Trials for Slowly Progressive Neurogenetic Diseases Need Surrogate Endpoints

Clinical Outcome Assessments and Biomarkers in Charcot-Marie-Tooth Disease

Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease (CMT) encompasses a diverse group of genetic forms of inherited peripheral neuropathy and stands as the most common hereditary neurologic disease worldwide. At present, no disease-modifying treatments exist for any form of CMT. However, promising therapeutic strategies are rapidly emerging, necessitating careful consideration of clinical outcome assessments (COAs) and clinical trial design. In this review, we discuss the challenges and successes over the past 2 decades in efforts to design and validate COAs and disease biomarkers of CMT. Natural history studies and completed clinical trials have underscored the limitations of early clinical scales for CMT, including the neuropathy impairment score, overall neuropathy limitation scale, and CMT neuropathy score. These studies prompted the development of newer, psychometrically supported scales including the CMT neuropathy score version 2, CMT pediatric scale, CMT infant scale, CMT functional outcome measure, and CMT health index. Although promising, many of these scales have yet to be formally tested in longitudinal studies. Given inherent challenges of relying solely on COAs in slowly progressive forms of CMT, there is growing recognition of the need for objective disease biomarkers that could serve as surrogate end points in clinical trials. Among these, MRI muscle fat fraction in the lower extremities has proven the most responsive biomarker to date, although its relationship to functional outcomes and its performance in treatment trials remain uncertain. Serum biomarkers including neurofilament light, transmembrane protease serine 5, specific microRNAs, neural cell adhesion molecule 1, and growth and differentiation factor 15 reliably distinguish patients with CMT from controls, but their responsiveness to effective therapies also remains unknown. Although the optimal combination of outcome measures in CMT has yet to be established, many of the most promising COAs and biomarkers are now being put to the test in ongoing clinical trials. These early studies will also help address other critical clinical trial considerations, such as patient selection and enrollment targets, which will become increasingly important in this exciting new era of bringing the first disease-modifying treatments to people living with CMT.

Gene therapies for CMT neuropathies: from the bench to the clinic

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Charcot-Marie-Tooth (CMT) neuropathies are rare, genetically heterogeneous and progressive diseases for which there are no approved treatments and their management remains mostly supportive and symptomatic. This review is intended to provide an update on recent developments in gene therapies for different CMT neuropathies.

RECENT FINDINGS

Increasing knowledge of disease pathomechanisms underlying several CMT types has facilitated the development of promising viral and nonviral gene therapy approaches. Some of these therapies are currently approaching the crucial step of moving from the bench to the clinic, having passed the proof-of-concept stage in rodent models and some also in larger animals. However, questions of optimal delivery route and dose, off-target effects, and possible payload toxicity remain to be clarified for several of these approaches. Furthermore, limited resources, the rarity of most CMT subtypes, and issues of safety and regulatory requirements, create the need for consensus guidelines and optimal clinical trial design.

SUMMARY

Promising gene therapies have been developed for several CMT neuropathies, with proof-of-principle demonstrated in relevant disease models. Advantages and drawbacks of each approach are discussed and remaining challenges are highlighted. Furthermore, we suggest important parameters that should be considered in order to successfully translate them into the clinic.

Clinical Characteristics of Charcot-Marie-Tooth Disease Type 4J

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease type 4J (CMT4J) is caused by autosomal recessive variants in the Factor-Induced Gene 4 (FIG4) gene. Recent preclinical work has demonstrated the feasibility of adeno-associated virus serotype 9-FIG4 gene therapy. This study aimed to further characterize the CMT4J phenotype and evaluate feasibility of validated CMT-related outcome measures for future clinical trials.

METHODS

This cross-sectional study enrolled children and adults with genetically confirmed CMT4J, with 2 documented disease-causing variants in the FIG4 gene. Patients were recruited through the Inherited Neuropathy Consortium network. Disease severity was assessed using standardized CMT-specific outcome measures and exploratory biomarkers including muscle MRI fat fraction, electrophysiology, and neurofilament light chain levels. Descriptive statistics and correlation analyses were conducted to explore relationships between variables.

