Identification of Structure-Activity Relationships from Screening a Structurally Compact DNA-Encoded Chemical Library

Highly pure DNA-encoded chemical libraries by dual-linker solid-phase synthesis

The first drugs discovered using DNA-encoded chemical library (DEL) screens have entered late-stage clinical development. However, DEL technology as a whole still suffers from poor chemical purity resulting in suboptimal performance. In this work, we report a technique to overcome this issue through self-purifying release of the DEL after magnetic bead-based synthesis. Both the first and last building blocks of each assembled library member were linked to the beads by tethers that could be cleaved by mutually orthogonal chemistry. Sequential cleavage of the first and last tether, with washing in between, ensured that the final library comprises only the fully complete compounds. The outstanding purity attained by this approach enables a direct correlation of chemical display and encoding, allows for an increased chemical reaction scope, and facilitates the use of more diversity elements while achieving greatly improved signal-to-noise ratios in selections.

Discovery and Optimization of WDR5 Inhibitors via Cascade Deoxyribonucleic Acid-Encoded Library Selection Approach

The DNA-encoded library (DEL) is a powerful hit generation tool for chemical biology and drug discovery; however, the optimization of DEL hits remained a daunting challenge for the medicinal chemistry community. In this study, hit compounds targeting the WIN binding domain of WDR5 were discovered by the initial three-cycle linear DEL selection, and their potency was further enhanced by a cascade DEL selection from the focused DEL designed based on the original first run DEL hits. As expected, these new compounds from the second run of focused DEL were more potent WDR5 inhibitors in the protein binding assay confirmed by the off-DNA synthesis. Interestingly, selected inhibitors exhibited good antiproliferative activity in two human acute leukemia cell lines. Taken together, this new cascade DEL selection strategy may have tremendous potential for finding high-affinity leads against WDR5 and provide opportunities to explore and optimize inhibitors for other targets.

Exploiting the Carboxylate-Binding Pocket of β-Lactamase Enzymes Using a Focused DNA-Encoded Chemical Library

β-Lactamase enzymes hydrolyze and thereby provide bacterial resistance to the important β-lactam class of antibiotics. The OXA-48 and NDM-1 β-lactamases cause resistance to the last-resort β-lactams, carbapenems, leading to a serious public health threat. Here, we utilized DNA-encoded chemical library (DECL) technology to discover novel β-lactamase inhibitors. We exploited the β-lactamase enzyme-substrate binding interactions and created a DECL targeting the carboxylate-binding pocket present in all β-lactamases. A library of 106 compounds, each containing a carboxylic acid or a tetrazole as an enzyme recognition element, was designed, constructed, and used to identify OXA-48 and NDM-1 inhibitors with micromolar to nanomolar potency. Further optimization led to NDM-1 inhibitors with increased potencies and biological activities. This work demonstrates that the carboxylate-binding pocket-targeting DECL, designed based on substrate binding information, aids in inhibitor identification and led to the discovery of novel non-β-lactam pharmacophores for the development of β-lactamase inhibitors for enzymes of different structural and mechanistic classes.

Evaluation of the Topology Space of DNA-Encoded Libraries

DNA-encoded libraries (DELs) are widely used in the discovery of drug candidates, and understanding their design principles is critical for accessing better libraries. Most DELs are combinatorial in nature and are synthesized by assembling sets of building blocks in specific topologies. In this study, different aspects of library topology were explored and their effect on DEL properties and chemical diversity was analyzed. We introduce a descriptor for DEL topological assignment (DELTA) and use it to examine the landscape of possible DEL topologies and their coverage in the literature. A generative topographic mapping analysis revealed that the impact of library topology on chemical space coverage is secondary to building block selection. Furthermore, it became apparent that the descriptor used to analyze chemical space dictates how structures cluster, with the effects of topology being apparent when using three-dimensional descriptors but not with common two-dimensional descriptors. This outcome points to potential challenges of attempts to predict DEL productivity based on chemical space analyses alone. While topology is rather inconsequential for defining the chemical space of encoded compounds, it greatly affects possible interactions with target proteins as illustrated in docking studies using NAD/NADP binding proteins as model receptors.

Combining pharmacophore models derived from DNA-encoded chemical libraries with structure-based exploration to predict Tankyrase 1 inhibitors

DNA-encoded chemical libraries (DECLs) interrogate the interactions of a target of interest with vast numbers of molecules. DECLs hence provide abundant information about the chemical ligand space for therapeutic targets, and there is considerable interest in methods for exploiting DECL screening data to predict novel ligands. Here we introduce one such approach and demonstrate its feasibility using the cancer-related poly-(ADP-ribose)transferase tankyrase 1 (TNKS1) as a model target. First, DECL affinity selections resulted in structurally diverse TNKS1 inhibitors with high potency including compound 2 with an IC50 value of 0.8 nM. Additionally, TNKS1 hits from four DECLs were translated into pharmacophore models, which were exploited in combination with docking-based screening to identify TNKS1 ligand candidates in databases of commercially available compounds. This computational strategy afforded TNKS1 inhibitors that are outside the chemical space covered by the DECLs and yielded the drug-like lead compound 12 with an IC50 value of 22 nM. The study further provided insights in the reliability of screening data and the effect of library design on hit compounds. In particular, the study revealed that while in general DECL screening data are in good agreement with off-DNA ligand binding, unpredictable interactions of the DNA-attachment linker with the target protein contribute to the noise in the affinity selection data.

