Rigid Cyclic Fluorinated Detergents: Fine-Tuning the Hydrophilic-Lipophilic Balance Controls Self-Assembling and Biochemical Properties

We report herein the synthesis of three detergents bearing a perfluorinated cyclohexyl group connected through a short, hydrogenated spacer (i.e., propyl, butyl, or pentyl) to a β-maltoside polar head that are, respectively, called FCymal-3, FCymal-4, and FCymal-5. Increasing the length of the spacer decreased the critical micellar concentration (CMC), as demonstrated by surface tension (SFT) and isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC), from 5 mM for FCymal-3 to 0.7 mM for FCymal-5. The morphology of the micelles was studied by dynamic light scattering (DLS), analytical ultracentrifugation (AUC), and small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS), indicating heterogeneous rod-like shapes. While micelles of FCymal-3 and -4 have similar hydrodynamic diameters of ∼10 nm, those of FCymal-5 were twice as large. We also investigated the ability of the detergents to solubilize lipid membranes made of 1-palmitoyl-2-oleyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC). Molecular modeling indicated that the FCymal detergents generate disorder in lipid bilayers, with FCymal-3 being inserted more deeply into bilayers than FCymal-4 and -5. This was experimentally confirmed using POPC vesicles that were completely solubilized within 2 h with FCymal-3, whereas FCymal-5 required >8 h. A similar trend was noticed for the direct extraction of membrane proteins from E. coli membranes, with FCymal-3 being more potent than FCymal-5. An opposite trend was observed in terms of stabilization of the two model membrane proteins bacteriorhodopsin (bR) and SpNOX. In all three FCymal detergents, bR was stable for at least 2 months with no signs of aggregation. However, while the structural integrity of bR was fully preserved in FCymal-4 and -5, minor bleaching was observed in FCymal-3. Similarly, SpNOX exhibited the least activity in FCymal-3 and the highest activity in FCymal-5. By combining solubilizing and stabilizing potency, FCymal detergents push forward our expectations of the usefulness of fluorinated detergents for handling and investigating membrane proteins.

Trends in the Diversification of the Detergentome

Detergents are amphiphilic molecules that serve as enabling steps for today's world applications. The increasing diversity of the detergentome is key to applications enabled by detergent science. Regardless of the application, the optimal design of detergents is determined empirically, which leads to failed preparations, and raising costs. To facilitate project planning, here we review synthesis strategies that drive the diversification of the detergentome. Synthesis strategies relevant for industrial and academic applications include linear, modular, combinatorial, bio-based, and metric-assisted detergent synthesis. Scopes and limitations of individual synthesis strategies in context with industrial product development and academic research are discussed. Furthermore, when designing detergents, the selection of molecular building blocks, i. e., head, linker, tail, is as important as the employed synthesis strategy. To facilitate the design of safe-to-use and tailor-made detergents, we provide an overview of established head, linker, and tail groups and highlight selected scopes and limitations for applications. It becomes apparent that most recent contributions to the increasing chemical diversity of detergent building blocks originate from the development of detergents for membrane protein studies. The overview of synthesis strategies and molecular blocks will bring us closer to the ability to predictably design and synthesize optimal detergents for challenging future applications.

Deciphering the Mechanistic Basis for Perfluoroalkyl-Protein Interactions

Although rarely used in nature, fluorine has emerged as an important elemental ingredient in the design of proteins with altered folding, stability, oligomerization propensities, and bioactivity. Adding to the molecular modification toolbox, here we report the ability of privileged perfluorinated amphiphiles to noncovalently decorate proteins to alter their conformational plasticity and potentiate their dispersion into fluorous phases. Employing a complementary suite of biophysical, in-silico and in-vitro approaches, we establish structure-activity relationships defining these phenomena and investigate their impact on protein structural dynamics and intracellular trafficking. Notably, we show that the lead compound, perfluorononanoic acid, is 106 times more potent in inducing non-native protein secondary structure in select proteins than is the well-known helix inducer trifluoroethanol, and also significantly enhances the cellular uptake of complexed proteins. These findings could advance the rational design of fluorinated proteins, inform on potential modes of toxicity for perfluoroalkyl substances, and guide the development of fluorine-modified biologics with desirable functional properties for drug discovery and delivery applications.

Zwitterionic fluorinated detergents: From design to membrane protein applications

We report herein the synthesis of zwitterionic sulfobetaine (SB) and dimethylamine oxide (AO) detergents whose alkyl chain is made of either a perfluorohexyl (F₆H₃) or a perfluoropentyl (F₅H₅) group linked to a hydrogenated spacer arm. In aqueous solution, the critical micellar concentrations (CMCs) measured by surface tensiometry (SFT) and isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) were found in the millimolar range (1.3-2.4 mM). The morphologies of the aggregates were evaluated by dynamic light scattering (DLS), analytical ultracentrifugation (AUC), small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS), and transmission electron microscopy (TEM), demonstrating that the two perfluoropentyl derivatives formed small micelles less than 10 nm in diameter, whereas the perfluorohexyl derivatives formed larger and more heterogeneous micelles. The two SB detergents were able to solubilize synthetic lipid vesicles in a few hours; by contrast, the perfluoropentyl AO induced much faster solubilization, whereas the perfluorohexyl AO did not show any solubilization. All detergents were tested for their abilities to stabilize three membrane proteins, namely, bacteriorhodopsin (bR), the Bacillus subtilis ABC transporter BmrA, and the Streptococcus pneumoniae enzyme SpNOX. The SB detergents outperformed the AO derivatives as well as their hydrogenated analogs in stabilizing these proteins. Among the four new compounds, F₅H₅SB combines many desirable properties for membrane-protein study, as it is a powerful yet gentle detergent.

