Electrostatic Perturbations from the Protein Affect C-H Bond Strengths of the Substrate and Enable Negative Catalysis in the TmpA Biosynthesis Enzyme

Tutorial Review on the Set-Up and Running of Quantum Mechanical Cluster Models for Enzymatic Reaction Mechanisms

Enzymes turnover substrates into products with amazing efficiency and selectivity and as such have great potential for use in biotechnology and pharmaceutical applications. However, details of their catalytic cycles and the origins surrounding the regio- and chemoselectivity of enzymatic reaction processes remain unknown, which makes the engineering of enzymes and their use in biotechnology challenging. Computational modelling can assist experimental work in the field and establish the factors that influence the reaction rates and the product distributions. A popular approach in modelling is the use of quantum mechanical cluster models of enzymes that take the first- and second coordination sphere of the enzyme active site into consideration. These QM cluster models are widely applied but often the results obtained are dependent on model choice and model selection. Herein, we show that QM cluster models can give highly accurate results that reproduce experimental product distributions and free energies of activation within several kcal mol-1, regarded that large cluster models with >300 atoms are used that include key hydrogen bonding interactions and charged residues. In this tutorial review, we give general guidelines on the set-up and applications of the QM cluster method and discuss its accuracy and reproducibility. Finally, several representative QM cluster model examples on metal-containing enzymes are presented, which highlight the strength of the approach.

What is the Origin of the Regioselective C3-Hydroxylation of L-Arg by the Nonheme Iron Enzyme Capreomycin C?

The nonheme iron dioxygenase capreomycin C (CmnC) hydroxylates a free L-arginine amino acid regio- and stereospecifically at the C3-position as part of the capreomycin antibiotics biosynthesis. Little is known on its structure, catalytic cycle and substrate specificity and, therefore, a comprehensive computational study was performed. A large QM cluster model of CmnC was created of 297 atoms and the mechanisms for C3-H, C4-H and C5-H hydroxylation and C3-C4 desaturation were investigated. All low-energy pathways correspond to radical reaction mechanisms with an initial hydrogen atom abstraction followed by OH rebound to form alcohol product complexes. The work is compared to alternative L-Arg hydroxylating nonheme iron dioxygenases and the differences in active site polarity are compared. We show that a tight hydrogen bonding network in the substrate binding pocket positions the substrate in an ideal orientation for C3-H activation, whereby the polar groups in the substrate binding pocket induce an electric field effect that guides the selectivity.

An Active Site Tyr Residue Guides the Regioselectivity of Lysine Hydroxylation by Nonheme Iron Lysine-4-hydroxylase Enzymes through Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer

Lysine dioxygenase (KDO) is an important enzyme in human physiology involved in bioprocesses that trigger collagen cross-linking and blood pressure control. There are several KDOs in nature; however, little is known about the factors that govern the regio- and stereoselectivity of these enzymes. To understand how KDOs can selectively hydroxylate their substrate, we did a comprehensive computational study into the mechanisms and features of 4-lysine dioxygenase. In particular, we selected a snapshot from the MD simulation on KDO5 and created large QM cluster models (A, B, and C) containing 297, 312, and 407 atoms, respectively. The largest model predicts regioselectivity that matches experimental observation with rate-determining hydrogen atom abstraction from the C4-H position, followed by fast OH rebound to form 4-hydroxylysine products. The calculations show that in model C, the dipole moment is positioned along the C4-H bond of the substrate and, therefore, the electrostatic and electric field perturbations of the protein assist the enzyme in creating C4-H hydroxylation selectivity. Furthermore, an active site Tyr233 residue is identified that reacts through proton-coupled electron transfer akin to the axial Trp residue in cytochrome c peroxidase. Thus, upon formation of the iron(IV)-oxo species in the catalytic cycle, the Tyr233 phenol loses a proton to the nearby Asp179 residue, while at the same time, an electron is transferred to the iron to create an iron(III)-oxo active species. This charged tyrosyl residue directs the dipole moment along the C4-H bond of the substrate and guides the selectivity to the C4-hydroxylation of the substrate.

