Open trial of methotrexate as treatment for autoimmune hearing loss

Relapsing autoimmune inner ear disease with significant response to methotrexate and azathioprine combination therapy: A case report and mini literature review

RATIONALE

Autoimmune inner ear disease typically presents with bilateral hearing loss that progresses over weeks or months though its mechanisms are unknown. Corticosteroids are the first-line treatment, but their responses are variable and relapses are frequent. Thus, many experts have sought to replace corticosteroids with immunosuppressive agents.

PATIENT CONCERNS

A 35-year-old woman experienced a progressive hearing impairment, initially on the left side and later becoming bilateral. Her response to corticosteroid monotherapy was temporary, and there have been two relapse episodes over several months.

DIAGNOSES

Autoimmune inner ear disease was considered due to evidence of autoimmunity combined with a clinical course of bilateral and recurrent sensorineural hearing loss and a partial response to corticosteroid therapy.

INTERVENTIONS

The patient received a 3-day mini-pulse of methylprednisolone at 250 mg/d, followed by 12 mg/d maintenance, and concurrently began an azathioprine regimen gradually increasing to 100 mg/day as a corticosteroid-sparing agent.

OUTCOMES

Three weeks after immunosuppressive therapy, hearing and pure-tone audiometry improved, and after 7 weeks, methylprednisolone was tapered to 8 mg/d. The dosage was further reduced by adding methotrexate at 7.5 mg/week, resulting in a reduction to 4 mg/d as maintenance therapy after 4 weeks.

LESSONS

For patients who are unresponsive to corticosteroids or experience difficulty tolerating them, a combination therapy of methotrexate and azathioprine is recommended as a viable alternative as this regimen is well-tolerated and yields positive outcomes.

Allergy, Immunotherapy, and Alternative Treatments for Dizziness

Allergic reactions may result in central symptoms of dizziness, including nonspecific chronic imbalance, Meniere's disease, and autoimmune inner ear disease. Excepting first-generation antihistamines, and short-term use of steroids, most pharmacotherapies used to treat allergic rhinitis have limited benefit in treating allergically induced or related dizziness. Allergy immunotherapy and/or an elimination diet for diagnosed food allergies have been found to be effective treatments. Individuals diagnosed with autoimmune inner ear disease remain challenging to treat and may require high-dose, long-term steroid treatment, biologics, or immunomodulators for symptom control.

Autoimmune inner ear disease: A systematic review of management

OBJECTIVES

The study systematically reviewed the existing literature on the management of autoimmune inner ear disease (AIED).

STUDY DESIGN

Systematic review.

METHODS

We performed a literature search of Embase, NCBI, Cochrane, and Web of Science databases from April 1990 to April 2020. Inclusion criteria included studies that were retrospective or prospective in nature evaluating the treatment of AIED with audiometric data measuring hearing outcomes during treatment. Hearing improvement was the primary study outcome and improvement in vestibular symptoms was the secondary study outcome.

RESULTS

Sixteen of 412 candidate articles were included in our study. Systemic steroid treatment is most commonly described. Alternative treatment modalities included intratympanic steroid treatment, methotrexate, cyclophosphamide, azathioprine, infliximab, etanercept, adalimumab, golimumab, methylprednisolone, rituximab, and anakinra.

CONCLUSION

Systemic corticosteroids are the first line treatment of AIED. Intratympanic steroids are a potential adjuvant or alternative treatment for patients who cannot tolerate or become refractory to steroid treatment. Steroid nonresponders may benefit from biologic therapy. Alternative treatment modalities including nonsteroidal immunosuppressants and biologics have been studied in small cohorts of patients with varying results. Prospective studies investigating the efficacy of biologic and nonsteroidal therapy are warranted.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

2.

