Molecular Transition Metal Oxide Electrocatalysts for the Reversible Carbon Dioxide-Carbon Monoxide Transformation

Heterometallic Transition Metal Oxides Containing Lewis Acids as Molecular Catalysts for the Reduction of Carbon Dioxide to Carbon Monoxide with Bimodal Activity

Electrocatalytic CO2 reduction (e-CO2RR) to CO is replete with challenges including the need to carry out e-CO2RR at low overpotentials. Previously, a tricopper-substituted polyoxometalate was shown to reduce CO2 to CO with a very high faradaic efficiency albeit at -2.5 V versus Fc/Fc+. It is now demonstrated that introducing a nonredox metal Lewis acid, preferably GaIII, as a binding site for CO2 in the first coordination sphere of the polyoxometalate, forming heterometallic polyoxometalates, e.g., [SiCuIIFeIIIGaIII(H2O)3W9O37]8-, leads to bimodal activity optimal both at -2.5 and -1.5 V versus Fc/Fc+; reactivity at -1.5 V being at an overpotential of ∼150 mV. These results were observed by cyclic voltammetry and quantitative controlled potential electrolysis where high faradaic efficiency and chemoselectivity were obtained at -2.5 and -1.5 V. A reaction with 13CO2 revealed that CO2 disproportionation did not occur at -1.5 V. EPR spectroscopy showed reduction, first of CuII to CuI and FeIII to FeII and then reduction of a tungsten atom (WVI to WV) in the polyoxometalate framework. IR spectroscopy showed that CO2 binds to [SiCuIIFeIIIGaIII(H2O)3W9O37]8- before reduction. In situ electrochemical attenuated total reflection surface-enhanced infrared absorption spectroscopy (ATR-SEIRAS) with pulsed potential modulated excitation revealed different observable intermediate species at -2.5 and -1.5 V. DFT calculations explained the CV, the formation of possible activated CO2 species at both -2.5 and -1.5 V through series of electron transfer, proton-coupled electron transfer, protonation and CO2 binding steps, the active site for reduction, and the role of protons in facilitating the reactions.

Pd-incorporated polyoxometalate catalysts for electrochemical CO2 reduction

Polyoxometalates (POMs), representing anionic metal-oxo clusters, display diverse properties depending on their structures, constituent elements, and countercations. These characteristics position them as promising catalysts or catalyst precursors for electrochemical carbon dioxide reduction reaction (CO2RR). This study synthesized various salts-TBA+ (tetra-n-butylammonium), Cs+, Sr2+, and Ba2+-of a dipalladium-incorporated POM (Pd2, [γ-H2SiW10O36Pd2(OAc)2]4-) immobilized on a carbon support (Pd2/C). The synthesized catalysts-TBAPd2/C, CsPd2/C, SrPd2/C, and BaPd2/C-were deposited on a gas-diffusion carbon electrode, and the CO2RR performance was subsequently evaluated using a gas-diffusion flow electrolysis cell. Among the catalysts tested, BaPd2/C exhibited high selectivity toward carbon monoxide (CO) production (ca. 90%), while TBAPd2/C produced CO and hydrogen (H2) with moderate selectivity (ca. 40% for CO and ca. 60% for H2). Moreover, BaPd2/C exhibited high selectivity toward CO production over 12 h, while palladium acetate, a precursor of Pd2, showed a significant decline in CO selectivity during the CO2RR. Although both BaPd2/C and TBAPd2/C transformed into Pd nanoparticles and WO x nanospecies during the CO2RR, the influence of countercations on their product selectivity was significant. These results highlight that POMs and their countercations can effectively modulate the catalytic performance of POM-based electrocatalysts in CO2RR.

