Synergy of Liquid-Crystalline Small-Molecule and Polymeric Donors Delivers Uncommon Morphology Evolution and 16.6% Efficiency Organic Photovoltaics

Dual Function of the Third Component in Ternary Organic Solar Cells: Broaden the Spectrum and Optimize the Morphology

Ternary organic solar cells (T-OSCs) have attracted significant attention as high-performance devices. In recent years, T-OSCs have achieved remarkable progress with power conversion efficiency (PCE) exceeding 19%. However, the introduction of the third component complicates the intermolecular interaction compared to the binary blend, resulting in poor controllability of active layer and limiting performance improvement. To address these issues, dual-functional third components have been developed that not only broaden the spectral range but also optimize morphology. In this review, the effect of the third component on expanding the absorption range of T-OSCs is first discussed. Second, the extra functions of the third component are introduced, including adjusting the crystallinity and molecular stack in active layer, regulating phase separation and purity, altering molecular orientation of the donor or acceptor. Finally, a summary of the current research progress is provided, followed by a discussion of future research directions.

What We have Learnt from PM6:Y6

Over the past three years, remarkable advancements in organic solar cells (OSCs) have emerged, propelled by the introduction of Y6-an innovative A-DA'D-A type small molecule non-fullerene acceptor (NFA). This review provides a critical discussion of the current knowledge about the structural and physical properties of the PM6:Y6 material combination in relation to its photovoltaic performance. The design principles of PM6 and Y6 are discussed, covering charge transfer, transport, and recombination mechanisms. Then, the authors delve into blend morphology and degradation mechanisms before considering commercialization. The current state of the art is presented, while also discussing unresolved contentious issues, such as the blend energetics, the pathways of free charge generation, and the role of triplet states in recombination. As such, this review aims to provide a comprehensive understanding of the PM6:Y6 material combination and its potential for further development in the field of organic solar cells. By addressing both the successes and challenges associated with this system, this review contributes to the ongoing research efforts toward achieving more efficient and stable organic solar cells.

Regulating Crystallinity Mismatch Between Donor and Acceptor to Improve Exciton/Charge Transport in Efficient Organic Solar Cells

Achieving a more balanced charge transport by morphological control is crucial in reducing bimolecular and trap-assisted recombination and enhancing the critical parameters for efficient organic solar cells (OSCs). Hence, a facile strategy is proposed to reduce the crystallinity difference between donor and acceptor by incorporating a novel multifunctional liquid crystal small molecule (LCSM) BDTPF4-C6 into the binary blend. BDTPF4-C6 is the first LCSM based on a tetrafluorobenzene unit and features a low liquid crystal phase transition temperature and strong self-assembly ability, conducive to regulating the active layer morphology. When BDTPF4-C6 is introduced as a guest molecule into the PM6 : Y6 binary, it exhibits better compatibility with the donor PM6 and primarily resides within the PM6 phase because of the similarity-intermiscibility principle. Moreover, systematic studies revealed that BDTPF4-C6 could be used as a seeding agent for PM6 to enhance its crystallinity, thereby forming a more balanced and favourable charge transport with suppressed charge recombination. Intriguingly, dual Förster resonance energy transfer was observed between the guest molecule and the host donor and acceptor, resulting in an improved current density. This study demonstrates a facile approach to balance the charge mobilities and offers new insights into boosting the efficiency of single-junction OSCs beyond 20 %.

Maximizing Performance and Stability of Organic Solar Cells at Low Driving Force for Charge Separation

Thanks to the development of novel electron acceptor materials, the power conversion efficiencies (PCE) of organic photovoltaic (OPV) devices are now approaching 20%. Further improvement of PCE is complicated by the need for a driving force to split strongly bound excitons into free charges, causing voltage losses. This review discusses recent approaches to finding efficient OPV systems with minimal driving force, combining near unity quantum efficiency (maximum short circuit currents) with optimal energy efficiency (maximum open circuit voltages). The authors discuss apparently contradicting results on the amount of exciton binding in recent literature, and approaches to harmonize the findings. A comprehensive view is then presented on motifs providing a driving force for charge separation, namely hybridization at the donor:acceptor interface and polarization effects in the bulk, of which quadrupole moments (electrostatics) play a leading role. Apart from controlling the energies of the involved states, these motifs also control the dynamics of recombination processes, which are essential to avoid voltage and fill factor losses. Importantly, all motifs are shown to depend on both molecular structure and process conditions. The resulting high dimensional search space advocates for high throughput (HT) workflows. The final part of the review presents recent HT studies finding consolidated structure-property relationships in OPV films and devices from various deposition methods, from research to industrial upscaling.

