Grading of oligodendrogliomas

Snail homolog 1 is involved in epithelial-mesenchymal transition-like processes in human glioblastoma cells

Despite advancements in neurosurgery, chemotherapy and radiation therapy, the outcome of patients with glioblastoma remains poor. The migration of tumor cells from the primary tumor site with subsequent invasion of these cells into the surrounding normal brain tissue is frequently responsible for relapse and treatment failure. The present study hypothesized that snail homolog 1 (SNAI1), a factor critically involved in the epithelial-mesenchymal transition (EMT) of human carcinoma cells, may also contribute to an invasive EMT-like phenotype of glioblastoma cells. The majority of glioblastoma cell lines investigated in the present study expressed SNAI1 at basal levels. The present study overexpressed SNAI1 in glioblastoma cell lines by lentiviral transfer of human SNAI1 complementary DNA. In addition, the inhibition of SNAI1 expression was achieved by lentiviral transfer of a short hairpin RNA specific for SNAI1. SNAI1 overexpression increased proliferation of one of the cell lines, U251MG, but exhibited only a weak effect on the migration and invasion of glioblastoma cells. However, downregulation of SNAI1 significantly decreased the invasive capacity of all investigated cell lines. In parallel, regained expression of E-cadherin, a marker that is usually lost during EMT, was observed subsequent to SNAI1 knockdown in the glioblastoma cell lines U87MG and U251MG. The data of the present study suggest that certain key genes of the EMT in carcinoma are also involved in the migration and invasion of human glioblastoma cells.

Grading of gliomas: the road from eminence to evidence

The development of concise grading schemes for diffuse gliomas with proven relevance to tumor behavior and susceptibility to therapy is important for clinical decision making. At present, there is unacceptably large interobserver discrepancy in the application of the current World Health Organization (WHO) criteria for accrual of patients in trials for patients with gliomas. Because of a lack of relevant studies, the WHO guidelines for grading are not yet as clear as would be desirable. The development of well-defined grading schemes consisting of features with low interobserver scoring variability and prognostic or predictive relevance is needed. Although interobserver concordance can be tested in retrospective studies, the prognostic or predictive qualities of histological parameters can only be tested in prospective studies. Only evidence-based histopathology will retain its critical role in the diagnosis and treatment of diffuse gliomas.

Update on diagnostic practice: tumors of the nervous system

CONTEXT

Changes in the practice of diagnosing brain tumors are formally reflected in the evolution of the World Health Organization classification. Beyond this classification, the practice of diagnostic pathology is also changing with the availability of new tests and the introduction of new treatment options.

OBJECTIVE

Glioblastomas, oligodendrogliomas, glioneuronal tumors, and primitive pediatric tumors are discussed in an exemplary way to illustrate these changes.

DATA SOURCES

Review of relevant publications through Medline database searches.

CONCLUSIONS

The example of glioblastomas shows how new predictive markers may help identify subgroups of tumors that respond to certain therapy regimens. The development of new treatment strategies also leads to different questions in the assessment of brain tumors, as seen in the example of pseudoprogression or the changes in tumor growth pattern in patients taking bevacizumab. Oligodendrogliomas illustrate how the identification of 1p/19q loss as a cytogenetic aberration aids our understanding of these tumors and changes diagnostic practice but also introduces new challenges in classification. Glioneuronal tumors are an evolving group of lesions. Besides a growing list of usually low-grade entities with well-defined morphologic features, these also include more poorly defined cases in which a component of infiltrating glioma is often associated with focal neuronal elements. The latter is biologically interesting but of uncertain clinical significance. Oligodendrogliomas and glioneuronal tumors both illustrate the importance of effective communication between the pathologist and the treating oncologist in the discussion of these patients. Finally, the discussion of primitive pediatric tumors stresses the clinical importance of the distinction between different entities, like atypical teratoid rhabdoid tumor, "central" (supratentorial) primitive neuroectodermal tumor, "peripheral" primitive neuroectodermal tumor, and medulloblastoma. In medulloblastomas, the recognition of different variants is emerging as a prognostic factor that may in the future also predict therapy responsiveness.

Proposal of a scoring scale as a survival predictor in intracranial oligodendrogliomas

INTRODUCTION

Histological, clinical and radiological features, and molecular genetic analysis are among the factors that have been considered in defining the prognosis of oligodendrogliomas (OD), but they have yielded conflicting results. The purpose of this study was to test out a scoring scale based on clinical, radiological, pathological and molecular features.

MATERIAL AND METHOD

To identify factors with prognostic significance, we analyzed 87 treated patients with a histological diagnosis of OD. Of the parameters analyzed, age, onset, clinical status, radiological enhancement, histological necrosis, mitosis and chromosomal anomalies emerged as significant prognosis factors using univariate analysis. Multivariate analysis revealed age and chromosomal anomalies as independent factors of survival.

RESULTS

The factors with a significant prognostic value were combined to determine which grouping factors best predict outcome. The proposed score is a pure number resulting from a combination of: 2 major factors: age and chromosomal anomalies (scored 3-0); 5 minor factors: onset, clinical examination, necrosis, mitoses (scored 1-0), and radiological enhancement (scored 2-0). According to our scale, 10 survival curves were produced for overall survival. Recursive partitioning of patients with the nearest score and outcome produced four groups with a significant difference in survival (p=10(-5)). The power of both the scale and the partitioned groups for predicting outcome was more accurate than the WHO and St Anne grading systems, and the molecular sub-classification.

CONCLUSIONS

Our scale is a plausible way of classifying patients harboring intracranial OD according to expected survival.

