Small animal imaging with pinhole single-photon emission computed tomography

Analytic Determination of Rectangular-Pinhole Sensitivity With Penetration

Modern small-animal SPECT systems use multiple pinhole collimators per detector to increase sensitivity while still maintaining high resolution. This resolution is a combination of aperture resolution combined with detector resolution, which is mitigated by magnification. Higher magnification results in better resolution, but fewer apertures per detector. When multiple pinhole collimators project onto the same detector, those with a rectangular field of view (FOV) can be packed more tightly than those with a circular FOV. In addition, a rectangular aperture can be used to obtain different resolution-sensitivity tradeoffs in the two orthogonal directions. Thus, these rectangular-pinhole collimators can have independent FOVs and independent resolution values in the two directions of the rectangular aperture. Previous work has determined the amount of penetration for circular pinholes (i.e., circular apertures with circular FOVs), where the pinhole walls were modeled as cones. In this work, a formula for the penetrative sensitivity for rectangular apertures with a rectangular FOV is determined. The formula was validated using numerical calculations for various combinations of acceptance angles, aperture sizes, linear attenuation coefficients, and incidence angles.

The effects of object activity distribution on multiplexing multi-pinhole SPECT

We aim to study the effects of activity distribution for multiplexing multi-pinhole (MPH) SPECT. Three digital phantoms, including a hot rod, a cold rod and a cold sphere phantom, were used. Different degrees of multiplexing were obtained by (i) adjusting the MPH pattern for the same 4-pinhole collimator (scheme 1) and (ii) increasing the number of pinholes (scheme 2). Noise-free and noisy projections were generated using a 3D analytical MPH projector based on the same acquisition time. Projections were reconstructed using OS-EM without resolution recovery. Normalized mean-square-error (NMSE), noise, image profiles and signal-to-background ratios (SBR) were assessed. For the hot rod phantom, the NMSE-noise trade-offs slightly improves for multiplexing designs in scheme 2. Substantial artifacts were observed and the NMSE-noise trade-offs slightly worsened for multiplexing designs for the cold phantoms. Resolutions slightly degraded for higher degrees of multiplexing (∼39-65%) for the cold rod phantom. For the cold sphere phantom, image profiles showed non-multiplexing designs better emulated the phantom, while ∼20% multiplexing performs similarly as compared to non-multiplexing in SBR. Our results indicate that multiplexing can help for sparse objects but leads to a significant image degradation in non-sparse distributions. Since many tracers are not highly specific, and the gain of detection efficiency by allowing multiplexing is fairly offset by image degradations, multiplexing needs to be kept to a minimum for optimum MPH collimator designs.

Evaluation of image reconstruction for mouse brain imaging with synthetic collimation from highly multiplexed SiliSPECT projections

We have performed a theoretical study to explore the potential and limitations of synthetic collimation for SPECT imaging with stacked-detector acquisition (dual magnification). This study will be used to optimize SiliSPECT, a small-animal SPECT for imaging small volumes such as a mouse brain at high sensitivity and resolution. The synthetic collimation enables image reconstruction with a limited number of camera views and in the presence of significant multiplexing. We also developed a new formulation to quantify the multiplexed object sensitivity and investigated how this changes for different acquisition parameters such as number of pinholes and combinations of front and back detector distances for imaging objects as small as the mouse brain. In our theoretical studies, we were not only able to demonstrate better reconstruction results by incorporating two detector magnifications in comparison to either one alone, but also observed an improved image reconstruction by optimizing the detector-collimator distances to change the multiplexing ratio between the front and back detectors.

Multi-pinhole collimator design for small-object imaging with SiliSPECT: a high-resolution SPECT

We have designed a multi-pinhole collimator for a dual-headed, stationary SPECT system that incorporates high-resolution silicon double-sided strip detectors. The compact camera design of our system enables imaging at source-collimator distances between 20 and 30 mm. Our analytical calculations show that using knife-edge pinholes with small-opening angles or cylindrically shaped pinholes in a focused, multi-pinhole configuration in combination with this camera geometry can generate narrow sensitivity profiles across the field of view that can be useful for imaging small objects at high sensitivity and resolution. The current prototype system uses two collimators each containing 127 cylindrically shaped pinholes that are focused toward a target volume. Our goal is imaging objects such as a mouse brain, which could find potential applications in molecular imaging.

