Void Space versus Surface Functionalization for Proton Conduction in Metal-Organic Frameworks

From Data to Discovery: Recent Trends of Machine Learning in Metal-Organic Frameworks

Renowned for their high porosity and structural diversity, metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) are a promising class of materials for a wide range of applications. In recent decades, with the development of large-scale databases, the MOF community has witnessed innovations brought by data-driven machine learning methods, which have enabled a deeper understanding of the chemical nature of MOFs and led to the development of novel structures. Notably, machine learning is continuously and rapidly advancing as new methodologies, architectures, and data representations are actively being investigated, and their implementation in materials discovery is vigorously pursued. Under these circumstances, it is important to closely monitor recent research trends and identify the technologies that are being introduced. In this Perspective, we focus on emerging trends of machine learning within the field of MOFs, the challenges they face, and the future directions of their development.

Anisotropic Superprotonic Conduction in a Layered Single-Component Hydrogen-Bonded Organic Framework with Multiple In-Plane Open Channels

Hydrogen-bonded organic frameworks (HOFs) are promising proton conductive materials because of their inherent and abundant hydrogen-bonding sites. However, most superprotonic-conductive HOFs are constructed from multiple components to enable favorable framework architectures and structural integrity. In this contribution, layered HOF-TPB-A3 with a single component is synthesized and exfoliated. The exfoliated nanoplates exhibited anisotropic superprotonic conduction, with in-plane proton conductivities reaching 1.34 × 10-2 S cm-1 at 296 K and 98% relative humidity (RH). This outperforms the previously reported single-component HOFs and is comparable with the state-of-the-art multiple-component HOFs. The high and anisotropic proton conductive properties can be attributed to the efficient proton transport along multiple open channels parallel to their basal planes. Moreover, an all-solid-state (ASS) proton rectifier device is demonstrated by combining HOF-TPB-A3 and a hydroxide ion-conducting layered double hydroxide (LDH). This work suggests that single-component HOFs with multiple open channels offer more opportunities as versatile platforms for proton conductors, making them promising candidates for conducting media in protonic devices.

Superprotonic Conductivity by Synergistic Blending of Coordination Polymers with Organic Polymers: Fabrication of Durable and Flexible Proton Exchange Membranes

Creation of an efficient and cost-effective proton exchange membrane (PEM) has emerged as a propitious solution to address the challenges of renewable energy development. Coordination polymers (CPs) have garnered significant interest due to their multifunctional applications and moldability, along with long-range order. To leverage the potential of CPs in fuel cells, it is essential to integrate microcrystalline CPs into organic polymers to prepare membranes and avoid grain boundary issues. In this study, we designed and synthesized CPs containing imidazole and sulfonate moieties via gel-to-crystal transformation. The integration of CPs into the PVDF-PVP matrix resulted in superprotonic conductivity in the order of 10-2 S cm-1 at room temperature (30 °C) and 98 % RH. The proton conductivity achieved with CP-integrated composite membrane was 4.69×10-2 S cm-1 at 80 °C and 98 % RH, the highest among all CP/MOF-integrated PVDF-PVP membranes under hydrous conditions. The excellent compatibility of CPs with PVDF-PVP produced highly flexible membranes with superior mechanical, chemical, and thermal stability. About 25 times higher proton conductivity value was achieved with membrane, compared to intrinsic CPs, at RT and 98 % RH. Thus, we present a cost-effective CP-integrated mixed-matrix membrane with superprotonic conductivity and long-term durability for cutting-edge fuel cell development.

Robust and Adhesive Laminar Solid Electrolyte with Homogenous and Fast Li-Ion Conduction for High-Performance All-Solid-State Lithium Metal Battery

