Energy Absorption Properties of Periodic and Stochastic 3D Lattice Materials

Crashworthiness Investigations for 3D-Printed Multi-Layer Multi-Topology Engineering Resin Lattice Materials

In comparison to monolithic materials, cellular solids have superior energy absorption capabilities. Of particular interest within this category are the periodic lattice materials, which offer repeatable and highly customizable behavior, particularly in combination with advances in additive manufacturing technologies. In this paper, the crashworthiness of engineering multi-layer, multi-topology (MLMT) resin lattices is experimentally examined. First, the response of a single- and three-layer single topology cubic and octet lattices, at a relative density of 30%, is investigated. Then, the response of MLMT lattices is characterized and compared to those single-topology lattices. Crashworthiness data were collected for all topology arrangements, finding that while the three-layer cubic and octet lattices were capable of absorbing 9.8 J and 7.8 J, respectively, up to their respective densification points, the unique MLMT lattices were capable of absorbing more: 19.0 J (octet-cube-octet) and 22.4 J (cube-octet-cube). These values are between 94% and 187% greater than the single-topology clusters of the same mass.

Design, Manufacturing, and Analysis of Periodic Three-Dimensional Cellular Materials for Energy Absorption Applications: A Critical Review

Cellular materials offer industries the ability to close gaps in the material selection design space with properties not otherwise achievable by bulk, monolithic counterparts. Their superior specific strength, stiffness, and energy absorption, as well as their multi-functionality, makes them desirable for a wide range of applications. The objective of this paper is to compile and present a review of the open literature focusing on the energy absorption of periodic three-dimensional cellular materials. The review begins with the methodical cataloging of qualitative and quantitative elements from 100 papers in the available literature and then provides readers with a thorough overview of the state of this research field, discussing areas such as parent material(s), manufacturing methods, cell topologies, cross-section shapes for truss topologies, analysis methods, loading types, and test strain rates. Based on these collected data, areas of great and limited research are identified and future avenues of interest are suggested for the continued maturation and growth of this field, such as the development of a consistent naming and classification system for topologies; the creation of test standards considering additive manufacturing processes; further investigation of non-uniform and non-cylindrical struts on the performance of truss lattices; and further investigation into the performance of lattice materials under the impact of non-flat surfaces and projectiles. Finally, the numerical energy absorption (by mass and by volume) data of 76 papers are presented across multiple property selection charts, highlighting various materials, manufacturing methods, and topology groups. While there are noticeable differences at certain densities, the graphs show that the categorical differences within those groups have large overlap in terms of energy absorption performance and can be referenced to identify areas for further investigation and to help in the preliminary design process by researchers and industry professionals alike.

Crashworthiness of 3D Lattice Topologies under Dynamic Loading: A Comprehensive Study

Periodic truss-based lattice materials, a particular subset of cellular solids that generally have superior specific properties as compared to monolithic materials, offer regularity and predictability that irregular foams do not. Significant advancements in alternative technologies-such as additive manufacturing-have allowed for the fabrication of these uniquely complex materials, thus boosting their research and development within industries and scientific communities. However, there have been limitations in the comparison of results for these materials between different studies reported in the literature due to differences in analysis approaches, parent materials, and boundary and initial conditions considered. Further hindering the comparison ability was that the literature generally only focused on one or a select few topologies. With a particular focus on the crashworthiness of lattice topologies, this paper presents a comprehensive study of the impact performance of 24 topologies under dynamic impact loading. Using steel alloy parent material (manufactured using Selective Laser Melting), a numerical study of the impact performance was conducted with 16 different impact energy-speed pairs. It was possible to observe the overarching trends in crashworthiness parameters, including plateau stress, densification strain, impact efficiency, and absorbed energy for a wide range of 3D lattice topologies at three relative densities. While there was no observed distinct division between the results of bending and stretching topologies, the presence of struts aligned in the impact direction did have a significant effect on the energy absorption efficiency of the lattice; topologies with struts aligned in that direction had lower efficiencies as compared to topologies without.

