Aromaticity‐promoted CO 2 Capture by P/N‐Based Frustrated Lewis Pairs: A Theoretical Study

Unveiling the Obscure Potential of O-Carborane Based IFLPs for CO2 Sequestration

Sequestering carbon dioxide (CO2) from the atmosphere is necessary to achieve a sustainable environment. However, the thermodynamic stability of the CO2 molecule poses a significant challenge to its capture, necessitating catalysts that can overcome this stability. The emergence of frustrated Lewis pairs (FLPs) has opened a new dimension in the development of organocatalysts for CO2 capture and utilization. To date, various FLPs have been developed for CO2 sequestration, yet the quest for robust FLPs continues. Based on the intriguing electronic effects of the carborane polyhedral, o-carboranes can be projected as a versatile bridging unit for intramolecular FLPs (IFLPs). In the present work, o-carborane based IFLPs i. e., 1-Al(CH3)2-2-P(CH3)2-1,2-C2B10H10, 1-B(CH3)2-2-P(CH3)2-1,2-C2B10H10, 1-Al(CH3)2-2-N(CH3)2-1,2-C2B10H10, 1-P(CH3)2-2-B(CH3)2-1,2-C2B10H10 abbreviated as AlP, BP, AlN and BN have been proposed for the activation of CO2 molecule. The density functional theory (DFT) based calculations and thorough orbital analysis have been carried out to extensively study the electronic structure of the o-carborane unit. The proposed IFLPs were systematically compared with their corresponding phenyl bridged analogues to assess the effect of o-carborane bridging unit on the reactivity of the acidic and basic sites. The results show that the o-carborane supported IFLPs are more reactive towards CO2 than the phenyl bridged IFLPs. Also, placing the basic site on the B atom at the 4th position of the o-carborane bridge rather than the C atom at the 2nd position results in more reactive IFLPs.

Orbital and free energy landscape expedition towards the unexplored catalytic realm of aromatically modified FLPs for CO2 sequestration

The emergence of frustrated Lewis pairs (FLPs) has created a whole new dimension in the development of metal free catalysts for CO2 sequestration. Efforts have been made to enhance the catalytic activity of the FLPs. The aromatic modulation of the catalytic sites has been successfully demonstrated to enhance the activity towards CO2. Although various aromatically modified geminal FLPs have been investigated for CO2 capture, the catalytic space of these FLPs has not been fully resolved yet. Thus, to fulfil the knowledge gap in the understanding of the catalytic behaviour and to extend the concept of aromatically enhanced FLPs, in the present study all the possible combinations of aromatic and antiaromatic modulations of the acidic and basic sites have been proposed and examined using density functional theory based orbital analysis. Further to verify the results obtained from the orbital analysis and to fully explore the catalytic space of the proposed systems, free energy landscapes have been examined using metadynamics simulations. The detailed intrinsic bond orbital (IBO) and principal interacting orbital (PIO) analyses capture crucial details of the reactions. Furthermore, evolution of anisotropy of induced current density (AICD) along the reaction justifies the effect of aromatic/antiaromatic modulation on the catalytic sites. The results show that highly asynchronous mechanisms have been found due to the aromatic/antiaromatic modulations. The simultaneous favourable aromatic/antiaromatic modification on the acidic and basic sites may greatly reduce the CO2 activation barrier. The enhancement of the acidic character of the B atom in the intramolecular FLPs (IFLPs) leads to a thermodynamically more feasible reaction with stable CO2 adducts. The acidic site has been found to play a major role in controlling the kinetics and thermodynamics of the reaction. This study provides valuable insights into the catalytic realm of the aromatically modified FLPs, which can be utilized to design more efficient and specific next-generation FLPs.

Asymmetric catalysis by chiral FLPs: A computational mini-review

Steric hindrance in Lewis acid (LA) and Lewis base (LB) obstruct the Lewis acid-base adduct formation, and the pair was termed as frustrated Lewis pair (FLP). In the past 16 years, the field of enantioselective catalysis by chiral FLPs has been slowly growing. It was shown that chiral LAs are significant as they are involved in the hydrogen transfer (HT) step to the imine, resulting in enantioselectivity. After H2 activation, the borohydride can exist in a number of plausible conformations and their stability is governed by the presence of noncovalent interaction through C-H····π and π····π interactions. However, LBs are not ideal for asymmetric induction as they compete with the imine substrate as a counter LB. Further, the proton transfer from chiral LB to the imine does not induce any chirality as chirality develops in the HT step. However, intramolecular FLPs with chiral scaffold are very efficient as they possess an optimum distance between LA and LB, which facilitates the H2 activation but precludes the adduct formation of the small molecules substrate with the LA component. This mini-review summarizes computational investigation involving chiral LA and LB, and discusses intramolecular FLPs in the enantioselective catalysis.

