Early development of retinal ganglion cell dendrites in the marsupial Setonix brachyurus, quokka

In vivo development of dendritic orientation in wild-type and mislocalized retinal ganglion cells

Background

Many neurons in the central nervous system, including retinal ganglion cells (RGCs), possess asymmetric dendritic arbors oriented toward their presynaptic partners. How such dendritic arbors become biased during development in vivo is not well understood. Dendritic arbors may become oriented by directed outgrowth or by reorganization of an initially unbiased arbor. To distinguish between these possibilities, we imaged the dynamic behavior of zebrafish RGC dendrites during development in vivo. We then addressed how cell positioning within the retina, altered in heart-and-soul (has) mutants, affects RGC dendritic orientation.

Results

In vivo multiphoton time-lapse analysis revealed that RGC dendrites initially exhibit exploratory behavior in multiple directions but progressively become apically oriented. The lifetimes of basal and apical dendrites were generally comparable before and during the period when arbors became biased. However, with maturation, the addition and extension rates of basal dendrites were slower than those of the apical dendrites. Oriented dendritic arbors were also found in misplaced RGCs of the has retina but there was no preferred orientation amongst the population. However, has RGCs always projected dendrites toward nearby neuropil where amacrine and bipolar cell neurites also terminated. Chimera analysis showed that the abnormal dendritic organization of RGCs in the mutant was non-cell autonomous.

Conclusions

Our observations show that RGC dendritic arbors acquire an apical orientation by selective and gradual restriction of dendrite addition to the apical side of the cell body, rather than by preferential dendrite stabilization or elimination. A biased arbor emerges at a stage when many of the dendritic processes still appear exploratory. The generation of an oriented RGC dendritic arbor is likely to be determined by cell-extrinsic cues. Such cues are unlikely to be localized to the basal lamina of the inner retina, but rather may be provided by cells presynaptic to the RGCs.

Development of the retina and optic pathway

Our understanding of the development of the retina and visual pathways has seen enormous advances during the past 25years. New imaging technologies, coupled with advances in molecular biology, have permitted a fuller appreciation of the histotypical events associated with proliferation, fate determination, migration, differentiation, pathway navigation, target innervation, synaptogenesis and cell death, and in many instances, in understanding the genetic, molecular, cellular and activity-dependent mechanisms underlying those developmental changes. The present review considers those advances associated with the lineal relationships between retinal nerve cells, the production of retinal nerve cell diversity, the migration, patterning and differentiation of different types of retinal nerve cells, the determinants of the decussation pattern at the optic chiasm, the formation of the retinotopic map, and the establishment of ocular domains within the thalamus.

Development of visual projections follows an avian/mammalian-like sequence in the lizard Ctenophorus ornatus

Development of primary visual projections was examined in a lizard Ctenophorus ornatus by anterograde and retrograde tracing with DiI and by GAP-43 immunohistochemistry. Visual pathway development was essentially similar to that in birds and mammals and thus differed from patterns in fish or amphibians. A number of features characterised the development as mammalian-like. Three phases occurred in rapid succession after laying: outgrowth (2-3 weeks, early), exuberance (4-5 weeks, intermediate), and retraction to the adult pattern (6-8 weeks, late) at about the time of hatching and eye opening. Furthermore, ipsilateral projections developed with only a slight lag relative to the contralateral ones. The dorsally located fovea could be identified from early stages. Optic axons formed transient exuberant projections to the ipsilateral optic tectum, to the opposite optic nerve, and to nonvisual regions. The pattern resembled that formed in the long term by regenerating optic axons in C. ornatus (Dunlop et al. [2000b] J. Comp. Neurol. 416:188-200), suggesting that axons recognise molecular signals associated with the initial exuberant innervation but not those associated with subsequent refinement.

Extent of retinal ganglion cell death in the frog Litoria moorei after optic nerve regeneration induced by lesions of different sizes

Some amphibian retinal ganglion cells die during optic nerve regeneration. Here we have investigated whether ganglion cell death in the frog Litoria moorei is associated with the lesion site. For one experimental series, the optic nerve lesion extended for 0.15 mm; in the other, it extended for 1.5 mm. The extent of ganglion cell death was estimated from cresyl violet-stained whole mounts at 24 weeks post lesion. In other animals, individual regenerating axons were visualised in the optic nerve by horseradish peroxidase (HRP) labelling from 1 day to 24 weeks post lesion; counterstaining with cresyl violet allowed examination of cells that repopulated the lesion site. Ganglion cell numbers fell significantly more after an extensive than after a localised lesion, long-term losses being 50% and 34%, respectively (P < 0.05). Regenerating axons were delayed in their passage across the cell-poor extensive lesion compared with the relatively cell-rich localised lesion. The differing rates of regeneration between series were matched by greater delay after extensive lesion in the return of visually guided behaviour as assessed by optokinetic horizontal head nystagmus. We suggest that delays in regeneration after an extensive lesion exacerbate ganglion cell death, indicating that conditions within the lesion are associated with the death of some ganglion cells.

