Triplet‐State Position and Crystal‐Field Tuning in Opto‐Magnetic Lanthanide Complexes: Two Sides of the Same Coin

Optical Phenomena in Molecule-Based Magnetic Materials

Since the last century, we have witnessed the development of molecular magnetism which deals with magnetic materials based on molecular species, i.e., organic radicals and metal complexes. Among them, the broadest attention was devoted to molecule-based ferro-/ferrimagnets, spin transition materials, including those exploring electron transfer, molecular nanomagnets, such as single-molecule magnets (SMMs), molecular qubits, and stimuli-responsive magnetic materials. Their physical properties open the application horizons in sensors, data storage, spintronics, and quantum computation. It was found that various optical phenomena, such as thermochromism, photoswitching of magnetic and optical characteristics, luminescence, nonlinear optical and chiroptical effects, as well as optical responsivity to external stimuli, can be implemented into molecule-based magnetic materials. Moreover, the fruitful interactions of these optical effects with magnetism in molecule-based materials can provide new physical cross-effects and multifunctionality, enriching the applications in optical, electronic, and magnetic devices. This Review aims to show the scope of optical phenomena generated in molecule-based magnetic materials, including the recent advances in such areas as high-temperature photomagnetism, optical thermometry utilizing SMMs, optical addressability of molecular qubits, magneto-chiral dichroism, and opto-magneto-electric multifunctionality. These findings are discussed in the context of the types of optical phenomena accessible for various classes of molecule-based magnetic materials.

Confining single Er3+ ions in sub-3 nm NaYF4 nanoparticles to induce slow relaxation of the magnetisation

Molecular systems known as single-molecule magnets (SMMs) exhibit magnet-like behaviour of slow relaxation of the magnetisation and magnetic hysteresis and have potential application in high-density memory storage or quantum computing. Often, their intrinsic magnetic properties are plagued by low-energy molecular vibrations that lead to phonon-induced relaxation processes, however, there is no straightforward synthetic approach for molecular systems that would lead to a small amount of low-energy vibrations and low phonon density of states at the spin-resonance energies. In this work, we apply knowledge accumulated over the last decade in molecular magnetism to nanoparticles, incorporating Er3+ ions in an ultrasmall sub-3 nm diamagnetic NaYF4 nanoparticle (NP) and probing the slow relaxation dynamics intrinsic to the Er3+ ion. Furthermore, by increasing the doping concentration, we also investigate the role of intraparticle interactions within the NP. The knowledge gained from this study is anticipated to enable better design of magnetically high-performance molecular and bulk magnets for a wide variety of applications, such as molecular electronics.

Utility of all-pyrazole heteroscorpionates in f-element chemistry

Since their discovery in 1966, scorpionate ligands have been utilized to make coordination compounds for a variety of applications such as: studying organometallic reactions, biomimetic complexes, light-emitting materials and single-ion magnets. The recent development of a solvent-free pyrazole substitution chemistry has yielded the quantitative synthesis of asymmetrically functionalized all-pyrazole heteroscorpionate ligands. In this frontier article, we highlight the utility of all-pyrazole heteroscorpionates, specifically, nitro-trispyrazolylborates, in f-element chemistry. They offer great versatility in coordinating ability, donor strength, steric bulk and even optical charge transfer properties, all of which can be used to tune the properties of resultant complexes with metal ions. We show how they can impart structural diversity, sensitize Ln3+ luminescence and engender magnetic anisotropy and slow magnetic relaxation in the ion they coordinate. Additionally, we comment on the future of functionalized trispyrazolyl scorpionates, which includes enabling post-synthetic modifications of f-element complexes and becoming a platform to study the electronic properties of low oxidation state actinides.