Resolution-effective diameters for asymmetric-knife-edge pinhole collimators

The effects of penetration are included in the formulas for the prediction of the resolution of pinhole collimators through the use of effective diameters. Expressions of the resolution-effective diameter for pinholes with a double-knife-edge (DKE) profile are available in the literature. In this paper the expressions applicable to asymmetric-knife-edge (AKE) profiles, which include the important case of the single-knife-edge (SKE), are presented. Results indicate that the simplest methods that are still accurate in the calculation of DKE effective diameters do not produce in general formulas with similar accuracy for AKE profiles, due to increased susceptibility to penetration. Especially at high energy (365 keV), for the SKE case more advanced formulas are necessary and were, therefore, derived.

Absorbed dose distribution in glioma tumors in rat brain after therapeutic intratumoral injection of 201Tl-chloride

Studies on animals with gliomas inoculated in the brain and treated with intratumoral injections of 201Tl-chloride have previously shown very promising results, with a survival several weeks longer than controls. Total regression was found in some animals, and necrosis was found in all the 201Tl-treated brain tumors. This study was undertaken to estimate the absorbed dose and dose distribution to the tumor based on the localization and clearance properties obtained from images with two high-resolution imaging techniques; pinhole single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) and beta-camera. The images from the beta-camera were used to calculate the absorbed dose rate, using an in-house-developed, voxel-based Monte Carlo program, based on the EGS4 package. To evaluate the effects of different beta-particle energies on the absorbed dose rate distribution, simulations of medium- and high-energy electrons were conducted. Dose-volume histograms from these simulations show that the energy absorption is very locally distributed for 201Tl and medium energy, whereas high-energy beta emitters show a broader dose-volume distribution. The calculated total absorbed dose of 2-8 Gy in the tumor seems to be relativity low when considering the therapeutic effect that was seen. Further investigations, to determine the cause of the high therapeutic efficacy, are needed.

A REVIEW OF SMALL ANIMAL IMAGING PLANAR AND PINHOLE SPECT gamma CAMERA IMAGING

Scintigraphy (positron emission tomography (PET) or single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) techniques) allows qualitative and quantitative measurement of physiologic processes as well as alterations secondary to various disease states. With the use of specific radioligands, molecular pathways and pharmaco-kinetic processes can be investigated. Radioligand delivery can be (semi)quantified in the region of interest in cross-sectional and longitudinal examinations, which can be performed under the same conditions or after physiologic or pharmacologic interventions. Most preclinical pharmacokinetic studies on physiological and experimentally altered physiological processes are performed in laboratory animals using high-resolution imaging systems. Single photon emission imaging has the disadvantage of decreased spatial and temporal resolution compared with PET. The advantage of SPECT is that equipment is generally more accessible and commonly used radionuclides have a longer physical half-life allowing for investigations over a longer time interval. This review will focus on single photon emission scintigraphy. An overview of contemporary techniques to measure biodistribution and kinetics of radiopharmaceuticals in small animal in vivo is presented. Theoretical as well as practical aspects of planar gamma camera and SPECT pinhole (PH) imaging are discussed. Current research is focusing on refining PH SPECT methodology, so specific regarding technical aspects and applications of PH SPECT will be reviewed.

