Theoretical advances in understanding and enhancing the thermostability of energetic materials

The quest for thermally stable energetic materials is pivotal in advancing the safety of applications ranging from munitions to aerospace. This perspective delves into the role of theoretical methodologies in interpreting and advancing the thermal stability of energetic materials. Quantum chemical calculations offer an in-depth understanding of the molecular and electronic structure properties of energetic compounds related to thermal stability. It is also essential to incorporate the surrounding interactions and their impact on molecular stability. Ab initio molecular dynamics (AIMD) simulations provide detailed theoretical insights into the reaction pathways and the key intermediates during thermal decomposition in the condensed phase. Analyzing the kinetic barrier of rate-determining steps under various temperature and pressure conditions allows for a comprehensive assessment of thermal stability. Recent advances in machine learning have demonstrated their utility in constructing potential energy surfaces and predicting thermal stability for newly designed energetic materials. The machine learning-assisted high-throughput virtual screening (HTVS) methodology can accelerate the discovery of novel energetic materials with improved properties. As a result, the newly identified and synthesized energetic molecule ICM-104 revealed excellence in performance and thermostability. Theoretical approaches are pivotal in elucidating the mechanisms underlying thermal stability, enabling the prediction and design of enhanced thermal stability for emerging EMs. These insights are instrumental in accelerating the development of novel energetic materials that optimally balance performance and thermal stability.

Insight into the Stability of Pentazolyl Derivatives based on Covalent Bond

Pentazole is regarded as a unique inorganic molecule that possess organic heterocyclic structure. Therefore, the research on pentazolyl derivatives represents a cutting-edge direction in both contemporary inorganic chemistry and heterocyclic chemistry. Moreover, their synthesis is regarded as the most significant research topic in the field of energetic materials due to the great potential of pentazolyl derivatives to breakthrough the energy bottleneck of CHNO-based energetic materials. However, synthesizing pentazolyl derivatives is challenging. To provide a theoretical support for the synthesis, we conducted theoretical studies on six single-ring pentazolyl derivatives with different functional groups. The results suggest that derivatization reduces the bond strength and weakens the aromaticity of the pentazolate ring. Further analysis showed that derivatization mainly affects the π aromaticity of the pentazolate ring, and ultimately causing poor stability of the pentazolyl derivatives. Among the six derivatives investigated in this study, fluoro pentazole (cyclo-N5-F) and hydroxyl pentazole (cyclo-N5-OH) possess good aromaticity, which is similar to the reported cyclo-N5-NCHN(CH3)2. Further calculations show that the kinetic stability of cyclo-N5-OH is higher than that of cyclo-N5-F. These results collectively indicate that cyclo-N5-OH is a promising candidate for synthesizing single-ring pentazolyl derivatives.

Pentazolate Anion: A Rare and Preferred Five-Membered Ligand for Constructing Pentasil-Zeolite Topology Architectures

As the fourth full-nitrogen structure, the pentazolate anion (cyclo-N5 - ) was highly coveted for decades. In 2017, the first air-stable non-metal pentazolate salt, (N5 )6 (H3 O)3 (NH4 )4 Cl, was obtained, representing a milestone in this field. As the latest member of the azole family, cyclo-N5 - is comprised of five nitrogen atoms. Although significant attention has been paid to the potential of cyclo-N5 - as an energetic material, its poor thermostability hinders any practical application. However, the unique ring structure and multiple coordination capability of cyclo-N5 - provide a platform for the fabrication of various structures, among which pentasil-zeolite topologies are the most intriguing. In addition, the introduction of structure-directing auxiliaries enables the self-assembly of diverse topological architectures, potentially imparting cyclo-N5 - with the potential to impact wide-ranging areas of coordination chemistry and topology. In this minireview, different pentasil-zeolite topologies based on metal-pentazolate frameworks are evaluated. To date, three zeolitic and zeolite-like topologies have been reported, namely the melanophlogite (MEP), chibaite (MTN), and unj topologies. The MEP topology consists of two nanocages, Na20 N60 and Na24 N60 , whereas the MTN topology contains Na20 N60 and Na28 N80 nanocages. Furthermore, the unj topology features multiple homochiral channels consisting of two helical chains. Various possible strategies for obtaining additional pentasil-zeolite topologies are also discussed.

