Newborn screening: A disease-changing intervention for glutaric aciduria type 1

Diagnosis of glutaric aciduria type I based on neuroradiological findings: when neonatal screening fails

BACKGROUND

Glutaric aciduria type I (GA-I) is an autosomal recessive disorder affecting the metabolism of lysine, hydroxylysine, and tryptophan. Patients present in the first age of life with an irreversible motor disorder, and neuroradiological imaging can suggest the presence of the condition. Biochemically, the disorder is characterized by elevated levels of glutaric and 3-hydroxy glutaric acid in the urine and glutarylcarnitine in the blood. This latter metabolite can be detected in dried blood spots, and the condition can therefore be included in some newborn screening programs.

CASE PRESENTATION

We present the case of a patient affected by GA-I that was undetected by newborn screening in whom the diagnosis was clinically oriented at the age of nine months by acute neurological symptoms, represented by persistent tonic seizures, and by neuroimaging showing bilateral signal alterations in the basal ganglia. Biochemical data, including glutarylcarnitine in dried blood spots and urinary excretion of glutaric acid, were normal in the acute phase and during follow-up. Molecular analysis confirmed a diagnosis of GA-I, showing a homozygous M405V variant of the GCDH gene, which is common in African populations and associated with a low-excretor phenotype characteristic of the disorder.

CONCLUSIONS

In conclusion, although GA-I is included in neonatal screening programs, the biochemical markers in dried blood spots can be absent. Therefore, in patients of African origin, clinicians should maintain a high degree of vigilance in the presence of suggestive clinical and neuroradiological findings, even if biochemical parameters are normal.

Long-Term Outcomes of Adolescents and Young Adults Identified by Metabolic Newborn Screening

OBJECTIVE

Although newborn screening (NBS) programs were expanded with the implementation of tandem mass spectrometry in the late 1990s, the impact on long-term clinical and cognitive outcomes of adolescents and young adults with inherited metabolic diseases (IMDs) has remained fairly unknown for most IMDs.

METHODS

A prospective, multicenter, observational study is performed in Southwest Germany (NGS2025, DRKS-ID: DRKS00013329). For systematic follow-up from preschool up to adulthood, individuals with IMDs identified by NBS between 1999 and 2014 were included.

RESULTS

In total, 257 (124 boys, 133 girls) screened individuals with at least 1 study visit in adolescence were followed until median age of 13.7 years. During the observation period, most did not develop permanent disease-specific signs (70.1%) or metabolic decompensations (55.2% of those at risk), had normal cognitive outcome (81.4%; IQ mean [SD], 98 [15]), and attended regular primary (91.2%) and secondary schools (90.8%). Nonetheless, NBS and early start of treatment did not prevent metabolic decompensations in 69 (44.8%) individuals at risk, and in 33 of them, metabolic decompensation occurred already before the NBS result was available. Permanent disease-specific symptoms were more frequently observed in patients experiencing metabolic decompensations compared with those without decompensations (75% vs 12.8%). Reliable therapy adherence was associated with better long-term outcome.

CONCLUSION

NBS for IMDs is a highly successful program of secondary prevention for most early-diagnosed and early-treated individuals with an IMD, allowing the start in an independent life; however, therapeutic effectiveness and quality remain a relevant limitation in some diseases.

Outcomes of deep brain stimulation surgery in the management of dystonia in glutaric aciduria type 1

OBJECTIVES

Glutaric aciduria type 1 (GA1) is a rare autosomal recessive organic acidaemia caused by deficiency of the glutaryl-CoA dehydrogenase enzyme. We describe the outcomes following deep brain stimulation (DBS) for the management of dystonia of children and adults with glutaric aciduria type 1 (GA1).

METHODS

Cases with GA1 were identified from the institutional databases of two tertiary movement disorder services. Data were extracted from clinical records using a standardised proforma, including baseline clinical characteristics, imaging and neurophysiological findings, complications post-surgery, and outcomes as measured by the Burke-Fahn-Marsden Dystonia Rating Scale (BMFDRS) motor scores and the Canadian Occupation Performance Measure (COPM).

RESULTS

A total of 15 children were identified aged 3-17.5 with a median age of 11.5 years at neurosurgery, and one adult undergoing DBS aged 31 years. Baseline BMFDRS motor score ranged from 58.5-114, median 105. GMFCS-equivalence level was 5 (i.e. non-ambulant) for 10/16 cases. Surgery was tolerated in all cases without evidence of metabolic decompensation. BFMDRS motor score 1-year post-surgery ranged from 57.5-108.5 (median 97.25) and at last follow-up 57.5-112 (median 104) (no statistically significant change compared to baseline at either time point, P > 0.05). COPM data were available for 11/13 children and young people (CAYP). Clinically significant improvement was reported in 7/11 at 1 year and 8/11 at last follow-up. Four CAYP transitioned to adult services. Death occurred in three cases during follow-up, in no case related to DBS.

CONCLUSION

DBS may be considered as a management option for children with GA1 who have appropriately selected goals for intervention.

Odd-chain dicarboxylic acid feeding recapitulates the biochemical phenotype of glutaric aciduria type 1 in mice

Glutaric aciduria type-1 (GA1) is an inherited mitochondrial neurometabolic disorder with a poorly understood pathogenesis and unmet medical needs. GA1 can be diagnosed via its hallmark biochemical signature consisting of glutaric aciduria, 3-hydroxyglutaric aciduria, and increased plasma glutarylcarnitine. These glutaryl-CoA-derived metabolites are thought to originate solely in the mitochondria. Here, we demonstrate that wild-type mice fed an 11-carbon odd-chain dicarboxylic acid (undecanedioic acid, DC 11 ) recreates the biochemical phenotype of GA1. Odd-chain dicarboxylic acids like DC 11 are not present in food but can arise from several endogenous processes, such as lipid peroxidation and fatty acid ω-oxidation. DC 11 is chain-shortened in peroxisomes to glutaryl (DC 5 )-CoA, which then gives rise to the GA1-like pattern of DC 5 metabolites in urine, tissues, and blood. Glutaric acid released from peroxisomes during DC 11 chain-shortening can enter mitochondria, be activated to CoA by the enzyme succinyl-CoA:glutarate-CoA transferase (SUGCT), and become substrate for glutaryl-CoA dehydrogenase (GCDH), the enzyme that is mutated in GA1. Our data provide proof-of-concept that the generation of dicarboxylic acids by ω-oxidation, which is stimulated during the same catabolic states known to trigger acute encephalopathy in GA1, may exacerbate disease by increasing the glutaryl-CoA substrate load in mitochondria.

Parental and child's psychosocial and financial burden living with an inherited metabolic disease identified by newborn screening

Newborn screening (NBS) is one of the most effective measures of secondary prevention. While the benefit of NBS on the clinical long-term outcomes of children with inherited metabolic diseases (IMD) has been demonstrated, the potential burden of families living with an early diagnosed and treated child with an IMD has not been thoroughly investigated. The aim of this longitudinal questionnaire-based study on 369 families living with a child with an IMD was to investigate the psychosocial and financial burden following a true-positive NBS. The reported psychosocial burden differed between children and their parents, and was associated with the child's age, diagnosis, and treatment. At younger ages, parent-reported burden was higher for the parents than for the individual child, while it increased for children and decreased for parents as the child grew older. Furthermore, psychosocial burden increased if the child required a strict dietary treatment and was at risk of metabolic decompensation. Regardless of diagnosis and treatment, the developmental delay of their child independently increased the parental psychosocial burden. Financial burden was reported by 24% of all families, and was higher in low-income families and in families whose children required dietary treatment. In conclusion, a substantial psychosocial and financial burden was revealed for children and their families after true-positive NBS. Since this burden is likely to have a negative impact on the long-term individual health benefits of NBS, this study underlines the importance of regularly assessing the psychosocial and financial needs of these families.

Digital-Tier Strategy Improves Newborn Screening for Glutaric Aciduria Type 1

Glutaric aciduria type 1 (GA1) is a rare inherited metabolic disease increasingly included in newborn screening (NBS) programs worldwide. Because of the broad biochemical spectrum of individuals with GA1 and the lack of reliable second-tier strategies, NBS for GA1 is still confronted with a high rate of false positives. In this study, we aim to increase the specificity of NBS for GA1 and, hence, to reduce the rate of false positives through machine learning methods. Therefore, we studied NBS profiles from 1,025,953 newborns screened between 2014 and 2023 at the Heidelberg NBS Laboratory, Germany. We identified a significant sex difference, resulting in twice as many false-positives male than female newborns. Moreover, the proposed digital-tier strategy based on logistic regression analysis, ridge regression, and support vector machine reduced the false-positive rate by over 90% compared to regular NBS while identifying all confirmed individuals with GA1 correctly. An in-depth analysis of the profiles revealed that in particular false-positive results with high associated follow-up costs could be reduced significantly. In conclusion, understanding the origin of false-positive NBS and implementing a digital-tier strategy to enhance the specificity of GA1 testing may significantly reduce the burden on newborns and their families from false-positive NBS results.

