Internal radiation therapy for hepatocellular carcinoma. Results of a French multicenter phase II trial of transarterial injection of iodine 131-labeled Lipiodol

Radiopharmaceutical therapy in cancer: clinical advances and challenges

Radiopharmaceutical therapy (RPT) is emerging as a safe and effective targeted approach to treating many types of cancer. In RPT, radiation is systemically or locally delivered using pharmaceuticals that either bind preferentially to cancer cells or accumulate by physiological mechanisms. Almost all radionuclides used in RPT emit photons that can be imaged, enabling non-invasive visualization of the biodistribution of the therapeutic agent. Compared with almost all other systemic cancer treatment options, RPT has shown efficacy with minimal toxicity. With the recent FDA approval of several RPT agents, the remarkable potential of this treatment is now being recognized. This Review covers the fundamental properties, clinical development and associated challenges of RPT.

History and development of radioembolization: an old idea with modern applications

The current review documents the major hallmarks in the history and development of radioembolization, the origins of which date back to the late 1940s. Radioembolization was initially abandoned because of the increased incidence of adverse effects and lack of commercial interest; however, it regained avid interest in clinical trials and has achieved established clinical utility in the last 15 years. This review focuses on the main stations of the evolution of radioembolization, namely, initial animal and human experimental studies, production of Y-microspheres, development of current therapeutic agents (resin and glass spheres and labeled Lipiodol), prediction and prevention of inadvertent, extrahepatic shunt side effects, initial prospective studies, and large randomized trials till final approval from the relevant official bodies. The historical knowledge of the initial concepts of the method and the limitations encountered may pave the way toward further evolution and possible new applications.

Therapeutic Strategies in HCC: Radiation Modalities

Patients with hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) comply with an advanced disease and are not eligible for radical therapy. In this distressed scenario new treatment options hold great promise; among them transarterial chemoembolization (TACE) and transarterial metabolic radiotherapy (TAMR) have shown efficacy in terms of both tumor shrinking and survival. External radiation therapy (RTx) by using novel three-dimensional conformal radiotherapy has also been used for HCC patients with encouraging results while its role had been limited in the past for the low tolerance of surrounding healthy liver. The rationale of TAMR derives from the idea of delivering exceptional radiation dose locally to the tumor, with cell killing intent, while preserving normal liver from undue exposition and minimizing systemic irradiation. Since the therapeutic efficacy of TACE is being continuously disputed, the TAMR with ¹³¹I Lipiodol or ⁹⁰Y microspheres has gained consideration providing adequate therapeutic responses regardless of few toxicities. The implementation of novel radioisotopes and technological innovations in the field of RTx constitutes an intriguing field of research with important translational aspects. Moreover, the combination of different therapeutic approaches including chemotherapy offers captivating perspectives. We present the role of the radiation-based therapies in hepatocellular carcinoma patients who are not entitled for radical treatment.

How grim is hepatocellular carcinoma?

Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is a complex disease and a major cause of death in high endemic areas of hepatitis B virus (HBV) or hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection. HCC has gone from being a universal death sentence to a cancer that can be prevented, detected at an early stage and effectively treated. Liver resection or tumour ablation techniques may be effective bridge to liver transplantation if they fulfill the Milan criteria. The areas of progress in HCC are in the control of HBV or HCV and the development of adjuvant or neoadjuvant therapies.

Survival after 131I-labeled lipiodol therapy for hepatocellular carcinoma

This study investigated the efficacy of 131iod- ine-labeled lipiodol (1311-lipiodol) as a palliative therapy, evaluated overall survival (OS) across Barcelona Clinic Liver Cancer (BCLC) stages, and determined the main prognostic factors influencing OS in patients with hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). Patients, methods: We retrospectively analyzed 57 (44 men; mean age, 65.7 years; mean activity per session, 1.6 GBq; mean cumulative activity in patients with >1 sessions, 3.9 GBq) HCC patients who underwent 1311-lipiodol therapy. A majority of patients exhibited Child-Pugh class B (53.6%) disease and a good Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group performance status (0-1; 72%). Multinodular disease was observed in 87.7% patients, bilobar disease in 73%, and portal vein occlusion (PVO) in 54%. Furthermore, 21.1% patients were staged as BCLC B and 59.6 % as BCLC C. All patients were followed until death. Results: The median OS was 6.4 months, which varied significantly with disease stage (median OS for BCLC A, B, C, and D was 29.4, 12.0, 4.6, and 2.7 months, respectively; p = 0.009); Child-Pugh score and class; presence of ascites, PVO, or extrahepatic disease; largest lesion size; favourable treatment response; international normalized ratio, baseline albumin and alpha-fetopro- tein levels. Patients with a Child-Pugh A liver disease had a longer OS. Conclusion: Currently, different treatment modalities for HCC include radioembolization, transarterial chemoemboliz- ation, and systemic therapy with sorafenib; however, 1311-lipiodol therapy remains a feasible alternative for patients without a favourable response to other therapies, particularly for patients with Child-Pugh A liver cirrhosis.

