Possibilities to improve automation, speed and precision of proteome analysis: a comparison of two-dimensional electrophoresis and alternatives

High electric field strength two-dimensional peptide separations using a microfluidic device

New instrumentation has been developed to improve the resolution, efficiency, and speed of microfluidic 2D separations using MEKC coupled to high field strength CE. Previously published 2D separation instrumentation [Ramsey, J. D. et al., Anal. Chem. 2003, 75, 3758-3764] from our group was limited to a maximum potential difference of 8.4 kV, resulting in an electric field strength of only approximately 200 V/cm in the first dimension. The circuit described in this report has been designed to couple a higher voltage supply with a rapidly switching, lower voltage supply to utilize the best features of each. Voltages applied in excess of 20 kV lead to high electric field strength separations in both dimensions, increasing the separation resolution, efficiency, and peak capacity while reducing the required analysis time. Detection rates as high as six peptides per second (based on total analysis time) were observed for a model protein tryptic digest separation. Additionally, higher applied voltages used in conjunction with microfluidic chips with longer length channels maintained higher electric field strengths and produced peak capacities of over 4000 for some separations. Total separation time in these longer channel devices was comparable to that obtained in short channels at low field strength; however, resolving power improved approximately threefold.

Microscale 2D separation systems for proteomic analysis

Microscale 2D separation systems have been implemented in capillaries and microfabricated channels. They offer advantages of faster analysis, higher separation efficiency and less sample consumption than the conventional methods, such as liquid chromatography (LC) in a column and slab gel electrophoresis. In this article, we review their recent advancement, focusing on three types of platforms, including 2D capillary electrophoresis (CE), CE coupling with capillary LC, and microfluidic devices. A variety of CE and LC modes have been employed to construct 2D separation systems via sophistically designed interfaces. Coupling of different separation modes has also been realized in a number of microfluidic devices. These separation systems have been applied for the proteomic analysis of various biological samples, ranging from a single cell to tumor tissues.

Examining serum amyloid P component microheterogeneity using capillary isoelectric focusing and MALDI-MS

Serum amyloid P component (SAP) is a glycoprotein of interest due to its presence in amyloid plaque formations. As with most glycoproteins, SAP can possibly vary greatly in its isoforms, which can be an important factor toward understanding the role of SAP. Interestingly, previous characterizations suggest varying degrees of microheterogeneity, some of which are in conflict. In this work, we provide new information to clarify SAP's microheterogeneity profile using CIEF to carefully analyze pooled samples and by studying individual samples across populations with mass spectrometric immunoassay. With respect to CIEF, a single pI band was observed suggesting that human SAP does not have extensive heterogeneity concluded from gel IEF experiments in the past. Additionally, this is supported by a population study, which revealed an overwhelming degree of uniformity. Overall, this work corroborates the idea that SAP is relatively consistent across the population and with respect to microheterogeneity.

Online nanoflow RP-RP-MS reveals dynamics of multicomponent Ku complex in response to DNA damage

Tandem affinity purification (TAP) coupled with mass spectrometry has become the technique of choice for characterization of multicomponent protein complexes. While current TAP protocols routinely provide high yield and specificity for proteins expressed under physiologically relevant conditions, analytical figures of merit required for efficient and in-depth LC-MS analysis remain unresolved. Here we implement a multidimensional chromatography platform, based on two stages of reversed-phase (RP) separation operated at high and low pH, respectively. We compare performance metrics for RP-RP and SCX-RP for the analysis of complex peptide mixtures derived from cell lysate, as well as protein complexes purified via TAP. Our data reveal that RP-RP fractionation outperforms SCX-RP primarily due to increased peak capacity in the first dimension separation. We integrate this system with miniaturized LC assemblies to achieve true online fractionation at low (≤5 nL/min) effluent flow rates. Stable isotope labeling is used to monitor the dynamics of the multicomponent Ku protein complex in response to DNA damage induced by γ radiation.

Integrated Multi-process Microfluidic Systems for Automating Analysis

Microfluidic technologies have been applied extensively in rapid sample analysis. Some current challenges for standard microfluidic systems are relatively high detection limits, and reduced resolving power and peak capacity compared to conventional approaches. The integration of multiple functions and components onto a single platform can overcome these separation and detection limitations of microfluidics. Multiplexed systems can greatly increase peak capacity in multidimensional separations and can increase sample throughput by analyzing many samples simultaneously. On-chip sample preparation, including labeling, preconcentration, cleanup and amplification, can all serve to speed up and automate processes in integrated microfluidic systems. This paper summarizes advances in integrated multi-process microfluidic systems for automated analysis, their benefits and areas for needed improvement.

Membrane proteome of the green sulfur bacterium Chlorobium tepidum (syn. Chlorobaculum tepidum) analyzed by gel-based and gel-free methods

Chlorobium tepidum is a Gram-negative bacterium of the green sulfur phylum (Chlorobia). Chlorobia are obligate anaerobic photolithoautotrophs that are widely distributed in aquatic environments where anoxic layers containing reduced sulfur compounds are exposed to light. The envelope of C. tepidum is a complex organelle composed of the outer membrane, the periplasm-peptidoglycan layer, and the cytoplasmic membrane. In addition to the outer and plasma membranes, C. tepidum contains chlorosomes attached to the cytoplasmic side of the plasma membrane. Each cellular compartment has a unique set of proteins, called sub-proteome. An important aim of proteome analysis is to study the level of the expressed genes and their response to environmental changes. Membrane protein studies are of primary importance to understand how nutrients are transported inside the cell, how toxic molecules are exported, and the mechanisms of photosynthesis and energy metabolism.