Polyoxometalate-Structured Materials: Molecular Fundamentals and Electrocatalytic Roles in Energy Conversion

Polyoxometalates (POMs), a kind of molecular metal oxide cluster with unique physical-chemical properties, have made essential contributions to creating efficient and robust electrocatalysts in renewable energy systems. Due to the fundamental advantages of POMs, such as the diversity of molecular structures and large numbers of redox active sites, numerous efforts have been devoted to extending their application areas. Up to now, various strategies of assembling POM molecules into superstructures, supporting POMs on heterogeneous substrates, and POMs-derived metal compounds have been developed for synthesizing electrocatalysts. From a multidisciplinary perspective, the latest advances in creating POM-structured materials with a unique focus on their molecular fundamentals, electrocatalytic roles, and the recent breakthroughs of POMs and POM-derived electrocatalysts, are systematically summarized. Notably, this paper focuses on exposing the current states, essences, and mechanisms of how POM-structured materials influence their electrocatalytic activities and discloses the critical requirements for future developments. The future challenges, objectives, comparisons, and perspectives for creating POM-structured materials are also systematically discussed. It is anticipated that this review will offer a substantial impact on stimulating interdisciplinary efforts for the prosperities and widespread utilizations of POM-structured materials in electrocatalysis.

Connecting Biological and Synthetic Approaches for Electrocatalytic CO2 Reduction

Electrocatalytic CO2 reduction has developed into a broad field, spanning fundamental studies of enzymatic 'model' catalysts to synthetic molecular catalysts and heterogeneous gas diffusion electrodes producing commercially relevant quantities of product. This diversification has resulted in apparent differences and a disconnect between seemingly related approaches when using different types of catalysts. Enzymes possess discrete and well understood active sites that can perform reactions with high selectivity and activities at their thermodynamic limit. Synthetic small molecule catalysts can be designed with desired active site composition but do not yet display enzyme-like performance. These properties of the biological and small molecule catalysts contrast with heterogeneous materials, which can contain multiple, often poorly understood active sites with distinct reactivity and therefore introducing significant complexity in understanding their activities. As these systems are being better understood and the continuously improving performance of their heterogeneous active sites closes the gap with enzymatic activity, this performance difference between heterogeneous and enzymatic systems begins to close. This convergence removes the barriers between using different types of catalysts and future challenges can be addressed without multiple efforts as a unified picture for the biological-synthetic catalyst spectrum emerges.

Conductive Covalent Organic Frameworks of Polymetallophthalocyanines as a Tunable Platform for Electrocatalysis

Developing an electrocatalyst platform that can control the interplay among activity, selectivity, and stability at atomic precision remains a grand challenge. Here, we have synthesized highly crystalline polymetallophthalocyanines (pMPcs, M = Fe, Co, Ni, and Cu) through the annulation of tetracyanobenzene in the presence of transition metals. The conjugated, conductive, and stable backbones with precisely installed metal sites render pMPcs a unique platform in electrochemical catalysis, where tunability emerges from long-range interactions. The construction of pCoNiPc with a Co and Ni dual-site integrates the advantageous features of pCoPc and pNiPc in electrocatalytic CO2 reduction through electronic communication of the dual-site with an unprecedented long atomic separation of ≥14 chemical bonds. This integration provides excellent activity (current density, j = -16.0 and -100 mA cm-2 in H-type and flow cell, respectively), selectivity (CO Faraday efficiency, FECO = 94%), and stability (>10 h), making it one of the best-performing reticular materials.

Nickel oxide/copper nanocluster anchored in carbon-nitride nanosheets realizing ultrahigh stability and broad potential range for zero-gap membrane flow reactor towards CO2-into-CO electroreduction

