Coexpression of p165 myeloid surface antigen and terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase: a comparison of acute myeloid leukaemia and normal bone marrow cells

Evolution of Hemostasis Testing: A Personal Reflection Covering over 40 Years of History

There is no certainty in change, other than change is certain. As Seminars in Thrombosis and Hemostasis celebrates 50 years of publication, I felt it appropriate to reflect on my own 40-year plus scientific career. My career in the thrombosis and hemostasis field did not start until 1987, but the subsequent 35 years reflected a period of significant change in associated disease diagnostics. I started in the Westmead Hospital "coagulation laboratory" when staff were still performing manual clotting tests, using stopwatches, pipettes, test tubes, and a water bath, which we transported to the hospital outpatient department to run our weekly warfarin clinic. Several hemostasis instruments have come and gone, including the Coag-A-Mate X2, the ACL-300R, the MDA-180, the BCS XP, and several StaR Evolution analyzers. Some instruments remain, including the PFA-100, PFA-200, the AggRAM, the CS-5100, an AcuStar, a Hydrasys gel system, and two ACL-TOP 750s. We still have a water bath, but this is primarily used to defrost frozen samples, and manual clotting tests are only used to teach visiting medical students. We have migrated across several methodologies in the 45-year history of the local laboratory. Laurel gel rockets, used for several assays in the 1980s, were replaced with enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay assays and most assays were eventually placed on automated instruments. Radio-isotopic assays, used in the 1980s, were replaced by an alternate safer method or else abandoned. Test numbers have increased markedly over time. The approximately 31,000 hemostasis assays performed at the Westmead-based laboratory in 1983 had become approximately 200,000 in 2022, a sixfold increase. Some 90,000 prothrombin times and activated partial thromboplastic times are now performed at this laboratory per year. Thrombophilia assays were added to the test repertoires over time, as were the tests to measure several anticoagulant drugs, most recently the direct oral anticoagulants. I hope my personal history, reflecting on the changes in hemostasis testing over my career to date in the field, is found to be of interest to the readership, and I hope they forgive any inaccuracies I have introduced in this reflection of the past.

Flow cytometric detection of minimal residual disease in acute lymphoblastic leukemia

Assessment of minimal residual disease (MRD) during the first months of therapy gives information on the timely response to treatment, and proves to be a powerful and independent indicator of treatment outcome in patients with acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL). Immunological evaluation by flow cytometry (FCM) is one of the most attractive approaches to this. The present review summarizes the historical development of this approach over the last 20 years, and shows that current methodology is based on the existence of leukemia-associated patterns of derangement in antigen expression with respect to normal differentiation or location of occurrence. Recent clinical studies are summarized which proved that FCM is applicable to more than 90% of patients with ALL and gives prognostic information comparable to polymerase chain-reaction (PCR)-based technology. Ongoing efforts based on parallel application of both technologies are explained which are designed to clarify which approach bears the best cost-relevance ratio in order to be broadly used in the future for risk assessment and tailoring of treatment modalities. Concluding perspectives relate to further technical developments like usage of peripheral blood (PB) instead of bone marrow (BM), absolute quantification, or strategic placement of investigative time-points, which may allow to simplify the MRD approach and thus augment it's economic efficiency.

Detection of residual disease in pediatric B-cell precursor acute lymphoblastic leukemia by comparative phenotype mapping: method and significance

The present review summarizes our efforts in developing a novel immunologic approach ("Comparative Phenotype Mapping") targeted at assessing minimal residual disease (MRD) in B-cell precursor (BCP) acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) patients. The method relies on quantitatively aberrant, leukemia-associated antigen expression patterns which allow to discriminate leukemic from normal BCP using a limited panel of antibody combinations and multidimensional flow cytometry. In an analysis of 63 follow up bone marrow samples of patients with BCP-ALL we show that this approach enables to efficiently detect MRD. Further clinical observation revealed that the patients which were MRD-positive by flow cytometry (although in morphological remission) had a very high probability of early disease recurrence compared to the good chances of a relapse-free survival (RFS) in the MRD-negative cohort (RFS 0.0 vs. 0.76 at 3 years). Comparative Phenotype Mapping thus proves to be a reliable method for MRD detection in BCP-ALL. Concluding remarks relate to the optional applications of the method as well as to future perspectives. An ongoing large prospective study which we are now conducting on the basis of Comparative Phenotype Mapping will clarify the clinical significance of MRD detection in ALL patients by this method, and will determine its value compared to related as well as molecular-genetic techniques.

