Structural Elucidation of Trace Amounts of Volatile Compounds Using the Crystalline Sponge Method

Atomic-resolution structure analysis inside an adaptable porous framework

We introduce a versatile metal-organic framework (MOF) for encapsulation and immobilization of various guests using highly ordered internal water network. The unique water-mediated entrapment mechanism is applied for structural elucidation of 14 bioactive compounds, including 3 natural product intermediates whose 3D structures are clarified. The single-crystal X-ray diffraction analysis reveals that incorporated guests are surrounded by hydrogen-bonded water networks inside the pores, which uniquely adapt to each molecule, providing clearly defined crystallographic sites. The calculations of host-solvent-guest structures show that the guests are primarily interacting with the MOF through weak dispersion forces. In contrast, the coordination and hydrogen bonds contribute less to the total stabilization energy, however, they provide highly directional point interactions, which help align the guests inside the pore.

Host-guest system of a phosphorylated macrocycle assisting structure determination of oily molecules in single-crystal form

X-ray crystallography is the most reliable method for structure elucidation and absolute configuration determination of organic molecules based on their single-crystal forms. However, many analytes are hard to crystallize because of their low melting points (an oily state at room temperature) or conformational flexibility. Here, we report the crystallization of a macrocycle, CTX[P(O)Ph] (host), which is a cyclotrixylohydroquinoylene (CTX) derivative, with 26 oily organic molecules (guests), which is applied for the structural determination of the guest with X-ray crystallography. With the aid of the host, CTX[P(O)Ph], the guest molecules were well-ordered with full occupancy in crystal structures. In most cases, at least one guest structure without any disorder could be observed; solvent masking was not necessary for the single crystal X-ray structural analysis, and thus the structures of the guests could be successfully determined, and the absolute configuration could be assigned reliably for chiral guests with this method. The crystallization mechanism was further discussed from theoretical and experimental perspectives, suggesting that the negative electrostatic potential surface of CTX[P(O)Ph] and noncovalent interactions between the host and guest were crucial for the ordered arrangements of the guest.

A systematic study of the interplay between guest molecule structure and intermolecular interactions in crystalline sponges

Utilization of the crystalline sponge {[(ZnI2)3(tpt)2·x(solvent)]n} method has enabled characterization of a novel family of synthetic organic oils. The systematic structural differences and diversity of functional groups offered by 13 related molecular adsorbates provide a detailed quantitative understanding of the relationship between the guest structure, its conformation, and the type of intermolecular interactions adopted with neighbouring guests and the host framework. This analysis is extended to assess the connection of these factors to the resulting quality indicators for a particular molecular structure elucidation.

Advanced crystallisation methods for small organic molecules

Molecular materials based on small organic molecules often require advanced structural analysis, beyond the capability of spectroscopic techniques, to fully characterise them. In such cases, diffraction methods such as single crystal X-ray diffraction (SCXRD), are one of the most powerful tools available to researchers, providing molecular and structural elucidation at atomic level resolution, including absolute stereochemistry. However SCXRD, and related diffraction methods, are heavily dependent on the availability of suitable, high-quality crystals, thus crystallisation often becomes the major bottleneck in preparing samples. Following a summary of classical methods for the crystallisation of small organic molecules, this review will focus on a number of recently developed advanced methods for crystalline material sample preparation for SCXRD. This review will cover two main areas of modern small organic molecule crystallisation, namely the inclusion of molecules within host complexes (e.g., "crystalline sponge" and tetraaryladamantane based inclusion chaperones) and the use of high-throughput crystallisation, employing "under-oil" approaches (e.g., microbatch under-oil and ENaCt). Representative examples have been included for each technique, together with a discussion of their relative advantages and limitations to aid the reader in selecting the most appropriate technique to overcome a specific analytical challenge.

Highly Luminescent Crystalline Sponge: Sensing Properties and Direct X-ray Visualization of the Substrates