RESULTS

We recruited a total of 19 patients, including 14 pediatric patients (mean age 10.9 ± 3.9 years) and 5 adults (mean age 40.0 ± 13.9 years). The most frequent symptoms were gross motor delay and distal more than proximal muscle weakness, which were observed in 14 of 19 patients. The most common non-neuromuscular symptoms were cognitive and respiratory deficits, each seen in 8 of 19 patients. We denoted asymmetric weakness in 2 patients and nonuniform slowing of conduction velocities in 6 patients. Charcot-Marie-Tooth Disease Pediatric Scale (CMTPedS), Pediatric Quality of Life Inventory, and Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scale scores were affected in most patients. We observed a significant positive correlation between neurofilament light chain levels and CMTPedS, but the study was underpowered to observe a correlation between CMTPedS and MRI fat fraction.

DISCUSSION

We obtained baseline clinical and biomarker data in a broad cohort with CMT4J in pediatric and adult patients. Motor delay, muscle weakness, and respiratory and cognitive difficulties were the most common clinical manifestations of CMT4J. Many patients had nerve conduction studies with nonuniform slowing, and 2 had an asymmetric pattern of muscle weakness. We observed that the neurofilament light chain levels correlated with the CMTPedS in the pediatric population. This study showed feasibility of clinical outcomes including CMTPedS in assessment of disease severity in the pediatric patient population and provided baseline characteristics of exploratory biomarkers, neurofilament light chain levels, and muscle MRI fat fraction. The coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic affected some of the visits, resulting in a reduced number of some of the assessments.

Quantitative Foot Muscle Magnetic Resonance Imaging Reliably Measures Disease Progression in Children and Adolescents with Charcot-Marie-Tooth Disease Type 1A

Quantitative muscle fat fraction (FF) responsiveness is lower in younger Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease type 1A (CMT1A) patients with lower baseline calf-level FF. We investigated the practicality, validity, and responsiveness of foot-level FF in this cohort involving 22 CMT1A patients and 14 controls. The mean baseline foot-level FF was 25.9 ± 20.3% in CMT1A patients, and the 365-day FF (n = 15) increased by 2.0 ± 2.4% (p < 0.001 vs controls). Intrinsic foot-level FF demonstrated large responsiveness (12-month standardized response mean (SRM) of 0.86) and correlated with the CMT examination score (ρ = 0.58, P = 0.01). Intrinsic foot-level FF has the potential to be used as a biomarker in future clinical trials involving younger CMT1A patients. ANN NEUROL 2024;96:170-174.

Quantitative MRI outcome measures in CMT1A using automated lower limb muscle segmentation

BACKGROUND

Lower limb muscle magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) obtained fat fraction (FF) can detect disease progression in patients with Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease 1A (CMT1A). However, analysis is time-consuming and requires manual segmentation of lower limb muscles. We aimed to assess the responsiveness, efficiency and accuracy of acquiring FF MRI using an artificial intelligence-enabled automated segmentation technique.

METHODS

We recruited 20 CMT1A patients and 7 controls for assessment at baseline and 12 months. The three-point-Dixon fat water separation technique was used to determine thigh-level and calf-level muscle FF at a single slice using regions of interest defined using Musclesense, a trained artificial neural network for lower limb muscle image segmentation. A quality control (QC) check and correction of the automated segmentations was undertaken by a trained observer.

RESULTS

The QC check took on average 30 seconds per slice to complete. Using QC checked segmentations, the mean calf-level FF increased significantly in CMT1A patients from baseline over an average follow-up of 12.5 months (1.15%±1.77%, paired t-test p=0.016). Standardised response mean (SRM) in patients was 0.65. Without QC checks, the mean FF change between baseline and follow-up, at 1.15%±1.68% (paired t-test p=0.01), was almost identical to that seen in the corrected data, with a similar overall SRM at 0.69.

CONCLUSIONS

Using automated image segmentation for the first time in a longitudinal study in CMT, we have demonstrated that calf FF has similar responsiveness to previously published data, is efficient with minimal time needed for QC checks and is accurate with minimal corrections needed.

Peripheral Nervous System (PNS) Myelin Diseases

This is a review of inherited and acquired causes of human demyelinating neuropathies and a subset of disorders that affect axon-Schwann cell interactions. Nearly all inherited demyelinating neuropathies are caused by mutations in genes that are expressed by myelinating Schwann cells, affecting diverse functions in a cell-autonomous manner. The most common acquired demyelinating neuropathies are Guillain-Barré syndrome and chronic, inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy, both of which are immune-mediated. An additional group of inherited and acquired disorders affect axon-Schwann cell interactions in the nodal region. Overall, these disorders affect the formation of myelin and its maintenance, with superimposed axonal loss that is clinically important.