Urine proteomic analysis: use of two-dimensional gel electrophoresis, isotope coded affinity tags, and capillary electrophoresis

The identities and abundance levels of proteins excreted in urine are not only key indicators of diseases associated with renal function but are also indicators of the overall health of individuals. Urine specimens are readily available and provide a noninvasive means to assess and diagnose many disease states. Proteins in urine originate from two sources: the ultrafiltrate of plasma, and those that are shed from the urinary tract. The protein concentration in urine excreted from a normal adult is approximately 150 mg/day, and is typically not greater than 10 mg/100 mL in any single specimen. Following precipitation, concentration, and fractionation methods, proteins of interest from urine samples can be separated, identified, and quantified. One of the most commonly used techniques in the field of urine proteomics is gel electrophoresis followed by identification with mass spectrometry and protein database search algorithms. In this chapter, two-dimensional gel electrophoresis (2-DE) will be discussed, along with less frequently applied techniques, such as isotope coded affinity tags (ICAT) and capillary electrophoresis (CE). Publications discussing the application of these techniques to urine proteomic analyses of healthy individuals and urinary disease biomarker discovery will also be summarized.

On-chip technologies for multidimensional separations

We review microfluidic devices designed for multidimensional sample analysis, with a primer on relevant theory, an emphasis on protein analysis, and an eye towards future improvements and challenges to the field. Image shows results of an on-chip IEF-CE separation of a protein mixture; unpublished surface plot data from A. E. Herr.

Microfluidic 2-D PAGE using multifunctional in situ polyacrylamide gels and discontinuous buffers

A two-dimensional microfluidic system is presented for intact protein separations combining isoelectric focusing (IEF) and sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) employing in situ photopolymerized polyacrylamide (PAAm) gels. The PAAm gels are used for multiple functions. In addition to serving as a highly-resolving separation medium for gel electrophoresis, discrete polyacrylamide gel plugs are used to enable the efficient isolation of different on-chip media including anolyte, catholyte, and sample/ampholyte solutions for IEF. The gel plugs are demonstrated as on-chip reagent containers, holding defined quantities of SDS for on-chip SDS-protein complexation, and enabling the use of a discontinuous buffer system for sample band sharpening during SDS-PAGE. The 2-D chip also employs several unique design features including an angled isoelectric focusing channel to minimize sample tailing, and backbiasing channels designed to achieve uniform interdimensional sample transfer. Separation results using E. coli cell lysate are presented using a 10-channel chip with and without the discontinuous buffer system, with resolving power more than doubled in the former case. Further improvements in separation resolution are demonstrated using a 20-channel chip design.

Gradient chromatofocusing-mass spectrometry: a new technique in protein analysis

A new analytical technique, gradient chromatofocusing-mass spectrometry (gCF-MS), was developed employing ion-exchange high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) interfaced to an electrospray-quadrupole mass spectrometer in the determination of proteins. There have been few reports, if any, of a HPLC-MS technique for proteins in which the ion-exchange column is directly interfaced to the mass spectrometer. The employment of a linear pH gradient elution scheme directly interfaced to mass spectrometry is also unique in the present work. The technique was demonstrated by the separation of six proteins (carbonic anhydrase II, enolase, beta-lactoglobulin A, lactoglobulin B, soybean trypsin inhibitor, and amyloglucosidase) employing a descending linear pH gradient from pH 9 to 2.6 on a 50 mm x 2.1 mm DEAE HPLC column using volatile buffer components. A signal enhancement solution consisting of 8% formic acid in acetonitrile was pumped post-column and was mixed 1:1 with column effluent and then directed on-line into the mass spectrometer. Molecular masses of the proteins were determined within +/-0.010% to 0.033% (+/-100 to 330 ppm) with peak height total ion current detection limits of 4 to 78 pmol of injected amounts (S/N = 3). This technique is applicable to the analysis of proteins and other charged molecules.

Proteomic analysis of the sarcosine-insoluble outer membrane fraction of Flavobacterium columnare

Outer membrane proteins (OMPs) of bacteria are key molecules interacting with the host environment. Flavobacterium columnare, a pathogen-causing columnaris disease of fish worldwide, was studied in order to understand the composition of its OMPs. The sarcosine-insoluble membrane fraction of the OMPs was analysed using sodium dodecyl sulphate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) in combination with reverse-phase high-performance liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (RP-HPLC MS/MS). Thirty-six proteins were identified, including proteins involved in cell wall/membrane biogenesis, specific transport of various nutrients and in essential metabolism. The present study is the first report on the OMPs of F. columnare, and may serve as the basis for understanding the pathogenesis of the bacterium.

Intact Protein Profiling of Chlorobium tepidum by Capillary Isoelectric Focusing, Reversed-Phase Liquid Chromatography, and Mass Spectrometry

Capillary isoelectric focusing (CIEF) coupled with reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RPLC) and electrospray ionization (ESI) mass spectrometry (MS) is shown to provide a liquid-based alternative to 2D-PAGE for intact protein profiling. This combination exhibits high resolution, sensitivity and throughput for protein profiling based on pI vs MW. The CIEF-RPLC-MS system described here facilitates the use of IEF markers for internal calibration of pI. It also provides a high dynamic range as evidenced by the detection of 100 pg (3 fmol) of a test protein spiked into 1 microg of a complex protein mixture. About 1200 individual proteins/polypeptides were detected from lysates of the green sulfur bacterium Chlorobium tepidum in a single <8 h run. The pI vs MW profile obtained from CIEF-RPLC-MS compares favorably with theoretical data derived from the C. tepidum genome and experimental data obtained from 2D-PAGE.