Melt blending crystallization regulating balanced nanodomains in efficient and scalable coating processed organic solar cells

The miscibility between active layer donors (D) and acceptors (A) is a key factor impeding the development of organic photovoltaics (OPVs) toward higher performance and large-area production. In this study, melt blending crystallization (MBC) was used to accomplish molecular-level blending and highly oriented crystallization in bulk heterojunction (BHJ) films realized by a scalable blade coating process, which increased the D/A contact area and provided sufficient exciton diffusion and dissociation. At the same time, the highly organized and balanced crystalline nanodomain structures permitted dissociated carriers to be efficiently transmitted and collected, resulting in significantly enhanced short-circuit current density, fill factor, and efficiency of the device by means of optimum melting temperature and quenching rates. The method can be simply incorporated into current efficient OPV material systems and achieve a device performance comparable to the best values. The blade-coating-processed PM6/IT-4F MBC devices achieved an efficiency of 13.86% in a small-area device and 11.48% in a large-area device. A power conversion efficiency (PCE) of 17.17% was obtained in PM6:BTP-BO-4F devices, and a PCE of 16.14% was acquired in PM6:Y6 devices.

Optimized Morphology Enables High-Efficiency Nonfullerene Ternary Organic Solar Cells

Tuning the three-dimensional morphology in the active layer is an effective method to improve the performance of bulk heterojunction organic solar cells (OSCs). In this work, an acceptor-donor-acceptor structured small molecule ST10-CN-1 was synthesized and employed as the guest donor to fabricate ternary OSCs based on a PBDB-T:IT-M host binary system. The incorporation of ST10-CN-1 could broaden the active layer's absorption range of solar light thereby leading to a promotional short-circuit current. Moreover, adding an appropriate amount of ST10-CN-1 could effectively regulate the morphology of the active layer in both the lateral direction and vertical stratification. All of these morphological alterations helped to speed up the exciton dissociation, charge transit, and charge collecting processes, which in turn increased the power conversion efficiency. As a result, an excellent PCE of 11.5% for the ternary device based on PBDB-T:IT-M:ST10-CN-1 was obtained. The enhanced PCE was also linked to the formation of an alloylike state between PBDB-T and ST10-CN-1, as evidenced by the fact that the open circuit voltage of ternary OSCs lay between those for PBDB-T:IT-M (0.925 V) and ST10-CN-1:IT-M (1.064 V). This work illustrates that refining the morphology of the active layer by incorporating an appropriate third component is an effective way to further enhance the device's performance.

Ternary Blend Organic Solar Cells: Understanding the Morphology from Recent Progress

Ternary blend organic solar cells (TB-OSCs) incorporating multiple donor and/or acceptor materials into the active layer have emerged as a promising strategy to simultaneously improve the overall device parameters for realizing higher performances than binary devices. Whereas introducing multiple materials also results in a more complicated morphology than their binary blend counterparts. Understanding the morphology is crucially important for further improving the device performance of TB-OSC. This review introduces the solubility and miscibility parameters that affect the morphology of ternary blends. Then, this review summarizes the recent processes of morphology study on ternary blends from the aspects of molecular crystallinity, molecular packing orientation, domain size and purity, directly observation of morphology, vertical phase separation as well as morphological stability. Finally, summary and prospects of TB-OSCs are concluded.

Computational Design of Crescent Shaped Promising Nonfullerene Acceptors with 1,4-Dihydro-2,3-quinoxalinedione Core and Different Electron-withdrawing Terminal Units for Photovoltaic Applications

This study aims to design a series of nonfullerene acceptors (NFAs) for photovoltaic applications having 1,4-dihydro-2,3-quinoxalinedione fused thiophene derivative as the core unit and 1,1-dicyanomethylene-3-indanone (IC) derivatives and different π-conjugated molecules other than IC as terminal acceptor units. All the investigated NFAs are found air-stable as the computed highest occupied molecular orbitals (HOMOs) are below the air oxidation threshold (ca. -5.27 eV vs saturated calomel electrode). The studied NFAs can act as potential nonfullerene acceptor candidates as they are found to have sufficient open-circuit voltage (V_oc) and fill factor (FF) ranging from 0.62 to 1.41 V and 83%-91%, respectively. From the anisotropic mobility analysis, it is noticed that the studied NFAs except dicyano-rhodanine terminal unit containing NFA, exhibit better electron mobility than the hole mobility, and therefore, they can be more promising electron transporting acceptor materials in the active layer of an organic photovoltaic cell. From the optical absorption analysis, it is noted that all the designed NFAs have the maximum absorption spectra ranging from 597 nm-730 nm, which lies in the visible region and near-infrared (IR) region of the solar spectrum. The computed light-harvesting efficiencies for the PM6 (thiophene derivative donor selected in our study):NFA blends are found to lie in the range of 0.96-0.99, which indicates efficient light-harvesting by the PM6:NFA blends during photovoltaic device operation.