The presence of necrosis and/or microvascular proliferation does not influence survival of patients with anaplastic oligodendroglial tumours: review of 98 patients

Accurate prognosis for patients with anaplastic oligodendroglial gliomas is increasingly difficult to make. Characterisation of these tumours remains challenging, increasing proportions of oligodendroglial diagnoses in gliomas are reported, and no WHO 2000 grade IV exists for them, so that highly anaplastic tumours can only be grouped with glioblastoma (GBM) or with grade III oligodendroglioma, which have differing clinical behaviour. Longer survival times reported for patients with glioblastoma containing an oligodendroglial element (GBMO) suggest that a grade IV for oligodendroglial tumours might exist. In patients with anaplastic gliomas containing an oligodendroglial element, we explored whether microvascular proliferation (MVP) and necrosis were associated with shorter survival, sufficient to create a grade IV. Biopsies for 98 patients with anaplastic oligodendroglioma, anaplastic oligoastrocytoma or tumours with an oligodendroglial and GBM element, discharged 1998-2004, were identified from databases at three allied neurosurgery units. Pathology reports were reviewed for the presence of MVP and necrosis. Anaplastic oligoastrocytoma and GBMO were combined to measure the effect of an astrocytic element on survival. For anaplastic oligodendroglioma patients, median survival time was 24 months, while for anaplastic oligoastrocytoma or GBMO patients, it was 9 months. Age 60 or over (P=0.006) and astrocytic element (P=0.01) were the only independent predictors of survival. Patients 60 and over with an astrocytic element had 4.6 times the risk of death of patients under 60 with anaplastic oligodendroglioma.A grade IV cannot be created using necrosis or MVP since neither feature predicted survival after adjustment for age and an astrocytic element. However age and an astrocytic element were strong predictors of poorer survival in patients with anaplastic oligodendroglial tumours.

The prognostic impact of histology and 1p/19q status in anaplastic oligodendroglial tumors

BACKGROUND

It has been reported previously that the combined loss of chromosomal arms 1p and 19q is a significant predictor of outcome for patients with anaplastic oligodendroglial (AO) tumors and that such chromosomal loss correlates with classic histology in AO. The authors sought to determine whether histology was an equivalent or superior predictor of outcome compared with 1p/19q status in 131 patients with AO tumors.

METHODS

The status of 1p and 19q was determined using real-time, quantitative polymerase chain reaction analysis and/or fluorescence in situ hybridization. Clinical features (response to adjuvant therapy and tumor location) and molecular genetic abnormalities (9p and 10q deletions, overexpression of p53 and epidermal growth factor receptor) were determined on available specimens. Histologic assessments for classic oligodendroglial features were performed by five neuropathologists.

RESULTS

Classic histology was associated closely with 1p/19q loss, as reported previously. Patients who had tumors that were considered classic by at least four of the five neuropathologists showed significantly increased progression-free and overall survival compared with the patients who had less classic tumors. The authors also tested the correlation between 1p/19q status and outcome in subsets of patients stratified according to classic tumor features. The association of 1p/19q status with survival was related closely to the presence of classic histology. Loss of 1p/19q was predictive of improved outcome only among patients who had tumors with classic histologic features.

CONCLUSIONS

The current results suggested that, in addition to 1p/19q status, histologic features contribute information to the prediction of outcome in patients with AO. Loss of 1p and 19q appeared to be a prognostic marker only in the subset of patients who had AO tumors with classic histologic features.

[Oligodendrogliomas: historical background of classifications]

The story of the classifications for gliomas is related to the development of the techniques used for cytological and histological examination of brain parenchyma. After a review of these techniques and the progressive discovery of the central nervous system cell types, the main classifications are presented. The first classification is due to Bailey and Cushing in 1926. It was based on histoembryogenetic theory. Then Kernohan introduced, in 1938, the concept of anaplasia. The WHO classification was published in 1979, then revised in 1993 and 2000. It took into account some data from both previous systems and introduced gradually the notion of histological criteria of malignancy. More recently; molecular genetics data and clinical evolution were retained. The Sainte-Anne classification for oligodendrogliomas is based on both histological and imaging data. It includes the notion of spatial histological structure of oligodendrogliomas. Contrast enhancement is closely related to endotheliocapillary hyperplasia. Gliomas classifications are changing and confusions can be made because of lack of reproductibility and misinterpretations of samples.

Oligodendroglioma: clinical study and survival analysis correlated with chromosomal anomalies

Object

Demonstration of the loss of chromosomes 1p and 19q in the presence of a brain neoplasm marks the emergence of genotype as a prognostic indicator. The authors report gene expression data for oligodendroglioma and correlate genotype with response to therapy. Gene expression subgroups may represent distinct types of disease.

Methods

Eighty-seven cases of supratentorial oligodendroglioma were selected from 145 cases treated in a single center between January 1990 and December 2001. Fluorescence in situ hybridization was used to determine the status of chromosomes 1p and 19q. Parameters evaluated included clinical data and radiological and histological features. Univariate and multivariate analyses were performed and a probability value less than 0.05 was considered significant.

The patients included 48 women and 39 men. The overall mean age at presentation was 45 years for women and 36 years for men (p = 0.006). The univariate analysis identified the following as favorable prognostic factors: younger patient age (p = 10−5), female sex (p = 0.0025), seizure as a presenting symptom (p = 10−5), normal clinical examination (p = 10−5), absence of lesion enhancement on neuroimaging studies (p = 0.0231), lack of histological necrosis (p = 0.0003), absence of mitoses (p = 0.0014), 1p and 19q deletions (p = 0.0001), absence of recurrence (p = 0.0021), and adjuvant radiotherapy and/or chemotherapy (p = 10−5). The multivariate analysis identified patient age (p = 10−5) and chromosomal anomalies (p = 0.002) as independently linked to survival. Three molecular subtypes emerged: oligodendroglioma with 1p and 19q deletions, oligodendroglioma demonstrating polysomia and a lack of meaningful response to radiotherapy or chemotherapy, and oligodendroglioma with no 1p-9q deletion in which partial response was seen.

Conclusions

According to our data, oligodendrogliomas could be divided into three molecular subtypes. Although chemotherapy seems efficient for managing this tumor, additional studies should be conducted to compare the efficacy of radiotherapy and chemotherapy.

Techniques to assess the proliferative potential of brain tumors

Assessment of brain tumor proliferative potential provides important prognostic information that supplements standard histopathologic grading. Many laboratories rely on mitotic figures to quantify the proliferative potential of brain tumors, but this conventional cellular proliferative index is subject to inter-observer variability and not consistently predictive for low-and high-grade tumors. Recent advancements in technology have made it possible to use proliferative indices as a standard supplement in pathology laboratories. Non-invasive tumor tissue measurements of cell proliferation can be performed using- bromodeoxyuridine labeling index (BrdU LI), flow cytometry (FCM), MIB-1 antibody to the Ki-67 antigen (MIB-1), proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA), and argyrophilic nucleolar organizing regions (AgNOR). Each of these assays has been described in the literature with respect to its ability to predict tumor grade or outcome. At the present time MIB-1 and AgNOR are the simplest and most reliable of these techniques. In addition, advances in our understanding of the genetic alterations associated with proliferation promise to provide more specific markers of proliferative potential. Beyond the pathology laboratory, radiographic studies such as positron emission tomography (PET), single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT), and most recently magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) have been used as follow-up measures, assessing response to treatment and tumor recurrence, rather than as predictors of response to treatment. These radiographic tools, however, have the potential to provide an assessment of tumor proliferation without the need for invasive measures. In this article, we present a review of the current techniques utilized to understand the proliferative potential of brain tumors.

