Origin of the Chemiresistive Response of Ultrathin Films of Conductive Metal–Organic Frameworks

Conductive Framework Materials for Chemiresistive Detection and Differentiation of Toxic Gases

ConspectusSensing complex gaseous mixtures and identifying their composition and concentration have the potential to achieve unprecedented improvements in environmental monitoring, medical diagnostics, industrial safety, and the food/agriculture industry. Electronically transduced chemical sensors capable of recognizing and differentiating specific target gases and transducing these chemical stimuli in a portable electronic device offer an opportunity for impact by bridging the utility of chemical information with global wireless connectivity. Among electronically transduced chemical sensors, chemiresistors stand out as particularly promising due to combined features of low-power requirements, room temperature operation, non-line-of-sight detection, high portability, and exceptional modularity. Relying on changes in resistance of a functional material triggered by variations in the surrounding chemical environment, these devices have achieved part-per-billion sensitivities of analytes by employing conductive polymers, graphene, carbon nanotubes (CNTs), metal oxides, metal nanoparticles, metal dichalcogenides, or MXenes as sensing materials. Despite these tremendous developments, the need for stable, selective, and sensitive chemiresistors demands continued innovation in material design in order to operate in complex mixtures with interferents as well as variations in humidity and temperature.To fill existing gaps in sensing capabilities, conductive metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) and covalent organic frameworks (COFs) have recently emerged as a promising class of materials for chemiresistive sensing. In contrast to previously reported chemiresistors, these materials offer at least three unique features for gas sensing applications: (i) bottom-up synthesis from molecularly precise precursors that allows for strategic control of material-analyte interactions, (ii) intrinsic conductivity that simultaneously facilitates charge transport and signal transduction under low power requirements, and (iii) high surface area that enables the accessibility of abundant active sites and decontamination of gas streams by coordinating to and, sometimes, detoxifying harmful analytes. Through an emphasis on molecular engineering of structure-property relationships in conductive MOFs and COFs, combined with strategic innovations in device integration strategies and device form factor (i.e., the physical dimensions and design of device components), our group has paved the way to demonstrating the multifunctional utility of these materials in the chemiresistive detection of gases and vapors. Backed by spectroscopic assessment of material-analyte interactions, we illustrated how molecular-level features lead to device performance in detection, filtration, and detoxification of gaseous analytes. By merging the bottom-up synthesis of these materials with device integration, we show the versatility and scalability of using these materials in low-power electronic sensing devices. Taken together, our achievements, combined with the progress spearheaded on this class of materials by other researchers, establish conductive MOFs and COFs as promising multifunctional materials for applications in electronically transduced, portable, low-power sensing devices.

Synthesis of Electrical Conductive Metal-Organic Frameworks for Electrochemical Applications

Electrical conductivity is very important property of nanomaterials for using wide range of applications especially energy applications. Metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) are notorious for their low electrical conductivity and less considered for usage in pristine forms. However, the advantages of high surface area, porosity and confined catalytic active sites motivated researchers to improve the conductivity of MOFs. Therefore, 2D electrical conductive MOFs (ECMOF) have been widely synthesized by developing the effective synthetic strategies. In this article, we have summarized the recent trends in developing the 2D ECMOFs, following the summary of potential applications in the various fields with future perspectives.

Metalloporphyrin-Based Metal-Organic Frameworks for the Ultrasensitive Chemiresistive Detection of NO2: Effect of the Central Metal on Tuning the Sensing Performance

The highly sensitive and selective detection of trace hazardous gases at room temperature is very promising for health protection and environmental safety. Herein, chemiresistive sensors for NO2 were fabricated based on self-assembled films of the four metalloporphyrin (MPor)-based metal-organic frameworks PCN-222-M (M = Cu, Ni, Co, Fe) by the quasi-Langmuir-Shäfer method. It is found that the relative responses of the four PCN-222-M films are linearly related to the NO2 concentration, and the PCN-222-Cu possessed an unprecedented high response to NO2 with a sensitivity of 2209% ppm-1 in the 4-20 ppb range and a low limit of detection (LOD) of 0.93 ppb, achieving the best performance reported so far for NO2 detection at room temperature. Meanwhile, PCN-222-Ni showed the fastest recovery among the four PCN-222-M films, which can be used for the rapid detection of NO2. Excellent reproducibility, stability, selectivity, and moisture resistance are shown for both PCN-222-Cu and PCN-222-Ni. Combining the experimental study and density functional theory (DFT) calculation, the essential roles of MPor units and the MPor/Zr6 cluster hybrid material in tuning the Fermi level and the electron transfer between PCN-222-M and NO2 were further proved. These were less considered topics in previous studies on MOFs. This work explores the application of MPor-based MOFs in gas sensing by selecting appropriate MPor units, thus providing guidance for the development of MOF-based chemiresistive sensors.