Experimental and computational analysis of energy absorption characteristics of three biomimetic lattice structures under compression

The objective of this study is to evaluate the mechanical properties and energy absorption characteristics of the gyroid, dual-lattice and spinodoid structures, as biomimetic lattices, through finite element analysis and experimental characterisation. As part of the study, gyroid and dual-lattice structures at 10% volume fraction were 3D-printed using an elastic resin, and mechanically tested under uniaxial compression. Computational models were calibrated to the observed experimental data and the response of higher volume fraction structures were simulated in an explicit finite element solver. Stress-strain data of groups of lattices at different volume fractions were studied and energy absorption parameters including total energy absorbed per unit volume, energy absorption efficiency and onset of densification strain were calculated. Also, the structures were characterized into bending-dominant and stretch-dominant structures, according to their nodal connectivity and Gibson-and-Ashby's law. The results of the study showed that the dual-lattice is capable of absorbing more energy at each volume fraction cohort. However, gyroid structures showed higher energy absorption efficiency and the onset of densification at higher strains. The spinodoid structure was found to be the poorest structure in terms of energy absorption, specifically at low volume fractions. Also, the results showed that the dual-lattice was a stretch dominated structure, while the gyroid structure was a bending dominated structure, which may be a reason that it is a better candidate for energy absorption applications.

Decoupling particle-impact dissipation mechanisms in 3D architected materials

Ultralight architected materials enabled by advanced manufacturing processes have achieved density-normalized strength and stiffness properties that are inaccessible to bulk materials. However, the majority of this work has focused on static loading and elastic-wave propagation. Fundamental understanding of the mechanical behavior of architected materials under large-deformation dynamic conditions remains limited, due to the complexity of mechanical responses and shortcomings of characterization methods. Here, we present a microscale suspended-plate impact testing framework for three-dimensional micro-architected materials, where supersonic microparticles to velocities of up to 850 m/s are accelerated against a substrate-decoupled architected material to quantify its energy dissipation characteristics. Using ultra-high-speed imaging, we perform in situ quantification of the impact energetics on two types of architected materials as well as their constituent nonarchitected monolithic polymer, indicating a 47% or greater increase in mass-normalized energy dissipation under a given impact condition through use of architecture. Post-mortem characterization, supported by a series of quasi-static experiments and high-fidelity simulations, shed light on two coupled mechanisms of energy dissipation: material compaction and particle-induced fracture. Together, experiments and simulations indicate that architecture-specific resistance to compaction and fracture can explain a difference in dynamic impact response across architectures. We complement our experimental and numerical efforts with dimensional analysis which provides a predictive framework for kinetic-energy absorption as a function of material parameters and impact conditions. We envision that enhanced understanding of energy dissipation mechanisms in architected materials will serve to define design considerations toward the creation of lightweight impact-mitigating materials for protective applications.

Point-of-Care Orthopedic Oncology Device Development

BACKGROUND

The triad of 3D design, 3D printing, and xReality technologies is explored and exploited to collaboratively realize patient-specific products in a timely manner with an emphasis on designs with meta-(bio)materials.

METHODS

A case study on pelvic reconstruction after oncological resection (osteosarcoma) was selected and conducted to evaluate the applicability and performance of an inter-epistemic workflow and the feasibility and potential of 3D technologies for modeling, optimizing, and materializing individualized orthopedic devices at the point of care (PoC).

RESULTS

Image-based diagnosis and treatment at the PoC can be readily deployed to develop orthopedic devices for pre-operative planning, training, intra-operative navigation, and bone substitution.

CONCLUSIONS

Inter-epistemic symbiosis between orthopedic surgeons and (bio)mechanical engineers at the PoC, fostered by appropriate quality management systems and end-to-end workflows under suitable scientifically amalgamated synergies, could maximize the potential benefits. However, increased awareness is recommended to explore and exploit the full potential of 3D technologies at the PoC to deliver medical devices with greater customization, innovation in design, cost-effectiveness, and high quality.