High and low grade oligodendrogliomas (ODG): correlation of amino-acid and glucose uptakes using PET and histological classifications

Classification and treatment strategy of oligodendrogliomas (ODG) remain controversial. Imaging relies essentially on contrast enhancement using CT or MRI. The aim of our study was to use positron emission tomography (PET) using [18F]-flurodeoxyglucose (FDG) and [11C]-L-methyl-methionine (MET) to evaluate metabolic characteristics of ODG. We studied 19 patients with proven ODG, comparing standardized uptake values (SUV) and maximal tumor/contralateral normal tissues ratios (T/N). Imaging findings were compared with WHO, Smith and Daumas-Duport classifications. Uptake of FDG was decreased only in 8 patients, independently of grading, while MET uptake was always increased. MET uptake was significantly higher for high grade tumors grouped according to Smith or Daumas-Duport classifications, while no significant difference in MET uptake was found when using WHO classification. A different correlation was found between FDG and MET uptakes in normal tissues and high grade tumors. A trend for improved progression free survival was found for tumors that lacked contrast enhancement on MRI or those showing low FDG or MET uptake. In conclusion, MET appeared more sensitive than FDG to detect proliferation in ODG. The preferential protein metabolism, already noticeable for low-grade tumor, correlated with glucose metabolism and helped to separate, in vivo, high and low grade tumors.

Pathology and molecular genetics of oligodendroglial tumors

Oligodendroglial gliomas are second only to astrocytic gliomas in frequency. The lack of stringent diagnostic criteria cause high interobserver variation in regard to classification and grading of these tumors. Previous studies have described oligodendrogliomas with features that overlap with those of neurocytic tumors, thus further complicating diagnostic decisions. The increasing need for standardized diagnostic criteria in this subset of gliomas is emphasized by the benefit of adjuvant therapies in patients with anaplastic oligodendrogliomas. Characteristic chromosomal aberrations have been successfully determined for oligodendroglial tumors in recent years. In contrast to astrocytomas, however, no genes in the affected regions have been clearly linked to their pathogenesis. However, the molecular findings promise to be helpful for diagnostic and therapeutic decisions. This review compiles clinical, pathological, and molecular genetic findings on WHO grades II and III oligodendrogliomas and oligoastrocytomas.

Low-grade glioma: supratentorial astrocytoma, oligodendroglioma, and oligoastrocytoma in adults

Low-grade glioma is not a single diagnosis but a category of biologically diverse neoplasms. They are indolent, progressive, and, following anaplastic transformation, invariably fatal. Neuro-oncologists have not established a treatment standard for these tumors. However, it is clear that "low-grade" is not synonymous with "benign," and treatment is required sometime in the course of the disease. Previously, achieving a consensus had been limited by a lack of class I evidence. Physicians treated patients based on retrospective series and personal experience. Currently, results from prospective clinical trials are becoming available. These studies have provided data that may serve as treatment guidelines. Additional results regarding the identification of prognostic variables have raised more questions to be answered. Attention is now directed to the importance of translational research to better define these neoplasms. In the future, it will be necessary to distinguish among low-grade gliomas and identify therapies that may differ between them.

Posterior fossa oligodendroglioma

Oligodendroglioma are the tumors of glial cells. They are rare in children and are more common in the cerebral hemispheres. A rare case of infratentorial oligodendroglioma in a female child is being reported here.

Advances in diagnosis and management of oligodendroglioma

Oligodendrogliomas are primary brain tumors, genetically characterized by chromosomal alterations in the 1p and 19q. Recent clinical trials have shown that oligodendrogliomas are sensitive to PCV chemotherapy with 60-65% of patients responding and median response duration of 1-1.5 years. The response rate in mixed oligoastrocytomas may be slightly less but is still better than that of pure astrocytic tumors. The chemosensitivity of oligodendroglioma is not limited to PCV but also to newer agent, such as temozolomide. Gross total resection remains the main step in the management of oligodendrogliomas and the extent of surgical tumor resection is an important prognostic variable. The role of postoperative radiation in low-grade oligodendroglioma remains controversial and are being trials conducted now to define its role.

Immunohistochemical markers for prognosis of oligodendroglial neoplasms

Despite numerous previous studies, oligodendrogliomas continue to generate considerable controversy in the identification of prognostic factors, including single histopathological patterns, and grade of tumor malignancy. The prognostic significance of various pathological and immunohistochemical factors has been intensively examined but numerous studies have yielded conflicting results. In the present study, biopsy samples of 123 oligodendrogliomas were examined immunohistochemically to evaluate a possible association between expression of various tumor-associated antigens and clinical outcome. Both the progression-free and overall survival times were significantly reduced for high-grade tumors, for Ki-S1 labeling index (LI) > 10%, for p27 LI < 20% and for p18, p53, and vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF)-positive tumors. For low-grade tumors survival rates were significantly reduced for p27 LI less than 20%, whereas high-grade oligodendrogliomas with Ki-S1 LI greater than 10%, and with p18 positivity revealed significantly shortened survival times. We found no differences in survival times in patients with or without p 14ARF, p21, mdm2, and pRb immunoreactivity. Multivariate analysis revealed that risk of oligodendroglioma progression is associated with high-grade tumors, with Ki-S1 LI > 10%, and with p27 LI < 20%; whereas risk of death is associated with high-grade tumors, with Ki-S1 LI > 10%, and with p18 positivity. CART modeling process identified four final groups of oligodendroglioma patients: (1) thirty-nine patients with low-grade tumors and p27 LI > 20%; (2) twenty patients with low-grade tumors and p27 LI < 20%; (3) thirty-four patients with high-grade tumors and Ki-S1 LI < 10%; and (4) thirty patients with high-grade tumors and Ki-S1 LI >10%. In summary, both the p27 and Ki-S1 scores were found to be the strong predictors of oligodendroglioma outcome together with the WHO tumor grade and they seem to be useful for assessing individual prognosis in routinely processed specimens.

