Molecular enantiodiscrimination by NMR spectroscopy in chiral oriented systems: Concept, tools, and applications

Direct Enantiomer Differentiation of Drugs and Drug-Like Compounds via Noncovalent Copper-Amino Acid Complexation and Ion Mobility-Mass Spectrometry

Drug enantiomers can possess vastly different pharmacological properties, yet they are identical in their chemical composition and structural connectivity. Thus, resolving enantiomers poses a great challenge in the field of separation science. Enantiomer separations necessitate interaction of the analyte with a chiral environment─in mass spectrometry-based analysis, a common approach is through a three-point interaction with a chiral selector commonly introduced during sample preparation. In select cases, the structural difference imparted through noncovalent complexation results in enantiomer-specific structural differences, facilitating measurement using a structurally selective analytical technique such as ion mobility-mass spectrometry (IM-MS). In this work, we investigate the direct IM-MS differentiation of chiral drug compounds using mononuclear copper complexes incorporating an amino acid chiral selector. A panel of 20 chiral drugs and drug-like compounds were investigated for separation, and four l-amino acids (l-histidine, l-tryptophan, l-proline, and l-tyrosine) were evaluated as chiral selectors (CS) to provide the chiral environment necessary for differentiation. Enantiomer differentiation was achieved for four chiral molecule pairs (R/S-thalidomide, R/S-baclofen, R/S-metoprolol, and d/l-panthenol) with two-peak resolution (Rp-p) values ranging from 0.7 (>10% valley) to 1.5 (baseline separation). Calibration curves relating IM peak areas to enantiomeric concentrations enabled enantiomeric excess quantitation of racemic thalidomide and metoprolol with residuals of 5.7 and 2.5%, respectively. Theoretical models suggest that CuII and l-histidine complexation around the analyte chiral center is important for gas-phase stereoselectivity. This study demonstrates the potential of combining enantioselective noncovalent copper complexation with structurally selective IM-MS for differentiating chiral drugs and drug-like compounds.

Enantiomer Differentiation by Interaction-Specific Prediction of Residual Dipolar Couplings in Spherical-like Molecules

Residual Dipolar Couplings (RDCs) are averaged dipolar couplings between nuclear spins of atoms in a molecule that can be measured by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy upon partial alignment by a chiral alignment medium. The estimation of differences in alignment of enantiomers may, in principle, enable the determination of absolute configuration. Here, we use molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to mimic the alignment of chiral molecules (i.e., isopinocampheol, quinuclidin-3-ol, borneol, and camphor) to the chiral poly-γ-benzyl-L-glutamate (PBLG) polymer to predict RDCs in silico and compare calculated and experimentally measured residual dipolar couplings for the four enantiomeric pairs. The aim is to validate the computational scheme for the prediction of RDCs in chiral molecules and understand the interaction leading to the alignment in more detail. We determine the indispensable importance of hydrogen bonds between a chiral molecule and the alignment medium on the overall quality of the simulated alignment and interaction poses toward high agreement with experiments. A good correlation with experimental data is found for camphor and isopinocampheol, while the correlation for quinuclidin-3-ol and borneol is lower. We attribute this observation to the high difficulty of the RDC prediction for rather almost spherical molecules. The study reveals that the prediction of alignment with small enantiomeric differences is possible with an MD-based approach; however, extended simulation times (e.g., 50-100 μs) are required to sufficiently reduce the statistical uncertainty. This may be further used for the determination of the relative, as well as absolute, configuration of chiral molecules.