Tetranuclear lanthanide-based silsesquioxanes: towards a combination of a slow relaxation of the magnetization and a luminescent thermometry

Lanthanide-based silsesquioxanes constitute an emerging family of cage-like metallasilsesquioxanes with exciting optical and magnetic properties. We report here the synthesis, structures and luminescence properties of a series of tetranuclear lanthanide-silsesquioxane compounds of general formula [NEt4]2[(Ph4Si4O8)2(Ln/Ln')4(NO3)6(EtOH)2(MeCN)2]·4(MeCN) with different lanthanide ions (where Ln/Ln' = Dy3+/Eu3+ (1), Dy3+/Tb3+ (2) and Eu3+/Tb3+/Y3+ (3)) and investigate the impact of the lanthanide ions combination on magnetic and photo-luminescent properties. Compound 1 behaves as a field-induced Single Molecule Magnet (SMM) and presents temperature-dependent luminescence characteristics of Eu3+ making it an emissive thermometer working in the temperature range 293-373 K with the maximum relative sensitivity of 1.15% K-1 achieved at 293 K. Compounds 2 and 3 are paramagnets, which demonstrate a characteristic photoluminescence with Dy3+ to Tb3+ and Tb3+ to Eu3+ energy transfers, respectively.

Lanthanide molecular cluster-aggregates as the next generation of optical materials

In this perspective, we provide an overview of the recent achievements in luminescent lanthanide-based molecular cluster-aggregates (MCAs) and illustrate why MCAs can be seen as the next generation of highly efficient optical materials. MCAs are high nuclearity compounds composed of rigid multinuclear metal cores encapsulated by organic ligands. The combination of high nuclearity and molecular structure makes MCAs an ideal class of compounds that can unify the properties of traditional nanoparticles and small molecules. By bridging the gap between both domains, MCAs intrinsically retain unique features with tremendous impacts on their optical properties. Although homometallic luminescent MCAs have been extensively studied since the late 1990s, it was only recently that heterometallic luminescent MCAs were pioneered as tunable luminescent materials. These heterometallic systems have shown tremendous impacts in areas such as anti-counterfeiting materials, luminescent thermometry, and molecular upconversion, thus representing a new generation of lanthanide-based optical materials.

Tuning the optical and magnetic properties of lanthanide single-ion magnets using nitro-functionalized trispyrazolylborate ligands

We report the synthesis, crystal structures, photophysical and magnetic properties of 11 novel lanthanide complexes with the asymmetrically functionalized trispyrazolylborate ligand 4-nitrotrispyrazolylborate, 4-NO₂Tp^-: [Ln(4-NO₂Tp)₃] (Ln = La-Dy, except Pm). In-depth photophysical characterization of the ligands via luminescence, reflectance and absorption spectroscopic techniques, decay lifetimes, quantum yields supported by time-dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT) and natural bond order (NBO) analysis reveal that n-NO₂Tp^- ligands are dominated by intra-ligand charge transfer (ILCT) transitions and that second-sphere interactions are critical to the stabilization of the T₁ state of n-NO₂Tp^- ligands and hence their ability to sensitize Ln³⁺ emission. The luminescence properties of the complexes indicate that 4-NO₂Tp^- is a poor sensitizer of Ln³⁺ emission, unlike 3-NO₂Tp^-. Moreover, [Nd(4-NO₂Tp)₃] (crystallized as a hexane solvate) displays single-molecule magnet (SMM) properties, with longer relaxation times and larger barrier than the non-functionalized [NdTp₃], attributed to the addition of the NO₂-group and subsequent rigidification of the molecular structure.