Dynamic diagnosis of metamaterials through laser-induced vibrational signatures

Mechanical metamaterials at the microscale exhibit exotic static properties owing to their engineered building blocks1-4, but their dynamic properties have remained substantially less explored. Their design principles can target frequency-dependent properties5-7 and resilience under high-strain-rate deformation8,9, making them versatile materials for applications in lightweight impact resistance10-12, acoustic waveguiding7,13 or vibration damping14,15. However, accessing dynamic properties at small scales has remained a challenge owing to low-throughput and destructive characterization8,16,17 or lack of existing testing protocols. Here we demonstrate a high-throughput, non-contact framework that uses MHz-wave-propagation signatures within a metamaterial to non-destructively extract dynamic linear properties, omnidirectional elastic information, damping properties and defect quantification. Using rod-like tessellations of microscopic metamaterials, we report up to 94% direction-dependent and rate-dependent dynamic stiffening at strain rates approaching 102 s-1, as well as damping properties three times higher than their constituent materials. We also show that frequency shifts in the vibrational response allow for characterization of invisible defects within the metamaterials and that selective probing allows for the construction of experimental elastic surfaces, which were previously only possible computationally. Our work provides a route for accelerated data-driven discovery of materials and microdevices for dynamic applications such as protective structures, medical ultrasound or vibration isolation.

Spectral energy scattering and targeted energy transfer in phononic lattices with local vibroimpact nonlinearities

We propose a method for manipulating wave propagation in phononic lattices by employing local vibroimpact (VI) nonlinearities to scatter energy across the underlying linear band structure of the lattice, and transfer energy from lower to higher optical bands. First, a one-dimensional, two-band phononic lattice with embedded VI unit cells is computationally studied to demonstrate that energy is scattered in the wave number domain, and this nonlinear scattering mechanism depends on the energy of the propagating wave. Next, a four-band lattice is studied with a similar technique to demonstrate the concept of nonresonant interband targeted energy transfer (IBTET) and to establish analogous scaling relations with respect to energy. Both phononic lattices are shown to exhibit a maximum energy transfer at moderate input energies, followed by a power-law decay of relative energy transfer either to the wave number domain or between bands on input energy. Last, the nonlinear normal modes (NNMs) of a reduced order model (ROM) of a VI unit cell are computed with the method of numerical continuation to provide a physical interpretation of the IBTET scaling with respect to energy. We show that the slope of the ROM's frequency-energy evolution for 1:1 resonance matches well with IBTET scaling in the full lattice. Moreover, the phase-space trajectories of the NNM solutions elucidate how the power-law scaling is related to the nonlinear dynamics of the VI unit cell.

3D-Printed Micro/Nano-Scaled Mechanical Metamaterials: Fundamentals, Technologies, Progress, Applications, and Challenges

Micro/nano-scaled mechanical metamaterials have attracted extensive attention in various fields attributed to their superior properties benefiting from their rationally designed micro/nano-structures. As one of the most advanced technologies in the 21st century, additive manufacturing (3D printing) opens an easier and faster path for fabricating micro/nano-scaled mechanical metamaterials with complex structures. Here, the size effect of metamaterials at micro/nano scales is introduced first. Then, the additive manufacturing technologies to fabricate mechanical metamaterials at micro/nano scales are introduced. The latest research progress on micro/nano-scaled mechanical metamaterials is also reviewed according to the type of materials. In addition, the structural and functional applications of micro/nano-scaled mechanical metamaterials are further summarized. Finally, the challenges, including advanced 3D printing technologies, novel material development, and innovative structural design, for micro/nano-scaled mechanical metamaterials are discussed, and future perspectives are provided. The review aims to provide insight into the research and development of 3D-printed micro/nano-scaled mechanical metamaterials.