Development of an Automatable Affinity Purification Process for DNA-Encoded Chemistry

DNA-encoded library technologies require high-throughput, compatible, and well automatable platforms for chemistry development, building block rehearsal, and library synthesis. An affinity-based process using Watson-Crick interactions was developed that enables purification of DNA-tagged compounds from complex reaction mixtures. The purification relies on a single-stranded DNA-oligonucleotide, called capture strand, which was covalently coupled to an agarose matrix and to which a DNA-compound conjugate from a DNA-encoded library (DEL) reaction can be reversibly annealed to. The thus-formed DNA duplex tolerated surprisingly stringent washing conditions with multiple solvents to remove excess reactants and reagents. The tolerated solvents included aqueous buffers, aqueous EDTA solutions to remove metal ions, aqueous mixtures of organic solvents, and even pure organic solvents. The purified DNA-conjugate was eluted with aqueous ammonia and could be used for reaction analysis or for instance in DNA-encoded library synthesis. The lab equipment for purification was tailored for automation with open-source hardware and constructed by 3D printing.

Machine Learning on DNA-Encoded Library Count Data Using an Uncertainty-Aware Probabilistic Loss Function

DNA-encoded library (DEL) screening and quantitative structure-activity relationship (QSAR) modeling are two techniques used in drug discovery to find novel small molecules that bind a protein target. Applying QSAR modeling to DEL selection data can facilitate the selection of compounds for off-DNA synthesis and evaluation. Such a combined approach has been done recently by training binary classifiers to learn DEL enrichments of aggregated "disynthons" in order to accommodate the sparse and noisy nature of DEL data. However, a binary classification model cannot distinguish between different levels of enrichment, and information is potentially lost during disynthon aggregation. Here, we demonstrate a regression approach to learning DEL enrichments of individual molecules, using a custom negative-log-likelihood loss function that effectively denoises DEL data and introduces opportunities for visualization of learned structure-activity relationships. Our approach explicitly models the Poisson statistics of the sequencing process used in the DEL experimental workflow under a frequentist view. We illustrate this approach on a DEL dataset of 108,528 compounds screened against carbonic anhydrase (CAIX), and a dataset of 5,655,000 compounds screened against soluble epoxide hydrolase (sEH) and SIRT2. Due to the treatment of uncertainty in the data through the negative-log-likelihood loss used during training, the models can ignore low-confidence outliers. While our approach does not demonstrate a benefit for extrapolation to novel structures, we expect our denoising and visualization pipeline to be useful in identifying structure-activity trends and highly enriched pharmacophores in DEL data. Further, this approach to uncertainty-aware regression modeling is applicable to other sparse or noisy datasets where the nature of stochasticity is known or can be modeled; in particular, the Poisson enrichment ratio metric we use can apply to other settings that compare sequencing count data between two experimental conditions.

Recent advances in DNA-encoded dynamic libraries

The DNA-encoded chemical library (DEL) has emerged as a powerful technology platform in drug discovery and is also gaining momentum in academic research. The rapid development of DNA-/DEL-compatible chemistries has greatly expanded the chemical space accessible to DELs. DEL technology has been widely adopted in the pharmaceutical industry and a number of clinical drug candidates have been identified from DEL selections. Recent innovations have combined DELs with other legacy and emerging techniques. Among them, the DNA-encoded dynamic library (DEDL) introduces DNA encoding into the classic dynamic combinatorial libraries (DCLs) and also integrates the principle of fragment-based drug discovery (FBDD), making DEDL a novel approach with distinct features from static DELs. In this Review, we provide a summary of the recently developed DEDL methods and their applications. Future developments in DEDLs are expected to extend the application scope of DELs to complex biological systems with unique ligand-discovery capabilities.

Reagent-Based Scaffold Diversity for DNA-Encoded Library Design: Solid Phase Synthesis of DNA-Tagged sp3-Rich Heterocycles by SnAP Chemistry

Reactions that require strictly dry conditions are challenging to translate to a DNA-encoded library format. Controlled pore glass solid support-connected DNA oligonucleotide-aldehyde conjugates could be condensed with SnAP reagents and cyclized to various sp³-rich heterocycles. The Boc-group of products provided a handle for product purification, and its facile removal under acidic conditions was tolerated by a chemically stabilized barcode. The reaction provides reagent-based scaffold diversity with functionalities for further library synthesis.

Multiplexed Small-Molecule-Ligand Binding Assays by Affinity Labeling and DNA Sequence Analysis

Small-molecule binding assays to target proteins are a core component of drug discovery and development. While a number of assay formats are available, significant drawbacks still remain in cost, sensitivity, and throughput. To improve assays by capitalizing on the power of DNA sequence analysis, we have developed an assay method that combines DNA encoding with split-and-pool sample handling. The approach involves affinity labeling of DNA-linked ligands to a protein target. Critically, the labeling event assesses ligand binding and enables subsequent pooling of several samples. Application of a purifying selection on the pool for protein-labeled DNAs allows detection of ligand binding by quantification of DNA barcodes. We demonstrate the approach in both ligand displacement and direct binding formats and demonstrate its utility in determination of relative ligand affinity, profiling ligand specificity, and high-throughput small-molecule screening.