Determination of the critical micelle concentration of surfactants using fluorescence strategies

The increasing importance of surfactants in various fields has led to growing interest in the comprehensive characterization of surfactants. The critical micelle concentration (CMC), the most fundamental property of surfactants, is a parameter that must be measured. In particular, with the continuous expansion of the molecular structure of surfactants, numerous novel amphiphilic molecules have been developed that are capable of forming ordered aggregates in various solvent systems. Fluorescence spectroscopy, based on the differences in fluorescence intensity and wavelength of the fluorescent probe in the solvent phase and micellar phase, can sensitively detect the CMC of surfactants. This review aims to summarize the various fluorescence methods used to determine the CMC, including aggregation-induced emission (AIE), excimer formation, intramolecular charge transfer (ICT), and other miscellaneous strategies. The difficulties and limitations in the CMC determination process are also described. Further suggestions are provided to guide the existing fluorescence probes and the corresponding fluorescence methods to detect critical aggregation concentrations of amphiphilic molecules.

Chaperones Skp and SurA dynamically expand unfolded OmpX and synergistically disassemble oligomeric aggregates

Outer membrane proteins (OMPs) are crucial for the survival of bacteria. The two chaperones 17-kilodalton protein (Skp) and survival factor A (SurA) play key roles in OMP maturation by keeping unfolded OMP proteins soluble in the periplasm. However, their functionalities are incompletely understood. Here, we establish connections between structural and energetic features employed by the two chaperones when interacting with unfolded OmpX. We find that expansion, accompanied with fast polypeptide chain reconfiguration, prevents unfolded OmpX from misfolding and aggregating. Moreover, chaperone interaction with unfolded OmpX is thermodynamically calibrated, allowing for a fine-tuned association of chaperones with OMPs in the adenosine triphosphate-depleted periplasm. We further discovered that Skp and SurA act together as disaggregases and are able to disassemble oligomeric OMP aggregates, revealing remarkable functionalities of this periplasmic chaperone system.

Periplasmic chaperones 17-kilodalton protein (Skp) and survival factor A (SurA) are essential players in outer membrane protein (OMP) biogenesis. They prevent unfolded OMPs from misfolding during their passage through the periplasmic space and aid in the disassembly of OMP aggregates under cellular stress conditions. However, functionally important links between interaction mechanisms, structural dynamics, and energetics that underpin both Skp and SurA associations with OMPs have remained largely unresolved. Here, using single-molecule fluorescence spectroscopy, we dissect the conformational dynamics and thermodynamics of Skp and SurA binding to unfolded OmpX and explore their disaggregase activities. We show that both chaperones expand unfolded OmpX distinctly and induce microsecond chain reconfigurations in the client OMP structure. We further reveal that Skp and SurA bind their substrate in a fine-tuned thermodynamic process via enthalpy–entropy compensation. Finally, we observed synergistic activity of both chaperones in the disaggregation of oligomeric OmpX aggregates. Our findings provide an intimate view into the multifaceted functionalities of Skp and SurA and the fine-tuned balance between conformational flexibility and underlying energetics in aiding chaperone action during OMP biogenesis.

Interaction of human erythrocyte catalase with air-water interface in cryoEM

One of the key goals in single-particle cryo-microscopy is to obtain a uniform distribution of particle orientations, so that the three-dimensional structure has isotropic resolution in Fourier space. A common problem arises from the interaction of protein molecules with the air-water interface that exists on both surfaces of the thin film of liquid that is formed prior to plunge-freezing into liquid ethane. Some proteins and other macromolecular complexes are disrupted by interaction with the air-water interface. Other proteins or macromolecules either become concentrated through their interaction with the interface or are excluded because they bind strongly to some other part of the grid or the filter paper used in blotting. In this paper, the interaction of human erythrocyte catalase with the air-water interface is investigated and minimized by the addition of certain detergents. Detergents can form an amphipathic monolayer at the air-water interface that creates a barrier and leaves the molecules free to adopt a variety of orientations, thus facilitating the 3D structure determination. These results suggest that further characterization and development of detergents for cryo-microscopy plunge-freezing would be useful.

Influence of Methylene Fluorination and Chain Length on the Hydration Shell Structure and Thermodynamics of Linear Diols

The interplay between the local hydration shell structure, the length of hydrophobic solutes, and their identity (perfluorinated or not) remains poorly understood. We address this issue by combining Raman-multivariate curve resolution (Raman-MCR) spectroscopy, simulation, and quantum-mechanical calculations to quantify the thermodynamics and the first principle interactions behind the formation of defects in the hydration shell of alkyl-diol and perfluoroalkyl-diol chains. The hydration shell of the fluorinated diols contains substantially more defects than that of the nonfluorinated diols; these defects are water hydroxy groups that do not donate hydrogen bonds and which either point to the solute (radial-dangling OH) or not (nonradial-dangling OH). The number of radial-dangling OH defects per carbon decreases for longer chains and toward the interior of the fluorinated diols, mainly due to less favorable electrostatics and exchange interactions; nonradial-dangling OH defects per carbon increase with chain length. In contrast, the hydration shell of the nonfluorinated diols only contains radial-dangling defects, which become more abundant toward the center of the chain and for larger chains, predominantly because of more favorable dispersion interactions. These results have implications for how the folding of macromolecules, ligand binding to biomacromolecules, and chemical reactions at water-oil interfaces could be modified through the introduction of fluorinated groups or solvents.