Examination of interactions of oppositely charged proteins in gels

Understanding the interactions of proteins with one another serves as an important step for developing faster protein separation methods. To examine protein-protein interactions of oppositely charged proteins, fluorescently labeled albumin and poly-l-lysine were subjected to electrophoresis in agarose gels, in which the cationic albumin and the anionic poly-L-lysine were allowed to migrate toward each other and interact. Fluorescence microscopy was used to image fluorescently tagged proteins in the gel. The secondary structure of the proteins in solution was studied using conventional FTIR spectroscopy. Results showed that sharp interfaces were formed where FITC tagged albumin met poly-L-lysine and that the interfaces did not migrate after they had been formed. The position of the interface in the gel was found to be linearly dependent upon the relative concentration of the proteins. The formation of the interface also depended upon the fluorescent tag attached to the protein. The size of the aggregates at the interface, the fluorescence intensity modifications, and the mobility of the interface for different pore sizes of the gel were investigated. It was observed that the interface was made up of aggregates of about 1 microm in size. Using dynamic light scattering, it was observed that the size of the aggregates that formed due to interactions of oppositely charged proteins depended upon the fluorescent tags attached to the proteins. The addition of small amounts of poly-L-lysine to solutions containing FITC albumin decreased the zeta potential drastically. For this, we propose a model suggesting that adding small amounts of poly-L-lysine to solutions containing FITC -albumin favors the formation of macromolecular complexes having FITC albumin molecules on its surface. Although oppositely charged FITC tagged poly-L-lysine and FITC tagged albumin influence each other's migration velocities by forming aggregates, there were no observable secondary structural modifications when the proteins were mixed in solution.

Capillary electrophoresis-based separation techniques for the analysis of proteins

CE offers the advantages of high speed, great efficiency, as well as the requirement of minimum amounts of sample and buffer for the analysis of proteins. In this review, we summarize the CE-based techniques coupled with absorption, LIF, and MS detection systems for the analysis of proteins mostly within the past 5 years. The basic principle of each technique and its advantages and disadvantages for protein analysis are discussed in brief. Advanced CE techniques, including on-column concentration techniques and high-efficiency multidimensional separation techniques, for high-throughput protein profiling of complex biological samples and/or of single cells are emphasized. Although the developed techniques provide improved peak capacity, they have not become practical tools for proteomics, mainly because of poor reproducibility, low-sample lading capacity, and low throughput due to ineffective interfaces between two separation dimensions and that between separation and MS systems. In order to identify the complexities and dynamics of the proteomes expressed by cells, tissues, or organisms, techniques providing improved analytical sensitivity, throughput, and dynamic ranges are still demanded.

Fast, comprehensive online two-dimensional high performance liquid chromatography through the use of high temperature ultra-fast gradient elution reversed-phase liquid chromatography

A new approach to high speed, comprehensive online dual gradient elution 2DLC (LCxLC) based on the use of ultra-fast, high temperature gradient elution reversed phase chromatography is described. Entirely conventional gradient elution instrumentation and columns are assembled in a system which develops a total peak capacity of about 900 in 25 min; this is equivalent to roughly one peak/2 s. Each second dimension gradient is done in a cycle time of 21 s and the peak retention times measured for a set of twenty six indole-3-acetic acid (IAA) derivatives are reproducible to 0.2 s. Each peak eluting from the first dimension column is sampled at least twice across its width, as the corresponding peaks on the second dimension column appear in two or three consecutive second dimension chromatograms, clearly indicating that there is little loss in the resolution gained in the first dimension separation. Application to the separation of the low molecular weight components of wild-type and mutant maize seedlings indicates the presence of about 100 peaks on a timescale of 25 min. Compelling illustrations of the analytical potential of fast, high temperature 2DLC are evident in the clear presence of nine distinct peaks in a single second dimension chromatogram from a single quite narrow first dimension peak, and the great power of 2DLC to solve the "analytic dynamic range" problem inherent in the measurement of small peaks that are neighbors to a gigantic peak.

Automation, parallelism, and robotics for proteomics

The speed of the human genome project (Lander, E. S., Linton, L. M., Birren, B., Nusbaum, C. et al., Nature 2001, 409, 860-921) was made possible, in part, by developments in automation of sequencing technologies. Before these technologies, sequencing was a laborious, expensive, and personnel-intensive task. Similarly, automation and robotics are changing the field of proteomics today. Proteomics is defined as the effort to understand and characterize proteins in the categories of structure, function and interaction (Englbrecht, C. C., Facius, A., Comb. Chem. High Throughput Screen. 2005, 8, 705-715). As such, this field nicely lends itself to automation technologies since these methods often require large economies of scale in order to achieve cost and time-saving benefits. This article describes some of the technologies and methods being applied in proteomics in order to facilitate automation within the field as well as in linking proteomics-based information with other related research areas.

Study of Joule heating effects on temperature gradient in diverging microchannels for isoelectric focusing applications

IEF is a high-resolution separation method taking place in a medium with continuous pH gradients, which can be set up by applying electrical field to the liquid in a diverging microchannel. The axial variation of the channel cross-sectional area will induce nonuniform Joule heating and set up temperature gradient, which will generate pH gradient when proper medium is used. In order to operationally control the thermally generated pH gradients, fundamental understanding of heat transfer phenomena in microfluidic chips with diverging microchannels must be improved. In this paper, two 3-D numerical models are presented to study heat transfer in diverging microchannels, with static and moving liquid, respectively. Through simulation, the temperature distribution for the entire chip has been revealed, including both liquid and solid regions. The model for the static liquid scenario has been compared with published results for validation. Parametric studies have showed that the channel geometry has significant effects on the peak temperature location, and the electrical conductivity of the medium and the wall boundary convection have effects on the generated temperature gradients and thus the generated pH gradients. The solution to the continuous flow model, where the medium convection is considered, shows that liquid convection has significant effects on temperature distribution and the peak temperature location.

Proteomics study of anthrax lethal toxin-treated murine macrophages

The anthrax lethal toxin (LeTx) is composed of two proteins, protective antigen and lethal factor, which bind and enter the cell through a host receptor termed the anthrax toxin receptor (ATR). In the cell, LeTx targets p38, part of the MAP kinase signaling pathway. The toxin appears to initiate an apoptotic pathway in infected cells, indicating additional downstream targets of the toxin. We have applied a proteomics approach to investigate these downstream targets and the affected processes. In this study we have used an improved strategy for fractionation based on protein pI, off-gel electrophoresis, employed in conjunction with relative quantitation using the mass labeling approach. In our survey, 67 proteins were observed and quantified from the cytosol of RAW 264.7 cells with respect to control versus toxin-treated cells. Many of these proteins are involved in the oxidative stress response, as well as apoptosis, and thus likely to be relevant to the effects of anthrax in infected cells. Our results indicate that the tumor necrosis factor-alpha-mediated pathway is compromised in intoxicated cells. The knowledge of such changes and the pathways leading to the changes should be of great value in understanding and combating this disease.