Glutaric aciduria type 1: Insights into diagnosis and neurogenetic outcomes

Glutaric aciduria type 1 (GA1) is a rare metabolic disorder characterized by a deficiency in the enzyme glutaryl-CoA dehydrogenase. This study aims to present the clinical, biochemical, genetic, and neuroimaging findings of GA1 patients, emphasizing the importance of early detection and the potential benefits of incorporating GA1 into NBS programs. The demographic, clinical, and laboratory findings of GA1 patients were reviewed retrospectively. This study presents the clinical, biochemical, genetic, and neuroimaging findings of 15 patients (six males, nine females) from 13 families diagnosed with GA1. The median age at diagnosis was 20 months, and the median follow-up period was 72 months. Developmental delay was observed in 66.7% of patients, with 46.7% experiencing seizures and 33.3% suffering from encephalopathic crises. Biochemical analyses showed elevated levels of glutaric acid and 3-hydroxyglutaric acid in 93.3% and 80% of patients, respectively. Genetic testing identified the p.Arg402Trp variant in 53.3% of patients. Neurological evaluations revealed delays in motor and speech development, with 66.7% of patients never achieving the ability to walk. Cranial MRI indicated white matter changes in all patients and basal ganglia involvement in 93.3%. Despite significant biochemical improvements with treatment in glutaric acid levels and head circumference over time, neurological deficits remain unchanged. Growth parameters such as body weight showed significant decreases due to poor neurological outcomes.

CONCLUSION

The study underscores the importance of early diagnosis and intervention to mitigate severe neurological outcomes. Our findings highlight the need for incorporating GA1 into newborn screening programs to ensure timely diagnosis and treatment.

WHAT IS KNOWN

• Glutaric aciduria type 1 (GA1) is a rare metabolic disorder caused by a deficiency of glutaryl-CoA dehydrogenase. If untreated, it often leads to severe neurological complications. Early diagnosis and treatment are crucial for improving clinical outcomes in GA1 patients.

WHAT IS NEW

• This study presents comprehensive data from a cohort of 15 Glutaric aciduria type 1 (GA1) patients, detailing their biochemical, genetic, clinical, and neuroimaging findings. Drawing attention to the severe neurological findings in late-diagnosed patients underscores the critical importance of including GA1 in newborn screening programs to enhance early diagnosis and prevent severe outcomes.

Wilson and Jungner Revisited: Are Screening Criteria Fit for the 21st Century?

Driven by technological innovations, newborn screening (NBS) panels have been expanded and the development of genomic NBS pilot programs is rapidly progressing. Decisions on disease selection for NBS are still based on the Wilson and Jungner (WJ) criteria published in 1968. Despite this uniform reference, interpretation of the WJ criteria and actual disease selection for NBS programs are highly variable. A systematic literature search [PubMED search "Wilson" AND "Jungner"; last search 16.07.22] was performed to evaluate the applicability of the WJ criteria for current and future NBS programs and the need for adaptation. By at least two reviewers, 105 publications (systematic literature search, N = 77; manual search, N = 28) were screened for relevant content and, finally, 38 publications were evaluated. Limited by the study design of qualitative text analysis, no statistical evaluation was performed, but a structured collection of reported aspects of criticism and proposed improvements was instead collated. This revealed a set of general limitations of the WJ criteria, such as imprecise terminology, lack of measurability and objectivity, missing pediatric focus, and absent guidance on program management. Furthermore, it unraveled specific aspects of criticism on clinical, diagnostic, therapeutic, and economical aspects. A major obstacle was found to be the incompletely understood natural history and phenotypic diversity of rare diseases prior to NBS implementation, resulting in uncertainty about case definition, risk stratification, and indications for treatment. This gap could be closed through the systematic collection and evaluation of real-world evidence on the quality, safety, and (cost-)effectiveness of NBS, as well as the long-term benefits experienced by screened individuals. An integrated NBS public health program that is designed to continuously learn would fulfil these requirements, and a multi-dimensional framework for future NBS programs integrating medical, ethical, legal, and societal perspectives is overdue.

Comparative analysis of gene and disease selection in genomic newborn screening studies

Genomic newborn screening (gNBS) is on the horizon given the decreasing costs of sequencing and the advanced understanding of the impact of genetic variants on health and diseases. Key to ongoing gNBS pilot studies is the selection of target diseases and associated genes to be included. In this study, we present a comprehensive analysis of seven published gene-disease lists from gNBS studies, evaluating gene-disease count, composition, group proportions, and ClinGen curations of individual disorders. Despite shared selection criteria, we observe substantial variation in total gene count (median 480, range 237-889) and disease group composition. An intersection was identified for 53 genes, primarily inherited metabolic diseases (83%, 44/53). Each study investigated a subset of exclusive gene-disease pairs, and the total number of exclusive gene-disease pairs was positively correlated with the total number of genes included per study. While most pairs receive "Definitive" or "Strong" ClinGen classifications, some are labeled as "Refuted" (n = 5) or "Disputed" (n = 28), particularly in genetic cardiac diseases. Importantly, 17%-48% of genes lack ClinGen curation. This study underscores the current absence of consensus recommendations for selection criteria for target diseases for gNBS resulting in diversity in proposed gene-disease pairs, their coupling with gene variations and the use of ClinGen curation. Our findings provide crucial insights into the selection of target diseases and accompanying gene variations for future gNBS program, emphasizing the necessity for ongoing collaboration and discussion about criteria harmonization for panel selection to ensure the screening's objectivity, integrity, and broad acceptance.

Disorders of organic acid metabolism and epilepsy

Epilepsy can be caused by a variety of causes, such as inborn errors of metabolism, organic acid disorders are the most significant type of metabolic disorders that cause seizures. The clinical manifestations of these diseases are generally nonspecific, and the types of seizures are different. Screening for multisystem clinical symptoms and identifying the underlying etiology are crucial for early treatment of epileptic seizures. This article provides a comprehensive summary of the pathogenesis, clinical features, diagnosis and treatment of epilepsy associated with organic acid metabolism disorders. Furthermore, relevant literature has also been reviewed to assist clinicians in the diagnosis of cases characterized by the coexistence of multisystemic symptoms and epileptic manifestations.

Characterization, Structure, and Inhibition of the Human Succinyl-CoA:glutarate-CoA Transferase, a Putative Genetic Modifier of Glutaric Aciduria Type 1

Glutaric Aciduria Type 1 (GA1) is a serious inborn error of metabolism with no pharmacological treatments. A novel strategy to treat this disease is to divert the toxic biochemical intermediates to less toxic or nontoxic metabolites. Here, we report a putative novel target, succinyl-CoA:glutarate-CoA transferase (SUGCT), which we hypothesize suppresses the GA1 metabolic phenotype through decreasing glutaryl-CoA and the derived 3-hydroxyglutaric acid. SUGCT is a type III CoA transferase that uses succinyl-CoA and glutaric acid as substrates. We report the structure of SUGCT, develop enzyme- and cell-based assays, and identify valsartan and losartan carboxylic acid as inhibitors of the enzyme in a high-throughput screen of FDA-approved compounds. The cocrystal structure of SUGCT with losartan carboxylic acid revealed a novel pocket in the active site and further validated the high-throughput screening approach. These results may form the basis for the future development of new pharmacological intervention to treat GA1.

Cerebral White Matter Alterations Associated With Oligodendrocyte Vulnerability in Organic Acidurias: Insights in Glutaric Aciduria Type I

The white matter is an important constituent of the central nervous system, containing axons, oligodendrocytes, and its progenitor cells, astrocytes, and microglial cells. Oligodendrocytes are central for myelin synthesis, the insulating envelope that protects axons and allows normal neural conduction. Both, oligodendrocytes and myelin, are highly vulnerable to toxic factors in many neurodevelopmental and neurodegenerative disorders associated with disturbances of myelination. Here we review the main alterations in oligodendrocytes and myelin observed in some organic acidurias/acidemias, which correspond to inherited neurometabolic disorders biochemically characterized by accumulation of potentially neurotoxic organic acids and their derivatives. The yet incompletely understood mechanisms underlying the high vulnerability of OLs and/or myelin in glutaric acidemia type I, the most prototypical cerebral organic aciduria, are particularly discussed.

Prenatal Ultrasound and Magnetic Resonance Findings of Glutaric Acidemia Type 1 and Its Challenges in Prenatal Diagnosis

Glutaric acidemia type 1 (GA1) presents unique challenges in prenatal diagnosis, especially in cases with no family history. This review article aims to review and present the prenatal ultrasound and magnetic resonance findings of GA1 and consolidate key insights into the difficulties associated with GA1 prenatal diagnosis and the neuroimaging features that require careful differentiation during the diagnostic process.