Development of retinal ganglion cell structure and function

In this review, we summarize the main stages of structural and functional development of retinal ganglion cells (RGCs). We first consider the various mechanisms that are involved in restructuring of dendritic trees. To date, many mechanisms have been implicated including target-dependent factors, interactions from neighboring RGCs, and afferent signaling. We also review recent evidence showing how rapidly such dendritic remodeling might occur, along with the intracellular signaling pathways underlying these rearrangements. Concurrent with such structural changes, the functional responses of RGCs also alter during maturation, from sub-threshold firing to reliable spiking patterns. Here we consider the development of intrinsic membrane properties and how they might contribute to the spontaneous firing patterns observed before the onset of vision. We then review the mechanisms by which this spontaneous activity becomes correlated across neighboring RGCs to form waves of activity. Finally, the relative importance of spontaneous versus light-evoked activity is discussed in relation to the emergence of mature receptive field properties.

A biophysical model for the developmental time course of retinal orientation selectivity

A quantitative study of the time course of development of the percentage of orientationally selective and isotropic ganglion cells in turtle retina has recently been performed. This study revealed that as soon as ganglion cells start responding to light, a large percentage of them are selective to the orientations of moving visual stimuli. This percentage decreases with age to reach a minimum around hatching, increases dramatically after birth and finally, decreases again following the first month of life to reach adult level. Concomitantly, the percentage of cells responding isotropically to the orientation of elongated stimuli increases monotonically until about 30 days after birth, stabilizing afterwards. To account for both time courses, we propose a biophysical model implementing features ubiquitous to developing vertebrate retinas. These features include early dendritic and synaptic spatial polarization, dendritic growth, and waves of activity generated spontaneously or by visual stimulation sweeping across the inner plexiform layer (IPL). The model also assumes a physiologically plausible Hebbian rule, which includes long-term potentiation and depression. Computer simulations of this model yield good fits of the data. The quality of these fits confirms and extends results from an earlier model using computationally-simple mechanisms, which suggested that early dendritic polarization might be the seed for mature orientation selectivity.

Axon order in the visual pathway of the quokka wallaby

Axon order throughout the visual pathway of the quokka wallaby (Setonix brachyurus) was determined after localised retinal applications of the tracers DiI and/or DiASP. Postnatal days (P) 22-90 were studied to encompass the development and refinement of retinal projections. Order was essentially similar at all stages. Axons entered the optic nerve head true to their sector of retinal origin. In the optic nerve, nasal and temporal axons continued to reflect their retinal origin, dominating, respectively, the medial and lateral halves. By contrast, dorsal and ventral axons exchanged locations between the retrobulbar level and one-third the distance along the nerve; thus, the inversion of the dorsoventral retinal axis, imposed by the lens, was corrected. Decussating axons maintained their relative locations through the chiasm. At the base of the optic tract, nasal and temporal axons underwent an axial rotation to lie on the medial and lateral sides, respectively; thus nasal overlapped with ventral axons and temporal with dorsal axons. Axons maintained their alignments throughout the tract, and as a result, nasal and ventral axons invaded the superior colliculus medially, whereas temporal and dorsal axons invaded laterally. Each retinal quadrant terminated preferentially in its retinotopically appropriate sector of the colliculus. The arrangement of axons in the quokka visual pathway displays several novel features. Axon order is distinct throughout, involving a well-demarcated exchange of dorsal and ventral axons in the nerve and an axial rotation of nasal and temporal axons at the base of the tract; these relocations suggest decision regions for growing axons. The organisation presumably underlies the less extensive searching within the developing superior colliculus to generate retinotopic maps in the quokka and also in tammar wallaby [Marotte, J. Comp Neurol. 293:524-539, 1990] than in the rat [Simon and O'Leary, J. Neurosci. 12:1212-1232, 1992].

