Identification and characterization of SmD183-119-reactive T cells that provide T cell help for pathogenic anti-double-stranded DNA antibodies

Regulatory T cells inhibit autoantigen-specific CD4+ T cell responses in lupus-prone NZB/W F1 mice

Introduction

Progressive loss of regulatory T cell (Treg)-mediated control over autoreactive effector T cells contributes to the development of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). Accordingly, we hypothesized that Treg may also have the capacity to suppress the activation of autoreactive CD4+ T cells that are considered to drive autoimmunity.

Methods

To investigate whether Treg are involved in the control of autoreactive CD4+ T cells, we depleted CD25+ Treg cells either in vivo or in vitro, or combined both approaches before antigen-specific stimulation with the SLE-associated autoantigen SmD1(83-119) in the NZB/W F1 mouse model either after immunization against SmD1(83-119) or during spontaneous disease development. Frequencies of autoantigen-specific CD4+ T cells were determined by flow cytometry using the activation marker CD154.

Results

Both in vitro and in vivo depletion of CD25+ Treg, respectively, increased the frequencies of detectable autoantigen-specific CD4+ T cells by approximately 50%. Notably, the combined in vivo and in vitro depletion of CD25+ Treg led almost to a doubling in their frequencies. Frequencies of autoantigen-specific CD4+ T cells were found to be lower in immunized haploidentical non-autoimmune strains and increased frequencies were detectable in unmanipulated NZB/W F1 mice with active disease. In vitro re-addition of CD25+ Treg after Treg depletion restored suppression of autoantigen-specific CD4+ T cell activation.

Discussion

These results suggest that the activation and expansion of autoantigen-specific CD4+ T cells are partly controlled by Treg in murine lupus. Depletion of Treg therefore can be a useful approach to increase the detectability of autoantigen-specific CD4+ T cells allowing their detailed characterization including lineage determination and epitope mapping and their sufficient ex vivo isolation for cell culture.

Potential for Antigen-Specific Tolerizing Immunotherapy in Systematic Lupus Erythematosus

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is a chronic complex systemic autoimmune disease characterized by multiple autoantibodies and clinical manifestations, with the potential to affect nearly every organ. SLE treatments, including corticosteroids and immunosuppressive drugs, have greatly increased survival rates, but there is no curative therapy and SLE management is limited by drug complications and toxicities. There is an obvious clinical need for safe, effective SLE treatments. A promising treatment avenue is to restore immunological tolerance to reduce inflammatory clinical manifestations of SLE. Indeed, recent clinical trials of low-dose IL-2 supplementation in SLE patients showed that in vivo expansion of regulatory T cells (Treg cells) is associated with dramatic but transient improvement in SLE disease markers and clinical manifestations. However, the Treg cells that expanded were short-lived and unstable. Alternatively, antigen-specific tolerance (ASIT) approaches that establish long-lived immunological tolerance could be deployed in the context of SLE. In this review, we discuss the potential benefits and challenges of nanoparticle ASIT approaches to induce prolonged immunological tolerance in SLE.

A Central Role for HLA-DR3 in Anti-Smith Antibody Responses and Glomerulonephritis in a Transgenic Mouse Model of Spontaneous Lupus

