Whole embryo culture: a “New” technique that enabled decades of mechanistic discoveries

Moderate alcohol consumption during pregnancy increases potency of two different drugs (the antifungal fluconazole and the antiepileptic valproate) in inducing craniofacial defects: prediction by the in vitro rat whole embryo culture

The prenatal exposure to ethanol (Eth), fluconazole (FLUCO) and sodium valproate (VPA) is related to effects on development, producing characteristic syndromic pictures. Among embryotoxic effects described for the three molecules, the alteration on craniofacial morphogenesis is a common feature in humans and animal models, including rodent embryos developed in vitro. The aim of the present work is to evaluate the developmental effects of low Eth serum concentration (17 mM, corresponding to the legal limit to drive in UK, USA, Canada, and many other countries) in mixture with increasing realistic concentrations of the antifungal drug FLUCO (62.5-500 µM) or with increasing realistic concentrations of the antiepileptic drug VPA (31.25-250 µM). Groups exposed to Eth alone (17-127.5 mM), FLUCO alone (62.5-500 µM) or VPA alone (31.25-750 µM) were also included. The chosen alternative animal model was the post-implantation rat whole embryo culture (WEC). E9.5 embryos were exposed in vitro to the test molecules during the whole test period (48 h, corresponding to the developmental stages characteristics of any vertebrate, for human embryos post-fertilization days 23-31). Data were statistically analyzed and processed for modelling applying the benchmark dose (BMD) and relative potency factor (RPF) approaches. Concentration-related effects on facial outcomes were observed in all experimental groups, with a significant enhancement in the groups co-exposed with Eth in comparison to the single exposures. Data obtained by the present work suggest an additional alert for the assumption of even low levels of alcohol in pregnant women during FLUCO or VPA therapy.

Embryotoxic effects of tribromophenol on early post-implantation development of mouse embryos in vitro

2,4,6-Tribromophenol (TBP, CAS No. 118-79-6), the most widely produced brominated phenol, is frequently detected in environmental components. The detection of TBP in human bodies has earned great concerns about its adverse effects on human beings, especially for early embryonic development. Here, we optimized the mouse embryo in vitro culture (IVC) system for early post-implantation embryos and employed it to determine the embryotoxicity of TBP. With this new research model, we revealed the dose-dependent toxic effects of TBP on mouse embryos from peri-implantation to egg cylinder stages. Furthermore, TBP exposure inhibited the differentiation and survival of epiblast (EPI) cells and extraembryonic endoderm (ExEn) cells, while those of extraembryonic ectoderm (ExEc) cells were not influenced. These results implied that TBP might inhibit embryonic development by influencing the generation of three primary germ layers and fetal membranes (the amnion, chorionic disk, umbilical cord, and yolk sac). In summary, we showed a proof of concept for applying mouse embryo IVC system as a novel research model for studying mammalian embryonic toxicology of environmental pollutants. This study also demonstrated the toxicity of TBP on early embryonic development of mammals.

Rat Whole Embryo Culture

The direct effects of chemical exposures, environmental extremes, and nutrient quality/quantity have been very difficult to study in mammalian embryos due to their anatomical inaccessibility, paucity of tissue, and other factors that make human studies unethical. Many acute and chronic developmental anomalies can trace their origins to postimplantation phases of gestation, where the organs are first being established and growth and differentiation are in highly active states of flux. Most chemical insults and conditions that produce birth defects are believed to act during this period of organogenesis. The evolution of rodent whole embryo culture (WEC) techniques has provided a valuable experimental model where physiological conditions and exposures can be carefully controlled and manipulated to test hypotheses and explore biochemical and molecular mechanisms of action that would otherwise be extremely difficult. Exposure to chemicals can be controlled through their direct addition to the culture medium. Optimal in vitro culture conditions support the growth of intact, viable conceptuses (embryo and associated extraembryonic membranes) from early egg cylinder stages through the establishment of the neural plate, gastrulation, neural tube closure, onset of active heartbeat and circulation, and the initial formation of all major organ systems that occur prior to the establishment of a functional placenta. Detailed comparisons of in vivo and in vitro growth show that conceptuses grown in WEC are nearly identical, structurally and functionally, to conceptuses of the same developmental stage that are allowed to develop normally in utero during a comparable developmental period. Culture conditions and mechanical apparatuses can be modified to suit a large number of different experimental approaches and paradigms.

