Probing Operating Electrochemical Interfaces by Photons and Neutrons

Synchrotron radiation based operando characterization of battery materials

Synchrotron radiation based techniques are powerful tools for battery research and allow probing a wide range of length scales, with different depth sensitivities and spatial/temporal resolutions. Operando experiments enable characterization during functioning of the cell and are thus a precious tool to elucidate the reaction mechanisms taking place. In this perspective, the current state of the art for the most relevant techniques (scattering, spectroscopy, and imaging) is discussed together with the bottlenecks to address, either specific for application in the battery field or more generic. The former includes the improvement of cell designs, multi-modal characterization and development of protocols for automated or at least semi-automated data analysis to quickly process the huge amount of data resulting from operando experiments. Given the recent evolution in these areas, accelerated progress is expected in the years to come, which should in turn foster battery performance improvements.

Optical Study of the Surface Film Formed during Li-Metal Deposition and Dissolution Investigated by Surface Plasmon Resonance Spectroscopy

The features of the electrode surface film during Li-metal deposition and dissolution cycles are essential for understanding the mechanism of the negative electrode reaction in Li-metal battery cells. The physical and chemical property changes of the interface during the initial stages of the reaction should be investigated under operando conditions. In this study, we focused on the changes in the optical properties of the electrode surface film of the negative electrode of a Li-metal battery. Cu-based electrochemical surface plasmon resonance spectroscopy (EC-SPR) was applied because of its high sensitivity to optical phenomena on the electrode surface and its stability against Li-metal deposition. The feature of SPR reflectance dip depends on the optical properties of the electrode surface; namely, the wavelength and depth of the reflectance dip directly connected the refractive index and extinction coefficient (color of electrode surface film), which was confirmed by reflectance simulation. In the operando EC-SPR experiment, various changes in optical properties were clearly observed during the cycles. In particular, the change in the extinction coefficient was more remarkable at the second process than the first process of Li-metal deposition. By electrochemical quartz-crystal microbalance (EQCM) measurements, surface film formation was confirmed during the first Li-metal deposition process. The remarkable change in the extinction coefficient is based on the color change of the surface film, which is caused by the chemical condition change during Li-metal deposition cycles.

Engineering and characterization of interphases for lithium metal anodes

Lithium metal is a very promising anode material for achieving high energy density for next generation battery systems due to its low redox potential and high theoretical specific capacity of 3860 mA h g-1. However, dendrite formation and low coulombic efficiency during cycling greatly hindered its practical applications. The formation of a stable solid electrolyte interphase (SEI) on the lithium metal anode (LMA) holds the key to resolving these problems. A lot of techniques such as electrolyte modification, electrolyte additive introduction, and artificial SEI layer coating have been developed to form a stable SEI with capability to facilitate fast Li+ transportation and to suppress Li dendrite formation and undesired side reactions. It is well accepted that the chemical and physical properties of the SEI on the LMA are closely related to the kinetics of Li+ transport across the electrolyte-electrode interface and Li deposition behavior, which in turn affect the overall performance of the cell. Unfortunately, the chemical and structural complexity of the SEI makes it the least understood component of the battery cell. Recently various advanced in situ and ex situ characterization techniques have been developed to study the SEI and the results are quite interesting. Therefore, an overview about these new findings and development of SEI engineering and characterization is quite valuable to the battery research community. In this perspective, different strategies of SEI engineering are summarized, including electrolyte modification, electrolyte additive application, and artificial SEI construction. In addition, various advanced characterization techniques for investigating the SEI formation mechanism are discussed, including in situ visualization of the lithium deposition behavior, the quantification of inactive lithium, and using X-rays, neutrons and electrons as probing beams for both imaging and spectroscopy techniques with typical examples.

The rise of the electrochemical NAPXPS operated in the soft X-ray regime exemplified in the oxygen evolution reaction on IrOx electrocatalysts

Photoelectron spectroscopy offers detailed information about of the electronic structure and chemical composition of surfaces owing to the short distance that the photoelectrons can escape from a dense medium. Unfortunately,...

Spiers Memorial Lecture: Prospects for photoelectron spectroscopy

An overview is presented of recent advances in photoelectron spectroscopy, focussing on advances in in situ and time-resolved measurements, and in extending the sampling depth of the technique. The future...