The Energy Absorption Behavior of 3D-Printed Polymeric Octet-Truss Lattice Structures of Varying Strut Length and Radius

We investigate the compressive energy absorption performance of polymeric octet-truss lattice structures that are 3D printed using high-resolution stereolithography. These structures are potential candidates for personal protective equipment, structural, and automotive applications. Two polymeric resins (high-strength/low-ductility and moderate-strength/high-ductility) were used in this work, and a comprehensive uniaxial tensile characterization was conducted to establish an optimal UV curing time. The external octet-truss structure geometry (3″ × 3″ × 3″) was maintained, and four different lattice cell densities (strut length, L) and three different strut radii (R) were printed, UV cured, and compression tested. The compressive stress-strain and energy absorption (EA) behavior were quantified, and the EA at 0.5 strain for the least dense and smallest R structure was 0.02 MJ/m³, while the highest density structure with the largest R was 1.80 MJ/m³ for Resin 2. The structural failure modes varied drastically based on resin type, and it was shown that EA and deformation behavior were related to L, R, and the structures' relative density (ρ¯). For the ductile resin, an empirical model was developed to predict the EA vs. compressive strain curves based on L and R. This model can be used to design an octet-truss lattice structure based on the EA requirements of an application.

Design and Fabrication Technology of Metal Mirrors Based on Additive Manufacturing: A Review

In recent years, much progress has been made on the development of metal mirrors based on additive manufacturing (AM). The sandwich mirror is well known for its excellent mechanical properties and challenging machining. Now, AM can be used to fabricate this complex structure and reduce the processing time and cost. In addition, with the aid of some new design methods for additive manufacturing, such as lattice, topology optimization (TO), and Voronoi, the freedom of mirror structure design is enormously improved. The common materials of mirrors include ceramics (SiC), glasses (glass ceramics, fused silica), and metals (aluminum, beryllium). Among them, the AM technology of metals is the most mature and widely used. Researchers have recently extensively developed the new-generation metal mirror to improve performance and lightweight rate. This review focuses on the following topics: (1) AM technologies and powder materials for metal mirrors, (2) recent advances in optomechanical design methods for AM metal mirrors, (3) challenges faced by AM metal mirrors in fabricating, and (4) future trends in AM metal mirrors.

Supersonic impact resilience of nanoarchitected carbon

Architected materials with nanoscale features have enabled extreme combinations of properties by exploiting the ultralightweight structural design space together with size-induced mechanical enhancement at small scales. Apart from linear waves in metamaterials, this principle has been restricted to quasi-static properties or to low-speed phenomena, leaving nanoarchitected materials under extreme dynamic conditions largely unexplored. Here, using supersonic microparticle impact experiments, we demonstrate extreme impact energy dissipation in three-dimensional nanoarchitected carbon materials that exhibit mass-normalized energy dissipation superior to that of traditional impact-resistant materials such as steel, aluminium, polymethyl methacrylate and Kevlar. In-situ ultrahigh-speed imaging and post-mortem confocal microscopy reveal consistent mechanisms such as compaction cratering and microparticle capture that enable this superior response. By analogy to planetary impact, we introduce predictive tools for crater formation in these materials using dimensional analysis. These results substantially uncover the dynamic regime over which nanoarchitecture enables the design of ultralightweight, impact-resistant materials that could open the way to design principles for lightweight armour, protective coatings and blast-resistant shields for sensitive electronics.

Programmed Plastic Deformation in Mathematically-Designed Architected Cellular Materials

The ability to control the exhibited plastic deformation behavior of cellular materials under certain loading conditions can be harnessed to design more reliable and structurally efficient damage-tolerant materials for crashworthiness and protective equipment applications. In this work, a mathematically-based design approach is proposed to program the deformation behavior of cellular materials with minimal surface-based topologies and ductile constituent material by employing the concept of functional grading to control the local relative density of unit cells. To demonstrate the applicability of this design tactic, two examples are presented. Rhombic, and double arrow deformation profiles were programmed as the desired deformation patterns. Grayscale images were used to map the relative density distribution of the cellular material. 316L stainless steel metallic samples were fabricated using the powder bed fusion additive manufacturing technique. Results of compressive tests showed that the designed materials followed the desired programmed deformation behavior. Results of mechanical testing also showed that samples with programmed deformation exhibited higher plateau stress and toughness values as compared to their uniform counterparts while no effect on Young’s modulus was observed. Plateau stress values increased by 8.6% and 13.4% and toughness values increased by 5.6% and 11.2% for the graded-rhombic and graded-arrow patterns, respectively. Results of numerical simulations predicted the exact deformation behavior that was programmed in the samples and that were obtained experimentally.

