De novo PHF5A variants are associated with craniofacial abnormalities, developmental delay, and hypospadias

PURPOSE

The SF3B splicing complex is composed of SF3B1-6 and PHF5A. We report a developmental disorder caused by de novo variants in PHF5A.

METHODS

Clinical, genomic, and functional studies using subject-derived fibroblasts and a heterologous cellular system were performed.

RESULTS

We studied 9 subjects with congenital malformations, including preauricular tags and hypospadias, growth abnormalities, and developmental delay who had de novo heterozygous PHF5A variants, including 4 loss-of-function (LOF), 3 missense, 1 splice, and 1 start-loss variant. In subject-derived fibroblasts with PHF5A LOF variants, wild-type and variant PHF5A mRNAs had a 1:1 ratio, and PHF5A mRNA levels were normal. Transcriptome sequencing revealed alternative promoter use and downregulated genes involved in cell-cycle regulation. Subject and control fibroblasts had similar amounts of PHF5A with the predicted wild-type molecular weight and of SF3B1-3 and SF3B6. SF3B complex formation was unaffected in 2 subject cell lines.

CONCLUSION

Our data suggest the existence of feedback mechanisms in fibroblasts with PHF5A LOF variants to maintain normal levels of SF3B components. These compensatory mechanisms in subject fibroblasts with PHF5A or SF3B4 LOF variants suggest disturbed autoregulation of mutated splicing factor genes in specific cell types, that is, neural crest cells, during embryonic development rather than haploinsufficiency as pathomechanism.

Sf3b4 regulates chromatin remodeler splicing and Hox expression

SF3B proteins form a heptameric complex in the U2 small nuclear ribonucleoprotein, essential for pre-mRNA splicing. Heterozygous pathogenic variants in human SF3B4 are associated with head, face, limb, and vertebrae defects. Using the CRISPR/Cas9 system, we generated mice with constitutive heterozygous deletion of Sf3b4 and showed that mutant embryos have abnormal vertebral development. Vertebrae abnormalities were accompanied by changes in levels and expression pattern of Hox genes in the somites. RNA sequencing analysis of whole embryos and somites of Sf3b4 mutant and control litter mates revealed increased expression of other Sf3b4 genes. However, the mutants exhibited few differentially expressed genes and a large number of transcripts with differential splicing events (DSE), predominantly increased exon skipping and intron retention. Transcripts with increased DSE included several genes involved in chromatin remodeling that are known to regulate Hox expression. Our study confirms that Sf3b4 is required for normal vertebrae development and shows, for the first time, that like Sf3b1, Sf3b4 also regulates Hox expression. We propose that abnormal splicing of chromatin remodelers is primarily responsible for vertebral defects found in Sf3b4 heterozygous mutant embryos.

The emerging significance of splicing in vertebrate development

Splicing is a crucial regulatory node of gene expression that has been leveraged to expand the proteome from a limited number of genes. Indeed, the vast increase in intron number that accompanied vertebrate emergence might have aided the evolution of developmental and organismal complexity. Here, we review how animal models for core spliceosome components have provided insights into the role of splicing in vertebrate development, with a specific focus on neuronal, neural crest and skeletal development. To this end, we also discuss relevant spliceosomopathies, which are developmental disorders linked to mutations in spliceosome subunits. Finally, we discuss potential mechanisms that could underlie the tissue-specific phenotypes often observed upon spliceosome inhibition and identify gaps in our knowledge that, we hope, will inspire further research.

SF3B4 Frameshift Variants Represented a More Severe Clinical Manifestation in Nager Syndrome

Nager syndrome (NS) is a rare disease marked with craniofacial and preaxial limb anomalies. In this report, we summarized the current evidence to determine a possible genotype-phenotype association among NS individuals. Twenty-four articles comprising of 84 NS (including 9 patients with a severe form of NS [Rodriguez syndrome]) patients were examined, of which 76% were caused by variants in SF3B4 (OMIM *605593, Splicing Factor 3B, Subunit 4). Within the SF3B4 gene, variants located in exon 3 commonly occurred (20%) from a total identified variant, while hotspot location was identified in exon 1 (12%), and primarily occurred as frameshift variants (64%). Thirty-five distinct pathogenic variants within SF3B4 gene were identified with two common sites, c.1A > G and c.1060dupC in exons 1 and 5, respectively. Although no significant genotype-phenotype association was found, it is notable that patients with frameshift SF3B4 variants and predicted to lead to nonsense-mediated RNA decay (NMD) of the transcripts tended to have a more severe clinical manifestation. Additionally, patients harboring variants in exons 2 and 3 displayed a higher proportion of cardiac malformations. Taken together, this article summarizes the pathogenic variants observed in SF3B4 and provides a possible genotype-phenotype relationship in this disease.