Volatile Solid Additive-Assisted Sequential Deposition Enables 18.42% Efficiency in Organic Solar Cells

Morphology optimization of active layer plays a critical role in improving the performance of organic solar cells (OSCs). In this work, a volatile solid additive-assisted sequential deposition (SD) strategy is reported to regulate the molecular order and phase separation in solid state. The OSC adopts polymer donor D18-Cl and acceptor N3 as active layer, as well as 1,4-diiodobenzene (DIB) as volatile additive. Compared to the D18-Cl:N3 (one-time deposition of mixture) and D18-Cl/N3 (SD) platforms, the D18-Cl/N3(DIB) device based on DIB-assisted SD method exhibits a finer phase separation with greatly enhanced molecular crystallinity. The optimal morphology delivers superior charge transport and extraction, offering a champion power conversion efficiency of 18.42% with significantly enhanced short-circuit current density (Jsc ) of 27.18 mA cm-2 and fill factor of 78.8%. This is one of the best performances in binary SD OSCs to date. Angle-dependent grazing-incidence wide-angle X-ray scattering technique effectively reveals the vertical phase separation and molecular crystallinity of the active layer. This work demonstrates the combination of volatile solid additive and sequential deposition is an effective method to develop high-performance OSCs.

Hybrid Cathode Interlayer Enables 17.4% Efficiency Binary Organic Solar Cells

With the emergence of fused ring electron acceptors, the power conversion efficiency of organic solar cells reached 19%. In comparison with the electron donor and acceptor materials progress, the development of cathode interlayers lags. As a result, charge extraction barriers, interfacial trap states, and significant transport resistance may be induced due to the unfavorable cathode interlayer, limiting the device performances. Herein, a hybrid cathode interlayer composed of PNDIT-F3N and PDIN is adopted to investigate the interaction between the photoexcited acceptor and cathode interlayer. The state of art acceptor Y6 is chosen and blended with PM6 as the active layer. The device with hybrid interlayer, PNDIT-F3N:PDIN (0.6:0.4, in wt%), attains a power conversion efficiency of 17.4%, outperforming devices with other cathode interlayer such as NDI-M, PDINO, and Phen-DPO. It is resulted from enhanced exciton dissociation, reduced trap-assisted recombination, and smaller transfer resistance. Therefore, the hybrid interlayer strategy is demonstrated as an efficient approach to improve device performance, shedding light on the selection and engineering of cathode interlayers for pairing the increasing number of fused ring electron acceptors.

Theoretical Study of Non-Fullerene Acceptors Using End-Capped Groups with Different Electron-Withdrawing Abilities toward Efficient Organic Solar Cells

Acceptors in organic solar cells (OSCs) are of paramount importance. On the basis of the well-known non-fullerene acceptor Y6, six acceptors (Y6-COH, Y6-COOH, Y6-CN, Y6-SO₂H, Y6-CF₃, and Y6-NO₂) were designed by end-capped manipulation. The effects of end-capped engineering on electronic properties, optical properties, and interfacial charge-transfer states were systematically studied by density functional theory, time-dependent density functional theory, and molecular dynamics. The designed acceptors possess suitable energy levels and improved optical properties. More importantly, the electron mobility of the new acceptors was greatly enhanced, even more than 20 times that of the parent molecule. Among them, Y6-NO₂ with the lowest-lying frontier molecular orbitals and the largest red-shifted absorption was selected to construct interfaces with the donor PM6. PM6/Y6-NO₂ exhibits stronger interfacial interactions and enhanced charge-transfer characteristics compared with PM6/Y6. This work not only enhances the understanding of the structure-property relationship for acceptors but also offers a set of promising acceptors for high-performance OSCs.

A simple single-thiophene derivative assists efficient as-cast ternary organic solar cells through Förster resonance energy transfer

Blending the single-thiophene derivative TTZD contributes to improved photovoltaic performance through utilizing an efficient Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) process.