QM/MM Study Into the Mechanism of Oxidative C=C Double Bond Cleavage by Lignostilbene-α,β-Dioxygenase

The enzymatic biosynthesis of fragrance molecules from lignin fragments is an important reaction in biotechnology for the sustainable production of fine chemicals. In this work we investigated the biosynthesis of vanillin from lignostilbene by a nonheme iron dioxygenase using QM/MM and tested several suggested proposals via either an epoxide or dioxetane intermediate. Binding of dioxygen to the active site of the protein results in the formation of an iron(II)-superoxo species with lignostilbene cation radical. The dioxygenase mechanism starts with electrophilic attack of the terminal oxygen atom of the superoxo group on the central C=C bond of lignostilbene, and the second-coordination sphere effects in the substrate binding pocket guide the reaction towards dioxetane formation. The computed mechanism is rationalized with thermochemical cycles and valence bond schemes that explain the electron transfer processes during the reaction mechanism. Particularly, the polarity of the protein and the local electric field and dipole moments enable a facile electron transfer and an exergonic dioxetane formation pathway.

Computational Study Into the Oxidative Ring-Closure Mechanism During the Biosynthesis of Deoxypodophyllotoxin

The nonheme iron dioxygenase deoxypodophyllotoxin synthase performs an oxidative ring-closure reaction as part of natural product synthesis in plants. How the enzyme enables the oxidative ring-closure reaction of (-)-yatein and avoids substrate hydroxylation remains unknown. To gain insight into the reaction mechanism and understand the details of the pathways leading to products and by-products we performed a comprehensive computational study. The work shows that substrate is bound tightly into the substrate binding pocket with the C7'-H bond closest to the iron(IV)-oxo species. The reaction proceeds through a radical mechanism starting with hydrogen atom abstraction from the C7'-H position followed by ring-closure and a final hydrogen transfer to form iron(II)-water and deoxypodophyllotoxin. Alternative mechanisms including substrate hydroxylation and an electron transfer pathway were explored but found to be higher in energy. The mechanism is guided by electrostatic perturbations of charged residues in the second-coordination sphere that prevent alternative pathways.

CO2 Reduction by an Iron(I) Porphyrinate System: Effect of Hydrogen Bonding on the Second Coordination Sphere

Transforming CO2 into valuable materials is an important reaction in catalysis, especially because CO2 concentrations in the atmosphere have been growing steadily due to extensive fossil fuel usage. From an environmental perspective, reduction of CO2 to valuable materials should be catalyzed by an environmentally benign catalyst and avoid the use of heavy transition-metal ions. In this work, we present a computational study into a novel iron(I) porphyrin catalyst for CO2 reduction, namely, with a tetraphenylporphyrin ligand and analogues. In particular, we investigated iron(I) tetraphenylporphyrin with one of the meso-phenyl groups substituted with o-urea, p-urea, or o-2-amide groups. These substituents can provide hydrogen-bonding interactions in the second coordination sphere with bound ligands and assist with proton relay. Furthermore, our studies investigated bicarbonate and phenol as stabilizers and proton donors in the reaction mechanism. Potential energy landscapes for double protonation of iron(I) porphyrinate with bound CO2 are reported. The work shows that the bicarbonate bridges the urea/amide groups to the CO2 and iron center and provides a tight bonding pattern with strong hydrogen-bonding interactions that facilitates easy proton delivery and reduction of CO2. Specifically, bicarbonate provides a low-energy proton shuttle mechanism to form CO and water efficiently. Furthermore, the o-urea group locks bicarbonate and CO2 in a tight orientation and helps with ideal proton transfer, while there is more mobility and lesser stability with an o-amide group in that position instead. Our calculations show that the o-urea group leads to reduction in proton-transfer barriers, in line with experimental observation. We then applied electric-field-effect calculations to estimate the environmental effects on the two proton-transfer steps in the reaction. These calculations describe the perturbations that enhance the driving forces for the proton-transfer steps and have been used to make predictions about how the catalysts can be further engineered for more enhanced CO2 reduction processes.