Rice proteomics: a cornerstone for cereal food crop proteomes

Proteomics-a systematic study of proteins present in a cell, tissue, organ, or organism at a particular moment during the life cycle-that began with classical two-dimensional electrophoresis and its advancement during the 1990s, has been revolutionized by a series of tremendous technological developments in mass spectrometry (MS), a core technology. Proteomics is exerting its influence on biological function of genes and genomes in the era (21st century) of functional genomics, and for this reason yeast, bacterial, and mammalian systems are the best examples. Although plant proteomics is still in its infancy, evolving proteomic technologies and the availability of the genome sequences of Arabidopsis thaliana (L.) Heyhn, and rice (Oryza sativa L.), model dicotyledoneous and monocotyledoneous (monocot) species, respectively, are propelling it towards new heights, as evidenced by the rapid spurt in worldwide plant proteome research. Rice, with an immense socio-economic impact on human civilization, is a representative model of cereal food crops, and we consider it as a cornerstone for functional genomics of cereal plants. In this review, we look at the history and the current state of monocot proteomes, including barley, maize, and wheat, with a central focus on rice, which has the most extensive proteomic coverage to date. On one side, we highlight advances in technologies that have generated enormous amount of interest in plant proteomics, and the other side summarizes the achievements made towards establishing proteomes during plant growth & development and challenge to environmental factors, including disease, and for studying genetic relationships. In light of what we have learned from the proteomic journey in rice and other monocots, we finally reveal and assess their impact in our continuous strive towards completion of their full proteomes.

Protein profiling by capillary isoelectric focusing, reversed-phase liquid chromatography, and mass spectrometry

An automated system for intact protein analysis is described that combines capillary isoelectric focusing (CIEF), reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RPLC), and electrospray ionization-mass spectrometry (ESI-MS). Performance is demonstrated with a complex yeast enzyme concentrate. CIEF is performed with a microdialysis membrane-based cathodic cell that permits pI fractions to be sampled and stored for subsequent LC-MS analysis. A total of 50 microg protein is loaded onto the capillary. Ten fractions are stored which span the pI range 3-10. Each fraction is subsequently cleaned on a reversed-phase trap column and then characterized by LC-MS. MaxEnt1 is used to deconvolute the raw mass spectra to obtain the molecular weight (MW) of intact proteins/peptides in the sample. A two-dimensional display of pI vs. MW is illustrated for the 500 most prevalent species as identified by MaxEnt1.

Advances in the analysis of proteins and peptides by capillary electrophoresis with matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization and electrospray-mass spectrometry detection

High throughput, outstanding certainty in peptide/protein identification, exceptional resolution, and quantitative information are essential pillars in proteome research. Capillary electrophoresis (CE) coupled to mass spectrometry (MS) has proven to meet these requirements. Soft ionization techniques, such as matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) and electrospray ionization (ESI), have paved the way for the story of success of CE-MS in the analysis of biomolecules and both approaches are subject of discussion in this article. Meanwhile, CE-MS is far away from representing a homogeneous field. Therefore the review will cover a vast area including the coupling of different modes of CE (capillary zone electrophoresis, capillary isoelectric foscusing, capillary electrochromatography, micellar electrokinetic chromatography, nonaqueous capillary electrophoresis) to MS as well as on-line preconcentration techniques (transient capillary isotachophoresis, solid-phase extraction, membrane preconcentration) applied to compensate for restricted detection sensitivity. Special attention is given to improvements in interfacing, namely addressing nanospray and coaxial sheath liquid design. Peptide mapping, collision-induced dissociation with subsequent tandem MS, and amendments in mass accuracy of instruments improve information validity gained from MS data. With 2-D on-line coupling of liquid chromatography (LC) and CE a further topic will be discussed. A special section is dedicated to recent attempts in establishing CE-ESI-MS in proteomics, in the clinical and diagnostic field, and in the food sector.

Quantification in capillary electrophoresis-mass spectrometry: long- and short-term variance components and their compensation using internal standards

Different approaches were chosen to examine ionization reproducibility of analytes after separation by capillary electrophoresis-mass spectrometry (CE-MS) in a commercially available sheath-flow electrospray interface. For this task three different standard samples were examined. Sample 1 contained neostigmine bromide (cationic), paracetamol (PCM) (neutral) and nicotinic acid (anionic component). Results were evaluated using internal standard (IS) calculations. Sample 2 represented an isotopically labelled IS of the quantified substance (PCM/D4-PCM), while sample 3 (neostigmine bromide/scopolamine hydrobromide) provided an IS closely migrating to the tested substance. Furthermore, short-time variations inside the interface were examined by multiple injections of the same substance. For sample 1, the relative standard deviations (RSD%s) were between 8 and 25% (n at least 58) for the peak area ratios. Multiple injected samples gave 5.5-19.4% (n = 25) for peak area RSD%. Using a closely migrating IS, sample 3, RSD%s between 6.5 and 10% (n at least 63) were achieved. With isotopically labelled IS, sample 2, an RSD% of 3-4% was achieved for peak area ratios over long periods (n = 25), for shorter periods (n = 9) even 1-2% RSD% was obtained. Keeping the instrument settings constant, the influence on the ionization efficiency and reproducibility was tested, varying the buffer pH, the organic buffer modifier and the sample concentration. Repeatabilities of migration time and peak area were measured and compared. Two 10 mM ammonium acetate buffers with pH 4.0 and 8.5 were investigated. No influence of buffer pH on peak area reproducibility was found. Isopropanol as organic buffer modifier significantly improved the ionisation leading to larger peak areas, but reduced reproducibility. The basic buffer produced slightly better RSD%s for migration times (2.5-4.0%) (n = 180) and faster analysis for the different test analytes of sample 1, while with the acetic buffer, RSD%s from 3.9 to 6.0% were obtained (n at least 163). The positioning of the capillary turned out to be the crucial parameter to ensure reproducible results. Thus, a procedure was established to ensure a defined ion-intensity level after capillary changes. The investigation of the different sample concentrations gave negligible differences in RSD%, showing that the signal-to-noise ratio was not the crucial parameter for reproducibility here, in contrast to CE-UV detection.

