Spin-Selective Thermal Activation of Methane by Closed-Shell [TaO3 ]+

Activation of CH4, NH3, and N2 by Tantalum Ions, Clusters and Their Oxides: What Can Be Learnt from Studies of Ions in the Gas Phase

The emission control of harmful compounds and greenhouse gases and the development of alternative, sustainable fuel sources is a major focus in current research. A solution for this problem lies in the development of efficient catalytic materials. Here, gas phase model systems represent prominent examples for obtaining fundamental insights on reaction properties of prospective catalytic systems. In this work, we review results from studies of tantalum clusters and their oxides in the gas phase and discuss insights with a potential relevance for applied systems. We focus on reactions that are essential for sustainable chemistry in the future. In detail, we address the activation of methane, which may enable the transformation of a greenhouse gas to a chemical feedstock, and we discuss the activation of NH3, which may function as an alternative energy carrier whose unwanted emission needs to be curbed in future applications. Finally, we consider the activation of N2 as a third reaction, since reducing the high energy demand of ammonia synthesis still bears significant challenges. While tantalum may be an interesting catalytic material, the discussed studies may also serve as benchmark for investigations of other materials.

Ion-molecule reactions of mass-selected ions

Gas-phase reactions of mass-selected ions with neutrals covers a very broad area of fundamental and applied mass spectrometry (MS). Oftentimes, ion-molecule reactions (IMR) can serve as a viable alternative to collision-induced dissociation and other ion dissociation techniques when using tandem MS. This review focuses on the literature pertaining applications of IMR since 2013. During the past decade considerable efforts have been made in analytical applications of IMR, including advances in one of the major techniques for characterization of unsaturated fatty acids and lipids, ozone-induced dissociation, and the development of a new technique for sequencing of large ions, hydrogen atom attachment/abstraction dissociation. Many advances have also been made in identifying gas-phase chemistry specific to a functional group in organic and biological compounds, which are useful in structure elucidation of analytes and differentiation of isomers/isobars. With "soft" ionization techniques like electrospray ionization having become mainstream for quite some time now, the efforts in the area of metal ion catalysis have firmly moved into exploring chemistry of ligated metal complexes in their "natural" oxidation states allowing to model individual steps of mechanisms in homogeneous catalysis, especially in combination with high-level DFT calculations. Finally, IMR continue to contribute to the body of knowledge in the area of chemistry of interstellar processes.

Methane Activation by [AlFeO3 ]+ : the Hidden Spin Selectivity

The performance of heteronuclear cluster [AlFeO3 ]+ in activating methane has been explored by a combination of high-level quantum chemical calculations with gas-phase experiments. At room temperature, [AlFeO3 ]+ is a mixture of 7 [AlFeO3 ]+ and 5 [AlFeO3 ]+ , in which two states lead to different reactivity and chemoselectivity for methane activation. While hydrogen extracted from methane is the only product channel for the 7 [AlFeO3 ]+ /CH4 couple, 5 [AlFeO3 ]+ is able to convert this substrate to formaldehyde. In addition, the introduction of an external electric field may regulate the reactivity and product selectivity. The interesting doping effect of Fe and the associated electronic origins are discussed, which may guide one on the design of Fe-involved catalyst for methane conversion.

Direct Conversion of Methane to Propylene

Nonoxidative coupling of methane exhibits promising prospect in that it affords value-added hydrocarbons and hydrogen with high atom economy. However, challenge remains in direct, selective conversion of methane to more valuable hydrocarbons like olefins. The current work presents a catalyst with well-dispersed Ta atoms anchored by graphitic C3N4-supported phthalocyanine. Such a catalyst is able to convert methane selectively to ethylene and propylene at a relatively low temperature (350 °C). The conception of the active center and construction of the catalyst have been described, and the origins of the catalytic performance are discussed.

Infrared photodissociation spectroscopy of mass-selected [TaO3(CO2)n]+ (n = 2-5) complexes in the gas phase

We report a joint experimental and theoretical study on the structures of gas-phase [TaO₃(CO₂)_n]⁺ (n = 2-5) ion-molecule complexes. Infrared photodissociation spectra of mass-selected [TaO₃(CO₂)_n]⁺ complexes were recorded in the frequency region from 2200 to 2450 cm^-1 and assigned through comparing with the simulated infrared spectra of energetically low-lying structures derived from quantum chemical calculations. With the increasing number of attached CO₂ molecules, the larger clusters show significantly enhanced fragmentation efficiency and a strong band appears at around 2350 cm^-1 near the free CO₂ antisymmetric stretching vibration band, indicating only a small perturbation of CO₂ molecules on the secondary solvation sphere while higher frequency bands corresponding to the core structure remain largely unaffected. A core structure [TaO₃(CO₂)₃]⁺ is identified to which subsequent CO₂ ligands are weakly attached and the most favorable cluster growth path is verified to proceed on the triplet potential energy surface higher in energy than that of ground states. Theoretical exploration reveals a two-state reactivity (TSR) scenario in which the energetically favored triplet transition state crosses over the singlet ground state to form a TaO₃⁺ core ion, providing new information on the cluster formation correlated with the reactivity of tantalum metal oxides towards CO₂.