Tunable Optical Molecular Thermometers Based on Metallacrowns

The effect of ligands' energy levels on thermal dependence of lanthanide emission was examined to create new molecular nanothermometers. A series of Ln₂Ga₈L₈^'L₈^″ metallacrowns (shorthand Ln₂L₈^'), where Ln = Gd³⁺, Tb³⁺, or Sm³⁺ (H₃L' = salicylhydroxamic acid (H₃shi), 5-methylsalicylhydroxamic acid (H₃mshi), 5-methoxysalicylhydroxamic acid (H₃moshi), and 3-hydroxy-2-naphthohydroxamic acid (H₃nha)) and H₂L″ = isophthalic acid (H₂iph), was synthesized and characterized. Within the series, ligand-centered singlet state (S₁) energy levels ranged from 23,300 to 27,800 cm^-1, while triplet (T₁) energy levels ranged from 18,150 to 21,980 cm^-1. We demonstrated that the difference between T₁ levels and relevant energies of the excited ⁴G_5/2 level of Sm³⁺ (17,800 cm^-1) and ⁵D₄ level of Tb³⁺ (20,400 cm^-1) is the major parameter controlling thermal dependence of the emission intensity via the back energy transfer mechanism. However, when the energy difference between S₁ and T₁ levels is small (below 3760 cm^-1), the S₁ → T₁ intersystem crossing (and its reverse, S₁ ← T₁) mechanism contributes to the thermal behavior of metallacrowns. Both mechanisms affect Ln³⁺-centered room-temperature quantum yields with values ranging from 2.07(6)% to 31.2(2)% for Tb₂L₈^' and from 0.0267(7)% to 2.27(5)% for Sm₂L₈^'. The maximal thermal dependence varies over a wide thermal range (ca. 150-350 K) based on energy gaps between relevant ligand-based and lanthanide-based electronic states. By mixing Tb₂moshi₈^' with Sm₂moshi₈^' in a 1:1 ratio, an optical thermometer with a relative thermal sensitivity larger than 3%/K at 225 K was created. Other temperature ranges are also accessible with this approach.

Luminescence thermometry in a Dy4 single molecule magnet

The tetranuclear linear complex [Dy₄(1,1,4-H₃L^r)₂(OAc)₆]·CH₃OH (1·CH₃OH) was satisfactorily prepared and characterized. Its X-ray structure shows that it contains two types of octacoordinated Dy^III ions, with distorted triangular dodecahedral and square antiprism geometries. This complex is an SMM, with multiple relaxation pathways, and with an anisotropic energy barrier of 39.7 K. 1·CH₃OH also operates as a luminescent thermometer in the 11-295 K range, with a maximum relative thermal sensitivity of 1.6% K^-1 and a minimum temperature uncertainty of 1.1 K at 295 K. Thus, 1·CH₃OH is the first Dy₄ SMM with luminescent thermometry, and this system is a rare example of dysprosium SMM that accesses the thermometric characteristics involving the ligand ascribed to the triplet emission in combination with Dy^III emission.

Luminescence thermometry and field induced slow magnetic relaxation based on a near infrared emissive heterometallic complex

The 1 : 1 : 1 reaction of YbCl₃·6H₂O, K₃[Co(CN)₆] and bpyO₂ in H₂O has provided access to a complex with formula [YbCo(CN)₆(bpyO₂)₂(H₂O)₃]·4H₂O (1) in a very good yield while its structure has been determined by single-crystal X-ray crystallography and characterised based on elemental analyses and IR spectra. Magnetic susceptibility studies showed the complex to be a field induced single molecule magnet, as confirmed by μ-SQUID measurements. CASSCF calculations confirm the existence of a m_J = 7/2 ground state, with rather large transverse components, responsible for the fast relaxation characteristic of compound 1 at zero DC field, which is reduced upon application of DC fields. Moreover, a combination of luminescence studies along with CASSCF calculation allows the identification of the band structure of the complex, which is ultimately related to its electronic properties. Compound 1 operates as a luminescent thermometer in the 125-300 K range with a maximum relative thermal sensitivity of ≈0.1% K^-1 at 180 K.