MHC, especially HLA-DR3 and HLA-DR2, is one of the most important genetic susceptibility regions for systemic lupus erythematosus. Human studies to understand the role of specific HLA alleles in disease pathogenesis have been hampered by the presence of strong linkage disequilibrium in this region. To overcome this, we produced transgenic mice expressing HLA-DR3 (DRβ1*0301) and devoid of endogenous class II (both I-A and I-E genes, AE(0)) on a lupus-prone NZM2328 background (NZM2328.DR3(+)AE(0)). Both NZM2328 and NZM2328.DR3(+)AE(0) mice developed anti-dsDNA and glomerulonephritis, but anti-dsDNA titers were higher in the latter. Although kidney histological scores were similar in NZM2328 and NZM2328.DR3(+)AE(0) mice (7.2 ± 4.3 and 8.6 ± 5.7, respectively, p = 0.48), the onset of severe proteinuria occurred earlier in NZM2328.DR3(+)AE(0) mice compared with NZM2328 mice (median, 5 and 9 mo respectively, p < 0.001). Periarterial lymphoid aggregates, classic wire loop lesions, and occasional crescents were seen only in kidneys from NZM2328.DR3(+)AE(0) mice. Interestingly, NZM2328.DR3(+)AE(0) mice, but not NZM2328 mice, spontaneously developed anti-Smith (Sm) Abs. The anti-Sm Abs were seen in NZM2328.DR3(+)AE(0) mice that were completely devoid of endogenous class II (AE(-/) (-)) but not in mice homozygous (AE(+/+)) or heterozygous (AE(+/-)) for endogenous MHC class II. It appears that only HLA-DR3 molecules can preferentially select SmD-reactive CD4(+) T cells for generation of the spontaneous anti-Sm immune response. Thus, our mouse model unravels a critical role for HLA-DR3 in generating an autoimmune response to SmD and lupus nephritis in the NZM2328 background.

Fate determination of mature autoreactive B cells

A large antibody repertoire is generated in developing B cells in the bone marrow. Before these B cells achieve immunocompetence, those expressing autospecificities must be purged. To that end, B cells within the bone marrow and just following egress from the bone marrow are subject to tolerance induction. Once B cells achieve immunocompetence, the antibody repertoire can be further diversified by somatic hypermutation of immunoglobulin genes in B cells that have been activated by antigen and cognate T cell help and have undergone a germinal center (GC) response. This process also leads to the generation of autoreactive B cells which must be again purged to protect the host. Thus, B cells within the GC and just following egress from the GC are also subject to tolerance induction. Available data suggest that B cell intrinsic processes triggered by signaling through the B cell receptor activate tolerance mechanisms at both time points. Recent data suggest that GC and post-GC B cells are also subject to B cell extrinsic tolerance mechanisms mediated through soluble and membrane-bound factors derived from various T cell subsets.

Differential responses to Smith D autoantigen by mice with HLA-DR and HLA-DQ transgenes: dominant responses by HLA-DR3 transgenic mice with diversification of autoantibodies to small nuclear ribonucleoprotein, double-stranded DNA, and nuclear antigens

Anti-Smith (Sm) D autoantibodies are specific for systemic lupus erythematosus. In this investigation, the influence of HLA-D genes on immune responses to SmD was investigated. Mice with HLA-DR3, HLA-DR4, HLA-DQ0601, HLA-DQ0604, or HLA-DQ8 transgenes were immunized with recombinant SmD1, and their Ab responses were analyzed. Analysis by ELISA showed that all strains responded well to SmD. However, when synthetic SmD peptides were used as substrate, DR3 mice had the highest Ab response followed by DQ8, DQ0604, DQ0601, and DR4. A similar trend was observed in Western blot analysis using WEHI 7.1 cell lysate as the substrate, with the exception that DR4 mice did not generate detectable amounts of Abs. Only sera from DR3 and DQ0604 mice immunoprecipitated A-ribonucleoprotein (RNP), SmB, and SmD. Intermolecular epitope spreading to A-RNP and SmB was evident in DR3 and DQ0604 mice, as sera depleted of anti-SmD Abs were reactive with these proteins. DR3 mice also generated an immune response to C-RNP. Anti-nuclear Abs were detected in the majority of the DR3 mice, whereas moderate reactivities were seen in DQ0604 and DQ8 mice. Interestingly, only DR3 mice mounted an anti-dsDNA Ab response. Approximately half of the anti-dsDNA Abs were cross-reactive with SmD. Ab responses correlated with the strength of the T cell responses. Thus, HLA-DR3 appears to be the dominant HLA-D gene that determines the magnitude and quality of the anti-SmD immune response. In addition, our findings provide insights into the origin of the anti-dsDNA Abs often detected in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus.