Enantiodiscrimination of Inherently Chiral Thiacalixarenes by Residual Dipolar Couplings

Inherently chiral compounds, such as calixarenes, are chiral due to a nonplanar three-dimensional (3D) structure. Determining their conformation is essential to understand their properties, with nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy being one applicable method. Using alignment media to measure residual dipolar couplings (RDCs) to obtain structural information is advantageous when classical NMR parameters like the nuclear Overhauser effect (NOE) or J-couplings fail. Besides providing more accurate structural information, the alignment media can induce different orientations of enantiomers. In this study, we examined the ability of polyglutamates with different side-chain moieties─poly-γ-benzyl-l-glutamate (PBLG) and poly-γ-p-biphenylmethyl-l-glutamate (PBPMLG) ─to enantiodifferentiate the inherently chiral phenoxathiin-based thiacalix[4]arenes. Both media, in combination with two solvents, allowed for enantiodiscrimination, which was, to the best of our knowledge, proved for the first time on inherently chiral compounds. Moreover, using the experimental RDCs, we investigated the calix[4]arenes conformational preferences in solution, quantitatively analyzed the differences in the alignment of the enantiomers, and discussed the pitfalls of the use of the RDC analysis.

Applications of Nanozymes in Chiral-Molecule Recognition through Electrochemical and Ultraviolet-Visible Analysis

Chiral molecules have similar physicochemical properties, which are different in terms of physiological activities and toxicities, rendering their differentiation and recognition highly significant. Nanozymes, which are nanomaterials with inherent enzyme-like activities, have garnered significant interest owing to their high cost-effectiveness, enhanced stability, and straightforward synthesis. However, constructing nanozymes with high activity and enantioselectivity remains a significant challenge. This review briefly introduces the synthesis methods of chiral nanozymes and systematically summarizes the latest research progress in enantioselective recognition of chiral molecules based on electrochemical methods and ultraviolet-visible absorption spectroscopy. Moreover, the challenges and development trends in developing enantioselective nanozymes are discussed. It is expected that this review will provide new ideas for the design of multifunctional chiral nanozymes and broaden the application field of nanozymes.

Potential and performance of anisotropic 19F NMR for the enantiomeric analysis of fluorinated chiral active pharmaceutical ingredients

Controlling the enantiomeric purity of chiral drugs is of paramount importance in pharmaceutical chemistry. Isotropic 1H NMR spectroscopy involving chiral agents is a widely used method for discriminating enantiomers and quantifying their relative proportions. However, the relatively weak spectral separation of enantiomers (1H Δδiso(R, S)) in frequency units at low and moderate magnetic fields, as well as the lack of versatility of a majority of those agents with respect to different chemical functions, may limit the general use of this approach. In this article, we investigate the analytical potential of 19F NMR in anisotropic chiral media for the enantiomeric analysis of fluorinated active pharmaceutical ingredients (API) via two residual anisotropic NMR interactions: the chemical shift anisotropy (19F-RCSA) and dipolar coupling ((19F-19F)-RDC). Lyotropic chiral liquid crystals (CLC) based on poly-γ-benzyl-L-glutamate (PBLG) show an interesting versatility and adaptability to enantiodiscrimination as illustrated for two chiral drugs, Flurbiprofen® (FLU) and Efavirenz® (EFA), which have very different chemical functions. The approach has been tested on a routine 300 MHz NMR spectrometer equipped with a standard probe (5 mm BBFO probe) in a high-throughput context (i.e., ≈10 s of NMR experiments) while the performance for enantiomeric excess (ee) measurement is evaluated in terms of trueness and precision. The limits of detection (LOD) determined were 0.17 and 0.16 μmol ml-1 for FLU and EFA, respectively, allow working in dilute conditions even with such a short experimental duration. The enantiodiscrimination capabilities are also discussed with respect to experimental features such as CLC composition and temperature.