Self-Assembly of Protein-Containing Lipid-Bilayer Nanodiscs from Small-Molecule Amphiphiles

When membrane proteins are removed from their natural environment, the quality of the membrane-solubilizing agent used is critical for preserving their native structures and functions. Nanodiscs that retain a lipid-bilayer core around membrane proteins have attracted great attention because they offer a much more native-like environment than detergent micelles. Here, two small-molecule amphiphiles with diglucose headgroups and either a hydrocarbon or a fluorocarbon hydrophobic chain are shown to directly assemble lipids and membrane proteins to form native nanodiscs rather than mixed micelles. Self-assembly of nanodiscs of increasing complexity from both defined, artificial vesicles as well as complex, cellular membranes is demonstrated. A detailed investigation of bilayer integrity and membrane-protein activity in these nanodiscs reveals gentle effects on the encapsulated bilayer core. The fluorinated amphiphile appears particularly promising because its lipophobicity results in gentle, non-perturbing interactions with the nanoscale lipid bilayer. A sequential model of nanodisc self-assembly is proposed that proceeds through perforation of the original membrane followed by saturation and complete solubilization of the bilayer. On this basis, pseudophase diagrams are established for mixtures of lipids and nanodisc-forming diglucoside amphiphiles, and the latter are used for the extraction of a broad range of membrane proteins from cellular membranes.

Glucose-Based Fluorinated Surfactants as Additives for the Crystallization of Membrane Proteins: Synthesis and Preliminary Physical-Chemical and Biochemical Characterization

We report herein the synthesis of a series of fluorinated surfactants with a glucose moiety as a polar head group and whose alkyl chain was varied in length and in fluorine/hydrogen ratio. They were synthesized in two or four steps in 20 to 50% overall yields allowing gram-scale synthesis. Their solubility in water is between 0.2 and 13.8 g/L, which indicates low water solubility. Two derivatives of the series were found to form micelles in water at ∼11 mM. Their hydrophilic-lipophilic balance was determined both by Griffin's and Davies' methods; they may exhibit a "harsh" character toward membrane proteins. This, combined with their low water solubility, suggest that they could advantageously be used in detergent mixtures containing a "mild" detergent. Finally, the potency of one of the derivatives, F₃H₅-β-Glu, to act as an additive for the crystallization of AcrB was evaluated in detergent mixtures with n-dodecyl-β-d-maltopyranoside (DDM). Among the six crystallization conditions investigated, adding F₃H₅-β-Glu improved the crystallization for three of them, as compared to control drops without additives. Moreover, preliminary tests with other compounds of the series showed that none of them hampered crystallization and suggested improvement for three of them. These novel glucose-based fluorinated detergents should be regarded as potential additives that could be included in screening kits used in crystallization.

Maltose-bis(hydroxymethyl)phenol (MBPs) and Maltose-tris(hydroxymethyl)phenol (MTPs) Amphiphiles for Membrane Protein Stability

Membrane protein structures provide a fundamental understanding of their molecular actions and are of importance for drug development. Detergents are widely used to solubilize, stabilize, and crystallize membrane proteins, but membrane proteins solubilized in conventional detergents are prone to denaturation and aggregation. Thus, developing novel detergents with enhanced efficacy for protein stabilization remains important. We report herein the design and synthesis of a class of phenol-derived maltoside detergents. Using two different linkers, we prepared two sets of new detergents, designated maltose-bis(hydroxymethyl)phenol (MBPs) and maltose-tris(hydroxymethyl)phenol (MTPs). The evaluation of these detergents with three transporters and two G-protein coupled receptors allowed us to identify a couple of new detergents (MBP-C9 and MTP-C12) that consistently conferred enhanced stability to all tested proteins compared to a gold standard detergent (DDM). Furthermore, the data analysis based on the detergent structures provides key detergent features responsible for membrane protein stabilization that together will facilitate the future design of novel detergents.

Comparison of functionality and structural stability of bacteriorhodopsin reconstituted in partially fluorinated dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine liposomes with different perfluoroalkyl chain lengths

Amphiphilic molecules with one or more perfluoroalkyl groups (Rf, C_nF_2n+1), which show peculiar interfacial properties, are attracting much attention in membrane protein science. We recently have developed a partially fluorinated dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC) with a perfluorobutyl group in the hydrophobic chain terminal (F4-DMPC) and demonstrated that F4-DMPC is a promising material for incorporating membrane proteins. Moreover, we have found out that membrane properties of a series of partially fluorinated DMPCs with different Rf chain lengths (Fn-DMPCs) vary in a significant Rf chain length-dependent manner. In the present study, structural and functional properties of a membrane protein bacteriorhodopsin (bR) in the Fn-DMPC (n = 4, 6, and 8) membranes (bR/Fn-DMPC) are investigated using several physicochemical techniques. Regardless of the Rf chain lengths, bR/Fn-DMPCs retain native-like structural and functional properties at 30 °C, unlike bR molecules in DMPC vesicles. In particular, bR/F6-DMPC, which is in the fluid phase at 30 °C, shows flash-induced transient absorption changes very similar to the native purple membrane (PM) and very high thermal stability of bR trimers comparable to the PM. Structural and functional properties of bR/Fn-DMPCs are discussed compared to the PM and bR/DMPC.

Cryo-EM grid optimization for membrane proteins

Cryo-EM grid preparation is an important bottleneck in protein structure determination, especially for membrane proteins, typically requiring screening of a large number of conditions. We systematically investigated the effects of buffer components, blotting conditions and grid types on the outcome of grid preparation of five different membrane protein samples. Aggregation was the most common type of problem which was addressed by changing detergents, salt concentration or reconstitution of proteins into nanodiscs or amphipols. We show that the optimal concentration of detergent is between 0.05 and 0.4% and that the presence of a low concentration of detergent with a high critical micellar concentration protects the proteins from denaturation at the air-water interface. Furthermore, we discuss the strategies for achieving an adequate ice thickness, particle coverage and orientation distribution on free ice and on support films. Our findings provide a clear roadmap for comprehensive screening of conditions for cryo-EM grid preparation of membrane proteins.