Inflammation associated with noise-induced hearing loss

Inflammation is a complex biological response to harmful stimuli including infection, tissue damage, and toxins. Thus, it is not surprising that cochlear damage by noise includes an inflammatory component. One mechanism by which inflammation is generated by tissue damage is the activation of damage-associated molecular patterns (DAMPs). Many of the cellular receptors for DAMPS, including Toll-like receptors, NOD-like receptors, and DNA receptors, are also receptors for pathogens, and function in the innate immune system. DAMP receptors are known to be expressed by cochlear cells, and binding of molecules released by damaged cells to these receptors result in the activation of cell stress pathways. This leads to the generation of pro-inflammatory cytokines and chemokines that recruit pro-inflammatory leukocytes. Extensive evidence indicates pro-inflammatory cytokines including TNF alpha and interleukin 1 beta, and chemokines including CCL2, are induced in the cochlea after noise exposure. The recruitment of macrophages into the cochlea has also been demonstrated. These provide substrates for noise damage to be enhanced by inflammation. Evidence is provided by the effectiveness of anti-inflammatory drugs in ameliorating noise-induced hearing loss. Involvement of inflammation provides a wide variety of additional anti-inflammatory and pro-resolution agents as potential pharmacological interventions in noise-induced hearing loss.

Pediatric Autoimmune Inner Ear Disease: A Rare, But Treatable Condition

Autoimmune inner ear disease (AIED) is a rare, but treatable cause of sudden sensorineural hearing loss in children. Most cases present acutely and involve both ears. The precise mechanism of hearing loss in AIED is not known. Many suspected etiologies have been proposed including infections, vascular abnormalities, and trauma. However, 70% of cases are defined as idiopathic. There are no standardized diagnostic criteria for AIED, and the diagnostic process may be challenging. Positive auto antibodies and response to immunosuppressive therapy support the diagnosis. Treatment may include corticosteroids and steroid-sparing immunosuppressive medications. A high index of suspicion is recommended as the hearing loss may be stabilized or even reversed with early treatment. Long-term medical treatment failures generally have good outcomes with cochlear implantation. [Pediatr Ann. 2019;48(10):e391-e394.].

Superparamagnetic Nanoparticle Delivery to the Cochlea Through Round Window by External Magnetic Field: Feasibility and Toxicity

Introduction. The objective of this study was to evaluate the feasibility and toxicity of superparamagnetic iron oxide nanoparticles (SPIONs) administered into the cochlea through the round window (RW) by an external magnetic field. Materials and Methods. In 5 Wistar rats, the left RW was punctured. SPIONs suspended in hyaluronic gel (5 mg/mL) were applied in the RW niche and covered by a muscle graft. The nanoparticles were mobilized using a rare earth magnet (0.54 T) held in 4 consecutive positions around the head. The right ear served as control. Hearing function was monitored by auditory brainstem responses (4-32 kHz tone bursts). Results. The auditory thresholds remained unchanged 1 month after the administration. The histological study of the cochleae showed that SPIONs were driven into the scala tympani in the basal turn, the second turn, and the apex. Conclusion. Superparamagnetic nanoparticles can be driven inside the cochlea toward the apex with a preserved hearing up to 1 month in rats.

Fluctuating Sensorineural Hearing Loss

BACKGROUND

Several otologic conditions can present with fluctuating sensorineural hearing loss, including Ménière's disease, autoimmune inner ear disease, and enlarged vestibular aqueduct. Although these 3 etiologies vary greatly, distinguishing between these conditions at initial presentation can be challenging. Furthermore, initial treatment of these conditions is often similar. In this review, we discuss historical and current perspectives on diagnosis and treatment of these conditions.

SUMMARY

A literature search was performed regarding fluctuating hearing loss, and current treatment of these etiologies of fluctuating hearing loss was summarized. Immediate measures at the onset of acute hearing loss include corticosteroid therapy, while preventative and chronic therapies, which can limit disease severity and frequency, vary based on the specific condition treated. Key Messages: Fluctuating hearing loss can represent a range of pathologies, but the precise etiology may not be clear at initial presentation. Timely treatment and long-term follow-up, along with appropriate diagnostics, are necessary to optimize long-term hearing.

Emerging options in immune-mediated hearing loss

Objective

AIED (autoimmune inner ear disease) is an autoimmune process that leads to the dysfunction of the inner ear, resulting in fluctuating, audiovestibular symptoms. Although the pathogenesis is likely heterogeneous, immune processes within the inner ear ultimately lead to histopathologic changes and sensorineural hearing loss. This review will discuss the latest evidence on treatment options.