Characterization, structure and inhibition of the human succinyl-CoA:glutarate-CoA transferase, a genetic modifier of glutaric aciduria type 1

Glutaric Aciduria Type 1 (GA1) is a serious inborn error of metabolism with no pharmacological treatments. A novel strategy to treat this disease is to divert the toxic biochemical intermediates to less toxic or non-toxic metabolites. Here, we report a novel target, SUGCT, which we hypothesize suppresses the GA1 metabolic phenotype through decreasing glutaryl-CoA. We report the structure of SUGCT, the first eukaryotic structure of a type III CoA transferase, develop a high-throughput enzyme assay and a cell-based assay, and identify valsartan and losartan carboxylic acid as inhibitors of the enzyme validating the screening approach. These results may form the basis for future development of new pharmacological intervention to treat GA1.

Compilation of Genotype and Phenotype Data in GCDH-LOVD for Variant Classification and Further Application

Glutaric aciduria type 1 (GA-1) is a rare but treatable autosomal-recessive neurometabolic disorder of lysin metabolism caused by biallelic pathogenic variants in glutaryl-CoA dehydrogenase gene (GCDH) that lead to deficiency of GCDH protein. Without treatment, this enzyme defect causes a neurological phenotype characterized by movement disorder and cognitive impairment. Based on a comprehensive literature search, we established a large dataset of GCDH variants using the Leiden Open Variation Database (LOVD) to summarize the known genotypes and the clinical and biochemical phenotypes associated with GA-1. With these data, we developed a GCDH-specific variation classification framework based on American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics and the Association for Molecular Pathology guidelines. We used this framework to reclassify published variants and to describe their geographic distribution, both of which have practical implications for the molecular genetic diagnosis of GA-1. The freely available GCDH-specific LOVD dataset provides a basis for diagnostic laboratories and researchers to further optimize their knowledge and molecular diagnosis of this rare disease.

[Evaluation and optimization of newborn screening by structured long-term follow-up-using the example of inherited metabolic diseases]

Newborn screening (NBS) is a highly successful secondary prevention program with the goal of preventing severe sequelae of congenital, mostly genetic, diseases by identifying them as early as possible, ideally in the pre-symptomatic period. Studies to date have shown the important achievements of NBS programs but also reveal a number of relevant weaknesses. These include the often incompletely understood natural history and phenotypic diversity of rare diseases as well as the inadequate ability to accurately predict individual disease severity at an early stage and thus the uncertainties in case definition, risk stratification, and treatment indication.In light of the rapid developments in high-throughput genetic technologies and the associated opportunities for substantial future expansion of NBS programs, it seems overdue to make structured long-term follow-up and the subsequent evaluation of the long-term health benefits mandatory for individuals with rare diseases identified through NBS. This article explains the importance of long-term follow-up for the evaluation and continuous optimization of the screening. Long-term clinical outcomes of people with inherited metabolic diseases identified by NBS are presented as examples.

[Genomic newborn screening-research approaches, challenges, and opportunities]

The application of high-throughput sequencing methods for population-based genomic newborn screening offers numerous opportunities for improving population health. The use of genome-based sequencing technology holds potential to enable the diagnosis of virtually any genetic disorder at an early stage and offers great flexibility when it comes to selection and expansion of target diseases. National and international efforts are therefore being made to investigate the ethical, legal, social, psychological, and technical aspects of genomic newborn screening. In addition to the many opportunities, there are numerous challenges and questions that remain to be answered: When and how should legal guardians be informed about such screening? Which diseases should be screened for? How should incidental findings or identification of a genetic predisposition be dealt with? Should data be stored long term and if so, how can this be done securely? Provided there is an appropriate regulatory framework and a transparent consent process, genomic newborn screening has the potential to fundamentally change the way in which we screen for congenital diseases. However, there is still much to be done. To achieve understanding and acceptance of genomic newborn screening amongst all stakeholders and thus to maximize its benefits for the population, a public discourse on the possibilities and limitations of genomic newborn screening is of critical importance. This article aims to provide an overview of the innovative technical developments in the field of human genetics, describe national and international approaches, and discuss challenges and opportunities of genomic newborn screening development.

Glutaric aciduria and L-2-hydroxyglutaric aciduria: Clinical and molecular findings of 35 patients from Turkey

Background

Cerebral organic acid disorders are progressive neurometabolic diseases characterized by neurologic dysfunction. Glutaric aciduria type I (GA-I) and L-2-hydroxyglutaric aciduria (L2HGA) are the main cerebral organic acid disorders. They are both classified as, and it is suggested that these two disorders may share a common metabolic pathway. Current treatment strategies are based on levocarnitine, vitamin B2, and diet. Recent guidelines recommend a lysine-restricted diet up to six years of age, but there is no consensus for patients over the age of six. Vitamin B2 is exists in the blood as riboflavin and its cofactors, flavin mononucleotide and flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD). FAD, the cofactor of L2HGD, accelerates the conversion of L-2-hydoxy glutarate to alpha-ketoglutarate. Levocarnitine stimulates the formation and excretion of derivatives of glutaric acid. Also, lysine-associated organic acidurias some results provide principal proof for the beneficial effects of riboflavin in GA-I. It has been previously reported that combination therapy with riboflavin and levocarnitine is effective for L2HGA as well as GA-I. Riboflavin and levocarnitine have been reported to improve not only clinical symptoms but also urinary 2-HGA levels. In our study, we aimed to evaluate the effect of the current treatment strategies and genotype on urinary metabolites and IQ scores in GA-I and L2HGA patients.

Methods

The presented retrospective multicenter study included patients followed up in Diyarbakir Children's Hospital and Izmir Katip Celebi University Faculty of Medicine, Division of Pediatric Metabolism. Between 2016 and 2021, we retrospectively evaluated 35 patients with confirmed diagnosis of GA-I and L-2HGA. We analyzed the clinical, biochemical, neuroradiological, molecular data and treatment of the patients. The follow-up period was every 2 months until 12 months old, every 3 months until 6 years of age, and every 6 months thereafter. Therapy monitoring was undertaken during follow-up visits that included evaluation of clinical parameters, laboratory parameters, and dietary consumption records. Denver II was applied in order to evaluate children aged 0-6 years in terms of development. Patients between 6 and 16 years of age were evaluated using the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Revised.

Results

We identified 25 with GA-I and 10 with L2HGA. The most common clinical symptoms were developmental delay, intellectual disability, and movement disorders. Behavioural problems were more common in L2HGA than in GA-I patients. In the same family, there were patients with severe developmental delay despite early diagnosis and treatment and individuals with normal IQ scores. In our study group, we used diet (lysine restricted or protein controlled), levocarnitine and vitamin B2 for GA-I patients. The mean urinary glutaric acid levels were decreased with treatment in GA-I patients. Group I consisted of 14/25 patients receiving lysine restricted diet and levocarnitine, Group II (8/25) received protein-controlled diet and levocarnitine. Group III (3/25) patients whom had p.Pro248Leu (P248L) variant, received riboflavin in combination with protein-controlled diet and levocarnitine. When we evaluated according to the treatment groups, a significant decrease was observed in urinary glutaric acid levels in group I. But there were no significant difference in Group II and III. The patients with c.1018C > T variant in GCDH gene had higher pre-treatment urinary metabolites and significant reduction in urinary metabolites with treatment was detected. In L2HGA patients, we used levocarnitine and vitamin B2. In all L2HGA patients, there was a significant decrease in the mean urinary 2- hydoxy glutarate with treatment. However, there was no significant difference between the c.164G > A and c.1115delT variants. The mean pre- and post-treatment IQ scores of GA-I patients, no significant difference was observed. Relative neurologic improvement was seen in three L2HGA patients. We found two novel variants, including the c.221A > G (p.Tyr74Cys) in the GCDH gene and the c.738 + 5A > G splice variant in the L2HGDH gene.

Conclusions

Glutaric aciduria type I and L2HGA are the most common cerebral organic acidurias. Early and correct diagnosis is crucial. Poor prognosis based on metabolic crises and progressive deterioration still appears. In countries where newborn screening is not performed, a clinical suspicion index is required for cerebral organic aciduria. GA-I and L-2HGA are difficult to examine by medical evidence standards because of the small sample size, regional differences in newborn screening, and medical care limits. More clinical studies are needed to identify effective treatments. However, the significant decrease in urinary glutaric acid levels after treatment in patients on lysine-restricted diet raises the question of whether lysine-restricted diet should be continued after six years of age. We also reported our experience in order to contribute to the literature.