Two-Dimensional Electrically Conductive Metal-Organic Frameworks as Chemiresistive Sensors

Metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) have emerged as attractive chemical sensing materials due to their exceptionally high porosity and chemical diversity. Nevertheless, the utilization of MOFs in chemiresistive type sensors has been hindered by their inherent limitation in electrical conductivity. The recent emergence of two-dimensional conductive MOFs (2D c-MOFs) has addressed this limitation by offering enhanced electrical conductivity, while still retaining the advantageous properties of MOFs. In particular, c-MOFs have shown promising advantages for the fabrication of sensors capable of operating at room temperature. Thus, active research on gas sensors utilizing c-MOFs is currently underway, focusing on enhancing sensitivity and selectivity. To comprehend the potential of MOFs as chemiresistive sensors for future applications, it is crucial to understand not only the fundamental properties of conductive MOFs but also the state-of-the-art works that contribute to improving their performance. This comprehensive review delves into the distinctive characteristics of 2D c-MOFs as a new class of chemiresistors, providing in-depth insights into their unique sensing properties. Furthermore, we discuss the proposed sensing mechanisms associated with 2D c-MOFs and provide a concise summary of the strategies employed to enhance the sensing performance of 2D c-MOFs. These strategies encompass a range of approaches, including the design of metal nodes and linkers, morphology control, and the synergistic use of composite materials. In addition, the review thoroughly explores the prospects of 2D c-MOFs as chemiresistors and elucidates their remarkable potential for further advancements. The insights presented in this review shed light on future directions and offer valuable opportunities in the chemical sensing research field.

Computational Prediction of Stacking Mode in Conductive Two-Dimensional Metal-Organic Frameworks: An Exploration of Chemical and Electrical Property Changes

Conductive two-dimensional metal-organic frameworks (2D MOFs) have attracted interest as they induce strong charge delocalization and improve charge carrier mobility and concentration. However, characterizing their stacking mode depends on expensive and time-consuming experimental measurements. Here, we construct a potential energy surface (PES) map database for 36 2D MOFs using density functional theory (DFT) for the experimentally synthesized and non-synthesized 2D MOFs to predict their stacking mode. The DFT PES results successfully predict the experimentally synthesized stacking mode with an accuracy of 92.9% and explain the coexistence mechanism of dual stacking modes in a single compound. Furthermore, we analyze the chemical (i.e., host-guest interaction) and electrical (i.e., electronic structure) property changes affected by stacking mode. The DFT results show that the host-guest interaction can be enhanced by the transition from AA to AB stacking, taking H2S gas as a case study. The electronic band structure calculation confirms that as AB stacking displacement increases, the in-plane charge transport pathway is reduced while the out-of-plane charge transport pathway is maintained or even increased. These results indicate that there is a trade-off between chemical and electrical properties in accordance with the stacking mode.

Fine Pore-Structure Engineering by Ligand Conformational Control of Naphthalene Diimide-Based Semiconducting Porous Coordination Polymers for Efficient Chemiresistive Gas Sensing

Exploring new porous coordination polymers (PCPs) that have tunable structure and conductivity is attractive but remains challenging. Herein, fine pore structure engineering by ligand conformation control of naphthalene diimide (NDI)-based semiconducting PCPs with π stacking-dependent conductivity tunability is achieved. The π stacking distances and ligand conformation in these isoreticular PCPs were modulated by employing metal centers with different coordination geometries. As a result, three conjugated PCPs (Co-pyNDI, Ni-pyNDI, and Zn-pyNDI) with varying pore structure and conductivity were obtained. Their crystal structures were determined by three-dimensional electron diffraction. The through-space charge transfer and tunable pore structure in these PCPs result in modulated selectivity and sensitivity in gas sensing. Zn-pyNDI can serve as a room-temperature operable chemiresistive sensor selective to acetone.

