Discordant serum thyroglobulin results generated by two classes of assay in patients with thyroid carcinoma: correlation with clinical outcome after 3 years of follow-up

Radioactive iodine therapy: multiple faces of the same polyhedron

The incidence of differentiated thyroid carcinoma (DTC) has increased in recent decades with early stage, low risk papillary thyroid cancer (PTC) being detected and diagnosed. As a result, the psychological, financial, and clinical ramifications of overdiagnosis and excessively aggressive therapy are being increasingly recognized with many authorities calling for a re-evaluation of the traditional "one size fits all" management approaches. To address these critical issues, most thyroid cancer guidelines endorse a more risk adapted management strategy where the intensity of therapy and follow up is matched to the anticipated risk of recurrence and death from DTC for each patient. This "less is more" strategy provides for a minimalistic management approach for properly selected patients with low-risk DTC. This has re-kindled the long-standing debate regarding the routine use of radioactive iodine therapy (RIT) in DTC. Although recent guidelines have moved toward a more selective use of RIT, particular in patients with low-intermediate risk DTC, the proper selection of patients, the expected benefit, and the potential risks continue to be a source of ongoing controversy and debate. In this manuscript, we will review the wide range of clinical, imaging, medical team, and patient factors that must be considered when evaluating individual patients for RIT. Through a review of the current literature evaluating the potential benefits and risks of RIT, we will present a risk adapted approach to proper patient selection for RIT which emphasizes peri-operative risk stratification as the primary tool that clinicians should use to guide initial RIT management recommendations.

Impact of Thyroglobulin and Thyroglobulin Antibody Assay Performance on the Differential Classification of DTC Patients

CONTEXT

Measurements of thyroglobulin (Tg) and Tg antibodies are crucial in the follow-up of treated differentiated thyroid cancer (DTC) patients. Interassay differences may significantly impact follow-up.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this multicenter study was to explore the impact of Tg and Tg antibody assay performance on the differential classification of DTC patients, as described in national and international guidelines.

DESIGN

Four commonly used Tg and Tg antibody assays were technically compared to reflect possible effects on patients with DTC follow-up. Storage stability at different storage temperatures was also investigated for LIAISON® and Kryptor assays, as this is an underexposed topic in current literature.

RESULTS

B.R.A.H.M.S. assays yield approximately 50% lower Tg values over the whole range compared to the DiaSorin and Roche assays investigated. These differences between assays may result in potential misclassification in up to 7% of patients if fixed cutoffs (eg, 1 ng/mL) are applied. Poor correlation was also observed between the Tg antibody assays when the method-specific upper limits of normal are used as cutoffs. Storage of Tg and Tg antibodies was possible for 3 to 4 weeks at -20°C and -80°C. Calibration of the assays, however, was found to be crucial for stable results over time.

CONCLUSIONS

Technical aspects of Tg and Tg antibody assays, including interassay differences, calibration and standardization, and cutoff values, may have a significant clinical impact on the follow-up of DTC patients.

Circulating biomarkers for the detection of tumor recurrence in the postsurgical follow-up of differentiated thyroid carcinoma

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

To discuss advances and challenges in thyroglobulin and Tg-antibody (TgAb) measurement and their impact on clinical management of differentiated thyroid carcinoma (DTC).

RECENT FINDINGS

Basal high-sensitive Tg (hsTg) measurement avoids the need for stimulation and greatly simplifies DTC patients' management. In addition, patients with undetectable hsTg after thyroid ablation are at a very low risk of recurrence and can be safely managed by periodic hsTg measurement alone. When TgAb is present, its trend over time serves as primary (surrogate) tumor marker. However, an undetectable hsTg measurement appears to indicate a complete remission of DTC even in the presence of TgAb. Finally, reliable reference values are not yet available for low-risk DTC who are treated with less than total thyroid ablation, and caution is needed before well-designed studies addressing these issues have been published.

SUMMARY

The use of hsTg assays has changed paradigms for DTC monitoring even in the presence of TgAb, and greatly reduced patients' discomfort and overall case-management costs. Reliable Tg interpretation criteria are urgently needed for patients treated with less than total thyroid ablation.

Serum midkine as a surrogate biomarker for metastatic prediction in differentiated thyroid cancer patients with positive thyroglobulin antibody

Serum thyroglobulin (Tg) is the main post-operative tumor biomarker for patients with differentiated thyroid cancer (DTC). However, the presence of thyroglobulin antibodies (TgAb) can interfere with Tg level and invalidate the test. In this study, we aimed to investigate the predicative value of midkine (MK) as a cancer biomarker for DTC patients with positive TgAb before the first ¹³¹I therapy. MK levels were measured by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay in 151 recruited DTC patients after exercising strict inclusion and exclusion criteria. There were 28 TgAb positive DTC patients with metastases and 123 DTC patients without metastases. The value of pre-¹³¹I-ablative MK to predict metastasis was assessed by receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves in these two groups of patients. MK levels in the TgAb positive DTC patients were significantly higher than the DTC patients without metastases. ROC showed good predictability of MK, with an area under the curve of 0.856 (P < 0.001), and a diagnostic accuracy of 83% at the optimal cut-off value of 550 pg/ml. In conclusion, we show that MK can potentially be used as a surrogate biomarker for predicting DTC metastases when Tg is not suitable due to TgAb positivity.