Glutaryl-CoA Dehydrogenase Misfolding in Glutaric Acidemia Type 1

Glutaric acidemia type 1 (GA1) is a neurotoxic metabolic disorder due to glutaryl-CoA dehydrogenase (GCDH) deficiency. The high number of missense variants associated with the disease and their impact on GCDH activity suggest that disturbed protein conformation can affect the biochemical phenotype. We aimed to elucidate the molecular basis of protein loss of function in GA1 by performing a parallel analysis in a large panel of GCDH missense variants using different biochemical and biophysical methodologies. Thirteen GCDH variants were investigated in regard to protein stability, hydrophobicity, oligomerization, aggregation, and activity. An altered oligomerization, loss of protein stability and solubility, as well as an augmented susceptibility to aggregation were observed. GA1 variants led to a loss of enzymatic activity, particularly when present at the N-terminal domain. The reduced cellular activity was associated with loss of tetramerization. Our results also suggest a correlation between variant sequence location and cellular protein stability (p < 0.05), with a more pronounced loss of protein observed with variant proximity to the N-terminus. The broad panel of variant-mediated conformational changes of the GCDH protein supports the classification of GA1 as a protein-misfolding disorder. This work supports research toward new therapeutic strategies that target this molecular disease phenotype.

Biochemical and molecular features of chinese patients with glutaric acidemia type 1 from Fujian Province, southeastern China

BACKGROUND

Glutaric acidemia type 1 (GA1) is a rare autosomal recessive inherited metabolic disorder caused by variants in the gene encoding the enzyme glutaryl-CoA dehydrogenase (GCDH). The estimated prevalence of GA1 and the mutational spectrum of the GCDH gene vary widely according to race and region. The aim of this study was to assess the acylcarnitine profiles and genetic characteristics of patients with GA1 in Fujian Province, southeastern China.

RESULTS

From January 2014 to December 2022, a total of 1,151,069 newborns (631,016 males and 520,053 females) were screened using MS/MS in six newborn screening (NBS) centers in Fujian Province and recruited for this study. Through NBS, 18 newborns (13 females and 5 males) were diagnosed with GA1. Thus, the estimated incidence of GA1 was 1 in 63,948 newborns in Fujian province. In addition, 17 patients with GA1 were recruited after clinical diagnosis. All but one patient with GA1 had a remarkable increase in glutarylcarnitine (C5DC) concentrations. The results of urinary organic acid analyses in 33 patients showed that the concentration of glutaric acid (GA) increased in all patients. The levels of C5DC and GA in patients identified via NBS were higher than those in patients identified via clinical diagnosis (P < 0.05). A total of 71 variants of 70 alleles were detected in patients with GA1, with 19 different pathogenic variants identified. The three most prevalent variants represented 73.23% of the total and were c.1244-2 A > C, p.(?) (63.38%), c.1261G > A, p.Ala421Thr (5.63%), and c.406G > T, p.Gly136Cys (4.22%). The most abundant genotype observed was c.[1244-2 A > C]; [1244-2 A > C] (18/35, 52.43%) and its phenotype corresponded to high excretors (HE, GA > 100 mmol/mol Cr).

CONCLUSIONS

In conclusion, we investigated the biochemical and molecular features of 35 unrelated patients with GA1. C5DC concentrations in dried blood spots and urinary GA are effective indicators for a GA1 diagnosis. Our study also identified a GCDH variant spectrum in patients with GA1 from Fujian Province, southeastern China. Correlation analysis between genotypes and phenotypes provides preliminary and valuable information for genetic counseling and management.

Deep brain stimulation and intrathecal/intraventricular baclofen for glutaric aciduria type 1: A scoping review, individual patient data analysis, and clinical trials review

Glutaric aciduria type 1 (GA1) is an autosomal recessive disease frequently leading to dystonia. Deep brain stimulation (DBS), intrathecal baclofen (ITB), and intraventricular baclofen (IVB) are the current interventional treatment options for refractory dystonia. We performed a scoping review, individual patient data (IPD) analysis, and clinical trials review to summarize the existing literature on these interventions in this population, characterize outcomes, and suggest directions for future investigation. PubMed, Embase, and Scopus were searched following PRISMA guidelines. IPD were extracted from studies providing IPD for GA1 patients. ClinicalTrials.gov was reviewed. Of 139 articles, 7 studies with 10 patients were included. In study-level data, 2/4 (50.0%) DBS studies found no improvement in dystonia and 3/3 (100%) on baclofen found decreased dystonia and enteral medication regimen. In the IPD analysis, four studies with 5 patients (2 IVB, 2 DBS, 1 ITB) were included. The average percent reduction in dystonia was 29.9% ± 32.5% (median:18%, IQR:18%-29.2%). Function improved in 4 (80.0%) patients. All patients with reported changes in enteral dystonia-related medication regimen (3/3, 100%) reported reduction in medication usage. No patients (0%) had perioperative complications. Mean follow-up length was 14.8 ± 12.2 months. No interventional clinical trials were found. ITB, IVB, and DBS represent present neuromodulatory approaches for the treatment of GA1. ITB and IVB reduce dystonia, while DBS has a heterogeneous effect. ITB and IVB improved function and reduced enteral medication regimens. These findings must be viewed with caution considering limited data and a serious risk of bias. Further large-scale studies are necessary to determine indications for ITB, IVB, and DBS and elucidate treatment algorithms.

Two novel compound heterozygous variants of the GCDH gene in two Chinese families with glutaric acidaemia type I identified by high-throughput sequencing and a literature review

Autosomal recessive glutaric acidaemia type I (GA-I) is a rare hereditary metabolic disease characterized by increased organic acids and neurologic symptoms. Although numerous variants in the GCDH gene have been identified to be connected with the pathogenesis of GA-I, the relationship between genotype and phenotype remains uncertain. In this study, we evaluated genetic data for two GA-I patients from Hubei, China, and we reviewed the previous research findings to clarify the genetic heterogeneity of GA-I and identify the potential causative variants. After we extracted genomic DNA from peripheral blood samples obtained from two unrelated Chinese families, we used target capture high-throughput sequencing combined with Sanger sequencing to determine likely pathogenic variants in the two probands. Electronic databases were also searched for the literature review. The genetic analysis revealed two compound heterozygous variants in the GCDH gene expected to lead to GA-I in the two probands (P1 and P2), with P1 carrying two known variants (c.892G > A/p. A298T and c.1244-2A > C/IVS10-2A > C) and P2 harbouring two novel variants (c.370G > T/p.G124W and c.473A > G/p.E158G). In the literature review, the most common alleles in low excretors (i.e., individuals with low excretion of GA) were R227P, V400M, M405V, and A298T, with variation in the severity of clinical phenotypes. Overall, we identified two novel GCDH gene candidate pathogenic variants in a Chinese patient, enriching the GCDH gene mutational spectrum and providing a solid foundation for the early diagnosis of GA-I patients with low excretion.

2-Methylglutaconic acid as a biomarker in routine urine organic acids leading to the diagnosis of glutaric acidemia type I in a low excretor

GA1 (OMIM# 231670) is an organic aciduria caused by defective Glutaryl-CoA dehydrogenase (GCDH), encoded by GCDH. Early detection of GA1 is crucial to prevent patients from developing acute encephalopathic crisis and subsequent neurologic sequelae. Diagnosis of GA1 relies on elevated glutarylcarnitine (C5DC) in plasma acylcarnitine analysis and hyperexcretion of glutaric acid (GA) and 3-hydroxyglutaric acid (3HG) in urine organic acid (UOA) analysis. Low excretors (LE), however, exhibit subtly elevated or even normal plasma C5DC and urinary GA levels, leading to screening and diagnostic challenges. The measurement of 3HG in UOA is thus often used as the 1st tier test for GA1. We described a case of LE detected via newborn screen with normal excretion of GA, absent of 3HG and increased 2-methylglutaconic acid (2MGA), which was detected at 3 mg/g creatinine (reference interval <1 mg/g creatinine) without appreciable ketones. We retrospectively examined UOA of 8 other GA1 patients and the 2MGA level ranged from 2.5 to 27.39 mg/g creatinine, which is significantly higher than normal controls (0.05-1.61 mg/g creatinine). Although the underlying mechanism of 2MGA formation in GA1 is unclear, our study suggests 2MGA is a biomarker for GA1 and should be monitored by routine UOA to evaluate its diagnostic and prognostic value.

Neuroimaging findings of inborn errors of metabolism: urea cycle disorders, aminoacidopathies, and organic acidopathies

Although there are many types of inborn errors of metabolism (IEMs) affecting the central nervous system, also referred to as neurometabolic disorders, individual cases are rare, and their diagnosis is often challenging. However, early diagnosis is mandatory to initiate therapy and prevent permanent long-term neurological impairment or death. The clinical course of IEMs is very diverse, with some diseases progressing to acute encephalopathy following infection or fasting while others lead to subacute or slowly progressive encephalopathy. The diagnosis of IEMs relies on biochemical and genetic tests, but neuroimaging studies also provide important clues to the correct diagnosis and enable the conditions to be distinguished from other, more common causes of encephalopathy, such as hypoxia-ischemia. Proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy (¹H-MRS) is a powerful, non-invasive method of assessing neurological abnormalities at the microscopic level and can measure in vivo brain metabolites. The present review discusses neuroimaging findings, including those of ¹H-MRS, of IEMs focusing on intoxication disorders such as urea cycle disorders, aminoacidopathies, and organic acidopathies, which can result in acute life-threatening metabolic decompensation or crisis.