•

Cryo-EM grid optimization is a limiting factor in protein structure determination

•

Membrane proteins require additional optimization of parameters such as surfactants

•

Aggregation and intactness of proteins depend on detergent and salt concentrations

•

Support films can help preserve protein intactness and improve particle coverage

Synthesis and application of non-bioaccumulable fluorinated surfactants: a review

Abstract

Due to negative effects of conventional fluorinated surfactants with long perfluorocarbon chain (CxF2x+ 1, x≥7) like perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA) and perfluorooctane sulfonate (PFOS), these conventional long perfluorocarbon chain surfactants have been restricted in many industrial applications. Nowadays, their potential non-bioaccumulable alternatives have been developed to meet the requirements of environmental sustainable development. In this paper, the recent advances of potential non-bioaccumulable fluorinated surfactants with different fluorocarbon chain structures, including the short perfluorocarbon chain, the branched fluorocarbon chain, and the fluorocarbon chain with weak points, are reviewed from the aspects of synthesis processes, properties, and structure-activity relationships. And their applications in emulsion polymerization of fluorinated olefins, handling membrane proteins, and leather manufacture also are summarized. Furthermore, the challenges embedded in the current non-bioaccumulable fluorinated surfactants are also highlighted and discussed with the hope to provide a valuable reference for the prosperous development of fluorinated surfactants.

Graphical abstract

Maltose-Based Fluorinated Surfactants for Membrane-Protein Extraction and Stabilization

Two new surfactants, F₅OM and F₅DM, were designed as partially fluorinated analogues of n-dodecyl-β-D-maltoside (DDM). The micellization properties and the morphologies of the aggregates formed by the two surfactants in water and phosphate buffer were evaluated by NMR spectroscopy, surface tension measurement, isothermal titration calorimetry, dynamic light scattering, small-angle X-ray scattering, and analytical ultracentrifugation. As expected, the critical micellar concentration (cmc) was found to decrease with chain length of the fluorinated tail from 2.1-2.5 mM for F₅OM to 0.3-0.5 mM for F₅DM, and micellization was mainly entropy-driven at 25 °C. Close to their respective cmc, the micelle sizes were similar for both surfactants, that is, 7 and 13 nm for F₅OM and F₅DM, respectively, and both increased with concentration forming 4 nm diameter rods with maximum dimensions of 50 and 70 nm, respectively, at a surfactant concentration of ∼30 mM. The surfactants were found to readily solubilize lipid vesicles and extract membrane proteins directly from Escherichia coli membranes. They were found more efficient than the commercial fluorinated detergent F₆H₂OM over a broad range of concentrations (1-10 mM) and even better than DDM at low concentrations (1-5 mM). When transferred into the two new surfactants, the thermal stability of the proteins bacteriorhodopsin (bR) and FhuA was higher than in the presence of their solubilization detergents and similar to that in DDM; furthermore, bR was stable over several months. The membrane enzymes SpNOX and BmrA were not as active as in DDM micelles but similarly active as in F₆OM. Together, these findings indicate both extracting and stabilizing properties of the new maltose-based fluorinated surfactants, making them promising tools in MP applications.

Improving Immunoassay Performance with Cleavable Blocking of Microarrays

Among the key issues that are commonly associated with the development of microarray-based assays are nonspecific binding and diffusion constraints. Here we present a novel strategy addressing both of these challenges simultaneously. The essence of the method consists in blocking the microarray surface with a blocking agent containing a perfluoroalkyl chain and a disulfide linker. The resulting surface is hydrophobic, and no immiscible liquid layer remains on it upon cyclically draining and replenishing the sample solution, ensuring an efficient mass transfer of an analyte onto a microarray. Prior to the signal detection procedure, disulfide bonds are chemically cleaved, and the perfluoroalkyl chains are removed from the microarray surface along with nonspecifically adsorbed proteins, resulting in extremely low background. Using conventional fluorescent detection, we show a 30-fold increase in signal/background ratio compared to a common epoxy-modified glass substrate. The combination of this technique with magnetic beads detection results in a simple and ultrasensitive cholera toxin (CT) immunoassay. The limit of detection (LOD) is 1 fM, which is achieved with an analyte binding time of 1 h. Efficient mass transfer provides highly sensitive detection of whole virus particles despite their low diffusion coefficient. The achieved LOD for vaccinia virus is 10⁴ particles in 1 mL of sample. Finally, we have performed for the first time the simultaneous detection of whole virus and CT protein biomarker in a single assay. The developed technique can be used for multiplex detection of trace amounts of pathogens of various natures.

New Malonate-Derived Tetraglucoside Detergents for Membrane Protein Stability

Membrane proteins are widely studied in detergent micelles, a membrane-mimetic system formed by amphiphilic compounds. However, classical detergents have serious limitations in their utility, particularly for unstable proteins such as eukaryotic membrane proteins and membrane protein complexes, and thus, there is an unmet need for novel amphiphiles with enhanced ability to stabilize membrane proteins. Here, we developed a new class of malonate-derived detergents with four glucosides, designated malonate-derived tetra-glucosides (MTGs), and compared these new detergents with previously reported octyl glucose neopentyl glycol (OGNG) and n-dodecyl-β-d-maltoside (DDM). When tested with two G-protein coupled receptors (GPCRs) and three transporters, a couple of MTGs consistently conferred enhanced stability to all tested proteins compared to DDM and OGNG. As a result of favorable behaviors for a range of membrane proteins, these MTGs have substantial potential for membrane protein research. This study additionally provides a new detergent design principle based on the effect of a polar functional group (i.e., ether) on protein stability depending on its position in the detergent scaffold.

