Characterization of [2Fe-2S]-Cluster-Bridged Protein Complexes and Reaction Intermediates by use of Native Mass Spectrometric Methods

Synergy of native mass spectrometry and other biophysical techniques in studies of iron‑sulfur cluster proteins and their assembly

The application of mass spectrometric methodologies has revolutionised biological chemistry, from identification through to structural and conformational studies of proteins and other macromolecules. Native mass spectrometry (MS), in which proteins retain their native structure, is a rapidly growing field. This is particularly the case for studies of metalloproteins, where non-covalently bound cofactors remain bound following ionisation. Such metalloproteins include those that contain an iron‑sulfur (FeS) cluster and, despite their fragility and O2 sensitivity, they have been a particular focus for applications of native MS because of its capacity to accurately monitor mass changes that reveal chemical changes at the cluster. Here we review recent advances in these applications of native MS, which, together with data from more traditionally applied biophysical methods, have yielded a remarkable breadth of information about the FeS species present, and provided key mechanistic insight not only for FeS cluster proteins themselves, but also their assembly.

Fe-S cluster biosynthesis and maturation: Mass spectrometry-based methods advancing the field

Iron‑sulfur (FeS) clusters are inorganic protein cofactors that perform essential functions in many physiological processes. Spectroscopic techniques have historically been used to elucidate details of FeS cluster type, their assembly and transfer, and changes in redox and ligand binding properties. Structural probes of protein topology, complex formation, and conformational dynamics are also necessary to fully understand these FeS protein systems. Recent developments in mass spectrometry (MS) instrumentation and methods provide new tools to investigate FeS cluster and structural properties. With the unique advantage of sampling all species in a mixture, MS-based methods can be utilized as a powerful complementary approach to probe native dynamic heterogeneity, interrogate protein folding and unfolding equilibria, and provide extensive insight into protein binding partners within an entire proteome. Here, we highlight key advances in FeS protein studies made possible by MS methodology and contribute an outlook for its role in the field.

[Applications of native mass spectrometry and ultraviolet photodissociation in protein structure and interaction analysis]

Dynamic changes in the structures and interactions of proteins are closely correlated with their biological functions. However, the precise detection and analysis of these molecules are challenging. Native mass spectrometry (nMS) introduces proteins or protein complexes into the gas phase by electrospray ionization, and then performs MS analysis under near-physiological conditions that preserve the folded state of proteins and their complexes in solution. nMS can provide information on stoichiometry, assembly, and dissociation constants by directly determining the relative molecular masses of protein complexes through high-resolution MS. It can also integrate various MS dissociation technologies, such as collision-induced dissociation (CID), surface-induced dissociation (SID), and ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD), to analyze the conformational changes, binding interfaces, and active sites of protein complexes, thereby revealing the relationship between their interactions and biological functions. UVPD, especially 193 nm excimer laser UVPD, is a rapidly evolving MS dissociation method that can directly dissociate the covalent bonds of protein backbones with a single pulse. It can generate different types of fragment ions, while preserving noncovalent interactions such as hydrogen bonds within these ions, thereby enabling the MS analysis of protein structures with single-amino-acid-site resolution. This review outlines the applications and recent progress of nMS and UVPD in protein dynamic structure and interaction analyses. It covers the nMS techniques used to analyze protein-small-molecule ligand interactions, the structures of membrane proteins and their complexes, and protein-protein interactions. The discussion on UVPD includes the analysis of gas-phase protein structures and interactions, as well as alterations in protein dynamic structures, and interactions resulting from mutations and ligand binding. Finally, this review describes the future development prospects for protein analysis by nMS and new-generation advanced extreme UV light sources with higher brightness and shorter pulses.