Synthesis mechanism of four metallic Cyclo-N5- energetic materials: A theoretical Perspective

In the past five years, over 20 types of cyclo-N5- energetic materials (EMs) have been successfully synthesized. Metallic cyclo-N5- EMs exhibit higher density and performance compared to non-metallic cyclo-N5- EMs. However, the mechanisms for such metallic cyclo-N5- EMs remain unexplored. Herein, we performed a thorough quantum chemistry study on the mechanistic pathway for the cyclo-N5- trapped by metal cations in four cyclo-N5- EMs: [Na(H2O) (N5)] · 2H2O, [M(H2O)4(N5)2] · 4H2O (M = Mn, Fe, and Co), by density functional theory methods and transition state theory. During the synthesis process, the cyclo-N5- in the precursor hybrid aromatic compound is susceptible to electrophilic attack by metal cations. This attack disrupts the hydrogen bond interaction surrounding the cyclo-N5-, ultimately leading to the formation of either an ionic bond or a coordination bond between the metal cation and the cyclo-N5-, resulting in an electrophilic substitution reaction. In addition, solvent effects reduce the energy of the ionic bond, thereby promoting the reaction. Our findings will provide valuable insights for future route design and contribute to enhancing the synthesis yield of cyclo-N5- EMs in both theoretical and experimental aspects.

Stabilization of hexazine rings in potassium polynitride at high pressure

Polynitrogen molecules are attractive for high-energy-density materials due to energy stored in nitrogen-nitrogen bonds; however, it remains challenging to find energy-efficient synthetic routes and stabilization mechanisms for these compounds. Direct synthesis from molecular dinitrogen requires overcoming large activation barriers and the reaction products are prone to inherent inhomogeneity. Here we report the synthesis of planar N₆^2- hexazine dianions, stabilized in K₂N₆, from potassium azide (KN₃) on laser heating in a diamond anvil cell at pressures above 45 GPa. The resulting K₂N₆, which exhibits a metallic lustre, remains metastable down to 20 GPa. Synchrotron X-ray diffraction and Raman spectroscopy were used to identify this material, through good agreement with the theoretically predicted structural, vibrational and electronic properties for K₂N₆. The N₆^2- rings characterized here are likely to be present in other high-energy-density materials stabilized by pressure. Under 30 GPa, an unusual N₂^0.75--containing compound with the formula K₃(N₂)₄ was formed instead.

Nitrification Progress of Nitrogen-Rich Heterocyclic Energetic Compounds: A Review

As a momentous energetic group, a nitro group widely exists in high-energy-density materials (HEDMs), such as trinitrotoluene (TNT), 1,3,5-triamino-2,4,6-trinitrobenzene (TATB), cyclo-1,3,5-trimethylene-2,4,6-trinitramine (RDX), etc. The nitro group has a significant effect on improving the oxygen balance and detonation performances of energetic materials (EMs). Moreover, the nitro group is a strong electron-withdrawing group, and it can increase the acidity of the acidic hydrogen-containing nitrogen-rich energetic compounds to facilitate the construction of energetic ionic salts. Thus, it is possible to design nitro-nitrogen-rich energetic compounds with adjustable properties. In this paper, the nitration methods of azoles, including imidazole, pyrazole, triazole, tetrazole, and oxadiazole, as well as azines, including pyrazine, pyridazine, triazine, and tetrazine, have been concluded. Furthermore, the prospect of the future development of nitrogen-rich heterocyclic energetic compounds has been stated, so as to provide references for researchers who are engaged in the synthesis of EMs.

Symmetrical cyclo-N5- hydrogen bonds: stabilization mechanism of four non-metallic cyclo-pentazolate energetic salts

Pairing different cations (R⁺) to stabilize cyclo-N₅^- is the main synthesis path for non-metallic cyclo-pentazolate (cyclo-N₅^-) salts. As novel energetic materials (EMs), crystalline packing-force of cyclo-N₅^- salts has been a puzzle, and whether cyclo-N₅^- is protonated also is a controversial issue. In this paper, four non-metallic cyclo-N₅^- salts, PHAC, N₂H₅N₅, NH₃OHN₅, and NH₄N₅, are quantitatively studied by coupling first-principle method and bond-strength analyzing technology. Different from the traditional CHON-EMs (molecular crystal) and azide-EMs (ionic crystal), the four salts are stabilized by 3D hydrogen bond (HB) networks. One new type of hydrogen bond, protonated HB (p-H, R-H⋯N₅^-), is discovered to be a key stabilizing factor for cyclo-N₅^-. Proton competition mechanism between R and cyclo-N₅^- in p-H HB showed that cyclo-N₅^- cannot be protonated into HN₅. In general, p-H HB can be adopted to estimate the stability of novel non-metallic cyclo-N₅^- EMs. Such findings have great significance for future design and performance prediction of novel cyclo-N₅^- EMs in both theoretical and experimental aspects.

