Sialic acid storage disease of the Salla phenotype in American monozygous twin female sibs

Free sialic acid storage disorder: Progress and promise

Lysosomal free sialic acid storage disorder (FSASD) is an extremely rare, autosomal recessive, neurodegenerative, multisystemic disorder caused by defects in the lysosomal sialic acid membrane exporter SLC17A5 (sialin). SLC17A5 defects cause free sialic acid and some other acidic hexoses to accumulate in lysosomes, resulting in enlarged lysosomes in some cell types and 10-100-fold increased urinary excretion of free sialic acid. Clinical features of FSASD include coarse facial features, organomegaly, and progressive neurodegenerative symptoms with cognitive impairment, cerebellar ataxia and muscular hypotonia. Central hypomyelination with cerebellar atrophy and thinning of the corpus callosum are also prominent disease features. Around 200 FSASD cases are reported worldwide, with the clinical spectrum ranging from a severe infantile onset form, often lethal in early childhood, to a mild, less severe form with subjects living into adulthood, also called Salla disease. The pathobiology of FSASD remains poorly understood and FSASD is likely underdiagnosed. Known patients have experienced a diagnostic delay due to the rarity of the disorder, absence of routine urine sialic acid testing, and non-specific clinical symptoms, including developmental delay, ataxia and infantile hypomyelination. There is no approved therapy for FSASD. We initiated a multidisciplinary collaborative effort involving worldwide academic clinical and scientific FSASD experts, the National Institutes of Health (USA), and the FSASD patient advocacy group (Salla Treatment and Research [S.T.A.R.] Foundation) to overcome the scientific, clinical and financial challenges facing the development of new treatments for FSASD. We aim to collect data that incentivize industry to further develop, obtain approval for, and commercialize FSASD treatments. This review summarizes current aspects of FSASD diagnosis, prevalence, etiology, and disease models, as well as challenges on the path to therapeutic approaches for FSASD.

Neuroimaging Findings in Lysosomal Disorders: 2018 Update

Lysosomal storage disorders are a heterogeneous group of genetic diseases characterized by defective function in one of the lysosomal enzymes. In this review paper, we describe neuroradiological findings and clinical characteristics of neuronopathic lysosomal disorders with a focus on differential diagnosis. New insights regarding pathogenesis and therapeutic perspectives are also briefly discussed.

A New Patient With Intermediate Severe Salla Disease With Hypomyelination: A Literature Review for Salla Disease

BACKGROUND

Likely pathogenic variants in SLC17A5 results in allelic disorders of free sialic acid metabolism including (1) infantile free sialic acid storage disease with severe global developmental delay, coarse facial features, hepatosplenomegaly, and cardiomegaly; (2) intermediate severe Salla disease with moderate to severe global developmental delay, hypotonia, and hypomyelination with or without coarse facial features, and (3) Salla disease with normal appearance, mild cognitive dysfunction, and spasticity.

PATIENT DESCRIPTION

This five-year-old girl presented with infantile-onset severe global developmental delay, truncal hypotonia, and generalized dystonia following normal development during her first six months of life. Brain magnetic resonance imaging showed marked hypomyelination and a thin corpus callosum at age 19 months, both unchanged on follow-up at age 28 months. Urine free sialic acid was moderately elevated. Cerebrospinal fluid free sialic acid was marginally elevated. Sequencing of SLC17A5 revealed compound heterozygous likely pathogenic variants, namely, a known missense (c.291G>A) variant and a novel truncating (c.819+1G>A) variant, confirming the diagnosis of Salla disease at age 3.5 years.

CONCLUSION

We report a new patient with intermediate severe Salla disease. Normal or marginally elevated urine or cerebrospinal fluid free sialic acid levels cannot exclude Salla disease. In patients with progressive global developmental delay and hypomyelination on brain magnetic resonance imaging, Salla disease should be included into the differential diagnosis.

The early detection of Salla disease through second-tier tests in newborn screening: how to face incidental findings

We describe here a 34 months child, practically asymptomatic which presented with high levels of free sialic acid in urine by biochemical detection in second-tier tests newborn screening and with two disease causing mutations in SLC17A5 gene. SLC17A5 mutation analysis showed p.Tyr306* previously described and the novel mutation p.Leu167Pro. This early onset diagnosis allowed us to perform a fast and accurate genetic counseling to the family, helped to better understanding the natural history of this rare disease and probably it could promote cost reduction in future diagnostic tests in the hypothetic case of starting symptoms without diagnosis established. Moreover, an early diagnosis could save family from a long period of time until achieving a definitive diagnostic and to develop an early symptomatic and supportive management of patient to attenuate, as much as possible, disease complications. But, above all, this case illustrates the huge ethical dilemma which arises from any secondary finding (second tier) in newborn screening.

