Polynuclear Bismuth-Oxo Clusters: Insight into the Formation Process of a Metal Oxide

Platonic and Archimedean solids in discrete metal-containing clusters

Metal-containing clusters have attracted increasing attention over the past 2-3 decades. This intense interest can be attributed to the fact that these discrete metal aggregates, whose atomically precise structures are resolved by single-crystal X-ray diffraction (SCXRD), often possess intriguing geometrical features (high symmetry, aesthetically pleasing shapes and architectures) and fascinating physical properties, providing invaluable opportunities for the intersection of different disciplines including chemistry, physics, mathematical geometry and materials science. In this review, we attempt to reinterpret and connect these fascinating clusters from the perspective of Platonic and Archimedean solid characteristics, focusing on highly symmetrical and complex metal-containing (metal = Al, Ti, V, Mo, W, U, Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Pd, Pt, Cu, Ag, Au, lanthanoids (Ln), and actinoids) high-nuclearity clusters, including metal-oxo/hydroxide/chalcogenide clusters and metal clusters (with metal-metal binding) protected by surface organic ligands, such as thiolate, phosphine, alkynyl, carbonyl and nitrogen/oxygen donor ligands. Furthermore, we present the symmetrical beauty of metal cluster structures and the geometrical similarity of different types of clusters and provide a large number of examples to show how to accurately describe the metal clusters from the perspective of highly symmetrical polyhedra. Finally, knowledge and further insights into the design and synthesis of unknown metal clusters are put forward by summarizing these "star" molecules.

Structural Chemistry of Giant Metal Based Supramolecules

The review presents a bird-eye view on the state of research in the field of giant nonbiological discrete metal complexes and ions of nanometer size, which are structurally characterized by means of single-crystal X-ray diffraction, using the crystal structure as a common key feature. The discussion is focused on the main structural features of the metal clusters, the clusters containing compact metal oxide/hydroxide/chalcogenide core, ligand-based metal-organic cages, and supramolecules as well as on the aspects related to the packing of the molecules or ions in the crystal and the methodological aspects of the single-crystal neutron and X-ray diffraction of these compounds.

Real-Time Observation of "Soft" Magic-Size Clusters during Hydrolysis of the Model Metallodrug Bismuth Disalicylate

Colloidal bismuth therapeutics have been used for hundreds of years, yet remain mysterious. Here we report an X-ray pair distribution function (PDF) study of the solvolysis of bismuth disalicylate, a model for the metallodrug bismuth subsalicylate (Pepto-Bismol). This reveals catalysis by traces of water, followed by multistep cluster growth. The ratio of the two major species, {Bi₉O₇} and {Bi₃₈O₄₄}, depends on exposure to air, time, and the solvent. The solution-phase cluster structures are of significantly higher symmetry in comparison to solid-state analogues, with reduced off-center Bi³⁺ displacements. This explains why such "magic-size" clusters can be both stable enough to crystallize and sufficiently labile for further growth.

Structural Changes during the Growth of Atomically Precise Metal Oxido Nanoclusters from Combined Pair Distribution Function and Small-Angle X-ray Scattering Analysis

The combination of in situ pair distribution function (PDF) analysis and small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) enables analysis of the formation mechanism of metal oxido nanoclusters and cluster-solvent interactions as they take place. Herein, we demonstrate the method for the formation of clusters with a [Bi38 O45 ] core. Upon dissolution of crystalline [Bi6 O5 (OH)3 (NO3 )5 ]⋅3 H2 O in DMSO, an intermediate rapidly forms, which slowly grows to stable [Bi38 O45 ] clusters. To identify the intermediate, we developed an automated modeling method, where smaller [Bix Oy ] structures based on the [Bi38 O45 ] framework are tested against the data. [Bi22 O26 ] was identified as the main intermediate species, illustrating how combined PDF and SAXS analysis is a powerful tool to gain insight into nucleation on an atomic scale. PDF also provides information on the interaction between nanoclusters and solvent, which is shown to depend on the nature of the ligands on the cluster surface.