Palliation: treating patients with inoperable biliary tract and primary liver tumors

This article summarizes the current literature in treatment of unresectable biliary tract and primary liver tumors. Locoregional therapies including radiofrequency ablation, percutaneous ethanol injection, cryoablation, microwave ablation, transarterial chemoembolization, hepatic artery infusion, radioembolization ((90)Y), and bland embolization are discussed and clinical trials compared. Palliative strategies including surgical, percutaneous, and endoscopic techniques to decompress the biliary system and improve symptoms are also summarized. Systemic chemotherapy and sorafenib used in conjunction with locoregional therapies or as sole therapeutic options are discussed.

Treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) by intra-arterial infusion of radio-emitter compounds: trans-arterial radio-embolisation of HCC

Traditional radiotherapy is only effective in treating hepatocellular cancer (HCC) in doses above 50 Gy, but this is above the recommended liver radiation exposure of about 35 Gy, which is an important limitation making this treatment unsuitable for routine clinical practice. Trans-arterial radio-embolisation (TARE), consists of delivery of compounds linked to radio-emitter particles which end up in hepatic end-arterioles or show affinity for the neoplasm itself, allowing localised delivery of doses beyond 120 Gy. These are well tolerated in patients treated with this type of internal radiation therapy. TARE for HCC is used for palliative treatment of advanced disease which cannot be treated in other ways, or for tumour down-staging before liver transplantation, or as adjuvant therapy for surgically resected HCC. Tumour response after TARE is between 25% and 60% if assessed by using RECIST criteria, and 80% by EASL criteria. In this review we outline the advantages and limitations of radio-emitter therapy including 131-I, 90-Y and 188-Re. We include several observational, and all comparative studies using these compounds. In particular we compare TARE to trans-arterial chemo-embolisation and other intra-arterial techniques.

Meta-analysis of interstitial pneumonia in studies evaluating iodine-131-labeled lipiodol for hepatocellular carcinoma using exact likelihood approach

PURPOSE

Iodine-131-labeled lipiodol is currently licensed for unresectable hepatocellular carcinoma with portal thrombosis. It is thought to be well tolerated. Cases of interstitial pneumonia have been reported, but their frequency (≈2%) has not been well estimated. Quantifying adverse drug event frequency requires an appropriate statistical approach because standard methods are biased.

METHODS

To estimate the frequency of interstitial pneumonia in patients with hepatocellular carcinoma receiving iodine-131-labeled lipiodol, we conducted a systematic review of English articles using MEDLINE and EMBASE. All types of articles were considered except case reports. Primary outcome measure was symptomatic interstitial pneumonia based on investigators' judgment. All pooled analyses were based on a random effects meta-analysis model using an exact likelihood approach based on the binomial within-study distribution.

RESULTS

Ten studies, including 142 patients, used low activity per dose, ranging from 0.3 to 1.1 GBq. No respiratory adverse event was noticed in these studies. Eighteen studies, including 542 patients, evaluated higher activity per dose, around 2.2 GBq; 24 cases of interstitial pneumonia were reported in these studies. Estimated frequency of interstitial pneumonia was 1.6% (95%CI, 0.4-6.4%) after one high dose and 4.1% (95%CI, 1.0-16.0%) after two or more high doses.

CONCLUSIONS

The frequency of interstitial pneumonia appears higher and more precise than previously estimated. The risk appears to be related to the number of injections and the dose level per injection. Generalized linear mixed models using the exact binomial within-study distribution initially described to summarize data on diagnostic evaluation could be relevant for drug-related adverse reaction frequency assessment.

Iodine-131-lipiodol therapy in hepatic tumours

The incidence of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is worldwide sharply on the rise and patients with advanced disease carry a poor prognosis. HCC is the sixth most common cancer and the third leading cause of cancer associated deaths in the world. Intra-arterially administered (131)I-Lipiodol is selectively retained by hepatocellular carcinomas, and has been used as a vehicle for delivery of therapeutic agents to these tumours. In this review we focus on the therapeutic indications, usefulness and methods of treatment with 131-Iodine Lipiodol. The effectiveness of (131)I-Lipiodol treatment is proven both in the treatment of HCC with portal thrombosis and also as an adjuvant to surgery after the resection of HCCs. It is at least as effective as chemoembolization and is tolerated much better. Severe liver dysfunction represents theoretic contraindication for radioembolization as well as for TACE. In such cases (131)I-Lipiodol is an alternative therapy option especially in tumours smaller than 6cm.

Stereotactic radiation therapy and selective internal radiation therapy for hepatocellular carcinoma

Recent technological advances allow precise and safe radiation delivery in hepatocellular carcinoma. Stereotactic body radiotherapy is a conformal external beam radiation technique that uses a small number of relatively large fractions to deliver potent doses of radiation therapy to extracranial sites. It requires stringent breathing motion control and image guidance. Selective internal radiotherapy or radioembolization refers to the injection of radioisotopes, usually delivered to liver tumors via the hepatic artery. Clinical results for both treatments show that excellent local control is possible with acceptable toxicity. Most appropriate patient populations and when which type of radiation therapy should be best employed in the vast therapeutic armamentarium of hepatocellular carcinoma are still to be clarified.

Treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma with intra-arterial injection of radionuclides

Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is becoming an important public health concern. Current therapeutic options are limited and new treatments are therefore being developed. The intra-arterial treatment chemoembolization has limited efficacy and few prospects for further progress. One particularly promising, though little used, alternative to chemoembolization is radioembolization with iodine-131 ((131)I) or rhenium-188 labeled lipiodol or yttrium-90 labeled microspheres (glass or resin beads). Three randomized studies have proven the effectiveness of (131)I-lipiodol in patients with HCC-as adjuvant therapy after surgery, compared with chemoembolization, and also in patients who have portal vein thrombosis. Microspheres enable the delivery of high-dose radiation (>200 Gy) to the tumor while sparing the neighboring hepatic tissue from overexposure. Overall, the efficacy of radioembolization has been good and toxic effects have been low. These results are comparable to those obtained with chemoembolization but further improvement can be expected by combining radioembolization with standard chemotherapy or with targeted therapies, such as anti-angiogenic drugs.

Intra-arterial rhenium-188 lipiodol in the treatment of inoperable hepatocellular carcinoma: results of an IAEA-sponsored multination study

PURPOSE

Intra-arterial injections (IAI) of 131I-lipiodol is effective in treating hepatocellular carcinoma patients, but is expensive and requires a 7-day hospitalization in a radioprotection room. 188Re is inexpensive, requires no patient isolation, and can be used with lipiodol.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

This International Atomic Energy Agency-sponsored phase II trial aimed to assess the safety and the efficacy of a radioconjugate 188Re + lipiodol (188Re-Lip) in a large cohort of hepatocellular carcinoma patients from developing countries. A scout dose is used to determine the maximal tolerated dose (lungs <12 Gy, normal liver <30 Gy, bone marrow <1.5 Gy) and then the delivery of the calculated activity. Efficacy was assessed using response evaluation criteria in solid tumor (RECIST) and alpha-feto-protein (alpha FP) levels and severe adverse events were graded using the Common Toxicity Criteria of the National Cancer Institute scale v2.0.

RESULTS

The trial included 185 patients from eight countries. The procedure was feasible in all participating centers. One treatment was given to 134 patients; 42, 8, and 1 received two, three, and four injections, respectively. The injected activity during the first treatment was 100 mCi. Tolerance was excellent. We observed three complete responses and 19 partial responses (22% of evaluable patients, 95% confidence interval 16-35%); 1- and 2-year survivals were 46% and 23%. Some factors affected survival: country of origin, existence of a cirrhosis, Cancer of the Liver Italian Program score, tumor dose, absence of progression, and posttreatment decrease in alpha FP level.

CONCLUSIONS

IAI of 188Re-Lip in developing countries is feasible, safe, cost-effective, and deserves a phase III trial.

Eradication of hepatocellular carcinoma xenografts by radiolabelled, lipiodol-inducible gene therapy

The promoter region of the early-growth response-1(Egr-1) gene has been shown to be activated by external radiation, thus making a selective tumoricidal effect possible. A previous experiment showed that the Egr-1 promoter can be activated by internal radiation using radioisotopes as well as external radiation. Internal radiation using I-131 lipiodol (I-131-Lip) has been established as one of the most useful therapeutic strategies against hepatoma. We herein linked the Egr-1 promoter to the herpes simplex virus-thymidine kinase (HSV-TK) gene, and investigated its efficacy in hepatoma gene therapy in combination with I-131-Lip. A luciferase assay showed the Egr-1-promoter activity to be markedly increased in hepatoma tissue specimens in an I-131-dose-dependent manner, whereas a less than two-fold increase in this activity was observed in other organs. In addition, the radioactivity derived from I-131 was selectively accumulated in the tumor tissue specimens. To examine the efficacy of EgrTK/ganciclovir (GCV) gene therapy in vivo, subcutaneous hepatoma xenografts in nude mice were transfected using a hemagglutinating virus of Japan (HVJ)-liposome vector. Complete tumor regression was observed in all the EgrTK-transfected tumors following combination treatment with I-131-Lip and GCV 42 days after treatment without any side effects (n=8). In contrast, the tumors continued to grow in all control mice (n=10). Furthermore, the serum alpha-fetoprotein levels decreased in the combination therapy group, while they increased in the controls. In conclusion, these data indicate that Egr-1 promoter-based gene therapy combined with internal radiation has a selective effect on hepatoma tumors while also showing an improved in vivo efficacy. This combination therapy might, therefore, be an effective human hepatoma gene therapy, even in advanced multiple cases.

Association of cisplatin and intra-arterial injection of 131I-lipiodol in treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma: results of phase II trial

PURPOSE

Intra-arterial injections of 131I-lipiodol (131I-Lip) provide an effective treatment for hepatocellular carcinoma. In hepatocellular carcinoma cell cultures, concurrent administration of cisplatin increases the cytotoxicity of 131I. The efficacy and tolerance of intra-arterial injections of 131I-Lip combined with systemic cisplatin was tested in a phase II trial.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

The inclusion criteria were proven unresectable nonmetastatic hepatocellular carcinoma, compensated liver disease, and adequate laboratory test findings. Treatment comprised the combination of intra-arterial injection of 131I-Lip (2.2 GBq) with intravenous infusion of low-dose cisplatin. The combined treatment could be repeated.

RESULTS

A total of 41 patients were included; 37 had cirrhosis and 38 had measurable tumors. One to four treatments (median, two) were given. The cisplatin dose was 75 mg for the first course and 72 mg for the second. Grade 3-4 (n/n) adverse effects were observed in 14 patients, polymorphonuclear leukocytes (3/0), platelets (5/1), asthenia (1/0), pain (1/0), and vomiting (1/0). Four patients developed pulmonary toxicity; 2 cases were likely related to 131I-Lip administration and 1 was fatal. The response rate was 47% (18 of 38), and the 1- and 2-year survival rate was 73% +/- 7% and 48% +/- 9%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

This combination had a tolerable toxicity profile and provided an objective response rate, warranting a phase III trial.