Constructing composite solid electrolytes (CSEs) integrating the merits of inorganic and organic components is a promising approach to developing high-performance all-solid-state lithium metal batteries (ASSLMBs). CSEs are now capable of achieving homogeneous and fast Li-ion flux, but how to escape the trade-off between mechanical modulus and adhesion is still a challenge. Herein, a strategy to address this issue is proposed, that is, intercalating highly conductive, homogeneous, and viscous-fluid ionic conductors into robust coordination laminar framework to construct laminar solid electrolyte with homogeneous and fast Li-ion conduction (LSE-HFC). A 9 µm-thick LSH-HFC, in which poly(ethylene oxide)/succinonitrile is adsorbed by coordination laminar framework with metal-organic framework nanosheets as building blocks, is used here as an example to determine the validity. The Li-ion transfer mechanism is verified and works across the entire LSE-HFC, which facilitates homogeneous Li-ion flux and low migration energy barriers, endowing LSE-HFC with high ionic conductivity of 5.62 × 10-4 S cm-1 and Li-ion transference number of 0.78 at 25 °C. Combining the outstanding mechanical strength against punctures and the enhanced adhesion force with electrodes, LSE-HFC harvests uniform Li plating/stripping behavior. These enable the realization of high-energy-density ASSLMBs with excellent cycling stability when being assembled as LiFePO4/Li and LiNi0.6Mn0.2Co0.2O2/Li cells.

Translocation and Confinement of Tetraamines in Adaptable Microporous Cavities

Metal-Organic Frameworks can be grafted with amines by coordination to metal vacancies to create amine-appended solid adsorbents, which are being considered as an alternative to using aqueous amine solutions for CO2 capture. In this study, we propose an alternative mechanism that does not rely on the use of neutral metal vacancies as binding sites but is enabled by the structural adaptability of heterobimetallic Ti2Ca2 clusters. The combination of hard (Ti4+) and soft (Ca2+) metal centers in the inorganic nodes of the framework enables MUV-10 to adapt its pore windows to the presence of triethylenetetramine molecules. This dynamic cluster response facilitates the translocation and binding of tetraamine inside the microporous cavities to enable the formation of bis-coordinate adducts that are stable in water. The extension of this grafting concept from MUV-10 to larger cavities not restrictive to CO2 diffusion will complement other strategies available for the design of molecular sorbents for decarbonization applications.

Prominent Intrinsic Proton Conduction in Two Robust Zr/Hf Metal-Organic Frameworks Assembled by Bithiophene Dicarboxylate

To date, developing crystalline proton-conductive metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) with an inherent excellent proton-conducting ability and structural stability has been a critical priority in addressing the technologies required for sustainable development and energy storage. Bearing this in mind, a multifunctional organic ligand, 3,4-dimethylthiophene[2,3-b]thiophene-2,5-dicarboxylic acid (H2DTD), was employed to generate two exceptionally stable three-dimensional porous Zr/Hf MOFs, [Zr6O4(OH)4(DTD)6]·5DMF·H2O (Zr-DTD) and [Hf6O4(OH)4(DTD)6]·4DMF·H2O (Hf-DTD), using solvothermal means. The presence of Zr6 or Hf6 nodes, strong Zr/Hf-O bonds, the electrical influence of the methyl group, and the steric effect of the thiophene unit all contribute to their structural stability throughout a wide pH range as well as in water. Their proton conductivity was fully examined at various relative humidities (RHs) and temperatures. Creating intricate and rich H-bonded networks between the guest water molecules, coordination solvent molecules, thiophene-S, -COOH, and -OH units within the framework assisted proton transfer. As a result, both MOFs manifest the maximum proton conductivity of 0.67 × 10-2 and 4.85 × 10-3 S·cm-1 under 98% RH/100 °C, making them the top-performing proton-conductive Zr/Hf-MOFs. Finally, by combining structural characteristics and activation energies, potential proton conduction pathways for the two MOFs were identified.

Breathing Behavior and Superprotonic Conductivity of Two-Dimensional Flexible Metal-Organic Frameworks Tuned with Alkoxy Groups