Depletion of autoreactive immunologic memory followed by autologous hematopoietic stem cell transplantation in patients with refractory SLE induces long-term remission through de novo generation of a juvenile and tolerant immune system

Clinical trials have indicated that immunoablation followed by autologous hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (ASCT) has the potential to induce clinical remission in patients with refractory systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), but the mechanisms have remained unclear. We now report the results of a single-center prospective study of long-term immune reconstitution after ASCT in 7 patients with SLE. The clinical remissions observed in these patients are accompanied by the depletion of autoreactive immunologic memory, reflected by the disappearance of pathogenic anti-double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) antibodies and protective antibodies in serum and a fundamental resetting of the adaptive immune system. The latter comprises recurrence of CD31(+)CD45RA(+)CD4(+) T cells (recent thymic emigrants) with a doubling in absolute numbers compared with age-matched healthy controls at the 3-year follow-up (P = .016), the regeneration of thymic-derived FoxP3(+) regulatory T cells, and normalization of peripheral T-cell receptor (TCR) repertoire usage. Likewise, responders exhibited normalization of the previously disturbed B-cell homeostasis with numeric recovery of the naive B-cell compartment within 1 year after ASCT. These data are the first to demonstrate that both depletion of the autoreactive immunologic memory and a profound resetting of the adaptive immune system are required to reestablish self-tolerance in SLE.

Aberrant Phenotype and Function of Myeloid Dendritic Cells in Systemic Lupus Erythematosus

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is characterized by a systemic autoimmune response with profound and diverse T cell changes. Dendritic cells (DCs) are important orchestrators of immune responses and have an important role in the regulation of T cell function. The objective of this study was to determine whether myeloid DCs from individuals with SLE display abnormalities in phenotype and promote abnormal T cell function. Monocyte-derived DCs and freshly isolated peripheral blood myeloid DCs from lupus patients displayed an abnormal phenotype characterized by accelerated differentiation, maturation, and secretion of proinflammatory cytokines. These abnormalities were characterized by higher expression of the DC differentiation marker CD1a, the maturation markers CD86, CD80, and HLA-DR, and the proinflammatory cytokine IL-8. In addition, SLE patients displayed selective down-regulation of the maturation marker CD83 and had abnormal responses to maturation stimuli. These abnormalities have functional relevance, as SLE DCs were able to significantly increase proliferation and activation of allogeneic T cells when compared with control DCs. We conclude that myeloid DCs from SLE patients display significant changes in phenotype which promote aberrant T cell function and could contribute to the pathogenesis of SLE and organ damage.

Immunological memory stabilizing autoreactivity

The etiopathologies of autoimmune diseases are complex. A broad variety of cell types and gene products are involved. However, clinical and experimental evidence suggests that the importance of an individual factor changes during the course of the disease. Factors and cell types that induce acute autoreactivity and initiate an autoimmune disease could be distinct from those that drive a chronic course of that disease. Autoreactive immunological memory, in particular B cell and plasma cell memory, contributes to chronicity through several mechanisms. Formation of autoreactive memory B cells leads to an increase in the numbers of autoreactive cells. In comparison to naive B cells, these memory B cells show a decreased threshold for activation. Additionally, a fraction of memory B cells express the chemokine receptor CXCR3, which supports their accumulation within chronically inflamed tissues. This may allow their escape from mechanisms for induction of peripheral tolerance. Within the inflamed tissue, inflammatory cytokines and autoantigens provide activation signals that promote plasma cell differentiation and survival. The autoantibodies produced locally by these plasma cells contribute to the severity of inflammation. Together, an autoreactive loop of autoantibody-induced inflammation is formed. Another integral part of immunological memory are long-lived plasma cells. These cells provide persistent humoral antibody memory. Though not all autoantibodies are produced by long-lived plasma cells, these cells have a special impact on immune pathology. Long-lived plasma cells are relatively resistant to existing therapies of immunosuppression and continuously secrete antibodies, without need for restimulation. Long-lived plasma cells provide titers of autoantibodies even during clinically quiescent phases and after immunosuppression. These persisting autoantibody titers, though often low and not causing acute clinical symptoms, are likely to maintain a low level of chronic inflammation and progressive tissue destruction, which reduces the threshold for another break of immunological tolerance.