131I-Labelled-iodized oil for palliative treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma

BACKGROUND

The incidence of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is growing in western countries. Poor liver status and tumour size make curative options scarce. Palliative treatments such as chemo-embolization are improving survival in selected patients, but side-effects are frequent. There is a need for the validation of alternative treatments. Metabolic radiotherapy using lipiodol labelled with 131I-iodine (I-131-lipiodol) is one of these treatments.

OBJECTIVES

To analyse the effect of I-131-lipiodol in a population of advanced HCC patients and to define the potential prognostic factors in this setting.

METHODS

A retrospective analysis of the effect of I-131-lipiodol on 29 patients bearing multifocal tumours was performed. An analysis of two subgroups, defined by a Cancer of the Liver Italian Program (CLIP) score of 2 or less (n=20) or greater than 2 (n=9) was performed to assess the prognostic significance of the score in this setting.

RESULTS

Overall median survival in the entire study population was 203 days (95% confidence interval 83-322 days). Median survival was significantly better in the group with CLIP scores of 2 or less than in the group with CLIP scores greater than 2 (453 versus 60 days, P< or =0.001). Treatment-related mortality was 6.9% (one interstitial pneumonia and one acute liver failure).

CONCLUSION

The survival of patients treated with I-131-lipiodol in this series compared favourably with published data. Stratification according to the CLIP score was useful to predict survival. In particular, patients with portal vein thrombosis should only be considered for I-131-lipiodol if the CLIP score is lower than 2.

Effect of Stabilized Iodized Oil Emulsion on Experimentally Induced Hepatocellular Carcinoma in Rats

PURPOSE

Previous studies have shown that the use of Lipiodol UltraFluid (LUF) emulsified with water leads to an increase in the tumoral uptake of iodine I 131-labeled LUF and reduced pulmonary uptake. Although emulsions containing LUF are currently used for chemoembolization of hepatocellular carcinomas (HCCs), this approach is impossible with intraarterial radiation therapy (RT) because of the problems of radiation protection linked to instability of the emulsions. The aims of this study were to develop stabilized emulsions of radiolabeled LUF of different particle sizes and viscosities and to study its biodistribution in rats with HCC.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

An emulsifier made of polyethylene glycol and hydrogenated castor oil was used to stabilize emulsions containing water and technetium Tc 99m-labeled Super Six Sulfur LUF. The various emulsions were injected in the hepatic arteries of rats with HCC. Twenty-four hours after injection, the rats were killed and the liver, tumor, and lungs were removed to perform ex-vivo gamma-counting to quantify tumoral, hepatic, and pulmonary uptake.

RESULTS

Emulsions of oil in water and water in oil of different viscosities (0.68-1.06 Pa.S) and particle size distributions (21-45 mum) were prepared and kept stable for more than 24 hours. Whatever the type of emulsion, the observed effect on tumoral uptake was the opposite of that expected. Indeed, a decrease in tumoral activity was observed (P < .05 in three of five cases) and a tendency toward increased pulmonary activity was observed (P < .05 in two of five cases) rather than any significant decrease.

CONCLUSIONS

This study made it possible to develop emulsions of radiolabeled iodized oil that remain stable for more than 24 hours. However, studies of biodistribution in rats with HCC failed to demonstrate any improvement in tumoral targeting, but rather showed a decrease in tumoral uptake that renders this approach impractical for intraarterial radiolabeled iodized oil RT as well as for intraarterial iodized oil chemoembolization. These results may possibly be explained by the use of an emulsifier containing lipophilic and hydrophilic components that modify the properties of LUF.

Preoperative treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma with intra-arterial injection of 131I-labelled lipiodol (Br J Surg 2003; 90: 1379-1383)

The Editors welcome topical correspondence from readers relating to articles published in the Journal. Responses can be sent electronically via the BJS website (www.bjs.co.uk) or by post. All letters will be reviewed and, if approved, appear on the website. A selection of these will be edited and published in the Journal. Letters must be no more than 250 words in length. Letters submitted by post should be typed on A4-sized paper in double spacing and should be accompanied by a disk.

Safe radiation exposure of medical personnel by using simple methods of radioprotection while administering 131I-lipiodol therapy for hepatocellular carcinoma