Flexible metal-organic frameworks (FMOFs) exhibit reversible structural transitions ("breathing" behaviors), which can regulate the proton transport passageway effectively. This property offers remarkable advantages for improving the proton conductivity. Our objective of this work is to design a single-variable flexibility synergistic strategy for the fabrication of FMOFs with high conductivity. Herein, four two-dimensional FMOFs, {[Co(4-bpdb)(R-ip)]·xsolvents}n (x = rich, 1-4), have been successfully designed and assembled (4-bpdb = 1,4-bis(4-pyridyl)-2,3-diaza-1,3-butadiene and R-ip = MeO/EtO/n-PrO/n-BuO-isophthalate). Upon the release and/or absorption of different solvent molecules, they display reversible breathing behaviors, thereby resulting in the formation of the partial and complete solvent-free compounds {[Co(4-bpdb)(R-ip)]·ysolvents}n (y = free or poor, 1A-4A). This breathing behavior involves the synergistic self-adaption of the dynamic torsion of alkoxy groups and reversible structural transformation, leading to remarkable changes in cell parameters and void space, as evidenced by single-crystal X-ray diffraction, powder X-ray diffraction, and N2 and CO2 adsorption analyses. At 363 K and 98% relative humidity, 2A exhibits the best proton conductivity among the FMOFs. Its conductivity reaches 4.08 × 10-2 S cm-1 and is one of the highest conductivities shown by reported unmodified MOF-based proton conductors.

Square-planar Tetranuclear Cluster-based Alkaline Earth Metal-organic Frameworks with Enhanced Proton Conductivity

Alkaline earth (AE) metal complexes have garnered significant interest in various functional fields due to their nontoxicity, low density, and low cost. However, there is a lack of systematic investigation into the structural characteristics and physical properties of AE-metal-organic frameworks (MOFs). In this research, we synthesized isostructural MOFs consisting of AE4(μ4-Cl) clusters bridged by benzo-(1,2;3,4;5,6)-tris(thiophene-2'-carboxylic acid) (BTTC3-) ligands. The resulting structure forms a truncated octahedral cage denoted as [AE4(m4-Cl)]6(BTTC)8, which further linked to a porous three-dimensional framework. Among the investigated AE ions (Ca, Sr, and Ba), the Ca4-MOF demonstrated good chemical stability in water compared to Sr4-MOF and Ba4-MOF. The N2 adsorption and solid-state UV-vis-NIR absorption behaviors were evaluated for all AE4-MOFs, showing similar trends among the different metal ions. Additionally, the proton conduction study revealed that the Ca4-MOF exhibited ultra-high proton conductivity, reaching 3.52×10-2 S cm-1 at 343 K and 98 % RH. Notably, the introduction of LiCl via guest exchange resulted in an improved proton conduction of up to 6.36×10-2 S cm-1 under similar conditions in the modified LiCl@Ca4-MOF. The findings shed light on the regulation of physical properties and proton conductivity of AE-MOFs, providing valuable insights for their potential applications in various fields.

Three-Dimensional Polyoxometalate Organic Frameworks with One-Dimensional Channels Constructed by Multiple Helical Chains Based on 22-Core Ln/Mn/Mo Clusters for Proton Conduction

Two unique 22-core sandwich {[Mn6Mo6O37]Ln3[MnMo6O24]} (Ln = La or Pr) units have been assembled, featuring an undisclosed {Mn6Mo6} cluster. This assembly is subsequently integrated into two three-dimensional polyoxometalate organic frameworks, which exhibit one-dimensional hydrophilic hexagonal channels formed by six intertwined 63 helical chains, leading to effective proton conduction primarily facilitated by an abundance of water molecules within the channels.

Insight into the Isoreticularity of Li-MOFs for the Design of Low-Density Solid and Quasi-Solid Electrolytes