T cell cytokine imbalance towards production of IFN-gamma and IL-10 in NZB/W F1 lupus-prone mice is associated with autoantibody levels and nephritis

OBJECTIVE

The role of T cell-derived cytokine production in lupus is poorly understood. We analysed the cytokine production of CD4(+) T cells in the NZB/W F1 mouse strain, the mouse model probably most closely resembling human systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), and assessed whether a possible shift in the cytokines expressed is associated with age or disease activity.

METHODS

We used intracellular cytokine staining and flow cytometry to determine the cytokine expression of splenic CD4(+) T cells for interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma), tumour necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha), interleukin-4 (IL-4) and IL-10. NZB/W F1 mice at different ages spanning 5 to 36 weeks were analysed, healthy Balb/cxNZW F1 (CWF1) mice were used as controls. Serum anti-double-stranded DNA (anti-dsDNA) antibody levels were determined by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA), and proteinuria and plasma creatinine were estimated using commercial test kits.

RESULTS

The cytokine profile of CD4(+) T cells was shifted towards T-helper 1 (Th1) cells and the frequencies of Th cells expressing IFN-gamma(+) correlated with age, anti-dsDNA-immunoglobulin G (IgG) titre and proteinuria. An increased percentage of IL-10 producers correlated positively with anti-dsDNA-IgG and proteinuria, and a small gain in IL-4 producers correlated with plasma creatinine. Neither the percentage of IL-10 producers nor IL-4 producers showed a significant correlation with age. There was no significant change observed in the frequency of TNF-alpha T cells. The IFN-gamma/IL-4 ratio demonstrated an increasing shift towards a Th1-type response during disease development that was not present in healthy mouse strains.

CONCLUSION

The association between the frequencies of T cells expressing IFN-gamma and IL-10 and clinical findings suggests a key role for these cells in the pathogenesis of lupus.

Regulatory T cells in lupus

Naturally occurring, CD4+ CD25+ regulatory T cells that are exported from the thymus early in life play an important role in controlling organ-specific autoimmune diseases, but they may not be critical for suppressing systemic autoimmunity in lupus. On the other hand, lupus-prone subjects appear to be deficient in generation of adaptive T-regulatory cells that can be induced by various means. We review autoantigen-specific therapeutic approaches that induce such regulatory T cells. Of particular interest are TGF-ss producing CD4+ CD25+ and CD8+ regulatory T cells that are induced by low dose tolerance therapy of lupus-prone mice with nucleosomal histone peptide epitopes, administered subcutaneously in subnanomolar doses. These regulatory T cells are not only efficient in suppressing autoantigen recognition and autoantibody production, but they also inhibit migration/accumulation of pathogenic autoimmune cells in the target organ, such as the kidneys of mice prone to develop lupus nephritis. We discuss why and under what conditions such therapeutic approaches would be beneficial in lupus patients and lupus-prone subjects.

The binding of lupus-derived autoantibodies to the C-terminal peptide (83-119) of the major SmD1 autoantigen can be mediated by double-stranded DNA and nucleosomes

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the binding of lupus-derived autoantibodies, double-stranded DNA and nucleosomes to the positively charged C-terminal SmD1(residues 83-119) peptide and the full-length SmD protein.

METHODS

The binding of lupus-derived monoclonal antibodies, sera from patients with systemic lupus erythematosus, rheumatoid arthritis and systemic sclerosis, dsDNA and nucleosomes to the SmD1(83-119) peptide or the full-length SmD protein was determined using different ELISA methods.

RESULTS

Monoclonal anti-dsDNA antibodies and the serum of patients with systemic lupus erythematosus that are positive for anti-dsDNA antibodies react with the SmD1(83-119) peptide in ELISA. However, DNaseI treatment of the blocking reagents leads to a decreased reactivity. Purified dsDNA and nucleosomes bind to the SmD1 peptide but not to the full-length SmD protein.

CONCLUSIONS

The SmD1(83-119) peptide is able to bind dsDNA and nucleosomes, and dsDNA or nucleosomes in applied reagents lead to an apparent reactivity of anti-dsDNA, anti-histone or nucleosome-specific antibodies with the SmD1(83-119) peptide in ELISA.