Interaction of phospholipid vesicles with gemini surfactants of different lysine spacer lengths

Peptide surfactants have shown many potential applications in biology and medicine; however, the mechanism of their interactions with biomembranes is still unclear. This work has studied the interactions of cationic peptide gemini surfactants based on lysine spacers (12-(Lys)_n-12, n = 2, 4, and 6) with model biological membranes, which are represented by the vesicles separately formed by zwitterionic unsaturated phospholipid 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DOPC), anionic unsaturated phospholipid 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phospho-(1'-rac-glycerol) (DOPG, sodium salt) and the DOPC/DOPG (1 : 1) mixture. The experiment results show that the presence of negatively charged DOPG slightly affects the interaction manners of 12-(Lys)_n-12 with the vesicles, while the interaction of 12-(Lys)₂-12 with the phospholipid vesicles is significantly different from that of 12-(Lys)₄-12 and 12-(Lys)₆-12 with the vesicles. The binding strength decreases in the order of 12-(Lys)₄-12 > 12-(Lys)₆-12 > 12-(Lys)₂-12. The 12-(Lys)₄-12 surfactant solubilizes the DOPC vesicles, and makes the DOPC molecules join the surfactant stiff fibers and changes them into long and flexible wormlike micelles, while the 12-(Lys)₆-12 and 12-(Lys)₂-12 aggregates are disassembled by the DOPC vesicles, and the surfactant molecules join the DOPC vesicles and convert the unilamellar vesicles into multilamellar vesicles. This work should be helpful in understanding the interaction of peptide surfactants with phospholipid membranes.

1,3,5-Triazine-Cored Maltoside Amphiphiles for Membrane Protein Extraction and Stabilization

Despite their major biological and pharmacological significance, the structural and functional study of membrane proteins remains a significant challenge. A main issue is the isolation of these proteins in a stable and functional state from native lipid membranes. Detergents are amphiphilic compounds widely used to extract membrane proteins from the native membranes and maintain them in a stable form during downstream analysis. However, due to limitations of conventional detergents, it is essential to develop novel amphiphiles with optimal properties for protein stability in order to advance membrane protein research. Here we designed and synthesized 1,3,5-triazine-cored dimaltoside amphiphiles derived from cyanuric chloride. By introducing variations in the alkyl chain linkage (ether/thioether) and an amine-functionalized diol linker (serinol/diethanolamine), we prepared two sets of 1,3,5-triazine-based detergents. When tested with several model membrane proteins, these agents showed remarkable efficacy in stabilizing three transporters and two G protein-coupled receptors. Detergent behavior substantially varied depending on the detergent structural variation, allowing us to explore detergent structure-property-efficacy relationships. The 1,3,5-triazine-based detergents introduced here have significant potential for membrane protein study as a consequence of their structural diversity and universal stabilization efficacy for several membrane proteins.

Hybrid Double-Chain Maltose-Based Detergents: Synthesis and Colloidal and Biochemical Evaluation

Four hybrid double-chain surfactants with a maltose polar head were synthesized. The apolar domain consists of a hydrogenated chain, and a partially fluorinated chain made of a propyl hydrogenated spacer terminated by a perfluorinated core of various lengths. Their water solubility was found to be lower than 1 g/L irrespective of the length of both chains. The self-assembling properties of pure hybrids in water were studied by dynamic light scattering and transmission electron microscopy, which revealed the formation of two populations of aggregates with diameters of 8-50 nm and 80-300 nm. When mixed with the classical detergent n-dodecylmaltoside (DDM), the four hybrids were well soluble and formed small mixed micelles. DDM/hybrid mixtures were further evaluated for the extraction of the full-length, wild-type human GPCR adenosine receptor (A_2AR), and the bacterial transporter AcrB. The solubilization of A_2AR showed extraction efficiencies ranging from 40 to 70%, while that of AcrB reached 60-90%. Finally, three of the hybrids exhibited significant thermostabilization when present as additives. The derivative with a C₁₂-hydrogenated chain and a C₄F₉-fluorinated chain emerged as the most potent additive exhibiting both good extraction yields of A_2AR and AcrB and thermostabilization of A_2AR by ∼7 °C.

Nitrone-Trolox conjugate as an inhibitor of lipid oxidation: Towards synergistic antioxidant effects

Free radical scavengers like α-phenyl-N-tert-butylnitrone (PBN) and 6-hydroxy-2,5,7,8-tetramethylchroman-2-carboxylic acid (Trolox) have been widely used as protective agents in various biomimetic and biological models. A series of three amphiphilic Trolox and PBN derivatives have been designed by adding to those molecules a perfluorinated chain as well as a sugar group in order to render them amphiphilic. In this work, we have studied the interactions between these derivatives and lipid membranes to understand how they influence their ability to prevent membrane lipid oxidation. We showed the derivatives better inhibited the AAPH-induced oxidation of 1,2-dilinoleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DLiPC) small unilamellar vesicles (SUVs) than the parent compounds. One of the derivatives, bearing both PBN and Trolox moieties on the same fluorinated carrier, exhibited a synergistic antioxidant effect by delaying the oxidation process. We next investigated the ability of the derivatives to interact with DLiPC membranes in order to better understand the differences observed regarding the antioxidant properties. Surface tension and fluorescence spectroscopy experiments revealed the derivatives exhibited the ability to form monolayers at the air/water interface and spontaneously penetrated lipid membranes, underlying pronounced hydrophobic properties in comparison to the parent compounds. We observed a correlation between the hydrophobic properties, the depth of penetration and the antioxidant properties and showed that the location of these derivatives in the membrane is a key parameter to rationalize their antioxidant efficiency. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations supported the understanding of the mechanism of action, highlighting various key physical-chemical descriptors.