Development of an SI-traceable N-terminal pro-B-type natriuretic peptide certified reference material using structure-based impurity-corrected isotope dilution mass spectrometry approaches

N-Terminal pro-B-type natriuretic peptide (NT-proBNP) is a pivotal biomarker for the diagnosis and prognosis of heart failure (HF). However, no SI-traceable certified reference material (CRM) or reference measurement procedure (RMP) is available for this biomarker, and so clinical testing results obtained in different laboratories cannot be traced to a higher-order standard, leading to incomparable measurements. Protein hydrolysis and protein cleavage isotope dilution mass spectrometry (AAA-IDMS and PepA-IDMS) were used to develop a CRM. Structurally related impurities were identified by high-resolution mass spectrometry. The quantitative AAA-IDMS results were corrected according to the amino acid compositions of the impurities. Using PepA-IDMS, two peptides from the proteolyzed product were confirmed as signature peptides. To obtain traceable and accurate results, the signature peptides were quantified using impurity-corrected AAA-IDMS. The candidate NT-proBNP solution was denatured and enzymatically digested using the Glu-C endoproteinase. The released signature peptides were measured using an isotopic dilution approach. The homogeneity and stability of the candidate CRM were characterized, and their uncertainties were combined with the value assignment process. The developed CRM can be considered a unique SI-traceable NT-proBNP reference material and is expected to be used as a primary calibrator for matrix NT-proBNP CRM development.

Probing the mechanism of the dedicated NO sensor [4Fe-4S] NsrR: the effect of cluster ligand environment

NsrR from Streptomyces coelicolor is a bacterial nitric oxide (NO) sensor/nitrosative stress regulator as its primary function, and has been shown to have differential response at low, mid, and high levels of NO. These must correspond to discrete structural changes at the protein-bound [4Fe-4S] cluster in response to stepwise nitrosylation of the cluster. We have investigated the effect of the monohapto carboxylate ligand in the site differentiated [4Fe-4S] cluster cofactor of the protein NsrR on modulating its reactivity to NO with a focus on indentifying mechanistic intermediates. We have prepared a synthetic model [4Fe-4S] cluster complex with tripodal ligand and one single site differentiated site occupied by either thiolate or carboxylate ligand. We report here the mechanistic details of sequential steps of nitrosylation as observed by ESI MS and IR spectroscopy. Parallel non-denaturing mass spectrometry analyses were performed using site-differentiated variants of NsrR with the native aspartic acid, cysteine, or alanine in the position of the forth ligand to the cluster. A mono-nitrosylated synthetic [4Fe-4S] cluster was observed for the first time in a biologically-relevant thiolate-based coordination environment. Combined synthetic and protein data give unprecedented clarity in the modulation of nitrosylation of a [4Fe-4S] cluster.

Native mass spectrometric studies of IscSU reveal a concerted, sulfur-initiated mechanism of iron-sulfur cluster assembly

Iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters are cofactors essential for life. Though the proteins that function in the assembly of Fe-S clusters are well known, details of the molecular mechanism are less well established. The Isc (iron-sulfur cluster) biogenesis apparatus is widespread in bacteria and is the closest homologue to the human system. Mutations in certain components of the human system lead to disease, and so further studies of this system could be important for developing strategies for medical treatments. We have studied two core components of the Isc biogenesis system: IscS, a cysteine desulfurase; and IscU, a scaffold protein on which clusters are built before subsequent transfer onto recipient apo-proteins. Fe2+-binding, sulfur transfer, and formation of a [2Fe-2S] was followed by a range of techniques, including time-resolved mass spectrometry, and intermediate and product species were unambiguously identified through isotopic substitution experiments using 57Fe and 34S. Under cluster synthesis conditions, sulfur adducts and the [2Fe-2S] cluster product readily accumulated on IscU, but iron adducts (other than the cluster itself) were not observed at physiologically relevant Fe2+ concentrations. Our data indicate that either Fe2+ or sulfur transfer can occur first, but that the transfer of sulfane sulfur (S0) to IscU must occur first if Zn2+ is bound to IscU, suggesting that it is the key step that initiates cluster assembly. Following this, [2Fe-2S] cluster formation is a largely concerted reaction once Fe2+ is introduced.