TierSPECT: Leistungsparameter einer dedizierten Kleintier-SPECT-Kamera und erste in vivo Messungen

This paper presents the performance of a new small-animal camera (TierSPECT) devised for the in vivo measurements of radiolabeled substances in small laboratory animals such as mice and rats. In a scatter medium, the camera has a tomographic spatial resolution of 2.87 mm and a sensitivity of 22 cps/MBq in a usable Field-of-View (FOV) with a diameter of 82 mm. The planar homogeneity amounts to 3.3%, the tomographic homogeneity lies between 3.2% and 3.5%. The deviation between filled and measured concentration of activity in a cylindrical 4-chamber-phantom was smaller than 2.6%. Using a novel rat head phantom with chamber volumes in the order of magnitude of the spatial resolution (between 0.065 ml and 0.19 ml) it could be demonstrated that studies of the rat neostriatal dopaminergic system are feasible under observance of physiological conditions. In vivo studies using [99mTc]diphosphonato-1,2-propandicarbonic acid (99mTc-DPD) and [123I]N-omega-fluoropropyl-2beta-carbomethoxy-3beta-(4-iodophenyl)-nortropane (123I-FP-CIT) proved that bone metabolism and dopamine transporter binding can be visualized with the TierSPECT. The fusion of 99mTc-DPD and 123I-FP-CIT images allowed the differentiation between intra- and extracerebral structures. Pretreatment with methylphenidate resulted in blockade of striatal dopamine transporter binding.

Imaging of intestinal lymphocyte homing by means of pinhole SPECT in a TNBS colitis mouse model

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

The increasing knowledge of the molecular basis of leukocyte trafficking results in the development of novel anti-inflammatory strategies for inflammatory bowel disease (IBD). For optimal evaluation of therapy efficacy, information about inflammatory activity in bowel segments or lymphocyte recirculation and kinetics in the follow-up of experimental treatment for IBD is needed. The aim of this study was to evaluate a non-invasive scintigraphic technique, able to assess lymphocyte trafficking in a trinitrobenzene sulfonic acid (TNBS) induced mouse colitis model of IBD.

METHODS

TNBS sensitized and non-sensitized murine total splenocytes were labeled in vitro with 111In-oxine and injected into either control or TNBS colitis BALB/c mice. Biodistribution and specific radioactive uptake, representing transferred cells, were determined by serial dedicated animal planar scintigraphy and pinhole SPECT of the abdomen 4, 24 and 48h post injection of labeled cells. In addition, the severity of inflammation was determined by histological scoring.

RESULTS

Migration of 111In labeled splenocytes to the colon increased in time and was maximal at 48h after administration. The highest specific radioactive uptake ratio in the colon after 48h was observed in mice with TNBS colitis that received TNBS sensitized lymphocytes. Histological scoring confirmed the presence of colitis in the TNBS treated groups.

CONCLUSION

Homing of TNBS-sensitized lymphocytes can be assessed in vivo by means of dedicated animal pinhole SPECT. Generally, this technique enables serial measurement of specific cell trafficking with potential of in vivo evaluation of novel anti-inflammatory strategies in inflammatory bowel disease.

Analytic determination of the resolution-equivalent effective diameter of a pinhole collimator

To account for photon penetration, the formulas used to calculate the geometric resolution of a pinhole collimator use an equivalent diameter d(e) rather than the physical diameter of the aperture. The expression commonly used for d(e), however, was originally derived to account for penetration in sensitivity calculations. In this paper, we show that the concept of equivalent diameter is also applicable to resolution calculations, propose angular-dependent expressions for d(e) specific to resolution calculations, and discuss the limits of their applicability and how they compare to other expressions. Results show that for normal incidence Paix's expression for d(e) tends to overestimate the resolution-equivalent diameter for full-width-at-half-maximum resolution, whereas Anger's is a better approximation, but may produce underestimates for submillimeter resolution imagers, especially in the case of high-energy photons. For grazing incidence, both expressions may result in significant overestimates.

Small animal imaging with high resolution single photon emission tomography

Molecular imaging of small animals in vivo is vital in the study of mouse and rat models of human diseases, and will provide important clues to the pathogenesis, progression and treatment of many disorders. Functional imaging of small animals using ultra-high resolution single photon emission tomography (SPECT) should be a valuable tool in the molecular imaging armamentarium. SPECT has been used to study cerebral binding sites, to image the expression of reporter genes, and in applications in cardiology and oncology. In this review, we summarize the most recent developments in SPECT imaging of small animals, with particular reference to the types of systems available, their application, and some of the potential limitations.