Isoreticularity in metal organic frameworks (MOFs) allows the design of the framework structure and tailoring the pore aperture at the molecular level. The optimal pore volume, long-range order of framework expansion, and crystallite size (grain size) could enable improving Li-ion conduction, thereby providing a unique opportunity to design high-performance solid and quasi-solid electrolytes. However, definitive understanding of the pore aperture, framework expansion, and crystallite size on the Li-ion conduction and its mechanism in MOFs remains at the exploratory stage. Among the different MOF subfamilies, Li-MOFs created by the isoreticular framework expansion using dicarboxylates of benzene, naphthalene, and biphenyl building blocks emerge as low-density porous solids with exceptional thermal stability to study the solid-state Li+ transport mechanisms. Herein, we report the subtle effect of the isoreticularity in Li-MOFs on the performance of solid and quasi-solid-state Li+ conduction, providing new insight into Li+ transport mechanisms in MOFs for the first time. Our experimental and computational results show that the reticular design on an isostructural extended framework structure with the optimal pore aperture and crystallite size can influence the Li+ conductivity, exhibiting comparable ionic conductivities to solid polymer electrolytes at room temperature. Aligning with the computational studies, our experimental absorption spectral traces of solid electrolytes prepared by encapsulating lithium salt (LiClO4) and the plasticizer (ethylene carbonate) with Li-MOFs confirm the participation of the free and bound states of Li+ in a pore filling-driven ion conduction mechanism. We postulate that porous channels of Li-MOFs aid free Li+ to move through the pores via a vehicle-type mechanism, in which the pore-filled plasticizer acts as a carrier for mobile Li+ while the framework's functional sites transport the bound state of Li+ via an ion hopping mechanism from one crystallite site to another. Our computational studies performed on the Li+ conduction pathway validated the postulated pore filling mechanism and confirmed the involvement of bridging complexes, formed by binding Li+ onto the framework's functional sites as well as to the pore-filled ethylene carbonates. The Li+ diffusion energy barrier profiles along with the respective conformational changes during the diffusion of Li+ in solid electrolytes prepared from Li-BDC MOF and Li-NDC MOF strongly support the cooperative movement of Li+ ions via ion hopping along the framework's edges and vehicle-type transfer, involving the pore-filled plasticizer. Our findings suggest that cooperative function of the optimal pore volume, framework expansion, and crystallite size play a unique role in Li-ion conduction, thereby providing design guidelines for the low-density solid and quasi-solid electrolytes.

A Multifunctional Co-Based Metal-Organic Framework as a Platform for Proton Conduction and Ni trophenols Reduction

The design and development of proton conduction materials for clean energy-related applications is obviously important and highly desired but challenging. An ultrastable cobalt-based metal-organic framework Co-MOF, formulated as [Co2(btzip)2(μ2-OH2)] (namely, LCUH-103, H2btzip = 4, 6-bis(triazol-1-yl)-isophthalic acid) had been successfully synthesized via the hydrothermal method. LCUH-103 exhibits a three-dimensional framework and a one-dimensional microporous channel structure with scu topology based on the binuclear metallic cluster {Co2}. LCUH-103 indicated excellent chemical and thermal stability; peculiarly, it can retain its entire framework in acid and alkali solutions with different pH values for 24 h. The excellent stability is a prerequisite for studying its proton conductivity, and its proton conductivity σ can reach up to 1.25 × 10-3 S·cm-1 at 80 °C and 100% relative humidity (RH). In order to enhance its proton conductivity, the proton-conducting material Im@LCUH-103 had been prepared by encapsulating imidazole molecules into the channels of LCUH-103. Im@LCUH-103 indicated an excellent proton conductivity of 3.18 × 10-2 S·cm-1 at 80 °C and 100% RH, which is 1 order of magnitude higher than that of original LCUH-103. The proton conduction mechanism was systematically studied by various detection means and theoretical calculations. Meanwhile, LCUH-103 is also an excellent carrier for palladium nanoparticles (Pd NPs) via a wetness impregnation strategy, and the nitrophenols (4/3/2-NP) reduction in aqueous solution by Pd@LCUH-103 indicated an outstanding conversion efficiency, high rate constant (k), and exceptional cycling stability. Specifically, the k value of 4-NP reduction by Pd@LCUH-103 is superior to many other reported catalysts, and its k value is as high as 1.34 min-1 and the cycling stability can reach up to 6 cycles. Notably, its turnover frequency (TOF) value is nearly 196.88 times more than that of Pd/C (wt 5%) in the reaction, indicating its excellent stability and catalytic activity.

Recent Progress of Crystalline Porous Frameworks for Intermediate-Temperature Proton Conduction

Proton exchange membranes (PEMs), especially for work under intermediate temperatures (100-200 °C), have attracted great interest because of the high CO toleration and facial water management of the corresponding proton exchange membrane fuel cells (PEMFCs). Traditional polymer PEMs faced challenges of low stability and proton carrier leaking. Crystalline porous materials, such as metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) and covalent organic frameworks (COFs), are promising to overcome these issues contributed by nanometer-sized channels. Herein we summarized the recent development of MOF/COF-based intermediate-temperature proton conductors. The strategies of framework engineering and pore impregnation were introduced in detail for raising proton conductivity. The proton-conducting mechanism was described as well. This spotlight will provide new insight into the fabrication of MOF/COF proton conductors under intermediate-temperature and anhydrous conditions.