Bimetallic Two-Dimensional Metal-Organic Frameworks for the Chemiresistive Detection of Carbon Monoxide

This paper describes the demonstration of a series of heterobimetallic, isoreticular 2D conductive metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) with metallophthalocyanine (MPc, M=Co and Ni) units interconnected by Cu nodes towards low-power chemiresistive sensing of ppm levels of carbon monoxide (CO). Devices achieve a sub-part-per-million (ppm) limit of detection (LOD) of 0.53 ppm toward CO at a low driving voltage of 0.1 V. MPc-based Cu-linked MOFs can continuously detect CO at 50 ppm, the permissible exposure limit required by the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), for multiple exposures, and realize CO detection in air and in humid environment. Diffuse reflectance infrared Fourier transform spectroscopy (DRIFTS), density functional theory (DFT) calculations, and comparison experiments suggest the contribution of Cu nodes to CO binding and the essential role of MPc units in tuning and amplifying the sensing response.

Petkov P, Heine T, Mannsfeld SCB, Feng X, Dong R. Surface-Modified Phthalocyanine-Based Two-Dimensional Conjugated Metal-Organic Framework Films for Polarity-Selective Chemiresistive Sensing

2D conjugated metal-organic frameworks (2D c-MOFs) are emerging as electroactive materials for chemiresistive sensors, but selective sensing with fast response/recovery is a challenge. Phthalocyanine-based Ni2 [MPc(NH)8 ] 2D c-MOF films are presented as active layers for polarity-selective chemiresisitors toward water and volatile organic compounds (VOCs). Surface-hydrophobic modification by grafting aliphatic alkyl chains on 2D c-MOF films decreases diffused analytes into the MOF backbone, resulting in a considerably accelerated recovery progress (from ca. 50 to ca. 10 s) during humidity sensing. Toward VOCs, the sensors deliver a polarity-selective response among alcohols but no signal for low-polarity aprotic hydrocarbons. The octadecyltrimethoxysilane-modified Ni2 [MPc(NH)8 ] based sensor displays high-performance methanol sensing with fast response (36 s)/recovery (13 s) and a detection limit as low as 10 ppm, surpassing reported room-temperature chemiresistors.

Large-area synthesis of nanoscopic catalyst-decorated conductive MOF film using microfluidic-based solution shearing

Conductive metal-organic framework (C-MOF) thin-films have a wide variety of potential applications in the field of electronics, sensors, and energy devices. The immobilization of various functional species within the pores of C-MOFs can further improve the performance and extend the potential applications of C-MOFs thin films. However, developing facile and scalable synthesis of high quality ultra-thin C-MOFs while simultaneously immobilizing functional species within the MOF pores remains challenging. Here, we develop microfluidic channel-embedded solution-shearing (MiCS) for ultra-fast (≤5 mm/s) and large-area synthesis of high quality nanocatalyst-embedded C-MOF thin films with thickness controllability down to tens of nanometers. The MiCS method synthesizes nanoscopic catalyst-embedded C-MOF particles within the microfluidic channels, and simultaneously grows catalyst-embedded C-MOF thin-film uniformly over a large area using solution shearing. The thin film displays high nitrogen dioxide (NO₂) sensing properties at room temperature in air amongst two-dimensional materials, owing to the high surface area and porosity of the ultra-thin C-MOFs, and the catalytic activity of the nanoscopic catalysts embedded in the C-MOFs. Therefore, our method, i.e. MiCS, can provide an efficient way to fabricate highly active and conductive porous materials for various applications.

The immobilization of catalysts within the pores of conductive metal-organic frameworks (C-MOFs) via facile and scalable methodologies remains challenging. Here the authors report a microfluidic channel-embedded solution shearing process that enables the high throughput, large-area, single-step preparation of Pt nanocatalyst-embedded C-MOF thin films.

Beyond Frameworks: Structuring Reticular Materials across Nano-, Meso-, and Bulk Regimes

Reticular materials are of high interest for diverse applications, ranging from catalysis and separation to gas storage and drug delivery. These open, extended frameworks can be tailored to the intended application through crystal-structure design. Implementing these materials in application settings, however, requires structuring beyond their lattices, to interface the functionality at the molecular level effectively with the macroscopic world. To overcome this barrier, efforts in expressing structural control across molecular, nano-, meso-, and bulk regimes is the essential next step. In this Review, we give an overview of recent advances in using self-assembly as well as externally controlled tools to manufacture reticular materials over all the length scales. We predict that major research advances in deploying these two approaches will facilitate the use of reticular materials in addressing major needs of society.