Clinical practice guidelines for the diagnosis and management of Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease

INTRODUCTION

Charcot-Marie-Tooth (CMT) disease is classified considering the neurophysiological and histological findings, the inheritance pattern and the underlying genetic defect. In recent years, with the advent of next generation sequencing, genetic complexity has increased exponentially, expanding the knowledge about disease pathways, and having an impact in clinical management. The aim of this guide is to offer recommendations for the diagnosis, prognosis, monitoring and treatment of this disease in Spain.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

This consensus guideline has been developed by a multidisciplinary panel encompassing a broad group of professionals including neurologists, neuropediatricians, geneticists, rehabilitators, and orthopaedic surgeons.

RECOMMENDATIONS

The diagnosis is based in the clinical characterization, usually presenting with a common phenotype. It should be followed by an appropriate neurophysiological study that allows for a correct classification, specific recommendations are established for the parameters that should be included. Genetic diagnosis must be approached in sequentially, once the PMP22 duplication has been ruled out if appropriate, a next generation sequencing should be considered taking into account the limitations of the available techniques. To date, there is no pharmacological treatment that modifies the course of the disease, but symptomatic management is important, as are the rehabilitation and orthopaedic considerations. The latter should be initiated early to identify and improve the patient's functional impairments, including individualised exercise guidelines, orthotic adaptation, and assessment of conservative surgeries such as tendon transpositions. The follow-up of patients with CMT is exclusively clinical, ancillary testing are not necessary in routine clinical practice.

Lower limb muscle MRI fat fraction is a responsive outcome measure in CMT X1, 1B and 2A

OBJECTIVE

With potential therapies for many forms of Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease (CMT), responsive outcome measures are urgently needed for clinical trials. Quantitative lower limb MRI demonstrated progressive calf intramuscular fat accumulation in the commonest form, CMT1A with large responsiveness. In this study, we evaluated the responsiveness and validity in the three other common forms, due to variants in GJB1 (CMTX1), MPZ (CMT1B) and MFN2 (CMT2A).

METHODS

22 CMTX1, 21 CMT1B and 21 CMT2A patients and matched controls were assessed at a 1-year interval. Intramuscular fat fraction (FF) was evaluated using three-point Dixon MRI at thigh and calf level along with clinical measures including CMT examination score, clinical strength assessment, CMT-HI and plasma neurofilament light chain.

RESULTS

All patient groups had elevated muscle fat fraction at thigh and calf levels, with highest thigh FF and atrophy in CMT2A. There was moderate correlation between calf muscle FF and clinical measures (CMTESv2 rho = 0.405; p = 0.001, ankle MRC strength rho = -0.481; p < 0.001). Significant annualised progression in calf muscle FF was seen in all patient groups (CMTX1 2.0 ± 2.0%, p < 0.001, CMT1B 1.6 ± 2.1% p = 0.004 and CMT2A 1.6 ± 2.1% p = 0.002). Greatest increase was seen in patients with 10-70% FF at baseline (calf 2.7 ± 2.3%, p < 0.0001 and thigh 1.7 ± 2.1%, p = 0.01).

INTERPRETATION

Our results confirm that calf muscle FF is highly responsive over 12 months in three additional common forms of CMT which together with CMT1A account for 90% of genetically confirmed cases. Calf muscle MRI FF should be a valuable outcome measure in upcoming CMT clinical trials.

Hurler Syndrome Glycosaminoglycans Decrease in Cerebrospinal Fluid without Brain-Targeted Therapy

Novel therapies for Hurler syndrome aim to cross the blood-brain barrier (BBB) to target neurodegeneration by degrading glycosaminoglycans (GAG). BBB penetration has been assumed with decreased cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) GAG, yet little is known about CSF GAG without brain-targeting therapies. We compared pre-transplant CSF GAG in patients who were treatment naïve (n = 19) versus receiving standard non-BBB penetrating enzyme replacement therapy (ERT, n = 12). In the ERT versus treatment naïve groups, CSF GAG was significantly lower across all content assayed, raising questions about using CSF GAG decrements to show BBB penetration. Future studies should compare GAG reduction in standard versus novel therapies. ANN NEUROL 2023;94:1182-1186.