Possible roles of spontaneous waves and dendritic growth for retinal receptive field development

Several models of cortical development postulate that a Hebbian process fed by spontaneous activity amplifies orientation biases occurring randomly in early wiring, to form orientation selectivity. These models are not applicable to the development of retinal orientation selectivity, since they neglect the polarization of the retina's poorly branched early dendritic trees and the wavelike organization of the retina's early noise. There is now evidence that dendritic polarization and spontaneous waves are key in the development of retinal receptive fields. When models of cortical development are modified to take these factors into account, one obtains a model of retinal development in which early dendritic polarization is the seed of orientation selectivity, while the spatial extent of spontaneous waves controls the spatial profile of receptive fields and their tendency to be isotropic.

Retinal ganglion cell dendritic development and its control. Filling the gaps

The way in which central neurons acquire their complex and precise dendrite arbors is of considerable developmental interest. Using retinal ganglion cells (RGCs) as a model, the mechanisms that pattern dendritic development are beginning to emerge. As in other systems, final dendrite phenotype is achieved by a mixture of intrinsic and extrinsic determinants. The extrinsic determinants of RGC dendrite shape reflect the anatomical constraints of producing a paracrystalline mosaic of arbors that laminates the inner plexiform layer of the retina. In this article, the key features of RGC dendrite development are reviewed. The emerging molecular mechanisms behind dendritic laminar segregation and "dendritic competition" are described. The role of afferent extrinsic influences are contrasted with those of retrograde, activity-dependent target influences that may regulate the final maturational phase of dendrite remodeling.

Ontogeny of the opioid growth factor, [Met5]-enkephalin, and its binding activity in the rat retina

The endogenous opioid peptide [Met5]-enkephalin is a tonically active opioid growth factor (OGF) with an inhibitory action on DNA synthesis in the developing rat retina. In this study, the ontogeny of the spatial and temporal expression of OGF and its binding activity was examined. OGF-like immunoreactivity was detected in the retina at gestation day (E) 20, but not at E18, and was localized to ganglion cell and neuroblast layers; immunochemical reaction was no longer seen in the retina by postnatal day 6. Native OGF was further identified and characterized by high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) studies and immunodot assays, which revealed that [Met5]-enkephalin was present in the neonatal, but not adult, rat retina. OGF binding activity was detected as early as E18 using [125I]-[Met5]-enkephalin and in vitro receptor autoradiography. Little OGF binding activity was noted for prenatal retinas, but appreciable activity was observed from birth to postnatal day 4; no OGF binding could be detected after postnatal day 5 or in the adult. These results reveal the transient appearance of the OGF, [Met5]-enkephalin, and its receptor binding activity in the developing mammalian retina, and show that their ontogeny coincides with the timetable of DNA synthesis of retinal neuroblasts.

Wiring up the visual system

1. In this review we describe some of our recent studies on the developing marsupial visual pathway. The description focuses on retinal ganglion cells, considering the formation of their dendritic trees, the outgrowth of axons and the formation of connections within the brain. 2. Both dendritic trees and outgrowing axons undergo a period of exuberance, followed by one of refinement. The dendritic tree transiently develops a more complex branching pattern than is found in adults. Short side branches, referred to as spines, are a feature of immature dendrites and, to a lesser extent, of axons. These structures are mostly lost as development proceeds. However, they are retained on the dendritic trees of small-field ganglion cells and, for a proportion of axons, on that part within the nerve fibre layer of the retina. Although most axons navigate fairly direct routes towards their targets, a minority follow inappropriate courses, such as doubling back towards the eye or entering the opposite optic nerve at the chiasm. As such errant axons are not seen in the adult, we assume that their parent cell bodies die during development. 3. Throughout development, optic axons are arranged in an approximate retinotopic order along the length of the visual pathway; as a result, axons approach the visual centres aligned to form, at least, a crude retinotopic map. Axons from dorsal and ventral retina exchange locations along the optic nerve and in this way correct for the inversion of the image brought about by the lens.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Exogenous glycosaminoglycans induce complete inversion of retinal ganglion cell bodies and their axons within the retinal neuroepithelium

Prior to forming an axon, retinal ganglion cells retain a primitive radial configuration while maintaining ventricular and vitreal endfeet attachments. During their subsequent differentiation, ganglion cells polarize their cell body and axon only along the vitreal surface. When the ventricular surfaces of intact retinas in organ culture were exposed to free chondroitin sulfate (CS) in solution, both the cell body and nerve fiber layers were repolarized to the opposite side of the neuroepithelium. However, the basal lamina remained in its usual position. Thus, the ability to initiate an axon is not restricted to the vitreal endfoot region of differentiating neurons, and in addition, the radial position at which the axon emerges can be mediated by the location and concentration of the extracellular CS milieu.