A multi-FLP approach for CO2 capture: investigating nitrogen, boron, phosphorus and aluminium doped nanographenes and the influence of a sodium cation

The reactivity of B3N3-doped hexa-cata-hexabenzocoronene (B3N3-NG), Al3N3-NG, B3P3-NG and Al3P3-NG, models of doped nanographenes (NGs), towards carbon dioxide was studied with density functional theory (DFT) calculations at the M06-2X/6-311++G(3df,3pd)//M06-2X/6-31+G* level of theory. The NG systems exhibit a poly-cyclic poly-frustrated Lewis pair (FLP) nature, featuring multiple Lewis acid/Lewis base pairs on their surface enabling the capture of several CO2 molecules. The capture of CO2 by these systems was investigated within two scenarios: (A) sequential capture of up to three CO2 molecules and (B) capture of CO2 molecules in the presence of a sodium cation. The resulting adducts were analyzed in terms of the activation barriers and relative stabilities. The presence of aluminium atoms changes the asynchrony of the reaction favoring the aluminium-oxygen bond and influences the regioselectivity of the multi-capture. A cooperative effect is predicted due to π-electron delocalization, with the sodium cation stabilizing the stationary points and favoring the addition of CO2 to the NGs.

The application of aromaticity and antiaromaticity to reaction mechanisms

Aromaticity, in general, can promote a given reaction by stabilizing a transition state or a product via a mobility of π electrons in a cyclic structure. Similarly, such a promotion could be also achieved by destabilizing an antiaromatic reactant. However, both aromaticity and transition states cannot be directly measured in experiment. Thus, computational chemistry has been becoming a key tool to understand the aromaticity-driven reaction mechanisms. In this review, we will analyze the relationship between aromaticity and reaction mechanism to highlight the importance of density functional theory calculations and present it according to an approach via either aromatizing a transition state/product or destabilizing a reactant by antiaromaticity. Specifically, we will start with a particularly challenging example of dinitrogen activation followed by other small-molecule activation, C-F bond activation, rearrangement, as well as metathesis reactions. In addition, antiaromaticity-promoted dihydrogen activation, CO2 capture, and oxygen reduction reactions will be also briefly discussed. Finally, caution must be cast as the magnitude of the aromaticity in the transition states is not particularly high in most cases. Thus, a proof of an adequate electron delocalization rather than a complete ring current is recommended to support the relatively weak aromaticity in these transition states.

PIO and IBO analysis to unravel the hidden details of the CO2 sequestration mechanism of aromatically tempered N/B-based IFLPs

Enhancing the catalytic reactivity of Frustrated Lewis Pairs (FLPs) in various activities such as CO2 activation and sequestration has recently gained interest among researchers around the globe. A recent investigation showed the use of aromaticity as a tool to modulate the catalytic behaviour of FLPs, establishing a whole new dimension in this area. In this work, aromatically tempered N/B-based intramolecular frustrated Lewis Pairs (IFLPs) are proposed for CO2 sequestration. Density functional theory (DFT)-based calculations were carried out to probe the reaction mechanism. The detailed mechanistic investigation was carried out using intrinsic reaction coordinate (IRC), principal interacting orbital (PIO), intrinsic bond orbital (IBO) and natural bonding orbital (NBO) analyses. The results show that aromatic gain in the system at the basic sites lowers the activation barrier, whereas the antiaromatic gain results in increased activation energy. The sequestration mechanism was found to be an asynchronous concerted mechanism, and polar solvents result in higher asynchronicity. This work, for the first time, reports asynchronicity in the catalytic behavior of aromatically tempered IFLPs, which can be crucial to designing better IFLPs for CO2 sequestration.

