Protein conformational space populated in solution probed with aromatic residual dipolar (13) C-(1) H couplings

Characterizing Fast Conformational Exchange of Aromatic Rings Using Residual Dipolar Couplings: Distinguishing Jumplike Flips from Other Exchange Mechanisms

Aromatic ring flips are a hallmark of protein dynamics. They are experimentally studied by NMR spectroscopy, where recent advances have led to improved characterization across a wide range of time scales. Results on different proteins have been interpreted as continuous diffusive ring rotations or jumplike flips, leading to diverging views of the protein interior as being fluidlike or solidlike, respectively. It is challenging to distinguish between these mechanisms and other types of conformational exchange because chemical-shift-mediated line broadening provides only conclusive evidence for ring flips only if the system can be moved from the slow- to intermediate/fast-exchange regime. Moreover, whenever the chemical shift difference between the two symmetry-related sites is close to zero, it is not generally possible to determine the exchange time scale. Here we resolve these issues by measuring residual dipolar coupling (RDC)-mediated exchange contributions using NMR relaxation dispersion experiments on proteins dissolved in dilute liquid crystalline media. Excellent agreement is found between the experimental difference in RDC between the two symmetry-related sites and the value calculated from high-resolution X-ray structures, demonstrating that dynamics measured for F52 in the B1 domain of protein G reports on distinct, jumplike flips rather than other types of conformational exchange.

From Protein Design to the Energy Landscape of a Cold Unfolding Protein

Understanding protein folding is crucial for protein sciences. The conformational spaces and energy landscapes of cold (unfolded) protein states, as well as the associated transitions, are hardly explored. Furthermore, it is not known how structure relates to the cooperativity of cold transitions, if cold and heat unfolded states are thermodynamically similar, and if cold states play important roles for protein function. We created the cold unfolding 4-helix bundle DCUB1 with a de novo designed bipartite hydrophilic/hydrophobic core featuring a hydrogen bond network which extends across the bundle in order to study the relative importance of hydrophobic versus hydrophilic protein-water interactions for cold unfolding. Structural and thermodynamic characterization resulted in the discovery of a complex energy landscape for cold transitions, while the heat unfolded state is a random coil. Below ∼0 °C, the core of DCUB1 disintegrates in a largely cooperative manner, while a near-native helical content is retained. The resulting cold core-unfolded state is compact and features extensive internal dynamics. Below -5 °C, two additional cold transitions are seen, that is, (i) the formation of a water-mediated, compact, and highly dynamic dimer, and (ii) the onset of cold helix unfolding decoupled from cold core unfolding. Our results suggest that cold unfolding is initiated by the intrusion of water into the hydrophilic core network and that cooperativity can be tuned by varying the number of core hydrogen bond networks. Protein design has proven to be invaluable to explore the energy landscapes of cold states and to robustly test related theories.

Transition-State Compressibility and Activation Volume of Transient Protein Conformational Fluctuations

Proteins are dynamic entities that intermittently depart from their ground-state structures and undergo conformational transitions as a critical part of their functions. Central to understanding such transitions are the structural rearrangements along the connecting pathway, where the transition state plays a special role. Using NMR relaxation at variable temperature and pressure to measure aromatic ring flips inside a protein core, we obtain information on the structure and thermodynamics of the transition state. We show that the isothermal compressibility coefficient of the transition state is similar to that of short-chain hydrocarbon liquids, implying extensive local unfolding of the protein. Our results further indicate that the required local volume expansions of the protein can occur not only with a net positive activation volume of the protein, as expected from previous studies, but also with zero activation volume by compaction of remote void volume, when averaged over the ensemble of states.

Conformational exchange of aromatic side chains by 1H CPMG relaxation dispersion

Aromatic side chains are attractive probes of protein dynamics on the millisecond time scale, because they are often key residues in enzyme active sites and protein binding sites. Further they allow to study specific processes, like histidine tautomerization and ring flips. Till now such processes have been studied by aromatic ¹³C CPMG relaxation dispersion experiments. Here we investigate the possibility of aromatic ¹H CPMG relaxation dispersion experiments as a complementary method. Artifact-free dispersions are possible on uniformly ¹H and ¹³C labeled samples for histidine δ2 and ε1, as well as for tryptophan δ1. The method has been validated by measuring fast folding-unfolding kinetics of the small protein CspB under native conditions. The determined rate constants and populations agree well with previous results from ¹³C CPMG relaxation dispersion experiments. The CPMG-derived chemical shift differences between the folded and unfolded states are in good agreement with those obtained directly from the spectra. In contrast, the ¹H relaxation dispersion profiles in phenylalanine, tyrosine and the six-ring moiety of tryptophan, display anomalous behavior caused by ³J ¹H-¹H couplings and, if present, strong ¹³C-¹³C couplings. Therefore they require site-selective ¹H/²H and, in case of strong couplings, ¹³C/¹²C labeling. In summary, aromatic ¹H CPMG relaxation dispersion experiments work on certain positions (His δ2, His ε1 and Trp δ1) in uniformly labeled samples, while other positions require site-selective isotope labeling.