Mechanistic Insights into IscU Conformation Regulation for Fe-S Cluster Biogenesis Revealed by Variable Temperature Electrospray Ionization Native Ion Mobility Mass Spectrometry

Iron-sulfur (Fe-S) cluster (ISC) cofactors are required for the function of many critical cellular processes. In the ISC Fe-S cluster biosynthetic pathway, IscU assembles Fe-S cluster intermediates from iron, electrons, and inorganic sulfur, which is provided by the cysteine desulfurase enzyme IscS. IscU also binds to Zn, which mimics and competes for binding with the Fe-S cluster. Crystallographic and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopic studies reveal that IscU is a metamorphic protein that exists in multiple conformational states, which include at least a structured form and a disordered form. The structured form of IscU is favored by metal binding and is stable in a narrow temperature range, undergoing both cold and hot denaturation. Interestingly, the form of IscU that binds IscS and functions in Fe-S cluster assembly remains controversial. Here, results from variable temperature electrospray ionization (vT-ESI) native ion mobility mass spectrometry (nIM-MS) establish that IscU exists in structured, intermediate, and disordered forms that rearrange to more extended conformations at higher temperatures. A comparison of Zn-IscU and apo-IscU reveals that Zn(II) binding attenuates the cold/heat denaturation of IscU, promotes refolding of IscU, favors the structured and intermediate conformations, and inhibits the disordered high charge states. Overall, these findings provide a structural rationalization for the role of Zn(II) in stabilizing IscU conformations and IscS in altering the IscU active site to prepare for Zn(II) release and cluster synthesis. This work highlights how vT-ESI-nIM-MS can be applied as a powerful tool in mechanistic enzymology by providing details of relationships among temperature, protein conformations, and ligand/protein binding.

Approaches to Heterogeneity in Native Mass Spectrometry

Native mass spectrometry (MS) is aimed at preserving and determining the native structure, composition, and stoichiometry of biomolecules and their complexes from solution after they are transferred into the gas phase. Major improvements in native MS instrumentation and experimental methods over the past few decades have led to a concomitant increase in the complexity and heterogeneity of samples that can be analyzed, including protein-ligand complexes, protein complexes with multiple coexisting stoichiometries, and membrane protein-lipid assemblies. Heterogeneous features of these biomolecular samples can be important for understanding structure and function. However, sample heterogeneity can make assignment of ion mass, charge, composition, and structure very challenging due to the overlap of tens or even hundreds of peaks in the mass spectrum. In this review, we cover data analysis, experimental, and instrumental advances and strategies aimed at solving this problem, with an in-depth discussion of theoretical and practical aspects of the use of available deconvolution algorithms and tools. We also reflect upon current challenges and provide a view of the future of this exciting field.

Characterization of a Salmonella transcription factor-DNA complex and identification of the inducer by native mass spectrometry

FraR, a transcriptional repressor, was postulated to regulate the metabolism of the Amadori compound fructose-asparagine (F-Asn) in the foodborne pathogen Salmonella enterica. Here, the DNA- and inducer-binding affinities and stoichiometries of FraR were determined and cross-validated by electrophoretic mobility-shift assays (EMSAs) and online buffer exchange coupled to native mass spectrometry (OBE-nMS). We demonstrate the utility of OBE-nMS to characterize protein and protein-DNA complexes that are not amenable to offline exchange into volatile buffers. OBE-nMS complemented EMSAs by revealing that FraR binds to the operator DNA as a dimer and by establishing 6-phosphofructose-aspartate as the inducer that weakens DNA binding by FraR. These results provide insights into how FraR regulates the expression of F-Asn-catabolizing enzymes and add to our understanding of the intricate bacterial circuitry that dictates utilization of diverse nutrients.

Glutaredoxin: Discovery, redox defense and much more

Glutaredoxin, Grx, is a small protein containing an active site cysteine pair and was discovered in 1976 by Arne Holmgren. The Grx system, comprised of Grx, glutathione, glutathione reductase, and NADPH, was first described as an electron donor for Ribonucleotide Reductase but, from the first discovery in E.coli, the Grx family has impressively grown, particularly in the last two decades. Several isoforms have been described in different organisms (from bacteria to humans) and with different functions. The unique characteristic of Grxs is their ability to catalyse glutathione-dependent redox regulation via glutathionylation, the conjugation of glutathione to a substrate, and its reverse reaction, deglutathionylation. Grxs have also recently been enrolled in iron sulphur cluster formation. These functions have been implied in various physiological and pathological conditions, from immune defense to neurodegeneration and cancer development thus making Grx a possible drug target. This review aims to give an overview on Grxs, starting by a phylogenetic analysis of vertebrate Grxs, followed by an analysis of the mechanisms of action, the specific characteristics of the different human isoforms and a discussion on aspects related to human physiology and diseases.