Surface Electron-Hole Rich Species Active in the Electrocatalytic Water Oxidation

Iridium and ruthenium and their oxides/hydroxides are the best candidates for the oxygen evolution reaction under harsh acidic conditions owing to the low overpotentials observed for Ru- and Ir-based anodes and the high corrosion resistance of Ir-oxides. Herein, by means of cutting edge operando surface and bulk sensitive X-ray spectroscopy techniques, specifically designed electrode nanofabrication and ab initio DFT calculations, we were able to reveal the electronic structure of the active IrO_x centers (i.e., oxidation state) during electrocatalytic oxidation of water in the surface and bulk of high-performance Ir-based catalysts. We found the oxygen evolution reaction is controlled by the formation of empty Ir 5d states in the surface ascribed to the formation of formally Ir^V species leading to the appearance of electron-deficient oxygen species bound to single iridium atoms (μ₁-O and μ₁-OH) that are responsible for water activation and oxidation. Oxygen bound to three iridium centers (μ₃-O) remains the dominant species in the bulk but do not participate directly in the electrocatalytic reaction, suggesting bulk oxidation is limited. In addition a high coverage of a μ₁-OO (peroxo) species during the OER is excluded. Moreover, we provide the first photoelectron spectroscopic evidence in bulk electrolyte that the higher surface-to-bulk ratio in thinner electrodes enhances the material usage involving the precipitation of a significant part of the electrode surface and near-surface active species.

Electrochemical Surface Plasmon Resonance Spectroscopy for Investigation of the Initial Process of Lithium Metal Deposition

The initial process of Li-metal electrodeposition on the negative electrode surface determines the charging performance of Li-metal secondary batteries. However, minute depositions or the early processes of nucleation and growth of Li metal are generally difficult to detect under operando conditions. In this study, we propose an optical diagnostic approach to address these challenges. Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) spectroscopy coupled with electrochemical operation is a promising technique that enables the ultrasensitive detection of the initial stage of Li-metal electrodeposition. The SPR is excited in a thin copper film deposited on a glass substrate, which also serves as a current collector enabling electrochemical Li-metal deposition. For a propylene carbonate (PC)-based Li-ion battery electrolyte, under both cyclic voltammetry and constant-current operation, Li-metal deposition is readily detected by changes in the SPR absorption dip in the reflectance spectrum. Electrochemical SPR is highly sensitive to metal deposition, with a demonstrated capability of detecting an average thickness of approximately 0.1 nm, corresponding to a few atomic layers of Li. To identify the growth mechanism, the SPR reflectance spectra of various possible Li-metal deposition processes were simulated. Comparison of the simulated spectra with the experimental data found good agreement with the well-known nucleation and growth model for Li-metal deposition from PC-based electrolytes. The demonstrated operando electrochemical SPR measurement should be a valuable tool for basic research on the initial Li-metal deposition process.

In-Operando Detection of the Physical Property Changes of an Interfacial Electrolyte during the Li-Metal Electrode Reaction by Atomic Force Microscopy

The physical properties of an interfacial electrolyte near the electrode surface essentially affect the electrochemical behavior of the Li metal negative electrode. Therefore, probing the interfacial electrolyte under in-operando conditions is highly desired to determine the true electrochemical interface and electrode performance. In this study, dissipation recording by force-distance analysis based on atomic force microscopy was applied for the first time to address these challenges and a notable performance was observed during this study. The energy dissipation of the cantilever during the force curve motion is an important indicator to evaluate the conditions of the interfacial electrolyte because the solution drag is based on the physical properties of the electrolyte. In the in-operando electrochemical experiments of the Li metal electrode with a tetraglyme-based electrolyte, the dissipation energy clearly changed corresponding to the charge-discharge reaction. Recording the dissipation based on the force-distance analysis coupled with electrochemical operation improved the understanding of the actual characteristics of the electrochemical interface based on the direct measurement of the physical properties.

Present and new frontiers in materials research by ambient pressure x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy

In this topical review we catagorise all ambient pressure x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy publications that have appeared between the 1970s and the end of 2018 according to their scientific field. We find that catalysis, surface science and materials science are predominant, while, for example, electrocatalysis and thin film growth are emerging. All catalysis publications that we could identify are cited, and selected case stories with increasing complexity in terms of surface structure or chemical reaction are discussed. For thin film growth we discuss recent examples from chemical vapour deposition and atomic layer deposition. Finally, we also discuss current frontiers of ambient pressure x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy research, indicating some directions of future development of the field.

Revealing the Active Phase of Copper during the Electroreduction of CO2 in Aqueous Electrolyte by Correlating In Situ X-ray Spectroscopy and In Situ Electron Microscopy

The variation in the morphology and electronic structure of copper during the electroreduction of CO₂ into valuable hydrocarbons and alcohols was revealed by combining in situ surface- and bulk-sensitive X-ray spectroscopies with electrochemical scanning electron microscopy. These experiments proved that the electrified interface surface and near-surface are dominated by reduced copper. The selectivity to the formation of the key C-C bond is enhanced at higher cathodic potentials as a consequence of increased copper metallicity. In addition, the reduction of the copper oxide electrode and oxygen loss in the lattice reconstructs the electrode to yield a rougher surface with more uncoordinated sites, which controls the dissociation barrier of water and CO₂. Thus, according to these results, copper oxide species can only be stabilized kinetically under CO₂ reduction reaction conditions.