High-power screening (HPS) empowered by DNA-encoded libraries

The world is totally dependent on medications. As science progresses, new, better, and cheaper drugs are needed more than ever. The pharmaceutical industry has been predominantly dependent on high-throughput screening (HTS) for the past three decades. Considering that the discovery rate has been relatively constant, can one hope for a much-needed sudden trend uptick? DNA-encoded libraries (DELs) and similar technologies, that have several orders of magnitude more screening power than HTS, and that we propose to group together under the umbrella term of high-power screening (HPS), are very well positioned to do exactly that. HPS also offers novel screening options such as parallel screening, ex vivo and in vivo screening, as well as a new path to druggable alternatives such as proteolysis targeting chimeras (PROTACs). Altogether, HPS unlocks novel powerful drug discovery avenues.

Photoredox-mediated hydroalkylation and hydroarylation of functionalized olefins for DNA-encoded library synthesis

DNA-encoded library (DEL) technology features a time- and cost-effective interrogation format for the discovery of therapeutic candidates in the pharmaceutical industry. To develop DEL platforms, the implementation of water-compatible transformations that facilitate the incorporation of multifunctional building blocks (BBs) with high C(sp3) carbon counts is integral for success. In this report, a decarboxylative-based hydroalkylation of DNA-conjugated trifluoromethyl-substituted alkenes enabled by single-electron transfer (SET) and subsequent hydrogen atom termination through electron donor-acceptor (EDA) complex activation is detailed. In a further photoredox-catalyzed hydroarylation protocol, the coupling of functionalized, electronically unbiased olefins is achieved under air and within minutes of blue light irradiation through the intermediacy of reactive (hetero)aryl radical species with full retention of the DNA tag integrity. Notably, these processes operate under mild reaction conditions, furnishing complex structural scaffolds with a high density of pendant functional groups.

Chemically Stabilized DNA Barcodes for DNA-Encoded Chemistry

DNA‐encoded compound libraries are a widely used small molecule screening technology. One important aim in library design is the coverage of chemical space through structurally diverse molecules. Yet, the chemical reactivity of native DNA barcodes limits the toolbox of reactions for library design. Substituting the chemically vulnerable purines by 7‐deazaadenine, which exhibits tautomerization stability similar to natural adenine with respect to the formation of stable Watson–Crick pairs, yielded ligation‐competent, amplifiable, and readable DNA barcodes for encoded chemistry with enhanced stability against protic acid‐ and metal ion‐promoted depurination. The barcode stability allowed for straightforward translation of 16 exemplary reactions that included isocyanide multicomponent reactions, acid‐promoted Pictet–Spengler and Biginelli reactions, and metal‐promoted pyrazole syntheses on controlled pore glass‐coupled barcodes for diverse DEL design. The Boc protective group of reaction products offered a convenient handle for encoded compound purification.

On the design of lead-like DNA-encoded chemical libraries

DNA-encoded libraries (DELs) are becoming an established technology for finding ligands for protein targets. We have abstracted and analysed libraries from the literature to assess the synthesis strategy, selections of reactions and monomers and their propensity to reveal hits. DELs have led to hit compounds across a range of diverse protein classes. The range of reactions and monomers utilised has been relatively limited and the hits are often higher in molecular weight than might be considered ideal. Considerations for future library designs with reference to chemical diversity and lead-like properties are discussed.

Copper(I/II)-Promoted Diverse Imidazo[1,2-α]pyridine Synthesis on Solid-Phase Bound DNA Oligonucleotides for Encoded Library Design

DNA-encoded libraries designed around heterocyclic scaffolds have proven highly productive in target-based screening. Here, we show the synthesis of imidazopyridines on a controlled pore glass-coupled DNA oligonucleotide for solid phase-initiated encoded library synthesis. The target compounds were synthesized by a variant of the A3 coupling reaction from aminopyridines, alkynes, and aldehydes promoted by copper(I/II) and furnished diverse substituted scaffolds with functionalities for library design. Although proceeding under forcing conditions, it produced minimal DNA damage.

Highly efficient on-DNA amide couplings promoted by micelle forming surfactants for the synthesis of DNA encoded libraries

DNA encoded libraries (DELs) represent powerful new technology for finding small molecule ligands for proteins and are increasingly being applied to hit finding in medicinal chemistry. Crucial to the synthesis of high quality DELs is the identification of chemical reactions for their assembly that proceed with very high conversion across a range of different substrates, under conditions compatible with DNA-tagged substrates. Many current chemistries used in DEL synthesis do not meet this requirement, resulting in libraries of low fidelity. Amide couplings are the most commonly used reaction in synthesis of screening libraries and also in DELs. The ability to carry out highly efficient, widely applicable amide couplings in DEL synthesis would therefore be highly desirable. We report a method for amide coupling using micelle forming surfactants, promoted by a modified linker, that is broadly applicable across a wide range of substrates. Most significantly, this works exceptionally well for coupling of DNA-conjugated carboxylic acids (N-to-C) with amines in solution, a procedure that is currently very inefficient. The optimisation of separate procedures for coupling of DNA-conjugated acids and amines by reagent screening and statistically driven optimisation is described. The generality of the method is illustrated by the application to a wide range of examples with unprecedented levels of conversion. The utility of the (N-to-C) coupling of DNA-conjugated acids in DEL synthesis is illustrated by the three cycle synthesis of a fully DNA-encoded compound by two cycles of coupling of an aminoester, with intermediate ester hydrolysis, followed by capping with an amine. This methodology will be of great utility in the synthesis of high fidelity DELs.