Methods

A literature search on articles pertaining to the treatment of autoimmune inner ear disease was performed on PubMed.

Results

Corticosteroid treatment continues to remain as first line therapy for AIED but long-term responsiveness is poor. Cytotoxic chemotherapies can be effective alternatives for steroid nonresponsive patients, but significant side effects may limit their use. Intratympanic steroid injections are beneficial and although there is not enough evidence currently to supplant oral steroid trial they may be a useful adjunct if steroid toxicity is an issue. The efficacy of biologic agents has been variable. Compared to placebo, etanercept does not improve the hearing improvement already attained by steroids alone. However, open pilot studies of other biologic agents show hearing improvements, improvements in tinnitus/aural fullness/vertigo, ability to wean steroid dependency, or benefits in steroid-resistant AIED.

Conclusion

There is currently not enough evidence that alternative treatments supersede the use of initial steroid treatment. Biologic agents and intratympanic steroid injections are relatively well tolerated and should be considered as adjunctive therapy. More studies on the efficacy of various biologics and more studies on the treatment of steroid resistant disease especially after initial benefit are still needed. For those who eventually lose their hearing, cochlear implantation remains as a viable option.

Level of Evidence

expert opinion.

Optimal management of Cogan's syndrome: a multidisciplinary approach

Cogan's syndrome (CS) is a rare disorder characterized by nonsyphilitic interstitial keratitis (IK) and audio-vestibular symptoms. CS affects mainly young Caucasian adults, mostly during their first three decades of age, and may develop into typical and atypical variants. Typical CS manifests primarily with IK and hearing loss, whereas atypical CS usually presents with inflammatory ocular manifestations in association with audio-vestibular symptoms but mostly different Ménière-like symptoms and, more frequently, with systemic inflammation (70%), of which vasculitis is the pathogenic mechanism. CS is considered as an autoimmune- or immune-mediated disease supported mainly by the beneficial response to corticosteroids. Using well-developed assays, antibodies to inner ear antigens, anti-Hsp70, and antineutrophil cytoplasmic antibodies were found to be associated with CS. Corticosteroids represent the first line of treatment, and multiple immunosuppressive drugs have been tried with variable degrees of success. Tumor necrosis factor-alpha blockers and other biological agents are a recent novel therapeutic option in CS. Cochlear implantation is a valuable rescue surgical strategy in cases with severe sensorineural hearing loss unresponsive to intensive and/or innovative immunosuppressive regimens.

Cogan and Behcet syndromes

Cogan and Behcet syndromes are considered large vessel vasculitides. Both are rare diseases, with varied clinical manifestations affecting multiple organ systems. Although both have hallmark symptoms (ocular and vestibuloauditory inflammation in Cogan syndrome and aphthous ulcers in Behcet syndrome), neither has confirmatory diagnostic testing. Delayed diagnosis can result in poor outcomes. In both syndromes, large vessel arterial inflammation may result in severe morbidity and mortality. Treatment strategies in both syndromes vary based on organ system involvement and severity of manifestations. In this article, the epidemiology, proposed pathogenesis, manifestations, and the most current treatment paradigms for these syndromes are reviewed.

Immune system of the inner ear as a novel therapeutic target for sensorineural hearing loss

Sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL) is a common clinical condition resulting from dysfunction in one or more parts in the auditory pathway between the inner ear and auditory cortex. Despite the prevalence of SNHL, little is known about its etiopathology, although several mechanisms have been postulated including ischemia, viral infection or reactivation, and microtrauma. Immune-mediated inner ear disease has been introduced and accepted as one SNHL pathophysiology; it responds to immunosuppressive therapy and is one of the few reversible forms of bilateral SNHL. The concept of immune-mediated inner ear disease is straightforward and comprehensible, but criteria for clinical diagnosis and the precise mechanism of hearing loss have not been determined. Moreover, the therapeutic mechanisms of corticosteroids are unclear, leading to several misconceptions by both clinicians and investigators concerning corticosteroid therapy. This review addresses our current understanding of the immune system in the inner ear and its involvement in the pathophysiology in SNHL. Treatment of SNHL, including immune-mediated inner ear disorder, will be discussed with a focus on the immune mechanism and immunocompetent cells as therapeutic targets. Finally, possible interventions modulating the immune system in the inner ear to repair the tissue organization and improve hearing in patients with SNHL will be discussed. Tissue macrophages in the inner ear appear to be a potential target for modulating the immune response in the inner ear in the pathophysiology of SNHL.