Assessment of whole-exome sequencing results in neurogenetic diseases

Neurogenetic diseases are rare genetic diseases in which neurological findings are prominent. Whole exome sequencing (WES) has led to great advances in the understanding of the causes of neurogenetic diseases. Etiological research ends with the WES method in many patients. This etiological research is called a "diagnostic odyssey" for many families. Here, we present the results of 168 patients who were previously undiagnosed and underwent WES with the suspicion of neurogenetic disease. A total of 168 cases, 94 males and 74 females, with suspected undiagnosed neurogenetic disease were included in the study. We presented the WES results of the patients. The mean age of patients at the time of WES request was 11 years (range 0.25-68 years). Seventy percent (n = 117) of the patients were born from consanguineous marriage. Most of the patients were children (n = 145). Patients were grouped according to age at the time of examination. Patients younger than 18 years of age at the time of examination were classified as children, otherwise adults. Seventy-eight patients had either a pathogenic variant or a likely pathogenic variant so the diagnostic rate for WES in our cohort was %46. Our experience showing the high diagnostic rate of WES, supports its use in undiagnosed neurogenetic diseases. It also affects medical treatment, prognosis and family planning by enabling early diagnosis in patients.

Natural History and Phenotypic Spectrum of GAA-FGF14 Sporadic Late-Onset Cerebellar Ataxia (SCA27B)

BACKGROUND

Heterozygous GAA expansions in the FGF14 gene have been related to autosomal dominant cerebellar ataxia (SCA27B-MIM:620174). Whether they represent a common cause of sporadic late-onset cerebellar ataxia (SLOCA) remains to be established.

OBJECTIVES

To estimate the prevalence, characterize the phenotypic spectrum, identify discriminative features, and model longitudinal progression of SCA27B in a prospective cohort of SLOCA patients.

METHODS

FGF14 expansions screening combined with longitudinal deep-phenotyping in a prospective cohort of 118 SLOCA patients (onset >40 years of age, no family history of cerebellar ataxia) without a definite diagnosis.

RESULTS

Prevalence of SCA27B was 12.7% (15/118). Higher age of onset, higher Spinocerebellar Degeneration Functional Score, presence of vertigo, diplopia, nystagmus, orthostatic hypotension absence, and sensorimotor neuropathy were significantly associated with SCA27B. Ataxia progression was ≈0.4 points per year on the Scale for Assessment and Rating of Ataxia.

CONCLUSIONS

FGF14 expansion is a major cause of SLOCA. Our natural history data will inform future FGF14 clinical trials. © 2023 The Authors. Movement Disorders published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society.

Gene therapy and other novel treatment approaches for Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease

There is still no effective drug treatment available for Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease (CMT). Current management relies on rehabilitation therapy, surgery for skeletal deformities, and symptomatic treatment. The challenge is to find disease-modifying therapies. Several approaches, including gene silencing (by means of ASO, siRNA, shRNA, miRNA, CRISPR-Cas9 editing), to counteract the PMP22 gene overexpression in the most frequent CMT1A type are under investigation. PXT3003 is the compound in the most advanced phase for CMT1A, as a second phase-III trial is ongoing. Gene therapy to substitute defective genes (particularly in recessive forms associated with loss-of-function mutations) or insert novel ones (e.g., NT3 gene) are being developed and tested in animal models and in still exceptional cases have reached the clinical trial phase in humans. Novel treatment approaches are also aimed at developing compounds acting on pathways important for different CMT types. Modulation of the neuregulin pathway determining myelin thickness is promising for both hypo-demyelinating and hypermyelinating neuropathies; intervention on Unfolded Protein Response seems effective for rescuing misfolded myelin proteins such as MPZ in CMT1B. HDAC6 inhibitors improved axonal transport and ameliorated phenotypes in different CMT models. Other potential therapeutic strategies include targeting macrophages, lipid metabolism, and Nav1.8 sodium channel in demyelinating CMT and the P2×7 receptor, which regulates calcium influx into Schwann cells, in CMT1A. Further approaches are aimed at correcting metabolic abnormalities, including the accumulation of sorbitol caused by biallelic mutations in the sorbitol dehydrogenase (SORD) gene and of neurotoxic glycosphingolipids in HSN1.