Pentazolate coordination polymers self-assembled by in situ generated [Pb4(OH)4]4+ cubic cations trapping cyclo-N5−

A series of cyclo-N5−-based lead-containing energetic coordination polymers [Pb(OH)]4(N5)4 (1), [Pb3(N5)3(H2O)9(NO3)]4(N5)8(H2O)5 (2), [Pb(OH)]4(N5)3(NO3)(H2O)3 (3), and [Pb(OH)]4(N5)3(ClO4)(H2O) (4) were synthesized by self-assembly and characterized by single-crystal X-ray diffraction, powder X-ray diffraction,...

Fascinating 3D energetic [Ag2(N5)2(EDA)]n: filling the ethylenediamine molecules into [Ag(N5)]n framework

An interesting 3D energetic motif based on Ag(I) ion, cyclo-pentazolate anion (cyclo-N5-) and ethylenediamine (EDA), namely, [Ag2(N5)2(EDA)]n, was prepared through embedding the ethylenediamine molecules into [Ag(N5)]n structure. The architecture was...

Reaction Mechanism and Energetics of Decomposition of Tetrakis(1,3-dimethyltetrazol-5-imidoperchloratomanganese(II)) from Quantum-Mechanics-based Reactive Dynamics

Energetic materials (EMs) are central to construction, space exploration, and defense, but over the past 100 years, their capabilities have improved only minimally as they approach the CHNO energetic ceiling, the maximum energy density possible for EMs based on molecular carbon-hydrogen-nitrogen-oxygen compounds. To breach this ceiling, we experimentally explored redox-frustrated hybrid energetic materials (RFH EMs) in which metal atoms covalently connect a strongly reducing fuel ligand (e.g., tetrazole) to a strong oxidizer (e.g., ClO₄). In this Article, we examine the reaction mechanisms involved in the thermal decomposition of an RFH EM, [Mn(Me₂TzN)(ClO₄]₄ (3, Tz = tetrazole). We use quantum-mechanical molecular reaction dynamics simulations to uncover the atomistic reaction mechanisms underlying this decomposition. We discover a novel initiation mechanism involving oxygen atom transfer from perchlorate to manganese, generating energy that promotes the fission of tetrazole into chemically stable species such as diazomethane, diazenes, triazenes, and methyl azides, which further undergo exothermic decomposition to finally form stable N₂, H₂O, CO, CO₂, Mn-based clusters, and additional incompletely combusted products.

Stabilization of pentazolate anions in the high-pressure compounds Na2N5 and NaN5 and in the sodium pentazolate framework NaN5·N2

Synthesis and characterization of nitrogen-rich materials is important for the design of novel high energy density materials due to extremely energetic low-order nitrogen-nitrogen bonds. The balance between the energy output and stability may be achieved if polynitrogen units are stabilized by resonance as in cyclo-N5- pentazolate salts. Here we demonstrate the synthesis of three oxygen-free pentazolate salts Na2N5, NaN5 and NaN5·N2 from sodium azide NaN3 and molecular nitrogen N2 at ∼50 GPa. NaN5·N2 is a metal-pentazolate framework (MPF) obtained via a self-templated synthesis method with nitrogen molecules being incorporated into the nanochannels of the MPF. Such self-assembled MPFs may be common in a variety of ionic pentazolate compounds. The formation of Na2N5 demonstrates that the cyclo-N5 group can accommodate more than one electron and indicates the great accessible compositional diversity of pentazolate salts.

Crystalline Structures and Energetic Properties of Lithium Pentazolate under Ambient Conditions

Recently, it has been reported that high-pressure synthesized lithium pentazolates could be quenched down to ambient conditions. However, the crystalline structures of LiN5 under ambient conditions are still ambiguous. In this work, the structures of LiN5 compound were directly explored at atmospheric pressure by using a new constrain structure search method. By using this method, three new allotropes were confirmed, and they show lower energy than the previous reported LiN5 phases. Both their thermodynamic and dynamic stability were confirmed through formation enthalpies, phonon spectrum, and ab initio molecular dynamics simulations under ambient conditions. Moreover, these three allotropes show similar formation enthalpies and properties, which suggests that it is hard to obtain a single LiN5 phase, which is well consistent with the experimental phenomenon. Furthermore, because of their low formation energy, all of them possess low energy density when they directly decompose to Li3N and nitrogen (0.52 kJ/g). Instead, the decomposed energy could be further improved to 3.78 kJ/g when they decompose under an oxygen-rich environment.