The intra-arterial administration of 131I-lipiodol is a therapeutic approach increasingly used for the treatment of inoperable hepatocellular carcinomas. This technique has even become the reference treatment for hepatocellular carcinomas with portal thrombosis and is the only effective treatment to reduce the risk of recurrence among patients who could benefit from surgical operation. Currently, few data have been published concerning the levels of exposure for personnel carrying out this type of treatment. We undertook a dosimetric study targeted mainly on the exposure of the person performing the injection of 131I-lipiodol to show that this treatment can be carried out with an exposure at the extremities distinctly lower than the regulatory annual threshold by using simple means of radioprotection. The point of puncture was carried out at the level of left femoral artery, the preparation and injection of the therapeutic dose was carried out extemporaneously by the nuclear medicine specialist using a 10 ml syringe (for an injected volume of 4 ml) fitted with an adapted syringe protector. The injection was carried out as rapidly as possible under scopic control while avoiding reflux, with compression carried out by the radiologist. This study comprises 52 intra-arterial injections of 131I-lipiodol (2016+/-92 MBq). For the nuclear medicine specialists, 52 measurements were carried out at the level of the thorax and 41 on the fingers. For the radiologists, 22 measurements were carried out at the level of the thorax and six on their index fingers; nine measurements were carried out at the level of the thorax for the technologist and four at the level of the thorax for the stretcher bearer. For the nuclear medicine specialists, the average dose received at the level of the fingers varies between 140 and 443 microSv (according to the fingers) and the average dose at the thorax is 17 microSv. For the radiologists, the average dose received is 215 microSv at the level of the fingers and 15 microSv at the thorax. These results show that the administration of high therapeutic activities of 131I-lipiodol can be carried out for the exposed personnel with a dose at the level of the fingers much lower than the European regulatory limit of 500 mSv.

Patient dosimetry for 131I-lipiodol therapy

Patient dosimetry data for intra-arterial()iodine-131 lipiodol therapy for hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) are scarce. The aim of this study was to determine the absorbed dose (D) to the tumour and healthy tissues, as well as the effective dose (E), by different methods for 17 therapies in 15 patients who received a mean activity of 1.9 GBq (SD 0.2) (131)I-lipiodol. Eight patients received thyroid blocking by potassium iodide (KI). Patient dosimetry was performed based on bi-planar total body scans using the Monte Carlo simulation program MCNP-4B and the MIRDOSE-3 standard software program. CT images of each patient were used to determine liver and tumour volume and position. The total body dose to the patient was also determined by biological dosimetry with the in vitro micronucleus (MN) assay. From the increase in micronucleus yield after therapy, the equivalent total body dose (ETBD) was calculated. Results for D and E were comparable between MCNP and MIRDOSE (liver: mean 7.8 Gy, SD 1.8, lungs: 6.8 Gy, SD 2.9, E: 2.01 Gy, SD 0.58). MIRDOSE gave a systematic overestimation for the tumour dose, especially for tumours <3 cm (15%). The MCNP method is more accurate since the dose contributions from tumour to organs and vice versa can be accounted for. The absorbed dose to the thyroid was significantly lower for patients who received KI (7.2 Gy, SD 2.2) than for the other patients (13.8 Gy, SD 5.0). MN yields could be obtained for only 12 of the 17 therapies due to hypersplenism. A mean ETBD of 1.66 Gy (SD 0.73) was obtained, but the MN results showed no correlation between the ETBD and the total body dose values of the physical dosimetry. Also, in all except one of the patients, no further reduction in the number of thrombocytes was observed after therapy, probably due to the existing hypersplenism. It is concluded that in view of the high E values, patient dosimetry is necessary for patients receiving (131)I-lipiodol therapy. Except in the case of the smaller tumours, comparable results were obtained with MCNP and MIRDOSE. Due to hypersplenism, biological dosimetry results based on the MN assay are not reliable.

Intra-arterial radionuclide therapy for liver tumours: effect of selectivity of catheterization and 131I-Lipiodol delivery on tumour uptake and response

Several authors have demonstrated the good tolerance of hepatic intra-arterial 131I-Lipiodol therapy and report survival rates of 21-25% after 1 year in inoperable patients. This study explored the possibility that more selective hepatic arterial instillation could be a strategy for increasing tumoural uptake and response of 131I-Lipiodol. Between June 1999 and September 2001 we selected 24 patients: 14 received a selective instillation of 131I-Lipiodol to the proper hepatic artery (SEL group); and 10 received a hyperselective instillation in the right or left hepatic artery (HYP-SEL group). The individual 131I-Lipiodol activity as a per cent of the injected activity per millilitre of tumour (%IA/ml tumour) was correlated with the selectivity of instillation in 28 tumours and with tumour response in 24 tumours. Differences in tumour response or tumour uptake between the SEL and HYP-SEL groups were not significant. In general, we observed a %IA/ml tumour of 0.05-2.6% for the uptake of 131I-Lipiodol. The uptake was significantly higher in responsive disease than in stable or progressive disease (P=0.002). A large tumour volume was invariably related to low uptake of 131I-Lipiodol and progressive disease (P=0.008). In conclusion, our study does not support the general use of hyper-selective or super-selective intra-arterial administration of 131I-Lipiodol. This result may be extrapolated to similar types of intra-arterial, loco-regional hepatic radionuclide therapy.

Locoregional therapies for hepatocellular carcinoma: a critical review from the surgeon's perspective

OBJECTIVE

This article reviews the current results of various locoregional therapies for hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC), with special reference to the implications for surgeons.

SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA

Resection or transplantation is the treatment of choice for HCC, but most patients are not suitable candidates. The past decade has witnessed the development of a variety of locoregional therapies for HCC. Surgeons are faced with the challenge of adopting these therapies in the management of patients with resectable or unresectable HCC.

METHODS

A review of relevant English-language articles was undertaken based on a Medline search from January 1990 to August 2001.