Toward Opto-Structural Correlation to Investigate Luminescence Thermometry in an Organometallic Eu(II) Complex

Lanthanide-based luminescent materials have unique properties and are well-studied for many potential applications. In particular, the characteristic 5d → 4f emission of divalent lanthanide ions such as Eu^II allows for tunability of the emissive properties via modulation of the coordination environment. We report the synthesis and photoluminescence investigation of pentamethylcyclopentadienyleuropium(II) tetrahydroborate bis(tetrahydrofuran) dimer (1), the first example of an organometallic, discrete molecular Eu^II band-shift luminescence thermometer. Complex 1 exhibits an absolute sensitivity of 8.2 cm^-1 K^-1 at 320 K, the highest thus far observed for a lanthanide-based band-shift thermometer. Opto-structural correlation via variable-temperature single-crystal X-ray diffraction and fluorescence spectroscopy allows rationalization of the remarkable thermometric luminescence of complex 1 and reveals the significant potential of molecular Eu^II compounds in luminescence thermometry.

One ion to catch them all: Targeted high-precision Boltzmann thermometry over a wide temperature range with Gd3

Ratiometric luminescence thermometry with trivalent lanthanide ions and their 4fn energy levels is an emerging technique for non-invasive remote temperature sensing with high spatial and temporal resolution. Conventional ratiometric luminescence thermometry often relies on thermal coupling between two closely lying energy levels governed by Boltzmann's law. Despite its simplicity, Boltzmann thermometry with two excited levels allows precise temperature sensing, but only within a limited temperature range. While low temperatures slow down the nonradiative transitions required to generate a measurable population in the higher excitation level, temperatures that are too high favour equalized populations of the two excited levels, at the expense of low relative thermal sensitivity. In this work, we extend the concept of Boltzmann thermometry to more than two excited levels and provide quantitative guidelines that link the choice of energy gaps between multiple excited states to the performance in different temperature windows. By this approach, it is possible to retain the high relative sensitivity and precision of the temperature measurement over a wide temperature range within the same system. We demonstrate this concept using YAl3(BO3)4 (YAB):Pr3+, Gd3+ with an excited 6PJ crystal field and spin-orbit split levels of Gd3+ in the UV range to avoid a thermal black body background even at the highest temperatures. This phosphor is easily excitable with inexpensive and powerful blue LEDs at 450 nm. Zero-background luminescence thermometry is realized by using blue-to-UV energy transfer upconversion with the Pr3+-Gd3+ couple upon excitation in the visible range. This method allows us to cover a temperature window between 30 and 800 K.

Inside-Out/Outside-In Tunability in Nanosized Lanthanide-Based Molecular Cluster-Aggregates: Modulating the Luminescence Thermometry Performance via Composition Control

Modulating the optical property of a material via structural modification is a powerful tool for obtaining the desired optical output. If a material can be tuned inside (core) and outside (outer shell), then the degree of control is greater toward application. Herein, we present a lanthanide-based nanosized molecular cluster aggregate (MCA) that allows fine-tuning of the inner core via composition control akin to nanoparticles. At the same time, the tunable outer shell enables light-harvesting properties similar to molecular systems. As such {Eu₄Tb₁₆}, {Eu₃Gd₅Tb₁₂}, {Eu₂Gd₁₀Tb₈}, and {Eu₁Gd₁₅Tb₄} compositions were synthesized, and their photophysical properties were investigated in solution and in the solid state. Controlling the composition and spacing of the emitter ions with the optically silent Gd^III ions results in a decrease in the Tb^III → Eu^III energy-transfer process efficiency. Consequently, ratiometric luminescence thermometry performance is fine-tuned to reach a maximum relative sensitivity of 4.17% °C^-1 at 36 °C for the {Eu₄Tb₁₆} MCA. This study demonstrates that the optical properties are intrinsic to individual MCA species rather than a collective intermolecular effect. The color change observed close to room temperature for {Eu₂Gd₁₀Tb₈} suggests potential applications such as multistage anticounterfeiting technology.