Neonatal testis growth recreated in vitro by two-dimensional organ spreading

Organ culture experiments can be hampered by central degeneration or necrosis due to the inadequate permeation of oxygen and nutrients, which deteriorates the function and growth of cultured tissues. In the current study, we aimed to overcome this limitation of organ culture through spreading the tissue two dimensionally on an agarose gel stand and molding into a disc shape by placing a ceiling of polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) chip, which is highly oxygen permeable. By this, every part of the tissue can receive a sufficient supply of oxygen through PDMS as well as nutrients through the agarose gel below. This method not only prevented central necrosis of tissues, but also supported the tissue growth over time. In addition, such growth, as volume enlargement, could be easily measured. Under these conditions, we examined the effect of several factors on the growth of neonatal mouse testis, and found that follicle stimulating hormone (FSH) and insulin significantly promoted the growth. These results are in good agreement with previous in vivo reports. Notably, the growth achieved over 7 days in our in vitro system is almost comparable to, about 80% of, that observed in vivo. Thus, we successfully monitored the promotion of tissue growth beyond the limits of the conventional organ culture method. This extremely simple method could offer a unique platform to evaluate the growth as well as functional properties of organs, not only the testis but also others as well.

Embryonic vascular disruption adverse outcomes: Linking high throughput signaling signatures with functional consequences

Embryonic vascular disruption is an important adverse outcome pathway (AOP) as chemical disruption of cardiovascular development induces broad prenatal defects. High throughput screening (HTS) assays aid AOP development although linking in vitro data to in vivo apical endpoints remains challenging. This study evaluated two anti-angiogenic agents, 5HPP-33 and TNP-470, across the ToxCastDB HTS assay platform and anchored the results to complex in vitro functional assays: the rat aortic explant assay (AEA), rat whole embryo culture (WEC), and the zebrafish embryotoxicity (ZET) assay. Both were identified as putative vascular disruptive compounds (pVDCs) in ToxCastDB and disrupted angiogenesis and embryogenesis in the functional assays. Differences were observed in potency and adverse effects: 5HPP-33 was embryolethal (WEC and ZET); TNP-470 produced caudal defects at lower concentrations. This study demonstrates how a tiered approach using HTS signatures and complex functional in vitro assays might be used to prioritize further in vivo developmental toxicity testing.

Use of the Coelomic Grafting Technique for Prolonged ex utero Cultivation of Late Preprimitive Streak-Stage Rabbit Embryos

Due to its morphological similarity with the early human embryo, the pregastrulation-stage rabbit may represent an appropriate mammalian model for studying processes involved in early human development. The usability of mammalian embryos for experimental studies depends on the availability of whole embryo culture methods facilitating prolonged ex utero development. While currently used culture methods yield high success rates for embryos from primitive streak stages onward, the success rate of extended cultivation of preprimitive streak-stage mammalian embryos is low for all previously established methods and for all studied species. This limits the usability of preprimitive streak-stage rabbit embryos in experimental embryology. We have tested whether the extraembryonic coelom of 4-day-old chick embryos may be used for prolonged ex utero culture of preprimitive streak-stage rabbit embryos (stage 2, 6.2 days post coitum). We found that, within this environment, stage 2 rabbit blastocysts can be cultured at decreasing success rates (55% after 1 day, 35% after 2 days, 15% after 3 days) up to a maximum of 72 h. Grafted blastocysts can continue development from the onset of gastrulation to early organogenesis and thereby form all structures characterizing age-matched controls (e.g. neural tube, somites, beating heart). Compared to normal controls, successfully cultured embryos developed at a slower rate and finally showed some structural and gross morphological anomalies. The method presented here was originally developed for whole embryo culture of mouse embryos by Gluecksohn-Schoenheimer in 1941. It is a simple and inexpensive method that may represent a useful extension to presently available ex utero culture systems for rabbit embryos.