Stereo- and regiodefined DNA-encoded chemical libraries enable efficient tumour-targeting applications

The encoding of chemical compounds with amplifiable DNA tags facilitates the discovery of small-molecule ligands for proteins. To investigate the impact of stereo- and regiochemistry on ligand discovery, we synthesized a DNA-encoded library of 670,752 derivatives based on 2-azido-3-iodophenylpropionic acids. The library was selected against multiple proteins and yielded specific ligands. The selection fingerprints obtained for a set of protein targets of pharmaceutical relevance clearly showed the preferential enrichment of ortho-, meta- or para-regioisomers, which was experimentally verified by affinity measurements in the absence of DNA. The discovered ligands included novel selective enzyme inhibitors and binders to tumour-associated antigens, which enabled conditional chimeric antigen receptor T-cell activation and tumour targeting.

Large screening of DNA-compatible reaction conditions for Suzuki and Sonogashira cross-coupling reactions and for reverse amide bond formation

Progress in DNA-encoded chemical library synthesis and screening crucially relies on the availability of DNA-compatible reactions, which proceed with high yields and excellent purity for a large number of possible building blocks. In the past, experimental conditions have been presented for the execution of Suzuki and Sonogashira cross-coupling reactions on-DNA. In this article, our aim was to optimize Suzuki and Sonogashira reactions, comparing our results to previously published procedures. We have tested the performance of improved conditions using 606 building blocks (including boronic acids, pinacol boranes and terminal alkynes), achieving >70% conversion for 84% of the tested molecules. Moreover, we describe efficient experimental conditions for the on-DNA synthesis of amide bonds, starting from DNA derivatives carrying a carboxylic acid moiety and 300 primary, secondary and aromatic amines, as amide bonds are frequently found in DNA-encoded chemical libraries thanks to their excellent DNA compatibility.

In Vivo Half-Life Extension of BMP1/TLL Metalloproteinase Inhibitors Using Small-Molecule Human Serum Albumin Binders

Reducing the required frequence of drug dosing can improve the adherence of patients to chronic treatments. Hence, drugs with longer in vivo half-lives are highly desirable. One of the most promising approaches to extend the in vivo half-life of drugs is conjugation to human serum albumin (HSA). In this work, we describe the use of AlbuBinder 1, a small-molecule noncovalent HSA binder, to extend the in vivo half-life and pharmacology of small-molecule BMP1/TLL inhibitors in humanized mice (HSA KI/KI). A series of conjugates of AlbuBinder 1 with BMP1/TLL inhibitors were prepared. In particular, conjugate c showed good solubility and a half-life extension of >20-fold versus the parent molecule in the HSA KI/KI mice, reaching half-lives of >48 h with maintained maximal inhibition of plasma BMP1/TLL. The same conjugate showed a half-life of only 3 h in the wild-type mice, suggesting that the half-life extension was principally due to specific interactions with HSA. It is envisioned that conjugation to AlbuBinder 1 should be applicable to a wide range of small molecule or peptide drugs with short half-lives. In this context, AlbuBinders represent a viable alternative to existing half-life extension technologies.

Diversified strategy for the synthesis of DNA-encoded oxindole libraries

DNA-encoded library technology (DELT) employs DNA as a barcode to track the sequence of chemical reactions and enables the design and synthesis of libraries with billions of small molecules through combinatorial expansion. This powerful technology platform has been successfully demonstrated for hit identification and target validation for many types of diseases. As a highly integrated technology platform, DEL is capable of accelerating the translation of synthetic chemistry by using on-DNA compatible reactions or off-DNA scaffold synthesis. Herein, we report the development of a series of novel on-DNA transformations based on oxindole scaffolds for the design and synthesis of diversity-oriented DNA-encoded libraries for screening. Specifically, we have developed 1,3-dipolar cyclizations, cyclopropanations, ring-opening of reactions of aziridines and Claisen–Schmidt condensations to construct diverse oxindole derivatives. The majority of these transformations enable a diversity-oriented synthesis of DNA-encoded oxindole libraries which have been used in the successful hit identification for three protein targets. We have demonstrated that a diversified strategy for DEL synthesis could accelerate the application of synthetic chemistry for drug discovery.

Constructing DNA-encoded oxindole libraries by a diversified strategy.

A Single-Stranded DNA-Encoded Chemical Library Based on a Stereoisomeric Scaffold Enables Ligand Discovery by Modular Assembly of Building Blocks

A versatile and Lipinski-compliant DNA-encoded library (DEL), comprising 366 600 glutamic acid derivatives coupled to oligonucleotides serving as amplifiable identification barcodes is designed, constructed, and characterized. The GB-DEL library, constructed in single-stranded DNA format, allows de novo identification of specific binders against several pharmaceutically relevant proteins. Moreover, hybridization of the single-stranded DEL with a set of known protein ligands of low to medium affinity coupled to a complementary DNA strand results in self-assembled selectable chemical structures, leading to the identification of affinity-matured compounds.