A Case Report of Dramatically Increased Thyroglobulin after Lymph Node Biopsy in Thyroid Carcinoma after Total Thyroidectomy and Radioiodine

Thyroglobulin (Tg) is an important modality for monitoring patients with thyroid cancers, especially after thyroidectomy followed by radioiodine (RAI). It is also used as a marker for burden of thyroid tissue whether malignant or benign. Although there have been several reports of rising serum Tg transiently after thyroid biopsy in intact glands and following palpation or trauma, there are no reports in the literature of elevation in Tg after biopsy of suspicious lesions in thyroidectomized patients. In this paper we report a fascinating case of a considerable and initially worrying, although ultimately transient, rise in Tg in a patient 2 years after total thyroidectomy and RAI ablation after fine needle aspiration (FNA) of a suspicious thyroid bed nodule that was proven positive.

Does (131)I Radioactivity Interfere with Thyroglobulin Measurement in Patients Undergoing Radioactive Iodine Therapy with Recombinant Human TSH?

OBJECTIVES

Recombinant human thyroid-stimulating hormone (rhTSH) is widely used in radioactive iodine therapy (RIT) to avoid side effects caused by hypothyroidism during the therapy. Owing to RIT with rhTSH, serum thyroglobulin (Tg) is measured with high (131)I concentrations. It is of concern that the relatively high energy of (131)I could interfere with Tg measurement using the immunoradiometric assay (IRMA). We investigated the effect of (131)I administration on Tg measurement with IRMA after RIT.

METHODS

A total of 67 patients with thyroid cancer were analysed retrospectively. All patients had undergone rhTSH stimulation for RIT. The patients' sera were sampled 2 days after (131)I administration and divided into two portions: for Tg measurements on days 2 and 32 after (131)I administration. The count per minute (CPM) of whole serum (200 μl) was also measured at each time point. Student's paired t-test and Pearson's correlation analyses were performed for statistical analysis.

RESULTS

Serum Tg levels were significantly concordant between days 2 and 32, irrespective of the serum CPM. Subgroup analysis was performed by classification based on the (131)I dose. No difference was noted between the results of the two groups.

CONCLUSIONS

IRMA using (125)I did not show interference from (131)I in the serum of patients stimulated by rhTSH.

Implications of thyroglobulin antibody positivity in patients with differentiated thyroid cancer: a clinical position statement

BACKGROUND

Even though the presence of antithyroglobulin antibodies (TgAbs) represents a significant problem in the follow-up of patients with differentiated thyroid cancer (DTC), the current guidelines on the management of DTC that have been published in recent years contain no text concerning the methods to be used for detecting such antibody-related interference in thyroglobulin (Tg) measurement or how to manage TgAb-positive patients in whom Tg cannot be used reliably as a tumor marker.

AIM

An international group of experts from the European Thyroid Association Cancer Research Network who are involved in the care of DTC patients met twice to form a consensus opinion on how to proceed with treatment and follow-up in TgAb-positive DTC patients based on the available evidence in the literature. Here we will report on the consensus opinions that were reached regarding technical and clinical issues.

RESULTS

This clinical opinion article provides an overview of the available evidence and the resulting consensus recommendations. The current literature does not provide sufficient data for giving evidence-based answers to many questions arising in the care of TgAb-positive DTC patients. Where insufficient evidence was available, a thorough discussion by a group of physician-scientists, all of whom have a distinguished track record in thyroid cancer care, was held to arrive at a consensus expert opinion. The questions and answers discussed were then summarized into an algorithm for the management of TgAb-positive patients.

CONCLUSION

We were able to define 26 consensus expert recommendations and a resulting algorithm for the care of TgAb-positive DTC patients.

Discordance in thyroglobulin measurements by radioimmunoassay and immunometric assay: a useful means of identifying thyroglobulin assay interference

Background

Serum thyroglobulin (Tg) is useful for monitoring patients with differentiated thyroid cancer (DTC) but is limited by interference from anti-Tg antibodies (TgAb). We determined Tg assay discordance between a radioimmunoassay (RIA) and one of two immunometric assays (IMA) in DTC patients over a 9-year period to gauge assay performance against evidence of recurrent/progressive DTC.

Methods

Patients with DTC monitored for >1 year attending local clinics between September 2000 and January 2010 were included. All samples were analysed for Tg using both RIA and IMA. TgAb were measured on all Tg requests made after May 2006. Bias plots comparing RIA against IMA were established to calculate a 2-SD outlier limit. Clinical records were viewed to compare discordant Tg results against clinical evidence of recurrent/progressive DTC.