Dual-modality imaging of function and physiology

Dual-modality imaging is a technique in which computed tomography (CT) or magnetic resonance imaging is combined with positron emission tomography or single-photon emission CT to acquire structural and functional images with an integated system. The data are acquired in a single procedure; the patient remains on the scanner table while undergoing both x-ray and radionuclide studies to facilitate correlation between the structural and functional images. The resulting data can aid in localization, enabling more specific diagnosis than can be obtained with a conventional imaging study. In addition, the anatomic information can be used to compensate the correlated radionuclide data for physical perturbations such as photon attenuation, scatter radiation, and partial volume errors. Thus, dual-modality imaging provides a priori information that can improve both the visual quality and the quantitative accuracy of the radionuclide images. Dual-modality imaging systems are also being developed for biologic research involving small animals. Small-animal dual-modality systems offer advantages for measurements that currently are performed invasively with autoradiography and tissue sampling. By acquiring data noninvasively, dual-modality imaging permits serial studies in a single animal, enables measurements to be performed with fewer animals, and improves the statistical quality of the data.

Analytic determination of the pinhole collimator's point-spread function and RMS resolution with penetration

Pinhole collimators are widely used to image small organs and animals. The pinhole response function (PRF) of knife-edge pinhole collimators has been estimated previously using geometric constructions without considering penetration and using "roll-off" models that employ an exponential model for the flux. An analytic expression for the PRF on the imaging plane that includes the effect of aperture penetration is derived in this paper by calculating the flux for photons passing through the aperture and those passing through the attenuating material. The PRF is then used to approximate the angular-dependent root-mean-square resolution in the directions parallel and perpendicular to the tilt of the point source. The corresponding aspect ratio is then obtained. The formulas are then compared with experimental data.

Imaging transgenic animals

Transgenic and eugenic animals as small as 30 g can be studied non-invasively by radionuclides with resolutions of 1-2 mm, by MRI with resolution of 100 microns and by light fluorescence and bioluminescence with high sensitivities. The technologies of radionuclide emission, magnetic resonance imaging, magnetic resonance spectroscopy, optical tomography, optical fluorescence and optical bioluminescence are currently being applied to small-animal studies. These technologies and examples of their applications are reviewed in this chapter.

In vivo imaging of gene and cell therapies

Molecular imaging can be broadly defined as the in vivo characterization and measurement of biological processes at the cellular and molecular level. In contrast to commonly used clinical imaging, it sets forth to probe the molecular abnormalities that are the basis of disease, rather than imaging the end effects of these molecular alterations. Development of new imaging technologies requires a multidisciplinary collaboration between biologists, chemists, physicists, and imaging scientists to create novel agents, signal amplification strategies, and imaging techniques that successfully address these questions. In this article we attempt to present some of the recent developments and show how molecular imaging can be used, at least experimentally, to assess specific molecular targets for gene- and cell-based therapies. In particular, we place emphasis on the development and use of experimental small-animal models, which are particularly inclined toward this approach, primarily in combination with magnetic resonance (MR), radionuclide, and optical imaging. In the future, specific imaging of disease targets will allow earlier detection and characterization of disease, as well as earlier and direct molecular assessment of treatment efficacy.

Analytic determination of pinhole collimator sensitivity with penetration

Pinhole collimators are widely used to image small organs and animals. The sensitivity of knife-edge pinhole collimators has been previously estimated using an "effective diameter" formulation and experimentally described using a sin(x) theta fit, where theta is the angle between the line segment from the center of the aperture to the photon source and its projection onto the plane of the aperture. An analytic form of the sensitivity of the pinhole collimator is derived in this paper. A numerical formula for predicting the sin(x) theta form of the sensitivity is calculated from the analytic form. Experimental data are compared with the theoretical estimate and the sin(x) theta prediction. The agreement is excellent.