Detection of residual disease in pediatric B-cell precursor acute lymphoblastic leukemia by comparative phenotype mapping: a study of five cases controlled by genetic methods

We recently investigated samples of pediatric B-cell precursor acute lymphoblastic leukemia (BCP-ALL) and normal bone marrow (BM). We found that leukemic blasts, compared to their physiologic counterpart cells, frequently display aberrant phenotypes with respect to levels of expression of certain antigens. Using multiparameter flow cytometry, these differences enabled us to trace leukemic cells admixed to normal BM, which suggested that this approach might be a useful strategy for minimal residual disease detection. In the present study, we used the same multiparameter approach ("comparative phenotype mapping") to prove that such quantitative phenotypic differences really exist between malignant and normal BCP when simultaneously present in the BM. We demonstrate this by five exemplary follow-up BM samples from patients with BCP-ALL, all of which showed phenotypically aberrant cells according to levels of expression of CD10, CD11a, CD19, CD34, CD44, or CD45RA, as well as according to altered orthogonal light scattering properties. We confirmed the leukemic nature of these cells by polymerase chain reaction-based detection of bcr1/abl transcripts, and of leukemia clone-specific immunoglobulin heavy chain rearrangements in only the suspicious cells when sorted by flow cytometry, but not in normal BCP or non-B cells. Comparative phenotype mapping thus allows one to distinguish between normal and leukemic cells, and we show that it may enable rapid, specific, and quantitative detection of residual/resurgent leukemia in BCP-ALL.

Four-Color Flow Cytometric Investigation of Terminal Deoxynucleotidyl Transferase–Positive Lymphoid Precursors in Pediatric Bone Marrow: CD79a Expression Precedes CD19 in Early B-Cell Ontogeny

Terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase (TdT)-positive cells in human bone marrow (BM) are a phenotypically inhomogeneous population of precursor cells. In their majority, these TdT+ cells are unambiguously committed to the B lineage, as evidenced by CD19 expression. However, TdT+ precursors that lack CD19 also exist and these may encompass a differentiation potential for the B as well as for other lineages. Because recent data suggested that CD19 expression is not the earliest differentiation event in B-cell ontogeny, we sought to reevaluate TdT+ lymphoid precursors in pediatric BM to define the phenotypic denominator of B-lineage affiliation upstream of CD19. Using four-color flow cytometry, we focused on the assessment of the CD79a antigen, which is highly B-cell specific and which may also be expressed very early in B-cell ontogeny. We found that a majority of TdT+ cells coexpressed CD19 and CD79a in addition to CD10 and CD34, whereas, in all investigated samples, some TdT+ precursors lacked CD19 but expressed CD79a, which suggestively indicates also their B-lineage affiliation. In contrast to the CD19+precursors, which were usually CD10hi and CD79b+, these CD19−CD79a+putative B-cell precursors preferentially expressed CD10 at low levels and were CD79b+ in only 41%. About 17% of these TdT+CD19−CD79a+ precursors also coexpressed CD33 and CD7, but not myeloperoxidase, CD14, or cytoplasmic CD3, which is discussed in the light of cellular activation rather than lineage promiscuity. Our data confirm that the earliest differentiation stages of B cells can be dissected upon expression of the lineage antigens CD79a and CD19 and imply that CD79a is earlier expressed than CD19. This raises the chance to follow the sequential events heralding B-cell commitment in the most immature precursors by correlating phenotypic and genetic differentiation markers.

© 1998 by The American Society of Hematology.

Four-Color Flow Cytometric Investigation of Terminal Deoxynucleotidyl Transferase–Positive Lymphoid Precursors in Pediatric Bone Marrow: CD79a Expression Precedes CD19 in Early B-Cell Ontogeny

Terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase (TdT)-positive cells in human bone marrow (BM) are a phenotypically inhomogeneous population of precursor cells. In their majority, these TdT+ cells are unambiguously committed to the B lineage, as evidenced by CD19 expression. However, TdT+ precursors that lack CD19 also exist and these may encompass a differentiation potential for the B as well as for other lineages. Because recent data suggested that CD19 expression is not the earliest differentiation event in B-cell ontogeny, we sought to reevaluate TdT+ lymphoid precursors in pediatric BM to define the phenotypic denominator of B-lineage affiliation upstream of CD19. Using four-color flow cytometry, we focused on the assessment of the CD79a antigen, which is highly B-cell specific and which may also be expressed very early in B-cell ontogeny. We found that a majority of TdT+ cells coexpressed CD19 and CD79a in addition to CD10 and CD34, whereas, in all investigated samples, some TdT+ precursors lacked CD19 but expressed CD79a, which suggestively indicates also their B-lineage affiliation. In contrast to the CD19+precursors, which were usually CD10hi and CD79b+, these CD19−CD79a+putative B-cell precursors preferentially expressed CD10 at low levels and were CD79b+ in only 41%. About 17% of these TdT+CD19−CD79a+ precursors also coexpressed CD33 and CD7, but not myeloperoxidase, CD14, or cytoplasmic CD3, which is discussed in the light of cellular activation rather than lineage promiscuity. Our data confirm that the earliest differentiation stages of B cells can be dissected upon expression of the lineage antigens CD79a and CD19 and imply that CD79a is earlier expressed than CD19. This raises the chance to follow the sequential events heralding B-cell commitment in the most immature precursors by correlating phenotypic and genetic differentiation markers.