Bismuth for Controlled Assembly/Disassembly of Transition-Metal Oxo Clusters, Defining Reaction Pathways in Inorganic Synthesis and Nature

Trivalent bismuth is a unique heavy p-block ion. It is highly insoluble in water, due to strong hydrolysis tendencies, and known for low toxicity. Its lone pair is structure-directing, providing framework materials with structural flexibility, leading to piezoelectric and multiferroic function. The flexibility it provides is also advantageous for dopants and vacancies, giving rise to conductivity, luminescence, color, and catalytic properties. We are exploiting Bi³⁺ in a completely different way, as a knob to "tune" the solubility and stability of transition-metal oxo clusters. The lone pair allows capping and isolation of metastable cluster forms for solid-state and solution characterization. With controlled release of the bismuth (via bismuth oxyhalide metathesis), the metal oxo clusters can be retained in aqueous solution, and we can track their reaction pathways and conversion to related metal oxyhydroxides. Here we present isolation of a bismuth-stabilized Mn^IV cluster, fully formulated [Mn^IV₆Bi₂KO₉(CH₃COO)₁₀(H₂O)₃(NO₃)₂] (Mn₆Bi₂). In addition to characterization by single-crystal X-ray diffraction, solution characterization in acetonitrile and acetonitrile-acetic acid by small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) and electrospray ionization mass spectrometry shows high stability and the tendency of Mn₆Bi₂ to link into chains by bridging the bismuth (and potassium) caps with nitrate and acetate ligands. On the other hand, the dissolution of Mn₆Bi₂ in water, with and without metathesis of the bismuth, leads to the precipitation of related oxyhydroxide phases, which we characterized by transmission electron microscopy (TEM), electron diffraction, and energy-dispersive spectroscopy, and the conversion pathway by SAXS. Without removal of bismuth, amorphous manganese/bismuth oxyhydroxides precipitate within a day. On the other hand, metathesis of BiOBr yields a solution containing soluble manganese oxyhydroxide prenucleation clusters that assemble and precipitate over 10 days. This allows tracking of the reaction pathway via SAXS. We observe one-dimensional growth of species, followed by the precipitation of nanocrystalline hollandite (identified by TEM). The hollandite is presumably templated by the K⁺, originally in the crystalline lattice of Mn₆Bi₂. In this Forum Article that combines new results and prospective, we compare these results to prior studies in which we first introduced the use of capping Bi³⁺ to stabilize reactive clusters, followed by destabilization to understand reaction pathways in synthesis and low-temperature geochemistry.

From a Cerium-Doped Polynuclear Bismuth Oxido Cluster to β-Bi2O3:Ce

The simultaneous hydrolysis of Bi(NO₃)₃·5H₂O and Ce(NO₃)₃·6H₂O results in the formation of novel heterometallic bismuth oxido clusters with the general formula [Bi₃₈O₄₅(NO₃)₂₄(DMSO)_28+δ]:Ce (DMSO = dimethyl sulfoxide; cerium content <1.50%), which is demonstrated by single-crystal X-ray diffraction analysis. The incorporation of cerium into the cluster core is a result of the interplay of hydrolysis and condensation of the metal nitrates in the presence of oxygen. Diffuse-reflectance UV-vis and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy reveal the presence of Ce^IV in the final bismuth oxido clusters as a result of oxidation of the cerium source. The cerium atoms are statistically distributed mainly on the bismuth atom positions of the central [Bi₆O₉] motif of the [Bi₃₈O₄₅] cluster core. Hydrolysis and subsequent annealing of the bismuth oxido clusters in the temperature range of 300-400 °C provides β-Bi₂O₃:Ce samples with slightly lowered band gaps of approximately 2.3 eV compared to the undoped β-Bi₂O₃ (approximately 2.4 eV). The sintering behavior of β-Bi₂O₃ is significantly affected by the cerium dopant. Finally, differences in the efficiency of the as-prepared β-Bi₂O₃:Ce and undoped β-Bi₂O₃ samples in the photocatalytic decomposition of the biocide triclosan in an aqueous solution under visible-light irradiation are demonstrated.

Hybrid Rare-Earth(III)/Bismuth(III) Clusters Assembled with Phosphonates

tert-Butylphosphonic acid and rare-earth precursors are employed to construct four trinuclear rare-earth phosphonate clusters, RE₃( ^tBuPO₃)₂(hfac)₅(CH₃OH)₈]·2CH₃OH (RE = Eu, Y, Pr, and Sm; hfac = hexafluoroacetylacetonate), which are composed of three RE³⁺ ions alternately bridged by two phosphonates. With the introduction of bismuth oxido diketonate, [Bi₉O₇(hfac)₁₃], three different types of rare-earth/bismuth phosphonate clusters, Bi₁₂RE₂ (RE = Pr and Sm), Bi₆Eu₇, and Bi₆Y₉, are successfully obtained via variation of the reaction conditions, and they are the first reported examples of bismuth-oxo clusters encapsulated by cyclic rare-earth-oxo or rare-earth/bismuth-oxo phosphonate clusters, respectively. These clusters show obvious absorption in the UV region, and the Eu-containing clusters exhibit bright-red fluorescence.