Fumarase deficiency in dichorionic diamniotic twins

Fumarase deficiency is a rare autosomal recessive inborn error of metabolism of the Krebs Tricarboxylic Acid cycle. A heavy neurological disease burden is imparted by fumarase deficiency, commonly manifesting as microcephaly, dystonia, global developmental delay, seizures, and lethality in the infantile period. Heterozygous carriers also carry an increased risk of developing hereditary leiomyomatosis and renal cell carcinoma. We describe a non-consanguineous family in whom a dichorionic diamniotic twin pregnancy resulted in twin boys with fumarase deficiency proven at the biochemical, enzymatic, and molecular levels. Their clinical phenotype included hepatic involvement. A novel mutation in the fumarate hydratase gene was identified in this family.

Large-scale molecular analysis of a 34 Mb interval on chromosome 6q: major refinement of the RP25 interval

A large scale bioinformatics and molecular analysis of a 34 Mb interval on chromosome 6q12 was undertaken as part of our ongoing study to identify the gene responsible for an autosomal recessive retinitis pigmentosa (arRP) locus, RP25. Extensive bioinformatics analysis indicated in excess of 110 genes within the region and we also noted unfinished sequence on chromosome 6q in the Human Genome Database, between 58 and 61.2 Mb. Forty three genes within the RP25 interval were considered as good candidates for mutation screening. Direct sequence analysis of the selected genes in 7 Spanish families with arRP revealed a total of 244 sequence variants, of which 67 were novel but none were pathogenic. This, together with previous reports, excludes 60 genes within the interval ( approximately 55%) as disease causing for RP. To investigate if copy number variation (CNV) exists within RP25, a comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) analysis was performed on a consanguineous family. A clone from the tiling path array, chr6tp-19C7, spanning approximately 100-Kb was found to be deleted in all affected members of the family, leading to a major refinement of the interval. This will eventually have a significant impact on cloning of the RP25 gene.

Prenatal diagnosis of free sialic acid storage disorders (SASD)

Free sialic acid storage disorders, Salla disease (SD) and Infantile sialic acid storage disease (ISSD), are lysosomal storage diseases due to impaired function of a sialic acid transporter, sialin, at the lysosomal membrane. Several mutations of the sialin gene, SLC17A5, are known, leading either to the severe neonatal/infantile disease or to the milder, adult-type developmental disorder, Salla disease. Free sialic acid accumulation in lysosomes causes increased tissue concentration and consequently elevated urinary excretion. Prenatal diagnosis of SASD is possible either by determination of free sialic acid concentration or by mutation analysis of the SLC17A5 gene in fetal specimen, in chorionic villus biopsy particularly. Both techniques have been successfully applied in several cases, sialic acid assay more often in ISSD cases but mutation analysis preferentially in SD. Sialic acid assay of amniotic fluid supernatant or cultured amniotic fluid cells may give erroneous results and should not be used for prenatal diagnosis of these disorders. The present comments are mainly based on our experience of prenatal diagnosis of SD in Finnish families. A founder mutation in SLC17A5 gene, 115C-> T, represents 95% of the disease alleles in the Finnish SD patients, which provides a unique possibility to apply mutation analysis. Therefore, molecular studies have successfully been used in 17 families since the identification of the gene and the characterization of the SD mutations. Earlier, eight prenatal studies were performed by measuring the free sialic acid concentration in chorionic villus samples.

Genome-wide SNP arrays as a diagnostic tool: Clinical description, genetic mapping, and molecular characterization of Salla disease in an Old Order Mennonite population

An Old Order Mennonite child was evaluated for gross motor delay, truncal ataxia, and slow linear growth. The diagnostic evaluation, which included sub-specialty consultations, neuroimaging, and metabolic testing, was long, costly, and did not yield a diagnosis. Recognition of a similarly affected second cousin prompted a genome-wide homozygosity mapping study using high-density single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) arrays. SNP genotypes from two affected individuals and their parents were used to localize the disease locus to a 14.9 Mb region on chromosome 6. This region contained 55 genes, including SLC17A5, the gene encoding the lysosomal N-acetylneuraminic acid transport protein. Direct sequencing of SLC17A5 in the proband revealed homozygosity for the 115C --> T (R39C) sequence variant, the common cause of Salla disease in Finland. Three additional affected Mennonite individuals, ages 8 months to 50 years, were subsequently identified by directed molecular genetic testing. This small-scale mapping study was rapid, inexpensive, and analytically simple. In families with shared genetic heritage, genome-wide SNP arrays with relatively high marker density allow disease gene mapping studies to be incorporated into routine diagnostic evaluations.