Cell proliferation and tumors of the central nervous system. Part 1: Evaluation of mitotic activity

Evaluation of cell proliferation has been long recognized in pathology as a mainstay of diagnosis and important in the prognostication of a variety of neoplasms. Routine light microscopic evaluation of mitotic activity has long served as a reasonable assessment of cell proliferation. Counting mitotic figures has the advantage of being inexpensive and relatively quick. The main objections leveled against utilization of mitosis counts in diagnostic decision making are related to the instability of mitotic figures due to prefixation and fixation issues and problems with interobserver reproducibility of counts. This paper reviews factors that affect the identification of mitotic figures and the determination of mitosis counts. The role mitosis evaluation plays in the evaluation of certain neoplasms of the central nervous system is discussed.

Extradural cord compression due to metastatic oligodendroglioma

Extraneural metastases from primary intracranial tumours are extremely rare. We present a case of metastatic oligodendroglioma causing extradural spinal cord compression at the level of the sixth thoracic vertebrae resulting in paraplegia. We discuss the routes of tumour dissemination and possible reasons for the rarity of cases of metastatic oligodendroglioma.

Radiation therapy for incompletely resected supratentorial low-grade glioma in adults

In this review on current concepts in radiation therapy in the treatment of incompletely resected supratentorial low-grade glioma, a number of important issues are discussed. They include indication for radiation therapy, timing (early vs delayed), dose response issue, impact of modern neuroimaging, 'optimal' treatment fields, impact of histology, new and promising approaches as well as quality of life in this disease are also discussed. This disease remains a focus of investigations in neuro-oncology owing to the fact that a number of questions discussed in the text are still far from being optimally addressed and answers are, therefore, lacking. New studies and more patients are needed to get more insight into this disease.

Low-grade hemispheric gliomas in adults: a critical review of extent of resection as a factor influencing outcome

OBJECT

The goal of this study was to perform a critical review of literature pertinent to low-grade gliomas of the cerebral hemisphere in adults and, on the basis of this review, to evaluate systematically the prognostic effect of extent of resection on survival and to determine if treatment-related guidelines could be established for patients in whom these tumors have been newly diagnosed. Quality of evidence for current treatment options, guidelines, and standards as well as methodological limitations were evaluated.

METHODS

Several prognostic factors thought to affect outcome in patients with low-grade gliomas include the patient's age and neurological status, tumor volume and histological characteristics, and treatment-related variables such as timing of surgical intervention, extent of resection, postoperative tumor volume, and radiation therapy. Patient age and the histological characteristics of the lesion are generally accepted prognostic factors. Among treatment-related factors, timing and extent of resection are controversial because of the lack of randomized controlled trials addressing these issues and the difficulty in obtaining information from available studies that have methodological limitations. All English-language studies on low-grade gliomas published between January 1970 and April 2000 were reviewed. Thirty studies that included statistical analyses were further evaluated with regard to the prognostic effect of extent of resection. Of these 30 studies, those that included pediatric patients, unless adults were analyzed separately, were excluded from further study because of the favorable outcome associated with the pediatric age group. Also excluded were studies including pilocytic and gemistocytic astrocytomas, because the natural histories of these histological subtypes are significantly different from that of low-grade gliomas. Series in which there were small numbers of patients (< 75) were also excluded. Results for oligodendrogliomas are reported separately. Currently, for patients with low-grade glial tumors located in the cerebral hemisphere, the only management standard based on high-quality evidence is tissue diagnosis. All other treatment methods are practice options supported by evidence that is inconclusive or conflicting. The majority of published series that the authors identified had design-related limitations including a small study size, a small number of events (that is, deaths for survival studies), inclusion of pediatric patients, and/or inclusion of various histological types of tumors with different natural histories. Of the 30 series addressing the issue of timing and extent of surgery, almost all had additional design limitations. Methods used to determine the extent of resection were subjective and qualitative in almost all studies. Only five of the 30 series met the authors' criteria, and these studies are discussed in detail.

CONCLUSIONS

Management of low-grade gliomas is controversial and practice parameters are ill defined. This is caused by limited knowledge regarding the natural history of these tumors and the lack of high-quality evidence supporting various treatment options. Although a prospective randomized study seems unlikely, both retrospective matched studies and prospective observational trials will improve the clinician's ability to understand the importance of various prognostic factors.

New perspectives for the diagnosis and treatment of oligodendroglioma

Oligodendroglial tumors (OD) constitute a specific type of glioma, with a better prognosis than astrocytic tumors of similar grade. OD are sensitive to chemotherapy, with 60-65% of patients responding to PCV chemotherapy and a median response duration of 1-1.5 years. This holds for both low- and high-grade OD. Despite this high response rate, most if not all patients are ultimately relapsing, requiring improvement of treatment. The presence of chromosomal lesions on the loci 1p36 and 19q13.3 is related to a favorable response to both chemotherapy and radiation therapy. In the near future molecular analysis will become an important tool to identify glial tumors that are likely to respond to treatment and will be used to select patients for clinical trials. Temozolomide appears to be a promising drug in OD.

PCV for oligodendroglial tumors: in search of prognostic factors for response and survival

BACKGROUND

We report survival and pretreatment prognostic factors for survival and chemosensitivity in 53 oligodendrogliomas treated with PCV (procarbazine, lomustine and vincristine) chemotherapy.

METHODS

A total of 53 patients with histologically proven oligodendroglioma, anaplastic oligodendroglioma or oligo-astrocytoma and treated with PCV were extracted from the London Regional Cancer Center database. A retrospective review was conducted to evaluate overall survival and pretreatment prognostic factors for survival and chemosensitivity.

RESULTS

The median survival time from diagnosis was 123.6 months. The overall five- and ten-year survival rates were 72.7% and 52.7% respectively. Age <40, seizure as an initial symptom, absence of cognitive deficit and presence of a homogeneous hypodense lesion without contrast enhancement on the initial pretreatment CT scan were all factors independently associated with favorable outcome. The presence of increased cellularity, pleomorphism, mitosis, vascular proliferation and grading as an anaplastic lesion using these surrogates on pathological assessment, were all associated with an unfavorable outcome in univariable analysis. In multivariable analysis, only the anaplastic grading and presence of increased cellularity were significant determinants of unfavorable survival. The only factor adversely associated with chemosensitivity was the presence of a focal symptom at presentation.