Local and systemic effects of low-dose transtympanic methotrexate: in vivo animal study

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the safety of low-dose transtympanic methotrexate in a rat model.

DESIGN

Experimental animal study.

SETTING

Tertiary training and research hospital.

METHODS

Twenty-four rats were randomly divided into three study groups. Diluted methotrexate solution was administered transtympanically to fill the middle-ear cavity, twice a week in group one and three times a week in group two. Ringer lactate solution was administered transtympanically three times a week in the control group.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Local and systemic effects of low-dose transtympanic methotrexate.

RESULTS

In the methotrexate groups, middle-ear mucosal oedema was present in all animals. Auditory brainstem response thresholds indicated no inner-ear dysfunction in any group. Liver function and serum haemoglobin levels showed no statistically significant difference in any group. However, liver biopsies from groups one and two showed mild portal hyperaemia.

CONCLUSION

These findings are encouraging, and support further investigation of the topical application of methotrexate in autoimmune hearing diseases, as an alternative or adjunct to transtympanic steroids.

Immunosuppressive therapy for autoimmune inner ear disease

Autoimmune inner ear disease (AIED) is a rare disease that is diagnosed after clinical suspicion and response to corticosteroids. AIED manifests as progressive, bilateral, although often asynchronous, sensorineural hearing loss and can be associated with vestibular symptoms. Since its description as a defined disease entity in 1979, the initial mainstay of treatment remains high-dose corticosteroids. Several animal models have been developed to assist in determining efficacy of immunosuppression in AIED, and several clinical studies have also investigated the role of both steroid and steroid-sparing treatments. Here we discuss the basic science and clinical research surrounding the history of immunosuppressive therapy in AIED.

Bilateral progressive hearing loss and vestibular dysfunction with inner ear antibodies

Autoimmune inner ear disease (AIED) is a clinical syndrome of uncertain etiology. We present the neuro-otological findings of 2 cases of bilateral hearing loss, dizziness and the antibody profiles of the inner ears. Case 1 had bilateral progressive hearing loss, vestibular dysfunction and abnormal eye movement as the disease progressed. She had inner ear antibodies against 42 and 58kDa protein antigency on Western blot immune assay, and responded to glycocorticosteroid but not to immunosuppressant treatment. Intratympanic steroid injection temporally eliminated her symptoms. However, she developed idiopathic Cushing's syndrome and underwent labyrinthectomy. Case 2 became deaf as a teenager and experienced dizziness 10 years after becoming deaf. He reacted strongly to 68kDa protein and was a good responder to immunosuppressant with steroid. As we still lack a definitive diagnostic test for AIED, careful observation of the clinical course is critical for differential diagnosis regarding the bilateral progressive hearing loss.

Cogan's syndrome: a rare cause of meningoencephalitis

We report a 14-year-old boy who presented with meningoencephalitis. Other features particularly auditory, vestibular, and ocular lead to the diagnosis of Cogan's syndrome. Treatment with prednisolone resulted in a rapid improvement and recovery of his hearing. Cogan's syndrome is a rare primary vasculitis, characterized by ocular, auditory, and vestibular symptoms, which can have significant morbidity and mortality. Presentation with a meningoencephalitic picture is unusual. Increased awareness of its clinical features among pediatricians and pediatric neurologists should lead to earlier diagnosis and increased recognition of the serious systemic manifestations. Early use of prednisolone can prevent hearing loss and can also be useful in treating the other vasculitic manifestations.