Overview of N-Rich Antennae Investigated in Lanthanide-Based Temperature Sensing

The market share of noncontact temperature sensors is expending due to fast technological and medical evolutions. In the wide variety of noncontact sensors, lanthanide-based temperature sensors stand out. They benefit from high photostability, relatively long decay times and high quantum yields. To circumvent their low molar light absorption, the incorporation of a light-harvesting antenna is required. This Review provides an overview of the nitrogen-rich antennae in lanthanide-based temperature sensors, emitting in the visible light spectrum, and discusses their temperature sensor ability. The N-rich ligands are incorporated in many different platforms. The investigation of different antennae is required to develop temperature sensors with diverse optical properties and to create a diverse offer for the multiple application fields. Molecular probes, consisting of small molecules, are first discussed. Furthermore, the thermometer properties of ratiometric temperature sensors, based on di- and polynuclear complexes, metal-organic frameworks, periodic mesoporous organosilicas and porous organic polymers, are summarized. The antenna mainly determines the application potential of the ratiometric thermometer. It can be observed that molecular probes are operational in the broad physiological range, metal-organic frameworks are generally very useful in the cryogenic region, periodic mesoporous organosilica show temperature dependency in the physiological range, and porous organic polymers are operative in the cryogenic-to-medium temperature range.

Lanthanide-Based Molecular Cluster-Aggregates: Optical Barcoding and White-Light Emission with Nanosized {Ln20 } Compounds

Counterfeit goods represent a major problem to companies, governments, and customers, affecting the global economy. In order to protect the authenticity of products and documents, optical anti-counterfeit technologies have widely been employed via the use of discrete molecular species, extended metal-organic frameworks (MOFs), and nanoparticles. Herein, for the first time we demonstrate the potential use of molecular cluster-aggregates (MCA) as optical barcodes via composition and energy transfer control. The tuneable optical properties for the [Ln₂₀ (chp)₃₀ (CO₃ )₁₂ (NO₃ )₆ (H₂ O)₆ ], where chp^- =deprotonated 6-chloro-2-pyridinol, allow the fine control of the emission colour output, resulting in high-security level optical labelling with a precise read-out. Moreover, a unique tri-doped composition of Gd^III , Tb^III , and Eu^III led to MCAs with white-light emission. The presented methodology is a unique approach to probe the effect of composition control on the luminescent properties of nanosized molecular material.

Lanthanoid Complexes as Molecular Materials: The Redox Approach

The development of molecular materials with novel functionality offers promise for technological innovation. Switchable molecules that incorporate redox-active components are enticing candidate compounds due to their potential for electronic manipulation. Lanthanoid metals are most prevalent in their trivalent state and usually redox-activity in lanthanoid complexes is restricted to the ligand. The unique electronic and physical properties of lanthanoid ions have been exploited for various applications, including in magnetic and luminescent materials as well as in catalysis. Lanthanoid complexes are also promising for applications reliant on switchability, where the physical properties can be modulated by varying the oxidation state of a coordinated ligand. Lanthanoid-based redox activity is also possible, encompassing both divalent and tetravalent metal oxidation states. Thus, utilization of redox-active lanthanoid metals offers an attractive opportunity to further expand the capabilities of molecular materials. This review surveys both ligand and lanthanoid centered redox-activity in pre-existing molecular systems, including tuning of lanthanoid magnetic and photophysical properties by modulating the redox states of coordinated ligands. Ultimately the combination of redox-activity at both ligands and metal centers in the same molecule can afford novel electronic structures and physical properties, including multiconfigurational electronic states and valence tautomerism. Further targeted exploration of these features is clearly warranted, both to enhance understanding of the underlying fundamental chemistry, and for the generation of a potentially important new class of molecular material.

Asymmetric Ring Opening in a Tetrazine-Based Ligand Affords a Tetranuclear Opto-Magnetic Ytterbium Complex