Glutaredoxins and iron-sulfur protein biogenesis at the interface of redox biology and iron metabolism

The physiological roles of the intracellular iron and redox regulatory systems are intimately linked. Iron is an essential trace element for most organisms, yet elevated cellular iron levels are a potent generator and amplifier of reactive oxygen species and redox stress. Proteins binding iron or iron-sulfur (Fe/S) clusters, are particularly sensitive to oxidative damage and require protection from the cellular oxidative stress protection systems. In addition, key components of these systems, most prominently glutathione and monothiol glutaredoxins are involved in the biogenesis of cellular Fe/S proteins. In this review, we address the biochemical role of glutathione and glutaredoxins in cellular Fe/S protein assembly in eukaryotic cells. We also summarize the recent developments in the role of cytosolic glutaredoxins in iron metabolism, in particular the regulation of fungal iron homeostasis. Finally, we discuss recent insights into the interplay of the cellular thiol redox balance and oxygen with that of Fe/S protein biogenesis in eukaryotes.

Sensing mechanisms of iron-sulfur cluster regulatory proteins elucidated using native mass spectrometry

The ability to sense and respond to various key environmental cues is important for the survival and adaptability of many bacteria, including pathogens. The particular sensitivity of iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters is exploited in nature, such that multiple sensor-regulator proteins, which coordinate the detection of analytes with a (in many cases) global transcriptional response, are Fe-S cluster proteins. The fragility and sensitivity of these Fe-S clusters make studying such proteins difficult, and gaining insight of what they sense, and how they sense it and transduce the signal to affect transcription, is a major challenge. While mass spectrometry is very widely used in biological research, it is normally employed under denaturing conditions where non-covalently attached cofactors are lost. However, mass spectrometry under conditions where the protein retains its native structure and, thus, cofactors, is now itself a flourishing field, and the application of such 'native' mass spectrometry to study metalloproteins is now relatively widespread. Here we describe recent advances in using native MS to study Fe-S cluster proteins. Through its ability to accurately measure mass changes that reflect chemistry occurring at the cluster, this approach has yielded a remarkable richness of information that is not accessible by other, more traditional techniques.

Molecular Basis of Multiple Mitochondrial Dysfunctions Syndrome 2 Caused by CYS59TYR BOLA3 Mutation

Multiple mitochondrial dysfunctions syndrome (MMDS) is a rare neurodegenerative disorder associated with mutations in genes with a vital role in the biogenesis of mitochondrial [4Fe-4S] proteins. Mutations in one of these genes encoding for BOLA3 protein lead to MMDS type 2 (MMDS2). Recently, a novel phenotype for MMDS2 with complete clinical recovery was observed in a patient containing a novel variant (c.176G > A, p.Cys59Tyr) in compound heterozygosity. In this work, we aimed to rationalize this unique phenotype observed in MMDS2. To do so, we first investigated the structural impact of the Cys59Tyr mutation on BOLA3 by NMR, and then we analyzed how the mutation affects both the formation of a hetero-complex between BOLA3 and its protein partner GLRX5 and the iron-sulfur cluster-binding properties of the hetero-complex by various spectroscopic techniques and by experimentally driven molecular docking. We show that (1) the mutation structurally perturbed the iron-sulfur cluster-binding region of BOLA3, but without abolishing [2Fe-2S]2+ cluster-binding on the hetero-complex; (2) tyrosine 59 did not replace cysteine 59 as iron-sulfur cluster ligand; and (3) the mutation promoted the formation of an aberrant apo C59Y BOLA3-GLRX5 complex. All these aspects allowed us to rationalize the unique phenotype observed in MMDS2 caused by Cys59Tyr mutation.