Catalytic divergencies in the mechanism of L-arginine hydroxylating nonheme iron enzymes

Many enzymes in nature utilize a free arginine (L-Arg) amino acid to initiate the biosynthesis of natural products. Examples include nitric oxide synthases, which generate NO from L-Arg for blood pressure control, and various arginine hydroxylases involved in antibiotic biosynthesis. Among the groups of arginine hydroxylases, several enzymes utilize a nonheme iron(II) active site and let L-Arg react with dioxygen and α-ketoglutarate to perform either C3-hydroxylation, C4-hydroxylation, C5-hydroxylation, or C4-C5-desaturation. How these seemingly similar enzymes can react with high specificity and selectivity to form different products remains unknown. Over the past few years, our groups have investigated the mechanisms of L-Arg-activating nonheme iron dioxygenases, including the viomycin biosynthesis enzyme VioC, the naphthyridinomycin biosynthesis enzyme NapI, and the streptothricin biosynthesis enzyme OrfP, using computational approaches and applied molecular dynamics, quantum mechanics on cluster models, and quantum mechanics/molecular mechanics (QM/MM) approaches. These studies not only highlight the differences in substrate and oxidant binding and positioning but also emphasize on electronic and electrostatic differences in the substrate-binding pockets of the enzymes. In particular, due to charge differences in the active site structures, there are changes in the local electric field and electric dipole moment orientations that either strengthen or weaken specific substrate C-H bonds. The local field effects, therefore, influence and guide reaction selectivity and specificity and give the enzymes their unique reactivity patterns. Computational work using either QM/MM or density functional theory (DFT) on cluster models can provide valuable insights into catalytic reaction mechanisms and produce accurate and reliable data that can be used to engineer proteins and synthetic catalysts to perform novel reaction pathways.

How Is Substrate Halogenation Triggered by the Vanadium Haloperoxidase from Curvularia inaequalis?

Vanadium haloperoxidases (VHPOs) are unique enzymes in biology that catalyze a challenging halogen transfer reaction and convert a strong aromatic C-H bond into C-X (X = Cl, Br, I) with the use of a vanadium cofactor and H₂O₂. The VHPO catalytic cycle starts with the conversion of hydrogen peroxide and halide (X = Cl, Br, I) into hypohalide on the vanadate cofactor, and the hypohalide subsequently reacts with a substrate. However, it is unclear whether the hypohalide is released from the enzyme or otherwise trapped within the enzyme structure for the halogenation of organic substrates. A substrate-binding pocket has never been identified for the VHPO enzyme, which questions the role of the protein in the overall reaction mechanism. Probing its role in the halogenation of small molecules will enable further engineering of the enzyme and expand its substrate scope and selectivity further for use in biotechnological applications as an environmentally benign alternative to current organic chemistry synthesis. Using a combined experimental and computational approach, we elucidate the role of the vanadium haloperoxidase protein in substrate halogenation. Activity studies show that binding of the substrate to the enzyme is essential for the reaction of the hypohalide with substrate. Stopped-flow measurements demonstrate that the rate-determining step is not dependent on substrate binding but partially on hypohalide formation. Using a combination of molecular mechanics (MM) and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, the substrate binding area in the protein is identified and even though the selected substrates (methylphenylindole and 2-phenylindole) have limited hydrogen-bonding abilities, they are found to bind relatively strongly and remain stable in a binding tunnel. A subsequent analysis of the MD snapshots characterizes two small tunnels leading from the vanadate active site to the surface that could fit small molecules such as hypohalide, halide, and hydrogen peroxide. Density functional theory studies using electric field effects show that a polarized environment in a specific direction can substantially lower barriers for halogen transfer. A further analysis of the protein structure indeed shows a large dipole orientation in the substrate-binding pocket that could enable halogen transfer through an applied local electric field. These findings highlight the importance of the enzyme in catalyzing substrate halogenation by providing an optimal environment to lower the energy barrier for this challenging aromatic halide insertion reaction.

Electrostatic Perturbations in the Substrate-Binding Pocket of Taurine/α-Ketoglutarate Dioxygenase Determine its Selectivity

Taurine/α-ketoglutarate dioxygenase is an important enzyme that takes part in the cysteine catabolism process in the human body and selectively hydroxylates taurine at the C1 -position. Recent computational studies showed that in the gas-phase the C2 -H bond of taurine is substantially weaker than the C1 -H bond, yet no evidence exists of 2-hydroxytaurine products. To this end, a detailed computational study on the selectivity patterns in TauD was performed. The calculations show that the second-coordination sphere and the protonation states of residues play a major role in guiding the enzyme to the right selectivity. Specifically, a single proton on an active site histidine residue can change the regioselectivity of the reaction through its electrostatic perturbations in the active site and effectively changes the C1 -H and C2 -H bond strengths of taurine. This is further emphasized by many polar and hydrogen bonding interactions of the protein cage in TauD with the substrate and the oxidant that weaken the pro-R C1 -H bond and triggers a chemoselective reaction process. The large cluster models reproduce the experimental free energy of activation excellently.