Self-Assembly Behaviors of a Penta-Phenylene Maltoside and Its Application for Membrane Protein Study

We prepared an amphiphile with a penta-phenylene lipophilic group and a branched trimaltoside head group. This new agent, designated penta-phenylene maltoside (PPM), showed a marked tendency to self-assembly into micelles via strong aromatic-aromatic interactions in aqueous media, as evidenced by 1 H NMR spectroscopy and fluorescence studies. When utilized for membrane protein studies, this new agent was superior to DDM, a gold standard conventional detergent, in stabilizing multiple proteins long term. The ability of this agent to form aromatic-aromatic interactions is likely responsible for enhanced protein stabilization when associated with a target membrane protein.

Hydrogenated Diglucose Detergents for Membrane-Protein Extraction and Stabilization

We report herein the design and synthesis of a novel series of alkyl glycoside detergents consisting of a nonionic polar headgroup that comprises two glucose moieties in a branched arrangement (DG), onto which octane-, decane-, and dodecanethiols were grafted leading to ODG, DDG, and DDDG detergents, respectively. Micellization in aqueous solution was studied by isothermal titration calorimetry, ¹H NMR spectroscopy, and surface tensiometry. Critical micellar concentration values were found to decrease by a factor of ∼10 for each pair of methylene groups added to the alkyl chain, ranging from ∼0.05 to 9 mM for DDDG and ODG, respectively. Dynamic light scattering and analytical ultracentrifugation sedimentation velocity experiments were used to investigate the size and composition of the micellar aggregates, showing that the aggregation number significantly increased from ∼40 for ODG to ∼80 for DDDG. All new compounds were able to solubilize membrane proteins (MPs) from bacterial membranes, insect cells, as well as the Madin-Darby canine kidney cells. In particular, native human adenosine receptor (A2AR) and bacterial transporter (BmrA) were solubilized efficiently. Striking thermostability improvements of +13 and +8 °C were observed when ODG and DDG were, respectively, applied to wild-type and full-length A2AR. Taken together, this novel detergent series shows promising detergent potency for solubilization and stabilization of membrane proteins (MPs) and thus makes a valuable addition to the chemical toolbox available for extracting and handling these important but challenging MP targets.

Successful amphiphiles as the key to crystallization of membrane proteins: Bridging theory and practice

BACKGROUND

Membrane proteins constitute a major group of proteins and are of great significance as pharmaceutical targets, but underrepresented in the Protein Data Bank. Particular reasons are their low expression yields and the constant need for cautious and diligent handling in a sufficiently stable hydrophobic environment substituting for the native membrane. When it comes to protein crystallization, such an environment is often established by detergents.

SCOPE OF REVIEW

In this review, 475 unique membrane protein X-ray structures from the online data bank "Membrane proteins of known 3D structure" are presented with a focus on the detergents essential for protein crystallization. By systematic analysis of the most successful compounds, including current trends in amphiphile development, we provide general insights for selection and design of detergents for membrane protein crystallization.

MAJOR CONCLUSIONS

The most successful detergents share common features, giving rise to favorable protein interactions. The hydrophile-lipophile balance concept of well-balanced hydrophilic and hydrophobic detergent portions is still the key to successful protein crystallization. Although a single detergent compound is sufficient in most cases, sometimes a suitable mixture of detergents has to be found to alter the resulting protein-detergent complex. Protein crystals with a high diffraction limit involve a tight crystal packing generally favored by detergents with shorter alkyl chains.

GENERAL SIGNIFICANCE

The formation of well-diffracting membrane protein crystals strongly depends on suitable surfactants, usually screened in numerous crystallization trials. The here-presented findings provide basic criteria for the assessment of surfactants within the vast space of potential crystallization conditions for membrane proteins.

Rationally Engineered Tandem Facial Amphiphiles for Improved Membrane Protein Stabilization Efficacy

A new family of tandem facial glucosides/maltosides (TFGs/TFMs) for membrane protein manipulation was prepared. The best detergent varied depending on the hydrophobic thickness of the target protein, but ether-based TFMs (TFM-C0E, TFM-C3E, and TFM-C5E) were notable for their ability to confer higher membrane protein stability than the previously developed amide-based TFA-1 (P. S. Chae, K. Gotfryd, J. Pacyna, L. J. W. Miercke, S. G. F. Rasmussen, R. A. Robbins, R. R. Rana, C. J. Loland, B. Kobilka, R. Stroud, B. Byrne, U. Gether, S. H. Gellman, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2010, 132, 16750-16752). Thus, this study not only introduces novel agents with the potential to be used in membrane protein research but also highlights the importance of both the hydrophobic length and linker functionality of the detergent in stabilizing membrane proteins.

Impact of Electric Fields on the Nanoscale Behavior of Lipid Monolayers at the Surface of Graphite in Solution

The nanoscale organization and dynamics of lipid molecules in self-assembled membranes is central to the biological function of cells and in the technological development of synthetic lipid structures as well as in devices such as biosensors. Here, we explore the nanoscale molecular arrangement and dynamics of lipids assembled in monolayers at the surface of highly ordered pyrolytic graphite (HOPG), in different ionic solutions, and under electrical potentials. Using a combination of atomic force microscopy and fluorescence recovery after photobleaching, we show that HOPG is able to support fully formed and fluid lipid membranes, but mesoscale order and corrugations can be observed depending on the type of the lipid considered (1,2-dioleoyl- sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine, 1,2-dioleoyl- sn-glycero-3-phospho-l-serine (DOPS), and 1,2-dioleoyl-3-trimethylammoniumpropane) and the ion present (Na⁺, Ca²⁺, Cl^-). Interfacial solvation forces and ion-specific effects dominate over the electrostatic changes induced by moderate electric fields (±1.0 V vs Ag/AgCl reference electrode) with particularly marked effects in the presence of calcium, and for DOPS. Our results provide insights into the interplay between the molecular, ionic, and electrostatic interactions and the formation of dynamical ordered structures in fluid lipid membranes.