Towards validating a method for two-dimensional electrophoresis/silver staining

Two-dimensional electrophoresis (2-DE) is a technique involving numerous steps, many of them to be performed manually. Hence, some operator dependency must be taken into account. An attempt to elucidate the reliability of 2-DE combined with silver staining is presented, employing the general practice to validate a method in pharmaceutical analysis. Most proteomic studies employing 2-DE aim at qualitative or quantitative differences in protein expression. One of the most sensitive and broadly applied staining techniques is silver staining. In order to gain information on accuracy, precision, linearity, and ruggedness of this technique, gels were run in replicates with different amounts of protein from a complex standard sample. In addition, sets of gels were repeated by two different operators in a second independent laboratory equipped with identical hardware and software. Our results show that reliable qualitative data on differential protein expression can be obtained by 2-DE, nevertheless replicate gels should be run and experimental conditions have to be kept stringently to a standardized protocol. Quantitative data are just achievable with spots, which are well-resolved, of high quality, with an optical density (OD) above a certain threshold (OD > 10), and which show a linear response. Quantitative differences occurring due to method-derived deviations may easily be misinterpreted as true changes in protein expression. After normalization, relative standard deviation (RSD) values of approximately 30% (n = 4) could be obtained, therefore minor changes (< 50%) should be critically reviewed.

Identification of proteins by combination of size-exclusion chromatography with matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry and comparison of some desalting procedures for both intact proteins and their tryptic digests

Separation of a protein mixture by size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) was combined with matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOFMS). Identification of proteins in the collected fractions was performed both as intact proteins by MALDI-TOFMS and using peptide mass fingerprinting (PMF) after their digestion with trypsin. The presence of salts mostly disturbs the MALDI-TOFMS signal and, therefore, proper purification or desalting procedures must be employed. Four desalting procedures (desalting column packed with Sephadex G-100, on-target washing, centrifugal filter devices and ZipTip C(18)) for purification of fractions of proteins separated by SEC and their tryptic digests prior to determination of their exact molecular masses by MALDI-TOFMS were compared. In the case of intact proteins, the experiments showed that the best desalting procedures are the use of ZipTip C(18) pipette tips and Ultrafree CL centrifugal filter devices. The peptide digests can be purified by using ZipTip C(18) pipette tips or on-target washing when both of these procedures provide similar results. On-target washing can be used as a simple procedure to improve the mass spectra of salt-containing samples. Analyses of the droplets collected after the on-target washing show losses of sample and matrix caused by dissolution of these compounds during this procedure. Further, it was found that protein identification based on PMF is more sensitive than analyses of intact proteins and that multiple on-target washing is very advantageous for analyses of peptide mixtures with a high content of salts.

Mining biomarkers in human sera using proteomic tools

One of the major difficulties in mining low abundance biomarkers from serum or plasma is due to the fact that a small number of proteins such as albumin, alpha2-macroglobulin, transferrin, and immunoglobulins, may represent as much as 80% of the total serum protein. The large quantity of these proteins makes it difficult to identify low abundance proteins in serum using traditional 2-dimensional electrophoresis. We recently used a combination of multidimensional liquid chromatography and gel electrophoresis coupled to matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization-quadrupole-time of flight and Ion Trap liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry to identify protein markers in sera of Alzheimer's disease (AD), insulin resistance/type-2 diabetes (IR/D2), and congestive heart failure (CHF) patients. We identified 8 proteins that exhibit higher levels in control sera and 36 proteins that exhibit higher levels in disease sera. For example, haptoglobin and hemoglobin are elevated in sera of AD, IR/D2, and CHF patients. The levels of several other proteins including fibrinogen and its fragments, alpha 2-macroglobulin, transthyretin, pro-platelet basic protein, protease inhibitors clade A and C, as well as proteins involved in the classical complement pathway such as complement C3, C4, and C1 inhibitor, were found to differ between IR/D2 and control sera. The sera levels of proteins, such as the 10 kDa subunit of vitronectin, alpha 1-acid glycoprotein, apolipoprotein B100, fragment of factor H, and histidine-rich glycoprotein were observed to be different between AD and controls. The differences observed in these biomarker candidates were confirmed by Western blot and the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. The biological meaning of the proteomic changes in the disease states and the potential use of these changes as diagnostic tools or for therapeutic intervention will be discussed.

High-efficiency, two-dimensional separations of protein digests on microfluidic devices

High-efficiency, two-dimensional separations of tryptic digests were achieved using glass microfluidic devices. Following micellar electrokinetic chromatography (MEKC) separations in a 19.6-cm-long serpentine channel, the peptides were rapidly sampled into a 1.3-cm-long second-dimension channel, where they were separated by capillary electrophoresis (CE). The turns in the serpentine channel were asymmetrically tapered to minimize geometrical contributions to band broadening and to provide ample channel length for high-efficiency chromatographic separations. Analysis of rhodamine B injections routinely produced plate numbers of 230000 and 40000 in the first (MEKC) and second (CE) dimensions, respectively, corresponding to plate heights of 0.9 and 0.3 microm. The electric field strengths were 200 V/cm for MEKC and 2400 V/cm for CE. In analysis times less than 15 min, two-dimensional separation of bovine serum albumin tryptic digest produced a peak capacity of 4200 (110 in the first dimension and 38 in the second dimension). The system was used to identify a peptide from a tryptic digest of ovalbumin using standard addition and to distinguish between tryptic digests of human and bovine hemoglobin.