Properties and Promise of Catenated Nitrogen Systems As High-Energy-Density Materials

The properties of catenated nitrogen molecules, molecules containing internal chains of bonded nitrogen atoms, is of fundamental scientific interest in chemical structure and bonding, as nitrogen is uniquely situated in the periodic table to form kinetically stable compounds often with chemically stable N-N bonds but which are thermodynamically unstable in that the formation of stable multiply bonded N₂ is usually thermodynamically preferable. This unique placement in the periodic table makes catenated nitrogen compounds of interest for development of high-energy-density materials, including explosives for defense and construction purposes, as well as propellants for missile propulsion and for space exploration. This review, designed for a chemical audience, describes foundational subjects, methods, and metrics relevant to the energetic materials community and provides an overview of important classes of catenated nitrogen compounds ranging from theoretical investigation of hypothetical molecules to the practical application of real-world energetic materials. The review is intended to provide detailed chemical insight into the synthesis and decomposition of such materials as well as foundational knowledge of energetic science new to most chemists.

High-Pressure Synthesis of Metal-Inorganic Frameworks Hf4 N20 ⋅N2 , WN8 ⋅N2 , and Os5 N28 ⋅3 N2 with Polymeric Nitrogen Linkers

Polynitrides are intrinsically thermodynamically unstable at ambient conditions and require peculiar synthetic approaches. Now, a one‐step synthesis of metal–inorganic frameworks Hf₄N₂₀⋅N₂, WN₈⋅N₂, and Os₅N₂₈⋅3 N₂ via direct reactions between elements in a diamond anvil cell at pressures exceeding 100 GPa is reported. The porous frameworks (Hf₄N₂₀, WN₈, and Os₅N₂₈) are built from transition‐metal atoms linked either by polymeric polydiazenediyl (polyacetylene‐like) nitrogen chains or through dinitrogen units. Triply bound dinitrogen molecules occupy channels of these frameworks. Owing to conjugated polydiazenediyl chains, these compounds exhibit metallic properties. The high‐pressure reaction between Hf and N₂ also leads to a non‐centrosymmetric polynitride Hf₂N₁₁ that features double‐helix catena‐poly[tetraz‐1‐ene‐1,4‐diyl] nitrogen chains [−N−N−N=N−]_∞.

Stabilization of the High-Energy-Density CuN5 Salts under Ambient Conditions by a Ligand Effect

A series of excellent works have demonstrated that high-nitrogen-content metal pentazolate (cyclo-N5 -) compounds could be stabilized by high pressure. However, under ambient conditions, low stability precludes their synthesis and application in the field of high-energy-density material. In this work, by using a constrained structure search method, we predicted two new structures as P212121-CuN5 and P21/c-CuN5 containing cyclo-N5 - with strong N-N and Cu-N bonds. In both structures, cyclo-N5 - form four coordination with the Cu+ ligand, which increases the structural stability by lowering the disturbance to the aromaticity of cyclo-N5 -. The calculated results show that the P212121-CuN5 and P21/c-CuN5 structures exhibit high dynamic and thermal stability up to 400 K, indicating that they can be stabilized under ambient conditions. The decomposing energy of P212121-CuN5 and P21/c-CuN5 can reach up to 2.40 and 2.42 kJ/g, respectively. Strikingly, the detonation velocity and the pressure of P212121-CuN5 is predicted to be up to 10.42 km/s and 617.46 kbar, respectively, indicating that they are promising high-energy candidates in the field of explosive combustion.