Tissue culture on a chip: Developmental biology applications of self-organized capillary networks in microfluidic devices

Organ culture systems are used to elucidate the mechanisms of pattern formation in developmental biology. Various organ culture techniques have been used, but the lack of microcirculation in such cultures impedes the long-term maintenance of larger tissues. Recent advances in microfluidic devices now enable us to utilize self-organized perfusable capillary networks in organ cultures. In this review, we will overview past approaches to organ culture and current technical advances in microfluidic devices, and discuss possible applications of microfluidics towards the study of developmental biology.

Morphology-based mammalian stem cell tests reveal potential developmental toxicity of donepezil

Various compounds, including therapeutic drugs, can adversely impact the survival and development of embryos in the uterus. Identification of such development-interfering agents is a challenging task, although multi-angle approaches--including the use of in vitro toxicology studies involving embryonic stem cells--should alleviate some of the current difficulties. In the present study, we utilized the in vitro elongation of embryoid bodies (EBs) derived from mouse embryonal carcinoma stem cell line P19C5 as a model of early embryological events, specifically that of gastrulation and axial patterning. From our study, we identified donepezil, a medication indicated for the management of Alzheimer's disease, as a potential developmental toxicant. The extent of P19C5 EB axial elongation was diminished by donepezil in a dose-dependent manner. Although donepezil is a known inhibitor of acetylcholinesterase, interference of elongation was not mediated through this enzyme. Quantitative reverse-transcriptase PCR revealed that donepezil altered the expression pattern of a specific set of developmental regulator genes involved in patterning along the anterior-posterior body axis. When tested in mouse whole embryo culture, donepezil caused morphological abnormalities including impaired somitogenesis. Donepezil also diminished elongation morphogenesis of EBs generated from human embryonic stem cells. These results suggest that donepezil interferes with axial elongation morphogenesis of early embryos by altering the expression pattern of regulators of axial development.

Transcriptomic analysis of neurulation and early organogenesis in rat embryos: an in vivo and ex vivo comparison

Cultured embryos mimic the morphological developmental progression of embryos (in vivo) undergoing neurulation and early organogenesis. Using available genomics technologies, comparative molecular-based assessments between cultured embryos and in vivo models may further clarify commonalities and dissimilarities, which contribute to differences between systems. Therefore, in this study, using a transcriptomic approach, we compared cultured whole rat embryos and embryos in vivo at comparable time points in development (gestational day (GD) 10 + 2-48 h, GD 0 = copulatory plug) to assess for commonalities and differences in gene expression in relation to morphology. We reveal strong parallels in time-dependent expression of genes in terms of magnitude, directionality, and functionality between whole embryo culture (WEC) and in vivo (rat). Genes changing in expression over time resemble previously hypothesized mechanisms underlying early development in mammalian systems. Furthermore, at the gene and functional level, we identify genes, which differ in expression between models, including genes related to development, oxygen transport, and metabolism. In summary, our results support the use of WEC for toxicological studies aimed at representing in vivo development during this time window at the molecular level. Additionally, we indicate genes, which differ in expression between models, providing possible insights for improvement of culture conditions.

Rodent whole embryo culture

The direct effects of chemical exposures, environmental extremes, and nutrient quality/quantity have been very difficult to study in mammalian embryos due to their anatomical inaccessibility, paucity of tissues, and other factors such as real ethical concerns in human studies. Many acute and chronic developmental anomalies can trace their origins to postimplantation phases of gestation where the organs are first being established and growth and differentiation are in highly active states of flux. Most agents and conditions that produce birth defects are believed to act during this period of organogenesis. The evolution of rodent whole embryo culture (WEC) techniques has provided a valuable experimental model where physiological conditions and exposures can be carefully controlled and manipulated to test hypotheses and explore biochemical and molecular mechanisms of action. Exposure to chemical agents can be controlled through their direct addition to the culture medium. Optimal in vitro culture conditions support the growth of intact, viable conceptuses (embryo and associated extraembryonic membranes) from early egg cylinder stages through establishment of the neural plate, gastrulation, neural tube closure, onset of active heartbeat and circulation, and the initial formation of all major organ systems that occur prior to the establishment of a functional placenta. Detailed comparisons of in vivo and in vitro growth show that conceptuses grown in WEC are nearly identical, structurally and functionally, to conceptuses of the same developmental stage that are allowed to develop normally in vivo. Culture conditions and mechanical apparatus can be modified to suit a large number of different experimental approaches and paradigms.