Induction of Pathogenic Anti-dsDNA Antibodies Is Controlled on the Level of B Cells in a Non-Lupus Prone Mouse Strain

The SmD1(83-119) peptide is a main target of autoantibodies and T cells in human and murine lupus, but its role in autoimmunity induction remains elusive. Therefore, female Balb/c mice and (NZW x Balb/c)F1 [CWF1] mice with identical MHC haplotype as lupus prone NZB/W mice were immunized with SmD1(83-119). Immunizations of CWF1 mice with SmD1(83-119), but not with the controls (irrelevant peptide, HEL peptide, or saline), induced anti-SmD1(83-119) and anti-dsDNA antibodies and proteinuria not present in Balb/c mice. DsDNA-specific plasma cell induction after SmD1(83-119) immunizations was confirmed by ELISPOT assays showing that the generation of dsDNA-specific antibody forming cells (AFC) was mainly driven by increased T-cell help. T-cell help for the generation of dsDNA-specific AFC was also present in saline-treated CWF1 mice but was controlled on the levels of B cells preventing autoimmunity.

Recent developments in immunomodulatory peptides in juvenile rheumatic diseases: from trigger to dimmer?

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Current therapy for juvenile rheumatic diseases is based on general immune suppression or blocking inflammatory pathways. These treatments do not induce long-term disease remission and have a risk of side effects; this is especially unfavorable in children. It is better to focus on induction of tolerance mechanisms than on suppression of inflammation. This promotes epitope specific immunotherapy as a possible safe treatment option.

RECENT FINDINGS

In the search for specific peptides for immunotherapy in autoimmunity, the focus is shifting from purported triggers of disease to peptides that regulate the ongoing inflammation. These so-called 'immunomodulatory peptides' are important in every healthy immune system. Several juvenile rheumatic diseases have been linked to certain immunomodulatory peptides. In juvenile dermatomyositis, peptides from human skeletal myosin play a role in the perpetuation of the disease. In systemic lupus erythematosus, the focus is mostly on DNA-derived peptides and peptides from anti-DNA antibodies. In juvenile idiopathic arthritis, heat shock proteins have been shown to contain important immunomodulatory epitopes.

SUMMARY

Immunomodulatory peptides play an important role in juvenile rheumatic diseases. Promising candidates for immunotherapy have been identified. This opens the possibility of clinical testing in rheumatic diseases of childhood.

T-helper cell intrinsic defects in lupus that break peripheral tolerance to nuclear autoantigens

Special populations of T helper cells drive B cells to produce IgG class switched, pathogenic autoantibodies in lupus. The major source of antigenic determinants (epitopes) that trigger interactions between lupus T and B cells is nucleosomes of apoptotic cells. These epitopes can be used for antigen-specific therapy of lupus. Secondly, the autoimmune T cells of lupus are sustained because they resist anergy and activation-induced programmed cell death by markedly upregulating cyclooxygenase (COX) 2 along with the antiapoptotic molecule c-FLIP. Only certain COX-2 inhibitors block pathogenic anti-DNA autoantibody production in lupus by causing death of autoimmune T helper cells. Hence COX-2 inhibitors may work independently of their ability to block the enzymatic function of COX-2, and structural peculiarities of these select inhibitors may lead to better drug discovery and design.

Intravenous Injection of a D1 Protein of the Smith Proteins Postpones Murine Lupus and Induces Type 1 Regulatory T Cells

T cells that recognize nucleoproteins are required for the production of anti-dsDNA Abs involved in lupus development. SmD1 83-119 (a D1 protein of the Smith (Sm) proteins, part of small nuclear ribonucleoprotein) was recently shown to provide T cell help to anti-dsDNA Abs in the NZB/NZW model of lupus. Using this model in the present study, we showed that high dose tolerance to SmD1 (600-1000 microg i.v. of SmD1(83-119) peptide/mo) delays the production of autoantibodies, postpones the onset of lupus nephritis as confirmed by histology, and prolongs survival. Tolerance to SmD1 83-119 was adoptively transferred by CD90+ T cells, which also reduce T cell help for autoreactive B cells in vitro. One week after SmD1 83-119 tolerance induction in prenephritic mice, we detected cytokine changes in cultures of CD90+ T and B220+ B cells with decreased IFN-gamma and IL-4 expression and an increase in TGFbeta. Increased frequencies of regulatory IFN-gamma+ and IL10+ CD4+ T cells were later detected. Such regulatory IL-10+/IFN-gamma+ type 1 regulatory T cells prevented autoantibody generation and anti-CD3-induced proliferation of naive T cells. In conclusion, these results indicate that SmD1 83-119 peptide may play a dominant role in the activation of helper and regulatory T cells that influence autoantibody generation and murine lupus.

