Overcoming Chemical Inertness under Ambient Conditions: A Critical View on Recent Developments in Ammonia Synthesis via Electrochemical N 2 Reduction by Asking Five Questions

Light-driven nitrogen fixation routes for green ammonia production

The global goal for decarbonization of the energy sector and the chemical industry could become a reality by a massive increase in renewable-based technologies. For this clean energy transition, the versatile green ammonia may play a key role in the future as a fossil-free fertilizer, long-term energy storage medium, chemical feedstock, and clean burning fuel for transportation and decentralized power generation. The high energy-intensive industrial ammonia production has triggered researchers to look for a step change in new synthetic approaches powered by renewable energies. This review provides a comprehensive comparison of light-mediated N2 fixation technologies for green ammonia production, including photocatalytic, photoelectrocatalytic, PV-electrocatalytic and photothermocatalytic routes. Since these approaches are still at laboratory scale, we examine the most recent developments and discuss the open challenges for future improvements. Last, we offer a technoeconomic comparison of current and emerging ammonia production technologies, highlighting costs, barriers, recommendations, and potential opportunities for the real development of the next generation of green ammonia solutions.

Searching for the Rules of Electrochemical Nitrogen Fixation

Li-mediated ammonia synthesis is, thus far, the only electrochemical method for heterogeneous decentralized ammonia production. The unique selectivity of the solid electrode provides an alternative to one of the largest heterogeneous thermal catalytic processes. However, it is burdened with intrinsic energy losses, operating at a Li plating potential. In this work, we survey the periodic table to understand the fundamental features that make Li stand out. Through density functional theory calculations and experimentation on chemistries analogous to lithium (e.g., Na, Mg, Ca), we find that lithium is unique in several ways. It combines a stable nitride that readily decomposes to ammonia with an ideal solid electrolyte interphase, balancing reagents at the reactive interface. We propose descriptors based on simulated formation and binding energies of key intermediates and further on hard and soft acids and bases (HSAB principle) to generalize such features. The survey will help the community toward electrochemical systems beyond Li for nitrogen fixation.

Coordinative Stabilization of Single Bismuth Sites in a Carbon-Nitrogen Matrix to Generate Atom-Efficient Catalysts for Electrochemical Nitrate Reduction to Ammonia

Electrochemical nitrate reduction to ammonia powered by renewable electricity is not only a promising alternative to the established energy-intense and non-ecofriendly Haber-Bosch reaction for ammonia generation but also a future contributor to the ever-more important denitrification schemes. Nevertheless, this reaction is still impeded by the lack of understanding for the underlying reaction mechanism on the molecular scale which is necessary for the rational design of active, selective, and stable electrocatalysts. Herein, a novel single-site bismuth catalyst (Bi-N-C) for nitrate electroreduction is reported to produce ammonia with maximum Faradaic efficiency of 88.7% and at a high rate of 1.38 mg h-1 mgcat -1 at -0.35 V versus reversible hydrogen electrode (RHE). The active center (described as BiN2 C2 ) is uncovered by detailed structural analysis. Coupled density functional theory calculations are applied to analyze the reaction mechanism and potential rate-limiting steps for nitrate reduction based on the BiN2 C2 model. The findings highlight the importance of model catalysts to utilize the potential of nitrate reduction as a new-generation nitrogen-management technology based on the construction of efficient active sites.

Metal-Based Electrocatalysts for Selective Electrochemical Nitrogen Reduction to Ammonia

Ammonia (NH3) plays a significant role in the manufacture of fertilizers, nitrogen-containing chemical production, and hydrogen storage. The electrochemical nitrogen reduction reaction (e-NRR) is an attractive prospect for achieving clean and sustainable NH3 production, under mild conditions driven by renewable energy. The sluggish cleavage of N≡N bonds and poor selectivity of e-NRR are the primary challenges for e-NRR, over the competitive hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). The rational design of e-NRR electrocatalysts is of vital significance and should be based on a thorough understanding of the structure-activity relationship and mechanism. Among the various explored e-NRR catalysts, metal-based electrocatalysts have drawn increasing attention due to their remarkable performances. This review highlighted the recent progress and developments in metal-based electrocatalysts for e-NRR. Different kinds of metal-based electrocatalysts used in NH3 synthesis (including noble-metal-based catalysts, non-noble-metal-based catalysts, and metal compound catalysts) were introduced. The theoretical screening and the experimental practice of rational metal-based electrocatalyst design with different strategies were systematically summarized. Additionally, the structure-function relationship to improve the NH3 yield was evaluated. Finally, current challenges and perspectives of this burgeoning area were provided. The objective of this review is to provide a comprehensive understanding of metal-based e-NRR electrocatalysts with a focus on enhancing their efficiency in the future.