Local Charge Distributions, Electric Dipole Moments, and Local Electric Fields Influence Reactivity Patterns and Guide Regioselectivities in α-Ketoglutarate-Dependent Non-heme Iron Dioxygenases

Non-heme iron dioxygenases catalyze vital processes for human health related to the biosynthesis of essential products and the biodegradation of toxic metabolites. Often the natural product biosyntheses by these non-heme iron dioxygenases is highly regio- and chemoselective, which are commonly assigned to tight substrate-binding and positioning. However, recent high-level computational modeling has shown that substrate-binding and positioning is only part of the story and long-range electrostatic interactions can play a major additional role.In this Account, we review and summarize computational viewpoints on the high regio- and chemoselectivity of α-ketoglutarate-dependent non-heme iron dioxygenases and how external perturbations affect the catalysis. In particular, studies from our groups have shown that often a regioselectivity in enzymes can be accomplished by stabilization of the rate-determining transition state for the reaction through external charges, electric dipole moments, or local electric field effects. Furthermore, bond dissociation energies in molecules are shown to be influenced by an electric field effect, and through targeting a specific bond in an electric field, this can lead to an unusually specific reaction. For instance, in the carbon-induced starvation protein, we studied two substrate-bound conformations and showed that regardless of what C-H bond of the substrate is closest to the iron(IV)-oxo oxidant, the lowest hydrogen atom abstraction barrier is always for the pro-S C²-H abstraction due to an induced dipole moment of the protein that weakens this bond. In another example of the hygromycin biosynthesis enzyme, an oxidative ring-closure reaction in the substrate forms an ortho-δ-ester ring. Calculations on this enzyme show that the selectivity is guided by a protonated lysine residue in the active site that, through its positive charge, triggers a low energy hydrogen atom abstraction barrier. A final set of examples in this Account discuss the viomycin biosynthesis enzyme and the 2-(trimethylammonio)ethylphosphonate dioxygenase (TmpA) enzyme. Both of these enzymes are shown to possess a significant local dipole moment and local electric field effect due to charged residues surrounding the substrate and oxidant binding pockets. The protein dipole moment and local electric field strength changes the C-H bond strengths of the substrate as compared to the gas-phase triggers the regioselectivity of substrate activation. In particular, we show that in the gas phase and in a protein environment C-H bond strengths are different due to local electric dipole moments and electric field strengths. These examples show that enzymes have an intricately designed structure that enables a chemical reaction under ambient conditions through the positioning of positively and negatively charged residues that influence and enhance reaction mechanisms. These computational insights create huge possibilities in bioengineering to apply local electric field and dipole moments in proteins to achieve an unusual selectivity and specificity and trigger a fit-for-purpose biocatalyst for unique biotransformations.

Can the isonitrile biosynthesis enzyme ScoE assist with the biosynthesis of isonitrile groups in drug molecules? A computational study

Computational studies show that the isonitrile synthesizing enzyme ScoE can catalyse the conversion of γ-Gly substituents in substrates to isonitrile. This enables efficient isonitrile substitution into target molecules such as axisonitrile-1.

Biodegradation of herbicides by a plant nonheme iron dioxygenase: mechanism and selectivity of substrate analogues

Aryloxyalkanoate dioxygenases are unique herbicide biodegrading nonheme iron enzymes found in plants and hence, from environmental and agricultural point of view they are important and valuable. However, they often are substrate specific and little is known on the details of the mechanism and the substrate scope. To this end, we created enzyme models and calculate the mechanism for 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid biodegradation and 2-methyl substituted analogs by density functional theory. The work shows that the substrate binding is tight and positions the aliphatic group close to the metal center to enable a chemoselective reaction mechanism to form the C 2 -hydroxy products, whereas the aromatic hydroxylation barriers are well higher in energy. Subsequently, we investigated the metabolism of R - and S -methyl substituted inhibitors and show that these do not react as efficiently as 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid substrate due to stereochemical clashes in the active site and particularly for the R -isomer give high rebound barriers.