CONCLUSION

Overall survival is significantly longer in oligodendroglial lesions than in fibrillary astrocytic tumors. A two tier grading system using standard morphological features seems accurate in predicting outcome in these patients. The presence of a neoplastic astrocytic component does not seem to impact the outcome. No clinical, radiological or pathological factor could be identified to reliably predict chemotherapy response.

The prognostic significance of DNA topoisomerase II-alpha (Ki-S1), p21/Cip-1, and p27/Kip-1 protein immunoexpression in oligodendrogliomas

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate a possible association between clinical outcome of patients with oligodendroglioma and expression of 2 cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitors, p21/Cip-1 (p21) and p27/Kip-1 (p27), and of DNA topoisomerase II-alpha (Ki-S1), which has been recently used as a marker of cellular proliferation.

DESIGN

Ninety-one specially selected patients with cerebral oligodendrogliomas treated with surgery and radiotherapy were studied retrospectively. Tumor specimens were immunohistochemically examined with antibodies to p21, p27, and Ki-S1. A computerized color image analyzer was used to count immunostained nuclei.

RESULTS

The mean Ki-S1 labeling index (LI) was found to be significantly prominent for World Health Organization (WHO) high-grade tumors (9.5% vs. 3.2% for WHO low-grade tumors). In contrast, the mean p27 LI was significantly higher for low-grade tumors (43.3% vs 25.7% for high-grade tumors). The number of p21-positive cases and the mean p21 LI were found to be relatively equal for low- and high-grade tumors. For low-grade oligodendrogliomas, the progression-free and overall survival times were found to be significantly shorter for tumors with p27 LIs less than 20%. For high-grade oligodendrogliomas, survival times were significantly reduced for tumors with Ki-S1 LIs greater than 10%. Regression-tree analysis identified 4 groups of oligodendrogliomas with distinctly different outcomes: (1) 32 patients with low-grade tumors and p27 LIs greater than 20%; (2) 14 patients with low-grade tumors and p27 LIs less than 20%; (3) 25 patients with high-grade tumors and Ki-S1 LIs less than 10%; and (4) 20 patients with high-grade tumors and Ki-S1 LIs greater than 10%.

CONCLUSIONS

Immunoreactivity for Ki-S1 and p27 was found to be useful for further subdividing oligodendroglioma prognoses among low-grade and high-grade tumors. It seems unlikely that p21 immunohistochemistry will be of value for determining clinical outcomes for patients with oligodendrogliomas.

Oligodendroglial neoplasms: current concepts, misconceptions, and folklore

Given current prognostic and therapeutic implications, the accurate classification and grading of oligodendroglial neoplasms has become critical. However, the prevalence of morphologically ambiguous gliomas, subjective histologic criteria, personal biases, oligodendroglioma mimics, and the lack of specific oligodendroglioma markers has led to high interobserver variability and created a contentious problem encountered daily in active surgical neuropathology practices. Since histologic assessment is still a powerful prognosticator, it appropriately remains the diagnostic gold standard. However, recent efforts have focused on identifying the most reproducible and clinically relevant criteria, standardizing classification and grading schemes, and searching for useful ancillary biologic and genetic markers capable of further stratifying an otherwise heterogeneous patient population. This paper reviews the morphologic and genetic spectrum of oligodendroglial neoplasms, recent diagnostic and prognostic developments, and potential future directions.

Tomografia computadorizada e ressonância magnética nos oligodendrogliomas: correlação clínica e patológica

Oligodendrogliomas são neoplasias do tecido neuroepitelial glial originárias de oligodendrócitos. São tumores infreqüentes, responsáveis por cerca de 4% a 7% das neoplasias primárias do cérebro, predominantemente supratentoriais. O presente trabalho consistiu na avaliação dos achados de imagem pré-operatória em tomografia computadorizada e ressonância magnética e correlação clínica e patológica, levando-se em consideração a presença de tumores puros ou mistos, com componente astrocitário e o seu grau de anaplasia. O aspecto mais freqüente foi o de lesão hipodensa na tomografia computadorizada ou com hipossinal em T1 e hipersinal em T2 na ressonância magnética, podendo ter componente cístico, com pouco edema ao redor, apresentando calcificações, quase sempre grosseiras, em dois terços dos casos. Reforço após contraste ocorre em 80% dos casos, na maioria discreto.

Reirradiation of primary brain tumours: survival, clinical response and prognostic factors

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

First, the aim was to determine the survival and quality of life after reirradiation of relapsing primary malignant brain tumours. The second aim was to assess the influence of a set of potentially prognostic factors on survival.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Forty-two patients received reirradiation for recurring primary brain tumours. The interval between the two consecutive treatments was at least 1 year. External beam irradiation for the initial and recurrent tumour was usually delivered with two opposing lateral fields or two wedged fields in orthogonal directions. The median physical doses of the first and second radiation course were 50 and 46 Gy, respectively. The median cumulative biological equivalent doses (BED) were 200.4 (alpha/beta = 2 Gy) and 115.2 Gy (alpha/beta = 10 Gy). During follow-up, corticosteroid medication and the WHO-performance were registered at regular intervals. The radiological response was assessed by reviewing all available CT- and MRI-films. Potentially prognostic factors with respect to survival were evaluated by both univariate and multivariate analyses.

RESULTS

A clinical response (i.e. clinical improvement) was seen in 24% of the patients. Of the evaluable patients, nearly one-third showed a complete (8%) or partial (22%) radiological response. The median overall survival (OS) and progression-free survival (PFS) after retreatment were 10.9 and 8.6 months, respectively. By multivariate analysis, four independent prognostic factors for survival were identified: (1), the WHO-score before retreatment (P = 0.002); (2), the length of the interval between treatments (P = 0.008); (3), the tumour histology; and (4), the response to initial treatment (P values, 0.04). The median survival times for patients with WHO-scores of 0-1 and > or = 2 were 14.0 and 7.4 months, respectively. Patients with oligodendrogliomas had a median OS of 27.5 months, whereas patients with astrocytomas had a median OS of 6.9 months after retreatment. Long-term complications of retreatment were seen in three patients, all of whom had a cumulative BED(2) of > 204 Gy (with alpha/beta = 2 Gy). The quality of life after retreatment, however, was well preserved in the majority of patients. They remained ambulant and capable of self-care until the time of progression which occurred after 8.6 months (median PFS).