© 1998 by The American Society of Hematology.

Monoclonal antibodies in the management of acute leukemia

This report reviews the diagnostic significance of immune markers, their relationship to patient outcome, and the therapeutic uses of monoclonal antibodies (MoAbs) in acute leukemia. Immunophenotyping allows for rapid and reproducible diagnosis in the majority of cases of acute leukemia. It is of particular importance in recognizing the major immunologic subclasses of acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL), and in identifying subtypes of acute myeloblastic leukemia (AML) which cannot be differentiated by morphology and cytochemistry alone, such as FAB M0 or M7. Immune marker analysis has been used to detect minimal residual disease in patients' bone marrow and CSF after treatment. However, the presence of leukemia-associated phenotypes on small numbers of normal cells may reduce the sensitivity of detection in some cases. The prognostic value of immune markers in AML is limited. In ALL, the prognostic significance of the different immunophenotypic subtypes has been lessened by modern treatment protocols. The relationship of mixed-lineage or biphenotypic antigen expression to patient outcome in both AML and ALL is unclear. Therapeutic applications of MoAbs in acute leukemia include immunologic techniques for purging malignant cells from autografts prior to transplantation, T-lymphocyte depletion from allografts as a strategy to reduce graft-versus-host disease, and the use of flow cytometry to monitor the timing and extent of leukapheresis in peripheral stem cell transplantation. MoAbs have also enabled the recent development of transplantation protocols using positively-selected CD34+ stem cells.

The role of immunophenotype in acute lymphoblastic leukemia of infant age

The prognosis of acute lymphoblastic leukemia in infants is still significantly worse than that of older children. This is thought to be due to both clinical and biological factors, such as high white blood cell (WBC) counts at diagnosis, irregular or immature phenotypes, and molecular and cytogenetical abnormalities. In order to focus the significance of immunophenotypic analysis, we have reviewed the immunophenotypic studies of 145 infants under 18 months of age treated at the AIEOP centers from 1984 to 1992. Children have been divided in three age groups of six months each; WBC count at diagnosis has been evaluated both as mean values and within different categories (< 10.10(9)/L, > 100.10(9)/L). These have been studied in correlation with immunophenotype and with the expression of single, specific markers. A significant correlation has been found between young age, high WBC count and immature phenotypes. Common ALL was more frequent in older children and showed lower WBC counts. Moreover, event-free survival was significantly better in older children with WBC count < 100.00/mm3, with CD10+, MyAg- ALL. Therefore, we suggest that immunophenotypic analysis is still an important prognostic factor and can be usefully used, together with simple clinical data, to plan therapy for ALL in infants.

Lymphoid lineage-associated features in acute myeloid leukaemia: phenotypic and genotypic correlations

This study is intended to establish biological correlation between the expression of lymphoid associated features in acute myeloid leukaemia (AML). In 62 AML patients, predominantly enrolled on Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group (ECOG) treatment protocols, in whom immunoglobulin (Ig) as well as T-cell receptor beta chain (TCR-beta) gene rearrangement analyses had been performed, morphology, cytochemistry, antigen profile and karyotype were reviewed retrospectively. Nuclear reactivity with anti-TdT antibody was demonstrated in 34 patients (55%) and confirmed by ribonuclease protection assay in all patients tested. Five TdT-protein negative patients were TdT-transcript positive. Lymphoid antigens (lyA) were detected in 24 of 51 cases tested (47%) with B-cell antigens (CD19, CD10) being restricted to TdT+ AML (P = 0.03). Only two patients had Ig heavy, none had Ig light chain or TCR-beta gene rearrangements. Although both patients with rearranged Ig loci were TdT+, either by protein or RNA analysis, the low incidence of such rearrangement within the TdT+ AML group (6%) argues against a significant association between the presence of TdT and crosslineage Ig gene rearrangements in AML. While FAB-diagnoses did not differ between TdT+ and TdT- or lyA+ and lyA- AML, particular immunophenotypic features correlated with TdT positively, e.g. the presence of early antigens, CD34 and HLA-DR, and the absence of the more mature myelo-monocytic antigens, CDw65 and CD14. Certain cytogenetic abnormalities were associated with TdT+ AML such as inv(16) (p13q22) or t(16;16) (p12;q22) (five patients; P = 0.03) and t(8;21) (q22;q22) (three patients). A greater number of TdT- than TdT+ AML patients had only normal karyotypes (P = 0.06). Neither immunophenotypic nor karyotypic correlations could be established for lyA+ AML.