Morphology and birth dates of horizontal cells in the retina of a marsupial

Most eutherian (placental) mammals have two horizontal cell types; however, one type only has been seen in rodents. In order to assess whether one type of horizontal cell or two is a basic mammalian feature, we have examined the morphology of horizontal cells in a marsupial, the quokka wallaby, by Golgi staining or horseradish peroxidase labelling. The birth dates of horizontal cells have also been determined by 3H-thymidine/autoradiography. There are two types of horizontal cell in the wallaby retina. One type has no axon and corresponds to the axonless cell in eutherian species; the other has shorter dendrites, an axon, and an axonal arbor, corresponding to the eutherian short-axon cell. As in eutherian mammals, the dendrites of each horizontal cell type lie in the outer plexiform layer (OPL) and contact cones and the axonal arbor of the short-axon cell contacts rods. The dendrites of the axonless cells are long, with an average length of 250 microns, and each cell has one, sometimes two, short, stubby processes, which branch off a dendrite, traverse the inner nuclear layer, and reach the inner plexiform layer. The dendritic field of these cells is elongated, and dendrites show a preferential orientation at right angles to the trajectory of overlying ganglion cell axons. Short-axon cells have a morphology similar to that seen in other species, although the axonal arbor is relatively small. Both types of horizontal cell are generated in the first phase of retinal cell generation.

Dendritic remodelling of retinal ganglion cells during development of the rat

Investigation of the morphology of ganglion cells in the cat retina has shown that a remarkable reduction in the number of dendritic spines and branches occurs during development of the alpha and beta cell classes. To learn whether dendritic remodelling represents a generalized mechanism of mammalian retinal ganglion cell development, we have examined the morphology of ganglion cells in the retina of the developing rat. The present study has concentrated on type II cells, which retain a great number of dendritic spines and branches in the adult and comprise a large proportion of the population of rat retinal ganglion cells. To reveal fine dendritic and axonal processes, Lucifer yellow was injected intracellularly in living retinae maintained in vitro. Size and complexity of the dendritic trees were found to increase rapidly during an initial stage of development lasting from late fetal life until approximately postnatal day 12 (P12). Dendrites and axons of immature ganglion cells expressed several transient morphological features comprising an excessive number of dendritic branches and spine-like processes, and short, delicate axonal sidebranches. The following developmental stage was characterized by a remarkable decrease in the morphological complexity of retinal ganglion cells and a slowed growth of their dendritic fields. The number of dendritic branches and spines of types I and II retinal ganglion cells declined after P12 to reach a mature level by the end of the first postnatal month. Thus, even cells that retain a highly complex dendritic tree into the adult state undergo extensive remodelling. These results suggest that regressive modifications at the level of the dendritic field constitute a generalized mechanism of maturation in mammalian retinal ganglion cells.

Morphogenesis of retinal ganglion cells during formation of the fovea in the Rhesus macaque

The morphology of retinal ganglion cells within the central retina during formation of the fovea was examined in retinal explants with horseradish-peroxidase histochemistry. A foveal depression was first apparent in retinal wholemounts at embryonic day 112 (E112; gestational term is approximately 165 days). At earlier fetal ages, the site of the future fovea was identified by several criteria that included peak density of ganglion cells, lack of blood vessels in the inner retinal layers, arcuate fiber bundles, and the absence of rod outer segments in the photoreceptor layer. Prior to E112, the terminal dendritic arbor of retinal ganglion cells within the central retina extended into the inner plexiform layer and were located directly beneath their somas of origin or at most were slightly displaced from it. For example, at E90 the mean horizontal displacement of the geometric center of the dendritic arbor from the somas of cells within 600 microns of the estimated center of the future fovea was 4.1 microns (S.D. 2.7, range 1.0-10.0, n = 97). Following formation of the foveal depression the dendritic arbors of cells were significantly displaced from their somas. For example, at E138 the mean displacement was 41.2 microns (S.D. 12.2, range 12.0-56.0, n = 97). The displacement of the dendritic arbor which occurred during this period was not accounted for by areal growth of the dendritic arbor, the somas, or the retina, but was produced by the lengthening of the primary dendritic trunk. Moreover, no significant displacement was observed within the remaining 1.5-6.5 mm of the central retina. These observations provide evidence supporting early speculations that the formation of the foveal pit occurs, in part, by the radial migration of ganglion cells from the center of the fovea during its formation. Our analyses suggest that this migration occurs by the lengthening of the primary dendrite presumably by the addition of membrane. This migration is in a direction opposite to the inward movement of photoreceptors that occurs during late fetal and early postnatal periods (Packer et al., 1990, Journal of Comparative Neurology 298, 472-493).