CONCLUSIONS

After an initial treatment with radiation up to tolerance levels of normal brain tissue, reirradiation of recurring primary brain tumours seems feasible. During the time until clinical progression, patients remained independent with a reasonable quality of life.

Multidisciplinary management of adult anaplastic oligodendrogliomas and anaplastic mixed oligo-astrocytomas

Once thought to be rare, oligodendroglial tumors might actually represent up to 25% of primary glial neoplasms. In recent years, the histologic criteria for the diagnosis of oligodendroglioma have been broadened to include most small cell, monomorphic glial neoplasms. These refinements have led to an increased recognition of oligodendroglial neoplasms, but uniform definitions of pure versus mixed oligodendroglioma as well as the criteria for high-grade (anaplastic) versus low-grade tumors remain elusive. From a prognostic standpoint, the presence of an oligodendroglial component in a malignant glioma predicts longer survivals times for patients treated with surgery, and radiation therapy with or without chemotherapy. High rates of response to PCV (procarbazine, CCNU and Vincristine) chemotherapy also have been noted among patients with anaplastic oligodendroglial neoplasms. Ongoing prospective trials seek to clarify the role of PCV chemotherapy when added to radiation therapy and surgery. In addition, the role of molecular markers as diagnostic aides and guides to therapy and prognosis are being explored for patients with pure and mixed anaplastic oligodendroglial tumors.

Oligodendrogliomas: reproducibility and prognostic value of histologic diagnosis and grading

Prognostic value of histological grading of oligodendroglial tumors is controversial and interobserver reproducibility in grading of these tumors is unknown. Seven neuropathologists and 6 surgical pathologists experienced in brain tumor-diagnosis assessed 124 oligodendroglial tumors operated at the Mayo Clinic (1960-1990). Among histologic parameters upon which current oligodendroglioma grading systems are based, only high cellularity, presence of mitoses, microcalcifications, endothelial hypertrophy, endothelial proliferation, and necrosis appeared to be reproducible. Reproducible histologic features, based on consensus ratings among neuropathologists (defined as > 60%), were evaluated for the association with cause-specific survival by fitting Cox regression models. By univariate analysis, a significant association with survival was found for age, high cellularity, presence of mitoses, endothelial hypertrophy and proliferation and necrosis. On multivariable analysis with a stepwise variable selection method, only age and presence of endothelial proliferation were found to be independently associated with survival with a discriminatory index of the model of 0.68. Mitotic index was significantly associated with survival based on the grading from each separate neuropathologist, but it was not based on consensus, most likely because this was classified as indeterminate in 54% of cases. Alternatively, "models fit" considering the assessment of single neuropathologists, identified a model based on age and on mitotic index with similar discriminatory indices of 0.69-0.7. Our study found few factors independently associated with cause specific-survival among morphological parameters. These findings are consistent with the present WHO stratification of oligodendrogliomas into low- and high-grade variants.

A histopathological contribution to supratentorial glioma grading, definition of mixed gliomas and recognition of low grade glioma with Rosenthal fibers

BACKGROUND

Previous glioma studies have described separate grading systems for oligodendrogliomas and astrocytomas. Many of these gliomas contain mixtures of neoplastic astrocytes and oligodendrocytes. Prognosis may be related to the percentages of these neoplastic components. Previous survival/grading studies have been limited to histopathological features but have not evaluated the importance of percentages of neoplastic components. This study attempted to perceive the relative importance of percentages of neoplastic astrocytes and oligodendrocytes for definition of astroglial, oligodendroglial and mixed oligoastroglial tumors. After determination of these limits we explored the possibility to develop a grading system for common supratentorial gliomas based on reproducible histopathological features.

METHODS

A retrospective study was performed of 362 cases of unselected supratentorial glioma. One hundred and thirty-eight binary and nine continuous histopathological variables, amongst which percentages of neoplastic astrocytes and oligodendrocytes, were scored and related to survival. Only well reproducible histological features were accepted in Cox regression to define glioma grades.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

Supratentorial gliomas appeared to be composed of variable percentages of neoplastic oligodendrocytes and astrocytes, but this spectrum did not correspond to a continuous change in prognosis. Gliomas containing 30% or more neoplastic oligodendrocytes had a slightly better outcome (p < 0.0432) but higher percentages did not further improve prognosis. Percentages of neoplastic astrocytes were not correlated to survival. We therefore propose to designate gliomas containing 30% or more neoplastic oligodendrocytes as oligodendroglial tumors, and others as astroglial tumors. From a prognostic point of view there is no need to recognize mixed oligoastrocytomas. An interesting finding was the recognition of a low grade glioma group with Rosenthal fibers, which had the longest postoperative survival. Another prognosticator of interest concerns the mitotic rate as a continuous variable. Atypical mitoses indicated the worst survival, after necrosis. It was possible to develop a grading system for all supratentorial gliomas using six reproducible histological parameters: necrosis, atypical mitoses, the mitotic rate, endothelial proliferative activity, percentage of neoplastic oligodendrocytes and Rosenthal fibers. This resulted in four grades for astroglial tumors (p < 0.002) and three grades for oligodendroglial tumors (p < 0.008) which differed significantly within each group with respect to survival.

The prognostic significance of vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF C-1) immunoexpression in oligodendroglioma. An analysis of 91 cases

Oligodendrogliomas continue to generate considerable difficulties in identifying prognostic factors, including single histopathological patterns. Among the latter, vascular productive changes have been intensively examined but the obtained results appear to be controversial. Numerous studies have revealed an indisputable importance of vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) immunoreactivity for malignant progression of astrocytomas but the data regarding oligodendrogliomas are heterogeneous. Ninety-one patients with oligodendroglioma were examined retrospectively for VECF immunoexpression. The results demonstrated significant preponderance of intracellular VEGF expression for WHO grade III tumors. Nevertheless, VEGF staining patterns correlated with both progression-free and overall survival only in univariate, but not in multivarite analysis. Only WHO tumor grade was found to be an independent prognostic factor for oligodendroglioma outcome. Therefore, it seems unlikely that VEGF immunohistochemistry will be of value in assessing individual oligodendroglioma prognosis, especially for determining of both progression-free and overall survival from histologically low-grade tumors.

Oligodendroglioma: an appraisal of recent data pertaining to diagnosis and treatment

OBJECTIVE

This article reviews and summarizes recent data on the diagnosis, prognosis, and treatment of oligodendroglial tumors.