Heteroaryl bismuthines: a novel synthetic concept and metalπ heteroarene interactions

The alkoxide Bi[OCMe₂(2-C₄H₃S)]₃ (1) is formed by the reaction of three equiv. of the alcohol HOCMe₂(2-C₄H₃S) with Bi(O^tBu)₃ and subsequent hydrolysis provides the bismuth oxido cluster [Bi₄O₂{OCMe₂(2-C₄H₃S)}₈] (2). In contrast, the reaction of Bi(O^tBu)₃ and Bi[N(SiMe₃)₂]₃ with the silanols HOSiMe₂(2-C₄H₃X) (X = O, S, Se, and NMe), HOSiMe₂(2-C₄H₂S-5-SiMe₃) and HOSiMe₂(3-C₄H₃S) leads to the formation of tris(heteroaryl)bismuthines Bi(2-C₄H₂X-5-R)₃ [where X = O, R = H (3); X = S, R = H (4); X = S, R = SiMe₃ (5); X = NMe, R = H (6); X = Se, R = H (7)] and Bi(3-C₄H₃S)₃ (8). For the silanols, bismuth-carbon bond formation is observed rather than silanol-alcoholate or silanol-amide exchange. The structures of compounds 1, 2, and 4-7a in the solid state were established by single crystal X-ray diffraction and all compounds except 5 show London dispersion type bismuthπ heteroarene interactions. For the bismuthine Bi(2-C₄H₃Se)₃ (7), two polymorphs were isolated depending on the conditions of crystallization. At 8 °C, polymorph I (7a) crystallizes from an n-hexane solution in the triclinic space group P1[combining macron], whereas polymorph II (7b) crystallizes at 20 °C from a CH₂Cl₂/n-pentane solution in the monoclinic space group P2₁/c. The heteroaryl bismuthines 3 and 4 exhibit 2D network structures as a result of bismuthπ heteroarene interactions, whereas for the pyrrole derivative 6 the dispersion type interactions provide separated dimers.

High-nuclearity silver ethynide clusters containing polynucleating oxygen donor ligands

Three high-nuclearity heterometallic ethynide clusters were constructed with various polynucleating oxygen donor ligands.

Structural influences on the activity of bismuth(III) indole-carboxylato complexes towards Helicobacter pylori and Leishmania

Seven new bismuth(III) complexes derived from indole-carboxylic acids have been synthesised: five are homoleptic; [Bi(IAA)₃] B1, [Bi(IPA)₃] B2, [Bi(IBA)₃] B3, [Bi(MICA)₃] B4, [Bi(IGA)₃] B6, and two are heteroleptic [BiPh(MICA)₂] B5 (where IAA-H=2-(1H-indol-3-yl)acetic acid, IPA-H=3-(1H-indol-3-yl)propanoic acid, IBA-H=4-(1H-indol-3-yl)butanoic acid, IGA-H=2-(1H-indol-3-yl)-2-oxoacetic acid, and MICA-H=1-methyl-1H-indole-3-carboxylic acid). All complexes were fully characterised by elemental analysis, infrared and mass-spectroscopy, and nuclear magnetic resonance (¹H, ¹³C) spectroscopy. Complex [BiPh(IGA)₂] B7 is structurally authenticated by X-ray crystallography as a dimer in the solid-state. The in-vitro anti-bacterial activity of the indole-carboxylic acids and their bismuth(III) complexes was assessed against Helicobacter pylori. While the acids were non-toxic at <100μgmL^-1, all the bismuth compounds showed an MIC of 6.25μgmL^-1, indicating that the anti-bacterial activity is insensitive to the degree of substitution at the Bi(III) centre or the composition of the indole-carboxylate ligands. All compounds were further tested for their anti-parasitic activity against Leishmania major and for their toxicity towards mammalian cells. From the anti-parasitic studies, it was found that the heteroleptic bismuth(III) complexes are the most active, with B5 and B7 showing comparable activity to Amphotericin B, without any toxicity towards the mammalian cells at their effective concentration.