Capillary electrochromatography of peptides and proteins

This review surveys the accomplishments in the separation of peptides and proteins by capillary electrochromatography (CEC) over the last decade. A significant number of research articles have been published on this topic since the last review. Peptide and proteins separations have been carried out in all three formats of CEC, i.e., packed bed, continuous bed and open-tubular (OT) format. In addition to electrophoresis, different chromatographic modes have been successfully exploited with the most prevalent being reversed-phase mode followed by ion-exchange. Although many researchers continue to use model proteins and peptides primarily to evaluate the performance of novel stationary phases some researchers have also applied CEC to the analysis of real-life samples. The potential of CEC to yield complementary information and sometimes a superior separation with respect to established techniques, i.e., microbore HPLC and capillary electrophoresis has been demonstrated. Instrumental modifications in order to facilitate coupling of CEC to mass spectrometry have further upgraded the value of CEC for proteomic analysis. Capillaries are still the separation vehicle of choice for most researchers yet the microfluidic platform is gaining momentum, propelled particularly by its potential for multitasking, e.g., performing different chromatographic modes in series.

Multivariate approaches in plant science

The objective of proteomics is to get an overview of the proteins expressed at a given point in time in a given tissue and to identify the connection to the biochemical status of that tissue. Therefore sample throughput and analysis time are important issues in proteomics. The concept of proteomics is to encircle the identity of proteins of interest. However, the overall relation between proteins must also be explained. Classical proteomics consist of separation and characterization, based on two-dimensional electrophoresis, trypsin digestion, mass spectrometry and database searching. Characterization includes labor intensive work in order to manage, handle and analyze data. The field of classical proteomics should therefore be extended to also include handling of large datasets in an objective way. The separation obtained by two-dimensional electrophoresis and mass spectrometry gives rise to huge amount of data. We present a multivariate approach to the handling of data in proteomics with the advantage that protein patterns can be spotted at an early stage and consequently the proteins selected for sequencing can be selected intelligently. These methods can also be applied to other data generating protein analysis methods like mass spectrometry and near infrared spectroscopy and examples of application to these techniques are also presented. Multivariate data analysis can unravel complicated data structures and may thereby relieve the characterization phase in classical proteomics. Traditionally statistical methods are not suitable for analysis of the huge amounts of data, where the number of variables exceed the number of objects. Multivariate data analysis, on the other hand, may uncover the hidden structures present in these data. This study takes its starting point in the field of classical proteomics and shows how multivariate data analysis can lead to faster ways of finding interesting proteins. Multivariate analysis has shown interesting results as a supplement to classical proteomics and added a new dimension to the field of proteomics.

Mapping of the Physcomitrella patens proteome

The moss Physcomitrella patens is unique among land plants due to the high rate of homologous recombination in its nuclear DNA. The feasibility of gene targeting makes Physcomitrella an unrivalled model organism in the field of plant functional genomics. To further extend the potentialities of this seed-less plant we aimed at exploring the P. patens proteome. Experimental conditions had to be adopted to meet the special requirements connected to the investigations of this moss. Here we describe the identification of 306 proteins from the protonema of Physcomitrella. Proteins were separated by two dimensional electrophoresis, excised form the gel and analysed by means of mass spectrometry. This reference map will lay the basis for further profound studies in the field of Physcomitrella proteomics.

Protein Characterization by On-Line Capillary Isoelectric Focusing, Reversed-Phase Liquid Chromatography, and Mass Spectrometry

Two-dimensional polyacrylmide gel electrophoresis (2D-PAGE), perhaps the most widely used method in proteomics research, is often limited by sensitivity and throughput. Capillary isoelectric focusing (CIEF) coupled with electrospray ionization (ESI) mass spectrometry (MS) provides a liquid-based alternative to 2D-PAGE that can overcome these problems but is limited by ampholyte interference and signal quenching in ESI-MS. Inserting a reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RPLC) step between CIEF and MS can remove this interference. In this work, a CIEF-RPLC-MS system is described for separation and characterization of proteins in complex mixtures. CIEF is performed with a microdialysis membrane-based cathodic cell that also permits protein fractions to be collected, washed to remove ampholyte, and analyzed by RPLC-MS. CIEF performance with this cell is equivalent to that achieved with a conventional cathodic cell, and no loss of protein is observed during faction collection. The cell can be easily and safely retrofitted into commercial instrumentation and is applicable for peptide analysis as well. Protein detection at the low-femtomole level is demonstrated with little or no interference from ampholyte, and CIEF-RPLC-MS data are used to construct a plot of pI vs MW for a protein mixture. The current instrumental configuration allows seven fractions in the pI range 3-10 to be analyzed by RPLC-MS in 2 h.

Capillary electrophoresis coupled to mass spectrometry to establish polypeptide patterns in dialysis fluids

Combination of capillary electrophoresis with mass spectrometry (CE-MS) allows generation of polypeptide patterns of body fluids. In a single CE-MS (45 min) run more than 600 polypeptides were analyzed in hemodialysis fluids obtained with different membranes (high-flux/low-flux). Larger polypeptides (M(r) > 10 000) were almost exclusively present in high-flux dialysates only, while in low-flux dialysates additional small polypeptides were detected. Comparison to the normal urine pattern yielded a surprisingly low consensus: a number of polypeptides present in urine were missing. We established a fast and sensitive technique, easily applicable to the monitoring of different modalities of dialyzers.

Direct Atmospheric Pressure Coupling of Polyacrylamide Gel Electrophoresis to Mass Spectrometry for Rapid Protein Sequence Analysis

Using laser desorption-atmospheric pressure chemical ionization we describe a novel approach for coupling mass spectrometry to polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. In contrast to other approaches, the method allows for the direct sampling of a polyacrylamide gel-embedded protein without the addition of any exogenous matrixes and is performed at atmospheric pressure. After electrophoresis and enzymatic digestion, the gel is analyzed at AP by photons that desorb neutral peptide molecules, followed by corona discharge ionization in the gas-phase, and subsequent mass analysis. Our experimental results demonstrate the method to (1) rapidly identify electrophoresed proteins via "peptide fingerprinting" using protein databases, (2) detect single-amino acid polymorphisms, and (3) has potential for sub-picomole sensitivity while still maintaining in situ gel desorption-ionization at ambient conditions.