Super Proton Conductivity Through Control of Hydrogen-Bonding Networks in Flexible Metal-Organic Frameworks

Metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) have received much attention as a solid-state electrolyte in proton exchange membrane fuel cells. The introduction of proton carriers and functional groups into MOFs can improve the proton conductivity attributed to the formation of hydrogen-bonding networks, while the underlying synergistic mechanism is still unclear. Here, a series of flexible MOFs (MIL-88B, [Fe3 O(OH)(H2 O)2 (O2 C-C6 H4 -CO2 )3 ] with imidazole) is designed to modify the hydrogen-bonding networks and investigate the resulting proton-conducting characteristics by controlling the breathing behaviors. The breathing behavior is tuned by varying the amount of adsorbed imidazole into pore (small breathing (SB) and large breathing (LB)) and introducing functional groups onto ligands (-NH2 , -SO3 H), resulting in four kinds of imidazole-loaded MOFs-Im@MIL-88B-SB, Im@MIL-88B-LB, Im@MIL-88B-NH2 , and Im@MIL-88B-SO3 H. Im@MIL-88B-LB without functional groups exhibits the highest proton conductivity of 8.93 × 10-2  S cm-1 at 60 °C and 95% relative humidity among imidazole-loaded proton conductors despite the mild condition, indicating that functional groups may not be always required to enhance proton conductivity. The elaborately controlled pore size and host-guest interaction in flexible MOFs through imidazole-dependent structural transformation are translated into the high proton concentration without the limitation of proton mobility, contributing to the formation of effective hydrogen-bonding networks in imidazole conducting media.

Investigation of the Influence of Functionalization Strategy on Urea 2D MOF Catalytic Performance

Urea-functionalized MOFs with unique properties have recently been used as efficient platforms to conduct organocatalytic reactions. To gain more insight into the key factors which govern an efficient organocatalytic reaction in urea-MOFs, two different urea-containing 2D MOFs TMU-58 ([Zn(L1)(oba)].CH₃CN) and TMU-83 ([Zn(L2)(oba)].DMF), where L1 = (1E,5E)-1,5-bis(1-(pyridine-4-ylethylidene)carbonohydrazide, L2 = (1E,5E)-1,5-bis(1-(pyridine-4-ylmethylene)carbonohydrazide, and oba = 4,4'-oxybisbenzoic acid, with abundant accessible active sites, were selected and examined in the methanolysis of styrene oxide. TMU-58 with the ability to form a two-point H-bond with different substrates revealed a high organocatalytic efficiency in the regioselective ring opening of styrene oxide. The catalytic activation of epoxide oxygen by the urea N-H functional sites, followed by the nucleophilic attack of methanol at the benzylic carbon led to the formation of 2-methoxy-2-phenylethanol as the major product. DFT calculations were also performed to investigate the acidic strength of the urea hydrogens in both TMU-58 and TMU-83 structures as a major factor to conduct an efficient catalytic reaction. The results indicated the more acidic nature of the urea hydrogens in TMU-83; however, its catalytic efficiency was remarkably reduced due to the inappropriate orientation of the active interaction sites within the framework revealing the importance of proper orientation of the urea hydrogens in conducting an efficient organocatalytic reaction. The current study provides a comparative study on the function-property relationship in 2D MOF assemblies which has not been explored so far.

Bio-Inspired Synthetic Hydrogen-Bonded Organic Frameworks for Efficient Proton Conduction

Hydrogen-bonded organic frameworks (HOFs) are a rising class of promising proton-conducting materials. However, they always suffer from the inherent contradiction between chemical stability and proton conduction. Herein, inspired by the self-assembly of lipid bilayer membranes, a series of aminomethylphosphonic acid-derived single-component HOFs are successfully developed with different substituents attached to the phosphonate oxygen group. They remain highly stable in strong acid or alkaline water solutions for one month owing to the presence of charge-assisted hydrogen bonds. Interestingly, in the absence of external proton carriers, the methyl-substituted phosphonate-based HOF exhibits a very high proton conductivity of up to 4.2 × 10^-3  S cm^-1 under 80 °C and 98% relative humidity. This value is not only comparable to that of HOFs consisting of mixed ligands but also is the highest reported in single-component HOFs. A combination of single-crystal structure analysis and density functional theory calculations reveals that the high conductivity is attributed to the strengthened H-bonding interactions between positively charged amines and negatively charged phosphonate groups in the channel of bio-inspired HOFs. This finding demonstrates that the well-defined molecular structure of proton conductors is of great importance in the precise understanding of the relationship between structure and property.