Anionic Bismuth-Oxido Carboxylate Clusters with Transition Metal Countercations

Six new anionic bismuth-oxido clusters containing trifluoroacetate ligands were prepared. These include two new Bi₆O₈ clusters: [M(NCMe)₂(H₂O)₄]₃[Bi₆(μ₃-O)₄(μ₃-OH)₄(CF₃CO₂)₁₂] with an octahedral Bi₆O₄(OH)₄ core (M = Ni, 1a; Co, 1b) and four Bi₄O₂ clusters, {[Co(NCMe)₆][Bi₄(μ₃-O)₂(CF₃CO₂)₁₀]}_n (2a), {[Co{HC(MeCO)₂(MeCNH)}₂][Bi₄(μ₃-O)₂(CF₃CO₂)₁₀]·2[CF₃CO₂]·2[CF₃CO₂H]·2[H₂O]}_n (2b), {[Cu(NCMe)₄]₂[Bi₄(μ₃-O)₂(CF₃CO₂)₁₀]·2[CF₃CO₂H]}_n (2c), and {[Me₄N]₂[Bi₄(μ₃-O)₂(CF₃CO₂)₁₀]·2[CF₃CO₂H]}_n (2d). These are among the first bismuth-oxido anionic clusters synthesized, and the first to have transition metal countercations. The Bi₆O₈ anion in 1a and 1b is a high-symmetry octahedron. Additionally, two of the new Bi₄O₂ clusters are arranged in 1D polymeric structures via bridging carboxylate ligands. The cation in compound 2c had not been previously characterized and was also observed in the synthesis of [Co{HC(MeCO)₂(MeCNH)}₂][Bi(NO₃)₆] (3). The new compounds were characterized using single crystal X-ray crystallography and elemental analysis.

Synthesis and characterization of a Bi10O8(OAr)16 oxo-cluster supported by p-tert-butylcalix[5]arene ligands

Wet [^tBuC5(Bn)(H)₄] ligand reacts with excess of Bi[N(SiMe₃)₂]₃ to yield the dimeric complex 1 [Bi{^tBuC5(Bn)(H)}]₂ and cluster 2 [Bi₁₀O₈{^tBuC5(Bn)(H)}₄]. Complex 2 features multicoordinated bismuth(iii) centers in an overall Bi₁₀O₈(OAr)₁₆ core which represents the largest bismuth oxo-cluster supported by calix[n]arene ligands to date.

Assembling anionic Sb(v)/(iii) containing polyoxostibonates stabilized by triphenyltellurium cations

Mixed valent polyoxostibonates ligated by tetraorganoditelluroxane and stabilized by weak interactions from triaryltellurium cations are presented. Successive reactions like reduction, dearylation and disproportionation have been observed en route to the formation of these novel POMs.

Synthesis and structural studies of the simplest bismuth(iii) oxo-salicylate complex: [Bi4(μ3-O)2(HO-2-C6H4CO2)8]·2Solv (Solv = MeCN or MeNO2)

Reaction of BiPh₃ with salicylic acid at room temperature in wet acetonitrile or nitromethane leads to the facile formation of the simplest bismuth oxo salicylate cluster found to date.

Bismuth(iii) benzohydroxamates: powerful anti-bacterial activity against Helicobacter pylori and hydrolysis to a unique Bi34 oxido-cluster [Bi34O22(BHA)22(H-BHA)14(DMSO)6]

Bismuth(iii) benzohydroxamates; [Bi₂(HBA)₃], [Bi(H-BHA)₃], [Bi(HBA)(H-HBA)] and [Bi₃₄O₂₂(BHA)₂₂(H-BHA)₁₄(DMSO)₆], all show exceptional toxicity towards Helicobacter pylori (MIC 0.08–3.24 μM).

The Anhydride Route to Group 15/16 Ligands in Oligomeric and Polymeric Environments: From Metal Complexes to Supraionic Chemistry

The aim of this paper is to introduce a synthetic concept suitable for the preparation of a broad variety of compounds. The so-called anhydride route (in this article the term anhydride is used for compounds derived from corresponding acids by formal loss of H2O, H2S and H2Se) has so far led to a range of unusual Group 15/16 ligands in oligomeric and polymeric environments. Commonly, reactions of neutral precursor molecules, for example, [{RP(S)(mu-S)}2] (R=4-anisyl) Lawesson's reagent or [{PhP(Se)(mu-Se)}2] Woollins's reagent and metal salts are performed to result in novel coordination compounds in which ligands and metal atoms form coordination oligomers and polymers. An attempt is made to relate the outcome of the investigations to the type of metal used. By relating the strength of ionic interactions, which correspond to metal-donor distances, to phenomena observed in the solid-state structures, an aspect of supraionic chemistry is described. Chemistry of and beyond novel Group 15/16 anions is further discussed using a novel approach in coordination chemistry where the chemical nature of ligands is unknown prior to the experiment despite the use of a range of similar starting materials.