CO2 electrochemical reduction is a sustainable approach to achieve chemical fixation of CO2 and storage of renewable energy. However, the catalyst which has the ability of mediating CO2 to a single product with a relatively high current density is highly demand. Herein, we reported a metallic nitrogen-carbon catalyst based on two kinds of metal phthalocyanines by a facile synthesis method. The synergistic effect of Cu and Ni and the active sites of nickel oxide/copper nanocluster endow the catalyst excellent performance towards CO2-into-CO electroreduction. Typically, the Cu-Ni bimetallic catalyst achieves high selectivity (85.2 %) at positive potential (-0.72 VRHE), with the stability of current density and product selectivity beyond 72 h. The volume ratio of CO/H2 can be effectively tuned (from 2:1, 1:1 to 1:2) by controlling the electrolysis potential, which is promising for synthesis gas in the Fischer-Tropsch reactions and methanol synthesis. Furthermore, the advantages are further amplified by applying it to zero-gap membrane flow reactor, which can enhance the selectivity over 90 % at a broad potential range (-2.5 ∼ -2.7 V) and achieve an current density of 9-fold of H-type cell. Our work proves a way for optimizing the CO2 electrocatalyst and electrolyzers.

Selective electrochemical CO2 conversion with a hybrid polyoxometalate

A multi-component coordination compound, in which ruthenium antenna complexes are connected to a polyoxotungstate core is presented. This hybrid cluster effectively promotes the electrochemical conversion of CO2 to C1 feedstocks, the selectivity of which can be controlled by the acidity of the media.

Two bimetal-doped (Fe/Co, Mn) polyoxometalate-based hybrid compounds for visible-light-driven CO2 reduction

Two polyoxometalate (POM)-based hybrid compounds have been successfully designed and constructed by the hydrothermal method with molecular formulas [K(H₂O)₂FeII0.33Co_0.67(H₂O)₂(DAPSC)]₂{[FeII0.33Co_0.67(H₂O)(DAPSC)]₂[FeII0.33Co_0.67(H₂O)₄]₂[Na₂FeIII4P₄W₃₂O₁₂₀]}·21.5H₂O (1), and [Na(H₂O)₂FeII0.33Mn_0.67(H₂O)₂(DAPSC)]₂{[FeII0.33Mn_0.67(H₂O)(DAPSC)]₂[FeII0.33Mn_0.67(H₂O)₄]₂[Na₂FeIII4P₄W₃₂O₁₂₀(H₂O)₂]}·24H₂O (2) (DAPSC = 2,6-diacetylpyridine bis-(semicarbazone)), respectively. Structural analysis revealed that 1 and 2 consisted of metal-organic complexes containing DAPSC ligands with dumbbell-type inorganic clusters, iron-cobalt (iron-manganese) and some other ions. By utilizing a combination of strongly reducing {P₂W₁₂} units and bimetal-doped centres the CO₂ photoreduction catalytic capacity of 1 and 2 was improved. Notably, the photocatalytic performance of 1 was much better than that of 2. In CO₂ photoreduction, 1 exhibited CO selectivity as high as 90.8%. Furthermore, for 1, the CO generation rate reached 6885.1 μmol g^-1 h^-1 at 8 h with 3 mg, and its better photocatalytic performance was presumably due to the introduction of cobalt and iron elements to give 1 a more appropriate energy band structure. Further recycling experiments indicated that 1 was a highly efficient CO₂ photoreduction catalyst, which could still possess catalytic activity after several cycles.

The concept of active site in heterogeneous catalysis

Catalysis is at the core of chemistry and has been essential to make all the goods surrounding us, including fuels, coatings, plastics and other functional materials. In the near future, catalysis will also be an essential tool in making the shift from a fossil-fuel-based to a more renewable and circular society. To make this reality, we have to better understand the fundamental concept of the active site in catalysis. Here, we discuss the physical meaning - and deduce the validity and, therefore, usefulness - of some common approaches in heterogeneous catalysis, such as linking catalyst activity to a 'turnover frequency' and explaining catalytic performance in terms of 'structure sensitivity' or 'structure insensitivity'. Catalytic concepts from the fields of enzymatic and homogeneous catalysis are compared, ultimately realizing that the struggle that one encounters in defining the active site in most solid catalysts is likely the one we must overcome to reach our end goal: tailoring the precise functioning of the active sites with respect to many different parameters to satisfy our ever-growing needs. This article ends with an outlook of what may become feasible within the not-too-distant future with modern experimental and theoretical tools at hand.