How guideline development has informed clinical research for organic acidurias (et vice versa)

Organic acidurias, such as glutaric aciduria type 1 (GA1), methylmalonic (MMA), and propionic aciduria (PA) are a prominent group of inherited metabolic diseases involving accumulation of eponymous metabolites causing endogenous intoxication. For all three conditions, guidelines for diagnosis and management have been developed and revised over the last years, resulting in three revisions for GA1 and one revision for MMA/PA. The process of clinical guideline development in rare metabolic disorders is challenged by the scarcity and limited quality of evidence available. The body of literature is often fragmentary and where information is present, it is usually derived from small sample sizes. Therefore, the development of guidelines for GA1 and MMA/PA was initially confronted with a poor evidence foundation that hindered formulation of concrete recommendations in certain contexts, triggering specific research projects and initiation of longitudinal, prospective observational studies using patient registries. Reversely, these observational studies contributed to evaluate the value of newborn screening, phenotypic diversities, and treatment effects, thus significantly improving the quality of evidence and directly influencing formulation and evidence levels of guideline recommendations. Here, we present insights into interactions between guideline development and (pre)clinical research for GA1 and MMA/PA, and demonstrate how guidelines gradually improved from revision to revision. We describe how clinical studies help to unravel the relative impact of therapeutic interventions on outcome and conclude that despite new and better quality of research data over the last decades, significant shortcomings of evidence regarding prognosis and treatment remain. It appears that development of clinical guidelines can directly help to guide research, and vice versa.

Recommendations for diagnosing and managing individuals with glutaric aciduria type 1: Third revision

Glutaric aciduria type 1 is a rare inherited neurometabolic disorder of lysine metabolism caused by pathogenic gene variations in GCDH (cytogenic location: 19p13.13), resulting in deficiency of mitochondrial glutaryl-CoA dehydrogenase (GCDH) and, consequently, accumulation of glutaric acid, 3-hydroxyglutaric acid, glutaconic acid and glutarylcarnitine detectable by gas chromatography/mass spectrometry (organic acids) and tandem mass spectrometry (acylcarnitines). Depending on residual GCDH activity, biochemical high and low excreting phenotypes have been defined. Most untreated individuals present with acute onset of striatal damage before age 3 (to 6) years, precipitated by infectious diseases, fever or surgery, resulting in irreversible, mostly dystonic movement disorder with limited life expectancy. In some patients, striatal damage develops insidiously. In recent years, the clinical phenotype has been extended by the finding of extrastriatal abnormalities and cognitive dysfunction, preferably in the high excreter group, as well as chronic kidney failure. Newborn screening is the prerequisite for pre-symptomatic start of metabolic treatment with low lysine diet, carnitine supplementation and intensified emergency treatment during catabolic episodes, which, in combination, have substantially improved neurologic outcome. In contrast, start of treatment after onset of symptoms cannot reverse existing motor dysfunction caused by striatal damage. Dietary treatment can be relaxed after the vulnerable period for striatal damage, that is, age 6 years. However, impact of dietary relaxation on long-term outcomes is still unclear. This third revision of evidence-based recommendations aims to re-evaluate previous recommendations (Boy et al., J Inherit Metab Dis, 2017;40(1):75-101; Kolker et al., J Inherit Metab Dis 2011;34(3):677-694; Kolker et al., J Inherit Metab Dis, 2007;30(1):5-22) and to implement new research findings on the evolving phenotypic diversity as well as the impact of non-interventional variables and treatment quality on clinical outcomes.

How longitudinal observational studies can guide screening strategy for rare diseases

Newborn screening (NBS) is an important secondary prevention program, aiming to shift the paradigm of medicine to the pre-clinical stage of a disease. Starting more than 50 years ago, technical advances, such as tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS), paved the way to a continuous extension of NBS programs. However, formal evidence of the long-term clinical benefits in large cohorts and cost-effectiveness of extended NBS programs is still scarce. Although published studies confirmed important benefits of NBS programs, it also unraveled a significant number of limitations. These include an incompletely understood natural history and phenotypic diversity of some screened diseases, unreliable early and precise prediction of individual disease severity, uncertainty about case definition, risk stratification, and indication to treat, resulting in a diagnostic and treatment dilemma in individuals with ambiguous screening and confirmatory test results. Interoperable patient registries are multi-purpose tools that could help to close the current knowledge gaps and to inform further optimization of NBS strategy. Standing at the edge of introducing high throughput genetic technologies to NBS programs with the opportunity to massively extend NBS programs and with the risk of aggravating current limitations of NBS programs, it seems overdue to include mandatory long-term follow-up of NBS cohorts into the list of screening principles and to build an international collaborative framework that enables data collection and exchange in a protected environment, integrating the perspectives of patients, families, and the society.

Towards Achieving Equity and Innovation in Newborn Screening across Europe

Although individual rare disorders are uncommon, it is estimated that, together, 6000+ known rare diseases affect more than 30 million people in Europe, and present a substantial public health burden. Together with the psychosocial burden on affected families, rare disorders frequently, if untreated, result in a low quality of life, disability and even premature death. Newborn screening (NBS) has the potential to detect a number of rare conditions in asymptomatic children, providing the possibility of early treatment and a significantly improved long-term outcome. Despite these clear benefits, the availability and conduct of NBS programmes varies considerably across Europe and, with the increasing potential of genomic testing, it is likely that these differences may become even more pronounced. To help improve the equity of provision of NBS and ensure that all children can be offered high-quality screening regardless of race, nationality and socio-economic status, a technical meeting, endorsed by the Slovenian Presidency of the Council of the European Union, was held in October 2021. In this article, we present experiences from individual EU countries, stakeholder initiatives and the meeting's final conclusions, which can help countries attempting to establish new NBS programmes or expand existing provision.

Rare Disease Registries Are Key to Evidence-Based Personalized Medicine: Highlighting the European Experience

Rare diseases, such as inherited metabolic diseases, have been identified as a health priority within the European Union more than 20 years ago and have become an integral part of EU health programs and European Reference Networks. Having the potential to pool data, to achieve sufficient sample size, to overcome the knowledge gap on rare diseases and to foster epidemiological and clinical research, patient registries are recognized as key instruments to evidence-based medicine for individuals with rare diseases. Patient registries can be used for multiple purposes, such as (1) describing the natural history and phenotypic diversity of rare diseases, (2) improving case definition and indication to treat, (3) identifying strategies for risk stratification and early prediction of disease severity (4), evaluating the impact of preventive, diagnostic, and therapeutic strategies on individual health, health economics, and the society, and (5) informing guideline development and policy makers. In contrast to clinical trials, patient registries aim to gather real-world evidence and to achieve generalizable results based on patient cohorts with a broad phenotypic spectrum. In order to develop a consistent and sustained framework for rare disease registries, uniform core principles have been formulated and have been formalized through the European Rare Disease Registration Infrastructure. Adherence to these core principles and compliance with the European general data protection regulations ensures that data collected and stored in patient registries can be exchanged and pooled in a protected environment. To illustrate the benefits and limitations of patient registries on rare disease research this review focuses on inherited metabolic diseases.

Clinico-Radiological Correlation in 26 Egyptian Children with Glutaric Acidemia Type 1

BACKGROUND

Glutaric acidemia type 1 (GA1) is an inherited neurometabolic disease with significant morbidity. However, neuro-radiological correlation is not completely understood.

OBJECTIVE

The study aimed to characterize the neuroimaging findings and their association with neurological phenotype in GA1 children.

METHODS

Twenty-six Egyptian children (median age = 12 months) diagnosed with GA1 underwent clinical evaluation and brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). We objectively assessed the severity of neurological phenotype at the time of MRI using movement disorder (MD) and morbidity scores. Evaluation of brain MRI abnormalities followed a systematic and region-specific scoring approach. Brain MRI findings and scores were correlated with MD and morbidity scores, disease onset, and presence of seizures.

RESULTS

Fifteen (57.7%) cases had insidious onset, eight (30.8%) manifested acute onset, whereas three (11.5%) were asymptomatic. Ten (38.5%) cases had seizures, five of which had no acute encephalopathic crisis. Putamen and caudate abnormalities (found in all acute onset, 93.3 and 73.3% of insidious onset, and one of three asymptomatic cases) were significantly related to MD (p = 0.007 and 0.013) and morbidity (p = 0.005 and 0.003) scores. Globus pallidus abnormalities (50% of acute onset, 46.7% of insidious onset, and one of three of asymptomatic cases) were significantly associated with morbidity score (p = 0.023). Other MRI brain abnormalities as well as gray and white matter score showed no significant association with neurological phenotype. Younger age at onset, acute onset, and seizures were significantly associated with worse neurological manifestations.