RESULTS

Retrospective studies suggested that transarterial chemoembolization is an effective treatment for inoperable HCC, but its perceived benefit for survival has not been substantiated in randomized trials, presumably because its antitumor effect is offset by its adverse effect on liver function. Nonetheless, it remains a widely used palliative treatment for HCC not amenable to resection or ablative therapies, and it also plays an important role as a treatment of postresection recurrence and as a pretransplant therapy for transplantable HCC. Better patient selection, selective segmental chemoembolization, and treatment repetition tailored to tumor response and patient tolerance may improve its benefit-risk ratio. Transarterial radiotherapy is a less available alternative that produces results similar to those of chemoembolization. Percutaneous ethanol injection has gained wide acceptance as a safe and effective treatment for HCCs 3 cm or smaller. Uncertainty in tumor necrosis limits its potential as a curative treatment, but its repeatability allows treatment of recurrence after ablation or resection of HCC that is crucial to prolongation of survival. Cryotherapy affords a better chance of cure because of predictable necrosis even for HCCs larger than 3 cm, but its use is limited by a high complication rate. There has been recent enthusiasm for heat ablation by microwave, radiofrequency, or laser, which provides predictable necrosis with a low complication rate. Preliminary data indicated that radiofrequency ablation is superior to ethanol injection in the radicality of tumor ablation. The advent of more versatile radiofrequency probes has allowed ablation of HCCs larger than 5 cm. Recent studies have suggested that combined transarterial embolization and heat ablation is a promising strategy for large HCCs. Thus far, no randomized trials comparing various thermoablative therapies have been reported. It is also uncertain whether a percutaneous route, laparoscopy, or open surgery affords the best approach for these therapies. Thermoablative therapies have been combined with resection or used to treat postresection recurrence, and they have also been used as a pretransplant therapy. However, the value of such strategies requires further evaluation.

CONCLUSIONS

Advances in locoregional therapies have led to a major breakthrough in the management of unresectable HCC, but the exact role of the various modalities needs to be defined by randomized studies. Novel thermoablative techniques provide the surgeon with an exciting opportunity to participate actively in the management of unresectable HCC. Locoregional therapies are also useful adjuncts in the management of patients with resectable or transplantable disease. Hence, surgeons must be equipped with the latest knowledge and techniques of ablative therapy to provide the most appropriate treatment for the wide spectrum of patients with HCC.

131I lipiodol therapy for unresectable hepatocellular carcinoma

BACKGROUND

More than 80% of hepatocellular carcinoma tumours (HCC) are unresectable at presentation because of the multicentric nature of the disease or the severity of liver disease. Arterially administered lipiodol is preferentially retained by HCC and has been used as a vehicle for delivery of therapeutic agents to the tumour. The aim of this phase I study is to present the experience with 131I-labelled lipiodol in the treatment of unresectable HCC.

METHODS

131Iodine lipiodol treatment was administered to 12 patients with unresectable HCC between 1994 and 1999. The outcome of treatment in these patients was evaluated for survival, clinical tolerance, liver function tests, alpha-fetoprotein (AFP) levels and changes in tumour size on computed tomography (CT) scans.

RESULTS

Ten of the 12 patients received more than one 131I treatment. Five patients had treatment for post-resection recurrence. Serum AFP levels dropped initially in five of the seven patients with elevated values. Tumour size, evaluated by CT scans at 3 months, decreased in six patients and remained stable in the rest, except one patient in whom both the AFP level and tumour size had increased. Using life table analysis, the 50% survival was 19 months.

CONCLUSIONS

Intra-arterial 131I treatment was very well tolerated. A reduction in AFP levels and tumour size occurred in half of the patients and resulted in a 50% probability of survival of 19 months. Further examination of the value of this treatment in phase II and III studies is required.

Non-surgical treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma

Primary hepatocellular cancer is a disease with a poor prognosis for which there is little consensus on treatment and a paucity of comparative trials. The coexistence of cancer with cirrhosis complicates treatment, and also confers a high risk for the development of further tumours. Surgery, either by hepatic resection or orthotopic liver transplantation, is only a feasible option in a minority of patients. This article surveys the non-surgical approaches to the treatment of hepatocellular cancers-local ablation techniques, arterial embolization with and without chemotherapy, conventional chemotherapy and hormonal modulation, and targeted and external irradiation.

Nonsurgical treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma

Given the poor prognosis of HCC and the therapeutic challenge posed by underlying liver cirrhosis, efforts and resources must be directed towards preventive strategies. Return on the investment in such research is likely to be greater than can be expected from treatment of advanced disease.

Hepatic intraarterial 131I iodized oil for treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma in patients with impeded portal venous flow

PURPOSE

To evaluate the efficacy and safety of intraarterial hepatic iodine 131 iodized oil for treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma in patients with impeded portal venous flow.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Twenty-four patients (mean age, 61 years) with hepatocellular carcinoma underwent 38 courses of 131I iodized oil (one to three per patient), with a mean dose of 2,146 MBq injected into the proper hepatic artery. Hepatocellular carcinoma manifested as single nodules (n = 8; mean, 7.75 cm), multiple nodules (n = 13; mean, 5.46 cm), or a mass (n = 3) occupying more than two hepatic segments. Portal venous thrombosis was complete (n = 10), right (n = 9), left (n = 2), or multisegmental (n = 1). Two patients had hepatofugal portal flow.