METHODS

Histological criteria for optimized diagnosis and grading of oligodendroglial tumors are described and discussed. The therapeutic approaches are analyzed in light of the results of recent series.

RESULTS

Oligodendroglial tumors may be more common than is generally thought. Perinuclear halo and "chicken-wire" pattern, although considered classic histological features of oligodendrogliomas, are unreliable as sole criteria for diagnosis. Nuclear regularity and roundness and an eccentric rim of eosinophilic cytoplasm lacking obvious cell processes are more constant features. Grading should be accomplished using a composite of radiological and histopathological relevant features. The allelic loss of chromosome arms 1p and 19q might be a marker for both chemosensitivity and longer survival after chemotherapy. Oligodendrogliomas are notably chemosensitive when compared with other gliomas. For aggressive lesions, chemotherapy should be used upfront, after surgery.

CONCLUSION

Oligodendrogliomas are underdiagnosed. One unfortunate implication is that a large number of patients may be receiving suboptimal care. A simplification in grading of oligodendroglioma to two grades would reduce the confusion surrounding the classification and better define prognosis and response to treatment modalities. A better definition of the so-called mixed tumor should also allow a better classification of these lesions in an intermediate prognostic class between astrocytic and oligodendroglial lesions. Loss of 1p and 19q could be used as a cytogenetic marker in assisting grading. New concepts emerging in the recent literature should help optimize the diagnosis of these lesions and reduce interobserver variability.

Prognostic relevance of MIB-1 immunoreactivity, S-phase fraction, 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine labeling indices, and mitotic figures in gliomas

Prognostic relevance of cell proliferation markers was evaluated in 27 glioma patients. By 1) flow cytometry (FCM), i.e., S-phase fraction (SPF), and BrdUrd-labeling index (LIfcm); 2) immunohistochemistry (IHC), i.e., BrdUrd-labeling index (LIihc) and MIB-1 immunoreactivity (MIB-1 LIihc); and 3) histologic examination, i.e., the presence or absence of cells in mitoses, were assessed. A longer local progression free survival (LPFS) was significantly associated with low SPF, low LIfcm, and low MIB-1 LIihc. For LIihc, no significant association was found. LIfcm appeared to be a more promising prognosticator than MIB-1 LIihc. In comparison with this marker, the presence or absence of mitotic figures appeared to be an even stronger prognosticator. Prognostic significance of LIfcm appeared to be of importance in low-grade gliomas. The number of patients in our study is limited. Our findings were: 1) the presence or absence of cells in mitoses (M-phase activity) appeared to be of more prognostic significance than LIfcm (S-phase activity) and MIB-1 LIihc (non-G0-phase activity); 2) of the tested experimental cell proliferation markers, LIfcm appeared to be of more prognostic significance than MIB-1 LIihc, SPF, and LIihc; and 3) LIfcm is likely to be an important prognosticator in low-grade gliomas and is, therefore, not definitive and only of potential interest.

The prognostic role of vessel productive changes and vessel density in oligodendroglioma

The recognition of the anaplastic variant of oligodendroglioma is difficult, since it is not easy to identify histological prognostic factors. Among the latter, vascular productive changes have been inconsistently put in relation with survival. In 95 cases of operated oligodendrogliomas, endothelial cell hyperplasia, microvascular proliferations and capillary density were studied by histological and immunohistochemical methods. Capillary density was evaluated on CD31-stained sections by a grid of 100 squares placed in the ocular of the microscope. Statistical analysis was performed in order to compare these parameters with survival. A nodular growth pattern was observed more frequently among tumor grades 3-4 than among tumor grades 1-2. Endothelial cell hyperplasia was more frequent in nodular growth pattern, but it did not correlate with survival. The highest capillary density was found in nodular growth pattern, but it did not correlate with survival as well. Microvascular proliferations correlated with survival only in univariate, but not in multivariate analysis. Age, extent of surgical removal, year of surgery, post-operative Karnofsky score and MIB-1 LI remained associated with survival, as observed in a previous study.

PCV chemotherapy for recurrent oligodendrogliomas and oligoastrocytomas

OBJECTIVE

The role of chemotherapy in the treatment of low-grade oligodendrogliomas and oligoastrocytomas is still unclear. A Phase II study was conducted to determine the benefits and toxicity of the procarbazine, lomustine, and vincristine (PCV) regimen in patients with low-grade oligodendrogliomas and oligoastrocytomas recurrent after surgery alone or surgery with radiotherapy.

METHODS

Patients with both enhancing and nonenhancing tumors were treated with up to six cycles of standard PCV, and response was evaluated by conventional criteria based on computed tomography or magnetic resonance imaging.

RESULTS

Sixteen of 26 patients (62%) responded to PCV: 3 (12%) experienced complete response, 13 (50%) experienced partial response, 8 (31%) had stable disease, and 2 (8%) had progressive disease. All symptomatic patients who responded and three with stable disease improved in seizure frequency, lateralizing signs, and symptoms of intracranial hypertension. The response rate for patients with enhancing lesions revealed by computed tomography or magnetic resonance imaging (74%) was significantly higher than that of patients with nonenhancing lesions (29%) (P < 0.05). Both oligodendrogliomas and oligoastrocytomas responded to PCV, with complete responses occurring in association with pure tumors only. The median time to tumor progression of all 26 patients was 24 months and was significantly longer for those with oligodendrogliomas compared with those with oligoastrocytomas (32 versus 12 mo) (P < 0.001). Chemotherapy was well tolerated, with mild hematological toxicity and rare skin rashes being the most frequent sequelae.

CONCLUSION

These results suggest that chemotherapy with PCV is effective in the treatment of recurrent low-grade oligodendrogliomas and oligoastrocytomas.

The treatment of cerebral oligodendrogliomas with particular reference to features indicating malignancy: report of seventy-seven cases

Oligodendrogliomas are relatively rare tumors that arise from the oligodendrocyte or its precursors. The role of postoperative radiotherapy (RT) in these tumors still remains unclear. Data concerning a study on 77 histologically verified cases of oligodendrogliomas of the brain among a total number of 1884 cases of an intracranial glioma treated at the Hacettepe Medical Centre between 1964 and 1991 were reviewed and analyzed (6.5%). One patient died in the early postoperative period and 8 patients in pediatric age group with an aggressive from of the tumor died within 6 months of treatment. The results suggest that oligodendrogliomas which arise in childhood primarily in the intraventricular region should be considered potentially more malignant than other lesions of this type. Because of this, we believe that postoperative radiotherapy is necessary to prevent the recurrences.