A phenomenon of crystalline sponge is represented by guest-dependent structural fluidity of the host polymeric lattice in highly crystalline sorbents, such as metal-organic frameworks, driven by multiple weak intermolecular interactions. Such induced fitting in MOFs is a valuable property in selective adsorption, guest determination by single-crystal XRD and in-situ structural analysis under external stimuli. In this work, a porous three-dimensional metal-organic framework [Eu₂(DMF)₄(ttdc)₃]·4.45DMF (1_DMF; DMF = N,N-dimethylformamide, ttdc^2- = trans-thienothiophenedicarboxylate anion) was applied as a crystalline sponge bearing luminescent functionality to couple its sensing properties with direct structural determination of the adsorbed molecules. As a result, the paper discusses crystal structures and luminescent properties for the successfully obtained new adducts with the crystallographic formulae [Eu₂(DMSO)₄(ttdc)₃]·2.5DMSO·2.2H₂O (1_DMSO; DMSO = dimethylsulfoxide), [Eu₂(DMF)₄(ttdc)₃]·3phet (1_phet; phet = phenylethanal) and [Eu₂(DMF)_3.5(cin)_0.5(ttdc)₃]·1.64cin (1_cin; cin = trans-cinnamaldehyde). As a result of inclusion of DMSO into 1, a slight increase in the quantum yield and excited state phosphorescence lifetime was observed, while the adsorption of phet leads to a considerable (up to three times) decrease in the corresponding values. The incorporation of cinnamal results in a full quenching of QY, from 20% down to zero, and a more than order of magnitude diminishing of the excited state lifetime compared to the initial 1_DMF. The effective sensing of cinnamal was explained from the structural point of view by its direct coordination to the Eu³⁺ emitter, as well as by multiple weak intermolecular interactions with ttdc antenna ligand, both capable of enhancing the non-radiative energy dissipation.

Highly selective acid-catalyzed olefin isomerization of limonene to terpinolene by kinetic suppression of the overreactions in a confined space of porous metal-macrocycle framework

Natural enzymes control the intrinsic reactivity of chemical reactions in the natural environment, giving only the necessary products. In recent years, challenging research on the reactivity control of terpenes with structural diversity using artificial host compounds that mimic such enzymatic reactions has been actively pursued. A typical example is the acid-catalyzed olefin isomerization of (+)-limonene, which generally gives a complex mixture due to over-isomerization to thermodynamically favored isomers. Herein we report a highly controlled conversion of (+)-limonene by kinetic suppression of over-isomerization in a confined space of a porous metal–macrocycle framework (MMF) equipped with a Brønsted acid catalyst. The terminal double bond of (+)-limonene migrated to one neighbor, preferentially producing terpinolene. This reaction selectivity was in stark contrast to the homogeneous acid-catalyzed reaction in bulk solution and to previously reported catalytic reactions. X-ray structural analysis and examination of the reaction with adsorption inhibitors suggest that the reactive substrates may bind non-covalently to specific positions in the confined space of the MMF, thereby inhibiting the over-isomerization reaction. The nanospaces of the MMF with substrate binding ability are expected to enable highly selective synthesis of a variety of terpene compounds.

A porous metal–macrocycle framework (MMF) equipped with a Brønsted acid catalyst in nanochannels enables highly selective isomerization of limonene to terpinolene by kinetically suppressing over-isomerization at confined acid sites.

Solvent Effects in the Crystalline Sponge Method: Importance of Co-solvents for Ordering Absorbed Guests

In the crystalline sponge method, the crucial step for ordering the absorbed guest is soaking of the guest into the pores of the crystalline sponge. Here, we find that the choice of solvent is particularly important for smooth guest soaking and ordering. Moderately polar solvents, such as ketones and esters, which we have previously avoided for the guest-soaking process, efficiently promote diffusion and guest ordering by filling the gaps in the pores through co-crystallization with the guests. Using this modified protocol, we successfully demonstrate the structural analysis of various steroids.

Comprehensive Structural Analysis of the Bitter Components in Beer by the HPLC-Assisted Crystalline Sponge Method

Trans-iso-α-acid is one of the main contributors to the bitter taste of fresh beer and is known to transform into various derivatives during beer aging. However, structural characterization of the derivatives has been a challenging task because of the formation of too many components. Herein, we report that most of the transformation products of trans-iso-α-acid, isolated in this study in only small quantities by HPLC, can be structurally analyzed with the crystalline sponge method. Thirteen compounds, including eight that were previously unreported, have been successfully isolated and analyzed with complete assignment of their absolute configuration. This provides an improved understanding of the chemical transformations that occur during beer aging.

Crystalline sponge X-ray analysis coupled with supercritical fluid chromatography: a novel analytical platform for the rapid separation, isolation, and characterization of analytes

Crystalline sponge (CS) based X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis allows for the observation of the structure of an analyte, including its absolute configuration. Herein we report a powerful analytical platform for the separation, isolation, and structural elucidation of a target analyte in a seamless way by coupling supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) with CS-based XRD analysis (SFC-CSXRD). The efficacy of this methodology is demonstrated by the rapid characterization of regio- and stereoisomers using three types of CSs with differing tolerances to the solvents used in SFC and guest-soaking.