RESULTS

Among the 23 patients with evaluable results, response to treatment was partial in three, and disease was stable in 12 and progressive in eight. Estimated actuarial survival rates were 70%, 33%, 12%, and 6% at 3, 6, 9, and 12 months, respectively, with two patients alive at 9 and 11 months. The median survival time was 147 days. Adverse events were the early death of one patient owing to hepatic failure and transient symptomatic hepatic failure after 12 courses in nine patients.

CONCLUSION

In this preliminary experience, intraarterial hepatic 131I iodized oil did not demonstrate high efficacy in the treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma in patients with portal venous thrombosis, as side effects were not rare.

Liver metastases from transitional cell carcinoma are lipiodol avid

A case of transitional cell carcinoma of the bladder with symptomatic liver metastases is presented. When conventional chemotherapy failed, a lipiodol CT scan demonstrated avid uptake by the tumours, which has implications for targeted cancer therapy.

Nonresectional therapies for hepatocellular carcinoma

BACKGROUND

Surgical resection is generally accepted as the first choice of treatment for hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). However, due to its multifocal nature, association with chronic liver disease, and frequent postresectional recurrence, nonresectional therapies are important in the management of a significant proportion of patients with HCC.

DATA SOURCES

A literature review was performed on the current status of different nonresectional treatment modalities commonly employed for HCC. They include direct ablation methods, systemic chemotherapy, transcatheter arterial chemoembolization, external and targeting radiotherapy, hormonal therapy, and immunotherapy. Multidisciplinary therapy resulting in preoperative cytoreduction has also been reported with improvement of therapeutic results.

CONCLUSION

Nonresectional therapies play an essential role in the treatment of inoperable HCC as they lead to satisfactory survival. Percutaneous ethanol injection and transcatheter arterial chemoembolization are the most frequently employed modalities, and they result in a 3-year survival rate of 55% to 70% and about 20%, respectively. Multidisciplinary therapy appears to be the current trend of management and improved survival is achieved especially when unresectable tumors are converted to resectable ones.

Clinical observation of 125I-labeled anti-alpha fetoprotein antibody radioimmunotherapy in hepatocellular carcinoma

AIM: To observe the therapeutic effects and toxic side effects of ¹²⁵I labeled horse anti-human alpha fetoprotein (AFP) polyclonal antibodies in immune targeted therapy against hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC).

METHODS: A modified chloramine-T method to produce nuclide ¹²⁵I labeled horse anti-human AFP polyclonal antibodies was used to treat 22 cases of HCC. Drugs were administered by intravenous drip. The median dose of ¹²⁵I in the whole group was 289.3 (100.3-708.9) MBq. In this series of 22 cases, 19 were evaluated. HCC cases of the same period treated by ¹³¹I anti AFP (A group), anti-cancer drugs and anti AFP conjugates (B group) and chemotherapy alone (C group) were used as controls.

RESULTS: The effective rate (CR + PR) was 31.6%, tumor shrinkage rate was 63.2% (12/19), AFP descending rate 64.7% (11/17) and 6 cases became AFP negative. The post treatment 1 year survival rate was 47.1% (8/17). Seven cases are still alive. Five cases survived 14.33 mo, showing good therapeutic tolerance and minimal toxic side effects.

CONCLUSION: The therapeutic effect in the treatment group was significantly better than that of the control groups. This may be due to the effect of the continuous radiation of the long half life ¹²⁵I within the tumor cells.

Etiology, screening, and treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma

The prognosis with large hepatocellular carcinomas is poor, and only palliative treatment is available. Small tumors are amenable to several modes of treatment, including liver transplantation, resection, or alcohol injection, with acceptable 5-year survival rates. Although the value of screening for hepatocellular carcinoma has yet to be shown, these data, coupled with the recognition of at-risk groups and useful diagnostic techniques, might encourage the clinician to screen at-risk patients in the clinic. New imaging techniques such as ultrasonographic angiography enhanced with CO2 microbubbles, or color Doppler ultrasound, may clarify the intratumoral blood flow of small tumors.

Limitations of hyperselective intraarterial injections for the treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma

The authors report the case of a cirrhotic patient with a multinodular hepatocellular carcinoma. Two nodules were located in the right liver lobe and a minute nodule was in the left lobe. Because of poor liver function, two injections of iodine-131-labeled Lipiodol were delivered in the right hepatic artery to protect the left lobe. The efficacy was obvious in the treated areas, but the minute lesion enlarged dramatically and was responsible for the patient's death.

Superselective intra-arterial radiometabolic therapy with I-131 lipiodol in hepatocellular carcinoma

Superselective transcatheter arterial radioembolization with radioiodinated lipiodol and gelatin sponges was evaluated in 11 patients with nodular hepatocellular carcinoma. Thirteen tumor nodules were treated using 3-5 ml of lipiodol labeled with 259 to 2220 MBq of I-131 followed by gelatin sponge with the following results: 1) there was elevated uptake in 12 tumor nodules with high tumor-to-background ratios: 2) there was excellent clinical tolerance to the treatment (stable cirrhosis in 5 patients and cirrhosis progression in 2 cases); 3) there was good disease control with size reduction in five tumor lesions (41%) and no increase in seven lesions (59%) followed for 2 years; 4) there was a 2-year survival rate of 70%; and 5) three deaths due to hepatic failure at 2, 3, and 20 months after therapy. Superselective arterial radioembolization with I-131 lipiodol is a useful palliative approach to inoperable hepatocarcinoma, providing long-term local control without severe complications in the progression of cirrhosis.