Fluorinated DNA Micelles: Synthesis and Properties

Creating new functional building blocks that expand the versatility of nanostructures depends on bottom-up self-assembly of amphiphilic biomolecules. Inspired by the unique physicochemical properties of hydrophobic perfluorocarbons, coupled with the powerful functions of nucleic acids, we herein report the synthesis of a series of diperfluorodecyl-DNA conjugates (PF-DNA) which can efficiently self-assemble into micelles in aqueous solution. On the basis of the micelle structure, both target binding affinity and enzymatic resistance of the DNA probe can be enhanced. In addition, based on the hydrophobic effect, the PF-DNA micelles (PFDM) can actively anchor onto the cell membrane, offering a promising tool for cell-surface engineering. Finally, the PFDM can enter cells, which is significant for designing carriers for intracellular delivery. The combined advantages of the DNA micelle structure and the unique physicochemical properties of perfluorocarbons make these PFDM promising for applications in bioimaging and biomedicine.

(Cryo)Transmission Electron Microscopy of Phospholipid Model Membranes Interacting with Amphiphilic and Polyphilic Molecules

Lipid membranes can incorporate amphiphilic or polyphilic molecules leading to specific functionalities and to adaptable properties of the lipid bilayer host. The insertion of guest molecules into membranes frequently induces changes in the shape of the lipid matrix that can be visualized by transmission electron microscopy (TEM) techniques. Here, we review the use of stained and vitrified specimens in (cryo)TEM to characterize the morphology of amphiphilic and polyphilic molecules upon insertion into phospholipid model membranes. Special emphasis is placed on the impact of novel synthetic amphiphilic and polyphilic bolalipids and polymers on membrane integrity and shape stability.

Monitoring the different micelle species and the slow kinetics of tetraethylammonium perfluorooctane-sulfonate by 19F NMR spectroscopy

Since we lack effective tools that can monitor the structures of surfactant micelles in situ, the different equilibrium species and the slow kinetics of micelles are still not well understood. Herein, by using ¹⁹F NMR, we simultaneously monitored that micelles of tetraethylammonium perfluorooctanesulfonate (TPFOS, C₈F₁₇SO₃N(C₂H₅)₄) in water grow more complex in virtue of hydrophobic counterions and the slow kinetic exchange process exists in the system. Apart from the monomeric signals, three sets of micelle signals which correspond to spherical micelles, wormlike/wormlike micelles with rings in end caps and toroidal micelles were successfully detected on the NMR time scale because of the slow exchange rate for surfactant molecules between the monomer and the micelle states. By comparison, other fluoro- and hydrocarbon surfactants with different tail lengths and counterions (⁺N(CH₃)₄, ⁺N(C₃H₇)₄, Li⁺ and Na⁺) have been studied, and the coexistence of different micelles could also been observed for the aqueous solution of C₉F₁₉COON(CH₃)₄. However, only one set of averaged NMR signals could be observed for these surfactants. The micellization of TPFOS in water is demonstrated to be a predominantly entropy-driven process. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulation revealed an unusual distribution of counterions, providing further understanding of the mechanism of the micelle formation process.

2-Methyl-2,4-pentanediol (MPD) boosts as detergent-substitute the performance of ß-barrel hybrid catalyst for phenylacetylene polymerization

Covering hydrophobic regions with stabilization agents to solubilize purified transmembrane proteins is crucial for their application in aqueous media. The small molecule 2-methyl-2,4-pentanediol (MPD) was used to stabilize the transmembrane protein Ferric hydroxamate uptake protein component A (FhuA) utilized as host for the construction of a rhodium-based biohybrid catalyst. Unlike commonly used detergents such as sodium dodecyl sulfate or polyethylene polyethyleneglycol, MPD does not form micelles in solution. Molecular dynamics simulations revealed the effect and position of stabilizing MPD molecules. The advantage of the amphiphilic MPD over micelle-forming detergents is demonstrated in the polymerization of phenylacetylene, showing a ten-fold increase in yield and increased molecular weights.

Base-catalyzed diastereoselective trimerization of trifluoroacetone

Amphiphilic fluorocarbons have unique properties that facilitate their self assembly and adhesion to both inorganic and biological substrates. Incorporation of these moieties into valuable constructs typically require complex synthetic routes that have limited their use. Here, the base-catalyzed diastereoselective synthesis of 6-methyl-2,4,6-tris(trifluoromethyl)tetrahydro-2H-pyran-2,4-diol is reported. Trimerization of trifluoroacetone in the presence of 5 mol% KHMDS delivers one of four diastereomers selectively in 81% yield with no column chromatography. Temperature screening revealed the reversibility of this trimerization and the funneling of material into the most thermodynamically stable oxane. Subsequent functionalization with boronic acids is reported.

Slow Interconversion in a Heterogeneous Unfolded-State Ensemble of Outer-Membrane Phospholipase A

Structural and dynamic investigations of unfolded proteins are important for understanding protein-folding mechanisms as well as the interactions of unfolded polypeptide chains with other cell components. In the case of outer-membrane proteins (OMPs), unfolded-state properties are of particular physiological relevance, because these proteins remain unfolded for extended periods of time during their biogenesis and rely on interactions with binding partners to support proper folding. Using a combination of ensemble and single-molecule spectroscopy, we have scrutinized the unfolded state of outer-membrane phospholipase A (OmpLA) to provide a detailed view of its structural dynamics on timescales from nanoseconds to milliseconds. We find that even under strongly denaturing conditions and in the absence of residual secondary structure, OmpLA populates an ensemble of slowly (>100 ms) interconverting and conformationally heterogeneous unfolded states that lack the fast chain-reconfiguration motions expected for an unstructured, fully unfolded chain. The drastically slowed sampling of potentially folding-competent states, as compared with a random-coil polypeptide, may contribute to the slow in vitro folding kinetics observed for many OMPs. In vivo, however, slow intramolecular long-range dynamics might be advantageous for entropically favored binding of unfolded OMPs to chaperones and, by facilitating conformational selection after release from chaperones, for preserving binding-competent conformations before insertion into the outer membrane.