Electrochemical Generation of Catalytically Active Edge Sites in C2 N-Type Carbon Materials for Artificial Nitrogen Fixation

The electrochemical nitrogen reduction reaction (NRR) to ammonia (NH₃ ) is a potentially carbon-neutral and decentralized supplement to the established Haber-Bosch process. Catalytic activation of the highly stable dinitrogen molecules remains a great challenge. Especially metal-free nitrogen-doped carbon catalysts do not often reach the desired selectivity and ammonia production rates due to their low concentration of NRR active sites and possible instability of heteroatoms under electrochemical potential, which can even contribute to false positive results. In this context, the electrochemical activation of nitrogen-doped carbon electrocatalysts is an attractive, but not yet established method to create NRR catalytic sites. Herein, a metal-free C₂ N material (HAT-700) is electrochemically etched prior to application in NRR to form active edge-sites originating from the removal of terminal nitrile groups. Resulting activated metal-free HAT-700-A shows remarkable catalytic activity in electrochemical nitrogen fixation with a maximum Faradaic efficiency of 11.4% and NH₃ yield of 5.86 µg mg^-1 _cat h^-1 . Experimental results and theoretical calculations are combined, and it is proposed that carbon radicals formed during activation together with adjacent pyridinic nitrogen atoms play a crucial role in nitrogen adsorption and activation. The results demonstrate the possibility to create catalytically active sites on purpose by etching labile functional groups prior to NRR.

Boosting electrochemical nitrogen reduction to ammonia with high efficiency using a LiNb3O8 electrocatalyst in neutral media

The nitrogen reduction reaction (NRR) has great potential as a method to replace the industrial Haber-Bosch process for ammonia synthesis. Nevertheless, the efficiency of the NRR is mainly dependent on the rational design of highly efficient and active electrocatalysts on account of the high energy of N₂ and HER as a competitive reaction. Herein, a simple solid-phase synthesis method is adopted to design and synthesize a LiNb₃O₈ (LNO) electrocatalyst, which proves that the synergistic effect of electron-rich Nb and Li elements can effectively improve the NRR activity of commercial Nb₂O₅ and Li₂CO₃. The resultant LNO electrocatalyst presents an ammonia yield rate of 7.85 μg h^-1 mg_cat.^-1 with a faradaic efficiency of 82.83% at -0.4 V vs. RHE under ambient conditions, which are much higher than those of commercial Nb₂O₅ (1.67 μg h^-1 mg_cat.^-1, 13.51%) and Li₂CO₃ (1.93 μg h^-1 mg_cat.^-1, 8.41%). Detailed characterizations demonstrate that the obtained LNO electrocatalyst has a larger specific surface area of electrochemical activity and more active sites to promote the activity of the NRR. Moreover, the synergistic effect of Li and Nb elements greatly improves the hydrophobicity of the material, which is more conducive to the occurrence of the NRR. This work highlights the enormous potential of the LNO electrocatalyst with a hydrophobic surface and easy activation of NN for highly efficient ammonia synthesis under ambient conditions.

Nanocarbon for Energy Material Applications: N2 Reduction Reaction

Nanocarbons are an important class of energy materials and one relevant application is for the nitrogen reduction reaction, i.e., the direct synthesis of NH₃ from N₂ and H₂ O via photo- and electrocatalytic approaches. Ammonia is also a valuable energy or hydrogen vector. This perspective paper analyses developments in the field, limiting discussion to nanocarbon-based electrodes. These aspects are discussed: i) active sites related to charge density differences on C atoms associated to defects/strains, ii) doping with heteroatoms, iii) introduction of isolated metal ions, iv) creation and in situ dynamics of metal oxide(hydroxide)/nanocarbon boundaries, and v) nanocarbon characteristics to control the interface. Discussion is focused on the performances and mechanistic aspects. Aim is not a systematic state-of-the-art report but to highlight the need to use a different perspective in studying this challenging reaction by using selected papers. Notwithstanding the large differences in the proposed nature of the active sites, fall all within a restricted range of performances, far from the targets. A holistic approach is emphasized to make a breakthrough advance.