CONCLUSION

Patients with GA1 manifest characteristic and region-specific brain MRI abnormalities, but only striatal affection appears to correlate with neurological phenotype.

A knock-in rat model unravels acute and chronic renal toxicity in glutaric aciduria type I

Glutaric aciduria type I (GA-I, OMIM # 231670) is an autosomal recessive inborn error of metabolism caused by deficiency of the mitochondrial enzyme glutaryl-CoA dehydrogenase (GCDH). The principal clinical manifestation in GA-I patients is striatal injury most often triggered by catabolic stress. Early diagnosis by newborn screening programs improved survival and reduced striatal damage in GA-I patients. However, the clinical phenotype is still evolving in the aging patient population. Evaluation of long-term outcome in GA-I patients recently identified glomerular filtration rate (GFR) decline with increasing age. We recently created the first knock-in rat model for GA-I harboring the mutation p.R411W (c.1231 C>T), corresponding to the most frequent GCDH human mutation p.R402W. In this study, we evaluated the effect of an acute metabolic stress in form of high lysine diet (HLD) on young Gcdh^ki/ki rats. We further studied the chronic effect of GCDH deficiency on kidney function in a longitudinal study on a cohort of Gcdh^ki/ki rats by repetitive ⁶⁸Ga-EDTA positron emission tomography (PET) renography, biochemical and histological analyses. In young Gcdh^ki/ki rats exposed to HLD, we observed a GFR decline and biochemical signs of a tubulopathy. Histological analyses revealed lipophilic vacuoles, thinning of apical brush border membranes and increased numbers of mitochondria in proximal tubular (PT) cells. HLD also altered OXPHOS activities and proteome in kidneys of Gcdh^ki/ki rats. In the longitudinal cohort, we showed a progressive GFR decline in Gcdh^ki/ki rats starting at young adult age and a decline of renal clearance. Histopathological analyses in aged Gcdh^ki/ki rats revealed tubular dilatation, protein accumulation in PT cells and mononuclear infiltrations. These observations confirm that GA-I leads to acute and chronic renal damage. This raises questions on indication for follow-up on kidney function in GA-I patients and possible therapeutic interventions to avoid renal damage.

Subdural hematoma in glutaric aciduria type 1: High excreters are prone to incidental SDH despite newborn screening

Subdural hematoma (SDH) was initially reported in 20% to 30% of patients with glutaric aciduria type 1 (GA1). A recent retrospective study found SDH in 4% of patients, but not in patients identified by newborn screening (NBS). 168 MRIs of 69 patients with GA1 (age at MRI 9 days - 73.8 years, median 3.2 years) were systematically reviewed for presence of SDH, additional MR and clinical findings in order to investigate the frequency of SDH and potential risk factors. SDH was observed in eight high-excreting patients imaged between 5.8 and 24.4 months, namely space-occupying SDH in two patients after minor accidental trauma and SDH as an incidental finding in six patients without trauma. In patients without trauma imaged at 3 to 30 months (n = 36, 25 NBS, 27/9 high/low excreters), incidence of SDH was 16.7% (16% in NBS). SDH was more common after acute (33.3%) than insidious onset of dystonia (14.3%) or in asymptomatic patients (5.9%). It was only seen in patients with wide frontoparietal CSF spaces and frontotemporal hypoplasia. High excreters were over-represented among patients with SDH (6/27 vs 0/9 low excreters), acute onset (10/12), and wide frontoparietal CSF spaces (16/19). Incidental SDH occurs despite NBS and early treatment in approximately one in six patients with GA1 imaged during late infancy and early childhood. Greater risk of high excreters is morphologically associated with more frequent enlargement of external CSF spaces including frontotemporal hypoplasia, and may be furthered aggravated by more pronounced alterations of cerebral blood volume and venous pressure.

Protective effects of L-carnitine on behavioral alterations and neuroinflammation in striatum of glutaryl-COA dehydrogenase deficient mice

Glutaric acidemia type 1 (GA1) is caused by glutaryl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency that leads to a blockage in the metabolic route of the amino acids lysine and tryptophan and subsequent accumulation of glutaric acid (GA), 3-hydroxyglutaric acids and glutarylcarnitine (C5DC). Patients predominantly manifest neurological symptoms, associated with acute striatal degeneration, as well as progressive cortical and striatum injury whose pathogenesis is not yet fully established. Current treatment includes protein/lysine restriction and l-carnitine supplementation of (L-car). The aim of this work was to evaluate behavior parameters and pro-inflammatory factors (cytokines IL-1β, TNF-α and cathepsin-D levels), as well as the anti-inflammatory cytokine IL10 in striatum of knockout mice (Gcdh-/-) and wild type (WT) mice submitted to a normal or a high Lys diet. The potential protective effects of L-car treatment on these parameters were also evaluated. Gcdh-/- mice showed behavioral changes, including lower motor activity (decreased number of crossings) and exploratory activity (reduced number of rearings). Also, Gcdh-/- mice had significantly higher concentrations of glutarylcarnitine (C5DC) in blood and cathepsin-D (CATD), interleukin IL-1β and tumor factor necrosis alpha (TNF-α) in striatum than WT mice. Noteworthy, L-car treatment prevented most behavioral alterations, normalized CATD levels and attenuated IL-1β levels in striatum of Gcdh-/- mice. Finally, IL-1β was positively correlated with CATD and C5DC levels and L-car was negatively correlated with CATD. Our results demonstrate behavioral changes and a pro-inflammatory status in striatum of the animal model of GA1 and, most importantly, L-car showed important protective effects on these alterations.

The biochemical subtype is a predictor for cognitive function in glutaric aciduria type 1: a national prospective follow-up study

The aim of the study was a systematic evaluation of cognitive development in individuals with glutaric aciduria type 1 (GA1), a rare neurometabolic disorder, identified by newborn screening in Germany. This national, prospective, observational, multi-centre study includes 107 individuals with confirmed GA1 identified by newborn screening between 1999 and 2020 in Germany. Clinical status, development, and IQ were assessed using standardized tests. Impact of interventional and non-interventional parameters on cognitive outcome was evaluated. The majority of tested individuals (n = 72) showed stable IQ values with age (n = 56 with IQ test; median test age 11 years) but a significantly lower performance (median [IQR] IQ 87 [78-98]) than in general population, particularly in individuals with a biochemical high excreter phenotype (84 [75-96]) compared to the low excreter group (98 [92-105]; p = 0.0164). For all patients, IQ results were homogenous on subscale levels. Sex, clinical motor phenotype and quality of metabolic treatment had no impact on cognitive functions. Long-term neurologic outcome in GA1 involves both motor and cognitive functions. The biochemical high excreter phenotype is the major risk factor for cognitive impairment while cognitive functions do not appear to be impacted by current therapy and striatal damage. These findings implicate the necessity of new treatment concepts.

Clinical, Biochemical, and Genetic Heterogeneity in Glutaric Aciduria Type II Patients

The variants of electron transfer flavoprotein (ETFA, ETFB) and ETF dehydrogenase (ETFDH) are the leading cause of glutaric aciduria type II (GA-II). In this study, we identified 13 patients harboring six variants of two genes associated with GA-II. Out of the six variants, four were missense, and two were frameshift mutations. A missense variant (ETFDH:p.Gln269His) was observed in a homozygous state in nine patients. Among nine patients, three had experienced metabolic crises with recurrent vomiting, abdominal pain, and nausea. In one patient with persistent metabolic acidosis, hypoglycemia, and a high anion gap, the ETFDH:p.Gly472Arg, and ETFB:p.Pro94Thrfs*8 variants were identified in a homozygous, and heterozygous state, respectively. A missense variant ETFDH:p.Ser442Leu was detected in a homozygous state in one patient with metabolic acidosis, hypoglycemia, hyperammonemia and liver dysfunction. The ETFDH:p.Arg41Leu, and ETFB:p.Ile346Phefs*19 variants were observed in a homozygous state in one patient each. Both these variants have not been reported so far. In silico approaches were used to evaluate the pathogenicity and structural changes linked with these six variants. Overall, the results indicate the importance of a newborn screening program and genetic investigations for patients with GA-II. Moreover, careful interpretation and correlation of variants of uncertain significance with clinical and biochemical findings are needed to confirm the pathogenicity of such variants.

Biochemical and molecular features of Chinese patients with glutaric acidemia type 1 detected through newborn screening

Background

Glutaric acidemia type 1 (GA1) is a treatable disorder affecting cerebral organic acid metabolism caused by a defective glutaryl-CoA dehydrogenase (GCDH) gene. GA1 diagnosis reports following newborn screening (NBS) are scarce in the Chinese population. This study aimed to assess the acylcarnitine profiles and genetic characteristics of patients with GA1 identified through NBS.