Anthranilic acid, the new player in the ensemble of aromatic residue labeling precursor compounds

The application of metabolic precursors for selective stable isotope labeling of aromatic residues in cell-based protein overexpression has already resulted in numerous NMR probes to study the structural and dynamic characteristics of proteins. With anthranilic acid, we present the structurally simplest precursor for exclusive tryptophan side chain labeling. A synthetic route to ¹³C, ²H isotopologues allows the installation of isolated ¹³C-¹H spin systems in the indole ring of tryptophan, representing a versatile tool to investigate side chain motion using relaxation-based experiments without the loss of magnetization due to strong ¹J_CC and weaker ²J_CH scalar couplings, as well as dipolar interactions with remote hydrogens. In this article, we want to introduce this novel precursor in the context of hitherto existing techniques of in vivo aromatic residue labeling.

Site-selective 13C labeling of histidine and tryptophan using ribose

Experimental studies on protein dynamics at atomic resolution by NMR-spectroscopy in solution require isolated ¹H-X spin pairs. This is the default scenario in standard ¹H-¹⁵N backbone experiments. Side chain dynamic experiments, which allow to study specific local processes like proton-transfer, or tautomerization, require isolated ¹H-¹³C sites which must be produced by site-selective ¹³C labeling. In the most general way this is achieved by using site-selectively ¹³C-enriched glucose as the carbon source in bacterial expression systems. Here we systematically investigate the use of site-selectively ¹³C-enriched ribose as a suitable precursor for ¹³C labeled histidines and tryptophans. The ¹³C incorporation in nearly all sites of all 20 amino acids was quantified and compared to glucose based labeling. In general the ribose approach results in more selective labeling. 1-¹³C ribose exclusively labels His δ2 and Trp δ1 in aromatic side chains and helps to resolve possible overlap problems. The incorporation yield is however only 37% in total and 72% compared to yields of 2-¹³C glucose. A combined approach of 1-¹³C ribose and 2-¹³C glucose maximizes ¹³C incorporation to 75% in total and 150% compared to 2-¹³C glucose only. Further histidine positions β, α and CO become significantly labeled at around 50% in total by 3-, 4- or 5-¹³C ribose. Interestingly backbone CO of Gly, Ala, Cys, Ser, Val, Phe and Tyr are labeled at 40-50% in total with 3-¹³C ribose, compared to 5% and below for 1-¹³C and 2-¹³C glucose. Using ribose instead of glucose as a source for site-selective ¹³C labeling enables a very selective labeling of certain positions and thereby expanding the toolbox for customized isotope labeling of amino-acids.

Site-selective 13C labeling of proteins using erythrose

NMR-spectroscopy enables unique experimental studies on protein dynamics at atomic resolution. In order to obtain a full atom view on protein dynamics, and to study specific local processes like ring-flips, proton-transfer, or tautomerization, one has to perform studies on amino-acid side chains. A key requirement for these studies is site-selective labeling with ¹³C and/or ¹H, which is achieved in the most general way by using site-selectively ¹³C-enriched glucose (1- and 2-¹³C) as the carbon source in bacterial expression systems. Using this strategy, multiple sites in side chains, including aromatics, become site-selectively labeled and suitable for relaxation studies. Here we systematically investigate the use of site-selectively ¹³C-enriched erythrose (1-, 2-, 3- and 4-¹³C) as a suitable precursor for ¹³C labeled aromatic side chains. We quantify ¹³C incorporation in nearly all sites in all 20 amino acids and compare the results to glucose based labeling. In general the erythrose approach results in more selective labeling. While there is only a minor gain for phenylalanine and tyrosine side-chains, the ¹³C incorporation level for tryptophan is at least doubled. Additionally, the Phe ζ and Trp η2 positions become labeled. In the aliphatic side chains, labeling using erythrose yields isolated ¹³C labels for certain positions, like Ile β and His β, making these sites suitable for dynamics studies. Using erythrose instead of glucose as a source for site-selective ¹³C labeling enables unique or superior labeling for certain positions and is thereby expanding the toolbox for customized isotope labeling of amino-acid side-chains.