Selection of DNA-Encoded Dynamic Chemical Libraries for Direct Inhibitor Discovery

Dynamic combinatorial libraries (DCLs) is a powerful tool for ligand discovery in biomedical research; however, the application of DCLs has been hampered by their low diversity. Recently, the concept of DNA encoding has been employed in DCLs to create DNA-encoded dynamic libraries (DEDLs); however, all current DEDLs are limited to fragment identification, and a challenging process of fragment linking is required after selection. We report an anchor-directed DEDL approach that can identify full ligand structures from large-scale DEDLs. This method is also able to convert unbiased libraries into focused ones targeting specific protein classes. We demonstrated this method by selecting DEDLs against five proteins, and novel inhibitors were identified for all targets. Notably, several selective BD1/BD2 inhibitors were identified from the selections against bromodomain 4 (BRD4), an important anti-cancer drug target. This work may provide a broadly applicable method for inhibitor discovery.

Comparative evaluation of DNA-encoded chemical selections performed using DNA in single-stranded or double-stranded format

DNA-encoded chemical libraries (DEL) are increasingly being used for the discovery and optimization of small organic ligands to proteins of biological or pharmaceutical interest. The DNA fragments, that serve as amplifiable identification barcodes for individual compounds in the library, are typically used in double-stranded DNA format. To the best of our knowledge, a direct comparison of DEL selections featuring DNA in either single- or double-stranded DNA format has not yet been reported. In this article, we describe a comparative evaluation of selections with two DEL libraries (named GB-DEL and NF-DEL), based on different chemical designs and produced in both single- and double-stranded DNA format. The libraries were selected in identical conditions against multiple protein targets, revealing comparable and reproducible fingerprints for both types of DNA formats. Surprisingly, selections performed with single-stranded DNA barcodes exhibited improved enrichment factors compared to double-stranded DNA. Using high-affinity ligands to carbonic anhydrase IX as benchmarks for selection performance, we observed an improved selectivity for the NF-DEL library (on average 2-fold higher enrichment factors) in favor of single-stranded DNA. The enrichment factors were even higher for the GB-DEL selections (approximately 5-fold), compared to the same library in double-stranded DNA format. Collectively, these results indicate that DEL libraries can conveniently be synthesized and screened in both single- and double-stranded DNA format, but single-stranded DNA barcodes typically yield enhanced enrichment factors.

An overview of DNA-encoded libraries: A versatile tool for drug discovery

DNA-encoded libraries (DELs) are collections of small molecules covalently attached to amplifiable DNA tags carrying unique information about the structure of each library member. A combinatorial approach is used to construct the libraries with iterative DNA encoding steps, facilitating tracking of the synthetic history of the attached compounds by DNA sequencing. Various screening protocols have been developed which allow protein target binders to be selected out of pools containing up to billions of different small molecules. The versatile methodology has allowed identification of numerous biologically active compounds and is now increasingly being adopted as a tool for lead discovery campaigns and identification of chemical probes. A great focus in recent years has been on developing DNA compatible chemistries that expand the structural diversity of the small molecule library members in DELs. This chapter provides an overview of the challenges and accomplishments in DEL technology, reviewing the technological aspects of producing and screening DELs with a perspective on opportunities, limitations, and future directions.

Critical Evaluation of Photo-cross-linking Parameters for the Implementation of Efficient DNA-Encoded Chemical Library Selections

The growing importance of DNA-encoded chemical libraries (DECLs) as tools for the discovery of protein binders has sparked an interest for the development of efficient screening methodologies, capable of discriminating between high- and medium-affinity ligands. Here, we present a systematic investigation of selection methodologies, featuring a library displayed on single-stranded DNA, which could be hybridized to a complementary oligonucleotide carrying a diazirine photoreactive group. Model experiments, performed using ligands of different affinity to carbonic anhydrase IX, revealed a recovery of preferential binders up to 10%, which was mainly limited by the highly reactive nature of carbene intermediates generated during the photo-cross-linking process. Ligands featuring acetazolamide or p-phenylsulfonamide exhibited a higher recovery compared to their counterparts based on 3-sulfamoyl benzoic acid, which had a lower affinity toward the target. A systematic evaluation of experimental parameters revealed conditions that were ideally suited for library screening, which were used for the screening of a combinatorial DECL library, featuring 669 240 combinations of two sets of building blocks. Compared to conventional affinity capture procedures on protein immobilized on solid supports, photo-cross-linking provided a better discrimination of low-affinity CAIX ligands over the background signal and therefore can be used as a tandem methodology with the affinity capture procedures.

Translation of the copper/bipyridine-promoted Petasis reaction to solid phase-coupled DNA for encoded library synthesis

The Petasis three-component reaction gives rise to diverse substituted α-aryl glycines from readily available amines, boronic acids and glyoxalic acid. Thus, this reaction is highly attractive for DNA-encoded small molecule screening library synthesis. The Petasis reaction is for instance promoted by a potentially DNA damaging copper(I)/bipyridine reagent system in dry organic solvents. We found that solid phase-coupled DNA strands tolerated this reagent system at elevated temperature allowing for synthesis of diverse substituted DNA-tagged α-aryl glycines from DNA-conjugated secondary amines.

Design and Construction of a Focused DNA-Encoded Library for Multivalent Chromatin Reader Proteins

Chromatin structure and function, and consequently cellular phenotype, is regulated in part by a network of chromatin-modifying enzymes that place post-translational modifications (PTMs) on histone tails. These marks serve as recruitment sites for other chromatin regulatory complexes that ‘read’ these PTMs. High-quality chemical probes that can block reader functions of proteins involved in chromatin regulation are important tools to improve our understanding of pathways involved in chromatin dynamics. Insight into the intricate system of chromatin PTMs and their context within the epigenome is also therapeutically important as misregulation of this complex system is implicated in numerous human diseases. Using computational methods, along with structure-based knowledge, we have designed and constructed a focused DNA-Encoded Library (DEL) containing approximately 60,000 compounds targeting bi-valent methyl-lysine (Kme) reader domains. Additionally, we have constructed DNA-barcoded control compounds to allow optimization of selection conditions using a model Kme reader domain. We anticipate that this target-class focused approach will serve as a new method for rapid discovery of inhibitors for multivalent chromatin reader domains.