Human T cell clones specific for heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoprotein A2 autoantigen from connective tissue disease patients assist in autoantibody production

OBJECTIVE

To identify and characterize human T cells reactive with heterogeneous nuclear RNP A2 (hnRNP A2) antigen, and to determine the ability of hnRNP-reactive T cells to assist in the production of human autoantibodies.

METHODS

T cells from patients with high serum levels of anti-hnRNP IgG autoantibody were stimulated with an hnRNP recombinant fusion protein, and the cells were cloned by limiting dilution. The surface phenotype and cytokine profiles of the T cells were examined by flow cytometry and enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA), respectively. T cell clones were cultured with highly purified autologous B cells, and the ability of T cells to enhance autoantibody production under a variety of conditions was measured by ELISA.

RESULTS

Human T cells reactive with hnRNP antigen were cloned from 2 patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) and 1 patient with mixed connective tissue disease (MCTD). The T cells were CD4+ and had a Th1-like functional phenotype. In coculture in vitro with autologous B cells, T cell clones augmented anti-hnRNP autoantibody production and did so without the need for direct T cell-B cell contact.

CONCLUSION

This study provides direct evidence for a role of anti-hnRNP-reactive T cells in autoantibody production in SLE and MCTD. These findings support the notion that hnRNP-reactive T cells play a role in the pathogenesis of these diseases.

Lupus Glomerulonephritis Revisited 2004: Autoimmunity and End-Organ Damage

Histopathology of the kidney and clinical presentation are critical factors in the diagnosis of immune-mediated glomerulonephritis (GN). The histological manifestations of glomerular injury are shared by multiple underlying mechanisms. Work from our laboratory and from other investigators shows that antinuclear, antihistone or anti-dsDNA antibodies are neither required nor sufficient for development of lupus GN. In addition, antibody to dsDNA can be generated by mechanisms other than loss of tolerance to chromatin. Genetic analyses demonstrate that although there is some interaction between autoantibody production and renal disease, the phenotypes are regulated by distinct genetic intervals. Furthermore, renal failure is not an essential outcome of the immune-complex deposition and proliferative lupus GN. These data are also supported by published studies from systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) patients. The immune regulation of lupus GN is distinct from other organ-specific diseases and not influenced by CD25(+) or NK1.1(+) regulatory T cells. Thus, fatal GN may depend upon a kidney-reactive T-cell response that, in turn, may be regulated by gender and intrinsic end-organ factors. The data discussed in this review call for a re-evaluation of the current paradigms for pathogenesis of SLE. An interactive model separating autoimmunity from end-organ susceptibility for the pathogenesis of SLE is proposed.

T cell abnormalities in human and mouse lupus: intrinsic and extrinsic

The purpose of this review is to discuss recent developments in the biology and biochemistry of the T cells in mice and humans with systemic lupus erythematosus. T cells that recognize self-antigens are present in systemic lupus erythematosus and normal organisms. It is obvious, though, that an autoimmune environment should be present to disrupt anergy and instigate a response that might cause disease. The environment that lifts anergy is defined by distinct molecular aberrations that include rewiring of the T cells. Aberrant transcription of genes that encode proteins involved in autoimmunity can be traced to abnormal expression and activation of transcription factors and promoter methylation intensity. Only certain components of the autoimmune response can be linked to pathologic changes in the target organ that might be dictated by additional local factors. The works reviewed imply that self-peptides might be considered to reestablish lost tolerance, whereas correction of the aberrant biochemistry might normalize T cell function and limit disease.