Molecular imaging

The term molecular imaging can be broadly defined as the in vivo characterization and measurement of biologic processes at the cellular and molecular level. In contradistinction to "classical" diagnostic imaging, it sets forth to probe the molecular abnormalities that are the basis of disease rather than to image the end effects of these molecular alterations. While the underlying biology represents a new arena for many radiologists, concomitant efforts such as development of novel agents, signal amplification strategies, and imaging technologies clearly dovetail with prior research efforts of our specialty. Radiologists will play a leading role in directing developments of this embryonic but burgeoning field. This article presents some recent developments in molecular sciences and medicine and shows how imaging can be used, at least experimentally, to assess specific molecular targets. In the future, specific imaging of such targets will allow earlier detection and characterization of disease, earlier and direct molecular assessment of treatment effects, and a more fundamental understanding of the disease process.

High resolution PET, SPECT and projection imaging in small animals

Positron emission tomography, single photon emission computed tomography and planar projection imaging of radioactive tracers have long been in use for detecting and diagnosing disease in human subjects. More recently, advanced versions of these same technologies have begun to be used across the breadth of modern biomedical research to study non-invasively small laboratory animals in a myriad of experimental settings. In this report, we describe some of the new instruments and techniques that make these measurements possible and illustrate, with a few examples, the potential power of these methods in modern biomedical research.

The role of 99mTc-tetrofosmin Pinhole-SPECT in breast cancer axillary lymph node staging

The number of metastatic axillary nodes represents one of the most important prognostic factors in preoperative breast cancer patients. 99mTc-Tetrofosmin high resolution Pinhole (P)-SPECT was employed in 112 patients, 100 with breast cancer and 12 with benign mammary lesions, to ascertain axillary lymph node involvement. Axillary P-SPECT images were acquired utilizing specific software connected to a circular high resolution, single-head gamma camera equipped with a pinhole collimator with aperture size of 4.45 mm, rotating 180 degrees around the involved axilla. At the same time, patients also underwent conventional SPECT and planar acquisitions. Per-patient sensitivity and specificity were 100% and 93.6% for P-SPECT, 96.2% and 93.6% for SPECT and 56.6% and 100% for planar imaging, respectively. Moreover, P-SPECT detected more than 51% of lesions ascertained by histology, whereas SPECT and planar detected 32.6% and 20.3%, respectively. Only P-SPECT succeeded in identifying the exact number of metastatic axillary lesions in patients with multiple nodes; this procedure was able to correctly differentiate 88.67% of patients with 3 or less nodes from those with more than 3, thus giving important prognostic information. These data suggest 99mTc-Tetrofosmin P-SPECT is a reliable imaging method both for staging and prognostic purposes in breast cancer, and its routine use is recommended.

An analytic model of pinhole aperture penetration for 3D pinhole SPECT image reconstruction

Photons penetrate the attenuating material close to the aperture of pinhole collimators in nuclear medicine, broadening the tails of point spread functions (PSFs) and degrading the resolution of planar and SPECT images. An analytic approximation has been developed that models this penetration contribution to the PSF for knife-edge point pinhole apertures. The approximation has the form exp(-gamma r), where r is the distance on the detector surface from the projection of the point source through the pinhole. The rolloff coefficient gamma is a function of the photon energy, point source location and the design parameters of the collimator. There was excellent agreement between measured values of gamma from photon transport simulations of I-131 point sources (364 keV emission only) and theoretical predictions from the analytic formula. Predicted gamma values from the analytic formula averaged 25% greater than measured values from experimental I-131 point source acquisitions. Photon transport simulations were performed that modelled the 364 keV and less abundant 637 and 723 keV emissions and scatter within the scintillation crystal. Measured gamma values from these simulations averaged 12% greater than the experimental values, indicating that about half of the error between the analytic formula and the experimental measurements was due to unmodelled 637 and 723 keV emissions. The remaining error may be due in part to scatter in the pinhole region and backscatter from gamma camera components behind the scintillation crystal. The analytic penetration model was used in designing Metz filters to compensate for penetration blur and these filters were applied to the projection data as part of 3D SPECT image reconstruction. Image resolution and contrast were improved in simulated and experimental I-131 tumour phantom studies. This analytic model of pinhole aperture penetration can be readily incorporated into iterative 3D SPECT pinhole reconstruction algorithms.