A comparison of drug-treated and untreated HCT-116 human colon adenocarcinoma cells using a 2-D liquid separation mapping method based upon chromatofocusing PI fractionation

A multidimensional chromatographic 2-D liquid-phase separation method has been developed for differential display of proteins from cell lysates and applied to a comparison of protein expression between Peninsularinone-treated and untreated HCT-116 human colon adenocarcinoma cells. The method involves fractionation according to pI using chromatofocusing with analytical columns in the first dimension followed by separation of the proteins in each pI fraction using nonporous reversed-phase HPLC. A 2-D map of the protein content of each cell line based upon pI versus hydrophobicity as detected by UV absorption was generated and a differential display map indicating the presence of up- or downregulated proteins displayed using ProteoVue and DeltaVue software. Using this method, > 1000 protein bands could be detected in 0.2 pH fractions over a pH range of 4-7. In addition, the liquid eluent from the separation was directed on-line into an electrospray TOF-MS to obtain an accurate molecular weight of the intact proteins. An accurate molecular weight together with the peptide map was used to obtain protein identification using database searching. The method has been shown to have high reproducibility for quantitative differential display analysis of interlysate comparisons, generation of accurate protein identifications, and ease of data interpretation. It has been used herein to identify proteins that change as a function of drug treatment. The relative simplicity of the current procedure and the potential for full automation will make this technique an essential tool in future proteomic studies.

Advantages and limitations of coupling isotachophoresis and comprehensive isotachophoresis-capillary electrophoresis to time-of-flight mass spectrometry

Capillary isotachophoresis (ITP) and comprehensive isotachophoresis-capillary electrophoresis (ITP-CE) were successfully coupled to electrospray ionization (ESI) orthogonal acceleration time-of-flight mass spectrometry (TOF-MS) using angiotensin peptides as model analytes. The utility of ITP-TOF-MS and ITP-CE-TOF-MS for the analysis of samples containing analyte amounts sufficient to form flat-top ITP zones (30 microM) as well as for samples with trace analyte amounts (0.3 microM) was studied. Separations were performed in 150 microm internal diameter (I.D.) capillaries for the ITP experiments, and in 200 microm I.D. (ITP) and 50 microm I.D. (CE) capillaries for ITP-CE experiments. The fused-silica columns were coated with poly(vinyl alcohol) to suppress electroosmotic flow that can disrupt ITP zone profiles. The sample loading capacity in both ITP and comprehensive ITP-CE was greatly enhanced (up to 10 microl) compared with typical nanoliter-sized injection volumes in CE. It was concluded that ITP-TOF-MS alone was adequate for the separation and detection of high concentration samples. The outcome was different at lower analyte concentrations where mixed zones or very sharp peaks formed. With formation of mixed zones, ion suppression and discrimination could occur, complicating quantitative determination of the analytes. This problem was effectively overcome by inserting a CE capillary between the ITP and TOF-MS. In such an arrangement, samples were preconcentrated in the high load WTP capillary and then injected into a CE capillary where they were separated into non-overlapping peaks prior to their detection by TOF-MS. The advantage of this comprehensive arrangement, which we have described previously, is that there is no need to discard portions of the sample in order to avoid overloading of the CE capillary. The whole sample is analyzed by multiple injections from ITP to CE. Thus, this method can be used for the analysis of complex samples with wide ranges of component concentrations.

A protein molecular weight map of ES2 clear cell ovarian carcinoma cells using a two-dimensional liquid separations/mass mapping technique

A molecular weight map of the protein content of ES2 human clear cell ovarian carcinoma cells has been produced using a two-dimensional (2-D) liquid separations/mass mapping technique. This method uses a 2-D liquid separation of proteins from whole cell lysates coupled on-line to an electrospray ionization-time of flight (ESI-TOF) mass spectrometer to map the accurate intact molecular weight (M(r)) of the protein content of the cells. The two separation dimensions involve the use of liquid isoelectric focusing as the first phase and nonporous silica reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) as the second phase of separation. The detection by ESI-TOF-MS provides an image of pI versus M(r) analogous to 2-D gel electrophoresis. Each protein is then identified based upon matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI)-TOF-MS peptide mapping and intact M(r) so that a standard map is produced against which other ovarian carcinoma cell lines can be compared. The accurate intact M(r) together with the pI fraction, and peptide map serve to tag the protein for future interlysate comparisons. An internal standard is also used to provide a means for quantitation for future interlysate studies. In the ES2 cell line under study it is shown that nearly 900 M(r) bands are detected over 17 pI fractions from pH 4 to 12 and a M(r) range up to 85 kDa and that around 290 of these bands can be identified using mass spectrometric based techniques. The protein M(r) is detected within an accuracy of 150 ppm and it is shown that many of the proteins in this human cancer sample are modified compared to the database. The protein M(r) map may serve as a highly reproducible standard Web-based method for comparing proteins from related human cell lines.

On-chip coupling of isoelectric focusing and free solution electrophoresis for multidimensional separations

We have developed an acrylic microfluidic device that sequentially couples liquid-phase isoelectric focusing (IEF) and free solution capillary electrophoresis (CE). Rapid separation (<1 min) and preconcentration (73x) of species were achieved in the initial IEF dimension. Using full-field fluorescence imaging, we observed nondispersive mobilization velocities on the order of 20 microm/s during characterization of the IEF step. This transport behavior allowed controlled electrokinetic mobilization of focused sample bands to a channel junction, where voltage switching was used to repeatedly inject effluent from the IEF dimension into an ampholyte-based CE separation. This second dimension was capable of analyzing all fluid volumes of interest from the IEF dimension, as IEF was 'parked' during each CE analysis and refocused prior to additional CE analyses. Investigation of each dimension of the integrated system showed time-dependent species displacement and band-broadening behavior consistent with IEF and CE, respectively. The peak capacity of the 2D system was approximately 1300. A comprehensive 2D analysis of a fluid volume spanning 15% of the total IEF channel length was completed in less than 5 min.