Nonionic Fluorinated Surfactant Removal from Mesoporous Film Using sc-CO2

Surfactant templated silica thin films were self-assembled on solid substrates by dip-coating using a partially fluorinated surfactant R₈^F(EO)₉ as the liquid crystal template. The aim was 2-fold: first we checked which composition in the phase diagram was corresponding to a 2D rectangular highly ordered crystalline phase and second we exposed the films to sc-CO₂ to foster the removal of the surfactant. The films were characterized by in situ X-ray reflectivity (XRR) and grazing incidence small angle X-ray scattering (GISAXS) under CO₂ pressure from 0 to 100 bar at 34 °C. GISAXS patterns reveal the formation of a 2-D rectangular structure at a molar ratio R₈^F(EO)₉/Si equal to 0.1. R₈^F(EO)₉ micelles have a cylindrical shape, which have a core/shell structure ordered in a hexagonal system. The core contains the R₈^F part and the shell is a mixture of (EO)₉ embedded in the silica matrix. We further evidence that the extraction of the template using supercritical carbon dioxide can be successfully achieved. This can be attributed to both the low solubility parameter of the surfactants and the fluorine and ethylene oxide CO₂-philic groups. The initial 2D rectangular structure was well preserved after depressurization of the cell and removal of the surfactant. We attribute the very high stability of the rinsed film to the large value of the wall thickness relatively to the small pore size.

Lipid perturbation by membrane proteins and the lipophobic effect

Understanding how membrane proteins interact with their environment is fundamental to the understanding of their structure, function and interactions. We have performed coarse-grained molecular dynamics simulations on a series of membrane proteins in a membrane environment to examine the perturbations of the lipids by the presence of protein. We analyze these perturbations in terms of elastic membrane deformations and local lipid protein interactions. However these two factors are insufficient to describe the variety of effects that we observe and the changes caused by membranes proteins to the structure and dynamics of their lipid environment. Other factors that change the conformation available to lipid molecules are evident and are able to modify lipid structure far from the protein surface, and thus mediate long-range interactions between membrane proteins. We suggest that these multiple modifications to lipid behavior are responsible, at the molecular level, for the lipophobic effect we have proposed to account for our observations of membrane protein organization.

Lateral Diffusion and Molecular Interaction in a Bilayer Membrane Consisting of Partially Fluorinated Phospholipids

Fluorinated lipids and surfactants are attractive biomimetic materials for the extraction and reorganization of membrane proteins because of the biological inertness of fluorocarbons. We investigated the fundamental physical properties of a partially fluorinated phospholipid (F4-DMPC), such as phase transition, area thermal expansion, and lateral lipid diffusion, to evaluate the intermolecular interaction of F4-DMPC in the hydrophobic region quantitatively on the basis of free-volume theory. Fluorescence microscope observation of the supported lipid bilayer (SLB) of F4-DMPC showed that the phase transition between the liquid crystalline and gel phases occurred at 5 °C and that the area thermal expansion coefficient was independent of the temperature near the phase transition temperature. We performed a single particle tracking of the F4-DMPC-SLB on a SiO₂/Si substrate, to measure the diffusion coefficient and its temperature dependence. The apparent activation energy (E'_a) of lateral lipid diffusion, which is an indicator of intermolecular interaction, was 39.1 kJ/mol for F4-DMPC, and 48.2 kJ/mol for a nonfluorinated 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine as a control. The difference of 9 kJ/mol in E'_a was significant compared with the difference due to the acyl chain species among nonfluorinated phosphatidylcholine and also that caused by the addition of cholesterol and alcohol in the bilayer membranes. We quantitatively evaluated the attenuation of intermolecular interaction, which results from the competition between the dipole-induced packing effect and steric effect at the fluorocarbon segment in F4-DMPC.

Hybrid Fluorinated and Hydrogenated Double-Chain Surfactants for Handling Membrane Proteins

Two hybrid fluorinated double-chain surfactants with a diglucosylated polar head were synthesized. The apolar domain consists of a perfluorohexyl main chain and a butyl hydrogenated branch as a side chain. They were found to self-assemble into small micelles at low critical micellar concentrations, demonstrating that the short branch increases the overall hydrophobicity while keeping the length of the apolar domain short. They were both able to keep the membrane protein bacteriorhodopsin stable, one of them for at least 3 months.

The styrene-maleic acid copolymer: a versatile tool in membrane research

A new and promising tool in membrane research is the detergent-free solubilization of membrane proteins by styrene-maleic acid copolymers (SMAs). These amphipathic molecules are able to solubilize lipid bilayers in the form of nanodiscs that are bounded by the polymer. Thus, membrane proteins can be directly extracted from cells in a water-soluble form while conserving a patch of native membrane around them. In this review article, we briefly discuss current methods of membrane protein solubilization and stabilization. We then zoom in on SMAs, describe their physico-chemical properties, and discuss their membrane-solubilizing effect. This is followed by an overview of studies in which SMA has been used to isolate and investigate membrane proteins. Finally, potential future applications of the methodology are discussed for structural and functional studies on membrane proteins in a near-native environment and for characterizing protein-lipid and protein-protein interactions.