancer after cholecystectomy was assessed retrospectively in 493 patients with colorectal cancer (239 women, 254 men). The results were compared with a control group of patients matched for sex and age. The overall relative risk was 0.7 (90% confidence interval, 0.7-0.8). However, when the data were analysed for site significant differences were seen. In the caecum and ascending colon the relative risk of developing colorectal cancer after cholecystectomy was 2.8 (90% confidence interval, 1.0-9.4). In the rectum the relative risk was only 0.3 (90% confidence interval, 0.2-0.6) in both sexes. The results suggest a relative increased risk of developing right-sided colon cancer after cholecystectomy in women. However, they only partially support the hypothesis that prior cholecystectomy increases the relative risk of developing colorectal cancer in view of the data relating to the rectum.

Quantitative microanalysis of bile acids in biological samples. Collaborative study

The analysis of bile acids in biological samples has always presented a problem because of their complex nature and low concentration. Recently, newer analytical procedures for bile acids have become available, including enzymatic analysis, radioimmunoassay, thin-layer chromatography (TLC), gas chromatography, high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) and gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) with selected ion monitoring (SIM). However, they differ greatly with respect to specificity, sensitivity, accuracy and simplicity. On the other hand, the choice of analytical procedure differs according to the specific aims and the nature of biological samples to be analysed. These newer procedures have been compared in a double-blind fashion by distributing bile, plasma and urine samples to seven participating laboratories. GC-MS-SIM was found to be the most sensitive and reliable, but it requires other procedures for preliminary clean-up and fractionation steps. Enzymatic analysis is simple and gives small analytical errors but tends to over-estimate plasma bile acids. Radioimmunoassay gives variable results but is useful as a screening procedure for large numbers of plasma samples. TLC gives reliable results for biliary bile acids in experienced hands, except for differentiation between conjugated dihydroxycholanoic acids. HPLC, whether using derivatization or with fixed 3 alpha-hydroxy steroid dehydrogenase detection, is suitable for the analysis of major bile acids in normal human serum but not for the identification of unknown minor peaks.

Unaltered risk of colorectal cancer within 14-17 years of cholecystectomy: updating of a population-based cohort study

The incidence of colorectal cancer after cholecystectomy was analysed in a historical population-based cohort study comprising 16,439 patients who were completely followed up for 14-17 years after operation. The observed number of colorectal cancers (150) was lower than the expected number of 166.3 (relative risk (RR) = 0.90:95 per cent confidence limits 0.77-1.05) and the overall risk for colon cancer (RR = 0.95) did not differ significantly from that of rectal cancer (RR = 0.82). Separate analyses by sex, age at operation and duration of follow-up revealed relative risks close to or lower than unity. Some deviations indicating a substantially reduced risk might have been due to the play of chance alone. Our results contradict the idea both of a causal and of a non-causal association-through common aetiological factors-between surgically confirmed gallbladder disease and colorectal cancer.

Cholecystectomy and adenomatous polyps of the large bowel

Seventy two patients (39 women) with colonic adenomas were compared with 72 adenoma free controls (39 women) to investigate the possible association between previous cholecystectomy and the subsequent development of adenomas. Data were gathered retrospectively from medical records. Overall there was no significant association between colonic adenomas and previous cholecystectomy. When women are considered separately, however, eight cases and no controls had undergone cholecystectomy (odds ratio infinity lower 95% confidence limits 1.7, p greater than 0.01). No association between previous cholecystectomy and large bowel adenomas was found in men. Four of nine (44.4%) women with right sided colonic adenomas had undergone previous cholecystectomy compared with only three of 23 (13%) women with left sided adenomas.

Fecal bile acid excretion pattern in cholecystectomized patients

The fecal bile acid excretion pattern was investigated in 25 cholecystectomized and 26 noncholecystectomized patients as a measure for the exposure of the colonic mucosa to bile acids. Separation of free, conjugated, and sulfated bile acids was achieved by liquid-gel chromatography using DEAP Sephadex LH-20 and quantification of individual bile acids by gas-liquid chromatography. Total bile acid concentration was higher in cholecystectomized (5.33 +/- 0.71 mg/g) than in noncholecystectomized patients (3.69 +/- 0.65 mg/g). Deoxycholic acid excretion was elevated in cholecystectomized patients in three aspects: the concentration of deoxycholic acid was higher (2.92 +/- 0.39 mg/g and 1.71 +/- 0.35 mg/g, respectively), its percentage proportion of total bile acids was increased (53.9 +/- 2.8% and 41.4 +/- 3.1%, respectively), and its daily output was twice as large as that in patients without previous cholecystectomy (63.2 +/- 11.5 and 32.9 +/- 5.9 mg/day, respectively).

Increase of the mitotic index of colonic mucosa after cholecystectomy

This study was undertaken to assess possible modifications of the proliferative activity of colonic mucosa, which could be related to a suggested cancer-promoting role of cholecystectomy. The mitotic index (number of mitoses per 1000 gland cells) was evaluated in the colonic mucosa of 14 healthy subjects, 11 patients with cholelithiasis, before and 6 months after surgery, and 10 patients who had undergone cholecystectomy 2 or more years previously. The mitotic index of cholecystectomized patients was significantly higher than controls. It rose significantly within 6 months of cholecystectomy. The mitotic index of patients with cholelithiasis before surgery was similar to controls. These data suggest that cholecystectomy is followed by an enhancement in the proliferative activity of the colonic mucosa, which could play a cancer-promoting role.

Enhancing effect of cholecystectomy on colon carcinogenesis induced by methylazoxymethanol acetate in hamsters

The effect of cholecystectomy on colon carcinogenesis induced by methylazoxymethanol (MAM) acetate was examined in four groups of Syrian golden hamsters. For the sexes combined, the incidences of total large intestinal neoplasms and adenomas in Group 1, which received cholecystectomy and a single intravenous injection of MAM acetate (20 mg/kg body weight), were significantly higher than those of hamsters in Group 2, which were given MAM acetate alone. The combined multiplicities of total large intestinal neoplasms from male and female hamsters, and the multiplicities of those in females of Group 1 were also significantly higher than those in animals in Group 2, respectively. No intestinal tumors were observed in hamsters in Group 3 (cholecystectomy alone) or Group 4 (untreated control). These results indicate an enhancing effect of cholecystectomy on MAM acetate-induced large intestinal carcinogenesis in hamsters.

The role of bile acids in colonic carcinogenesis

Several line of evidence suggest that bile acids may be implicated in the pathogenesis of colonic cancer. A high consumption of fat and animal protein and a low dietary intake of fiber have been shown to be related to the incidence of colonic cancer. From these epidemiologic observations the hypothesis was proposed that the correlation between diet and colon cancer might be explained by the involvement of bile acids. Populations at a high risk of developing cancer were shown to have an increased excretion both of total and bacterially modified bile acids in their feces. Animal studies demonstrated a cocarcinogenic effect of bile acids and experimental diets containing large amounts of fat did not only induce an increased bile acid excretion but also an enhanced tumor formation in the colon. Furthermore, microbial in vitro tests showed a comutagenic activity of secondary bile acids. However, case control studies comparing the fecal bile acid excretion pattern in colonic cancer patients and control subjects failed to show such a clear relationship, which might be explained by rather similar dietary habits within one population and individual differences in sensitivity to environmental factors contributing to the tumor development. Cholecystectomy, leading to an increased exposure of bile acids to the intestinal microflora, has been suggested as a predisposing factor for the development of colonic cancer, but the results of experimental and epidemiologic studies so far are rather inconsistent.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)