We report the formation of a tetranuclear lanthanide cluster, [Yb₄ (bpzch)₂ (fod)₁₀ ] (1), which occurs from a serendipitous ring opening of the functionalised tetrazine bridging ligand, bpztz (3,6-dipyrazin-2-yl-1,2,4,5-tetrazine) upon reacting with Yb(fod)₃ (fod^- =6,6,7,7,8,8,8-heptafluoro-2,2-dimethyl-3,5-octandionate). Compound 1 was structurally elucidated via single-crystal X-ray crystallography and subsequently magnetically and spectroscopically characterised to analyse its magnetisation dynamics and its luminescence behaviour. Computational studies validate the observed M_J energy levels attained by spectroscopy and provides a clearer picture of the slow relaxation of the magnetisation dynamics and relaxation pathways. These studies demonstrate that 1 acts as a single-molecule magnet (SMM) under an applied magnetic field in which the relaxation occurs via a combination of Raman, direct, and quantum tunnelling processes, a behaviour further rationalised analysing the luminescent properties. This marks the first lanthanide-containing molecule that forms by means of an asymmetric tetrazine decomposition.

Effect of the aromatic substituent on the para-position of pyridine-bis(oxazoline) sensitizers on the emission efficiency of their EuIII and TbIII complexes

Two efficient lanthanide ion sensitizers 2,6-bis(oxazoline)-4-phenyl-pyridine (PyboxPh, 1) and 2,6-bis(oxazoline)-4-thiophen-2-yl-pyridine (Pybox2Th, 2) were synthesized. 1 crystallizes in the monoclinic space group P21/c with cell parameters a = 16.3794(4) Å, b = 7.2856(2) Å, c = 11.7073(3) Å, β = 97.229(1)° and V = 1385.97(6) Å3. 2 crystallizes in the monoclinic space group P21/n with cell parameters a = 5.9472(2), b = 16.0747(6), c = 14.3716(5) Å, β = 93.503(1)° and V = 1371.35(8) Å3. Photophysical characterization of 1 shows that its triplet state energy is located at 22 250 cm-1 and efficient energy transfer is observed for EuIII and TbIII. Solutions of [Ln(PyboxPh)3]3+ in dichloromethane display an emission efficiency of 37.2% for Ln[double bond, length as m-dash]Eu and 24.0% for Ln[double bond, length as m-dash]Tb. The excited state lifetimes for EuIII and TbIII are 2.227 ms and 723 μs, respectively. The triplet state energy of 2 is located at 19 280 cm-1 and is therefore too low to efficiently sensitize TbIII emission. However, the sensitization of EuIII is effective, with an emission quantum yield of 14.5% and an excited state lifetime of 714 μs. This shows that the derivatization of the chelator is strongly influenced by the aromatic substituents on the para-position of the pyridine ring. New isostructural 1 : 1 complexes of PyboxPh with EuIII (3) and TbIII (4) were also isolated and crystallize in the triclinic space group P1[combining macron] with cell parameters a = 9.1845(2) Å, b = 10.3327(2) Å, c = 11.9654(2) Å, α = 98.419(1)°, β = 108.109(1)°, γ = 91.791(1)°, V = 1064.08(4) Å3 and a = 7.8052(1) Å, b = 11.8910(1) Å, c = 14.2668(2) Å, α = 72.557(1)°, β = 86.355(1)°, γ = 77.223(1)°, V = 1231.95(3) Å3, respectively.

[Ga3+ 8 Sm3+ 2 , Ga3+ 8 Tb3+ 2 ] Metallacrowns are Highly Promising Ratiometric Luminescent Molecular Nanothermometers Operating at Physiologically Relevant Temperatures

Nanothermometry is the study of temperature at the submicron scale with a broad range of potential applications, such as cellular studies or electronics. Molecular luminescent-based nanothermometers offer a non-contact means to record these temperatures with high spatial resolution and thermal sensitivity. A luminescent-based molecular thermometer comprised of visible-emitting Ga³⁺ /Tb³⁺ and Ga³⁺ /Sm³⁺ metallacrowns (MCs) achieved remarkable relative thermal sensitivity associated with very low temperature uncertainty of S_r =1.9 % K^-1 and δT<0.045 K, respectively, at 328 K, as an aqueous suspension of polystyrene nanobeads loaded with the corresponding MCs. To date, they are the ratiometric molecular nanothermometers offering the highest level of sensitivity in the physiologically relevant temperature range.