A Squaramide-Based Organocatalyst as a Novel Versatile Chiral Solvating Agent for Carboxylic Acids

A squaramide-based organocatalyst for asymmetric Michael reactions has been tested as a chiral solvating agent (CSA) for 26 carboxylic acids and camphorsulfonic acid, encompassing amino acid derivatives, mandelic acid, as well as some of its analogs, propionic acids like profens (ketoprofen and ibuprofen), butanoic acids and others. In many cases remarkably high enantiodifferentiations at 1H, 13C and 19F nuclei were observed. The interaction likely involves a proton transfer from the acidic substrates to the tertiary amine sites of the organocatalyst, thus allowing for pre-solubilization of the organocatalyst (when a chloroform solution of the substrate is employed) or the simultaneous solubilization of both the catalyst and the substrate. DOSY experiments were employed to evaluate whether the catalyst-substrate ionic adduct was a tight one or not. ROESY experiments were employed to investigate the role of the squaramide unit in the adduct formation. A mechanism of interaction was proposed in accordance with the literature data.

Chiral Recognition of Chiral (Hetero)Cyclic Derivatives Probed by Tetraaza Macrocyclic Chiral Solvating Agents via 1H NMR Spectroscopy

In the field of chiral recognition, chiral cyclic organic compounds, especially heterocyclic organic compounds, have attracted little attention and have been rarely studied as chiral substrates by means of 1H NMR spectroscopy. In this paper, enantiomers of thiohydantoin derivatives, representing typical five-membered N,N-heterocycles, have been synthesized and utilized for assignment of absolute configuration and analysis of enantiomeric excess. All enantiomers have been successfully differentiated with the assistance of novel tetraaza macrocyclic chiral solvating agents (TAMCSAs) by 1H NMR spectroscopy. Surprisingly, unprecedented nonequivalent chemical shift values (up to 2.052 ppm) of the NH proton of substrates have been observed, a new milestone in the evaluation of enantiomers. To better understand the intermolecular interactions between host and guest, Job plots and theoretical calculations of (S)-G1 and (R)-G1 with TAMCSA 1a were investigated and revealed significant geometric differentiation between the diastereomers. In order to evaluate practical applications of the present systems in analyzing optical purity of chiral substrates, enantiomeric excesses of a typical substrate (G1) with different optical compositions in the presence of a representative TAMCSA (1a) can be accurately calculated based on the integration of the NH proton's signal peaks. Importantly, this work provides a significant breakthrough in exploring and developing the chiral recognition of chiral heterocyclic organic compounds by 1H NMR spectroscopy.

Chiral Discrimination of Acyclic Secondary Amines by 19F NMR

Chiral aliphatic amine compounds exhibit a range of physiological activities, making them highly sought-after in the pharmaceutical industry and biological research. One notable obstacle in studying these compounds stems from the pronounced steric hindrance surrounding the nitrogen atom. This characteristic often leads to a weak affinity of acyclic secondary amines for molecular probes, making their chiral discrimination intricate. In response to this challenge, our research has unveiled a novel 19F-labeled probe adept at recognizing and distinguishing between enantiomers of these acyclic secondary amines. By strategically incorporating a single fluorine atom as the 19F label, we have managed to diminish the steric hindrance at the binding site. This alteration bolsters the probe's affinity toward bulkier analytes. As a testament to its effectiveness, we have successfully employed our probe in the chiral analysis of relevant pharmaceuticals, accurately determining their enantiocomposition.

Residual-Chemical-Shift-Anisotropy-Based Enantiodifferentiation in Lyotropic Liquid Crystalline Phases Based on Helically Chiral Polyacetylenes

Anisotropic NMR spectroscopy, revealing residual dipolar couplings (RDCs) and residual chemical shift anisotropies (RCSAs) has emerged as a powerful tool to determine the configurations of synthetic and complex natural compounds. The deduction of the absolute in addition to the relative configuration is one of the primary goals in the field. Therefore, the investigation of the enantiodiscriminating capabilities of chiral alignment media becomes essential. While RDCs and RCSAs are now used for the determination of the relative configuration routinely, RCSAs have not been measured in chiral alignment media such as chiral liquid crystals. Herein, we present this application by measuring RCSAs for chiral analytes such as indanol and isopinocampheol in the lyotropic liquid crystalline phase of an L-valine derived helically chiral polyacetylenes. We have also demonstrated that a single 1D 13 C-{1 H} NMR spectrum suffices to get the RCSAs circumventing the necessity to acquire two spectra at two alignment conditions.