Unusually High Concentration of Alkyl Ammonium Hydroxide in the Cation-Hydroxide-Water Coadsorbed Layer on Pt

Interactions between a catalyst and electrolyte have paramount importance for the performance of electrochemical devices. Here, we present the cation-hydroxide-water coadsorption on the Pt surface by a rotating disk electrode and neutron reflectometry. The rotating disk electrode experiments show that the current density of Pt rapidly dropped at hydrogen oxidation potentials due to tetramethylammonium hydroxide (TMAOH)-water coadsorption. Subsequent neutron reflectometry in 0.1 M TMAOD/D₂O reveals that the thickness of the coadsorbed layer increased to 18 Å after 10.5 h exposure at 0.1 V vs reverse hydrogen electrode (RHE). The scattering length density analysis revealed that the TMAOD to water ratio in the coadsorbed layer was 4.5, which was significantly higher than the reportedly highest TMAOH concentration in aqueous solution. Finally, we discuss the potential impact of the coadsorbed layer on the performance and durability of alkaline membrane fuel cells, which sheds light on the material design of high-performance alkaline electrochemical devices.

Controlling the Activity and Stability of Electrochemical Interfaces Using Atom-by-Atom Metal Substitution of Redox Species

Understanding the molecular-level properties of electrochemically active ions at operating electrode-electrolyte interfaces (EEI) is key to the rational development of high-performance nanostructured surfaces for applications in energy technology. Herein, an electrochemical cell coupled with ion soft landing is employed to examine the effect of "atom-by-atom" metal substitution on the activity and stability of well-defined redox-active anions, PMo _xW_{12- x}O₄₀^3- ( x = 0, 1, 2, 3, 6, 9, or 12) at nanostructured ionic liquid EEI. A striking observation made by in situ electrochemical measurements and further supported by theoretical calculations is that the substitution of only one to three tungsten atoms by molybdenum atoms in the PW₁₂O₄₀^3- anions results in a substantial spike in their first reduction potential. Specifically, PMo₃W₉O₄₀^3- showed the highest redox activity in both in situ electrochemical measurements and as part of a functional redox supercapacitor device, making it a "super-active redox anion" compared with all other PMo _xW_{12- x}O₄₀^3- species. Electronic structure calculations showed that metal substitution in PMo _xW_{12- x}O₄₀^3- causes the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) to protrude locally, making it the "active site" for reduction of the anion. Several critical factors contribute to the observed trend in redox activity including (i) multiple isomeric structures populated at room temperature, which affect the experimentally determined reduction potential; (ii) substantial decrease of the LUMO energy upon replacement of W atoms with more-electronegative Mo atoms; and (iii) structural relaxation of the reduced species produced after the first reduction step. Our results illustrate a path to achieving superior performance of technologically relevant EEIs in functional nanoscale devices through understanding of the molecular-level electronic properties of specific electroactive species with "atom-by-atom" precision.

In situ solid-state electrochemistry of mass-selected ions at well-defined electrode-electrolyte interfaces

Molecular-level understanding of electrochemical processes occurring at electrode-electrolyte interfaces (EEIs) is key to the rational development of high-performance and sustainable electrochemical technologies. This article reports the development and application of solid-state in situ thin-film electrochemical cells to explore redox and catalytic processes occurring at well-defined EEIs generated using soft-landing (SL) of mass- and charge-selected cluster ions. In situ cells with excellent mass-transfer properties are fabricated using carefully designed nanoporous ionic liquid membranes. SL enables deposition of pure active species that are not obtainable with other techniques onto electrode surfaces with precise control over charge state, composition, and kinetic energy. SL is, therefore, demonstrated to be a unique tool for studying fundamental processes occurring at EEIs. Using an aprotic cell, the effect of charge state ([Formula: see text]) and the contribution of building blocks of Keggin polyoxometalate (POM) clusters to redox processes are characterized by populating EEIs with POM anions generated by electrospray ionization and gas-phase dissociation. Additionally, a proton-conducting cell has been developed to characterize the oxygen reduction activity of bare Pt clusters (Pt₃₀ ∼1 nm diameter), thus demonstrating the capability of the cell for probing catalytic reactions in controlled gaseous environments. By combining the developed in situ electrochemical cell with ion SL we established a versatile method to characterize the EEI in solid-state redox systems and reactive electrochemistry at precisely defined conditions. This capability will advance the molecular-level understanding of processes occurring at EEIs that are critical to many energy-related technologies.