On-line hyphenation of capillary isoelectric focusing and capillary gel electrophoresis by a dialysis interface

An on-line two-dimensional (2D) capillary electrophoresis (CE) system consisting of capillary isoelectric focusing (CIEF) and capillary gel electrophoresis (CGE) was introduced. To validate this 2D system, a dialysis interface was developed by mounting a hollow fiber on a methacrylate resin plate to hyphenate the two CE modes. The two dimensions of capillary shared a cathode fixated into a reservoir in the methacrylate plate; thus, with three electrodes and only one high-voltage source, a 2D CE framework was successfully established. A practical 2D CIEF-CGE experiment was carried out to deal with a target protein, hemoglobin (Hb). After the Hb variants with different isoelectric points (pIs) were focused in various bands in the first-dimension capillary, they were chemically mobilized one after another and fed to the second-dimension capillary for further separation in polyacrylamide gel. During this procedure, a single CIEF band was separated into several peaks due to different molecular weights. The resulting electrophoregram is quite different from that of either CIEF or CGE; therefore, more information about the studied Hb sample can be obtained.

Two-dimensional liquid separations-mass mapping of proteins from human cancer cell lysates

A review of two-dimensional (2D) liquid separation methods used in our laboratory to map the protein content of human cancer cells is presented herein. The methods discussed include various means of fractionating proteins according to isoelectric point (pI) in the first dimension. The proteins in each pI fraction are subsequently separated using nonporous (NPS) reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography (RP-HPLC). The liquid eluent of the RP-HPLC separation is directed on-line into an electrospray ionization time-of-flight (ESI-TOF) mass spectrometer where an accurate value of the protein intact M(r) can be obtained. The result is a 2D map of pI versus M(r) analogous to 2D gel electrophoresis; however the highly accurate and reproducible M(r) serves as the basis for interlysate comparisons. In addition, the use of liquid separations allows for the collection of hundreds of purified proteins in the liquid phase for further analysis via peptide mass mapping using matrix assisted laser desorption ionization TOF MS. A description of the methodology used and its applications to analysis of several types of human cancer cell lines is described. The potential of the method for differential proteomic analysis for the identification of biomarkers of disease is discussed.

Laser desorption-atmospheric pressure chemical ionization: a novel ion source for the direct coupling of polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis to mass spectrometry

Laser desorption-atmospheric pressure chemical ionization-mass spectrometry (LD-APCI-MS) is presented for the atmospheric pressure (AP) sampling of tryptic peptides directly from a polyacrylamide gel. In contrast to other gel sampling mass spectrometric approaches, this technique does not require the addition of any exogenous matrices to the gel to assist with ionization. In this arrangement, a CO(2) laser at 10.6 micro m is used to desorb intact neutral peptide molecules from the gel, followed by ionization in the gas-phase with APCI. The ions are then sampled via a heated capillary inlet and transferred to a quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometer for mass analysis. Preliminary results suggest the polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis-LD-APCI-MS technique provides several advantages that could translate into a more convenient, robust methodology for the rapid identification and characterization of proteins. Finally, strategies regarding the further development of the method are presented.

Methods for fractionation, separation and profiling of proteins and peptides

In the last few years there has been an increased effort to develop technologies capable of identifying and quantifying large numbers of proteins expressed within a cell system (i.e., the proteome). The complexity of the mixtures being analyzed has made the development of effective fractionation and separation methods a critical component of this effort. This review highlights many of the protein and peptide fractionation and separation methods, such as electrophoresis and high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC), which have experienced significant development over the past forty years. Modern instrumental strategies for the resolution of cell proteins, based on separations employing a single high-resolution or multidimensional approach, and the relative merits of each, will be discussed. The focus of this manuscript will be on the development of multidimensional separations such as two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (2D-PAGE), HPLC/HPLC, and HPLC-capillary electrophoresis and their application to the characterization of complex proteome mixtures.

On-line coupling of capillary isoelectric focusing with transient isotachophoresis-zone electrophoresis: A two-dimensional separation system for proteomics

A microdialysis junction is employed as the interface for on-line coupling of capillary isoelectric focusing with transient isotachophoresis-zone electrophoresis in a two-dimensional separation system. Capillary isoelectric focusing not only provides high-resolution separation of tryptic peptides based on their differences in isoelectric point, but also potentially allows the analysis of low-abundance proteins with a typical concentration factor of 50-100 times. Carrier ampholytes, employed for the creation of a pH gradient during focusing, are further utilized as the leading electrolyte in the second separation dimension, transient isotachophoresis-zone electrophoresis. Many peptides which have the same isoelectric point would most likely have different charge-to-mass ratios, and thus different electrophoretic mobilities in zone electrophoresis. Two-dimensional separation of proteolytic peptides is demonstrated using standard proteins, including cytochrome c, ribonuclease A, and carbonic anhydrase II. The maximum peak capacity is estimated to be around approximately 1600 and can be significantly increased by simply increasing the capillary column length and manipulating the range of pH gradient in isoelectric focusing. In addition to enhanced separation efficiency and resolution, this two-dimensional electrokinetic separation system permits sensitive and comprehensive analysis of peptide fragments, especially when integrated with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry for peptide/protein identification.

Two-dimensional gel electrophoresis; better than a poke in the ICAT?

To date, the most widely used technology for conducting proteomic studies has been two-dimensional gel electrophoresis (2DGE), but this approach does have drawbacks. Isotope-coded affinity tagging (ICAT) is starting to challenge 2DGE as a new proteomic tool for the analysis of proteins in complex biological specimens. An appraisal of these two methodologies reveals that neither ICAT nor 2DGE provide comprehensive coverage on a proteome-wide scale.