DNA-Encoded Library Screening as Core Platform Technology in Drug Discovery: Its Synthetic Method Development and Applications in DEL Synthesis

DNA-encoded library technology (DELT) was introduced to our medicinal chemistry society more than 20 years ago. The application of DELT in the development of clinical candidates has been actively reported in the literature recently. A few representative examples include RIP1K inhibitors for inflammatory diseases and sEH inhibitors for endothelial dysfunction or abnormal tissue repair, among many others. Here, the authors would like to recall the recent developments in on-DNA synthetic methodologies for DEL construction and to analyze recent examples in the literature of DELT-based drug development efforts pursued in both the academic and industrial sectors. With this perspective, we hope to provide a useful summary of recent DELT-based drug discovery research and to discuss the future scope of DELT in medicinal chemistry.

Optimization of Ligands Using Focused DNA-Encoded Libraries To Develop a Selective, Cell-Permeable CBX8 Chromodomain Inhibitor

Polycomb repressive complex 1 (PRC1) is critical for mediating gene expression during development. Five chromobox (CBX) homolog proteins, CBX2, CBX4, CBX6, CBX7, and CBX8, are incorporated into PRC1 complexes, where they mediate targeting to trimethylated lysine 27 of histone H3 (H3K27me3) via the N-terminal chromodomain (ChD). Individual CBX paralogs have been implicated as drug targets in cancer; however, high similarities in sequence and structure among the CBX ChDs provide a major obstacle in developing selective CBX ChD inhibitors. Here we report the selection of small, focused, DNA-encoded libraries (DELs) against multiple homologous ChDs to identify modifications to a parental ligand that confer both selectivity and potency for the ChD of CBX8. This on-DNA, medicinal chemistry approach enabled the development of SW2_110A, a selective, cell-permeable inhibitor of the CBX8 ChD. SW2_110A binds CBX8 ChD with a K_d of 800 nM, with minimal 5-fold selectivity for CBX8 ChD over all other CBX paralogs in vitro. SW2_110A specifically inhibits the association of CBX8 with chromatin in cells and inhibits the proliferation of THP1 leukemia cells driven by the MLL-AF9 translocation. In THP1 cells, SW2_110A treatment results in a significant decrease in the expression of MLL-AF9 target genes, including HOXA9, validating the previously established role for CBX8 in MLL-AF9 transcriptional activation, and defining the ChD as necessary for this function. The success of SW2_110A provides great promise for the development of highly selective and cell-permeable probes for the full CBX family. In addition, the approach taken provides a proof-of-principle demonstration of how DELs can be used iteratively for optimization of both ligand potency and selectivity.

A Point of Inflection and Reflection on Systems Chemical Biology

For the past several decades, chemical biologists have been leveraging chemical principles for understanding biology, tackling disease, and biomanufacturing, while systems biologists have holistically applied computation and genome-scale experimental tools to the same problems. About a decade ago, the benefit of combining the philosophies of chemical biology with systems biology into systems chemical biology was advocated, with the potential to systematically understand the way small molecules affect biological systems. Recently, there has been an explosion in new technologies that permit massive expansion in the scale of biological experimentation, increase access to more diverse chemical space, and enable powerful computational interpretation of large datasets. Fueled by these rapidly increasing capabilities, systems chemical biology is now at an inflection point, poised to enter a new era of more holistic and integrated scientific discovery. Systems chemical biology is primed to reveal an integrated understanding of fundamental biology and to discover new chemical probes to comprehensively dissect and systematically understand that biology, thereby providing a path to novel strategies for discovering therapeutics, designing drug combinations, avoiding toxicity, and harnessing beneficial polypharmacology. In this Review, we examine the emergence of new capabilities driving us to this inflection point in systems chemical biology, and highlight holistic approaches and opportunities that are arising from integrating chemical biology with a systems-level understanding of the intersection of biology and chemistry.

Beyond protein binding: recent advances in screening DNA-encoded libraries

DNA-encoded library (DEL) screening has emerged as an important method for early stage drug and probe molecule discovery. The vast majority of screens using DELs have been relatively simple binding assays. The library is incubated with a target molecule, which is almost always a protein, and the DNAs that remain associated with the target after thorough washing are amplified and deep sequenced to reveal the chemical structures of the ligands they encode. Recently however, a number of different screening formats have been introduced that demand more than simple binding. These include a format that demands hits exhibit high selectivity for target vs. off-targets, a protocol to screen for enzyme inhibitors and another to identify organocatalysts in a DEL. These and other novel assay formats are reviewed in this article. We also consider some of the most significant remaining challenges in DEL assay development.

Screening of metal ions and organocatalysts on solid support-coupled DNA oligonucleotides guides design of DNA-encoded reactions

DNA-encoded compound libraries are widely used in drug discovery. Screening of catalysts for compatibility with solid phase-coupled DNA sequences guided the selection of encoded reactions, exemplified by a Zn(II)-mediated aza-Diels–Alder reaction.