Assignment of the absolute configuration of molecules that are chiral by virtue of deuterium substitution using chiral tag molecular rotational resonance spectroscopy

Chiral tag molecular rotational resonance (MRR) spectroscopy is used to assign the absolute configuration of molecules that are chiral by virtue of deuterium substitution. Interest in the improved performance of deuterated active pharmaceutical ingredients has led to the development of precision deuteration reactions. These reactions often generate enantioisotopomer reaction products that pose challenges for chiral analysis. Chiral tag rotational spectroscopy uses noncovalent derivatization of the enantioisotopomer to create the diastereomers of the 1:1 molecular complexes of the analyte and a small, chiral molecule. Assignment of the absolute configuration requires high-confidence determinations of the structures of these weakly bound complexes. A general search method, CREST, is used to identify candidate geometries. Subsequent geometry optimization using dispersion corrected density functional theory gives equilibrium geometries with sufficient accuracy to identify the isomers of the chiral tag complexes produced in the pulsed jet expansion used to introduce the sample into the MRR spectrometer. Rotational constant scaling based on the fact that the diastereomers have the same equilibrium geometry gives accurate predictions allowing identification of the homochiral and heterochiral tag complexes and, therefore, assignment of absolute configuration. The method is successfully applied to three oxygenated substrates from enantioselective Cu-catalyzed alkene transfer hydrodeuteration reaction chemistry.

Rapid Enantiomeric Excess Measurements of Enantioisotopomers by Molecular Rotational Resonance Spectroscopy

Recent work in drug discovery has shown that selectively deuterated small molecules can improve the safety and efficacy for active pharmaceutical ingredients. The advantages derive from changes in metabolism resulting from the kinetic isotope effect when deuterium is substituted for a hydrogen atom at a structural position where rate limiting C-H bond breaking occurs. This application has pushed the development of precision deuteration strategies in synthetic chemistry that can install deuterium atoms with high regioselectivity and with stereocontrol. Copper-catalyzed alkene transfer hydrodeuteration chemistry has recently been shown to have high stereoselectivity for deuteration at the metabolically important benzyl C-H position. In this case, stereocontrol results in the creation of enantioisotopomers-molecules that are chiral solely by virtue of the deuterium substitution-and chiral analysis techniques are needed to assess the reaction selectivity. It was recently shown that chiral tag molecular rotational resonance (MRR) spectroscopy provides a routine way to measure the enantiomeric excess and establish the absolute configuration of enantioisotopomers. High-throughput implementations of chiral tag MRR spectroscopy are needed to support optimization of the chemical synthesis. A measurement methodology for high-throughput chiral analysis is demonstrated in this work. The high-throughput ee measurements are performed using cavity-enhanced MRR spectroscopy, which reduces measurement times and sample consumption by more than an order-of-magnitude compared to the previous enantioisotopomer analysis using a broadband MRR spectrometer. It is also shown that transitions for monitoring the enantiomers can be selected from a broadband rotational spectrum without the need for spectroscopic analysis. The general applicability of chiral tag MRR spectroscopy is illustrated by performing chiral analysis on six enantioisotopomer reaction products using a single molecule as the tag for chiral discrimination.

Chirality Sensing of N-Heterocycles via 19F NMR

Methods to rapidly detect and differentiate chiral N-heterocyclic compounds become increasingly important owing to the widespread application of N-heterocycles in drug discovery and materials science. We herein report a ¹⁹F NMR-based chemosensing approach for the prompt enantioanalysis of various N-heterocycles, where the dynamic binding between the analytes and a chiral ¹⁹F-labeled palladium probe create characteristic ¹⁹F NMR signals assignable to each enantiomer. The open binding site of the probe allows the effective recognition of bulky analytes that are otherwise difficult to detect. The chirality center distal to the binding site is found sufficient for the probe to discriminate the stereoconfiguration of the analyte. The utility of the method in the screening of reaction conditions for the asymmetric synthesis of lansoprazole is demonstrated.