Molecular mechanisms of hearing loss in Nager syndrome

Nager syndrome is a rare human developmental disorder characterized by hypoplastic neural crest-derived craniofacial bones and limb defects. Mutations in SF3B4 gene, which encodes a component of the spliceosome, are a major cause for Nager. A review of the literature indicates that 45% of confirmed cases are also affected by conductive, sensorineural or mixed hearing loss. Conductive hearing loss is due to defective middle ear ossicles, which are neural crest derived, while sensorineural hearing loss typically results from defective inner ear or vestibulocochlear nerve, which are both derived from the otic placode. Animal model of Nager syndrome indicates that upon Sf3b4 knockdown cranial neural crest progenitors are depleted, which may account for the conductive hearing loss in these patients. To determine whether Sf3b4 plays a role in otic placode formation we analyzed the impact of Sf3b4 knockdown on otic development. Sf3b4-depleted Xenopus embryos exhibited reduced expression of several pan-placodal genes six1, dmrta1 and foxi4.1. We confirmed the dependence of placode genes expression on Sf3b4 function in animal cap explants expressing noggin, a BMP antagonist critical to induce placode fate in the ectoderm. Later in development, Sf3b4 morphant embryos had reduced expression of pax8, tbx2, otx2, bmp4 and wnt3a at the otic vesicle stage, and altered otic vesicle development. We propose that in addition to the neural crest, Sf3b4 is required for otic development, which may account for sensorineural hearing loss in Nager syndrome.

Spliceosomopathies and neurocristopathies: Two sides of the same coin?

Mutations in core components of the spliceosome are responsible for a group of syndromes collectively known as spliceosomopathies. Patients exhibit microcephaly, micrognathia, malar hypoplasia, external ear anomalies, eye anomalies, psychomotor delay, intellectual disability, limb, and heart defects. Craniofacial malformations in these patients are predominantly found in neural crest cells-derived structures of the face and head. Mutations in eight genes SNRPB, RNU4ATAC, SF3B4, PUF60, EFTUD2, TXNL4, EIF4A3, and CWC27 are associated with craniofacial spliceosomopathies. In this review, we provide a brief description of the normal development of the head and the face and an overview of mutations identified in genes associated with craniofacial spliceosomopathies. We also describe a model to explain how and when these mutations are most likely to impact neural crest cells. We speculate that mutations in a subset of core splicing factors lead to disrupted splicing in neural crest cells because these cells have increased sensitivity to inefficient splicing. Hence, disruption in splicing likely activates a cellular stress response that includes increased skipping of regulatory exons in genes such as MDM2 and MDM4, key regulators of P53. This would result in P53-associated death of neural crest cells and consequently craniofacial malformations associated with spliceosomopathies.

Heterozygous mutation of the splicing factor Sf3b4 affects development of the axial skeleton and forebrain in mouse

BACKGROUND

Splicing factor 3B subunit 4 (SF3B4) is a causative gene of an acrofacial dysostosis, Nager syndrome. Although in vitro analyses of SF3B4 have proposed multiple noncanonical functions unrelated to splicing, less information is available based on in vivo studies using model animals.

RESULTS

We performed expression and functional analyses of Sf3b4 in mice. The mouse Sf3b4 transcripts were found from two-cell stage, and were ubiquitously present during embryogenesis with high expression levels in several tissues such as forming craniofacial bones and brain. In contrast, expression of a pseudogene-like sequence of mouse Sf3b4 (Sf3b4_ps) found by in silico survey was not detected up to embryonic day 10. We generated a Sf3b4 knockout mouse using CRISPR-Cas9 system. The homozygous mutant mouse of Sf3b4 was embryonic lethal. The heterozygous mutant of Sf3b4 mouse (Sf3b4^+/- ) exhibited smaller body size compared to the wild-type from postnatal to adult period, as well as homeotic posteriorization of the vertebral morphology and flattened calvaria. The flattened calvaria appears to be attributable to mild microcephaly due to a lower cell proliferation rate in the forebrain.

CONCLUSIONS

Our study suggests that Sf3b4 controls anterior-posterior patterning of the axial skeleton and guarantees cell proliferation for forebrain development in mice.