Results

Discordant Tg results were observed in 53/433 patients (12.2%). Four were discordant owing to a higher IMA result, one of which demonstrated recurrence. The remaining 49 patients demonstrated a disproportionately higher RIA result, of which four had recurrent/persistent disease. Twelve patients with a higher RIA result but no evidence of recurrence underwent thyrogen stimulation testing, which was negative in all 12. In many cases, assay discordance appeared more sensitive at indicating interference than direct measurement of TgAb.

Conclusions

Interference was evident with both Tg assays, such that neither could be solely relied upon to provide the correct result in the presence of TgAb. The concomitant measurement of Tg by RIA and IMA methods should be considered as an alternative to monitoring TgAb status.

Concordance between thyroglobulin antibody assays

Background

Antithyroglobulin antibodies are a prevalent cause of interference in serum thyroglobulin immunoassays. Current guidelines recommend that antithyroglobulin antibodies should be measured concurrently with thyroglobulin when monitoring thyroid cancer patients post‐thyroidectomy. However, the concordance between different antithyroglobulin assays has been questioned despite the availability of an international thyroglobulin antibody Reference Preparation.

Methods

Four antithyroglobulin assays currently in use in UK laboratories (Siemens Immulite®, Brahms GmbH, PerkinElmer AutoDELFIA and Siemens ADVIA Centaur®) were compared in a cohort of 145 thyroid cancer patients.

Results

Using reference data provided by the kit manufacturer, concordance between the assays was 74%. Adjusting the cut-offs to maximize agreement increased concordance to 90%. Recovery of exogenous thyroglobulin using the Brahms Tg-plus immunoradiometric assay was neither a specific nor a sensitive test for the presence of a positive antibody result by any assay.

Conclusions

Despite the availability of an international reference preparation, current antithyroglobulin assays show unacceptable variance.

Development and clinical impact of thyroglobulin antibodies in patients with differentiated thyroid carcinoma during the first 3 years after thyroidectomy

OBJECTIVE AND DESIGN

Cross-sectional studies have reported an increased prevalence of circulating thyroglobulin autoantibodies (TgAbs) in patients with differentiated thyroid carcinoma (DTC). With the advent of more sensitive assays, a longitudinal study monitoring the development of TgAb levels after ablative therapy was warranted.

METHODS

One hundred and twelve consecutive patients with follicular cell-derived thyroid cancer were followed for 3 years. All patients had been thyroidectomized and received, on average, two radioiodine therapies. Residual tissue was quantified scintigraphically by 131I 24-h uptake. TgAb and thyroglobulin (Tg) serum levels were determined with a sensitive direct radioligand assay and an IRMA respectively.

RESULTS

The prevalence of TgAbs at the initial examination was 29% (median 130 U/ml). During follow-up, TgAb levels rose transiently in one-tenth of the patients, but the prevalence of demonstrable TgAbs decreased to < 10% after 3 years. The median serum half-life of TgAbs in treated DTC patients was 10 weeks. At initial examination (when all patients still had residual thyroid tissue and 17 had metastases), rising TgAb levels were correlated with the inability to detect Tg in 4, 30 and 73% of the patients, when initial TgAbs were < 6, 6-50 or > 50 U/ml respectively. While the Tg recovery test was valid for all patients, an in vitro dilution assay with TgAb serum reduced Tg values by up to 32%.

CONCLUSIONS

The development and course of TgAbs in DTC patients cannot be predicted by initial or residual tumour volume, TgAb or Tg levels. The presence of TgAbs, even in low concentrations, may cause Tg underestimation despite valid recovery tests in DTC patients.

Incidental metastases of well-differentiated thyroid carcinoma in lymph nodes of patients with squamous cell head and neck cancer: eight cases with a review of the literature

The examination of a large series of cervical lymph nodes in patients with head and neck cancer revealed the presence of incidental metastases of occult thyroid carcinoma in eight patients, of which six cases were squamous cell carcinoma of glottic and supraglottic sites of the larynx and two cases were pyriform sinus and tongue carcinomas. Three patients had two lymph nodes and the remaining patients had one lymph node each involved. The nodal chains affected were the jugular (n=5; level IV), Kuttner (level II), supraomohyoid (level III) and supraclavicular (level VI). In four cases, a subtotal thyroidectomy or unilateral lobectomy was performed during laryngectomy (for surgical reasons) or after histologic nodal examination; a minimal focus of thyroid papillary carcinoma was detected in one patient. Three of eight patients died from recurrence of the squamous cell carcinoma; no case presented clinical evidence of thyroid malignancy. The differential diagnosis from benign thyroid heterotopia was based on the presence of minimal nuclear atypia. The choice of treatment of patients with a coexisting neoplasm characterized by poor prognosis is difficult, and contrasting opinions exist regarding the use of radical thyroidectomy and the subsequent management. As reported in the literature (66 cases), the more aggressive squamous cell carcinoma will determine the prognosis of these patients; in fact, only one of the referred cases died of cerebellar metastases of the thyroid cancer. Our results emphasize the importance of an accurate re-evaluation and follow-up of patients with incidental occult metastases for detection of a primary thyroid tumor. In the general population, this incidental nodal involvement may be related to a minimal occult thyroid carcinoma.