The Stable Pentamethylcyclopentadienyl Cation Remains Unknown

Planar Cyclopenten-4-yl Cations: Highly Delocalized π Aromatics Stabilized by Hyperconjugation

Theoretical studies predicted the planar cyclopenten-4-yl cation to be a classical carbocation, and the highest-energy isomer of C5 H7 + . Hence, its existence has not been verified experimentally so far. We were now able to isolate two stable derivatives of the cyclopenten-4-yl cation by reaction of bulky alanes CpR AlBr2 with AlBr3 . Elucidation of their (electronic) structures by X-ray diffraction and quantum chemistry studies revealed planar geometries and strong hyperconjugation interactions primarily from the C-Al σ bonds to the empty p orbital of the cationic sp2 carbon center. A close inspection of the molecular orbitals (MOs) and of the anisotropy of current (induced) density (ACID), as well as the evaluation of various aromaticity descriptors indicated distinct aromaticity for these cyclopenten-4-yl derivatives, which strongly contrasts the classical description of this system. Here, strong delocalization of π electrons spanning the whole carbocycle has been verified, thus providing rare examples of π aromaticity involving saturated sp3 carbon atoms.

[Co2 (CO)6 (Alkynyl)] Complexes of Dibenzosuberyl and Dibenzosuberenyl Carbocations: Dibenzotropylium or Dibenzoheptafulvene?

The reaction of dibenzo[a,d]cycloheptan-5-one (dibenzosuberone) and dibenzo[a,d]cyclohept-10-en-5-one (dibenzosuberenone) with aryl- or trimethylsilylacetylides led to the formation of the corresponding alkynyldibenzosuberols and alkynyldibenzosuberenols. Treatment with dicobalt octacarbonyl and then with bis(diphenylphosphino)methane (dppm) furnished the corresponding [Co₂ (CO)₄ (dppm)(alkynol)] clusters 25 and 29. Upon protonation with HBF₄ at 203 K to generate the relevant cobalt-stabilised cations, the dibenzosuberyl system 30 exhibited fluxionality such that the cation migrated between cobalt centres. Variable-temperature ³¹ P NMR spectroscopy revealed a barrier of approximately 12.5 kcal mol^-1 . In contrast, in the supposedly aromatic [Co₂ (CO)₄ (dppm)(dibenzosuberenyl)]⁺ cation (31), which would be expected to have less need of cobalt stabilisation, the barrier was too high to be measured experimentally, but is certainly in excess of 16 kcal mol^-1 . These data were rationalised by DFT calculations on the structures and energies of the relevant ground states and transition states, which suggested that the nonplanar alkynyldibenzosuberenyl moiety in 31 is better regarded as a neutral dibenzoheptafulvene coordinated to a cationic alkynyl-dicobalt cluster. The question of the bonding of both aromatic and antiaromatic cations to alkyne-dicobalt clusters is considered, and it is proposed that their stabilities, when complexed, parallel the inversion of (4n+2) π and 4n π systems seen under photochemical conditions.

The (Me 5 C 5 )Si + Cation: A Stable Derivative of HSi +

The reaction of decamethylsilicocene, (Me5C5)2Si, with the proton-transfer reagent Me5C5H2+B(C6F5)4- produces the salt (Me5C5)Si+ B(C6F5)4(2), which can be isolated as a colorless solid that is stable in the absence of air and moisture. The crystal structure reveals the presence of a cationic pi complex with an eta5-pentamethylcyclopentadienyl ligand bound to a bare silicon center. The 29Si nuclear magnetic resonance at very high field (delta = - 400.2 parts per million) is typical of a pi complex of divalent silicon. The (eta5-Me5C5)Si+ cation in 2 can be regarded as the "resting state" of a silyliumylidene-type (eta1-Me5C5)Si+ cation. The availability of 2 opens new synthetic avenues in organosilicon chemistry. For example, 2 reacted with lithium bis(trimethylsilyl)amide to give the disilene E-[(eta1-Me5C5)[N(SiMe3)2]Si]2(3).