Over 17% Efficiency of Ternary Organic Photovoltaics Employing Two Acceptors with an Acceptor-Donor-Acceptor Configuration

Ternary organic photovoltaics (OPVs) were constructed with one wide-band-gap donor PM6 and two A-D-A-type acceptors (M-series M36 and MQ5) with similar chemical structures. Power conversion efficiency (PCE) of the optimal ternary OPVs reaches 17.24% with 20 wt % MQ5 content, arising from a simultaneously increased short circuit current density (J_SC) of 25.36 mA cm^-2 and a fill factor (FF) of 76.02% as compared to those of two binary OPVs. The photon harvesting of ternary active layers can be maximized by adjusting the MQ5 content by reason of the complementary absorption spectra of M36 and MQ5. The molecular arrangement of PM6 and M36 can be collectively optimized by introducing an appropriate amount of MQ5 as a morphology regulator for facilitating effective charge transportation in ternary active layers. The improved photon harvesting and charge transport in active layers should be two important factors responsible for J_SC and FF improvement of optimal ternary OPVs, respectively. More than an 8.8% improvement of PCE is achieved in ternary OPVs with an appropriate amount of MQ5 as the photon-harvesting enhancer and morphology regulator. The huge potential of A-D-A-type materials in constructing highly efficient OPVs can be further exploited based on a ternary strategy.

Recent Progress of Organic Photovoltaics with Efficiency over 17%

The power conversion efficiency (PCE) of organic photovoltaics (OPVs) has exceeded 18% with narrow bandgap, non-fullerene materials Y6 or its derivatives when used as an electron acceptor. The PCE improvement of OPVs is due to strong photon harvesting in near-infrared light range and low energy loss. Meanwhile, ternary strategy is commonly recognized as a convenient and efficient means to improve the PCE of OPVs. In this review article, typical donor and acceptor materials in prepared efficient OPVs are summarized. From the device engineering perspective, the typical research work on ternary strategy and tandem structure is introduced for understanding the device design and materials selection for preparing efficient OPVs.

Backbone Engineering with Asymmetric Core to Finely Tune Phase Separation for High-Performance All-Small-Molecule Organic Solar Cells

In order to obtain high-performance all-small-molecule organic solar cells (ASM-OSCs), it is crucial to exploit the available strategy for molecular design and to further understand key structure-property relationship that can rationally control the blend nanomorphology and influence the physical process. In this work, we design two small molecule donors FBD-S1 and TBD-S2 with identical electron-withdrawing units but various asymmetric central cores, which exhibit differing phase separation in Y6-based blend films. It is found that TBD-S2 with increased phase separation between donor and acceptor can lead to more favorable interpenetrating networks, effective exciton dissociation, and enhanced and more balanced charge transport. Importantly, a remarkable PCE of 13.1% is obtained for TBD-S2:Y6 based ASM-OSCs, which is an attractive photovoltaic performance for ASM-OSCs. This result demonstrates that the central core modification at the atomic level for small molecule donors can delicately control the phase separation and optimize photophysical processes, and refines device performance, which facilitate development in the ASM-OSC research field.

Optimized Active Layer Morphologies via Ternary Copolymerization of Polymer Donors for 17.6 % Efficiency Organic Solar Cells with Enhanced Fill Factor

Regulating molecular structure to optimize the active layer morphology is of considerable significance for improving the power conversion efficiencies (PCEs) in organic solar cells (OSCs). Herein, we demonstrated a simple ternary copolymerization approach to develop a terpolymer donor PM6-Tz20 by incorporating the 5,5'-dithienyl-2,2'-bithiazole (DTBTz, 20 mol%) unit into the backbone of PM6 (PM6-Tz00). This method can effectively tailor the molecular orientation and aggregation of the polymer, and then optimize the active layer morphology and the corresponding physical processes of devices, ultimately boosting FF and then PCE. Hence, the PM6-Tz20: Y6-based OSCs achieved a PCE of up to 17.1% with a significantly enhanced FF of 0.77. Using Ag (220 nm) instead of Al (100 nm) as cathode, the champion PCE was further improved to 17.6%. This work provides a simple and effective molecular design strategy to optimize the active layer morphology of OSCs for improving photovoltaic performance.

Enhancing Open-Circuit Voltage of High-Efficiency Nonfullerene Ternary Solar Cells with a Star-Shaped Acceptor

The ternary strategy has been widely used in high-efficiency organic solar cells (OSCs). Herein, we successfully incorporated a mid-band-gap star-shaped acceptor, FBTIC, as the third component into the PM6/Y6 binary blend film, which not only achieved a panchromatic absorption but also significantly improved the open-circuit voltage (V_OC) of the devices due to the high-lying lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) of the FBTIC. Morphology characterizations show that star-shaped FBTIC molecules are amorphously distributed in the ternary system, and the finely tuned ternary film morphology facilitates the exciton dissociation and charge collection in ternary devices. As a result, the best PM6/Y6/FBTIC-based ternary OSCs achieved a power conversion efficiency (PCE) of 16.7% at a weight ratio of 1.0:1.0:0.2.