Postnatal development of type I retinal ganglion cells in hamsters: a lucifer yellow study

The postnatal development of a population of superior colliculus projecting retinal ganglion cells with large somata in hamsters aged from postnatal day (P) 4 to adult was studied by the intracellular injection of Lucifer Yellow. This population of cells was interpreted as Type I cells based on their large soma sizes and dendritic morphology resembling that of mature Type I cells. In addition to the growth of the soma and the dendritic field, transient morphological features such as intraretinal axon collaterals and exuberant dendritic spines, but not somatic spines, were frequently observed on this population of cells in hamsters during development. None of them exhibited any intraretinal axon collaterals after P7. The number of transient spine-like processes on dendrites increased from P4 onwards to reach a peak at P16, decreased abruptly within a few days after the peak, and stabilised to reach the adult level by P30. These developing cells attained the maximum number of dendritic branches by P16 and there seems to be little, if any, reduction in the number of branch points after this time point. In addition, the length of individual branches of dendrites was not increased excessively during development and then shortened during maturation. Thus, the dendritic remodeling of these cells after P16 seems to be mainly the increase of the length of dendrites and the removal of exuberant dendritic spines.

Early dendritic outgrowth of primate retinal ganglion cells

The pattern of dendritic stratification of retinal ganglion cells in the fetal monkey (Macaca mulatta) was examined using horseradish peroxidase and retinal explants. Ganglion cells in the rhesus monkey are born between embryonic day (E) 30-70 (LaVail et al., 1983). At E60, E67, and E68, approximately 50% of all ganglion cells within the central 3.0 mm of the retina had dendritic arbors that were unistratified within the inner plexiform layer (IPL), while the remaining 50% had bistratified arbors. Unistratified cells had relatively flat arbors that ramified within a restricted portion of the IPL. In contrast, bistratified cells had one portion of the arbor that branched in the inner half of the IPL and a second portion that branched in the outer half of the IPL. Relatively few bistratified cells were encountered in the central 1.0 mm of the retina but were more numerous with increasing eccentricity. At E81, E90, and E110, the dendritic arbors of ganglion cells increased in both area and complexity, but occupied a relatively small percentage of the total depth of the IPL. The bistratified cells encountered at these fetal ages were typically located in the far retinal periphery. Between E125-E140, the dendritic arbors of individual ganglion cells increased in area and depth to occupy a greater proportion of the total IPL than at earlier fetal ages. These observations suggest that ganglion cells in the macaque undergo at least three stages of dendritic stratification: (1) an initial period of dendritic growth during which the cells have either unistratified or bistratified dendritic arbors; (2) a loss of the majority of bistratified cells through cell death or remodeling of the arbor; and (3) growth or expansion of the arbor to occupy a greater percentage of the total depth of the IPL. The first two stages are similar to recent observations in the fetal cat (Maslim & Stone, 1988) with the exception that dendritic development in the primate lacks an initial diffuse ingrowth to the IPL. Additionally, primate ganglion cells undergo a third stage of dendritic growth in late fetal development during which the arbor occupies a greater proportion of the depth of the IPL.

Alpha ganglion cells in mammalian retinae: common properties, species differences, and some comments on other ganglion cells

A specific morphological class of ganglion cell, the alpha cell, was first defined in cat retina. Alpha cells have since been found in a wide range of mammalian retinae, including several orders of placental and marsupial mammals. Characteristically, they have the largest somata and a large dendritic field with a typical branching pattern. They occur as inner and outer stratifying subpopulations, presumably corresponding to ON-center and OFF-center receptive fields. In all species, alpha cells account for less than 10% of the ganglion cells, their somata are regularly spaced, and their dendritic fields evenly and economically cover the retina in a mosaic-like fashion. The morphology of alpha cells and many features, both of single cells and of the population, are conserved across species with different habitats and life-styles. This suggests that alpha cells are a consistent obligatory ganglion cell type in every mammalian retina and probably subserve some fundamental task(s) in visual performance. Some general rules about the construction principles of ganglion cell classes are inferred from the alpha cells, stressing the importance of population parameters for the definition of a class. The principle, that a functionally and morphologically homogeneous population should have a regular arrangement and a complete and even coverage of the retina to perform its part in image processing at each retinal location, is especially evident across species and across ganglion cell types.