Unprecedented Activation of CO2 by α-Amino Boronic Acids

Efficient and environmentally benign transformation of carbon dioxide (CO2) into valuable chemicals is mainly obstructed by the lack of suitable catalysts. To date, various catalysts have already been investigated for the conversion of CO2 molecules, but still finding metal-free, simple, and environment-friendly catalysts is a topic of utmost interest among researchers. Thus, in this regard, the present work projects α-amino boronic acids (AABs) as a metal-free and simple catalyst for CO2 activation. The density functional theory (DFT)-based calculations have been carried out to explore the catalytic potential of AABs. The detailed electronic structure analysis of the considered AABs unveils the catalytic similarities with frustrated Lewis pairs (FLPs) in a gas phase. Interestingly, a peculiar catalytic action of AABs has been observed in the presence of solvents. The contrasting catalytic behavior of AABs in solvents has been extensively investigated by employing principal interacting orbital (PIO), intrinsic bond orbital (IBO), and natural bond orbital (NBO) analyses along the reaction paths. The results of the orbital studies provide concrete ground for the observed reaction mechanism. Further, the energetic analysis of the reaction of CO2 with AABs reveals that <5 kcal/mol energy is required for activation in a solvent phase, and the formed adducts are readily active. These observations show that AABs can be considered as an efficient catalyst for CO2 activation.

Probing Near-infrared Absorbance of E and Z Diazene Isomers via Antiaromaticity

The photoswitching behaviors of heteroaryl azos and azobenzenes have attracted considerable interest due to their applications from material science to pharmacology. However, the use of UV light limits their application, especially in biomedicine and photopharmacology. In this work, using several aromaticity descriptors, including anisotropy of the induced current density analysis and nucleus-independent chemical shifts, we systematically investigate the relationship between anti-aromaticity and the absorption of a series of heterocyclic azos. We have demonstrated that the antiaromatic heterocycles substituted with diazenes enable the significant red shifts of the n → π* and π → π* transition bands of E and Z isomers via density functional theory calculations. Moreover, introducing substituents into heterocycles could further tune the absorption. Finally, the λmax of the first transition bands of the E (ca. 1026 nm) and Z isomers (ca. 1167 nm) of azos is achieved in the near-infrared region.

Frustrated Lewis Pairs: Bonding, Reactivity, and Applications

The outstanding capability of Frustrated Lewis Pair (FLP) catalysts to activate small molecules has gained significant attention in recent times. Reactivity of FLP is further extended toward the hydrogenation of various unsaturated species. Over the past decade, this unique catalysis concept has been successfully expanded to heterogeneous catalysis as well. The present review article gives a brief survey on several studies on this field. A thorough discussion on quantum chemical studies concerning the activation of H₂ is provided. The role of aromaticity and boron-ligand cooperation on the reactivity of FLP is discussed in the Review. How FLP can activate other small molecules by cooperative action of its Lewis centers is also discussed. Further, the discussion is shifted to the hydrogenation of various unsaturated species and the mechanism regarding this process. It also discusses the latest theoretical advancements in the application of FLP in heterogeneous catalysis across various domains, such as two-dimensional materials, functionalized surfaces, and metal oxides. A deeper understanding of the catalytic process may assist in devising new heterogeneous FLP catalysts through experimental design.

Screening Carbon-Boron Frustrated Lewis Pairs for Small-Molecule Activation including N2 , O2 , CO, CO2 , CS2 , H2 O and CH4 : A Computational Study

Dinitrogen (N₂ ) activation is particularly challenging under ambient conditions because of its large highest occupied molecular orbital-lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (HOMO-LUMO) gap (10.8 eV) and high bond dissociation energy (945 kJ mol^-1 ) of the N≡N triple bond, attracting considerable attention from both experimental and theoretical chemists. However, most effort has focused on metallic systems. In contrast, nitrogen activation by frustrated Lewis pairs (FLPs) has been initiated recently via theoretical calculations. Here we perform density functional theory (DFT) calculations to screen a series of experimentally viable FLPs for small-molecule activation including N₂ , O₂ , CO, CO₂ , CS₂ , H₂ O and CH₄ . In addition, aromaticity is found to play an important role in most of these small-molecule activation. The particularly thermodynamic stabilities of the activation products and low reaction barriers could be a step forward for the development of FLP towards small-molecule activation including N₂ , inviting experimental chemists' verification.