Cogan's syndrome: present and future directions

Cogan's syndrome, typified by the combination of interstitial keratitis and immune-mediated sensorineural hearing loss, is a rare condition, and commonly associated with a diagnostic delay. Using a standard search protocol, we review the literature to date, focusing on a number of key areas pertaining to diagnosis, presentation and treatment. Using a case illustration of atypical disease which led to fulminant aortic regurgitation, we highlight the need for continued and collaborative research in order to identify negative prognostic factors and thus tailor therapeutic regimens. Atypical Cogan's syndrome is more commonly associated with systemic manifestations than typical disease, and may be refractory to immunosuppressive treatment. We discuss the application of laboratory (e.g antibodies targeting inner ear antigens) and radiological (PET-CT) aids to disease confirmation and detection of sub-clinical vascular inflammation. As illustrated by the included case description, some patients remain refractory to intense immunosuppression and delineation of adverse prognostic factors which may direct treatment, perhaps including the use of PET-CT, will contribute in the future to improving patient outcomes.

Atypical Cogan's syndrome with aortitis

Cogan's syndrome is characterized by non syphilitic interstitial keratitis and Meniere's syndrome-like audiovestibular function disorder, as well as various systemic manifestations, including fever, arthralgia, vasculitis, and aortitis. We report the case of atypical Cogan's syndrome with aortitis; the patient's symptoms caused by active inflammation, including inflammatory ocular manifestations, audiovestibular symptoms, and aortitis, were improved by early administration of corticosteroids, however, her reduced visual acuity was not improved because of post-inflammatory change in her left eye.

Sensorineural hearing loss in systemic lupus erythematosus: case report and literature review

OBJECTIVES

We present a case of systemic lupus erythematosus with symptomatic sensorineural hearing loss which was successfully treated with azathioprine, as assessed both clinically and radiologically. We also present a review of the relevant literature.

CASE REPORT

A woman with systemic lupus erythematosus presented with sensorineural hearing loss, initially on the right and subsequently developing on the left over several months. An audiogram revealed profound neurosensory hearing loss bilaterally. The patient was treated with prednisone 60 mg daily and azathioprine 200 mg daily. An improvement on the left was noted on follow-up audiography as well as on magnetic resonance imaging of the internal auditory canals and surrounding structures.

CONCLUSION

Sensorineural hearing loss has been described in autoimmune disorders but is rare. Aural symptoms have been described, with varying incidences (0-57.5 per cent), in systemic lupus erythematosus. However, symptomatic sensorineural hearing loss is rare in systemic lupus erythematosus. Prednisone appears essential when an immunological or vasculitic cause is found. The use of azathioprine should be considered, as well as follow-up with magnetic resonance imaging to detect improvement.

Low-dose oral methotrexate for the management of childhood Cogan’s syndrome: a case report

Cogan's syndrome is a rare inflammatory disease characterized by nonsyphilitic ocular interstitial keratitis associated with hearing loss and vestibular impairment. Although systemic corticosteroids are usually used as the standard therapy, hearing ability in most cases gradually deteriorates. We, herein, describe a patient with childhood Cogan's syndrome who was treated with low-dose oral methotrexate, which successfully helped to taper the doses of the systemic corticosteroids. The serum levels of the complements were good markers for the disease activity in this patient.

Asymptomatic Sensorineural Hearing Loss in Patients With Systemic Lupus Erythematosus

OBJECTIVE

Hearing loss can accompany systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). The purpose of this study was to evaluate the prevalence of asymptomatic sensorineural hearing loss (ASNHL) in patients with SLE.

METHODS

Thirty-one unselected consecutive female patients with SLE (American College of Rheumatology criteria, 1982) were evaluated (in a prospective and descriptive study) for evidence of hearing abnormalities. Twenty-five healthy age-matched women served as controls. All patients and control groups underwent both a normal tympanoscopy and an audiometric testing as a prerequisite to be included in the study.

RESULTS

Patients with SLE had a mean age of 35 years (range, 19-64 years) and the follow-up time (median) was 48 months (range, 4-180 months). One of 31 patients was excluded because of middle ear infectious disease. Of the remaining 30 patients, 21 (70%) had impaired hearing; 20 (66%) had sensorineural loss at high frequencies in a bilateral and symmetric way, and one had conductive alteration. Ten patients had normal audiometric studies. Four women in the control group had alterations of the audiometric tests: 3 patients had conductive alteration and the other one had bilateral ASNHL. No statistically significant correlation was found among the presence of ASNHL, the detection of antiphospholipid antibodies, and the treatment with hydroxychloroquine. Also, no correlation was observed between impaired hearing and SLE activity.

