Gasphasenkatalyse mit atomaren und Cluster-Metall-Ionen: ultimative “Single-Site”-Katalysatoren

Size Effects in Gas-phase C-H Activation

The gas-phase clusters reaction permits addressing fundamental aspects of the challenges related to C-H activation. The size effect plays a key role in the activation processes as it may substantially affect both the reactivity and selectivity. In this paper, we reviewed the size effect related to the hydrocarbon oxidation by early transition metal oxides and main group metal oxides, methane activation mediated by late transition metals. Based on mass-spectrometry experiments in conjunction with quantum chemical calculations, mechanistic discussions were reviewed to present how and why the size greatly regulates the reactivity and product distribution.

Gas-Phase Mechanism of O.- /Ni2+ -Mediated Methane Conversion to Formaldehyde

The gas-phase reaction of NiAl₂ O₄ ⁺ with CH₄ is studied by mass spectrometry in combination with vibrational action spectroscopy and density functional theory (DFT). Two product ions, NiAl₂ O₄ H⁺ and NiAl₂ O₃ H₂ ⁺ , are identified in the mass spectra. The DFT calculations predict that the global minimum-energy isomer of NiAl₂ O₄ ⁺ contains Ni in the +II oxidation state and features a terminal Al-O^.- oxygen radical site. They show that methane can react along two competing pathways leading to formation of either a methyl radical (CH₃ ⋅) or formaldehyde (CH₂ O). Both reactions are initiated by hydrogen atom transfer from methane to the terminal O^.- site, followed by either CH₃ ⋅ loss or CH₃ ⋅ migration to an O^2- site next to the Ni²⁺ center. The CH₃ ⋅ attaches as CH₃ ⁺ to O^2- and its unpaired electron is transferred to the Ni-center reducing it to Ni⁺ . The proposed mechanism is experimentally confirmed by vibrational spectroscopy of the reactant and two different product ions.

Identification of a Two‐Coordinate Iron(I)–Oxalate Complex

Exotic oxidation states of the first‐row transition metals have recently attracted much interest. In order to investigate the oxidation states of a series of iron–oxalate complexes, an aqueous solution of iron(III) nitrate and oxalic acid was studied by infrared free liquid matrix‐assisted laser desorption/ionization as well as ionspray mass spectrometry. Here, we show that iron is not only detected in its common oxidation states +II and +III, but also in its unusual oxidation state +I, detectable in both positive‐ion and in negative‐ion modes, respectively. Vibrational spectra of the gas phase anionic iron oxalate complexes [Fe^III(C₂O₄)₂]⁻, [Fe^II(C₂O₄)CO₂]⁻, and [Fe^I(C₂O₄)]⁻ were measured by means of infrared photodissociation spectroscopy and their structures were assigned by comparison to anharmonic vibrational spectra based on second‐order perturbation theory.

Carbide Dihydrides: Carbonaceous Species Identified in Ta4 + -Mediated Methane Dehydrogenation

The products of methane dehydrogenation by gas‐phase Ta₄⁺ clusters are structurally characterized using infrared multiple photon dissociation (IRMPD) spectroscopy in conjunction with quantum chemical calculations. The obtained spectra of [4Ta,C,2H]⁺ reveal a dominance of vibrational bands of a H₂Ta₄C⁺ carbide dihydride structure over those indicative for a HTa₄CH⁺ carbyne hydride one, as is unambiguously verified by studies employing various methane isotopologues. Because methane dehydrogenation by metal cations M⁺ typically leads to the formation of either MCH₂⁺ carbene or HMCH⁺ carbyne hydride structures, the observation of a H₂MC⁺ carbide dihydride structure implies that it is imperative to consider this often‐neglected class of carbonaceous intermediates in the reaction of metals with hydrocarbons.

Reductive Activation of Small Molecules by Anionic Coinage Metal Atoms and Clusters in the Gas Phase

Metal atoms and clusters exhibit chemical properties that are significantly different or totally absent in comparison to their bulk counterparts. Such peculiarity makes them potential building units for the generation of novel catalysts. Investigations of the gas-phase reactions between size- and charge-selected atoms/clusters and small molecules have provided fundamental insights into their intrinsic reactivity, thus leading to a guiding principle for the rational design of the single-atom and cluster-based catalysts. Especially, recent gas-phase studies have elucidated that small molecules such as O₂ , CO₂ , and CH₃ I can be catalytically activated by negatively-charged atoms/clusters via donation of a partial electronic charge. This Minireview showcases typical examples of such "reductive activation" processes promoted by anions of metal atoms and clusters. Here, we focus on anionic atoms/clusters of coinage metals (Cu, Ag, and Au) owing to the simplicity of their electronic structures. The determination of a correlation between their activation modes and the electronic structures might be helpful for the future development of innovative coinage metal catalysts.