Tailoring the Recognition Property of a 19F-Labeled Gallium-Based NMR Probe: The Influence of the Metal Center

Chirality is a fundamental property of nature and an essential element of the life process. As the biological activities, metabolic pathways, and toxicity of individual enantiomers are often varied, methods to rapidly and accurately discriminate chiral analytes are in great demand. Here, we report a ¹⁹F-labeled gallium-based probe for the enantiodifferentiation of chiral monoamines, diamines, amino alcohols, amino acids, and N-heterocycles. A comparison between the new gallium-based probe and the previously developed aluminum aminotrisphenolate complex was performed. It was revealed that the gallium metal center displays a much stronger affinity toward the amino group compared to the hydroxy group, thereby producing simplified ¹⁹F NMR signals for analytes with multiple Lewis basic sites. For sterically bulky analyte, the replacement of the aluminum with gallium is envisioned to expand the binding pocket of the probe to allow different binding models to interconvert rapidly. This feature is important to the creation of easily interpretable ¹⁹F signals corresponding to each enantiomer. It is further demonstrated that the gallium-based probe is suitable for the assessment of the enantiomeric excess values of the crude products obtained in asymmetric reactions without the need for purification.

Use of chiral ionic liquid as additive for synergistic enantioseparation of basic drugs in capillary electrophoresis

This work presents a synergistic system for enantioseparation in capillary electrophoresis (CE) with a chiral ionic liquid (CIL) based on D-10-camphorsulfonic acid as additive and carboxymethyl-β-cyclodextrin (CM-β-CD) as the chiral selector. The proposed method showed excellent enantioseparation performance towards sixteen chiral drugs. In contrast to the single CM-β-CD system, the notably improved resolution (Rs) and selectivity factor (α) of model drugs were observed in synergistic system. Several key parameters such as CIL concentration, CM-β-CD concentration, buffer pH and separation voltage were investigated, after which Statistical Product and Service Solutions (SPSS) was used to prove the potential synergistic effect. The nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) results further demonstrated the function of the CIL and the superiority of synergistic system. Finally, chiral impurity determination of chlorpheniramine maleate sample was successfully carried out using the established method.

Light-Controlled Lyotropic Liquid Crystallinity of Polyaspartates Exploited as Photo-Switchable Alignment Medium

Two polyaspartates bearing ortho-fluorinated azobenzenes (pFAB) as photo-responsive groups in the side chain were synthesized: PpFABLA (1) and co-polyaspartate PpFABLA-co-PBLA [11, 75%(n/n) PpFABLA content]. As a consequence of the E/Z-isomerization of the side chain, PpFABLA (1) undergoes a visible-light-induced reversible coil-helix transition in solution: Green light (525 nm) affords the coil, and violet light (400 nm) affords the helix. pFAB significantly increases the thermal stability of the Z-isomer at 20 °C (t_1/2 = 66 d for the Z-isomer) and effectively counters the favored back formation of the helix. At 20%(w/w) polymer concentration, the helical polymer forms a lyotropic liquid crystal (LLC) that further orients unidirectionally inside a magnetic field, while the coil polymer results in an isotropic solution. The high viscosity of the polymer solution stabilizes the coexistence of liquid crystalline and isotropic domains, which were obtained with spatial control by partial light irradiation. When used as an alignment medium, PpFABLA (1) enables (i) the measurement of dipolar couplings without the need for a separate isotropic reference and (ii) the differentiation of enantiomers. PpFABLA-co-PBLA (11) preserves the helical structure, by intention, independently of the E/Z-isomerization of the side chain: Both photo-isomers of PpFABLA-co-PBLA (11) form a helix that─at a concentration of 16%(w/w)─form an LLC. Despite the absence of a change in the secondary structure, the E/Z-isomerization of the side chain changes the morphology of the liquid crystal and leads to different sets of dipolar coupling for the same probe molecule.