Crystalline sponge affinity screening: A fast tool for soaking condition optimization without the need of X-ray diffraction analysis

Structural elucidation of small molecules only available in low quantity (nanogram) is one of the big advantages of the crystalline sponge method. The optimization of various soaking parameters is crucial for effective analyte absorption and repetitive positioning in the pores of the crystal. Time-consuming X-ray diffraction measurements are necessary for data collection and confirmation of successful guest inclusion. In this work, we report a screening method to select optimal soaking conditions without the need of single-crystal X-ray diffraction analysis for individual compounds and mixtures. 14 substances were chosen as test compounds. Parallel guest soaking of individual compounds and mixtures was conducted using various soaking conditions. After evaporation of solvent, excessive material was removed, and guest molecules released through dissolution of the framework. Liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry allowed the estimation of analyte trapped in the pores and the selection of optimal soaking condition dependent on the highest amount of analyte to crystal size (affinity factor). The tool allowed subsequent crystallographic analysis of ten compounds with minimal experiment time. Additionally, a study to examine the lower limit of detection of the crystalline sponge method was conducted. Determination of two target analytes was possible using only 5 ng of sample. Our study shows the potential of an affinity screening to prioritize soaking parameters by estimation of the guest concentration in a single crystal for one or multiple target compounds within a short period of time.

Crystalline Sponge Method: X-ray Structure Analysis of Small Molecules by Post-Orientation within Porous Crystals-Principle and Proof-of-Concept Studies

This Review discusses, along with the historical background, the principles as well as proof-of-concept studies of the crystalline sponge (CS) method, a new single-crystal X-ray diffraction (SCXRD) method for the analysis of the structures of small molecules without sample crystallization. The method uses single-crystalline porous coordination networks (crystalline sponges) that can absorb small guest molecules within their pores. The absorbed guest molecules are ordered in the pores through molecular recognition and become observable by conventional SCXRD analysis. The complex {[(ZnI₂ )₃ (tpt)₂ ]⋅x(solvent)}_n (tpt=tris(4-pyridyl)-1,3,5-triazine) was first proposed as a crystalline sponge and has been most generally used. Crystalline sponges developed later are also discussed here. The principle of the CS method can be described as "post-crystallization" of the absorbed guest, whose ordering is templated by the pre-latticed cavities. The method has been widely applied to synthetic chemistry as well as natural product studies, for which proof-of-concept examples will be shown here.

Applying the Crystalline Sponge Method to Agrochemicals: Obtaining X-ray Structures of the Fungicide Metalaxyl-M and Herbicide S-Metolachlor

The crystalline sponge method is a technique that provides the ability to elucidate the absolute structure of noncrystalline or hard to crystallize compounds through single-crystal X-ray diffraction by removing the need to obtain crystals of the target compound. In this study the crystalline sponges {[(ZnX₂)₃(2,4,6-tris(4-pyridyl)-1,3,5-trazine)₂].x(solvent)} _n (X = I, Br) were used to obtain X-ray structures of the agrochemical active ingredients metalaxyl-M and S-metolachlor. The effect of the temperature used during guest uptake and the influence of changing the host framework ZnX₂ nodes on guest encapsulation were investigated. Additionally, three compounds containing chemical fragments similar to those of metalaxyl-M and S-metolachlor (phenylacetaldehyde, N-ethyl-o-toluidine, and methyl phenylacetate) were also encapsulated. This allowed for the effect of guest size on the position that guests occupy within the host frameworks to be examined. The disorder experienced by the guest compounds was documented, and an analysis of the intermolecular host-guest interactions (CH···π and π ···π) used for guest ordering within the host frameworks was also undertaken in this study.

Application of Crystalline Matrices for the Structural Determination of Organic Molecules

While single-crystal X-ray diffraction (SC-XRD) is one of the most powerful structural determination techniques for organic molecules, the requirement of obtaining a suitable crystal for analysis limits its applicability, particularly for liquids and amorphous solids. The emergent use of preformed porous crystalline matrices that can absorb organic compounds and stabilize them via host-guest interactions for observation via SC-XRD offers a way to overcome this hindrance. A topical and current discussion of SC-XRD in organic chemistry and the use of preformed matrices for the in crystallo analysis of organic compounds, with a particular focus on the absolute structure determination of chiral molecules, is presented. Preformed crystalline matrices that are covered include metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) as used in the crystalline sponge method, metal-organic polyhedra (MOPs, coordination cages), porous organic materials (POMs)/porous organic molecular crystals (POMCs), and biological scaffolds. An outlook and perspective on the current technology and on its future directions is provided.