Results

From January 2014 to September 2020, 517,484 newborns were screened by tandem mass spectrometry, 102 newborns with elevated glutarylcarnitine (C5DC) levels were called back. Thirteen patients were diagnosed with GA1, including 11 neonatal GA1 and two maternal GA1 patients. The incidence of GA1 in the Quanzhou region was estimated at 1 in 47,044 newborns. The initial NBS results showed that all but one of the patients had moderate to markedly increased C5DC levels. Notably, one neonatal patient with low free carnitine (C0) level suggest primary carnitine deficiency (PCD) but was ultimately diagnosed as GA1. Nine neonatal GA1 patients underwent urinary organic acid analyses: eight had elevated GA and 3HGA levels, and one was reported to be within the normal range. Ten distinct GCDH variants were identified. Eight were previously reported, and two were newly identified. In silico prediction tools and protein modeling analyses suggested that the newly identified variants were potentially pathogenic. The most common variant was c.1244-2 A>C, which had an allelic frequency of 54.55% (12/22), followed by c.1261G>A (p.Ala421Thr) at 9.09% (2/22).

Conclusions

Neonatal GA1 patients with increased C5DC levels can be identified through NBS. Maternal GA1 patients can also be detected using NBS due to the low C0 levels in their infants. Few neonatal GA1 patients may have atypical acylcarnitine profiles that are easy to miss during NBS; therefore, multigene panel testing should be performed in newborns with low C0 levels. This study indicates that the GCDH variant spectra were heterogeneous in this southern Chinese cohort.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s13023-021-01964-5.

Precision medicine for genetic childhood movement disorders

Increasingly effective targeted precision medicine is either already available or in development for a number of genetic childhood movement disorders. Patient-centred, personalized approaches include the repurposing of existing treatments for specific conditions and the development of novel therapies that target the underlying genetic defect or disease mechanism. In tandem with these scientific advances, close collaboration between clinicians, researchers, affected families, and stakeholders in the wider community will be key to successfully delivering such precision therapies to children with movement disorders. What this paper adds Precision medicine for genetic childhood movement disorders is developing rapidly. Accurate diagnosis, disease-specific outcome measures, and collaborative multidisciplinary work will accelerate the progress of such strategies.

Use of Molecular Genetic Analyses in Danish Routine Newborn Screening

Historically, the analyses used for newborn screening (NBS) were biochemical, but increasingly, molecular genetic analyses are being introduced in the workflow. We describe the application of molecular genetic analyses in the Danish NBS programme and show that second-tier molecular genetic testing is useful to reduce the false positive rate while simultaneously providing information about the precise molecular genetic variant and thus informing therapeutic strategy and easing providing information to parents. When molecular genetic analyses are applied as second-tier testing, valuable functional data from biochemical methods are available and in our view, such targeted NGS technology should be implemented when possible in the NBS workflow. First-tier NGS technology may be a promising future possibility for disorders without a reliable biomarker and as a general approach to increase the adaptability of NBS for a broader range of genetic diseases, which is important in the current landscape of quickly evolving new therapeutic possibilities. However, studies on feasibility, sensitivity, and specificity are needed as well as more insight into what views the general population has towards using genetic analyses in NBS. This may be sensitive to some and could have potentially negative consequences for the NBS programme.

Enlargement of the Optic Chiasm: A Novel Imaging Finding in Glutaric Aciduria Type 1

Patients with glutaric aciduria type 1, without early diagnosis and initiation of preventive treatment, often develop movement disorders and various degrees of motor disability due to striatal area-specific damage induced by an acute episode of metabolic decompensation. The neuroimaging phenotype of patients with glutaric aciduria type 1 includes characteristic cyst-like bilateral enlargement of the Sylvian fissures and anterior subarachnoid spaces and signal abnormalities including supratentorial white matter and deep gray matter structure T2 hyperintensities, frequently associated with restricted diffusion. In this retrospective study, we add to the neuroimaging spectrum of glutaric aciduria type 1, a novel imaging finding present regardless of a previous metabolic crisis: the enlargement of the optic chiasm associated with signal abnormalities in the anterior intracranial visual structures observed in 6 of 10 patients. These optic pathway abnormalities are suggested as useful diagnostic clues for glutaric aciduria type 1, and possible pathophysiologic mechanisms are discussed.

Evaluation of the Clinical, Biochemical, Neurological, and Genetic Presentations of Glutaric Aciduria Type 1 in Patients From China

Purpose

To characterize the phenotypic and genotypic variations associated with Glutaric aciduria type 1 (GA1) in Chinese patients.

Methods

We analyzed the clinical, neuroradiological, biochemical, and genetic information from 101 GA1 patients in mainland China.

Results

20 patients were diagnosed by newborn screening and the remaining 81 cases were identified following clinical intervention. Macrocephaly was the most common presentation, followed by movement disorders and seizures. A total of 59 patients were evaluated by brain MRI and 58 patients presented with abnormalities, with widening of the sylvian fissures being the most common symptom. The concentration of glutarylcarnitine in the blood, glutarylcarnitine/capryloylcarnitine ratio, and urine levels of glutaric acid were increased in GA1 patients and were shown to decrease following intervention. A total of 88 patient samples were available for genotyping and 74 variants within the GCDH gene, including 23 novel variants, were identified. The most common variant was c.1244-2A > C (18.4%) and there were no significant differences in the biochemical or clinical phenotypes described for patients with the four most common variants: c.1244-2A > C, c.1064G > A, c.533G > A, and c.1147C > T. Patients identified by newborn screening had better outcomes than clinical patients.

Conclusion

Our findings expand the spectrum of phenotypes and genotypes for GA1 in Chinese populations and suggest that an expanded newborn screening program using tandem mass spectrometry may facilitate the early diagnosis and treatment of this disease, improving clinical outcomes for patients in China.

Newborn screening and disease variants predict neurological outcome in isovaleric aciduria

Isovaleric aciduria (IVA), a metabolic disease with severe (classic IVA) or attenuated phenotype (mild IVA), is included in newborn screening (NBS) programs worldwide. The long-term clinical benefit of screened individuals, however, is still rarely investigated. A national, prospective, observational, multi-center study of individuals with confirmed IVA identified by NBS between 1998 and 2018 was conducted. Long-term clinical outcomes of 94 individuals with IVA were evaluated, representing 73.4% (for classic IVA: 92.3%) of the German NBS cohort. In classic IVA (N = 24), NBS prevented untimely death except in one individual with lethal neonatal sepsis (3.8%) but did not completely prevent single (N = 10) or recurrent (N = 7) metabolic decompensations, 13 of them occurring already neonatally. IQ (mean ± SD, 90.7 ± 10.1) was mostly normal but below the reference population (P = .0022) and was even lower in individuals with severe neonatal decompensations (IQ 78.8 ± 7.1) compared to those without crises (IQ 94.7 ± 7.5; P = .01). Similar results were obtained for school placement. In contrast, individuals with mild IVA had excellent neurocognitive outcomes (IQ 105.5 ± 15.8; normal school placement) and a benign disease course (no metabolic decompensation, normal hospitalization rate), which did not appear to be impacted by metabolic maintenance therapy. In conclusion, NBS reduces mortality in classic IVA, but does not reliably protect against severe neonatal metabolic decompensations, crucial for favorable neurocognitive outcome. In contrast, individuals with mild IVA had excellent clinical outcomes regardless of metabolic maintenance therapy, questioning their benefit from NBS. Harmonized stratified therapeutic concepts are urgently needed.

The first knock-in rat model for glutaric aciduria type I allows further insights into pathophysiology in brain and periphery

Glutaric aciduria type I (GA-I, OMIM # 231670) is an inborn error of metabolism caused by a deficiency of glutaryl-CoA dehydrogenase (GCDH). Patients develop acute encephalopathic crises (AEC) with striatal injury most often triggered by catabolic stress. The pathophysiology of GA-I, particularly in brain, is still not fully understood. We generated the first knock-in rat model for GA-I by introduction of the mutation p.R411W, the rat sequence homologue of the most common Caucasian mutation p.R402W, into the Gcdh gene of Sprague Dawley rats by CRISPR/CAS9 technology. Homozygous Gcdh^ki/ki rats revealed a high excretor phenotype, but did not present any signs of AEC under normal diet (ND). Exposure to a high lysine diet (HLD, 4.7%) after weaning resulted in clinical and biochemical signs of AEC. A significant increase of plasmatic ammonium concentrations was found in Gcdh^ki/ki rats under HLD, accompanied by a decrease of urea concentrations and a concomitant increase of arginine excretion. This might indicate an inhibition of the urea cycle. Gcdh^ki/ki rats exposed to HLD showed highly diminished food intake resulting in severely decreased weight gain and moderate reduction of body mass index (BMI). This constellation suggests a loss of appetite. Under HLD, pipecolic acid increased significantly in cerebral and extra-cerebral liquids and tissues of Gcdh^ki/ki rats, but not in WT rats. It seems that Gcdh^ki/ki rats under HLD activate the pipecolate pathway for lysine degradation. Gcdh^ki/ki rat brains revealed depletion of free carnitine, microglial activation, astroglyosis, astrocytic death by apoptosis, increased vacuole numbers, impaired OXPHOS activities and neuronal damage. Under HLD, Gcdh^ki/ki rats showed imbalance of intra- and extracellular creatine concentrations and indirect signs of an intracerebral ammonium accumulation. We successfully created the first rat model for GA-I. Characterization of this Gcdh^ki/ki strain confirmed that it is a suitable model not only for the study of pathophysiological processes, but also for the development of new therapeutic interventions. We further brought up interesting new insights into the pathophysiology of GA-I in brain and periphery.