Selective Activation of the C-H Bond in Methane by Single Platinum Atomic Anions

Mass spectrometric analysis of the anionic products of interaction between platinum atomic anions, Pt^- , and methane, CH₄ and CD₄ , in a collision cell shows the preferred generation of [PtCH₄ ]^- and [PtCD₄ ]^- complexes and a low tendency toward dehydrogenation. [PtCH₄ ]^- is shown to be H-Pt-CH₃ ^- by a synergy between anion photoelectron spectroscopy and quantum chemical calculations, implying the rupture of a single C-H bond. The calculated reaction pathway accounts for the observed selective activation of methane by Pt^- . This study presents the first example of methane activation by a single atomic anion.

Thermal Activation of CH4 and H2 as Mediated by the Ruthenium Oxide Cluster Ions [RuOx ]+ (x=1-3): On the Influence of Oxidation States

Thermal gas-phase reactions of the ruthenium-oxide clusters [RuO_x ]⁺ (x=1-3) with methane and dihydrogen have been explored by using FT-ICR mass spectrometry complemented by high-level quantum chemical calculations. For methane activation, as compared to the previously studied [RuO]⁺ /CH₄ couple, the higher oxidized Ru systems give rise to completely different product distributions. [RuO₂ ]⁺ brings about the generations of [Ru,O,C,H₂ ]⁺ /H₂ O, [Ru,O,C]⁺ /H₂ /H₂ O, and [Ru,O,H₂ ]⁺ /CH₂ O, whereas [RuO₃ ]⁺ exhibits a higher selectivity and efficiency in producing formaldehyde and syngas (CO+H₂ ). Regarding the reactions with H₂ , as compared to CH₄ , both [RuO]⁺ and [RuO₂ ]⁺ react similarly inefficiently with oxygen-atom transfer being the main reaction channel; in contrast, [RuO₃ ]⁺ is inert toward dihydrogen. Theoretical analysis reveals that the reduction of the metal center drives the overall oxidation of methane, whereas the back-bonding orbital interactions between the cluster ions and dihydrogen control the H-H bond activation. Furthermore, the reactivity patterns of [RuO_x ]⁺ (x=1-3) with CH₄ and H₂ have been compared with the previously reported results of Group 8 analogues [OsO_x ]⁺ /CH₄ /H₂ (x=1-3) and the [FeO]⁺ /H₂ system. The electronic origins for their distinctly different reaction behaviors have been addressed.

Identification of Active Sites and Structural Characterization of Reactive Ionic Intermediates by Cryogenic Ion Trap Vibrational Spectroscopy

Cryogenic ion trap vibrational spectroscopy paired with quantum chemistry currently represents the most generally applicable approach for the structural investigation of gaseous cluster ions that are not amenable to direct absorption spectroscopy. Here, we give an overview of the most popular variants of infrared action spectroscopy and describe the advantages of using cryogenic ion traps in combination with messenger tagging and vibrational predissociation spectroscopy. We then highlight a few recent studies that apply this technique to identify highly reactive ionic intermediates and to characterize their reactive sites. We conclude by commenting on future challenges and potential developments in the field.

Probing the gas-phase structure of charge-tagged intermediates of a proline catalyzed aldol reaction – vibrational spectroscopy distinguishes oxazolidinone from enamine species

Charge-tagging enables the detection of reaction intermediates which are probed by IRMPD spectroscopy in combination with theory.

Coupling of Methane and Carbon Dioxide Mediated by Diatomic Copper Boride Cations

The use of CH₄ and CO₂ to produce value-added chemicals via direct C-C coupling is a challenging chemistry problem because of the inertness of these two molecules. Herein, mass spectrometric experiments and high-level quantum-chemical calculations have identified the first diatomic species (CuB⁺ ) that can couple CH₄ with CO₂ under thermal collision conditions to produce ketene (H₂ C=C=O), an important intermediate in synthetic chemistry. The order to feed the reactants (CH₄ and CO₂ ) is important and CH₄ should be firstly fed to produce the C₂ product. Molecular-level mechanisms including control of product selectivity have been revealed for coupling of CH₄ with CO₂ under mild conditions.

Metal Cluster Models for Heterogeneous Catalysis: A Matrix-Isolation Perspective

Metal cluster models are of high relevance for establishing new mechanistic concepts for heterogeneous catalysis. The high reactivity and particular selectivity of metal clusters is caused by the wealth of low-lying electronically excited states that are often thermally populated. Thereby the metal clusters are flexible with regard to their electronic structure and can adjust their states to be appropriate for the reaction with a particular substrate. The matrix isolation technique is ideally suited for studying excited state reactivity. The low matrix temperatures (generally 4-40 K) of the noble gas matrix host guarantee that all clusters are in their electronic ground-state (with only a very few exceptions). Electronically excited states can then be selectively populated and their reactivity probed. Unfortunately, a systematic research in this direction has not been made up to date. The purpose of this review is to provide the grounds for a directed approach to understand cluster reactivity through matrix-isolation studies combined with quantum chemical calculations.