Solution NMR Experiment for Measurement of (15)N-(1)H Residual Dipolar Couplings in Large Proteins and Supramolecular Complexes

NMR residual dipolar couplings (RDCs) are exquisite probes of protein structure and dynamics. A new solution NMR experiment named 2D SE2 J-TROSY is presented to measure N-H RDCs for proteins and supramolecular complexes in excess of 200 kDa. This enables validation and refinement of their X-ray crystal and solution NMR structures and the characterization of structural and dynamic changes occurring upon complex formation. Accurate N-H RDCs were measured at 750 MHz (1)H resonance frequency for 11-mer 93 kDa (2)H,(15)N-labeled Trp RNA-binding attenuator protein tumbling with a correlation time τc of 120 ns. This is about twice as long as that for the most slowly tumbling system, for which N-H RDCs could be measured, so far, and corresponds to molecular weights of ∼200 kDa at 25 °C. Furthermore, due to the robustness of SE2 J-TROSY with respect to residual (1)H density from exchangeable protons, increased sensitivity at (1)H resonance frequencies around 1 GHz promises to enable N-H RDC measurement for even larger systems.

Novel approaches in selective tryptophan isotope labeling by using Escherichia coli overexpression media

NMR-based investigations of large protein complexes require optimized isotopic labeling schemes. We report new methods to introduce stable isotopes into tryptophan residues; these are fine-tuned to the requirements of the particular protein NMR experiment. Selective backbone labeling was performed by using a new α-ketoacid precursor as an additive in cell-based overexpression media. Additionally, we developed synthetic routes to certain isotopologues of indole with (13)C-(1)H spin systems surrounded by (12)C and (2)H. The corresponding proteins, overexpressed in the presence of these precursor compounds, can be effectively analyzed for conformational changes in tryptophan residues in response to external stimuli, such as interaction with other proteins or small molecules.

Spatially selective heteronuclear multiple-quantum coherence spectroscopy for biomolecular NMR studies

Spatially selective heteronuclear multiple-quantum coherence (SS HMQC) NMR spectroscopy is developed for solution studies of proteins. Due to "time-staggered" acquisitioning of free induction decays (FIDs) in different slices, SS HMQC allows one to use long delays for longitudinal nuclear spin relaxation at high repetition rates. To also achieve high intrinsic sensitivity, SS HMQC is implemented by combining a single spatially selective (1)H excitation pulse with nonselective (1) H 180° pulses. High-quality spectra were obtained within 66 s for a 7.6 kDa uniformly (13) C,(15) N-labeled protein, and within 45 and 90 s for, respectively, two proteins with molecular weights of 7.5 and 43 kDa, which were uniformly (2)H,(13) C,(15) N-labeled, except for having protonated methyl groups of isoleucine, leucine and valine residues.

Off-resonance rotating-frame relaxation dispersion experiment for 13C in aromatic side chains using L-optimized TROSY-selection

Protein dynamics on the microsecond-millisecond time scales often play a critical role in biological function. NMR relaxation dispersion experiments are powerful approaches for investigating biologically relevant dynamics with site-specific resolution, as shown by a growing number of publications on enzyme catalysis, protein folding, ligand binding, and allostery. To date, the majority of studies has probed the backbone amides or side-chain methyl groups, while experiments targeting other sites have been used more sparingly. Aromatic side chains are useful probes of protein dynamics, because they are over-represented in protein binding interfaces, have important catalytic roles in enzymes, and form a sizable part of the protein interior. Here we present an off-resonance R 1ρ experiment for measuring microsecond to millisecond conformational exchange of aromatic side chains in selectively (13)C labeled proteins by means of longitudinal- and transverse-relaxation optimization. Using selective excitation and inversion of the narrow component of the (13)C doublet, the experiment achieves significant sensitivity enhancement in terms of both signal intensity and the fractional contribution from exchange to transverse relaxation; additional signal enhancement is achieved by optimizing the longitudinal relaxation recovery of the covalently attached (1)H spins. We validated the L-TROSY-selected R 1ρ experiment by measuring exchange parameters for Y23 in bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor at a temperature of 328 K, where the ring flip is in the fast exchange regime with a mean waiting time between flips of 320 μs. The determined chemical shift difference matches perfectly with that measured from the NMR spectrum at lower temperatures, where separate peaks are observed for the two sites. We further show that potentially complicating effects of strong scalar coupling between protons (Weininger et al. in J Phys Chem B 117: 9241-9247, 2013b) can be accounted for using a simple expression, and provide recommendations for data acquisition when the studied system exhibits this behavior. The present method extends the repertoire of relaxation methods tailored for aromatic side chains by enabling studies of faster processes and improved control over artifacts due to strong coupling.

Quality assessment of protein NMR structures

Biomolecular NMR structures are now routinely used in biology, chemistry, and bioinformatics. Methods and metrics for assessing the accuracy and precision of protein NMR structures are beginning to be standardized across the biological NMR community. These include both knowledge-based assessment metrics, parameterized from the database of protein structures, and model versus data assessment metrics. On line servers are available that provide comprehensive protein structure quality assessment reports, and efforts are in progress by the world-wide Protein Data Bank (wwPDB) to develop a biomolecular NMR structure quality assessment pipeline as part of the structure deposition process. These quality assessment metrics and standards will aid NMR spectroscopists in determining more accurate structures, and increase the value and utility of these structures for the broad scientific community.