Reactivity of a model of B3P3-doped nanographene with up to three CO2 molecules

The reactivity of a B₃P₃-doped hexa-cata-hexabenzocoronene, as a model of nanographene (B₃P₃-NG), towards carbon dioxide was studied at the DFT M06-2X/6-311++G(3df,3pd)//M06-2X/6-31+G* level of theory. This compound can be classified as a poly-cyclic poly-Frustrated Lewis Pair (FLP) system, as it presents more than one Lewis Acid/Lewis Base pair on its surface, making the capture of several carbon dioxide molecules possible. Two scenarios were considered to fully characterize the capture of CO₂ by this multi-FLP system: (i) fixation of three CO₂ molecules sequentially one by one; and (ii) simultaneous contact of three CO₂ molecules with the B₃P₃-NG surface. The resulting adducts were analyzed as function of activation barriers and the relative stability of the CO₂ capture. A cooperativity effect due to the π-delocalization of the hexa-cata-hexabenzocoronene is observed. The fixation of a CO₂ molecule modifies the electronic properties. It enhances the capture of additional CO₂ molecules by changing the acidy and basicity of the rest of the boron and phosphorus atoms in the B₃P₃-NG system.

Probing a General Strategy to Break the C-C Bond of Benzene by a Cyclic (Alkyl)(Amino)Aluminyl Anion

The oxidative addition of C-C bonds in aromatic hydrocarbons by low valent main group species has attracted considerable attention from both theoretical and experimental chemists due to the big challenge in breaking their aromaticity. Herein, a general strategy to break the C-C bonds in benzene by cyclic (alkyl)(amino)aluminyl anion is demonstrated via density functional theory (DFT) calculations. The results suggest that the activation of the C-C bond of benzene by this anion is both kinetically and thermodynamically unfavorable whereas introducing electron-withdrawing groups makes such C-C bond activation becomes favorable both kinetically and thermodynamically. Such a sharp change on the kinetics and thermodynamics could be rationalized by the frontier molecular orbital theory by decreasing the lowest unoccupied molecular orbitals of the mono- and disubstituted benzenes. Aromaticity is found to stabilize the transition state for the ring open step. All these findings can help develop the chemistry of small-molecule activation.

Use of 5,10-Disubstituted Dibenzoazaborines and Dibenzophosphaborines as Cyclic Supports of Frustrated Lewis Pairs for the Capture of CO2

The reactivity of 5,10-disubstituted dibenzoazaborines and dibenzophosphaborines towards carbon dioxide was studied at the DFT, M06-2X/def2-TZVP, computational level. The profile of this reaction comprises of three stationary points: the pre-reactive complex and adduct minima and the transition state(TS) linking both minima. Initial results show that dibenzoazaborines derivatives are less suitable to form adducts with CO2 than dibenzophosphaborine systems. The influence of the basicity on the P atom and the acidity on the B center of the dibenzophosphaborine in the reaction with CO2 was also explored. Thus, an equation was developed relating the properties (acidity, basicity and boron hybridization) of the isolated dibenzophosphaborine derivatives with the adduct energy. We found that modulation of the boron acidity allows to obtain more stable adducts than the pre-reactive complexes and isolated monomers.

Predicting dinitrogen activation by borenium and borinium cations

The activation of thermodynamically stable and kinetically inert dinitrogen (N₂) has been a great challenge due to the significant strength of the triple bond. Recently, in an experimental study on N₂ activation by boron species, a highly reactive two-coordinated borylene broke through the limitations of traditional strategies of N₂ activation by metal species. Still, studies on metal-free N₂ activation remain underdeveloped. Here, we systematically investigate a frustrated Lewis pair (FLP) combining carbene and borenium (or borinium) cations to screen potential candidates for N₂ activation via density functional theory calculations. As a result, we found that two FLPs (closed form FLP, borenium and open form FLP, borinium) are able to activate N₂ in a thermodynamically and kinetically favorable manner, with a low energy barrier of 9.6 and 7.3 kcal mol^-1, respectively. Furthermore, aromaticity was found to play an important role in the stabilization of the products, supported by nucleus-independent chemical shift (NICS), anisotropy of the current-induced density (ACID) and electron density of delocalized bonds (EDDB) analysis. Our findings provide an alternative approach for metal-free N₂ activation, highlighting the importance of FLP chemistry and aromaticity in N₂ activation.