Biochemical impact of a disease-causing Ile67Asn substitution on BOLA3 protein

Iron-sulfur (Fe-S) cluster biosynthesis involves the action of a variety of functionally distinct proteins, most of which are evolutionarily conserved. Mutations in these Fe-S scaffold and trafficking proteins can cause diseases such as multiple mitochondrial dysfunctions syndrome (MMDS), sideroblastic anemia, and mitochondrial encephalopathy. Herein, we investigate the effect of Ile67Asn substitution in the BOLA3 protein that results in the MMDS2 phenotype. Although the exact functional role of BOLA3 in Fe-S cluster biosynthesis is not known, the [2Fe-2S]-bridged complex of BOLA3 with GLRX5, another Fe-S protein, has been proposed as a viable intermediary cluster carrier to downstream targets. Our investigations reveal that the Ile67Asn substitution impairs the ability of BOLA3 to bind its physiological partner GLRX5, resulting in a failure to form the [2Fe-2S]-bridged complex. Although no drastic structural change in BOLA3 arises from the substitution, as evidenced by wild-type and mutant BOLA3 1H-15N HSQC and ion mobility native mass spectrometry experiments, this substitution appears to influence cluster reconstitution on downstream proteins leading to the disease phenotype. By contrast, substituted derivatives of the holo homodimeric form of BOLA3 are formed and remain active toward cluster exchange.

Native Mass Spectrometry of Iron-Sulfur Proteins

Iron-sulfur clusters constitute a large and widely distributed group of protein cofactors that play key roles in a wide range of metabolic processes. The inherent reactivity of iron-sulfur clusters toward small molecules, for example, O₂, NO, or free Fe, makes them ideal for sensing changes in the cellular environment. Nondenaturing, or native, MS is unique in its ability to preserve the noncovalent interactions of many (if not all) species, including stable intermediates, while providing accurate mass measurements in both thermodynamic and kinetic experimental regimes. Here, we provide practical guidance for the study of iron-sulfur proteins by native MS, illustrated by examples where it has been used to unambiguously determine the type of cluster coordinated to the protein framework. We also describe the use of time-resolved native MS to follow the kinetics of cluster conversion, allowing the elucidation of the precise series of molecular events for all species involved. Finally, we provide advice on a unique approach to a typical thermodynamic titration, uncovering early, quasi-stable, intermediates in the reaction of a cluster with nitric oxide, resulting in cluster nitrosylation.

PRE-driven protein NMR structures: an alternative approach in highly paramagnetic systems

Metalloproteins play key roles across biology, and knowledge of their structure is essential to understand their physiological role. For those metalloproteins containing paramagnetic states, the enhanced relaxation caused by the unpaired electrons often makes signal detection unfeasible near the metal center, precluding adequate structural characterization right where it is more biochemically relevant. Here, we report a protein structure determination by NMR where two different sets of restraints, one containing Nuclear Overhauser Enhancements (NOEs) and another containing Paramagnetic Relaxation Enhancements (PREs), are used separately and eventually together. The protein PioC from Rhodopseudomonas palustris TIE-1 is a High Potential Iron-Sulfur Protein (HiPIP) where the [4Fe-4S] cluster is paramagnetic in both oxidation states at room temperature providing the source of PREs used as alternative distance restraints. Comparison of the family of structures obtained using NOEs only, PREs only, and the combination of both reveals that the pairwise root-mean-square deviation (RMSD) between them is similar and comparable with the precision within each family. This demonstrates that, under favorable conditions in terms of protein size and paramagnetic effects, PREs can efficiently complement and eventually replace NOEs for the structural characterization of small paramagnetic metalloproteins and de novo-designed metalloproteins by NMR. DATABASES: The 20 conformers with the lowest target function constituting the final family obtained using the full set of NMR restraints were deposited to the Protein Data Bank (PDB ID: 6XYV). The 20 conformers with the lowest target function obtained using NOEs only (PDB ID: 7A58) and PREs only (PDB ID: 7A4L) were also deposited to the Protein Data Bank. The chemical shift assignments were deposited to the BMRB (code 34487).