Keeping Superprotonic Conductivity over a Wide Temperature Region via Sulfate Hopping Sites-Decorated Zirconium-Oxo Clusters

Metal-oxo clusters have emerged as advanced proton conductors with well-defined and tunable structures. Nevertheless, the exploitation of metal-oxo clusters with high and stable proton conductivity over a relatively wide temperature range still remains a great challenge. Herein, three sulfate groups decorated zirconium-oxo clusters (Zr₆ , Zr₁₈ , and Zr₇₀ ) as proton conductors are reported, which exhibit ultrahigh bulk proton conductivities of 1.71 × 10^-1 , 2.01 × 10^-2 , and 3.73 × 10^-2  S cm^-1 under 70 °C and 98% relative humidity (RH), respectively. Remarkably, Zr₆ and Zr₇₀ with multiple sulfate groups as proton hopping sites show ultralow activation energies of 0.22 and 0.18 eV, respectively, and stable bulk conductivities of >10^-2  S cm^-1 between 30 and 70 °C at 98% RH. Moreover, a time-dependent proton conductivity test reveals that the best performing Zr₆ can maintain high proton conductivity up to 15 h with negligible loss at 70 °C and 98% RH, representing one of the best crystalline cluster-based proton conducting materials.

One-pot self-assembly synthesis of H3+xPMo12−xVxO40@[Cu6O(TZI)3(H2O)9(NO3)n]·(H2O)15 for enhanced proton conduction materials

One-pot self-assembly encapsulation of PMoVx in rht-MOF-1 affords enhanced the proton conduction material PMoVx@rht-MOF-1.

Porosity regulation of metal-organic frameworks for high proton conductivity by rational ligand design: mono- versus disulfonyl-4,4′-biphenyldicarboxylic acid

Porous crystalline metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) bearing sulfonic groups (–SO3H) are receiving increasing attention as solid-state proton-conductors because the –SO3H group can not only enhance the proton concentration but also form...

Dual-Functional Metal-Organic Framework for Luminescent Detection of Carcinoid Biomarkers and High Proton Conduction

It remains a challenge to exploit dual-functional metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) for applications, including luminescence detection and proton conduction. With the deliberate selection of the bifunctional organic ligand 5-sulfoisophthalic acid monosodium salt (NaH₂bts), and the phosphonic acid ligand N,N'-piperazine (bismethylenephosphonic acid; H₄L), a robust three-dimensional (3D) noninterpenetrating dual-functional MOF, [Tb(H₂L)(H₂bts)(H₂O)]·H₂O (1), has been synthesized hydrothermally. On the basis of the excellent thermal and chemical as well as superior luminescence stabilities in water and solutions with different pHs, 1 can serve as the simple, rapid, and highly selective and sensitive luminescence detection of the carcinoid biomarkers 5-hydroxytryptamine (HT) and its metabolite 5-hydroxyindole-3-acetic acid (HIAA) with detection limits of nanomolar magnitude in water and in simulated blood plasma and urine systems. Due to the change in the signals that could be readily differentiated by the naked eye under a UV lamp, a portable test paper has been developed. The probable quenching mechanisms are discussed in detail. In addition, a great number of hydrogen-bonding networks are formed among the uncoordinated carboxylic oxygen atoms, sulfonate oxygen atoms, protonated nitrogen atoms, and water molecules, which provide potential proton-hopping sites for proton conduction, leading to a maximum proton conductivity of 2.3 × 10^-4 S cm^-1 at 368 K and 95% relative humidity. The above results suggest that rationally designed dual-functional MOFs can open an avenue for the development of occupational diagnostic tools and alternative energy technology.