Theoretical Insights on the High Pressure Behavior of Pentazolate Anion Complex [Co(H2O)4(N5)2]·4H2O

Periodic dispersion corrected density functional theory (DFT) calculations were carried out to examine the Hirshfeld surface, two dimensional (2D) fingerprint plots, crystal structure, molecular structure and density of state of all-nitrogen pentazolate anion complex [Co(H2O)4(N5)2]·4H2O under hydrostatic pressure from 0 to 20 GPa. The GGA/PW91-OBS method was applied in the present study. The intercontacts in [Co(H2O)4(N5)2]·4H2O were analyzed by Hirshfeld surfaces and 2D fingerprint plots. With ascending pressure, the lattice constants, compression rates, bond lengths, bond angles, and density of states change irregularly. Under 11.5, 13.0 and 15.8 GPa, covalent interaction competition is obvious between Co-N and Co-O bonds. It is possible to achieve orderly modification and regulation of the internal structure of [Co(H2O)4(N5)2]·4H2O by applied pressure. This is in accordance with the results from density of states analysis. The external compression causes the nonuniformity of electron density and the differential covalent interaction between pentazolate anion, coordinated water and atom Co. It is of great significance to interpret inter/intramolecular interaction and structural stability of [Co(H2O)4(N5)2]·4H2O and provide theoretical guidance for the design of metal complexes of all-nitrogen pentazolate anion.

Predictions on High-Power Trivalent Metal Pentazolate Salts

High-energy-density materials (HEDMs) have been intensively studied for their significance in fundamental sciences and practical applications. Here, using the molecular crystal structure search method based on first-principles calculations, we have predicted a series of metastable energetic trivalent metal pentazolate salts MN₁₅ (M= Al, Ga, Sc, and Y). These compounds have high energy densities, with the highest nitrogen content among the studied nitrides so far. Pentazolate N₅^- molecules stack up face-to-face and form wave-like patterns in the C222₁ and Cc symmetries. The strong covalent bonding and very weak noncovalent interactions with nonbonded overlaps coexist in these ionic-like structures. We find MN₁₅ molecular structures are mechanically stable up to high temperature (∼1000 K) and ambient pressure. More importantly, these trivalent metal pentazolate salts have high detonation pressure (∼80 GPa) and velocity (∼12 km/s). Their detonation pressures exceeding that of TNT and HMX make them good candidates for high-brisance green energetic materials.

Syntheses of Energetic cyclo-Pentazolate Salts

Three energetic salts of cyclo-N₅ ^- were synthesized via a metathesis reaction of barium pentazolate and sulfates which was driven by the precipitation of BaSO₄ . All the energetic cyclo-N₅ ^- salts were characterized by single-crystal X-ray diffraction, infrared (IR), ¹ H and ¹³ C multinuclear NMR spectroscopies, thermal analysis (TGA and DSC), and elemental analysis. The salts exhibit relatively good detonation performance with low sensitivities and good thermal stabilities. This new method opens the door to exploring more pentazolate anion-containing high-performance energetic materials.

Stabilization of the Dual-Aromatic cyclo-N5- Anion by Acidic Entrapment

Pentazole anion, the best candidate for full-nitrogen energetic materials, can be isolated only from acidic solution for unclear reasons, which hinders the high-yield realization of a full-nitrogen substance with higher energy density. Herein, we report for the first time the discovery of the dual aromaticity (π and σ) of cyclo-N₅^-, which makes the anion unstable in nature but confers additional stability in acidic surroundings. In addition to the usual π-aromaticity, similar to that of the prototypical benzene, five lone pairs are delocalized in the equatorial plane of cyclo-N₅^-, forming additional σ-aromaticity. It is the compatible coexistence of the inter-lone-pair repulsion and inter-lone-pair attraction within the σ-aromatic system that makes the naked cyclo-N₅^- highly reactive to electrophiles and easily broken. Only in sufficiently acid solution can the cyclo-N₅^- become unsusceptible to the electrophilic attack and gain extra stability through the formation of hydrogen-bonded complex from surrounding electrophiles; otherwise, the cyclo-N₅^- cannot be productively isolated. The dual aromaticity discovered in cyclo-N₅^- is expected to be universal for pnictogen five-membered ring systems.

A kinetically persistent isomer found for pentazole: a global potential energy surface survey

After the pentazole with a 103-year-old research history, the second N₅R isomer with reasonable kinetic stability was found computationally.

Origin of the considerably high thermal stability of cyclo-N5− containing salts at ambient conditions

Ionization, conjugation, hydrogen bonding, coordination bonding and π–π stacking consolidate the cyclo-N₅⁻ caged in salt crystals.

Recent advances in the syntheses and properties of polynitrogen pentazolate anion cyclo-N5− and its derivatives

This review summarizes recent developments and advances in pentazole chemistry, including substituted-pentazole precursors, strategies for the preparation of pentazolate anion, derivatives of pentazolate anion and their bonding properties.