Effect of Fillets on Mechanical Properties of Lattice Structures Fabricated Using Multi-Jet Fusion Technology

Cellular structures with tailored topologies can be fabricated using additive manufacturing (AM) processes to obtain the desired global and local mechanical properties, such as stiffness and energy absorption. Lattice structures usually fail from the sharp edges owing to the high stress concentration and residual stress. Therefore, it is crucial to analyze the failure mechanism of lattice structures to improve the mechanical properties. In this study, several lattice topologies with fillets were designed, and the effects of the fillets on the stiffness, energy absorption, energy return, and energy loss of an open-cell lattice structure were investigated at a constant relative density. A recently developed high-speed AM multi-jet fusion technology was employed to fabricate lattice samples with two different unit cell sizes. Nonlinear simulations using ANSYS software were performed to investigate the mechanical properties of the samples. Experimental compression and loading–unloading tests were conducted to validate the simulation results. The results showed that the stiffness and energy absorption of the lattice structures can be improved significantly by the addition of fillets and/or vertical struts, which also influence other properties such as the failure mechanism and compliance. By adding the fillets, the failure location can be shifted from the sharp edges or joints to other regions of the lattice structure, as observed by comparing the failure mechanisms of type B and C structures with that of the type A structure (without fillets). The results of this study suggest that AM software designers should consider filleted corners when developing algorithms for generating various types of lattice structures automatically. Additionally, it was found that the accumulation of unsintered powder in the sharp corners of lattice geometries can also be minimized by the addition of fillets to convert the sharp corners to curved edges.

3D-printed cellular tips for tuning fork atomic force microscopy in shear mode

Conventional atomic force microscopy (AFM) tips have remained largely unchanged in nanomachining processes, constituent materials, and microstructural constructions for decades, which limits the measurement performance based on force-sensing feedbacks. In order to save the scanning images from distortions due to excessive mechanical interactions in the intermittent shear-mode contact between scanning tips and sample, we propose the application of controlled microstructural architectured material to construct AFM tips by exploiting material-related energy-absorbing behavior in response to the tip–sample impact, leading to visual promotions of imaging quality. Evidenced by numerical analysis of compressive responses and practical scanning tests on various samples, the essential scanning functionality and the unique contribution of the cellular buffer layer to imaging optimization are strongly proved. This approach opens new avenues towards the specific applications of cellular solids in the energy-absorption field and sheds light on novel AFM studies based on 3D-printed tips possessing exotic properties.

The authors investigate 3D-printed tips, based on controlled microstructural architectured materials, as probes for shear-mode atomic force microscopy. They demonstrate that the tailored stiffness and energy-absorbing behaviour of the material are beneficial for improving image quality.

Liquid-Crystal-Elastomer-Based Dissipative Structures by Digital Light Processing 3D Printing

Digital Light Processing (DLP) 3D printing enables the creation of hierarchical complex structures with specific micro- and macroscopic architectures that are impossible to achieve through traditional manufacturing methods. Here, this hierarchy is extended to the mesoscopic length scale for optimized devices that dissipate mechanical energy. A photocurable, thus DLP-printable main-chain liquid crystal elastomer (LCE) resin is reported and used to print a variety of complex, high-resolution energy-dissipative devices. Using compressive mechanical testing, the stress-strain responses of 3D-printed LCE lattice structures are shown to have 12 times greater rate-dependence and up to 27 times greater strain-energy dissipation compared to those printed from a commercially available photocurable elastomer resin. The reported behaviors of these structures provide further insight into the much-overlooked energy-dissipation properties of LCEs and can inspire the development of high-energy-absorbing device applications.