CONCLUSION

If it can be established how often this ASNHL progresses to a clinical problem, it can be important that, as part of initial studies, patients with SLE undergo audiometric tests.

Alternatives to systemic steroid therapy for refractory immune-mediated inner ear disease: a physiopathologic approach

Immune-mediated inner ear disease (IMIED) is one of the few forms of reversible sensorineural hearing loss. Corticosteroids-responsive patients are usually associated with hearing improvement. Due to the long clinical course of IMIED that frequently present recurrences (hearing loss and vertigo), alternatives to corticosteroids such as methotrexate and recently TNF-alpha blockers have been proposed. Likewise new procedures for delivering corticosteroids to the inner ear have been developed. The aim of this article is to assess the efficacy of methotrexate and transtympanic 6-methylprednisolone in refractory IMIED. From a database of 200 patients affected by IMIED, 16 selected patients with refractory disease were included in the present study. Five patients were treated with methotrexate and 11 by means of transtympanic injection of 6-methylprednisolone. All patients treated with methotrexate had an improvement in their vestibular symptoms. However, hearing loss did not improve. Most patients treated with local 6-methylprednisolone (68.75%) showed an improvement in hearing loss and vestibular symptoms. Methotrexate has been shown to be ineffective in maintaining long-term remissions of hearing relapses although patients presented an improvement in vestibular symptoms. However, transtympanic 6-methylprednisolone has been shown to be a safe, easy and useful therapy in refractory IMIED and it may actually become the first-line treatment for these patients based on the existence of glucocorticoid receptors and the possible targets of immune-mediated damage within the inner ear.

Syndrome de Cogan révélé par une diarrhée glairo-sanglante

INTRODUCTION

Cogan's syndrome is defined by the combination of non syphilitic interstitial keratitis and inner ear dysfunction, similar to Meniere's disease.

OBSERVATION

Cogan's syndrome was revealed by haemorrhagic glaireous diarrhoea in a 21 year-old woman whose medical history included Hirschsprung's disease. Cerebral MRI revealed viral-like bilateral neuritis of the eighth cranial nerve, never described in the literature before. The auditory and visual disorders regressed after treatment with corticosteroids.

CONCLUSION

The early diagnosis of Cogan's syndrome permits the cure of the visual and auditory and notably inner ear symptoms with corticosteroid therapy.

Etanercept therapy for immune-mediated cochleovestibular disorders: A multi-center, open-label, pilot study

OBJECTIVE

Immune-mediated cochleovestibular disorders (IMCVDs) continue to present a diagnostic and therapeutic challenge. Antirheumatic agents, commonly employed for IMCVDs, are associated with variable efficacy and sometimes with serious side effects. The objective of the current study was to preliminarily evaluate the efficacy of etanercept therapy for IMCVD.

METHODS

In this open-label prospective pilot study, 23 patients with bilateral IMCVDs or symptoms of bilateral Meniere's disease were treated with etanercept (25 mg twice weekly, by subcutaneous injection) for 24 weeks. All participants showed progressive hearing loss within 3 months prior to the study and responded to prednisone therapy. Hearing improvement was defined as an improvement of sensorineural hearing from baseline, in at least one ear, of 15 dB or more in the pure-tone air conduction thresholds, or an increase of more than 12% in word identification score. When present, vertigo and tinnitus were assessed by frequency and severity of attack and a functional level scale. Limited serial positron emission tomography (PET) of the inner ear region was performed in 5 patients to assess disease activity.

RESULTS

There were 12 female (52%) and 11 male patients with a mean age of 48 years. Hearing improved in 7 (30%) patients, was unchanged in 13 (57%), and worsened in 3 (13%). Of 21 patients with tinnitus, this symptom improved in 7 (33%), was unchanged in 10 (48%), and worsened in 3 (13%). Of 16 patients with vertigo, 8 (50%) were improved, 7 (47%) unchanged, and 1 (3%) worse at the end of the study. Etanercept was generally well tolerated. PET was positive on one ear of 2 of 5 patients, remained positive with treatment on 1 of these, and was initially positive in 1 deaf ear, becoming negative at followup.