Formation of Acetylene in the Reaction of Methane with Iron Carbide Cluster Anions FeC3- under High-Temperature Conditions

The underlying mechanism for non-oxidative methane aromatization remains controversial owing to the lack of experimental evidence for the formation of the first C-C bond. For the first time, the elementary reaction of methane with atomic clusters (FeC₃^- ) under high-temperature conditions to produce C-C coupling products has been characterized by mass spectrometry. With the elevation of temperature from 300 K to 610 K, the production of acetylene, the important intermediate proposed in a monofunctional mechanism of methane aromatization, was significantly enhanced, which can be well-rationalized by quantum chemistry calculations. This study narrows the gap between gas-phase and condensed-phase studies on methane conversion and suggests that the monofunctional mechanism probably operates in non-oxidative methane aromatization.

Size-Dependent Reactivity of Nano-Sized Neutral Manganese Oxide Clusters toward Ethylene

Neutral manganese oxide clusters with the general composition Mn_2 N O_3 N+x (N=2-22; x=-1, 0, 1) with dimensions up to a nanosize were prepared by laser ablation and reacted with C₂ H₄ in a fast flow reactor. The size-dependent reactivity of C₂ H₄ adsorption on these clusters was experimentally identified and the adsorption reactivity decreases generally with an increase of the cluster size. Density functional theory calculations were performed to study the geometrical and electronic structures of the Mn_2 N O_3 N (N=1-6) clusters. The calculated results indicated that the coordination number and the charge distribution of the metal centers are responsible for the experimentally observed size-dependent reactivity. The highly charged Mn atoms with low coordination are preferential to adsorb C₂ H₄ . In contrast, the neutral manganese oxide clusters are completely inert toward the saturated hydrocarbon molecule C₂ H₆ . This work provides new perspectives to design related materials in the separation of hydrocarbon molecules.

Selective C-H Bond Cleavage in Methane by Small Gold Clusters

Methane represents the major constituent of natural gas. It is primarily used only as a source of energy by means of combustion, but could also serve as an abundant hydrocarbon feedstock for high quality chemicals. One of the major challenges in catalysis research nowadays is therefore the development of materials that selectively cleave one of the four C-H bonds of methane and thus make it amenable for further chemical conversion into valuable compounds. By employing infrared spectroscopy and first-principles calculations it is uncovered herein that the interaction of methane with small gold cluster cations leads to selective C-H bond dissociation and the formation of hydrido methyl complexes, H-Au_x⁺ -CH₃ . The distinctive selectivity offered by these gold clusters originates from a fine interplay between the closed-shell nature of the d states and relativistic effects in gold. Such fine balance in fundamental interactions could prove to be a tunable feature in the rational design of a catalyst.

Thermal Methane Activation by the Metal-Free Cluster Cation [Si2 O4 ]

The thermal reaction of methane with the metal-free cluster cation [Si₂ O₄ ]^.+ has been examined by using Fourier transform-ion cyclotron resonance (FT-ICR) mass spectrometry. In addition to generating a methyl radical via hydrogen-atom abstraction, [Si₂ O₄ ]^.+ can selectively oxidize methane to formaldehyde. The mechanisms of these rather efficient reactions have been elucidated by high-level quantum-chemical calculations.

Thermal Methane Activation by [Si2 O5 ].+ and [Si2 O5 H2 ].+ : Reactivity Enhancement by Hydrogenation

The thermal reactions of methane with the oxygen-rich cluster cations [Si₂ O₅ ]^⋅+ and [Si₂ O₅ H₂ ]^⋅+ have been examined using Fourier transform-ion cyclotron resonance (FT-ICR) mass spectrometry in conjunction with state-of-the-art quantum chemical calculations. In contrast to the inertness of [Si₂ O₅ ]^.+ towards methane, the hydrogenated cluster [Si₂ O₅ H₂ ]^.+ brings about hydrogen-atom transfer (HAT) from methane with an efficiency of 28 % relative to the collision rate. The mechanisms of this process have been investigated in detail and the reasons for the striking reactivity difference of the two cluster ions have been revealed.

Generation of Hydroxyl Radicals in the Reaction of Dihydrogen with AuNbO4+ Cluster Cations

A molecular-level insight into the nature of reactive oxygen species involved in dihydrogen (H₂ ) dissociation is of great importance to understand gold catalysis. In this study, laser ablation generated and mass-selected AuNbO₄⁺ oxide cluster cations could dissociate H₂ in an ion-trap reactor. The reaction has been characterized by time-of-flight mass spectrometric experiments and density functional calculations. The lowest energy isomer of AuNbO₄⁺ contains two lattice oxygen (O^2- ) and one superoxide (O₂^.- ) species. The gold atom anchors the H₂ molecule in the first step and then delivers one hydrogen atom to the O^2- ion in H₂ dissociation. At the same time, O₂^.- is reduced into a peroxide unit that can accept the second hydrogen atom of H₂ with the generation of a hydroxyl radical as the main product. In this study, the important roles of the O₂^.- unit in the dissociation of H₂ have been identified.