Expression of vascular endothelial growth factor and its receptors in the anaplastic progression of astrocytoma, oligodendroglioma, and ependymoma

Vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) is a hypoxia-inducible angiogenic factor, which is known to be upregulated in most cases of glioblastoma multiforme (GBM). The expression of VEGF and its receptors in ependymomas, oligodendrogliomas, and particularly the expression during anaplastic progression of these three types of gliomas has not been studied extensively. Fifty-six gliomas, consisting of 10 ependymomas, 12 oligodendrogliomas, 3 anaplastic oligodendrogliomas, 6 astrocytomas grade II, 5 anaplastic astrocytomas, and 20 glioblastoma multiformes, were investigated for VEGF and receptor expression using in situ hybridization (ISH) and reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR). Results showed that VEGF was moderately to strongly expressed in 8 of 10 ependymomas and in all anaplastic oligodendrogliomas and glioblastoma multiforme cases. These tumors displayed similar degrees of extensive necrosis and vascular proliferation, with VEGF expression consistently seen in tumor cells around necrotic areas. The VEGF expression, although present at a lower level, also was shown in 4 of 12 oligodendrogliomas, in 3 of 6 astrocytomas grade II, and in 2 of 5 anaplastic astrocytomas, with a regional rather than diffuse pattern of positive result. The findings from the in situ hybridization study correlated with the expression index, as determined by reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction. Expression of VEGF was correlated significantly with vascular proliferation (p < 10(-5)) and necrosis (p < 10(-5)), as well as with microvessel density (p = 0.002, rs = 0.41). The VEGF receptors, kinase domain region (KDR) and Fms-like-tyrosine kinase (Flt-1), also were upregulated in the tumor vasculature of glioblastoma multiforme, anaplastic oligodendrogliomas, and ependymomas with necrosis, whereas the astrocytomas grade II, anaplastic astrocytomas, and oligodendroglioma tumors tended to express a weak to nondetectable signal. Anaplastic progression in all three types of gliomas is heralded by the occurrence of small zones of VEGF-expressing cells and early vascular proliferation, followed by an accelerated phase of angiogenesis closely associated with VEGF induction around areas of necrosis and with the expression of VEGF receptors in the tumor vasculature.

S-phase fraction, 5-bromo-2'-deoxy-uridine labelling index, duration of S-phase, potential doubling time, and DNA index in benign and malignant brain tumors

Seventy-one histologically malignant brain tumors, 52 histologically benign brain tumors, and 14 cerebral metastases were characterized according to DNA content and proliferative capacity. DNA ploidy, DNA index (DI), S-phase fraction (SPF), 5-bromo-2'-deoxy-uridine (BrdUrd) labelling index (LI), duration of S-phase (Ts), and potential doubling time (Tpot) were assessed by flow cytometry (FCM). In histologically benign tumors, a high percentage of DNA diploid tumors and a low proliferative capacity in DNA diploid tumors were found. Histologically malignant tumors and cerebral metastases were both found to be characterized by a low percentage of DNA diploid tumors and a high proliferative capacity in DNA diploid tumors. The proliferative capacity of DNA aneuploid benign tumors and that of DNA aneuploid malignant tumors, however, appeared not to differ significantly. The number of DNA aneuploid tumors was small. Duration of S-phase was short (range 3.9-4.7 hr) and appeared not to differ between the three groups. From this, the observed differences in Tpot values should be accredited mainly to differences in LI. High-grade as well as low-grade gliomas both appeared to be characterized by malignant (FCM) features, i.e., 1) a high percentage DNA aneuploidy, 2) a high mean DI (for DI > 1), and 3) a high proliferative capacity.

The prognostic significance of Ki-67 labeling indices for oligodendrogliomas

OBJECTIVE

The prognostic significance of quantitative measurement of tumor proliferative activity was evaluated for oligodendroglial tumors.

METHODS

Ki-67/MIB-1 immunochemistry was used to measure proliferative activity in 81 oligodendrogliomas and oligoastrocytomas. The relationship among survival, proliferation, histological features, and clinical variables were evaluated using a Cox proportional hazards analysis.

RESULTS

After stratifying by histological grade and adjusting for age at diagnosis, there was a significant association between the Ki-67/MIB-1 labeling index (LI) (percentage of positive cells) and survival (P = 0.04). This association was illustrated further by the significantly different survival of two groups based on LI ranges of less than or equal to 5 and greater than 5 (P < 0.0001).

CONCLUSION

The poor correlation between mitotic figures and survival in oligodendrogliomas that has been reported previously emphasizes the need for an accurate method to measure proliferative activity. Our study demonstrated the usefulness of the Ki-67/MIB-1 LI and demonstrated that LI ranges can be defined for clinical application.

Oligodendrogliomas. Part II: A new grading system based on morphological and imaging criteria

This second part of our study of 'pure' oligodendrogliomas focuses on survival data analysis. In order to identify potentially useful prognostic factors and to assess the effectiveness of a new grading system, the 79 patients in the previously analyzed series for whom adequate follow-up could be obtained (52%) were entered in the present analysis. Statistical analysis demonstrated that contrast enhancement and endothelial hyperplasia had powerful and similar influence on survival. Median survival with and without contrast enhancement were: 3 versus 11 years, and with or without endothelial hyperplasia were: 3.5 versus 11 years. Conversely, the degree of nuclear atypia and presence or absence of mitosis or necrosis were not correlated with survival. These findings allowed us to devise a simple grading system which discriminates two malignancy grades as follows: absence of endothelial hyperplasia and of contrast enhancement = Grade A, presence of endothelial hyperplasia and/or of contrast enhancement = Grade B. Of the 79 oligodendrogliomas in this study, 59 tumors were categorized as grade A and 20 as grade B. Median survival were: 11 years in grade A and 3.5 years in grade B. Five-year and 8-year survival rates were: 89% and 60% in grade A and: 33% and 15% in grade B. Double blind grading between two independent observers was concordant in 96% of the cases. Application of this simple efficient and reproducible grading scheme should permit reliable comparison of retrospective or prospective therapeutic data emanating from various institutions.