Clinical, biochemical, and molecular diagnosis of a free sialic acid storage disease patient of moderate severity

The allelic autosomal recessive lysosomal storage disorders Salla disease and infantile free sialic acid storage disease (ISSD) result from mutations in SLC17A5. This gene codes for sialin, a lysosomal membrane protein that transports the charged sugar, N-acetylneuraminic acid (sialic acid), out of lysosomes. ISSD has a severe phenotype with infantile onset, while the Finnish variant, Salla disease, has a milder phenotype with later onset. Both disorders cause developmental delay, and ISSD is generally fatal in early childhood. We describe a 30-month old non-Finnish, Caucasian child with global developmental delay of postnatal onset, language, and motor skills stagnant at a 3-4 month level, hypotonia, and mild but progressive coarsening of facial features. Urinary excretion of free sialic acid was elevated 4.5 times above control. EM of a skin biopsy revealed enlarged secondary lysosomes consistent with oligosaccharide storage. Free sialic acid in fibroblasts was 3.8+/-0.9 nmol/mg protein (concurrent normal controls, 0.5+/-0.1); differential centrifugation indicated a lysosomal location. Genomic analysis revealed compound heterozygosity for two new SLC17A5 mutations. This child's clinical manifestations of a lysosomal free sialic acid storage disease are consistent with her sialin mutations and biochemical findings. The differential diagnosis of postnatal developmental delay should include free sialic acid storage disorders such as ISSD and Salla disease.

A novel mutation in the SLC17A5 gene causing both severe and mild phenotypes of free sialic acid storage disease in one inbred Bedouin kindred

Four members of an extended consanguineous Bedouin family presented with different phenotypic variants of an autosomal recessive lysosomal free sialic acid storage disease. One affected individual had congenital ascites followed by rapid clinical deterioration and death, a presentation concordant with the clinical course of infantile free sialic acid storage disorder. His three first cousins had a more slowly progressive neurodegenerative disease, in line with the clinical phenotype of the milder form (Salla type) of this lysosomal disorder. Diagnosis of free sialic acid storage disease was based on clinical findings, histology, and biochemical assays of sialic acid. Molecular studies showed that all four affected individuals were homozygous for the same novel 983G > A mutation in exon 8 of the SLC17A5 gene, replacing glycine with glutamic acid at position 328 of the sialin protein. This family demonstrates the significant phenotypic variability of the disease in affected members of a single inbred kindred with precisely the same mutation, suggesting a role for modifier genes or environmental factors. It also highlights the need to consider this rare disorder in the differential diagnosis of congenital ascites and of unexplained psychomotor retardation, ataxia, and hypomyelination in infancy.

Quantification of Free Sialic Acid in Urine by HPLC–Electrospray Tandem Mass Spectrometry: A Tool for the Diagnosis of Sialic Acid Storage Disease

Background: Sialic acid storage diseases (SSDs) are severe autosomal recessive neurodegenerative disorders caused by a transport defect across the lysosomal membrane, which leads to accumulation of sialic acid in tissues, fibroblasts, and urine. Defective free sialic acid transport can be established by quantification of free sialic acid in urine.

Methods: Urine sample size was adjusted to the equivalent of 100 nmol of creatinine. After addition of 2-keto-3-deoxy-d-glycero-d-galactonononic acid as internal standard, samples were diluted with water to an end volume of 250 μL. We used 10 μL for HPLC–tandem mass spectrometric analysis in the negative electrospray ionization mode, monitoring transitions m/z 308.3→m/z 86.9 (sialic acid) and m/z 267.2→m/z 86.9 (internal standard). The overall method was validated and studied for ion suppression, interfering compounds, and pH effects. Samples from controls (n = 72) and SSD patients (n = 3) were analyzed.

Results: The limit of detection was 3 μmol/L. Intraassay imprecision (CV; n = 10) was 6%, 3%, and 2% at 30, 130, and 1000 mmol/mol creatinine, respectively; corresponding interassay CV (n = 10) were 5%, 5%, and 2%. Recovery was 109% (100–1000 mmol/mol creatinine). The mean (SD) [range] excretion rates (mmol/mol creatinine) were 31.3 (16.6) [0.7–56.9] at 0–1 year (n = 20), 21.2 (9.8) [6.3–38.3] at 1–3 years (n = 15), 14.4 (8.2) [1.7–32.9] at 3–10 years (n = 25), and 4.6 (2.6) [0–9.8] above age 10 years (n = 12). SSD patients 1.2, 3.9, and 12 years of age had concentrations of 111.5, 54.2, and 36.1 mmol/mol creatinine, respectively.

Conclusions: The HPLC-tandem MS method for free sialic acid in urine is more rapid, accurate, sensitive, selective, and robust than earlier methods and may serve as a candidate reference method for free sialic acid in diagnosis of SSD.