Glutaredoxins with iron-sulphur clusters in eukaryotes - Structure, function and impact on disease

Among the thioredoxin superfamily of proteins, the observation that numerous glutaredoxins bind iron-sulphur (Fe/S) clusters is one of the more recent and major developments concerning their functional properties. Glutaredoxins are present in most organisms. All members of the class II subfamily (including most monothiol glutaredoxins), but also some members of the class I (mostly dithiol glutaredoxins) and class III (land plant-specific monothiol or dithiol glutaredoxins) are Fe/S proteins. In glutaredoxins characterised so far, the [2Fe2S] cluster is coordinated by two active-site cysteine residues and two molecules of non-covalently bound glutathione in homo-dimeric complexes bridged by the cluster. In contrast to dithiol glutaredoxins, monothiol glutaredoxins possess no or very little oxidoreductase activity, but have emerged as important players in cellular iron metabolism. In this review we summarise the recent developments of the most prominent Fe/S glutaredoxins in eukaryotes, the mitochondrial single domain monothiol glutaredoxin 5, the chloroplastic single domain monothiol glutaredoxin S14 and S16, the nuclear/cytosolic multi-domain monothiol glutaredoxin 3, and the mitochondrial/cytosolic dithiol glutaredoxin 2.

Structural Properties and Catalytic Implications of the SPASM Domain Iron-Sulfur Clusters in Methylorubrum extorquens PqqE

Understanding the relationship between the metallocofactor and its protein environment is the key to uncovering the mechanism of metalloenzymes. PqqE, a radical S-adenosylmethionine enzyme in pyrroloquinoline quinone (PQQ) biosynthesis, contains three iron-sulfur cluster binding sites. Two auxiliary iron-sulfur cluster binding sites, designated as AuxI and AuxII, use distinctive ligands compared to other proteins in the family while their functions remain unclear. Here, we investigate the electronic properties of these iron-sulfur clusters and compare the catalytic efficiency of wild-type (WT) Methylorubrum extorquens AM1 PqqE to a range of mutated constructs. Using native mass spectrometry, protein film electrochemistry, and electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy, we confirm the previously proposed incorporation of a mixture of [2Fe-2S] and [4Fe-4S] clusters at the AuxI site and are able to assign redox potentials to each of the three iron-sulfur clusters. Significantly, a conservative mutation at AuxI, C268H, shown to selectively incorporate a [4Fe-4S] cluster, catalyzes an enhancement of uncoupled S-adenosylmethionine cleavage relative to WT, together with the elimination of detectable peptide cross-linked product. While a [4Fe-4S] cluster can be tolerated at the AuxI site, the aggregate findings suggest a functional [2Fe-2S] configuration within the AuxI site. PqqE variants with nondestructive ligand replacements at AuxII also show that the reduction potential at this site can be manipulated by changing the electronegativity of the unique aspartate ligand. A number of novel mechanistic features are proposed based on the kinetic and spectroscopic data. Additionally, bioinformatic analyses suggest that the unique ligand environment of PqqE may be relevant to its role in PQQ biosynthesis within an oxygen-dependent biosynthetic pathway.

Cluster exchange reactivity of [2Fe-2S]-bridged heterodimeric BOLA1-GLRX5

Mitochondrial BOLA1 is known to form a [2Fe-2S] cluster-bridged heterodimeric complex with mitochondrial monothiol glutaredoxin GLRX5; however, the function of this heterodimeric complex is unclear. Some reports suggest redundant roles for BOLA1 and a related protein, BOLA3, with both involved in the maturation of [4Fe-4S] clusters in a subset of mitochondrial proteins. However, a later report on the structure of BOLA1-GLRX5 heterodimeric complex demonstrated a buried cluster environment and predicted a redox role instead of the cluster trafficking role suggested for the BOLA3-GLRX5 heterodimeric complex. Herein, we describe a detailed kinetic study of relative cluster exchange reactivity involving heterodimeric complex of BOLA1 with GLRX5. By the use of CD spectroscopy, it is demonstrated that [2Fe-2S]-bridged BOLA1-GLRX5 can be readily formed by cluster uptake from donors such as ISCU or [2Fe-2S](GS)₄ complex, but not from ISCA1 or ISCA2. Rapid holo-formation following delivery from [2Fe-2S](GS)₄ supports possible physiological relevance in the cellular labile iron pool. Holo [2Fe-2S] BOLA1-GLRX5 heterodimeric complex is incapable of donating cluster to apo protein acceptors, providing experimental support for a nontrafficking role. Finally, we report the formation and reactivity of the holo [2Fe-2S]-bridged BOLA1 homodimer (lacking a partner GLRX). While the holo-heterodimer is thermodynamically more stable, by contrast the holo BOLA1 homodimer does demonstrate facile cluster exchange reactivity.