Combined Analysis Based on a Crystalline Sponge Method

The crystalline sponge (CS) method was developed as an X-ray crystallographic molecular structure analysis method that can be performed without the need for crystallization of the analyte. CS has strong molecular-recognition properties and a highly flexible framework. The amount of analyte can be reduced to a sub-milligram level. These features of the crystalline nano-space allow for determining the absolute structure of a trace analyte. In this review, we focus on the discovery of the CS method and its applications to biosynthetic products in combination with NMR spectroscopy. We also describe some examples of the CS method that are used mainly in combination with mass spectrometry (MS). Both approaches demonstrate the potential of microanalysis to determine the molecular structure of an unknown sample. Finally, we mention the use of a crystalline "nano-surface" rather than a crystalline nano-space in MS, which can detect small metabolites as well as post-translation biomolecules.

Elucidating pore chemistry within metal–organic frameworks via single crystal X-ray diffraction; from fundamental understanding to application

The application of metal–organic frameworks (MOFs) to diverse chemical sectors is aided by their crystallinity, which permits the use of X-ray crystallography to characterise their pore chemistry and provides invaluable insight into their properties.

Absolute Configuration of Small Molecules by Co-Crystallization

The most reliable method to determine the absolute configuration of chiral molecules is X-ray crystallography, but small molecules can be difficult to crystallize. We report rapid co-crystallization of tetraaryladamantanes with small molecules as different as n-decane to nicotine to produce crystals for X-ray analysis and the assignment of absolute configuration when the molecules are chiral. A screen of 52 diverse compounds gave inclusion in co-crystals for 88 % of all cases and a high-resolution structure in 77 % of cases. Furthermore, starting from three milligrams of analyte, a combination of NMR spectroscopy and X-ray crystallography produced a full structure in less than three days using an adamantane crystallization chaperone that encapsulates the analyte at room temperature.

High fatigue resistance of a photochromic dithienylethene embedded into the pores of a metal–organic framework (MOF)

The incorporation of photochromic dyes into porous metal–organic frameworks (MOFs) is an attractive way to transfer the photochromic properties of the dye to a solid crystalline material.

Tracking the light-induced isomerization processes and the photostability of spiropyrans embedded in the pores of crystalline nanoporous MOFs via IR spectroscopy

Difference IR spectroscopy of spiropyran@MOF systems to obtain the characteristic signatures of the spiropyran and merocyanine form at ambient conditions.

Halogen Bonding in a Crystalline Sponge

Host-guest interactions are the key to the supramolecular chemistry and the further application of the receptors to study the structural details of the small guest molecules. Crystalline sponges as a kind of supramolecular receptor need to be investigated in terms of the binding ability with the guests. We found in this work that one guest with σ-hole donors and another with electron-donating species were separately entrapped in two distinct channels of the host framework via the crystalline sponge method. Halogen bonding and weak hydrogen bonding were detected between the host and the two guests, respectively. The ability of the crystalline sponge to absorb and sort guests of different types was unambiguously confirmed by X-ray crystallography.

Microcrystal Electron Diffraction (MicroED) for Small-Molecule Structure Determination

The development of new methods to analyze and determine molecular structures parallels the ability to accelerate synthetic research. For many decades, single-crystal analysis by X-ray diffraction (SXRD) has been the definitive tool for structural analysis at the atomic level; the drawback, however, is that a suitable single crystal of the analyte needs to be grown. The recent innovation of the crystalline sponge (CS) method allows the microanalysis of compounds simply soaked in a readily prepared CS crystal, thus circumventing the need to screen crystallization conditions while also using only a trace amount of the sample. In this context, electron diffraction for the structure determination of small molecules is discussed as potentially the next big development in this field.

Racemic and Enantiopure Camphene and Pinene Studied by the Crystalline Sponge Method

The use of an achiral metal-organic framework for structure determination of chiral compounds is demonstrated for camphene and pinene. The structure of enantiopure β-pinene can be resolved using the crystalline sponge method. However, α-pinene cannot be resolved using enantiopure material alone because no ordering of guest molecules takes place in that case. Interestingly, enantiomeric pairs order inside the channels of the host framework when impure (+)-camphene is offered to the host, which is also the case when a racemic mixture of α-pinene is used. A mixture of (+)-α-pinene and (-)-β-pinene also leads to ordered incorporation in the host, showing the influence of the presence of an inversion center in the host framework. We further show that powder X-ray diffraction provides a direct view on incorporation of ordered guest molecules. This technique, therefore, provides a way to determine the optimal and/or minimal soaking time. In contrast, color change of the crystal only demonstrates guest uptake, not ordering. Moreover, we show that color change can also be caused by guest-induced host degradation.