Design strategies of two-dimensional metal-organic frameworks toward efficient electrocatalysts for N2 reduction: cooperativity of transition metals and organic linkers

Two-dimensional (2D) metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) serve as emerging electrocatalysts due to their high conductivity, chemical tunability, and accessibility of active sites. We herein proposed a series of 2D MOFs with different metal atoms and organic linkers with the formula M₃C₁₂X₁₂ (M = Cr, Mo, and W; X = NH, O, S, and Se) to design efficient nitrogen reduction reaction (NRR) electrocatalysts. Our theoretical calculations showed that metal atoms in M₃C₁₂X₁₂ can efficiently capture and activate N₂ molecules. Among these candidates, W₃C₁₂X₁₂ (X = O, S, and Se) show the best NRR performance due to their high activity and selectivity as well as low limiting potential (-0.59 V, -0.14 V, and -0.01 V, respectively). Moreover, we proposed a d-band center descriptor strategy to screen out the high activity and selectivity of M₃C₁₂X₁₂ for the NRR. Therefore, our work not only demonstrates a class of promising electrocatalysts for the NRR but also provides a strategy for further predicting the catalytic activity of 2D MOFs.

Synergy of Bi2 O3 and RuO2 Nanocatalysts for Low-Overpotential and Wide pH-Window Electrochemical Ammonia Synthesis

Electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction reaction (NRR) under ambient conditions is still seriously impeded by the inferior NH₃ yield and low Faradaic efficiency, especially at low overpotentials. Herein, we report the synthesis of nano-sized RuO₂ and Bi₂ O₃ particles grown on functionalized exfoliated graphene (FEG) through in situ electrodeposition, denoted as RuO₂ -Bi₂ O₃ /FEG. The prepared self-supporting RuO₂ -Bi₂ O₃ /FEG hybrid with a Bi mass loading of 0.70 wt% and Ru mass loading of 0.04 wt% shows excellent NRR performance at low overpotentials in acidic, neutral and alkaline electrolytes. It achieves a large NH₃ yield of 4.58±0.16 μg_NH3  h^-1  cm^-2 with a high Faradaic efficiency of 14.6 % at -0.2 V versus reversible hydrogen electrode in 0.1 M Na₂ SO₄ electrolyte. This performance benefits from the synergistic effect between Bi₂ O₃ and RuO₂ which respectively have a fairly strong interaction of Bi 6p orbitals with the N 2p band and abundant supply of *H, as well as the binder-free characteristic and the convenient electron transfer via graphene nanosheets. This work highlights a new electrocatalyst design strategy that combines transition and main-group metal elements, which may provide some inspirations for designing low-cost and high-performance NRR electrocatalysts in the future.

Comparing Molecular Mechanisms in Solar NH3 Production and Relations with CO2 Reduction

Molecular mechanisms for N2 fixation (solar NH3) and CO2 conversion to C2+ products in enzymatic conversion (nitrogenase), electrocatalysis, metal complexes and plasma catalysis are analyzed and compared. It is evidenced that differently from what is present in thermal and plasma catalysis, the electrocatalytic path requires not only the direct coordination and hydrogenation of undissociated N2 molecules, but it is necessary to realize features present in the nitrogenase mechanism. There is the need for (i) a multi-electron and -proton simultaneous transfer, not as sequential steps, (ii) forming bridging metal hydride species, (iii) generating intermediates stabilized by bridging multiple metal atoms and (iv) the capability of the same sites to be effective both in N2 fixation and in COx reduction to C2+ products. Only iron oxide/hydroxide stabilized at defective sites of nanocarbons was found to have these features. This comparison of the molecular mechanisms in solar NH3 production and CO2 reduction is proposed to be a source of inspiration to develop the next generation electrocatalysts to address the challenging transition to future sustainable energy and chemistry beyond fossil fuels.

Bismuth-Based Free-Standing Electrodes for Ambient-Condition Ammonia Production in Neutral Media

Electrocatalytic nitrogen reduction reaction is a carbon-free and energy-saving strategy for efficient synthesis of ammonia under ambient conditions. Here, we report the synthesis of nanosized Bi2O3 particles grown on functionalized exfoliated graphene (Bi2O3/FEG) via a facile electrochemical deposition method. The obtained free-standing Bi2O3/FEG achieves a high Faradaic efficiency of 11.2% and a large NH3 yield of 4.21 ± 0.14 [Formula: see text] h-1 cm-2 at - 0.5 V versus reversible hydrogen electrode in 0.1 M Na2SO4, better than that in the strong acidic and basic media. Benefiting from its strong interaction of Bi 6p band with the N 2p orbitals, binder-free characteristic, and facile electron transfer, Bi2O3/FEG achieves superior catalytic performance and excellent long-term stability as compared with most of the previous reported catalysts. This study is significant to design low-cost, high-efficient Bi-based electrocatalysts for electrochemical ammonia synthesis.