Anisotropic 1 H STD-NMR Spectroscopy: Exploration of Enantiomer-Polypeptide Interactions in Chiral Oriented Environments

We explore and report for the first time the use of ¹ H saturation transfer difference NMR experiments (STD-NMR) in weakly aligning chiral anisotropic media to identify the hydrogen sites of enantiomers of small chiral molecules interacting with the side-chain of poly-γ-benzyl-l-glutamate (PBLG), a helically chiral polypeptide polymer. The first experimental results obtained on three model mono-stereogenic compounds outcomes are highly promising and demonstrate the possibility to track down possible differences of spatial position of enantiomers at the vicinity of the polymer side-chain. Anisotropic STD experiments appear to be well suited for rapid screening of chiral analytes that bind favorably to orienting polymeric systems, while providing new insights into the mechanism of enantio-discrimination without resorting to the time-consuming determination of molecular order parameters.

Bis-Thiourea Chiral Sensor for the NMR Enantiodiscrimination of N-Acetyl and N-Trifluoroacetyl Amino Acid Derivatives

A C2-symmetrical bis-thiourea chiral solvating agent (CSA), TFTDA, for NMR spectroscopy has been obtained by reacting (1R,2R)-1,2-bis(2-hydroxyphenyl)ethylenediamine and 3,5-bis(trifluoromethyl)phenyl isothiocyanate. TFTDA shows remarkable propensity to enantiodiscriminate N-trifluoroacetyl (N-TFA) and N-acetyl (N-Ac) derivatives of amino acids with free carboxyl functions, with the co-presence of 1,4-diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane (DABCO) as the third achiral additive, which is needed for substrate solubilization. TFTDA shows enhanced enantiodiscriminating efficiency in comparison with the corresponding monomeric counterpart, TFTMA, pointing out cooperativity between its two symmetrical entities. A wide range of amino acid derivatives have been efficiently enantiodiscriminated in CDCl₃, with high enantioresolution quotients, which guarantee high quality in applications devoted to the quantification of enantiomers. High enantiodiscriminating efficiency is maintained also in diluted 5 mM conditions or in the presence of sub-stoichiometric amounts of CSA (0.3 equiv). The role of phenolic hydroxyls in the DABCO-mediated interaction mechanism between TFTDA and the two enantiomeric substrates has been pointed out by means of diffusion-ordered spectroscopy (DOSY) and rotating frame Overhauser effect spectroscopy (ROESY) experiments. A conformational model for both the CSA and its diastereomeric solvates formed with the two enantiomers of N-acetyl leucine has also been conceived on the basis of ROE data in order to give a chiral discrimination rationale.

Enantioselective Synthesis of Enantioisotopomers with Quantitative Chiral Analysis by Chiral Tag Rotational Spectroscopy

Fundamental to the synthesis of enantioenriched chiral molecules is the ability to assign absolute configuration at each stereogenic center, and to determine the enantiomeric excess for each compound. While determination of enantiomeric excess and absolute configuration is often considered routine in many facets of asymmetric synthesis, the same determinations for enantioisotopomers remains a formidable challenge. Here, we report the first highly enantioselective metal-catalyzed synthesis of enantioisotopomers that are chiral by virtue of deuterium substitution along with the first general spectroscopic technique for assignment of the absolute configuration and quantitative determination of the enantiomeric excess of isotopically chiral molecules. Chiral tag rotational spectroscopy uses noncovalent chiral derivatization, which eliminates the possibility of racemization during derivatization, to perform the chiral analysis without the need of reference samples of the enantioisotopomer.