DNA-encoded compound libraries are a widely used technology for target-based small molecule screening. Generally, these libraries are synthesized by solution phase combinatorial chemistry requiring aqueous solvent mixtures and reactions that are orthogonal to DNA reactivity. Initiating library synthesis with readily available controlled pore glass-coupled DNA barcodes benefits from enhanced DNA stability due to nucleobase protection and choice of dry organic solvents for encoded compound synthesis. We screened the compatibility of solid-phase coupled DNA sequences with 53 metal salts and organic reagents. This screening experiment suggests design of encoded library synthesis. Here, we show the reaction optimization and scope of three sp³-bond containing heterocyclic scaffolds synthesized on controlled pore glass-connected DNA sequences. A ZnCl₂-promoted aza-Diels–Alder reaction with Danishefsky's diene furnished diverse substituted DNA-tagged pyridones, and a phosphoric acid organocatalyst allowed for synthesis of tetrahydroquinolines by the Povarov reaction and pyrimidinones by the Biginelli reaction, respectively. These three reactions caused low levels of DNA depurination and cover broad and only partially overlapping chemical space though using one set of DNA-coupled starting materials.

Isocyanide Multicomponent Reactions on Solid-Phase-Coupled DNA Oligonucleotides for Encoded Library Synthesis

Isocyanide multicomponent reactions play a prominent role in drug discovery. This chemistry has hardly been investigated for compatibility with DNA-encoded combinatorial synthesis. The Ugi, Ugi-azide, and Groebke-Blackburn-Bienaymé reactions are well-tolerated by DNA on the solid phase and show a broad scope. However, an oxadiazole-forming variant of the Ugi reaction caused DNA depurination, requiring a more stable hexathymidine DNA for encoded library synthesis. Cheminformatic analysis revealed that isocyanide multicomponent-reaction-based encoded libraries cover a diverse chemical space.

Synthesis of DNA-coupled isoquinolones and pyrrolidines by solid phase ytterbium- and silver-mediated imine chemistry

DNA-encoded libraries of chemically synthesized compounds are an important small molecule screening technology. The synthesis of encoded compounds in solution is currently restricted to a few DNA-compatible and water-tolerant reactions. Encoded compound synthesis of short DNA-barcodes covalently connected to solid supports benefits from a broad range of choices of organic solvents. Here, we show that this encoded chemistry approach allows for the synthesis of DNA-coupled isoquinolones by an Yb(iii)-mediated Castagnoli-Cushman reaction under anhydrous reaction conditions and for the synthesis of highly substituted pyrrolidines by Ag(i)-mediated 1,3-dipolar azomethine ylide cycloaddition. An encoding scheme for these DNA-barcoded compounds based on a DNA hairpin is demonstrated.

Non-covalent albumin-binding ligands for extending the circulating half-life of small biotherapeutics

Peptides and small protein scaffolds are gaining increasing interest as therapeutics. Similarly to full-length antibodies, they can bind a target with a high binding affinity and specificity while remaining small enough to diffuse into tissues. However, despite their numerous advantages, small biotherapeutics often suffer from a relatively short circulating half-life, thus requiring frequent applications that ultimately restrict their ease of use and user compliance. To overcome this limitation, a large variety of half-life extension strategies have been developed in the last decades. Linkage to ligands that non-covalently bind to albumin, the most abundant serum protein with a circulating half-life of ∼19 days in humans, represents one of the most successful approaches for the generation of long-lasting biotherapeutics with improved pharmacokinetic properties and superior efficacy in the clinic.

Screening of copper and palladium-mediated reactions compatible with DNA-encoded chemical libraries

The construction of DNA-encoded chemical libraries (DECLs) crucially relies on the availability of chemical reactions, which are DNA-compatible and which exhibit high conversion rates for a large number of diverse substrates. In this work, we present our optimization and validation procedures for three copper and palladium-catalyzed reactions (Suzuki cross-coupling, Sonogashira cross-coupling and copper(I)-catalyzed alkyne-azide cycloaddition (CuAAC)), which have been successfully used by our group for the construction of large encoded libraries.

DNA-encoded libraries - an efficient small molecule discovery technology for the biomedical sciences

DNA-encoded compound libraries are a highly attractive technology for the discovery of small molecule protein ligands. These compound collections consist of small molecules covalently connected to individual DNA sequences carrying readable information about the compound structure. DNA-tagging allows for efficient synthesis, handling and interrogation of vast numbers of chemically synthesized, drug-like compounds. They are screened on proteins by an efficient, generic assay based on Darwinian principles of selection. To date, selection of DNA-encoded libraries allowed for the identification of numerous bioactive compounds. Some of these compounds uncovered hitherto unknown allosteric binding sites on target proteins; several compounds proved their value as chemical biology probes unraveling complex biology; and the first examples of clinical candidates that trace their ancestry to a DNA-encoded library were reported. Thus, DNA-encoded libraries proved their value for the biomedical sciences as a generic technology for the identification of bioactive drug-like molecules numerous times. However, large scale experiments showed that even the selection of billions of compounds failed to deliver bioactive compounds for the majority of proteins in an unbiased panel of target proteins. This raises the question of compound library design.