CO2-Activation by size-selected tantalum cluster cations (Ta1-16+): thermalization governing reaction selectivity

The reactions of tantalum cluster cations of different sizes toward carbon dioxide are studied in an ion trap under multi-collisional conditions. For all sizes studied, consecutive reactions with several CO₂ molecules are observed. This reveals two different pathways, namely oxide formation and the pickup of an entire molecule. Supported by calculations of the thermochemistry of Ta_nO⁺ formation upon reaction with CO₂, changes in the branching ratios at a particular cluster size are related to heat effects due to the vibrational heat capacity of the clusters and the exothermicity of the reaction.

Room-Temperature Methane Activation Mediated by Free Tantalum Cluster Cations: Size-by-Size Reactivity

The energetics of small cationic tantalum clusters and their gas-phase adsorption and dehydrogenation reaction pathways with methane are investigated with ion-trap experiments and spin-density-functional-theory calculations. Ta_n⁺ clusters are exposed to methane under multicollision conditions in a cryogenic ring electrode ion-trap. The cluster size affects the reaction efficiency and the number of consecutively dehydrogenated methane molecules. Small clusters (n = 1-4) dehydrogenate CH₄ and concurrently eliminate H₂, while larger clusters (n > 4) demonstrate only molecular adsorption of methane. Unique behavior is found for the Ta⁺ cation, which dehydrogenates consecutively up to four CH₄ molecules and is predicted theoretically to promote formation of a [Ta(CH₂-CH₂-CH₂)(CH₂)]⁺ product, exhibiting C-C coupled groups. Underlying mechanisms, including reaction-enhancing couplings between potential energy surfaces of different spin-multiplicities, are uncovered.

Carbide Dihydrides: Carbonaceous Species Identified in Ta4 + -Mediated Methane Dehydrogenation

The products of methane dehydrogenation by gas‐phase Ta₄⁺ clusters are structurally characterized using infrared multiple photon dissociation (IRMPD) spectroscopy in conjunction with quantum chemical calculations. The obtained spectra of [4Ta,C,2H]⁺ reveal a dominance of vibrational bands of a H₂Ta₄C⁺ carbide dihydride structure over those indicative for a HTa₄CH⁺ carbyne hydride one, as is unambiguously verified by studies employing various methane isotopologues. Because methane dehydrogenation by metal cations M⁺ typically leads to the formation of either MCH₂⁺ carbene or HMCH⁺ carbyne hydride structures, the observation of a H₂MC⁺ carbide dihydride structure implies that it is imperative to consider this often‐neglected class of carbonaceous intermediates in the reaction of metals with hydrocarbons.

On the Crucial Role of Isolated Electronic States in the Thermal Reaction of ReC+ with Dihydrogen

Presented here is that isolated, long‐lived electronic states of ReC⁺ serve as the root cause for distinctly different reactivities of this diatomic ion in the thermal activation of dihydrogen. Detailed high‐level quantum chemical calculations support the experimental findings obtained in the highly diluted gas phase using FT‐ICR mass spectrometry. The origin for the existence of these long‐lived excited electronic states and the resulting implications for the varying mechanisms of dihydrogen splitting are addressed.

Catalytic Non-Oxidative Coupling of Methane on Ta8O2

Mass-selected Ta₈O₂⁺ cluster ions catalyze the transformation of methane in a gas-phase ion trap experiment via nonoxidative coupling into ethane and H₂, which is a prospective reaction for the generation of valuable chemicals on an industrial scale. Systematic variation of the reaction conditions and the isotopic labeling of methane by deuterium allow for an unambiguous identification of a catalytic cycle. Comparison with the proposed catalytic cycle for tantalum-doped silica catalysts reveals surprising similarities as the mechanism of the C-C coupling step, but also peculiar differences like the mechanism of the eventual formation of molecular hydrogen and ethane. Therefore, this work not only supplies insights into the mechanisms of methane coupling reactions but also illustrates how the study of trapped ionic catalysts can contribute to the understanding of reactions, which are otherwise difficult to study.

Selective Generation of Free Hydrogen Atoms in the Reaction of Methane with Diatomic Gold Boride Cations

The thermal reaction of diatomic gold boride cation AuB+ with methane has been studied by using state-of-the-art mass spectrometry in conjunction with density functional theory calculations. The AuB+ ion can activate a methane molecule to produce exclusively the free hydrogen atom, an important intermediate in hydrocarbon transformation. This result is different from the reactivity of AuC+ and CuB+ counterparts with methane in previous studies. The AuC+ cation mainly transforms methane into ethylene. The CuB+ reaction system principally generates the free hydrogen atoms, but it also gives rise a portion of ethylene-like product H2B−CH2. The B atom of AuB+ is the active site to activate methane. The strong relativistic effect on gold plays an important role for the product selectivity. The mechanistic insights obtained from this study provide guidance for rational design of active sites with high product selectivity toward methane activation.