Epirubicin-Lipiodol chemotherapy versus 131iodine-Lipiodol radiotherapy in the treatment of unresectable hepatocellular carcinoma

BACKGROUND

Arterially administered iodized oil (Lipiodol) is selectively retained by hepatocellular carcinomas (HCCs), and has been used as a vehicle for delivery of therapeutic agents to these tumors. This study compared the efficacy of Lipiodol-targeted epirubicin chemotherapy with Lipiodol-131I radiotherapy.

METHODS

Ninety-five patients with unresectable HCC confined to the liver were administered either Lipiodol-epirubicin emulsion (n = 69; 61 cirrhotics; Okuda tumor Stage I, 14; II, 37; III, 18; epirubicin dose, 75 mg/m2) or Lipiodol-131I (131I) (n = 26; 18 cirrhotics; Okuda tumor Stage I, 6; II, 19; III, 1; dose 750-1050 MBq). The last 28 patients (17 epirubicin, 11 131I) were treated within a prospective randomized trial. Bolus drug or isotope was injected into the hepatic artery by transfemoral cannulation. Lipiodol and 131I uptake were gauged by 10th day computed tomography and 48-hour scintiscan. Treatments were repeated two-monthly when indicated.

RESULTS

Tumor size at 2 months remained static or diminished partially in 21 of 38 epirubicin recipients (55%) and 15/22 131I recipients (68%). Actuarial survival at 6, 12, and 24 months was 40%, 25%, and 6% with epirubicin, and 58%, 25%, and 0% with 131I; 30-day mortality was 11% and 15%, respectively. Comparison with historic controls indicated survival benefit in Stages I and II. Similar findings were recorded in the 28 patients in the randomized trial.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with unresectable HCC receiving Lipiodol-epirubicin or Lipiodol-131I show good tumor localization, acceptable toxicity, and comparable survival benefit at 6 and 12 months with either modality.

Lipiodol uptake and retention by human hepatoma cells

Lipodol has important diagnostic and therapeutic uses in hepatoma. However, the mechanisms of its selective, prolonged retention in hepatoma cells is not well understood. Therefore, using oil-red O, light and electron microscopy and neutron activation analysis we have determined that HepG2 cells are characterized by lipiodol deposition and emulsification on the cell surface, action uptake of lipodol by endocytosis, and prolonged intracellular retention. These findings may have major clinical significance in the development of a new treatment for hepatoma patients.

Iodized oil in the treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma

When injected into the hepatic artery the contrast agent Lipiodol (iodized poppy seed oil) is selectively retained by hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) for a prolonged period of time. Liver computed tomography (CT) performed after Lipiodol angiography is more sensitive than ordinary CT at imaging HCC. Arterial administration of cytotoxic drugs and radioisotopes conjugated to Lipiodol has been shown to be reasonably safe in patients with irresectable HCC. These therapies, often combined with embolization, provide effective palliation, better tumour response and improved survival compared with other available treatments. Their use as a preoperative adjunct to surgical resection of HCC is controversial.

Usefulness of hepatic artery injection of iodized oil and 131I-labeled iodized oil before the therapeutic decision in hepatocellular carcinoma

This study assesses the usefulness of intra-arterial injection of iodized oil (Lipiodol) as a tool for evaluating the therapeutic choice in a series of 72 consecutive patients with hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). In 52 of these patients a scintigraphic study of the biodistribution of iodized oil was done, using 131I-iodized oil injection. A single tumor was detected in only 17 cases; 18 patients had a tumor involving only 1 lobe; in 7 cases CT scan disclosed a minute nodule in the opposite lobe of the main tumor. Eighteen patients had a portal thrombosis; in 12 of these cases CT scan showed iodized oil in the tumor emboli. The degree of intratumoral retention of iodized oil depended on the size of tumors and on the presence of arterioportal shunts. Our study demonstrates that only a few patients (4%) with HCC might benefit from curative surgery. The therapeutic benefit of methods using iodized oil injection might be estimated by means of its biodistribution variables (CT and/or scintigraphic data).

Non-surgical treatment of hepatocarcinoma

Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is one of the most common tumors affecting man. It is the general feeling that only hepatectomy can give a chance for cure. However, less than 20% of patients can be resected, and other treatment modalities are required. Systemic (chemotherapy, hormonotherapy, immunotherapy) and loco-regional (intratumoral injection of alcohol, intra-arterial chemotherapy embolization, internal radiotherapy) approaches have been developed. In view of the small number of patients, tumor and patient heterogeneity, and difficulties in assessing tumor response, the real place of these treatments is difficult to evaluate. A review of the literature suggests that embolization with Gelfoam, even when given without chemotherapy, has an effect on response rate and on survival, and could be considered, at the present time, as the most attractive treatment in non-operable HCC. Chemotherapy seems effective only if combined with embolization. When administered alone by the systemic or the intra-arterial hepatic route, no clinically significant activity can be found. Unexpectedly, Lipiodol by itself seems inactive, and the co-administration of chemotherapy does not improve activity. Other approaches such as intratumoral injection of alcohol, immunotherapy, hormonotherapy, and radioimmunotherapy are still experimental, and well-designed studies are needed to identify their role.