Structure and Functional Differences of Cysteine and 3-Mercaptopropionate Dioxygenases: A Computational Study

Thiol dioxygenases are important enzymes for human health; they are involved in the detoxification and catabolism of toxic thiol-containing natural products such as cysteine. As such, these enzymes have relevance to the development of Alzheimer's and Parkinson's diseases in the brain. Recent crystal structure coordinates of cysteine and 3-mercaptopropionate dioxygenase (CDO and MDO) showed major differences in the second-coordination spheres of the two enzymes. To understand the difference in activity between these two analogous enzymes, we created large, active-site cluster models. We show that CDO and MDO have different iron(III)-superoxo-bound structures due to differences in ligand coordination. Furthermore, our studies show that the differences in the second-coordination sphere and particularly the position of a positively charged Arg residue results in changes in substrate positioning, mobility and enzymatic turnover. Furthermore, the substrate scope of MDO is explored with cysteinate and 2-mercaptosuccinic acid and their reactivity is predicted.

Product Distributions of Cytochrome P450 OleTJE with Phenyl-Substituted Fatty Acids: A Computational Study

There are two types of cytochrome P450 enzymes in nature, namely, the monooxygenases and the peroxygenases. Both enzyme classes participate in substrate biodegradation or biosynthesis reactions in nature, but the P450 monooxygenases use dioxygen, while the peroxygenases take H2O2 in their catalytic cycle instead. By contrast to the P450 monooxygenases, the P450 peroxygenases do not require an external redox partner to deliver electrons during the catalytic cycle, and also no external proton source is needed. Therefore, they are fully self-sufficient, which affords them opportunities in biotechnological applications. One specific P450 peroxygenase, namely, P450 OleTJE, reacts with long-chain linear fatty acids through oxidative decarboxylation to form hydrocarbons and, as such, has been implicated as a suitable source for the biosynthesis of biofuels. Unfortunately, the reactions were shown to produce a considerable amount of side products originating from Cα and Cβ hydroxylation and desaturation. These product distributions were found to be strongly dependent on whether the substrate had substituents on the Cα and/or Cβ atoms. To understand the bifurcation pathways of substrate activation by P450 OleTJE leading to decarboxylation, Cα hydroxylation, Cβ hydroxylation and Cα-Cβ desaturation, we performed a computational study using 3-phenylpropionate and 2-phenylbutyrate as substrates. We set up large cluster models containing the heme, the substrate and the key features of the substrate binding pocket and calculated (using density functional theory) the pathways leading to the four possible products. This work predicts that the two substrates will react with different reaction rates due to accessibility differences of the substrates to the active oxidant, and, as a consequence, these two substrates will also generate different products. This work explains how the substrate binding pocket of P450 OleTJE guides a reaction to a chemoselectivity.

Density Functional Theory Study into the Reaction Mechanism of Isonitrile Biosynthesis by the Nonheme Iron Enzyme ScoE

The nonheme iron enzyme ScoE catalyzes the biosynthesis of an isonitrile substituent in a peptide chain. To understand details of the reaction mechanism we created a large active site cluster model of 212 atoms that contains substrate, the active oxidant and the first- and second-coordination sphere of the protein and solvent. Several possible reaction mechanisms were tested and it is shown that isonitrile can only be formed through two consecutive catalytic cycles that both use one molecule of dioxygen and α-ketoglutarate. In both cycles the active species is an iron(IV)-oxo species that in the first reaction cycle reacts through two consecutive hydrogen atom abstraction steps: first from the N–H group and thereafter from the C–H group to desaturate the NH-CH2 bond. The alternative ordering of hydrogen atom abstraction steps was also tested but found to be higher in energy. Moreover, the electronic configurations along that pathway implicate an initial hydride transfer followed by proton transfer. We highlight an active site Lys residue that is shown to donate charge in the transition states and influences the relative barrier heights and bifurcation pathways. A second catalytic cycle of the reaction of iron(IV)-oxo with desaturated substrate starts with hydrogen atom abstraction followed by decarboxylation to give isonitrile directly. The catalytic cycle is completed with a proton transfer to iron(II)-hydroxo to generate the iron(II)-water resting state. The work is compared with experimental observation and previous computational studies on this system and put in a larger perspective of nonheme iron chemistry.