The immunophenotype in infant acute lymphoblastic leukaemia: correlation with clinical outcome. An Italian multicentre study (AIEOP)

A detailed analysis of immunophenotype of 112 infants aged less than 18 months with acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (ALL) was performed. Patients were divided into three groups on the basis of age at presentation (under 6 months: group 1: 6-12 months: group 2; 13-18 months: group 3). There were three cases of T-ALL (2.6%). The proportion of other subtypes was: common ALL in 59 patients (52.68%), pre-B ALL in 15 patients (13.3%), pre-pre-B ALL in 27 (24.1%) and acute undifferentiated leukaemia (AUL) in eight patients (7.14%). In non-T ALL, positivity to CD10 (corresponding to C-ALL and pre-B ALL) was distributed in the three age groups as follows: 38.88% (group I) 65.38% (group II) and 86.36% (group III). Conversely, immature phenotypes (pre-pre-B and AUL) were found more often in the younger patients of groups I and II, as well as anomalous phenotypes, such as the presence of myeloid antigens (MyAg) and of CD7. Prognostic significance was evaluated as event-free survival (EFS) by statistical analysis. A better outcome in CD10-positive ALL than in CD10-negative ones (48% v. 25% of long-term survivors) was demonstrated in all infants. Similarly, EFS was significantly better in MyAg-negative than in MyAg-positive cases. These results were confirmed also when adjusting for white blood cell count. This allowed the identification of CD10-negative, MyAg-positive ALL, which were relatively more frequent in infants and had a poorer clinical outcome with the current therapies. This study stresses the prognostic relevance of the immunological study in infant leukaemias and its utility in choosing different therapeutic modalities for poor risk phenotypes.

Immune markers in hematologic malignancies

The precise delineation of biologic traits that distinguish normal hematopoietic cells from their malignant counterparts is of fundamental importance in understanding all aspects of hematologic malignancies. An increasingly sophisticated technologic battery has been utilized to dissect out these differences--primarily utilization of monoclonal antibodies, by immunoperoxidase, immunoalkaline phosphatase and flow cytometric techniques. An even more basic understanding of normal and malignant hematopoietic cells has begun to evolve as molecular biology begins to unravel gene misprogramming by Southern and Northern blot analysis and the polymerase chain reaction. These techniques not only help distinguish a normal cell from a malignant one, but characterize the malignant clone as B-lymphoid, T-lymphoid or myeloid and allow further subcategorization within these broad lineages. These distinctions are vital to the entire spectrum of basic and clinical research involving hematologic malignancies and are assuming an increasingly important role in their diagnosis, prognosis and treatment.

Mixed acute leukaemias

In recent years immunophenotyping and analysis of clonal rearrangement of immunoglobulin and T-cell antigen receptor genes have proved valuable for the diagnosis and classification of leukaemia. These techniques aid in the assignment of cell lineage in cases of acute leukaemia in which the standard FAB criteria of morphology and cytochemistry do not reveal clear lymphoid or myeloid phenotype. These new techniques have also revealed that the leukaemic blasts in a sizable minority of otherwise typical cases of acute leukaemia express 'inappropriate' lineage-associated markers and have been termed mixed acute leukaemias. The spectrum of characteristics encompassed by mixed acute leukaemias ranges from fairly common cases expressing one or two inappropriate markers to the more extreme, rare cases of acute leukaemia termed 'hybrid' in which a truly scrambled picture is seen. A subgroup of these mixed cases have two distinct populations of blasts, e.g. one lymphoid and the other myeloid. These observations raise a number of issues about the cell of origin of these leukaemias and about the mechanisms controlling the developmental regulation of expression of different lineage-associated markers. In addition, accumulating evidence suggests that inappropriate expression of markers may identify sub-groups of both acute myeloid and lymphoblastic leukaemia with an inferior prognosis.