CONCLUSION

These prospective pilot data suggest that etanercept therapy is safe among patients with IMCVDs. However, these data do not suggest substantial efficacy of etanercept among patients with IMCVDs in improving hearing loss. There appeared to be stabilization or improvement of hearing in 87% in this group of patients with pretreatment intractable progressive hearing loss. However, the study endpoint of improvement in 70% of patients was not attained. This short-term effect of possible stabilization requires further study. PET scanning was not useful as a tool to evaluate hearing loss in a limited subset of patients.

Immune-mediated inner ear disease: 10-year experience

BACKGROUND

Autoimmune inner ear disease (AIED) was first described in 1979 and the disease has become more widely recognized over the last decade. Limited information is available regarding clinical features of the disease, disease course, and response to treatment.

OBJECTIVE

To analyze data from 42 patients with documented immune mediated inner ear disease to further define this syndrome.

METHODS

A retrospective chart review was conducted on all patients considered to have AIED by the Otolaryngology division physicians and on all patients positive for antibody testing to inner ear antigens from 1990 to 1999. Patients who were antibody positive with a clinical diagnosis of AIED were included in this review.

RESULTS

Patients with AIED presented with rapidly progressive, frequently bilateral (79%), often fluctuating sensironeural hearing loss. Mean age at presentation was 50 years (22-80) with no gender predilection. Tinnitus (83%), vestibular complaints (79%), and Menieres (50%) were common concomitant symptoms along with hearing loss. Seven of 42 (17%) of the patients had evidence for other systemic autoimmune disorders. In 4 of the patients the onset of vestibuloauditory complaints preceded the diagnosis of autoimmune disorder. Thirty-three of 42 demonstrated antibodies to inner ear antigens but other autoantibodies were infrequent except in patients with systemic autoimmune disorders. Twenty-three of 33 (70%) of patients treated with corticosteroids improved clinically, often short-term. Sixteen patients received treatment with other immunosuppressive drugs including methotrexate, cyclophosphamide, azathioprine, mycophenolic mofetil, and intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIg) generally with a limited modest response. Using clinical trial criteria for response, only 5/35 (14%) demonstrated improvement over a mean 34.4 months follow-up.

CONCLUSIONS

Immune-mediated inner ear disease is not a uniform disease with simple diagnosis or treatment. The course of the disease often results in significant long-term disability due to hearing loss and response to aggressive immunosuppression including corticosteroids is poor.

Blockage of immune-mediated inner ear damage by etanercept

HYPOTHESIS

Etanercept will be able to reduce the inflammation and hearing loss associated with experimentally induced labyrinthitis.

BACKGROUND

Inner ear immune responses cause hearing loss that may be reversible with pharmacologic treatment. Etanercept, tumor necrosis factor receptor blocker, was investigated in a guinea pig model of immune-mediated hearing loss. Sterile labyrinthitis was created by injection of keyhole limpet hemocyanin into the inner ear after systemic sensitization to keyhole limpet hemocyanin with adjuvant. Labyrinthitis involves infiltration of inflammatory cells and hearing loss detectable 3 to 5 days after challenge with keyhole limpet hemocyanin.

METHODS

Etanercept was administered either systemically (2.5 mg) 30 minutes before intracochlear challenge with keyhole limpet hemocyanin, with a second intraperitoneal dose (2.5 mg) 3 days later or locally by long-term infusion into the scala tympani with an osmotic pump (5.0 microg/h for 7 days). Auditory evoked brainstem response thresholds were measured before and after treatment to determine hearing loss. Cochleas were evaluated for the amount of inflammation.

RESULTS

Hearing loss in the untreated systemic group averaged 71 +/- 21 dB versus 37 +/- 32 dB in the etanercept-treated animals (t test, P < 0.001). There was also less inflammation in the cochleas from etanercept-treated animals (t test, P < 0.01). Hearing loss with local administration of etanercept was 59 +/- 31 dB in the nontreated ears and 18 +/- 8 dB in the treated ears (t test, P < 0.02). Inflammation was also less (t test, P < 0.01). Etanercept was not ototoxic.

CONCLUSION

Prompt intervention with the anti-inflammatory drug etanercept significantly reduces inflammation sufficient for substantive hearing preservation.