[New Inborn Errors of Metabolism added in the French program of neonatal screening]

Inborn Errors of Metabolism (IEM) are rare and heterogenous disorders. For most IEMs, clinical signs are non-specific or belated. Late diagnosis is frequent, leading to death or severe sequelae. Some IEM induce intermediate metabolites circulating in the blood. They may be detected by tandem mass spectrometry. This method allows the simultaneous detection of many IEM in different metabolic pathways. In France, newborn screening (NBS) program for IEM, limited to phenylketonuria for decades, has been recently extended to medium chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency. Rationale, methodology and organization of this new NBS program are described. Seven other IEM (maple syrup urine disease, homocystinuria, tyrosinemia type I, glutaric aciduria type I, isovaleric acidemia, long chain hydroxy-acyl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency, carnitine uptake disorder) should be screened in the next program extension. Efforts are needed to fully understand the predictive value of each abnormal testing at birth, decrease the false positive rate, and develop the adequate management strategies.

Impact of interventional and non-interventional variables on anthropometric long-term development in glutaric aciduria type 1: A national prospective multi-centre study

Glutaric aciduria type 1 (GA1) is a rare neurometabolic disorder, caused by inherited deficiency of glutaryl-CoA dehydrogenase, mostly affecting the brain. Early identification by newborn screening (NBS) significantly improves neurologic outcome. It has remained unclear whether recommended therapy, particular low lysine diet, is safe or negatively affects anthropometric long-term outcome. This national prospective, observational, multi-centre study included 79 patients identified by NBS and investigated effects of interventional and non-interventional parameters on body weight, body length, body mass index (BMI) and head circumference as well as neurological parameters. Adherence to recommended maintenance and emergency treatment (ET) had a positive impact on neurologic outcome and allowed normal anthropometric development until adulthood. In contrast, non-adherence to ET, resulting in increased risk of dystonia, had a negative impact on body weight (mean SDS -1.07; P = .023) and body length (mean SDS -1.34; P = -.016). Consistently, longitudinal analysis showed a negative influence of severe dystonia on weight and length development over time (P < .001). Macrocephaly was more often found in female (mean SDS 0.56) than in male patients (mean SDS -0.20; P = .049), and also in individuals with high excreter phenotype (mean SDS 0.44) compared to low excreter patients (mean SDS -0.68; P = .016). In GA1, recommended long-term treatment is effective and allows for normal anthropometric long-term development up to adolescence, with gender- and excreter type-specific variations. Delayed ET and severe movement disorder result in poor anthropometric outcome.

Bilateral subdural hematomas and retinal hemorrhages mimicking nonaccidental trauma in a patient with D-2-hydroxyglutaric aciduria

INTRODUCTION

Nonaccidental trauma (NAT) is considered when pediatric patients present with intracranial injuries and a negative history of an accidental injury or concomitant medical diagnosis. The evaluation of NAT should include the consideration of possible medical causes including coagulation, hematologic, metabolic and other genetic disorders, as well as witnessed and unwitnessed accidental injuries.

CASE PRESENTATION

We present a 7-month-old male with spells and incidental findings of bilateral subdural hematomas, retinal hemorrhages, and secondary macrocephaly, leading to investigation for NAT. Biochemical analysis showed excretion of a large amount of D-2-hydroxyglutaric in urine consistent with a biochemical diagnosis of D-2-hydroxyglutaric aciduria, a rare neurometabolic disorder characterized by developmental delay, epilepsy, hypotonia, and psychomotor retardation. None of these symptoms were present in our patient at the time of diagnosis. Molecular genetic testing revealed a pathogenic splice site variant (c.685-2A>G) and a variant of uncertain significance (c.1256G>T) with evidence of pathogenicity in the D2HGDH gene, consistent with a molecular diagnosis of D-2-hydroxyglutaric aciduria type I (OMIM #600721).

CONCLUSION

Since several metabolic disorders, including D-2-hydroxyglutaric aciduria type I, can present solely with symptoms suggestive of NAT (subdural and retinal hemorrhages), an early metabolic evaluation by urine organic acid analysis should be included in clinical protocols evaluating NAT. A methodical and nonjudgmental approach coordinated between pediatricians and metabolic specialists is also necessary to ensure that rare genetic conditions are not overlooked to prevent devastating social, legal, and financial consequences of suspected child abuse.

Spinal cerebrotendinous xanthomatosis: A case report and literature review

Background

Classic cerebrotendinous xanthomatosis (CTX; OMIM #213700) manifests with chronic diarrhea, juvenile cataracts, tendon xanthomas and neurological symptoms. It is due to biallelic inactivation of CYP27A1 wich leads to cholestanol accumulation in the central nervous system, eyes and tendons. Less commonly, the disease can present in young adults as spastic paraparesis in the absence of xanthomas.

Case presentation

We report a 38-year old woman who presented with chronic diarrhea and progressive spastic paraparesis in her twenties. Brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) showed cerebral atrophy with diffuse periventricular white matter hyperintensities. Spinal MRI was normal. CYP27A1 gene sequencing confirmed the diagnosis of CTX. Chenodeoxycholic acid (CDCA) treatment was introduced with remission of diarrhea. Unfortunately, the treatment had to be discontinued several times and the patient developed psychosis and an severe ataxospastic gait. Spinal MRI revealed new linear hyperintensities of the corticospinal and gracile tracts. Thirty-three spinal CTX patients were identified by searching in Pubmed, EMBASE™ and Web of Science databases. All patients presented pyramidal signs and 48% had dorsal column signs. Juvenile cataracts were described in 78% of patients, chronic diarrhea in 65%, and tendon xanthomas in 31%. Disease improvement or stabilization with chenodeoxycholic acid was observed in 69% of patients. A higher prevalence of the Arg395Cys allele was observed in patients with spinal CTX as compared to CTX in general (ᵡ²; p < 0.00001).

Conclusions

The diagnosis of spinal CTX can be easily missed or delayed in absence of xanthomas. There is a higher prevalence of the Arg395Cys allele in spinal CTX as compared to classic childhood-onset CTX. CDCA treatment seems to stabilize or improve clinical symptoms in most patients. However, as seen in our patient and in two previously reported cases, sudden interruption of CDCA may lead to irreversible neurological complications.

Organic acidurias: Major gaps, new challenges, and a yet unfulfilled promise

Organic acidurias (OADs) comprise a biochemically defined group of inherited metabolic diseases. Increasing awareness, reliable diagnostic work-up, newborn screening programs for some OADs, optimized neonatal and intensive care, and the development of evidence-based recommendations have improved neonatal survival and short-term outcome of affected individuals. However, chronic progression of organ dysfunction in an aging patient population cannot be reliably prevented with traditional therapeutic measures. Evidence is increasing that disease progression might be best explained by mitochondrial dysfunction. Previous studies have demonstrated that some toxic metabolites target mitochondrial proteins inducing synergistic bioenergetic impairment. Although these potentially reversible mechanisms help to understand the development of acute metabolic decompensations during catabolic state, they currently cannot completely explain disease progression with age. Recent studies identified unbalanced autophagy as a novel mechanism in the renal pathology of methylmalonic aciduria, resulting in impaired quality control of organelles, mitochondrial aging and, subsequently, progressive organ dysfunction. In addition, the discovery of post-translational short-chain lysine acylation of histones and mitochondrial enzymes helps to understand how intracellular key metabolites modulate gene expression and enzyme function. While acylation is considered an important mechanism for metabolic adaptation, the chronic accumulation of potential substrates of short-chain lysine acylation in inherited metabolic diseases might exert the opposite effect, in the long run. Recently, changed glutarylation patterns of mitochondrial proteins have been demonstrated in glutaric aciduria type 1. These new insights might bridge the gap between natural history and pathophysiology in OADs, and their exploitation for the development of targeted therapies seems promising.

Outcome of the glutaric aciduria type 1 (GA1) newborn screening program in Manitoba: 1980–2020

Glutaric aciduria type 1 (GA1) is a severe inherited neurometabolic disorder whose clinical outcome has improved after implementation of newborn screening (NBS) programs and prompt beginning of guideline-directed presymptomatic metabolic treatment. We report the outcome of our 40-year experience with the diagnosis and management of GA1 which has improved but remains suboptimal.