Holmium(iii) molecular nanomagnets for optical thermometry exploring the luminescence re-absorption effect

Coordination complexes of lanthanide(3+) ions can combine Single-Molecule Magnetism (SMM) with thermally modulated luminescence applicable in optical thermometry. We report an innovative approach towards high performance SMM-based optical thermometers which explores tunable anisotropy and the luminescence re-absorption effect of Ho^III complexes. Our concept is shown in dinuclear cyanido-bridged molecules, {[Ho^III(4-pyridone)₄(H₂O)₂][M^III(CN)₆]}·nH₂O (M = Co, 1; Rh, 2; Ir, 3) and their magnetically diluted analogues, {[Ho^III _x Y^III _1-x (4-pyridone)₄(H₂O)₂][M^III(CN)₆]}·nH₂O (M = Co, x = 0.11, 1@Y; Rh, x = 0.12, 2@Y; Ir, x = 0.10, 3@Y). They are built of pentagonal bipyramidal Ho^III complexes revealing the zero-dc-field SMM effect. Experimental studies and the ab initio calculations indicate an Orbach magnetic relaxation with energy barriers varying from 89.8 to 86.7 and 78.7 cm^-1 K for 1, 2, and 3, respectively. 1-3 also differ in the strength of quantum tunnelling of magnetization which is suppressed by hyperfine interactions, and, further, by the magnetic dilution. The Y^III-based dilution governs the optical properties as 1-3 exhibit poor emission due to the dominant re-absorption from Ho^III while 1@Y-3@Y show room-temperature blue emission of 4-pyridone. Within ligand emission bands, the sharp re-absorption lines of the Ho^III electronic transitions were observed. Their strong thermal variation was used in achieving highly sensitive ratiometric optical thermometers whose good performance ranges, lying between 25 and 205 K, are adjustable by using hexacyanidometallates. This work shows that Ho^III complexes are great prerequisites for advanced opto-magnetic systems linking slow magnetic relaxation with unique optical thermometry exploiting a luminescence re-absorption phenomenon.

Beyond Chiral Organic (p-Block) Chromophores for Circularly Polarized Luminescence: The Success of d-Block and f-Block Chiral Complexes

Chiral molecules are essential for the development of advanced technological applications in spintronic and photonic. The best systems should produce large circularly polarized luminescence (CPL) as estimated by their dissymmetry factor (g _lum), which can reach the maximum values of -2 ≤ g _lum ≤ 2 when either pure right- or left-handed polarized light is emitted after standard excitation. For matching this requirement, theoretical considerations indicate that optical transitions with large magnetic and weak electric transition dipole moments represent the holy grail of CPL. Because of their detrimental strong and allowed electric dipole transitions, popular chiral emissive organic molecules display generally moderate dissymmetry factors (10^-5 ≤ g _lum ≤ 10^-3). However, recent efforts in this field show that g _lum can be significantly enhanced when the chiral organic activators are part of chiral supramolecular assemblies or of liquid crystalline materials. At the other extreme, chiral Eu^III- and Sm^III-based complexes, which possess intra-shell parity-forbidden electric but allowed magnetic dipole transitions, have yielded the largest dissymmetry factor reported so far with g _lum ~ 1.38. Consequently, 4f-based metal complexes with strong CPL are currently the best candidates for potential technological applications. They however suffer from the need for highly pure samples and from considerable production costs. In this context, chiral earth-abundant and cheap d-block metal complexes benefit from a renewed interest according that their CPL signal can be optimized despite the larger covalency displayed by d-block cations compared with 4f-block analogs. This essay thus aims at providing a minimum overview of the theoretical aspects rationalizing circularly polarized luminescence and their exploitation for the design of chiral emissive metal complexes with strong CPL. Beyond the corroboration that f-f transitions are ideal candidates for generating large dissymmetry factors, a special attention is focused on the recent attempts to use chiral Cr^III-based complexes that reach values of g _lum up to 0.2. This could pave the way for replacing high-cost rare earths with cheap transition metals for CPL applications.