Activation of Small Molecules and Hydrogenation of CO2 Catalyzed by Frustrated Lewis Pairs

The chemistry of frustrated Lewis pair (FLP) is widely explored in the activation of small molecules, the hydrogenation of CO2, and unsaturated organic species. A survey of several experimental works on the activation of small molecules by FLPs and the related mechanistic insights into their reactivity from electronic structure theory calculation are provided in the present review, along with the catalytic hydrogenation of CO2. The mechanistic insight into H2 activation is thoroughly discussed, which may provide a guideline to design more efficient FLP for H2 activation. FLPs can activate other small molecules like, CO, NO, CO2, SO2, N2O, alkenes, alkynes, etc. by cooperative action of the Lewis centers of FLPs, as revealed by several computational analyses. The activation barrier of H2 and other small molecules by the FLP can be decreased by utilizing the aromaticity criterion in the FLP as demonstrated by the nucleus independent chemical shift (NICS) analysis. The term boron-ligand cooperation (BLC), which is analogous to the metal-ligand cooperation (MLC), is invoked to describe a distinct class of reactivity of some specific FLPs towards H2 activation.

Antiaromaticity-Promoted Radical Anion stability in α-vinyl Heterocyclics

As an electron-rich species, radical anions have a wide range of applications in organic synthesis. In addition, aromaticity is an essential concept in chemistry that has attracted considerable attention from...

Anti-Electrostatic Main Group Metal-Metal Bonds That Activate CO2

There has been growing interest in the CO₂ capture and reduction by transition-metal-free catalysts. Here we performed a proof-of-concept study using an ab initio valence bond method called the block-localized wave function (BLW) method. The integrated BLW and density function theory (DFT) computations demonstrated that heterobimetallic Ae⁺/Al(I) (Ae represents alkaline earth metals Mg and Ca) Lewis acid/base combinations without transition metals can facilely capture and activate CO₂. There are two remarkable findings in this study. The first concerns the ionic nature of the metal-metal bonds. The experimentally synthesized low valent aluminum compound with a bidentate β-diketiminate (BDI) ligand, or (BDI)Al(I) in brief, is a Lewis base due to the lone pair on the aluminum cation though overall Al(I) is positively charged. Al(I) can form ionic metal-metal bonds with the alkaline earth metals of the positively charged Lewis acids (BDI)Ae⁺. This type of ionic metal-metal bonds is counterintuitive and antielectrostatic as both metals carry positive charges. The second finding is the CO₂ activation mechanism. (BDI)Al(I) can effectively bind and activate CO₂ by transferring one electron to CO₂, and the resulting complex can be best expressed as [(BDI)Al(I)]⁺[CO₂]^-. The participation of (BDI)Ae⁺ further enhances the capture and activation of CO₂ by (BDI)Al(I).

Probing hyperconjugative aromaticity in 2H-pyrrolium and cyclopentadiene containing group 9 transition metal substituents: bridged carbonyl ligands can enhance aromaticity

Bridged carbonyls can enhance hyperconjugative aromaticity of group 9 transition metal disubstituted 2H-pyrrolium and cyclopentadiene.

Probing the origin of the stereoselectivity and enantioselectivity of cobalt-catalyzed [2 + 2] cyclization of ethylene and enynes

Theoretical calculations reveal the origin of the stereoselectivity and enantioselectivity of cobalt-catalyzed [2 + 2] cyclization of ethylene and enynes.

Reaction Mechanisms on [3 + 2] Cycloaddition of Azides with Metal Carbyne Complexes: Significant Effects of Aromaticity, Substituent, and Metal Center

Density functional theory calculations were used to investigate the reaction mechanisms on [3 + 2] cycloaddition reactions of azides with metal carbyne complexes. Our results reveal that the formation of a 1,4-metallatriazole regioisomer is a kinetically favorable process in comparison with the formation of 1,5-metallatriazole. Aromaticity plays an important role in stabilizing the products in these reactions. Further analyses show that the electron-donating ligand on metal centers or the electron-withdrawing group on the azide could accelerate the [3 + 2] cycloaddition reaction. All of these findings could be useful for experimental chemists to develop "click reactions" in organometallic chemistry.