Open-Air Alkylation Reactions in Photoredox-Catalyzed DNA-Encoded Library Synthesis

DNA-encoded library (DEL) technology is a powerful tool commonly used by the pharmaceutical industry for the identification of compounds with affinity to biomolecular targets. Success in this endeavor lies in sampling diverse chemical libraries. However, current DELs tend to be deficient in C(sp³) carbon counts. We report unique solutions to the challenge of increasing both the chemical diversity of these libraries and their C(sp³) carbon counts by merging Ni/photoredox dual catalytic C(sp²)-C(sp³) cross-coupling as well as photoredox-catalyzed radical/polar crossover alkylation protocols with DELs. The successful integration of multiple classes of radical sources enables the rapid incorporation of a diverse set of alkyl fragments.

A DNA-Encoded Library of Chemical Compounds Based on Common Scaffolding Structures Reveals the Impact of Ligand Geometry on Protein Recognition

A DNA-encoded chemical library (DECL) with 1.2 million compounds was synthesized by combinatorial reaction of seven central scaffolds with two sets of 343×492 building blocks. Library screening by affinity capture revealed that for some target proteins, the chemical nature of building blocks dominated the selection results, whereas for other proteins, the central scaffold also crucially contributed to ligand affinity. Molecules based on a 3,5-bis(aminomethyl)benzoic acid core structure were found to bind human serum albumin with a Kd value of 6 nm, while compounds with the same substituents on an equidistant but flexible l-lysine scaffold showed 140-fold lower affinity. A 18 nm tankyrase-1 binder featured l-lysine as linking moiety, while molecules based on d-Lysine or (2S,4S)-amino-l-proline showed no detectable binding to the target. This work suggests that central scaffolds which predispose the orientation of chemical building blocks toward the protein target may enhance the screening productivity of encoded libraries.

DNA-Encoded Chemical Libraries: A Selection System Based on Endowing Organic Compounds with Amplifiable Information

The discovery of organic ligands that bind specifically to proteins is a central problem in chemistry, biology, and the biomedical sciences. The encoding of individual organic molecules with distinctive DNA tags, serving as amplifiable identification bar codes, allows the construction and screening of combinatorial libraries of unprecedented size, thus facilitating the discovery of ligands to many different protein targets. Fundamentally, one links powers of genetics and chemical synthesis. After the initial description of DNA-encoded chemical libraries in 1992, several experimental embodiments of the technology have been reduced to practice. This review provides a historical account of important milestones in the development of DNA-encoded chemical libraries, a survey of relevant ongoing research activities, and a glimpse into the future.

DNA-encoded chemical libraries - achievements and remaining challenges

DNA-encoded chemical libraries (DECLs) are collections of compounds, individually coupled to DNA tags serving as amplifiable identification barcodes. Since individual compounds can be identified by the associated DNA tag, they can be stored as a mixture, allowing the synthesis and screening of combinatorial libraries of unprecedented size, facilitated by the implementation of split-and-pool synthetic procedures or other experimental methodologies. In this review, we briefly present relevant concepts and technologies, which are required for the implementation and interpretation of screening procedures with DNA-encoded chemical libraries. Moreover, we illustrate some success stories, detailing how novel ligands were discovered from encoded libraries. Finally, we critically review what can realistically be achieved with the technology at the present time, highlighting challenges and opportunities for the future.

Robustness of In Vitro Selection Assays of DNA-Encoded Peptidomimetic Ligands to CBX7 and CBX8

The identification of protein ligands from a DNA-encoded library is commonly conducted by an affinity selection assay. These assays are often not validated for robustness, raising questions about selections that fail to identify ligands and the utility of enrichment values for ranking ligand potencies. Here, we report a method for optimizing and utilizing affinity selection assays to identify potent and selective peptidic ligands to the highly related chromodomains of CBX proteins. To optimize affinity selection parameters, statistical analyses (Z' factors) were used to define the ability of selection assay conditions to identify and differentiate ligands of varying affinity. A DNA-encoded positional scanning library of peptidomimetics was constructed around a trimethyllysine-containing parent peptide, and parallel selections against the chromodomains from CBX8 and CBX7 were conducted over three protein concentrations. Relative potencies of off-DNA hit molecules were determined through a fluorescence polarization assay and were consistent with enrichments observed by DNA sequencing of the affinity selection assays. In addition, novel peptide-based ligands were discovered with increased potency and selectivity to the chromodomain of CBX8. The results indicate low DNA tag bias and show that affinity-based in vitro selection assays are sufficiently robust for both ligand discovery and determination of quantitative structure-activity relationships.

Versatile protein recognition by the encoded display of multiple chemical elements on a constant macrocyclic scaffold

In nature, specific antibodies can be generated as a result of an adaptive selection and expansion of lymphocytes with suitable protein binding properties. We attempted to mimic antibody-antigen recognition by displaying multiple chemical diversity elements on a defined macrocyclic scaffold. Encoding of the displayed combinations was achieved using distinctive DNA tags, resulting in a library size of 35,393,112. Specific binders could be isolated against a variety of proteins, including carbonic anhydrase IX, horseradish peroxidase, tankyrase 1, human serum albumin, alpha-1 acid glycoprotein, calmodulin, prostate-specific antigen and tumour necrosis factor. Similar to antibodies, the encoded display of multiple chemical elements on a constant scaffold enabled practical applications, such as fluorescence microscopy procedures or the selective in vivo delivery of payloads to tumours. Furthermore, the versatile structure of the scaffold facilitated the generation of protein-specific chemical probes, as illustrated by photo-crosslinking.