Identification of Active Sites and Structural Characterization of Reactive Ionic Intermediates by Cryogenic Ion Trap Vibrational Spectroscopy

Cryogenic ion trap vibrational spectroscopy paired with quantum chemistry currently represents the most generally applicable approach for the structural investigation of gaseous cluster ions that are not amenable to direct absorption spectroscopy. Here, we give an overview of the most popular variants of infrared action spectroscopy and describe the advantages of using cryogenic ion traps in combination with messenger tagging and vibrational predissociation spectroscopy. We then highlight a few recent studies that apply this technique to identify highly reactive ionic intermediates and to characterize their reactive sites. We conclude by commenting on future challenges and potential developments in the field.

Selective C-O Coupling Hidden in the Thermal Reaction of [Al2 CuO5 ]+ with Methane

The thermal gas-phase reaction of [Al₂ CuO₅ ]⁺ with methane has been explored by using FT-ICR mass spectrometry complemented by high-level quantum chemical calculations. The generation of atomic [Cu]⁺ from the [Al₂ CuO₅ ]⁺ /CH₄ couple corresponds to the only reaction channel. Labeling experiments and computational studies strongly suggest that methane activation is indeed involved in the production of [Cu]⁺ , and generation of CH₂ O prevails. Mechanistic aspects and the associated doping effects are discussed.

Thermal activation of methane by vanadium boride cluster cations VBn+ (n = 3–6)

A new type of active species, transition metal boride cluster cations [VB_n⁺ (n = 3–6)], has been experimentally identified to dehydrogenate methane under thermal collision conditions. The B₃ unit in VB₃⁺ cluster is polarized by the V⁺ cation to activate CH₄.

Electronic Effects on Room-Temperature, Gas-Phase C-H Bond Activations by Cluster Oxides and Metal Carbides: The Methane Challenge

This Perspective discusses a story of one molecule (methane), a few metal-oxide cationic clusters (MOCCs), dopants, metal-carbide cations, oriented-electric fields (OEFs), and a dizzying mechanistic landscape of methane activation! One mechanism is hydrogen atom transfer (HAT), which occurs whenever the MOCC possesses a localized oxyl radical (M-O^•). Whenever the radical is delocalized, e.g., in [MgO]_n^•+ the HAT barrier increases due to the penalty of radical localization. Adding a dopant (Ga₂O₃) to [MgO]₂^•+ localizes the radical and HAT transpires. Whenever the radical is located on the metal centers as in [Al₂O₂]^•+ the mechanism crosses over to proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET), wherein the positive Al center acts as a Lewis acid that coordinates the methane molecule, while one of the bridging oxygen atoms abstracts a proton, and the negatively charged CH₃ moiety relocates to the metal fragment. We provide a diagnostic plot of barriers vs reactants' distortion energies, which allows the chemist to distinguish HAT from PCET. Thus, doping of [MgO]₂^•+ by Al₂O₃ enables HAT and PCET to compete. Similarly, [ZnO]^•+ activates methane by PCET generating many products. Adding a CH₃CN ligand to form [(CH₃CN)ZnO]^•+ leads to a single HAT product. The CH₃CN dipole acts as an OEF that switches off PCET. [MC]⁺ cations (M = Au, Cu) act by different mechanisms, dictated by the M⁺-C bond covalence. For example, Cu⁺, which bonds the carbon atom mostly electrostatically, performs coupling of C to methane to yield ethylene, in a single almost barrier-free step, with an unprecedented atomic choreography catalyzed by the OEF of Cu⁺.

Thermal Methane Activation by the Metal-Free Cluster Cation [Si2 O4 ]

The thermal reaction of methane with the metal-free cluster cation [Si₂ O₄ ]^.+ has been examined by using Fourier transform-ion cyclotron resonance (FT-ICR) mass spectrometry. In addition to generating a methyl radical via hydrogen-atom abstraction, [Si₂ O₄ ]^.+ can selectively oxidize methane to formaldehyde. The mechanisms of these rather efficient reactions have been elucidated by high-level quantum-chemical calculations.

Consecutive reactions of small, free tantalum clusters with dioxygen controlled by relaxation dynamics

The reaction of small cationic tantalum clusters (Ta_n⁺, n = 4–8) with molecular oxygen is studied under multi-collision conditions in the gas phase, and the reaction kinetics are analyzed in order to elucidate underlying mechanisms.

Ménage-à-trois: single-atom catalysis, mass spectrometry, and computational chemistry

Genuine, single-atom catalysis can be realized in the gas phase and probed by mass spectrometry combined with computational chemistry.

From oxidative degradation to direct oxidation: size regimes in the consecutive reaction of cationic tantalum clusters with dioxygen

Cationic tantalum clusters (Ta_9–12⁺) are reacted with molecular oxygen under multi-collision conditions in the gas phase in order to analyze the reaction kinetics.